Demons and Monsters in the Mesopotamian Textual and Artistic Tradition
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
They are Seven: Demons and Monsters in the Mesopotamian Textual and Artistic Tradition by Gina V. Konstantopoulos A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Near Eastern Studies) in the University of Michigan 2015 Doctoral Committee: Professor Piotr A. Michalowski, Chair Professor Gary M. Beckman Associate Professor Ian S. Moyer Associate Professor Ellen Muehlberger Professor Daniel Schwemer, Julius Maximilians Universität Würzburg © Gina V. Konstantopoulos 2015 Acknowledgements I owe debts of gratitude (as well as the existence of this dissertation as anything resembling a complete – perhaps even coherent – form) to many different people. First and foremost, my thanks go to my dissertation committee. I am deeply grateful to have worked with Piotr Michalowski as my advisor from the beginning of my time at Michigan, and to have had the great privilege of so much time studying under his Sumerological wing. I am thankful to Gary Beckman for years of careful instruction and equally dedicated care to this dissertation. Ian Moyer agreed to join on as my cognate member and committed his careful attention to the project. Ellen Muehlberger tirelessly read drafts, fielded questions, and was endlessly patient with letting me know when I had gone too far afield or otherwise off-book. Daniel Schwemer kindly agreed to sign onto the committee while I was studying with him at Würzburg, and applied his meticulous attention to it. I was able to spend the 2012-2013 academic year at the University of Würzburg thanks to a fellowship from the Deutscher Akademischer Austausch Dienst, and I could not have been more fortunate to spend my first full year of research and writing in such a supportive department. I would thank in particular Greta van Buylaere, Mikko Luukko, and Dahlia Shehata. Frans Wiggermann, while visiting Würzburg, kindly shared his notes on the Sebettu with me. In addition, my research has been made possible through several grants: the Frances Mary Hazen Alumnae Fellowship from Mount Holyoke College, the Rackham Graduate Student Research Grant and International Research Award, and the Margaret Ayers Host Award. Without ii this support, the research for this dissertation would not have been possible. Several museums and institutions generously allowed me access to their collections, including; the British Museum, the Ashmolean Museum, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the Musée du Louvre. If my starting of this dissertation was only possible because of one fellowship, then my finishing it is surely thanks to another. I was able to spend my final year as a fellow in residence at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, having received the Sylvan C. Coleman and Pamela Coleman Memorial Fund Fellowship. I owe the entire department my thanks, in particular my supervisor and mentor, Sarah Graff, who fielded many questions concerning the final, critical chapter on the iconography of the Sebettu. I would also thank the other ancient Near Eastern fellow, Colette LeRoux, who handled the desperation that characterizes a final year of dissertation writing with good grace, constant humor, and internet references. I have been lucky to spend my time at Michigan with a fantastic and supportive cohort in an equally supportive department. In particular, I owe thanks to my fellow ACABS students, including: Christine Efta, Ilgi Gerçek, and Ty Bilgin, ACABS comrade-in-arms from the start. Further, non-ACABS thanks to Noah Gardiner and Nancy Linthicum, and non-NES thanks to Neville McFerrin and Nikki Roda. Finally, I would thank my family, who reacted to my announcement that yes, I was going to write about demons and monsters for the foreseeable future with an appreciated mix of stoicism, unfailing support, and occasional comments that I leave any potential "practical applications" out of my work. In this last regard, I will simply say that I have done my best. iii Table of Contents: Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... ii List of Tables ................................................................................................................................ vii List of Figures .............................................................................................................................. viii List of Appendices: ........................................................................................................................ ix List of Abbreviations: ......................................................................................................................x Abstract ........................................................................................................................................ xiii Chapter One: Introduction ...............................................................................................................1 1.1. Prior Research ......................................................................................................................2 1.2. Arc of this study ...................................................................................................................5 1.3. Concerning Terminology: On Demons ..............................................................................10 1.3.1. Sumerian and Akkadian Transliteration and Transcription Conventions ..................14 1.3.2. Writing the Sebettu .....................................................................................................15 1.4. Why Seven? The Significance of the Number as a Group in the Ancient Near East ........15 Chapter Two - On the Nature of Demons: Protective Spirits and Demonic Dualities ..................19 2.1. "Good" Demon or "Bad" Demon: Inherent Natures and Some Statistics ..........................26 2.1.1. Concerning Pazuzu and Lamaštu ...............................................................................31 2.2. The Udug and its Ambivalence ..........................................................................................32 2.2.1. The Benevolent Udug .................................................................................................40 2.3. The šēdu .............................................................................................................................45 2.4. The Benevolent Lama ........................................................................................................48 2.5. The Occasionally Malevolent Lama ..................................................................................58 Chapter Three: The Seven which Stalk the Land – Examining Early Attestations and Later Malevolence ...................................................................................................................................64 3.1. Third Millennium References .........................................................................................65 3.2. The Sumerian Narrative of Gilgamesh and Huwawa .....................................................68 3.2.1. Gilgamesh and Huwawa B and Aratta: .....................................................................76 3.2.2. Constructing Aratta ..................................................................................................79 3.3. Lugalbanda in the Wilderness: the Torches of Inanna .....................................................82 3.4. The Malevolent Sebettu in Incantations of the Old Babylonian Period .............................89 3.4.1. Old Babylonian Tablets of Udug Hul .........................................................................90 3.5. The Hymn to Hendursaĝa and Lagaš Pecularities ...........................................................95 3.6. Referenced Texts: Old Babylonian Sumerian Incantations .............................................108 Chapter Four: "Rome was also built on ruins": The Grounding of Second Millennium Literary and Political Sources ....................................................................................................................111 4.1. The Subservience of Demons: Subduing Demonic Powers .............................................114 4.1.1. The Beasts of Marduk's Chariot ..............................................................................118 4.1.2. Binding Huwawa: Gilgamesh, Enkidu, and Huwawa ............................................123 4.2. Laying the Foundations: Second Millennium Cultic Evidence ....................................130 4.2.1. Second Millennium Cults and Worship ..................................................................132 4.2.2. The Sebettu on Kudurru Inscriptions ......................................................................137 iv 4.2.3. Personal Names ........................................................................................................140 4.2.4. Assyrian Royal Inscriptions ....................................................................................142 4.3. Figure 1: Inscription of Aššur-bēl-kala ............................................................................150 Chapter Five: "Cry 'Havoc!'": The Escalated Use of the Sebettu in the First Millennium ..........151 5.1. First Millennium Literary Texts ....................................................................................156 5.1.1. The Birdcall Text ....................................................................................................157 5.1.2. Erra .........................................................................................................................162