Utility Rate Analysis Consultants (URAC) 156 Scranton Avenue (516) 536-4545 fax (516) 594-9413 Lynbrook, NY 11563 email: [email protected] ______
December 14, 2017
Submitted by email to [email protected] Ms. Kathleen H. Burgess, Secretary State of New York Department of Public Service 3 Empire State Plaza Albany, NY 12223
Re: Re: PETITION FOR REHEARING 17-S-0542 - In the Matter of the Rules and Regulations of the Public Service Commission, Contained in 16 NYCRR, in Relation to Complaint Procedures—Appeal by 36 East 72 Street Corp. of the Informal Decision Rendered in Favor of Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. (649082).
Dear Secretary Burgess:
Subsequent to our filing for rehearing in the above referenced matter, Ms. Mary
Krayeske, representing Con Edison, contacted my office and advised that in consumer complaint case 639886 URAC was informed that meter number 7825 was tested on September 9, 2015 and found to be registering slow at 94.87%. The filing in that case directly conflicts with a filing in consumer complaint case 549672, on which I relied, where Con Edison listed meters tested in bulk and testified that meter number 7825 was not tested. I have attached both the meter test report from case 639886 and the submission by Con Ed in 549672.
After review of both consumer complaint files I have decided that the meter test report in case 639886 outweighs the submission by Con Edison in case 549672. As such, unless the
Commission see’s any reason otherwise, I am withdrawing the Petition and the matter can be considered closed.
Kathleen H. Burgess, Secretary December 14, 2017 Page 2 of 2
If you have questions or require further information please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely, Douglas DiCeglio Douglas DiCeglio President of URAC, Complainants Representative
C: Mr. Matt Sexton by email [email protected]
Ms. Mary Krayeske by email [email protected]
ConsoHdated Edison Company of New York, Inc.
Shuntflo Steam Meter Air Calibration 91612016:07:56:03
Employee: MfteheD, Authouy Type Of Test: Periodie Test Date: 091191Z015 Meter #: 7825 Size: ZKS Plate: B Line #: 1 Barometric Pressure(Pb): 30.68 Date Out of Service: 08l131Z015 Overhauled By: Overhauled Date: ~t PolJot JIG JIIa/Bl Po .. To 2'11 - UK IIPJI/s..... n' 35 ... · n.n f.017 ".3410 137.5 112.' 53.10 0.770. un 31.73 n.07 l.n7 '.32. In.l 113.3 51.07 0.7'" un U' 27." 28.15 1.001 '.73. 111.1 115.' n.n 0.7700 2671 27." 28 ••4 5."0 '.723 U2.' 111.' n.n 0.7617 2144 20' 11.74 20.02 5 •• n 5.012 1".3 118.3 75.37 0.700 un 1'.11 20.07 B.'" 5.0n lt5.2 118 •• 11.73 0.7&13 2U3 7" 7.lt 7.01 5.'12 5."2 U4.' 111.' 1n.U 0.7'.' 2107 7.11 7.02 I .•n 5.160 144 •• 11•• 0 130.51 0.7110 25"
Averages Otber ____ ~ .. ___.. __4_ ---.. --~ BAM: 0.769S -QmaxPPH: 2620.91
RPHlSRHm: 2647 SRPMlSRHm: 0.0176
D.C.: 0.9833 Meier Multiplier: 0.188
Sweep HandIHour: 13.969
Test Results•••
Constant k is out of range. Constant is out of range = =-----~~~---======~-======--
Percent Acc:uraey: 94.87 Counter k from previous test: 0.178
Account: 1$32000000 Address: 34-36 E 72 ST !POE: 34 E72 ST Reason for assignment:
PressIDe District: Operation: ______
Date Assigned: 06109120 II Dale Replatod: _____ FInal Prep By: ______Final Prep D8te:,______
Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. 4 Irving Place, New York, NY 10003
October 5, 2015
Case Number: 549672
CUSTOMER INFORMATION # 0102000000, 30 Sutton Place Corp, 30 Sutton Place, New York, NY 10022 # 0532000000, Park 71 St Corp, 730 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 0700323444, 995 5th Avenue Owners Corp, 995 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10028 # 1402000000, 655 Park Ave Inc, 655 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 1451000000, One Beekman Place Inc, 1 Beekman Place, New York, NY 10022 # 1532000000, 36 E 72 ST CORP, 34-36 East 72 Street, New York, NY 10021 # 1604370091, 18 Gramercy Park Condominium, 18 Gramercy Park South, New York, NY 10003 # 1991000000, 820 5th Ave, 820 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 2022000000, 8 E 83 St Tenant Corp, 8-26 East 83rd Street, New York, NY 10028 # 2112000000, 834 5th Ave, 834 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 2222000000, 898 Corporation, 898 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 2421000000, Athena-Liberty Lofts, 43 West 64th Street, New York, NY 10023 # 2512000000, 990 Fifth Ave Condo. 960 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 2632000000, 114 Tenants Corp, 114-22 East 72nd Street, New York, NY 10021 # 2841000000, Sixty Sutton Corp, 60 Sutton Place, New York, NY 10003 # 2912000000, Ten Eighty Apartment Corp, 1080 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10128 # 3142000000, The 740 Corp, 740 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 3232000000, 79 East 79 Street Corp, 79 East 79th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 3241000000, Fifty-First Beekman Corp, 420 East 51st Street, New York, NY 10022 # 3271000000, 57 S Dorchester, 110 East 57th Street, New York, NY 10022 # 3612000000, Richmond 1411 Condos, 201 East 80th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 3632000000, 117 E 72 St Co Inc, 117 East 72nd Street, New York, N Y 10021 # 3702000000, Fifth And 67 St Inc, 856 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 3812000000, Tenants Assoc of 955 5 Ave, 955 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 3902000000, 880 Fifth Avenue Corp, 880 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 4022000000, 990 Fifth Avenue Condo, 990 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 4241000000, 4 Sutton Pl Inc, 4 Sutton Place, New York, NY 10022 # 4302000000, 777 Madison Inc. 777 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 4312000000, 455 E 57 St Inc, 455 East 57th Street, New York, NY 10022 # 4451000000, 14 Beekman Pl Cp, 12 Beekman Place, New York, NY 10022 # 4622000000, 800 Park Ave Corp, 800 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 4861000000, 525 Park Ave Assoc, 525 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 4912000000, Fifth and 88 Inc,1068 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10128 # 5022000000, 988 Fifth Avenue Condo, 988 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10075 # 5122000000, 21 East 79 St Corp, 21 East 79th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 5160000000, 50 Gramercy Park North, 50 Gramercy Park North, New York, NY 10010 # 5222000000, 151 E 79 St Corp, 151 East 79th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 5432000000, 920 5 Ave Corp, 920 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 6114523955, 770 Realty Associates LLC, 770 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10065 # 6261000000, Residential Board of Galleria, 117 East 57th Street, New York, NY 10022
Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. 4 Irving Place, New York, NY 10003
CUSTOMER INFORMATION # 6321000000, Fifteen Central Park West Condominium, 15 Central Park West, New York, NY 10023 # 6351000000, 14 Sutton Tenants Corp, 437-53 East 56th Street, New York, NY 10022 # 6632000000, 160 E 72 St Corp, 160 East 72nd Street, New York, NY 10021 # 6912000000, 1050 5 Ave Inc, 1050 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10028 # 7132000000, 66 East 79 Street, 66 East 79th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 7322000000, Madison at 84 Tenants Corp, 1121 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10028 # 7691000000, Hampton House Condominium, 29 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021 # 7791000000, 139 E 63 St Inc, 139 East 63rd Street, New York, NY 10065 # 8122000000, 1040 Madison Inc, 31 East 79th Street, New York, NY 10075 # 8312000000, East 67 Street Owners Inc, 1150-54 Third Ave, New York, NY 10075 # 8332000000, 720 Park Ave Corp, 720 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 8622000000, 772 Park Av Bldg Corp. 770 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10021 # 9091000000, 485 Park Ave, 485 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10022 # 9232000000, The Siena, 186 East 76th Street, New York, NY 10021 # 9612000000, Oxford on 72nd Condominium, 422 East 72nd Street, New York, NY 10021 # 9961000000, 817 Fifth Avenue, 817 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10065
In response to the inquiry for the above accounts, Con Edison has reviewed the meter tickets for each account. If a meter was recording outside of the accuracy range of 98% to 102% then regulation requires us to make an adjustment for the bill. We do provide the meter tests to the PSC directly and attached are the results summarized in a table, and documentation attached.
Amount Account Removal Meter Test Meter Test Accuracy Meter # Install date adjusted? Number Date Date (%) ($) 2222000000 1564 4/7/2011 N/A 1400 7/7/2006 4/7/2011 5/11/2011 96.63 $1,795.83 7861 4/7/2011 N/A 11244 7/7/2006 4/7/2011 5/11/2011 96.35 $1,795.83
2421000000 25311 5/14/2013 N/A N/A 25113 7/23/2008 5/14/2013 10/22/2014 99.1 N/A 421050 5/14/2013 N/A N/A 421012 7/23/2008 5/14/2013 8/24/2013 100.45 N/A
2512000000 14936 4/19/2013 N/A 14599 7/9/2010 4/19/2013 4/25/2013 Non-registering N/A 2062 2/8/2010 7/9/2010 8/12/2010 Non-registering N/A 1179 8/16/2007 2/8/2010 2/17/2010 Non-registering N/A 10269 3/26/2015 N/A 11269 4/9/2014 3/26/2015 4/22/2015 Non-registering N/A 11393 4/9/2013 4/9/2014 5/22/2014 Non-registering N/A 9860 8/16/2007 4/9/2013 4/17/2013 95.95 $4,307.03 7854 3/26/2015 N/A 6546 8/4/2010 3/26/2015 4/23/2015 92.46 $7,540.14 14264 8/23/2005 8/4/2010 8/27/2010 91.15 $1,571.68
2632000000 5382 3/21/2012 N/A 8878 4/12/2007 3/21/2012 4/24/2012 Non-registering N/A 8909 3/21/2012 N/A 10740 4/12/2007 3/21/2012 4/17/2012 Indeterminate N/A
2841000000 22226 6/27/2015 N/A 22358 4/1/2011 6/27/2015 8/4/2015 100.17 N/A 22389 5/11/2006 4/1/2011 6/18/2011 99.6 N/A 431055 2/4/2013 N/A 431018 9/11/2008 2/4/2013 8/23/2013 100.67 N/A
2912000000 11516 12/9/2011 N/A 9850 5/5/2008 12/9/2011 3/20/2012 Non-registering N/A 11640 3/5/2012 N/A 11646 1/3/2008 3/5/2012 4/18/2012 100.13 N/A
3142000000 23329 9/28/2012 N/A 23395 7/1/2007 9/28/2012 2/11/2015 99.68 N/A 25282 9/28/2012 N/A 25329 7/1/2007 9/28/2012 11/11/2014 98.88 N/A 3232000000 3343 8/6/2015 N/A 2003 5/10/2011 8/6/2015 1335 7/11/2006 5/10/2011 5/31/2011 97.63 $294.10 10305 8/6/2015 N/A 11501 5/10/2011 8/6/2015 11454 7/11/2006 5/10/2011 6/13/2011 96.45 $2,367.98
3241000000 321300 11/18/2014 N/A 321148 5/4/2009 11/18/2014 2/16/2015 100.14 N/A 331035 11/18/2014 N/A 331081 5/4/2009 11/18/2014 2/25/2015 100.84 N/A
3271000000 320034 9/24/2011 N/A 12637 7/28/2009 6/1/2011 7/8/2011 98.13 N/A 320032 9/24/2011 N/A 14246 3/10/2006 9/24/2011 1/10/2012 85.89
8622000000 310053 8/13/2014 N/A 310004 3/19/2009 8/13/2014 6/8/2015 99.48 N/A 320071 8/13/2014 N/A 320035 3/19/2009 8/13/2014 7/25/2015 99.07 N/A
9091000000 14921 10/4/2012 N/A 14675 9/10/2007 10/4/2012 N/A 11324 8/25/2014 N/A 10736 6/10/2009 8/25/2014 10/24/2014 96.38 N/A
9232000000 22455 3/12/2015 N/A 22077 4/18/2011 3/12/2015 4/15/2015 100.06 N/A 22399 3/22/2006 4/18/2011 9/19/2011 100.03 N/A 22266 3/12/2015 N/A 22052 4/18/2011 3/12/2015 4/8/2015 99.03 N/A 22408 3/22/2006 4/18/2011 8/11/2011 100.22 N/A
7322000000 14756 8/7/2015 N/A 11657 5/3/2010 8/7/2015 8/11/2015 100.55 N/A 9219 7/22/2005 5/3/2010 5/21/2010 96.75 $98.76 11518 8/7/2015 N/A 11348 7/7/2010 8/7/2015 N/A 11522 5/3/2010 7/7/2010 8/3/2010 100.19 N/A 13106 7/22/2005 5/3/2010 6/4/2010 Indeterminate N/A
7691000000 14691 3/30/2012 N/A 14459 9/11/2009 3/30/2012 4/17/2012 96.9 14691 3/9/2007 9/11/2009 10/1/2009 99.65 N/A 10903 8/4/2010 N/A 14211 4/1/2005 8/4/2010 9/17/2010 97.6 $103.38 7132000000 14646 8/7/2015 N/A 14387 5/3/2010 8/7/2015 N/A 14681 6/20/2005 5/3/2010 5/21/2010 93.66 $2,702.61 8420 8/7/2015 N/A 13189 11/9/2011 8/7/2015 N/A 7476 5/3/2010 11/9/2011 1/23/2012 Non-registering N/A 4527 6/20/2005 5/3/2010 5/10/2010 96.59 $2,702.61
7791000000 621001 6/18/2015 N/A 8395 8/6/2010 6/18/2015 7/20/2015 90.61 $10,628.34 13171 7/5/2005 8/6/2010 9/17/2010 Non- registering N/A 632002 6/18/2015 N/A 9642 8/21/2012 6/18/2015 8/11/2015 103.87 -$2,131.27 14782 10/11/2007 8/21/2012 10/10/2012 96.11 $927.11
8122000000 14918 8/2/2011 N/A 14935 6/8/2006 8/2/2011 10/4/2011 Indeterminate N/A 11112 10/4/2011 N/A 11359 6/8/2006 10/4/2011 1/13/2012 98.24 N/A
4861000000 6864 11/23/2013 6523 4/30/2008 11/23/2013 1/17/2014 92.24 $9,254.49 6547 11/23/2013 10300 4/30/2008 11/23/2013 1/27/2014 94.47 $9,254.49
4912000000 10893 8/27/2015 11144 4/12/2011 8/27/2015 14212 7/18/2006 4/12/2011 6/7/2011 INDETERMINATE 1689 9/9/2014 2823 7/9/2009 9/9/2014 10/25/2014 93.67 $1,010.34 2755 5/15/2009 7/9/2009 7/22/2009 NON-REGISTERING
5022000000 11461 7/1/2011 10467 8/14/2006 7/1/2011 8/3/2011 91.74 $6,491.70 14631 7/1/2011 14926 8/14/2006 7/1/2011 8/8/2011 93.27 $6,491.70
5122000000 8054 11/29/2013 11236 6/10/2008 11/29/2013 12/30/2013 92.10 $6,906.87 14620 11/29/2013 14424 6/10/2008 11/29/2013 2/4/2014 NON-REGISTERING
5160000000 22153 5/20/2010 25281 12/27/2005 5/20/2010 10/30/2010 99.95 25161 5/20/2010 25285 12/27/2005 5/20/2010 99.53 5222000000 621036 12/9/2014 6503 11/3/2009 12/9/2014 2/6/2005 93.48 $5,922.01
5432000000 25000 6/24/2015 25226 5/11/2011 6/24/2015 8/4/2015 98.62 25007 6/24/2015 25225 5/11/2011 6/24/2015 8/4/2015 100.89
6114523955 321044 2/11/2013 321089 12/7/2009 2/11/2013 11/29/2014 99.75 342097 2/11/2013 342041 5/17/2008 2/11/2013 8/8/2015 NON-REGISTERING
6261000000 22263 8/2/2010 22238 1/14/2005 8/2/2010 2/19/2011 100.17 22290 8/2/2010 22303 1/14/2005 8/2/2010 2/19/2011 INDETERMINATE
6321000000 22013 8/23/2012 22376 1/21/2009 8/23/2012 12/1/2012 99.82 23063 8/23/2012 23215 1/21/2009 8/23/2012 12/12/2012 100.10
3612000000 321042 1/7/2013 322050 4/14/2010 1/7/2013 8/3/2015 100.21 n/a 9130 7/10/2009 4/14/2010 4/29/2010 99.21 n/a 332146 12/12/2014 332079 4/14/2010 12/12/2014 2/25/2015 100.82 n/a
3632000000 21078 8/27/2015 21010 5/11/2011 8/27/2015 21132 8/25/2006 5/11/2011 9/20/2011 99.01 n/a 25169 8/27/2015 25255 5/11/2011 8/27/2015 25254 8/25/2006 5/11/2011 9/19/2011 Indeterminate n/a
3702000000 632006 12/6/2014 9213 5/15/2013 12/6/2014 1/5/2015 95.01 n/a 9928 8/8/2008 5/15/2013 6/13/2013 97.36 $3,268.23 610019 12/6/2014 14579 10/30/2009 12/6/2014 12/20/2014 95.75 $1,342.38 2003 5/10/2006 10/30/2009 11/20/2009 101.17
3812000000 621023 12/11/2014 10592 4/7/2011 12/11/2014 1/5/2015 91.57 $6,289.05 10923 8/16/2006 4/7/2011 5/11/2011 91.79 $8,294.76 611036 12/11/2014 3484 12/9/2009 12/11/2014 1/31/2015 101.16 N/A 1260 8/16/2006 12/9/2009 12/16/2009 96.52 $1,234.25
3902000000 321284 8/14/2013 321113 9/2/2008 8/14/2013 7/15/2015 100.2352 331051 8/14/2013 331076 9/2/2008 8/14/2013 11/12/2014 99.8592
4022000000 1345 10/4/2013 2505 3/3/2011 10/4/2013 11/12/2013 Non-registering 1574 7/12/2006 3/3/2011 4/4/2011 Non-registering 10484 5/22/2013 10918 4/2/2008 5/22/2013 5/23/2013 94.85 $2,987.00
4241000000 621039 12/1/2014 14243 8/5/2009 12/1/2014 1/3/2015 98.32 6872 8/3/2004 8/5/2009 8/25/2009 95.93
4302000000 11094 8/9/2010 11019 5/3/2005 8/9/2010 10/4/2010 Indeterminate 2591 8/9/2010 1458 5/3/2005 8/9/2010 8/27/2010 96.00 $629.61
4312000000 10473 4/10/2013 7376 6/6/2007 4/10/2013 4/30/2013 96.04 $4,086.13 14639 12/5/2013 14986 9/10/2008 12/5/2013 2/6/2014 98.19
4451000000 11204 11/28/2011 10285 1/9/2007 11/28/2011 3/19/2012 90.79 $10,236.19 7832 11/28/2011 11324 1/9/2007 11/28/2011 2/23/2012 96.07 $59.43
4622000000 25298 1/9/2013 25367 11/6/2008 1/9/2013 9/21/2013 99.44 25301 1/9/2013 25368 11/6/2008 1/9/2013 9/14/2013 99.99
0102000000 21073 2/4/2013 21042 3/4/2008 2/4/2013 6/7/2014 100.6145 2376 12/26/2000 10/2/2003 11/7/2003 98.91 25057 2/4/2013 25347 3/4/2008 2/4/2013 9/14/2013 100.0416
0532000000 321304 8/27/2013 321069 8/21/2008 8/27/2013 8/9/2015 97.8506 N/A 322016 8/27/2013 322019 8/21/2008 8/27/2013 11/29/2014 100.2691
0700323444 22129 11/16/2011 22402 1/31/2007 11/16/2011 2/2/2012 100.2 25099 11/16/2011 25098 1/31/2007 11/16/2011 3/21/2012 99.6782
1402000000 322021 8/10/2015 13673 5/26/2006 12/2/2010 1/18/2011 95.79 $2,984.34 342058 8/10/2015 8933 5/26/2006 12/2/2010 12/6/2010 96.33 $6,025.73
1451000000 11928 8/24/2011 13180 7/27/2006 8/24/2011 2/15/2012 93.43 11439 8/24/2011 9133 7/27/2006 8/24/2011 10/4/2011 unknown
1532000000 10736 8/13/2015 7825 6/9/2011 8/13/2015 11494 7/3/2006 6/9/2011 7/1/2011 92.77 $849.46 3484 8/13/2015 2342 8/4/2011 8/13/2015 785 6/13/2011 8/4/2011 8/11/2011 106.19 $894.46 1215 9/30/2007 6/13/2011 8/9/2011 93.88 $6,809.17
1604370091 321207 11/29/2012 9832 4/22/2009 11/29/2012 310009 11/29/2012 12648 4/22/2009 11/29/2012
1991000000 6508 3/3/2011 10496 5/31/2006 3/3/2011 5/2/2011 94.93 $8,600.62 10920 8/28/2012 11089 3/3/2011 6/1/2011 7/14/2011 101.3 7857 12/8/2009 3/3/2011 5/2/2011 92.76 $8,600.62
2022000000 321048 5/21/2013 321066 8/6/2008 5/21/2013 7/25/2015 99.39 331018 5/21/2013 331035 8/6/2008 5/21/2013 9/29/2014 99.92
2112000000 25360 7/15/2014 25106 8/24/2011 7/15/2014 11/3/2014 99.05 25227 1/14/2009 3/27/2009 3/10/2015 100.3 421054 7/15/2014 421032 3/27/2009 4/11/2014 3/17/2015 100.38 22319 1/14/2009 3/27/2009 4/20/2010 unknown
9612000000 321070 9/5/2012 321031 10/11/2007 9/5/2012 12/8/2012 100.24 331019 9/5/2012 331047 10/11/2007 9/5/2012 10/3/2012 Indeterminate
9961000000 621028 12/15/2014 7478 7/2/2009 12/15/2014 1/5/2015 97.31 $2,221.21 611027 12/15/2014 14379 7/2/2009 12/152014 3/30/2015 102.92 -$1,720.22
6351000000 8882 4/10/2013 7402 8/28/2007 4/10/2013 5/6/2013 98.51 2730 4/18/2013 1404 8/28/2007 4/18/2013 4/23/2013 Indetermine
6632000000 621018 12/12/2014 14054 4/3/2009 12/12/2014 1/5/2015 92.69 $5,186.16 611005 3/4/2015 611041 12/12/2014 3/4/2015 14431 4/3/2009 12/12/2014 2/6/2015 98.41
6912000000 622012 6/26/2015 7850 10/14/2010 12/9/2014 2/4/2015 91.66 $15,977.07 10680 3/3/2005 10/14/2010 11/24/2010 N/A 632005 12/9/2014 14336 8/6/2009 12/9/2014 1/5/2015 97.77 NONE
8312000000 25294 6/1/2012 25321 3/10/2011 6/1/2012 8/11/2012 98.55 25082 4/6/2012 25330 6/16/2007 3/21/2012 8/11/2012 100.09
8332000000 25278 12/5/2013 25335 7/16/2008 9/28/2012 11/13/2014 99.17 25279 9/28/2012 25334 9/30/2007 9/28/2012 5/3/2014 99.59