<<

The Incorporation of '4C- into Different Species of and in Rat Slices

EDWARD E. HILL, WILLIAM E. M. LANDS and SISTER P. M. SLAKEY1, Department of Biological Chemistry, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104

ABSTRACT ing the specificity for certain diglycerides in the The relative rates of enzymic acylation of diglycerides to produce of species of diglycerides and triglycerides triglycerides have been reported (5, 6); how- from 14C-glycerol were examined in rat ever, the significance of these studies Was ob- Tiver slices. Diglycerides containing one scured by differences in solubility of different or two double bonds per molecule and diglycerides. Likewise, no appreciable specifi- triglycerides containing four or more city has been observed in the formation of double bonds per molecule represented phosphatidic acid by acylation of glycerol-3- 70% and 60% respectively of the newly phosphate (7) or in the of phos- synthesized diglycerides and triglycerides. phate from phosphatidic acid (8). The newly synthesized triglycerides were In the present study the de novo synthesis more unsaturated than the endogenous of diglycerides and triglycerides from a4C- triglycerides. Our results suggest that a glycerol was examined to see if all types of nonrandom synthesis of species of diglyc- were formed at similar rates. Our erides occurred followed by an almost results indicate that a degree of selectivity random utilization of the various diglyc- occurred in the synthesis of triglycerides by eride species for the biosynthesis of tri- rat liver, and that the de novo synthesis of . triglyceride did not lead to a duplication of the pre-existing distribution of molecular species INTRODUCTION of triglycerides.

N LIVER 1,2-DtGLYCERIDES can be considered EXPERIMENTAL I to serve as a common precursor for the bio- synthesis of glyceryl triglycerides, leci- Incorporation of 1'C-Glycerol into Liver thin and cephalin. Since the formation of all Male Sprague-Dawley rats (175-240 g) were three types of requires reaction at only sacrificed by decapitation. The body cavity was the 3 position, the ordered structure of the di- immediately opened, and the liver was per- glycerides would be expected to remain as a fused with cold Locke's solution (9) devoid common feature of the product glyceryl esters. of calcium containing 0.027 M trisodium citrate Saturated and unsaturated fatty acids are pre- until the liver attained a creamy color. Liver dominantly present at the 1 and 2 positions slices were prepared with a Briggs-Stadie respectively of triglycerides, and cepha- microtome. lin (1-3), but differences in com- Liver slices (2 to 3) were incubated in Krebs- position of these types of lipids have been Ringer buffer (9) containing one- observed. For example, stearic and arachidonic half the normal amount of calcium with 100 acids, which are major components of rat liver ~moles of ATP, 0.2 mg of reduced coenzyme lecithin and cephalin, are minor components A and 10/,c of 1-14C-glycerol (10 #c//~m). The in rat liver triglycerides (1, 4). Such struc- final volume of the incubation mixture was 7.5 tural studies indicate that the distribution of ml. Incubations were performed at 37C with fatty acids in glyceryl esters is not a random constant shaking in an atmosphere of 5% process, but rather that mechanisms exist in dioxide and 95% . Liver slices the cell which control both the positional oc- were removed at indicated time intervals, currence and the extent of occurrence of a rinsed, and immediately frozen between 2 given fatty acid in different glyceryl esters. blocks of dry ice. Attempts to demonstrate the reactions which Extraction of Lipids control the location of a given fatty acid have not been overly successful. Experiments test- After the weight (200-400 rag) of the frozen tissue had been recorded, the sample was homogenized in 5 mi of chloroform-meth- 1Present address: Saint Dominic College, Saint Charles, anol (1:1, v/v) containing 100/d of a solution Illinois 6017~. of 1% 2,6-di(t-butyl) 4-methylphenol in chlo- 411 412 EDWARD E. HILL, WILLIAM E. M. LANDS AND SISTER P. M. SLAKEY reform with a Virtis microhomogenizer for 1 rechromatographed on thin layer plates as de- rain. An additional 2.5 ml of chloroform was scribed above; to give a radiochemical purity added, and the homogenization was continued of greater than 95%. for approximately 30 seconds. Additional Similarly, the isolated diglycerides were chloroform-methanol (2:1) was added to give found to be contaminated with small amounts a final volume of 20 ml, and the samples were of and an unidentified impurity. allowed to remain at room temperature for Since these contaminants yielded anomalous approximately 30 min. The extracts were bands in the subsequent separation of the di- washed once with 0.2 volumes of 0.58% so- fraction into species, the diglycerides dium chloride and once with "pure upper were further purified by TLC in a solvent of phase" as described by Folch et al. (10). The chloroform-acetone (96:4) with a layer of samples were evaporated to dryness using a boric acid-Adsorbosil-1 (12). Approximately rotary evaporator which was fushed with 90% of it was located in the 1,2- nitrogen, dissolved in chloroform and stored fraction and more than 95% of the isotope was at -15C. recovered. The remainder of the radioactivity Isolation of Neutral Lipids was found in nearly equal amounts in mono- glyceride, 1,3-diglyceride and triglyceride frac- Neutral lipids were separated from polar tions. lipids using DEAE-cellulose columns as de- scribed by Rouser et el. (11 ). Diglycerides Separation of Di- and Triglycerides and triglycerides were isolated by thin-layer into Molecular Species chromatography (TLC) using Mallinckrodt The separation of diglycerides into individual silicic acid of less than 200 mesh. The plates species was achieved using thin layer plates were developed 4 cm in diethyl ether-petroleum containing 5% (w/w) silver nitrate Adsorbosil- ether (4:1). After drying for 15 min at room 1. Thin layers (0.3 mm) were activated at temperature, they were developed in diethyl 125C for 75 rnin and stored over a saturated ether-petroleum ether (12:88) to a distance solution of calcium chloride in a metal cabinet. of 18-20 cm. The lipids were visualized under Diglycerides prepared from pig liver lecithin ultraviolet light after spraying the plate with a by the action of phospholipase C (13) were solution of 0.2% 2',7'-dichlorofluorescein in added as a carrier to all diglyceride samples to methanol. The bands of triglycerides (R~ = facilitate location of the samples in subsequent 0.70) and diglycerides (R r = 0.30) were steps. The plates were developed in a solvent scraped from the plate and the lipids were system composed of dietbyl ether-petroleum eluted with methanol-ether (I :9). ether-benzene-methanol (45:35:30:2). After An aliquot of the recovered triglyceride spraying the plates lightly with a solution of fraction revealed a radiochemical purity of less 0.1% of 2',7'-dichlorofluorescein in methanol than 90% when chromatogrammed with car- five discrete bands were visible under ultra- rier diglycerides and triglycerides. Accordingly, violet light. These bands were found to con- the whole triglyceride samples were routinely tain one to five or more double bonds per

TABLE I Fatty Acid Composition of the Carrier Diglyceride Resolved by Silver Nitrate-TLC

Fatty acid 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:3 20:4 22:4 22:6 Band Band a Mole % designation

4 20 29 45 5 2 .... b 19 30 44 6 2 .... Monoene

5 13 35 4 49 ..... b 14 33 7 46 ..... Diene 7 10 44 4 -- 18 25 ------b 10 42 3 10 17 28 ------Triene 8 12 43 4 -- I 1 35 5 -- b 13 48 4 ------36 -- -- Tetraene 9 17 41 3 -- 1 I 1 -- 28 b 17 41 3 -- I 4 -- -- 34 Polyunsaturated

Total 16 35 20 13 3 4 4 1 4

aThe TLC-plate was divided into ten bands. Less than 3% of the total fatty acids was located in bands other than those indicated in this table. bThe second row represents a separate experiment. LIPIDS, VOL. 3, No. 5 '*C-GLYCEROL IN D~- AND TRIGLYCERIDES 413 molecule by means of GLC analysis of the methyl esters derived from the diglycerides. 50 The fatty acid composition of these bands is indicated in Table I. Less than 3% of the total diglyceride sample applied to the TLC plate was recovered in areas other than the five bands described in Table I.

The method used to separate the triglyceride gg fraction of rat liver into its component species has been described in a previous communica- ~176 tion from this laboratory (14). Elution of Di- and Triglycerides from ~10 Silver Nitrate-Silicic Acid / The bands of silicic acid that contained the separated glycerides were scraped from the 1 | II thin layer plates and transferred into small so rio ,h test tubes. A solution of 1% sodium chloride Time, min in 90% methanol was added in portions (ap- proximately 0.5 ml) with vigorous mixing until Fro. l. The incorporation of "C-glycerol into the characteristic red color of the silver-di- diglycerides and triglycerides in rat liver slices. chlorofluorescein complex was destroyed. The Q) Q) Diglycerides, /k-/k Triglycerides. glycerides were extracted with 5 ml of ether- methanol (9:1). After centrifugation, the neutral lipids. The total counts present in the supernatant solution was transferred to a scin- diglyceride and triglyceride fractions were tillation vial. The residue was washed two nearly equal at each time interval measured. additional times. The combined extracts were Since the quantity of triglyceride in rat liver evaporated to dryness under a stream of nitro- is much greater than that of diglyceride, the gen with gentle heating. specific activity of the diglyceride pool at a The triglycerides were counted in 7.0 ml of given time interval was much greater than that a scintillation fuid containing 4 g of 2,5-di- of the triglyceride pool. phenyloxazole and 50 mg of p-bis[5-phenyl- The percentage of distribution of 14C-glyc- oxazoyl]-benzene per liter of toluene. Diglyc- erol among the species of triglycerides at erides were counted in 10.0 ml of scintillation various time intervals is shown in Table II. fluid prepared with dioxane (15). The recovery After 20 min of incubation approximately 70% of radioactivity applied to the plate was greater of the incorporated label was located in three than 90% in either case. fractions, the SMD, SD 2 and the polyunsatu- rated species. The other six Species indicated Gas-Liquid Chromatography contained less than 30% of the incorporated These methods have been described in an label. The distribution of incorporate~t glycerol earlier paper (14). among the species had been established at the MATERIALS first time point measured. This pattern was not altered upon extended incubation even All solvents were analytical reagent grade though the total incorporation of 14C-glycerol and were used without further purification. increased several fold. The petroleum ether had a boiling point range The mole percent distribution 9 f triglyceride of 30-60C. DEAE-cellulose (DE-23) was species of unincubated rat liver and two in- obtained from Reeve Angel Corp. cubated samples is shown in Table III. The SM2, SMD and polyunsaturated subfractions RESULTS of triglycerides were the major components to The time course of incorporation of 14C- accumulate 14C-glycerol, and they comprised glycerol into diglycerides and triglycerides is 16, 24 and 22% respectively of the total mass shown in Fig. 1. The total counts incorporated represented by the triglyceride fraction. The into neutral lipids increased in a linear fashion weight distribution of species of triglycerides for 2-3 hr. Preliminary results showed that did not demonstrably change during the course optimal yields of lipid soluble 14C-glycerol were of the incubation. obtained when ATP and CoA were added to Comparison of the distribution of 14C-glyc- the incubation medium. In addition, the lower erol among species to the weight distribution Ca ++ content led to more radioactivity in the of species shows that the de novo synthesis of LIP1DS, VOL. 3, No. 5 414 EDWARD E. HILL, WILLIAM E. M. LANDS AND SISTER P. M. SLAKEY

TABLE 1[ TABLE lIl Incorporation of 14C-glycerol into Species of Triglycerides Distribution of Individual Species of Triglycerides in Rat Liver Percentage Distribution of Counts Unincubated a 20 minb 120 minb 20 40 60 90 120 180 min min min min rain rain Species Mole %

Subfractionsa % S~ 1 1 2 $3 1 0 1 1 0 1 S~M 6 4 8 S~M 3 2 1 2 3 3 SM2 14 16 20 SM~. 8 5 6 6 6 5 S-D + M~ 8 8 8 S~D + M, 8 ? l0 8 9 8 SMD 26 24 23 SMD 16 15 ]6 15 16 14 M2D 8 7 4 M,,D 7 5 5 5 4 4 SD~ 11 10 9 SD~ 11 13 15 14 14 12 MD,, 5 6 5 MD~ 6 7 5 6 5 5 Polyunsaturated 22 23 21 Polyunsaturatedb 42 46 39 44 44 47 a rhe value represents the average of three different tri- aS,M and D are used as abbre-iations for saturated, glyceride samples isolated from whole liver. The values are monounsaturated, and diunvaturated fatty acids respec- corrected for cross contamination. tively. The subscript refers to the m~mber of times a given bA portion of the triglyceride sample from liver slices acid appears in the same species of triglyceride. incubated with ~4C-glycerol was separated into species by bpolyunsaturated triglycerides represent several slow silver nitrate-TLC. The individual species of triglycerides moving bands which were combined. These triglycerides were converted to methyl esters for analysis by GLC. contain at least one fatty acid containing five or more doub!e bonds or they contain six or more double bonds by virtue of the pretence of more than one unsaturated fatty arated according to the total number of double acid. bonds per molecule. Thus a diglyceride con- taining 2 monoenoic acids and a diglyceride triglycerides from glycerol did not produce containing a saturated acid and a dienoic acid new molecular species in proportion to their were not separated from one another. In con- endogenous abundance. Certain species, SM 2 trast to the results with triglycerides, the dis- and SMD, incorporated approximately one- tribution of 14C-glycerol among the species of half the amount of isotope that would be pre- diglycerides was predominantly in the more dicted from their original abundance. Con- saturated species rather than in the unsaturated versely, the polyunsaturated species incorpo- species. At all time points examined, approxi- rated approximately twice the amount of iso- mately 70% of the isotope was found in the tope that would be predicted from the weight monoenoic and dienoic diglycerides. With in- of this subfraction. creasing times of incubation, the isotopic con- In Table IV the distribution of l~C-glycerol tent of the tetrae~e fraction gradually increased. among the species of diglycerides is shown. This percentage increase was compensated by Shorter periods of incubation were examined in a decrease in the relative radioactivity of the this experiment since no alterations in labeling diene fraction. Other species contained a more pattern were observed with species of triglyc- or less constant percentage of the incorporated erides from incubations of 20 min or longer. a4C-glycerol throughout the course of the in- As indicated earlier, the observable bands were cubation. due to the molecular species of added diglyc- When the 14C-diglycerides were subjected to eride that had been prepared from pig liver methanolysis with sodium methoxide, 2-4% of lecithin; however, no appreciable amount of the recovered counts appeared in the methyl radioactivity was detected in the other areas esters regardless of the length of the incubation in which bands were not discernible. In the period. The recovery of counts in methyl present experiments, the diglycerides were sep- esters plus glycerol ranged from 90-93 %. Thus,

TABLE IV The Incorporation of 1'C-glycerol into Species of Diglycerides

Number of Percentage Distribution of Counts double bonds 5 mina 10 min a 15 mina 20 min~ 30rain 40min a 60 min a 90 min a 120min 180rain % 1 24 26 24 24 25 23 28 28 27 29 2 51 48 48 46 43 41 40 40 40 42 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 6 7 8 10 11 14 14 13 12 I1 5 10 12 10 10 9 14 10 10 13 11 Origin 3 2 5 5 7 4 4 6 2 3

aThese values are the average of two separate experiments. LIpIDS, VOL. 3, NO. 5 14C-GLYCEROL IN DI- AND TR1GLYCERIDES 415 the labeling patterns observed are representa- TABLE V tive of the incorporation of 14C-glycerol into Predicted Distributiona of Species in Newly-Synthesized Triglycerides the glycerol portion rather than the fatty acid of the diglyceride. Precursorb Expected number of double bonds diglyceride in triglyceride DISCUSSION 0 1 2 3 4 5 >6 The present experiments were designed to % Monoene ~ 3 9 5 1 1 6 consider two questions. First, does the bio- Diene 6 18 9 1 12 synthesis of triglycerides from diglycerides in- Triene 1 2 1 1 Tetraene -- 1 4 5 volve a random acylation of diglyceride units Polyunsaturated -- 15 from a pool of diglycerides or does the syn- Predicted 0 3 15 24 13 7 39 thesis preferentially select certain diglyceride Observede 1 3 16 16 18 6 42 units? Secondly, are fatty acids randomly in- corporated into the newly-synthesized species aThe expected (predicted) percentage of isotope in spe- cies of triglyeerides is estimated by multiplication of the of diglycerides? The pathway by which .14C- percentage of isotope in a given species of diglyceride times glycerol can be incorporated into these pools th0 fractional occurrence of fatty acids at the 3 position of of lipids is summarized below. endogenous triglycerides. The eomposition of the 3 posi- tion is 12, 39, 20, 3, 3 and 23% respectively for saturated, monoenoie, dienoie, trienoic, tetraenoie and unidentified Glycerol acids (14). $ bThese values are taken from Table IV, 20 min. Glycerol-3-phosphate eThese values are taken from Table 11, 20 rain. $ 1,2-Diacylglycerol-3-phosphate the newly-formed triglycerides to their precur- $ Sor diglycerides, we asssumed that the fatty 1,2-Diglyceride acid composition at the 3 position might be $ similar to that reported. If the diglyceride units Triglyceride were randomly esterified in a non-correlative manner, we could predict the expected quanti- The de novo synthesis of triglycerides from ties of isotope in the triglyceride species by glycerol did not yield the same relative amounts multiplication of the mole fractional occurrence of species which are endogenous to the entire of a given fatty acid at the 3 position of tri- liver. The differences that we observed in the glyceride times the percentage distribution of distribution of mass and radioactivity can be isotope in the newly-synthesized diglycerides. attributed to the presence of a separate pool For example, diglyceride species containing 2 which is rapidly synthesized and does not rep- double bonds per molecule constituted 46% resent the triglycerides of the whole liver. Stein of the total radioactive diglycerides. This spe- and Shapiro (16) suggested the presence of cies of diglyceride will lead to the formation two pools of triglyceride, one of which rapidly of SDX or MMX triglycerides (X denotes the equilibrates with plasma triglyceride and a sec- fatty acid esterified to the 3-position). If X ond pool which is relatively inert. Other work- is saturated, the triglyceride will contain only ers (17, 18) have also found that those triglyc- two double bonds whereas if X is a monene erides synthesized for secretion into plasma the triglyceride will contain three double bonds, represent a more active pool. etc. For simplicity, we considered only the Approximately 70% of the ~C-glycerol in- total number of double bonds per molecule. corporated into diglycerides was located in the The extent to which each type of diglyceride monoene and diene fractions. On the other would be expected to produce the different hand, approximately 60% of the total radio- triglyceride species is shown in Table V. activity in triglycerides is present in those spe- For those triglycerides containing 1, 2, 5 and cies of triglycerides containing four or more 6 or more double bonds per molecule, the double bonds per molecule. Since acylation of predicted values for radioactivity agree very the 3 position can introduce further unsatura- closely with the observed values. These cal- tion into the molecule; it is not surprising that culations, however, predict somewhat higher the degree of unsaturation of the product tri- and lower values respectively for those triglyc- glyceride is greater than that of the precursor- erides containing four and five double bonds diglycerides. The unsaturated character of the per molecule. Similar calculations for other 3 position of rat liver triglycerides has been periods of incubations yielded analogous re- emphasized in a recent report from this lab- suits. The close correlation between the pre- oratory (14). dicted and observed values leads us to believe To compare the degree of unsaturation of that very little selectivity occurred in the LIPIDS, VOL. 3, No. 5 416 EDWARD E. HILL, WILLIAM E. M. LANDS AND SISTER P. M. SLAKEY utilization of diglyceride species for triglyceride that 14C- appeared in rat liver phos- biosynthesis, and that acylation of the diglyc- pholipids at a much faster rate than would be erides proceeded with non-correlative specificity predicted from the amount of isotope appear- as had been previously suggested (14). ing in the diglycerides, whereas de- The observed distribution of 14C-glycerol rived from stearic acid appeared more rapidly among diglyceride units indicates that the in diglycerides than in (19). He newly-synthesized diglycerides were composed suggested that the stearic acid was preferentially of about 25, 45, 5 and 10% respectively of incorporated into liver phospholipids via acyla- monoenoic, dienoic, trienoic and tetraenoic di- tion of monoacyl phospholipids rather than by glycerides. The total amount of 14C-glycerol the action of the aminophosphotransferase on in all diglyceride fractions increased several- the diglyceride unit. fold with time. The only significant variations Nevertheless, transfer of a4C-~]ycerol from observed in the percentage distribution of iso- phospholipids to triglycerides via diglyceride tope among the diglyceride units were a two- was expected to be minimal at early time points fold increase in the tetraenoic fraction and a in these experiments since the labeled phos- slight decrease in the relative percent of label pholipid would be greatly diluted by the large found in the diene fraction. The increase in size of the endogenous pool. Thus, the con- radioactivity of the polyunsaturated diglycerides tribution of radioactivity to the diglyceride could arise in part from the hydrolysis at the pool by units derived from choline and etha- 1 position of a radioactive triglyceride contain- nolamine phospholioid should be very small ing a polyunsaturated fatty acid at the 3 posi- compared to that of 14C-diglyceride arising by tion. This reaction would be expected to con- de novo synthesis. tribute greater amounts of isotope to diglyc- ACKNOWLEDGMENT erides with longer times of incubation, and This work was supported in part by grant AM-05310 would eventually tend to produce triglycerides from the United States Public Health Service. and one of us (Sister Paul Michael Slakey) was a National Science with similar acid composition at the 1 and 3 Foundation Graduate Fellow. positions. The small percentage of saturated REFERENCES and trienoic diglycerides compared to the large 1. Dittmer. J. C., and D. J. Hanahan, J. Biol. Chem. 234. 1976-1982 (1959). percentage of monoenoic and dienoic diglyc- 2. Hanahan, D. J.. H. Brockerhoff and E. J. Barron, erides indicates that the acylation of glycero- J. Biol. Chem. 235, 1917-1923 (1960). 3-phosphate was not a random process, but 3. Lands, W. E. M.. R. A. Pieringer, Sr., P. M. Slakey and A. Zschocke, Lipids I, 444-448 (1966). rather that certain diglyceride units were 4. Getz, G. S.. W. Bartiey. F. Stirpe. B. M. Notton and formed in preference to others. A. Renshaw, Biochem. J. 80. 176-181 (1961). 5. Wei~s, S. B., E. P. Kennedy and J. Y. Kiyasu, J. The diglyceride pool in of young rats Biol. Chem. 235, 40-44 (1960). that had been fasted and refed 6. Goldman. P., and P. R. Vagelos, J. Biol. Chem. 236, 26~0-2623 (1961). was reported to contain approximately 40, 30 7. Lands, W. E. M., and P. Hart, J. Lipid Res. 5, 81-87 and 20% respectively of monoene, diene plus (1964). triene and tetraene diglycerides (19). The 8. McCaman, R. E.. M. Smith and K. Cook, 3. Biol, Chem. 240, 3513-3517 (1966). content of monoenoic acids was presumably 9. Long. C.. E. J. King and W. M. Sperry. "Biochem- higher than normal due to the increased ists' Itandbook," D. Van Nostrand Company Inc., Prince- ton N. J.. 1961. p. 58. stearoyl-CoA desaturase activity under these I0. Folch. J.. M. Lees and G. H. Sloane-Stanley, J. conditions (20, 21). In view of the known Biol. Chem. 226. 497-509 (1957). increase in monoene diglyceride units and de- I1. Rouser. G.. G. Kritchevsky, D. Heller and E. Lieber, JAOCS 40, 425-4.54 (1963). crease in polyene diglyceride units of glycero- 12. Thomas III, A. E., J. E. Scharoun and H. Ralston, lipids evoked by and refeeding (13), Ibid. 42. 789-792 (1965). 13. Lands, W. E. M., and P. Hart, Ibid. 43, 290-295 our results on the newly synthesized diglyc- (1965). erides would seem to reflect the distribution of 14. Slakey, Sr., P. M. and W. E. M. Lands, Lipids 3, 3O-36 (1968). mass among diglycerides. 15. Snyder, F., Anal. Biochem. 9, 183-196 (1964). may also form diglycerides by the 16. Stein, Y., and B. Shapiro, Am. J. Physiol. 196, 1238-1241 (1959). reverse action of CDP-choline:diglyceride cho- 17. Baker, N., and M. C. Sholz, J. Lipid Res. 3, 188- line phosphotransferase, although this reaction 197 (1964). does not represent net synthesis of diglyceride. 18. Windmueller. H. G., and A. E. Spaeth, J. Biol. Chem. 241, 2891-2899 (1966). Bjernstad and Bremer (22) demonstrated a 19. Elovson, J., Biochim. Biophys. Acta 106, 480-494 rapid reversibility of the CDP-choline:diglyc- (1965). 20. Elovson, J., Ibid. 106, 291-303 (1965). eride choline phosphotransferase reaction in 21. D. W. Allman, D. H. Hubbard and D. M. Gibson, vivo in rat liver; however, it is not known J. Lipid Res. 6, 63-74 (1965). whether all species of lecithin take part equally 22. BjC,rnstad, P., and J. Bremer, Ibid. 7, 38-45 (1966). in this reversible reaction. Elovson showed [Received Nov. 14, 1967] LiPms, VOL. 3, NO. 5