Biotransenergetica: a Transpersonal Psychotherapy. a Description of BTE Practices from a Therapist and Client Perspective
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Middlesex University Research Repository An open access repository of Middlesex University research http://eprints.mdx.ac.uk Calabrese, Giovanna (2014) Biotransenergetica: a transpersonal psychotherapy. A description of BTE practices from a therapist and client perspective. Other thesis, Middlesex University / Metanoia Institute. [Thesis] Final accepted version (with author’s formatting) This version is available at: https://eprints.mdx.ac.uk/15779/ Copyright: Middlesex University Research Repository makes the University’s research available electronically. Copyright and moral rights to this work are retained by the author and/or other copyright owners unless otherwise stated. The work is supplied on the understanding that any use for commercial gain is strictly forbidden. A copy may be downloaded for personal, non-commercial, research or study without prior permission and without charge. Works, including theses and research projects, may not be reproduced in any format or medium, or extensive quotations taken from them, or their content changed in any way, without first obtaining permission in writing from the copyright holder(s). They may not be sold or exploited commercially in any format or medium without the prior written permission of the copyright holder(s). Full bibliographic details must be given when referring to, or quoting from full items including the author’s name, the title of the work, publication details where relevant (place, publisher, date), pag- ination, and for theses or dissertations the awarding institution, the degree type awarded, and the date of the award. If you believe that any material held in the repository infringes copyright law, please contact the Repository Team at Middlesex University via the following email address: [email protected] The item will be removed from the repository while any claim is being investigated. See also repository copyright: re-use policy: http://eprints.mdx.ac.uk/policies.html#copy GIOVANNA CALABRESE, M.D., Ph.D. Middlesex University and Metanoia Institute Doctor in Psychotherapy by Professional Study 21382 - DPY 5180 Biotransenergetica a transpersonal psychotherapy A description of BTE practices from a therapist and client perspective. February 2015 To those, psychotherapists and clients that sharing their therapeutic process and personal and spiritual development made possible to realize this study. AKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my family for the moral and material support which has accompanied me on this journey of further personal and professional development. Thanks to Eleonora Prazzoli and Paul Barber for the discussion and suggestions really helpful to complete this study and for their help in the writing of the thesis. Thanks also to Timothy Perazzoli for his help in the translation from Italian to English. Last, but not the least, a sincere thank to Pierluigi Lattuada for trusting me and letting me test his creature. CONTENTS ABSTRACT pg 1 PROLOGUE pg 3 CHAPTER 1 - Introduction: My research journey pg 5 1.1 Professional development as researcher pg 5 1.2 The meeting of transpersonal psychology and Biotransenergetica pg 10 1.3 The history of Biotransenergetica pg 12 1.4 My journey into consciousness and spirituality pg 15 1.5 The research question: a different approach to therapy and a new research approach pg 21 CHAPTER 2 - Biotransenergetica pg 26 2.1 Psychodynamic pg 26 2.2 Psychotherapy pg 32 2.3 Epistemology pg 42 2.4 Science pg 44 CHAPTER 3 - Research question pg 46 3.1 The meaning of Transe in psychotherapy pg 46 3.2 Methodology: heuristic inquiry in transpersonal research pg 49 CHAPTER 4 - Research project pg 55 4.1 Method: three levels of heuristic inquiry pg 55 4.2 Data collection pg 60 4.3 Quality assurance pg 61 4.4 Ethical issues pg 63 CHAPTER 5 - Data analysis: Explication phase pg 66 5.1 Data description pg 66 5.2The Transe from the therapist perspective pg 69 5.3 The Transe from the client perspective pg 74 5.4 The Transe in the healing process pg 89 5.5 Heuristic circles pg 97 CHAPTER 6 - Discussion: Creative synthesis pg 101 6.1 The meaning of Transe as a field of non-ordinary state of Consciousness pg 102 6.2 Biotransenergetica conceptual description: the meaning of Transe in a therapeutic setting pg 109 6.3 Biotransenergetica structural description: the therapeutic setting in transpersonal psychotherapy pg 117 6.4 Heuristic method for clinical studies in transpersonal pg 126 6.5 Critical consideration pg 131 CHAPTER 7 - Research outcomes pg 138 7.1 Writing a book: “Transe: the healing field” pg 138 7.2 Biotransenergetica presentation in mental health clinic and hospitals pg 140 7.3 Expanding research practice among transpersonal psychotherapists in Italy and in the Eurotas Community pg 142 EPILOGUE pg 148 REFERENCES pg 150 APPENDIXES Appendix 1 – Biotransenergetica map pg 162 Appendix 2- Recruitment letter and consent forms pg 163 Appendix 3 – Data description tables pg 168 Appendix 4 – Research outcomes pg 179 ABSTRACT In Biotransenergetica (BTE), a transpersonal psychotherapy model developed in the 1980s by Lattuada, the uniqueness of self-experience is pivotal. In the therapeutic process inner experiences and felt sense are essential. These are contained in the concept of Transe. During the psychotherapy session the psychotherapist favors the creation of the Transe, a field, using mindfulness techniques; the psychotherapist and the patient “indwell” together in this experience at a multilevel dimension (physical, emotional, energetic, mental and spiritual) to allow the psychotherapeutic process to happen. The present study was carried out to describe the psychotherapist and the patient lived experience of the Transe. The aim was to describe how this process actually works to the therapeutic effect and could relate to self- development. The study, involving 7 psychotherapists and 13 patients, for a total of 121 clinical sessions, comes within the field of qualitative research, using a heuristic methodology, to provide a conceptual and structural description of BTE practice based on its clinical application. The heuristic method described by Moustakas, has been adapted for this particular clinical setting. As it is described by the patients and the psychotherapists, the Transe, allows integration of the five levels, physical, emotional, mental, energetic and spiritual, to occur. At the same time a process of dis-identification from the mental and emotional contents might happen. Patients reported that the therapeutic process during the Transe would lead to a subjective state of well being, improving awareness about inner mechanisms, both on the mental and the emotional levels. The patients reported also an improved ability of self listening and also listening to others’ emotion, leading to more satisfying relationships. The Transe as a non ordinary state of consciousness will be discussed comparing it with other mindfulness practices applied in different therapeutic contexts, both for psychological support and for medical problems. Moreover, 1 I will consider the Transe from the evidences coming from neuroscience studies about the effect of mindfulness practices on brain structure and functions. Results will also be discussed from BTE theoretical framework, contrasting BTE structural boundaries with other psychotherapy approaches, mainly Bioenergetic and Gestalt. A discussion about the heuristic method used, as a valid tool to study non ordinary state of consciousness in transpersonal psychotherapy research, will be also provided. 2 PROLOGUE Close your eyes, relax, find a comfortable position. Slowly move your attention to your body, feel the heaviness of your body and leave it down, let all the heavy things to go down to mother earth, she will accept everything, hold everything, transform everything; you just have to leave everything to her... At the same time keep breathing, follow your breath, as the air comes from up above, from the sky, filling your body with lightness; inhale and exhale, and when you exhale the light breath will go up connecting you with the sky... Keep your attention to this incessant flow: everything which weights goes down, everything which is light goes up, and you stay there observing with a focused attention, like a fire lighting up in the dark... The very first time I did this practice it was just relaxing. Practicing it more often, I started to detach from whatever was around me, the noisy street outside, footsteps in the other room; I could detach also from what was inside: worries about some difficult situation at home, fear of not succeeding. Once I was in such a state of detachment, I could start to feel a pain, heaviness in my heart, and I could talk to my heart, ask him what was hurting him. However, it was not always, pain. Being at 0, 0, like the Tao, cannot be defined; it is only possible to say what it is not, or what it is like. Can be like a falling drop and I observe it in the exact moment it detaches, slowly... closing the circle, detach from the surface and free itself, free to fall, and I keep my attention to the exact moment of that beginning... Once I am there I forget the drop, and the fall, I will stay there, empty and calm... and light and joy will came, but in a way that they have no name, no need to be told, I just feel them, filling me from the inside...I will became that light and that joy. Once I am there I can acknowledge my spiritual part, recognize that all my life 3 story is not so important, and whatever was bothering me is not really filling me from the outside with pain and worries, as long as I remember that I can be also light and joy. And when I will be back to my ordinary state of consciousness, I do not need to explain, I will just know that now something is different. When I started to use these techniques in my clinical practices, may be even when I was learning them, I started to wonder how would they relate to the therapeutic process.