Standards Council Meeting SUPPLEMENTAL AGENDA August
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Standards Council Meeting SUPPLEMENTAL AGENDA August 3-5, 2016 NFPA Headquarters 1 Batterymarch Park Quincy, MA 02169 617-770-3000 16-8-1 Act on the issuance of NFPA 25, Standard for the Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance of Water-Based Fire Protection Systems, with an issuance date of August 4, 2016 and an effective date of August 24, 2016, as acted on at the NFPA Technical Meeting, with three amendments and two appeals. See related Minute Item 16-8-10 16-8-1-a Amendment No. 25-1 (CAM 25-1): Accept Public Comment No. 4. This motion (CAM 25-1) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 36VM - 14 agree/15 disagree/7 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-1-a SA16-8-1-a 16-8-1-a-1 Appeal of Joe Scibetta of BuildingReports, requesting the Standards Council overturn the Technical Committee ballot results on CAM 25-1 which in effect would uphold the action at the NFPA Technical Meeting to Accept Public Comment No. 4. This Motion passed at the NFPA Technical Meeting. SA16-8-1-a-1 ADDITION 16-8-1-b Appeal of Marcelo Hirschler of GBH International, requesting the Council APPEAL overturn the Association action and Accept Public Comment Nos. 56 and 57. This motion (CAM 25-2) failed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. See Attachment 16-8-1-b 16-8-1-c Amendment No. 25-2 (CAM 25-7): Reject Second Revision No. 13. This motion (CAM 25-7) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED TC Ballot – 36VM - 21 agree/8 disagree/7 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-1-c SA16-8-1-c 16-8-1-d Amendment No. 25-3 (CAM 25-9): Reject Second Revision No. 41. This motion (CAM 25-9) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED TC Ballot – 36VM - 21 agree/8 disagree/7 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-1-d SA16-8-1-d 16-8-1-e Appeal of Peter Larrimer, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs requesting the APPEAL Council remove Chapter 16 from the 2017 edition of NFPA 25. See Attachment 16-8-1-e 16-8-2 Act on the issuance of NFPA 58, Liquefied Petroleum Gases, with an issuance date of August 4, 2016 and an effective date of August 24, 2016, as acted on at the NFPA Technical Meeting, with eight amendments and no appeals. 16-8-2-a Amendment No. 58-1 (CAM 58-1): Reject an Identifiable Part of Second Revision No. 14. This motion (CAM 58-1) passed on the floor of the NFPA July 28, 2016 Supplemental Agenda-Standards Council Meeting August 3-5, 2016 Technical Meeting. (PASSED TC Ballot – 27VM - 17 agree/3 disagree/1 abstained/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-a SA16-8-2-a 16-8-2-b Amendment No. 58-2 (CAM 58-2): Accept Public Comment No. 15. This motion (CAM 58-2) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 9 agree/12 disagree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-b SA16-8-2-b 16-8-2-c Amendment No. 58-3 (CAM 58-3): Accept Public Comment No. 16. This motion (CAM 58-3) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 8 agree/13 disagree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-c SA16-8-2-c 16-8-2-d Amendment No. 58-4 (CAM 58-4): Accept Public Comment No. 17. This motion (CAM 58-4) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 9 agree/12 disagree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-d SA16-8-2-d 16-8-2-e Amendment No. 58-5 (CAM 58-5): Reject Second Revision No. 8. This motion (CAM 58-5) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED TC Ballot – 27VM - 21 agree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-e SA16-8-2-e 16-8-2-f Amendment No. 58-6 (CAM 58-6): Accept Public Comment No. 63. This motion (CAM 58-6) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 6 agree/14 disagree/ 1 abstained/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-f SA16-8-2-f 16-8-2-g Amendment No. 58-7 (CAM 58-7): Accept Public Comment No. 18. This motion (CAM 58-7) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 9 agree/12 disagree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-g SA16-8-2-g 16-8-2-h Amendment No. 58-8 (CAM 58-8): Reject Second Revision No. 8. This motion (CAM 58-8) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (FAILED TC Ballot – 27VM - 9 agree/12 disagree/6 not returned). See Attachment 16-8-2-h SA16-8-2-h 16-8-2- Appeal of Marcelo Hirschler, GBH International, requesting the NFPA b/c/d/g/h Standards Council Accept Public Comment No. 15 (CAM 58-2); Accept APPEAL Public Comment No. 16 (CAM 58-3); Accept Public Comment No. 17 (CAM 58-4); Accept Public Comment No. 18 (CAM 58-7); Accept Public Comment No. 19 (CAM 58-8). These Motion passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting but failed Technical Committee ballot. SA16-8-2-b/c/d/g/h ADDITION 16-8-2- One comment received on the appeal of M. Hirschler. SA 16-8-2-b/c/d/g/h-1 b/c/d/g/h-1 ADDITION 16-8-3 Act on the issuance of NFPA 70, National Electrical Code®, with an issuance date of August 4, 2016 and an effective date of August 24, 2016, as acted on at the NFPA Technical Meeting, with twelve amendments and seven appeals. See related Attachment 16-8-15 16-8-3-a Amendment No. 70-1 (CAM 70-3): Accept an Identifiable Part of Public Comment No. 793. This motion (CAM 70-3) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED CC Ballot – 12VM - 11 agree/1 not July 28, 2016 Supplemental Agenda-Standards Council Meeting August 3-5, 2016 returned) (FAILED Panel Ballot – 16VM - 7 agree/9 disagree). See Attachment 16-8-3-a SA16-8-3-a 16-8-3-b Amendment No. 70-2 (CAM 70-4): Reject Second Revision No. 1004. This motion (CAM 70-4) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (No CC/Panel Vote is required) See Attachment 16-8-3-b 16-8-3-c Appeal of Christel Hunter of General Cable, requesting the Council overturn APPEAL the Association action to Accept Public Comment No. 1136. This motion (CAM 70-5) failed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. See Attachment 16-8-3-c 16-8-3-d Amendment No. 70-3 (CAM 70-7): Reject an Identifiable Part of Second Revision No. 1223. This motion (CAM 70-7) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED CC Ballot – 12VM - 11 agree/1 not returned) (FAILED Panel Ballot – 17VM - 7 agree/9 disagree/1 abstained). See Attachment 16-8-3-d SA16-8-3-d 16-8-3-e Appeal of Travis Lindsey of TLC Services Inc., requesting the Council APPEAL overturn the Association action to Accept Public Comment No. 1401. This motion (CAM 70-11) failed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. See Attachment 16-8-3-e 16-8-3-e-1 Three comments received on the appeal of T. Lindsey. See Attachment 16-8- 3-e-1 16-8-3-e-2 Comment received by M. Smith, Chair of CMP-6, on the appeal of T. Lindsey. SA16-8-3-e-2. ADDITION 16-8-3-f Appeals of Amy Cronin of Strategic Code Solutions, representing Cable Bus APPEAL Manufacturers Association, and Fred Hartwell of Hartwell Electrical Services, Inc., requesting the Council overturn the Association action to Reject Second Revision No. 2110. This motion (CAM 70-13) failed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. See Attachment 16-8-3-f 16-8-3-f-1 Comment received by L. Cogburn, Chair of the CMP-8, on the appeal of A. Cronin representing Cable Bus Manufacturers Association and F. Hartwell. See Attachment 16-8-3-f-1 16-8-3-f-2 Six comments received on the appeal of A. Cronin and F. Hartwell. See Attachment 16-8-3-f-2 SA16-8-3-f-2 16-8-3-g Amendment No. 70-4 (CAM 70-14): Accept Public Comment No. 834. This motion (CAM 70-14) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (PASSED CC Ballot – 12VM - 11 agree/1 not returned) (PASSED Panel Ballot – 15VM - 12 agree/2 disagree/1 not returned). See Attachment 16-8- 3-g SA16-8-3-g 16-8-3-h Amendment No. 70-5 (CAM 70-15): Reject an Identifiable Part of Second Revision No. 1801. This motion (CAM 70-15) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (No CC/Panel Vote is required) See Attachment 16-8-3-h 16-8-3-i Amendment No. 70-6 (CAM 70-20): Reject Second Revision No. 607. This motion (CAM 70-20) passed on the floor of the NFPA Technical Meeting. (No CC/Panel Vote is required) See Attachment 16-8-3-i 16-8-3-j Amendment No. 70-7 (CAM 70-22): Reject an Identifiable Part of Second Revision No.