Portrait of Don Mattera ------8
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ON AFRICANA/ISLAMICA EXISTENTIAL THOUGHT: DON MATTERA AND THE QUESTION OF TRANSCENDENCE Tahir Fuzile T. Sitoto (STTFUZ001) Thesis Presented for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the Department of Religious Studies, Faculty of Humanities UNIVERSITY OF CAPE TOWN Supervisor: Professor A.K. Tayob University of Cape Town Submitted: June 2018 The copyright of this thesis vests in the author. No quotation from it or information derived from it is to be published without full acknowledgement of the source. The thesis is to be used for private study or non- commercial research purposes only. Published by the University of Cape Town (UCT) in terms of the non-exclusive license granted to UCT by the author. University of Cape Town DECLARATION I declare that this thesis has been composed solely by myself and that it has not been submitted, in whole or in part, in any previous application for a degree. Except where stated otherwise by reference or acknowledgements, the work presented is entirely my own. Name: Tahir Fuzile T. Sitoto Student number: STTFUZOOI Signature: Date: 25 June 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------2 TABLE OF CONTENTS --------------------------------------------------------------------------3 PORTRAIT OF DON MATTERA --------------------------------------------------------------8 DEDICATION ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------9 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ----------------------------------------------------------------------10 ABSTRACT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------14 PART I: SITUATING THE STUDY, LITERATURE REVIEW, BIOGRAPHICAL MATTERS, METHOD AND THEORETICAL ISSUES CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ---------------------------------------------------------------17 Background and Motivation for the Study ---------------------------------------------------17 Locating Don Mattera in the Study: A Brief Personal Narrative ------------------------18 Focus of Study --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------21 Between ‘Obscurity’ and ‘Reception’: Why a Dissertation on Don Mattera Matters? --25 Method, Questions Considered and Theoretical Approach -------------------------------37 Preliminary Note on Africana/Islamica Existential Thought as a Conceptual and Theoretical Approach---- ---------------------------------------------------------------------38 Research Methodology: A Case Study Design Approach ----------------------------------44 Chapter Outline and Structure of the Dissertation -----------------------------------------46 3 CHAPTER 2: MATTERA: AN INTELLECTUAL BIOGRAPHICAL PORTRAIT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------48 Introduction: Why an Intellectual Portrait? -------------------------------------------------48 Unconventional and ‘Self-Taught’: The Making of a Writer and an Intellectual ----50 Major Works, Themes and Reception ---------------------------------------------------------51 Birth, Early Pedagogy and the Gift of Poetry ------------------------------------------------52 Delinquency: From Catholic Convent to the ‘Twilight Zone’ ----------------------------55 ‘Metamorphosis’ and a Heightened Political Consciousness ------------------------------57 Literary Censorship, Banning Orders and House Arrest: 1975–1983 ---------------------60 From Sophiatown Renaissance to Post-1976 Cultural Icon: Mattera as an ‘Intellectual Bridge’ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------61 Becoming a Muslim: Mattera’s Enthralment with Islam’s notion of Compassion----63 Vocation as a Journalist --------------------------------------------------------------------------65 Rhetoric and Practice of a Journalist: When Art and Journalism Collide ---------------67 Advocacy or Radical Journalism? ---------------------------------------------------------------70 ‘Rhythm of Words’ in Print: Mattera’s Journalistic Style -----------------------------------71 Concluding Remarks ------------------------------------------------------------------------------76 CHAPTER 3: ON AFRICANA/ISLAMICA EXISTENTIAL THOUGHT (AND PHILOSOPHY) AS A CONCEPTUAL APPROACH AND METHOD ---------------78 Introduction ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------78 4 Africana Thought (and Studies), More Than a Label: Genesis of an Academic Field ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------84 ‘Africology’ and the Afrocentric Critique of Africana Thought and Studies ------------91 Africana Existential Thought/Philosophy an Epistemological Shift from Afrocentricity --------------------------------------------------------------------------------93 On ‘Existential’ in Africana/Islamica Existential Thought -------------------------------97 Inscribing Islam in Africana Existential Thought ------------------------------------------101 On Transcendence as a Theoretical Point of Departure ----------------------------------103 Concluding Remarks -----------------------------------------------------------------------------105 PART II: POETRY, FICTION AND EMERGING THEMES CHAPTER 4: REREADING MATTERA’S POETRY: THE ‘BARD OF LIBERATION’ AND ‘POET OF COMPASSION’ ----------------------------------------108 Introduction: Plotting a Reading of Mattera’s Poetry ------------------------------------108 The Poet and His Work: An Overview -------------------------------------------------------110 Search for ‘Complexity of Vision’ in Mattera’s Poetry: An Intertextual Reading --111 The Paradoxical and the Dialectical in Mattera’s Poetry ---------------------------------125 Transcendence and ‘Implicit’ Religiosity in Mattera’s Poetry --------------------------128 Concluding Remarks -----------------------------------------------------------------------------133 5 CHAPTER 5: ON MATTERA’S FICTION: DECENTRING THE ‘PROTEST ETHOS’ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------136 Introduction: Locating an Approach to Reading the Short Stories --------------------136 The Short Stories: Context and Content -----------------------------------------------------140 Analysis and an Interpretation: Religiosity and Transcendence Embedded in the Political ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------152 Concluding Remarks -----------------------------------------------------------------------------157 PART III: COMPARATIVE FOCUS AND CONCLUSION CHAPTER 6: MATTERA IN CONVERSATION WITH MALCOLM X: DELINEATING CONTOURS OF AFRICANA/ISLAMICA EXISTENTIAL THOUGHT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------159 Introduction: Why Read Mattera with Malcolm X? ---------------------------------------159 Islam and Black Experience in South Africa and North America: Brief Overview --162 ‘But Allah Had Another Plan’: Mattera and Malcolm X’s ‘Black Pilgrimage To Islam’ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------167 Flight from an Anti-Black World? --------------------------------------------------------------169 Reading Mattera and Malcolm X through black/Africana Existential Philosophy -175 The Paradox of Race and Quest to Transcend ‘Racial Frontiers’ ------------------------178 On Compassion as Self-Transcendence -------------------------------------------------------182 6 Concluding Remarks-----------------------------------------------------------------------------188 CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION: DRAWING MEANINGS, READINGS AND AN INTERPRETATION -----------------------------------------------------------------------192 Introduction ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------192 Discussion of Content and This Study’s Contribution ------------------------------------195 Discursive Rupture with Conventional black/Africana Existential Philosophy and Thought ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------199 Possible Limitation ------------------------------------------------------------------------------206 Concluding Remarks ----------------------------------------------------------------------------206 BIBLIOGRAPHY --------------------------------------------------------------------------------209 7 PORTRAIT OF DON MATTERA Photo Courtesy South African History Online (SAHO) 8 DEDICATION For all his dislike for interviews, Don Mattera gave time whenever we met to share insights on different aspects of his life, work and writings. I cannot thank you sufficiently, ‘Bra Don’, for your selfless spirit and compassion. This work is dedicated to you and the Mattera clan and to the memory of my late father, uVakele Alfred Sitoto, who departed so early to the world of the unseen. 9 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS To complete this study has taken a long journey saddled with many challenges and low and high moments. From the onset, I would like to thank my supervisor, Professor Abdulkader Tayob, whose critical guidance and patience ensured that this dissertation ended up in a decent form. I cannot thank him enough for embracing a prodigal student back from the wilderness. Without his gentle persuasion, this work would have remained a project deferred. Heartfelt thanks are also due to Nabowayah Kafaar, Tasneem Wise and Danika Driesen for ensuring that ‘all documents’ and registration procedures at UCT were in