TERF Wars: Narrative Productions of Gender and Essentialism in Radical-Feminist (Cyber)Spaces Jennifer Earles University of South Florida, [email protected]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 4-27-2017 TERF Wars: Narrative Productions of Gender and Essentialism in Radical-Feminist (Cyber)spaces Jennifer Earles University of South Florida, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the Sociology Commons Scholar Commons Citation Earles, Jennifer, "TERF Wars: Narrative Productions of Gender and Essentialism in Radical-Feminist (Cyber)spaces" (2017). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/6696 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. TERF Wars: Narrative Productions of Gender and Essentialism in Radical-Feminist (Cyber)spaces by Jennifer Earles A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Sociology College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Sara L. Crawley, Ph.D. Donileen R. Loseke, Ph.D. Robert D. Benford, Ph.D. Elizabeth Bell, Ph.D. Date of Approval: April 26, 2017 Keywords: gender, lesbians, feminism, social movements, narrative, textual analysis, comparative historical, social media Copyright © 2017, Jennifer Earles DEDICATION Even before I understood feminism and how to put it into practice, my mother cared for me, encouraged me, and stood by my side. And, this process has certainly had its ups and downs. Through my own battle with colon cancer at 35, to the loss of my dear grandmother “Mimmi,” and to the death of my dog Spice who comforted me through it all, my mom, Jenny Hedden, accepted all my sadness, anger, and grief. She supported me with the unconditional love, care, and beauty that inspired me to push forward and succeed. I dedicate this dissertation to her and all the wonderful women in my life, especially my sister Eva and my grandmother Mimmi. Through her love, encouragement, and wonderful uniqueness, Eva has stayed my best friend through everything – she is someone who calls me every day just to make sure I’m happy, someone who drives 11 hours just to visit, and someone with whom I can laugh, cry, and scream at the world. We travel together and still love each other. And, though Mimmi is gone, I feel her love and inspiration everyday – through care and community, she became a feminist even before any of us knew what that meant. I love you all. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This incredible journey would not have been possible without the mentorship, encouragement, patience, and support of so many people. In no particular order, I extend my sincerest gratitude, respect, and appreciation to each of them. First, I would like to thank the community of women who dedicated their lives to producing feminist ideas, politics, and community. Their commitment to feminism and women’s liberation not only inspires me, but has afforded me the opportunities to live out load, to find communities of my own, and to pursue the study of feminism in higher education. These women certainly experienced some ups and downs of their own, but I hope I treated their words and experiences with the respect they deserve. They provided the lineage, history, and pride through which feminist and lesbian communities today can find inspiration. I wish to thank my committee chair and doctoral advisor, Dr. Sara L. Crawley. Not only has she become a trusted friend, but she also encouraged me to pursue feminist sociology from my work in women’s studies. Through our work together, Sara pushed me to stay grounded in the data and to continually think about my position as an analyst. She helped me to shape my areas of expertise, to think independently about my research, and to get the work done. Thanks to her, I have discovered the beauty in theory that will shape my work throughout the rest of my career. I am very grateful to have had the opportunity to work with a woman as talented, caring, and tough as Sara. I would also like to thank the other members of my committee, starting with Doni Loseke. After I learned of my cancer diagnosis during my third year, Doni found me in a state of shock. She listened, comforted me, and told me exactly what I needed to hear – that this wasn’t fair. Doni’s expertise in methodology and narrative identity has also been integral to my research, transforming me from a women’s studies scholar in sociology to a sociologist in my own right. Once again, I am so fortunate to claim Doni as a mentor. I am also grateful to Rob Benford and Elizabeth Bell who took on this project and who provided me with so much support over the years. I am particularly thankful to Rob who wrote so highly of me in letters of recommendation and who took the time to chat with me about my interests and my life. A special thanks to Maralee Mayberry who also wrote many letters on my behalf and who provided me with invaluable pedagogical support. I would also like to thank Laurel Graham who sent me all those funny books and comics – they were just what I needed to get through some difficult times. And, I would especially like to thank Marilyn Myerson. I was lucky enough to have her as my mentor during my graduate work in women’s studies and she remains my friend today. During my long and painful months in the hospital, Marilyn visited almost every day. She held my hand as we talked and I cried. She shaped how I think of myself as a feminist and helped me to understand that feminism is not only important in public protests, but also how you treat those closest to you and in how you center women in your life. You are an amazing and inspiring woman that I am so lucky to call my friend. And, without the support of her friend and mine, Carolyn Ellis, I would not have discovered the beauty of autoethnography and been afforded the opportunity to work through my experiences. You have personally reshaped what it means to be a scholar and so many women owe their success to you. I am also grateful to my third-grade teacher, Mrs. Ready. Through all my social awkwardness, Mrs. Ready recognized my academic potential and set me on a track that culminated in a Ph.D. She was kind, beloved, and, recognized me thirty years later when we met on the streets of my hometown. You are gone but never forgotten. Many people afforded me the financial support and opportunities I received during my graduate work, including the University of South Florida, the Office of Graduate Studies, the Office of Research and Innovation, the Student Government, the Sociology and Women’s and Gender Studies departments, and Sociologists for Women in Society. My success also could not be possible without the incredible support network of my cohort, fellow graduate students, faculty, and staff who helped create such a warm and welcoming department. In particular, I wish to thank Brenda Mason for her emotional, personal, and scholarly support throughout this process. In addition to offering her invaluable comments on my work, Brenda was always there to listen, commiserate, and celebrate all our successes. We met through sociology, but have become lifelong friends. Thank you. I am also thankful for the support of Elaina Behounek, Hilary Dotson, Sean Currie, Loren Wilbers, David Zeller, Katie Cooper, and so many others. And, I would be remiss if I did not thank the administrative staff, including Elizabeth Fernandez, Patricia Greene, Fransheska Andaluz, Joan Jacobs, and Emelda Curry. Without you, I would still be sifting through mounds of paperwork and floundering through important deadlines. It was a pleasure working with you all. Once again, thank you to my mother, Jenny Hedden. You have persevered through so much and continue to support me with your kindness, camaraderie, and encouragement. And, thank you to my sister, Eva. You are my best friend, closest ally, and the person who best understands how far we’ve come and how much this project means. I would also like to thank my grandma Mimmi, the original feminist in the family, and my grandpa Derald “Big D” who was more like a father to me – you drove hours to help me when my car broke down, drove me to the airport even though you hated the traffic, and shared heart-breaking, yet inspiring stories about your time in Korea. You are missed every day. Lastly, thank you to Laurie and Jerry Rinnert, Nancy and Kevin Emmons, David and Julie Hedden, Ron Hedden, Stephen McGregor, all my cousins, and Spice, Sophie, and Sandy for all their love. Thank you. TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Figures ...................................................................................................................... iv Abstract ................................................................................................................................. v Chapter One: Introduction .................................................................................................... 1 Situating Radical Feminism and Lesbian Separatism within the Broader Movement ........................................................................................................... 5 Situating Radical Feminism in Online Spaces .......................................................... 9 Method: Narrative Productions of Meaning ........................................................... 11 Data ........................................................................................................................