Monitoring of the General Local Elections of 20 October 2019 from the Perspective of the Inclusion of Persons with Disabilities
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Monitoring of the General Local Elections of 20 October 2019 from the Perspective of the Inclusion of Persons with Disabilities Monitoring period: 18 October 2019 – 13 November 2019 Project funded by the Project co-financed by Sweden European Union The Report was produced as part of the Project ‘Civil Society Advocacy for Inclusive and Fair Elections in Moldova, Compliant with EU and OSCE/ODIHR Recommendations and Human Rights Commitments’, implemented by the East Europe Foundation (EEF) in partnership with the ‘Partnership for Development’ Center (PDC), Piligrim Demo, and Tarna Rom, funded by the European Union and co-funded by Sweden. The opinions expressed herein belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the donors’ view. Chisinau, 13 November 2019 TABLE OF CONTENS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.....................................................................................4 METHODOLOGY...............................................................................................6 INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................7 KEY FINDINGS ON THE FOLLOWING: I. Degree of persons with disabilities’ inclusion by the election candidates in the election campaign. Representation of persons with disabilities on the lists of candidates and their involvement in election campaign activities...............................................................................9 II. Accessibility of the information on election candidates’ platforms for persons with mobility, sensory, mental, intellectual disabilities..........................................................................................13 III. Coverage by the election candidates’ platforms of the issues faced by the persons with disabilities.................................19 IV. Physical and information access of polling stations........................20 V. Financial matters of persons with disabilities’ inclusion in election processes.............................................................................25 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.....................................................................27 ANNEX 1. Request for access to information of public interest – ECC Ceadir- Lunga No 36/2, ECC ATU Gagauzia and Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Moldova………………………………….………………………………………………….…..….29 ANNEX 2. Request for access to information of public interest – Broadcasting Council of the Republic of Moldova...........................................................30 ANNEX 3. Request for access to information of public interest – National Social Insurance House...........................................................................................31 ANNEX 4. Template of Request for access to access information of public interest – Political parties in the Republic of Moldova…………………………………………………..………....32 ANNEX 5. Template of Request for access to information of public interest – Level I and level II public administration ANNEX 6. Audit of the accessibility of political party headquarters in the Republic of Moldova........................................................................................................34 ANNEX 7. Monitoring of Ungheni EOPS accessibility……..…....54 ANNEX 8. Information on the number of pension beneficiaries for persons with disabilities and the number of social allowance beneficiaries for persons with disabilities (as of 1 October 2019)……………………………………..…...55 ANNEX 9. Answer of the Broadcasting Council (4 November 2019)….………………..…57 ANNEX 10. Answer of Duruitoarea Noua Mayoralty (Riscani district) (29 October 2019)……………………………………………………………………………………….59 ANNEX 11. Answer of Pociumbeni Mayoralty (Riscani district) (30 October 2019).60 ANNEX 12. Answer of Straseni Mayoralty (30 October 2019)..………..61 ANNEX 13. Answer of Singerei District Council (31 October 2019)…………….…63 ANNEX 14. Answer of Falesti Mayoralty (31 October 2019)…………………..65 ANNEX 15. Answer of Vulcanesti Mayoralty (1 November 2019)……………….66 ANNEX 16. Answer of Riscani District Council (1 November 2019)…………………..67 ANNEX 17. Answer of Straseni District Council (1 November 2019)…………………69 ANNEX 18. Answer of Chisinau General Department of Architecture, Urban Planning and Land Relations (4 November 2019)………………………………………………71 ANNEX 19. Answer of Cricova Mayoralty (5 November 2019)……..……………73 ANNEX 20. Answer of Orhei General Department of Social Assistance and Family Protection (6 November 2019)………………………………………………………….………..74 ANNEX 21. Answer of Edinet District Council (7 November 2019)…………….……..76 ANNEX 22. Answer of Telenesti District Council (8 November 2019)………………..78 ANNEX 23. Answer of Falesti General Department of Social Assistance, Family and Child Protection (12 November 2019)………………………………………………..80 ANNEX 24. Answer of Glodeni District Council (12 November 2019)………….…….82 ANNEX 25. Answer of Nisporeni District Council (12 November 2019)……….…….85 ANNEX 26. Answer of Chisinau General Department of Social Assistance and Healthcare (13 November 2019)…………………………………………………………86 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Report on the monitoring of the inclusion of persons with disabilities in the general local elections of 20 October 2019 was produced as part of the Project ‘Civil Society Advocacy for Inclusive and Fair Elections in Moldova, Compliant with EU and OSCE/ODIHR Recommendations and Human Rights Commitments’, implemented by the East Europe Foundation (EEF) in partnership with the ‘Partnership for Development’ Center (PDC), Piligrim Demo and Tarna Rom, and INFONET Alliance, funded by the European Union and co-funded by Sweden. The data included in the Report were gathered during 18 October – 13 November 2019. The Observation Mission for the General Local Elections of 20 October 2019 from the perspective of the inclusion of persons with disabilities consists of a group of relevant experts, including persons with disabilities, and covers geographically five administrative units (Edinet and Causeni districts; ATU Gagauzia, Balti and Chisinau municipalities). The main findings: - According to the updated data, 20 persons with disabilities stood as candidates at the General Local Elections of 20 October 2019. They have the following profile: 10 women and 10 men, 7 from urban regions and 13 from rural regions, 2 candidates for mayor, 20 candidates for local councilor, and 4 for district councilor, 7 have previously ran, and 3 of them have worked as local or district councilor, 13 ran for the first time, 20 candidates had mobility disabilities (!), 7 of whom were wheelchair users, - 2 independent candidates and 18 on party lists - The following results were registered after the elections: 9 persons became local councilors, of whom: . 7 women and 2 men, . 2 wheelchair users, . 1 independent candidate and 8 on party lists, . 1 public dignitary resigned. - The Observation Mission identified trends to marginalise the candidates with disabilities by placing them on non-eligible positions. In Ceadir-Lunga, a person with disabilities was initially placed by PSRM on an eligible position. Later, the election candidate modified the initial list, placing this person after the 20th position. In Glodeni, after being placed by ACUM Bloc on the last position on the list, a person with disabilities did not agree with the positioning and withdrew from the race. - In addition to the less favourable treatment identified in these cases, the Mission found a systemic breach characterised by the lack of real-time information on the election candidates included in the lists, their initial positioning and subsequent changes, as well as the issue of limited access to the information on candidate profile, which is an important prerequisite for free and fair elections. - Though there is some progress in ensuring the access of persons with sensory disabilities to election information, this access is still limited. The information broadcast by certain TV channels was accessible to the persons with sensory disabilities. Thus, during the monitoring period, TV Moldova 1, TVR Moldova, Media TV Cimislia, BTV Balti broadcast election debates translated into the sign language. The Central Electoral Commission is the only state authority that developed and broadcast videos (1 video (a total of 10 during the entire election period)) translated into the sign language (SL). No election candidate developed and disseminated videos in a format accessible for persons with sensory disabilities. - Political party headquarters, their representative offices in the territory, and the polling stations remain largely inaccessible to the persons with disabilities. The accessibility of access ways and of building entries where political parties are located is poor. Out of 104 offices assessed in 23 towns in Moldova, only 6 are accessible, 15 are partially accessible, and 83 are inaccessible. EOPSs’ accessibility remains a serious unsolved issue on the agenda of public authorities. Accessibility is one of the fundamental principles of the UN Convention and a prerequisite for the ability of persons with disabilities to enjoy other rights in various aspects of life. Accessibility issues were also found in the reports submitted by other organisations that monitored the local elections in Moldova. Most of the observations relate to the physical accessibility of persons with disabilities to the election process and to the insufficient accessibility of the polling stations. - ‘Unghiul’ newspaper offered a quick and effective assessment of the accessibility of 8 polling