Annual Supervision Report 2010. Norwegian Board of Health Supervision

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Annual Supervision Report 2010. Norwegian Board of Health Supervision Annual Supervision Report 2 0 1 0 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 Content Use management systems actively! . 3 Municipal services for frail elderly people: Are they adequate? . 4–7 Regional supervision of specialized health services . 8–9 Mixing roles . 10–11 Management of medication – what can go wrong? . 12 Health care personnel who cross borders . 13 When deficiencies in the health service affect elderly people and other people with comprehensive needs for care . .14-19 More speedy supervision after unnatural death or serious injury . .20-21 Countrywide Supervision 2011 . 22 The first supervision of the regulations relating to handling human cells and tissue . 23 Facts and figures . 24–33 Published by the Norwegian Board of Health Supervision Editor: Lars E. Hanssen Editorial Group: Berit Austveg, Magne Braaten, Helge Høifødt, Sverre Nesheim, Finn Pedersen (leader), Mariann Aronsen, Anne Solberg and Nina Vedholm. English translation: Linda Grytten Graphic layout and printing: 07 Gruppen. Illustrations: Inger Sandved Anfinsen Kobolt Design Font: Times New Roman 10.6/12.2 point ISSN 1501-8083 Comments and questions can be sent to: [email protected] The Annual Supervision Report 2010 is also available in English on the website of the Norwegian Board of Health Supervision: www.helsetilsynet.no. A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 Use management systems actively! Welfare services in Norway are based organization. An adequate manage- on the premise that everyone shall ment system must be suitable for daily have equal access to sound and use, and at the same time it must be adequate services. The state, the anchored in the top leadership and the municipalities and the county committee. It must show what the authorities have responsibility for requirements are and it must be ensuring that this aim is achieved. suitable as a basis for sharing experi- Resources are allocated from central ence both within the organization and funding through the public budget. between different organizations. Therefore, an understanding of fairness and equity in a Norwegian The management system is the context is based on the ability and the leaders’ tool for ensuring that the will to achieve solidarity for all groups requirement to provide sound and in the population in all parts of the adequate services, along with other country. For many decades, here in requirements, is met. It must be based Norway there has been political on the requirements laid down in the agreement about these main legislation. But if the system is not principles. based on daily activities, it is not a «An adequate useful tool. It is important that leaders In order to ensure equal access to management system investigate nonconformities and learn services that are sound and adequate, from them. The management system comprehensive legislation has been must be suitable for must be continually adapted according developed. An important aim of the to experience gained within the legislation is that services shall be safe daily use, and at the organization and in other organiza- and predictable for clients. Meeting same time it must be tions. Experience gained from supervi- the statutory requirements and sion and from adverse events is also providing services within the anchored in the top useful. It is worth noting that in the economic constraints involves two documents from the Ministry of different management principles. In leadership and the Health and Care Services defining the order to succeed, the leadership must committee.» tasks for 2011, the health trusts are be able to understand the principles directed to learn from adverse events and requirements that form the basis and system failure both at the leaders- for Norwegian welfare services, and We are particularly concerned that the hip level and at the committee level. at the same time provide services in organizations should have a clear The same challenge can just as well be a way that utilizes resources as conception of what can be regarded as given to the municipalities. effectively as possible. sound and adequate services. The aim of both planned supervision and We see that supervision works. The Norwegian legislation contains few incident-based supervision is often to effect can be even greater if the requirements about how services shall assess whether service providers have findings we report from supervision be organized, but contains relatively planned and carried out their work in and from the complaints we deal with strict requirements about the content such a way as to ensure that the are also used by other service provi- of the services. Therefore, in order to services that are provided are sound ders. We are pleased to see the assess how resources are utilized, it is and adequate. This is the essence of progress being made by the municipa- not sufficient to base management on the concept of quality in order to lities and the health trusts. A summary economic data. Leadership, the ensure patient safety. of our findings from supervision municipal councils and the executive carried out in 2010 is presented in this committees of the health trusts must The management system can just as publication. More can be found on our have a continuous overview of the well be called the internal control web site: www.helsetilsynet.no. quality of the services that they system or the patient safety system. provide. Based on the findings from But the system must be able to detect supervision, we know that there is new professional and clinical know- much to be done in this area. ledge and ensure that this knowledge is made known and used in the Lars E. Hansen A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 3 4 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 A n n u A l S u p e r v i S i o n r e p o r t 2 0 1 0 Municipal services for frail elderly people: Are they adequate? In 2010, as part of our focus Supervision of municipal provided, and changes in the way on supervision of services for health and social services for personnel provide care, can make elderly people, we carried out elderly people with dementia clients more confused. We found that supervision of municipal Many people suffer from dementia, some clients had had as many as 26 health and social service. We and the prevalence increases with different service providers in one carried out supervision of increasing age. Figures from the month. We expect municipalities to nursing homes, the home Norwegian Directorate of Health introduce measures and arrangements nursing service, general show that about 17 per cent of people that ensure that the special needs of practitioners, and the aged 80-84, and about 41 per cent of people with dementia are met. For administrative routines of people aged 90 and over, suffer from example, the leadership must evaluate the municipalities. We used dementia. This disease also affects the measures to limit the number of care several different types of elderly person’s family and friends. providers. Sound reporting and methodology. Altogether, we documentation shall ensure that carried out supervision of 294 In 2010, supervision was carried out helpers always know what care each services. Here, we present a in 48 municipalities. The aim was to individual client needs and what other selection of our findings. identify, investigate and follow up colleagues have done, planned and We will continue this elderly people with dementia living in observed. supervision in their own homes, and cooperation 2011. with general practitioners. Breaches of the legislation were found in 32 of the municipalities. «Frequent changes in Many municipalities lacked adequate personnel, changes in the routines for identifying patients with time care is provided, and dementia, for ensuring that they receive adequate medical care, and for changes in the way identifying changes in patients’ needs. Cooperation with general personnel provide care, practitioners was not always can make clients more adequately planned. When there is no common understanding confused. We found that of how tasks shall be carried out, it is up to some clients had had as the individual how things shall be done. many as 26 different Such a practice leaves service providers in one things to chance and increases the risk that month.» services are inadequate. The result may be that people with dementia are Knowledge about dementia is impor- not identified and tant in order to provide sound services investigated as they to people with this diagnosis. Several should be, and that they municipalities lacked training plans, do not receive the help they need. and staff training was inadequate in This can have serious consequences many services. Lack of qualified for people with dementia, who cannot personnel can result in people with express their needs.
Recommended publications
  • Daming Jin Master Thesis
    Corporate Governance of Norwegian Health Trusts with Sector Political Goals Daming Jin Master thesis Department of Health Management and Health Economics UNIVERSITY OF OSLO May 15, 2011 SUMMARY Since 2002, the ownership of Norwegian hospitals has been centralized to the state. The four regional health authorities are responsible for the management of the hospitals, and the actual performance is done by the subsidiary health trusts (or HFs). As state-owned enterprises with certain sector political goals, the corporate governance of the health trusts is not exactly the same as private enterprises which mainly pursue pure business goals. The survey which the thesis uses investigates the HF board members’ opinions on some issues of sector political goals and corporate governance. The main purpose of this thesis is to find the differences of the opinions among different groups of HF board members, and to study whether the differences are consistent with relevant theories such as motivation and management theories. The data of the thesis is based on a questionnaire of the survey program Management of State-owned enterprises with sector political goals. The respondents of the survey cover all HF board members who are the target population of my research. Several quantitative methods, such as descriptive statistics and non-parametric tests, are chosen to detect the HF board members’ opinions and the differences of their opinions on the issues of sector political goals and corporate governance. The analyses mainly show that, the appointed board members with macro and broad perspective pay more attention to sector political goals than the employee representatives with micro and specific perspective do.
    [Show full text]
  • Response of the Norwegian Government to the Report of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman Or Degrad
    CPT/Inf (2019) 22 Response of the Norwegian Government to the report of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) on its visit to Norway from 28 May to 5 June 2018 The Norwegian Government has requested the publication of this response. The CPT’s report on the May/June 2018 visit to Norway is set out in document CPT/Inf (2019) 1. Strasbourg, 28 June 2019 Response of the Norwegian authorities to the report of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment’s (CPT) periodic visit to Norway from 28th May to 5th June 2018. Item 7 - The CPT trusts that the Norwegian authorities will take all necessary steps to ensure that, also in the future, visiting delegations of the Committee will have unrestricted access to medical files in all types of establishments where persons may be deprived of their liberty, as had been the case during this and all previous visits by the CPT to Norway. Reply: Norway's interpretation of Article 8, paragraph 2, sub-paragraph (d) of the Convention is that it entails no obligation to grant the Committee unlimited access to documents and information, regardless of Norwegian rules of confidentiality. Both Article 8, paragraph 2, sub-paragraph (d) of the Convention and paragraph 64 of the Explanatory Report to the Convention acknowledge that member States have different rules concerning disclosure of information, and it is stated that the Committee shall take such rules into consideration when seeking information.
    [Show full text]
  • Adoption of Routine Telemedicine in Norway: the Current Picture
    Global Health Action æ ORIGINAL ARTICLE Adoption of routine telemedicine in Norway: the current picture Paolo Zanaboni1*, Undine Knarvik1 and Richard Wootton1,2 1Norwegian Centre for Integrated Care and Telemedicine, University Hospital of North Norway, Tromsø, Norway; 2Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Tromsø, Tromsø, Norway Background: Telemedicine appears to be ready for wider adoption. Although existing research evidence is useful, the adoption of routine telemedicine in healthcare systems has been slow. Objective: We conducted a study to explore the current use of routine telemedicine in Norway, at national, regional, and local levels, to provide objective and up-to-date information and to estimate the potential for wider adoption of telemedicine. Design: A top-down approach was used to collect official data on the national use of telemedicine from the Norwegian Patient Register. A bottom-up approach was used to collect complementary information on the routine use of telemedicine through a survey conducted at the five largest publicly funded hospitals. Results: Results show that routine telemedicine has been adopted in all health regions in Norway and in 68% of hospitals. Despite being widely adopted, the current level of use of telemedicine is low compared to the number of face-to-face visits. Examples of routine telemedicine can be found in several clinical specialties. Most services connect different hospitals in secondary care, and they are mostly delivered as teleconsultations via videoconference. Conclusions: Routine telemedicine in Norway has been widely adopted, probably for geographical reasons, as in other settings. However, the level of use of telemedicine in Norway is rather low, and it has significant potential for further development as an alternative to face-to-face outpatient visits.
    [Show full text]
  • The Western Norway Regional Health Authority
    The Western Norway Regional Health Authority The Western Norway Regional Health Authority (WNRHA, "Helse Vest") has overall responsibility for providing specialist healthcare services in the counties of Rogaland, Hordaland and Sogn og Fjordane. Its role is to ensure that people in the region have access to the services that they are legally entitled to. Helse Vest owns the six health trusts in the region and provides them with group management services. It also owns the ICT provider Helse Vest IKT AS. The health trusts employ around 27,500 health service staff. The authority’s total budget is approximately NOK 25 billion. Around 50 people are employed directly by the authority, which is based at Forus in Stavanger. Helse Vest is one of four regional health authorities in Norway and reports to the Ministry of Health and Care Services. The six health trusts within Helse Vest in addition to Helse Vest IKT AS are: Bergen Hospital Trust Fonna Hospital Trust Førde Hospital Trust Stavanger Hospital Trust Trust Sjukehusapoteka Vest (Hospital Pharmacies) Trust Helse Vest Procurement (est. April 2015) The health trusts in the region own and operate around 50 public hospitals and other health institutions, and they provide health care to a population of approximately 1.1 million. Overall objectives and priorities Patient treatment Health personnel training Research Training of patients and next of kin Mission and vision Mission: Helse Vest should provide effective and future-orientated high-quality health services. The services should contribute to good health and quality of life, and they should promote self-rehabilitation. Vision: Helse Vest delivers the very best in service, quality and research and is your preferred health services provider.
    [Show full text]
  • The State Ownership Report 2018
    THE STATE OWNERSHIP REPORT 2018 1 Contents In case of discrepancy between the original text in Norwegian Contents and the English translation, the Norwegian text shall prevail. Foreword by the Minister 3 Electronic Chart Centre AS 64 Rogaland Teater AS 104 GIEK Kredittforsikring AS 65 Simula Research Scope and key figures 5 Investinor AS 66 Laboratory AS 105 Key issues for the State as owner 9 Kommunalbanken AS 67 Siva – Selskapet for Industrivekst SF 106 Mantena AS 68 Return and financial values 11 Space Norway AS 107 Nysnø Klimainvesteringer AS 69 Statnett SF 108 Key figures describing Posten Norge AS 70 Statskog SF 109 financial performance 17 Statkraft SF 71 Staur gård AS 110 Vygruppen AS 72 Corporate governance 23 Store Norske Spitsbergen Kulkompani AS 111 You are what you measure 29 CATEGORY 4 Talent Norge AS 112 Diversity as a – Sectoral policy objectives Trøndelag Teater AS 113 competitive advantage 35 Andøya Space Center AS 76 Universitetssenteret Avinor AS 77 på Svalbard AS 114 AS Vinmonopolet 115 CATEGORY 1– Bane NOR SF 78 Commercial objectives Bjørnøen AS 79 Carte Blanche AS 80 Regional health authorities Ambita AS 42 AS Den Nationale Scene 81 Helse Midt-Norge RHF 118 Baneservice AS 43 Den Norske Opera & Ballett AS 82 Helse Nord RHF 119 Entra ASA 44 Eksportkreditt Norge AS 83 Helse Sør-Øst RHF 120 Flytoget AS 45 Enova SF 84 Helse Vest RHF 121 Mesta AS 46 Entur AS 85 Other companies 123 Gassco AS 86 CATEGORY 2 – Commercial objectives and ensuring head office functions Gassnova SF 87 Appendices 125 in Norway Graminor AS 88 Remuneration
    [Show full text]
  • The State Ownership Report 2017
    Tittel innTHE her STATE OWNERSHIP REPORT 2017 1 Innhold In case of discrepancy between the original text in Norwegian and the English translation, the Norwegian text shall prevail. In case of discrepancy between the original text in Norwegian Contents and the English translation, the Norwegian text shall prevail. Foreword 3 CATEGORY 3 Nye Veier AS 102 Contents – Commercial objectives and Petoro AS 103 Scope and key figures 5 other specifically defined objectives Rogaland Teater AS 104 Key issues for Argentum Simula Research Contents 2 the State as owner 9 Fondsinvesteringer AS 64 Laboratory AS 105 Eksportfinans ASA 65 Siva – Selskapet Return and financial values 13 Electronic Chart Centre AS 66 for Industrivekst SF 106 Foreword 3 Key figures describing GIEK Kredittforsikring AS 67 Space Norway AS 107 financial performance 19 Investinor AS 68 Statnett SF 108 Kommunalbanken AS 69 Statskog SF 109 Turn yourself inside out! Mantena AS 70 Staur gård AS 110 Opportunities with better Scope and key figures 5 NSB AS 71 Store Norske Spits- corporate reporting 25 bergen Kulkompani AS 111 Overview of the state’s direct ownership by ministry 6 Posten Norge AS 72 Talent Norge AS 112 Corporate governance 29 Statkraft SF 73 Trøndelag Teater AS 113 Perspectives on UNINETT AS 114 the work relating to CATEGORY 4 goals and strategies 37 Universitetssenteret Key issues for – Sectoral policy objectives på Svalbard AS 115 Andøya Space Center AS 76 AS Vinmonopolet 116 CATEGORY 1 Avinor AS 77 – Commercial objectives Bane NOR SF 78 Regional health authorities the
    [Show full text]
  • QUALITY and COSTS at the HOSPITAL LEVEL in NORWAY Does There Exist a Trade-Off Between Quality and Costs at Norwegian Hospitals?
    QUALITY AND COSTS AT THE HOSPITAL LEVEL IN NORWAY Does there exist a trade-off between quality and costs at Norwegian hospitals? Author: Supervisor: Elise Emilsen Bakke Sverre A. C. Kittelsen Thesis submitted as a part of the Master of Philosophy Degree in Health Economics, Policy and Management Department of Health Management and Health Economics The Faculty of Medicine University of Oslo May 15, 2019 I © Elise Emilsen Bakke 2019 Quality and Costs at the Hospital Level in Norway Elise Emilsen Bakke http://www.duo.uio.no/ Printed: Reprosentralen, University of Oslo II ABSTRACT Background: Norway has throughout history introduced several reforms in order to aim focus on cost containment and improving efficiency in the health sector. However, expenditures are rising and there is a political pressure to contain costs as well as being efficient. As a result, it has led to a larger policy focus on efficiency and costs, but this can affect the level of quality of the health services. It is therefore an interest to find more information on the association between quality and costs across the Norwegian hospitals. The objective: This paper analyses the relationship between costs and quality across 22 Norwegian hospitals for the years 2008 to 2014. The objective is to study the association between quality and costs at 22 Norwegian hospitals and determine if a trade-off is present between quality and costs. A previous study found no clear cost-quality trade-off. Further on, average cost efficiency is estimated for all hospital across the 7 years in order to see how the level of cost efficiency varies.
    [Show full text]
  • ANNUAL SUPERVISION REPORT 2005 Contents Page Introduction
    ANNUAL SUPERVISION REPORT 2005 Contents page Introduction .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Use of Coercion and Restraint ................................................................................................................................................................... 4–5 Do Clients with Long-term, Complex Needs Receive Fragmentary and Divided Services? .............................. 6–7 Serious defi ciencies in confi dentiality and patient record keeping in hospital departments of gastrointestinal surgery ................................................................................................................... 9–10 Inadequate patient record keeping ....................................................................................................................................................... 11 Suicide despite treatment ............................................................................................................................................................................ 11 Hospital occupancy rates that are too high ..................................................................................................................................... 13 Evaluation of Supervision of Maternity Units .................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Health Buildings in Norway - a Historical Overview
    Health buildings in Norway - a historical overview Runar Jordåen he purpose of this article is to provide a historical overview of the most important changes Tand characteristics of measures taken in relation to illness and the provision of care services, with special emphasis on how institutions have emerged and changed. Much has been written about the general history of the health service on the one hand, and about specific hospitals and facilities on the other hand, but there is no comprehensive overview of the Norwegian health insti- tutions from the Middle Ages and to today. A decision has been made that somatic and psychiatric hospitals are to be at the centre of the presentation, as these types of institutions are at the centre of today's health trusts and their histories are thus central to the national preservation plan. This article was written for the national preservation plan's preliminary project.1 INTRODUCTION The history of the health measures taken through the clinical pictures and conceptualisations of the state. ages and the buildings that have been raised to serve These aspects go beyond what we today call the health these purposes is a complex one. The health buildings sector, both because the concentration of health and tell us not only a history of medical advances and care functions as state concern is a relatively new how society has handled illness and those who are ill phenomenon in Norway, and because the buildings and in need of care, they are also silent witnesses to reveal so much about social conditions that fall societal ideologies, views of human life, demography, outside of pure health issues.
    [Show full text]
  • The National System for the Introduction of New Health Technologies Within the Specialist Health Service – for Better and Safer Patient Care
    System Description The National system for the introduction of new health technologies within the specialist health service – For better and safer patient care A working document from - The Regional Health Authorities - The Norwegian Medicines Agency - The Norwegian Knowledge Centre for Health Services - The Norwegian Directorate of Health June 2013/January 2014 Version: 1.0 Date: 11 June 2013/23 January 2014 Contents 1.0 Summary 4 2.0 Abbreviations 9 3.0 Glossary 10 4.0 Approval and regulation of health technologies in the health services 12 5.0 Introduction 13 6.0 Functions and appraisal of technologies in the national system for introduction of new health technologies within the specialist health service 16 6.1 Horizon scanning 16 6.2 Proposals for National Health Technology Assessments 16 6.3 Health Technology Assessments 21 6.4 HTAs and the disinvestment of existing health technologies 29 7.0 Decision-making processes 30 8.0 National clinical guidelines 30 9.0 Implementation and follow-up during to the introduction of new health technologies 32 10.0 The four Regional Health Authorities 32 11.0 National Council for Priority Setting in Health Care 33 12.0 Patient perspective and participation 33 13.0 Manufacturers, innovation and research groups 34 14.0 Economics and financing 34 14.1 Economic evaluation of health initiatives 34 14.2 The Regional Health Authorities' financing system 34 15.0 Significance for the primary health service 35 16.0 Monitoring and further development of the national system for the introduction of new health technologies 36 17.0 Knowledge gaps and the instigation of clinical studies 36 18.0 Participation in international collaboration 37 19.0 References 37 Publishers The Regional Health Authorities The Norwegian Knowledge Centre for the Health Services The Norwegian Medicines Agency The Norwegian Directorate of Health Contributors The present document has been prepared by the national working group for the introduction of new health technologies.
    [Show full text]
  • Adoption of Routine Telemedicine in Norway, an Overview of Activities from 2009 to 2011
    Project report Adoption of Routine Telemedicine in Norway An overview of activities from 2009 to 2011 A study based on a quantitative data collection through the Norwegian Patient Register, as well as a qualitative and detailed survey on existing routine telemedicine services in five Norwegian hospitals Undine Knarvik, Paolo Zanaboni, Richard Wootton Title: Adoption of Routine Telemedicine in Norway, An overview of activities from 2009 to 2011 NST-report: 03-2014 Project manager: Undine Knarvik Authors: Undine Knarvik, Paolo Zanaboni, Richard Wootton ISBN: 978-82-8242-041-9 Date: 2014-01-17 Number of pages: 52 Keywords: telemedicine; adoption; routine use; implementation; decision- making. Summary: This study provides findings regarding the adoption of telemedicine in Norway at regional, institutional and clinical level. We reported both quantitative data collected through the Norwegian Patient Register, and more qualitative and detailed data regarding routine telemedicine services in five Norwegian hospitals through a survey. The results are in line with other studies. The rate of adoption is high, and examples of routine telemedicine can be found in several clinical specialties. However, similarly to the experience in other countries, the current level of use of telemedicine in Norway is still rather low, with significant potential for further development as alternative to face-to-face visits. We believe that the adoption of telemedicine is influenced by several contextual factors, such as reimbursement policies as a form of incentive for health professionals. This study is considered as a first attempt to map routine telemedicine services in Norway, and provides useful findings to understand the adoption of telemedicine in routine use.
    [Show full text]
  • Approved Research Organisations
    Approved research organisations A research organisation is an entity, irrespective of its legal status (organised under public or private law) or way of financing, whose primary goal is to independently conduct fundamental research and/or applied research (industrial research and experimental development). The following types of organisations are approved as research organisations by the Research Council, and are eligible to serve as Project Owners and/or partners in grant applications and projects stipulating that these roles must be held by approved research organisations: universities, specialised university colleges and university colleges accredited at the institution level by the Norwegian Agency for Quality Assurance in Education (NOKUT); research organisations encompassed by the Norwegian guidelines for public basic funding of research institutes health trusts/hospitals with legally mandated research and development tasks and private, non-profit hospitals that are encompassed by the national system for measuring research activity under the Ministry of Health and Care Services; other organisations that have research as an objective and have been assessed and approved in accordance with the definition of research organisation in the state aid rules and an overall assessment carried out by the Research Council. The list below provides an overview of the organisations that have been approved as research organisations in accordance with the Research Council’s criteria. Organisations that are not listed below must apply for qualification
    [Show full text]