DOCSLIB.ORG

The Politics of Health Insurance Reform in Japan and South Korea

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Politics of Health Insurance Reform in Japan and South Korea Solidarity, labour, and institution: The politics of health insurance reform in Japan and South Korea Seongjo Kim Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of East Asian Studies University of Sheffield May 2017 ii ABSTRACT Why did South Korea integrate multiple health insurers into a single national health insurance in 2003 while Japan maintained its fragmented insurance system based on labour market status? Why did labour in South Korea support the integra- tion of health insurance schemes whilst labour in Japan was opposed to it? The health insurance systems in Japan and South Korea were both based on the social insurance system and fragmented on the basis of occupation and labour market status. However, these two countries have taken different reform paths. This thesis argues that the two self-undermining effects and ideas were in- terwined and these led to different policy coalitions. Firstly, workers’ support for the consolidation reform was dependent on the inclusivity of the decision-making pro- cess at company-level health insurance schemes. Labour in Korea was not able to take part in the decision-making process in company-based health insurance societies while Japanese workers were. The absence of self-governance in the Korean health insurance system reduced incentives for the labour unions to protect their health schemes. Secondly, the Korean government conferred small credibility to support for the municipal health insurance. The subsidy for municipal health schemes in Korea was provided at the discretion of the central government and local government had no legal responsibility for its municipal health funds. These regulations were in stark contrast to the Japanese regulations. It made the friction with the idea of universal health care in Korea. Thirdly, the socially oriented unionism and dense network be- tween trade unions and reformers in Korea contributed to the integration of the health insurance system through creating intensive policy learning for solidarity in- side labour movements. In contrast, the cooperative labour-management relationship and their strong networks in the Japanese healthcare policy arena led to the coalition to protect their occupational health funds. iii Contents Abstract..................................................................................................................................ⅲ List of tables...........................................................................................................................ⅵ List of Figures.........................................................................................................................ⅶ List of Abbreviations ..............................................................................................................ⅷ Acknowledgements...............................................................................................................ⅹ Chapter 1 Introduction........................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Research question..............................................................................................................1 1.2 Critique of the relevant literature..................................................................................... 4 1.3 Methodology and data......................................................................................................5 1.4 The aim of this research...................................................................................................10 1.5 Significance of research and its contributions.................................................................12 1.6 Structure of thesis........................................................................................................... 14 Chapter 2 Literature review and analytic framework......................................................... 16 2.1 Literature review on health care reforms ………………………………………………………………….. 16 2.2 Theoretical framework…………………………………………………………………………………………….....28 2.3 Arguments.......................................................................................................................36 2.4 Conclusion........................................................................................................................37 Chapter 3 The politics of health care reforms......................................................................39 3.1 The distinctiveness of health care service and its politics...............................................39 3.2 Typology of the health care systems...............................................................................40 3.3 Reforms in the Bismarckian health care system..............................................................43 3.4 The Debate between the single-payer and multi-payer system......................................46 3.5 Conclusion........................................................................................................................50 Chapter 4 Political context of the health insurance reform in Korea..................................51 4.1 Historical development of health insurance in South Korea...........................................51 4.2 The structure of health insurance system in South Korea before reform.......................53 4.3 Major problems in the health insurance system.............................................................60 4.4 Major actors related to the health insurance system.....................................................66 4.5 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………………………..……………73 Chapter 5 Political context of the health insurance reform in Japan..................................75 5.1 Historical development of health insurance in Japan......................................................75 5.2 The structure of health insurance in Japan before reform..............................................79 5.3 Major problems in the health insurance system………………………………………………………….85 5.4 Major actors related to the health insurance system before reform..............................92 5.5 Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…99 Chapter 6 The political dynamics of health insurance reform in South Korea .................101 6.1 Reform attempt after democratisation between 1987 and 1989.................................101 6.2 Labour, the reshaping of a coalition, and the introduction of a partial reform between 1990 and 1997…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………112 6.3 Large-scale health insurance reform between 1997 and 2003.....................................133 6.4 Conclusion......................................................................................................................143 iv Chapter 7 The political dynamics of health insurance reform in Japan............................ 145 7.1 Health insurance reform trial in the 1990s....................................................................146 7.2 Koizumi era reforms.......................................................................................................161 7.3 The DPJ’s failed reforms.................................................................................................177 7.4 Conclusion......................................................................................................................187 Chapter 8 Comparative politics of health insurance reform in Korea and Japan …………..189 8.1 Comparison of Korean and Japanese health insurance reform ………………………….……. 189 8.2 Labour’s significant role in the health insurance reform…………………………….……………. 191 8.3 Ideational and Institutional differences in Korea and Japan ……………………………………..194 8.4 Interactions between ideational and institutional factors and reinterpretations of insti- tutional meanings…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..197 8.5 Conclusion......................................................................................................................201 Chapter 9 Conclusion..........................................................................................................203 9.1 Theoretical contributions..............................................................................................203 9.2 political implications..................................................................................................... 205 9.3 Closing remarks............................................................................................................. 206 Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………208 Appendix1: List of interviewees.………………………………………………………………………………….…234 v LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1 Incentive structures on health insurance reforms on the basis of the level of risk and in- come.....................................................................................................................................................46 Table 4.1 Health insurance coverage from 1977 to 1989.....................................................................53 Table 4.2 The structure of health insurance programmes in Korea (as of December 1991)…….…..….54 Table 4.3 The trend of health care spending in South Korea...............................................................60 Table 4.4 Estimates of the volume of health care in the late 1990s.............................................61 Table 4.5 Diffusion of medical technology in South Korea...................................................................62 Table 4.6 The financial
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 2018 Issued BL 11192018 by DATE
    2018 Issued Tukwila Business Licenses Sorted by Date of Application DBA Name Full Name Full Primary Address UBC # NAICS Creation NAICS Description Code Date TROYS ELECTRIC EDWARDS TROY A 2308 S L ST 602712157 238210 11/13/2018 Electrical Contractors TACOMA WA 98405 and Oth OLD MACK LLC OLD MACK LLC 2063 RYAN RD 604216260 423320 11/13/2018 Brick, Stone, and BUCKLEY WA 98321 Related Cons DRAGONS BREATH CREAMERY NITRO SNACK LLC 1027 SOUTHCENTER MALL 604290130 445299 11/9/2018 All Other Specialty Food TUKWILA WA 98188 Store NASH ELECTRIC LLC NASH ELECTRIC LLC 8316 71ST ST NE 603493097 238210 11/8/2018 Electrical Contractors MARYSVILLE WA 98270 and Oth BUDGET WIRING BUDGET WIRING 12612 23RD AVE S 601322435 238210 11/7/2018 Electrical Contractors BURIEN WA 98168 and Oth MATRIX ELECTRIC LLC MATRIX ELECTRIC LLC 15419 24TH AVE E 603032786 238210 11/7/2018 Electrical Contractors TACOMA WA 98445-4711 and Oth SOUNDBUILT HOMES LLC SOUNDBUILT HOMES LLC 12815 CANYON RD E 602883361 236115 11/7/2018 General Contractor M PUYALLUP WA 98373 1ST FIRE SOLUTIONS LLC 1ST FIRE SOLUTIONS LLC 4210 AUBURN WAY N 603380886 238220 11/6/2018 Plumbing, Heating, and 7 Air-Con AUBURN WA 98002 BJ'S CONSTRUCTION & BJ'S CONSTRUCTION & 609 26TH ST SE 601930579 236115 11/6/2018 General Contractor LANDSCAPING LANDSCAPING AUBURN WA 98002 CONSTRUCTION BROKERS INC CONSTRUCTION BROKERS INC 3500 DR GREAVES RD 604200594 236115 11/6/2018 General Contractor GRANDVIEW MO 64030 OBEC CONSULTING ENGINEERS OBEC CONSULTING ENGINEERS 4041 B ST 604305691 541330 11/6/2018 Engineering Services
    [Show full text]
  • The United States and Japan in Global Context: 2015
    THE EDWIN O. REISCHAUER CENTER FOR EAST ASIAN STUDIES THE UNITED STATES AND JAPAN IN GLOBAL CONTEXT: 2015 THE PAUL H. NITZE SCHOOL OF ADVANCED INTERNATIONAL STUDIES THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY Washington, D.C. Edwin O. Reischauer October 15, 1910 – September 1, 1990 Yearbook Class of 2015 From Left to Right: Sung Hui “Sophie” Yang, Jeffrey Bond, Ju Hyung Kim, Luoxi Dao, Ji Won Kwon, Malcolm Whitehead, Michael Wakcher, Professor William Brooks, Evan Sankey, Benjamin Garton, Ian Hamilton, Michael Kotler, Waichiro Katsuda, Yiwei “Jenny” Pan TABLE OF CONTENTS The Year at the Reischauer Center 1 Reischauer Center Events, 2014-2015 7 Introduction 10 William L. Brooks For U.S.-Japan Relations, the JET Program Is a Hidden National Treasure 46 Malcolm Whitehead U.S.-Japan Cultural Exchange in a New Era of Public Diplomacy 73 Michael Wakcher New U.S.-Japan Partnership in Disaster Management and Japan’s Role 95 Waichiro Katsuda India and the US-Japan Alliance 113 Evan Sankey Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s Central Asia Strategy: Is it Effective? 129 Ian Hamilton Trilateral security cooperation in Northeast Asia 157 Ju Hyong Kim Japan’s Trade Agreement Strategies: Three Case Studies 172 Ji Won Kwon Changing Trade Patterns among the U.S., Japan and China: Does Politics Trump Market Forces? 205 Jenny Iwei Pan Impact of “Abenomics” on Mergers and Acquisition Trends in Japan 222 Luoxi Dao Japan’s Long Road to Corporate Governance Reform 240 Ben Garton Building Japan’s Entrepreneurial Ecosystem 258 Jeff Bond Class Research Trip to Tokyo, March 2014: Photo Album 281 1 THE YEAR AT THE REISCHAUER CENTER The 2014-2015 academic year, during which the Reischauer Center celebrated its thirtieth anniversary, was a historic one--for the Center, SAIS, and for trans-Pacific relations.
    [Show full text]
  • Illustration and the Visual Imagination in Modern Japanese Literature By
    Eyes of the Heart: Illustration and the Visual Imagination in Modern Japanese Literature By Pedro Thiago Ramos Bassoe A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy in Japanese Literature in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in Charge: Professor Daniel O’Neill, Chair Professor Alan Tansman Professor Beate Fricke Summer 2018 © 2018 Pedro Thiago Ramos Bassoe All Rights Reserved Abstract Eyes of the Heart: Illustration and the Visual Imagination in Modern Japanese Literature by Pedro Thiago Ramos Bassoe Doctor of Philosophy in Japanese Literature University of California, Berkeley Professor Daniel O’Neill, Chair My dissertation investigates the role of images in shaping literary production in Japan from the 1880’s to the 1930’s as writers negotiated shifting relationships of text and image in the literary and visual arts. Throughout the Edo period (1603-1868), works of fiction were liberally illustrated with woodblock printed images, which, especially towards the mid-19th century, had become an essential component of most popular literature in Japan. With the opening of Japan’s borders in the Meiji period (1868-1912), writers who had grown up reading illustrated fiction were exposed to foreign works of literature that largely eschewed the use of illustration as a medium for storytelling, in turn leading them to reevaluate the role of image in their own literary tradition. As authors endeavored to produce a purely text-based form of fiction, modeled in part on the European novel, they began to reject the inclusion of images in their own work.
    [Show full text]
  • Los Angeles City Clerk
    ESTINEH MAILIAN EXECUTIVE OFFICES CHIEF ZONING ADMINISTRATOR City of Los Angeles 200 N. SPRING STREET, ROOM 525 CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES, CA 90012-4801 ASSOCIATE ZONING ADMINISTRATORS (213) 978-1271 JACK CHIANG HENRY CHU ,-ToS VINCENT P. BERTONI, AICP JONATHAN HERSHEY S m\ DIRECTOR THEODORE L. IRVING *7 KEVIN J. KELLER, AICP FRANKLIN N. QUON II yj. EXECUTIVE OFFICER CHARLES J. RAUSCH JR. BPJ FERNANDO TOVAR MnW' SHANA M.M. BONSTIN CHRISTINA TOY-LEE DEPUTY DIRECTOR DAVID S. WEINTRAUB eric garcetti ARTHI L. VARMA, AICP mayor DEPUTY DIRECTOR LISA M. WEBBER, AICP DEPUTY DIRECTOR VACANT DEPUTY DIRECTOR October 14, 2020 Rahul Kumar (A) CASE NO. ZA-2020-1556-CUB South Park Pharmacy & Market Place CONDITIONAL USE 1120 S. Grand Ave., Suite 103 1120 South Grand Avenue, Suite 103 Los Angeles, CA 90015 Central City Planning Area Zone : [Q] R5-4D-O DTLA South Park Properties C.D. 14 - Vacant PropCo II LLC (O) D.M. 126A207 60 1150 S. Olive St. CEQA ENV-2020-1557-CE Los Angeles, CA 90015 Legal Description: Lot(s) 11-18, Subdivision of Block 78 Ord’s Kevin Hufford (R) Survey ABC Liquor Consultants 1528 6th St., #511 Santa Monica, CA 90401 Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15061, I hereby DETERMINE: based on the whole of the administrative record, that the Project is exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, and there is no substantial evidence demonstrating that an exception to a categorical exemption pursuant to CEQA Guidelines, Section 15300.2 applies; and, Pursuant to Los Angeles Municipal Code Section 12.24-W, 1, I hereby APPROVE: a Conditional Use Permit to allow the sale and dispensing of a beer and wine for on-site and off-site consumption in conjunction with a new pharmacy, cafe, and market establishment in the [Q]R5 Zone, Upon the following additional terms and conditions: 1.
    [Show full text]
  • For the Rainbow's Beauty Cast After Floods of Human Tears, Arks of Safety
    Songs re-written: For the Beauty … For the rainbow’s beauty cast after floods of human tears, arks of safety in the past, -- claiming faith and conquering fears God of all, to you we raise -- this our hymn of grateful praise. For the joy of human love – partners named by church and state, allies here and friends above who, with joy, have silenced hate – God of all to you we raise – this our hymn of grateful praise. For the church with open doors, for the pews where all may rest, for each child by love restored, once outside, now home and blessed – God of all, to you we raise -- this our hymn of grateful praise. Woke Up this Morning with my Mind I woke up this morning with my mind -- stayed on Jesus I woke up this morning with my mind -- stayed on Jesus I woke up this morning with my mind -- stayed on Jesus Hallelu, hallelu, Hallelujah. I'm singing a rainbow with my mind -- stayed on Jesus I'm singing a rainbow with my mind -- stayed on Jesus I'm singing a rainbow with my mind -- stayed on Jesus Hallelu, hallelu, Hallelujah. We opened the doors up in our church -- stayed on Jesus We opened the doors up in our church -- stayed on Jesus We opened the doors up in our church -- stayed on Jesus Hallelu, hallelu, Hallelujah. Just as I am Just as I am, your holy child, my truth so fragile, undefiled, I turned to you and then you smiled – O Lamb of God, I come, I come.
    [Show full text]
  • Western Influence on Japanese Art Song (Kakyoku) in the Meiji Era Japan
    WESTERN INFLUENCE ON JAPANESE ART SONG (KAKYOKU) IN THE MEIJI ERA JAPAN JOANNE COLE Master of Music Performance (by Research) Faculty of the Victorian College of the Arts and Music The University of Melbourne December 2013 Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Music Performance (by Research) Produced on Archival Quality Paper Abstract The focus of this dissertation is the investigation of the earliest Western influences on Kōjō no Tsuki (Moon over the Castle) the composition of Japanese composer Rentaro Taki. Kōjō no Tsuki is an example of an early Japanese Art Song known as Kakyoku composed during Meiji Era Japan (1868 - 1912). The dissertation is divided into four chapters with an introduction. Chapter One explores the historical background of the Meiji Era Japan, highlighting the major impact of the signing of the treaty between the United States of America and Japan in 1853. This treaty effectively opened Japan to the West, not only for trade, but for exchange of social, political and cultural ideas. The resulting evolution that occurred in Japan from feudal society to one of early twentieth century is illustrated by reference to articles and writings of the Meiji Era. The second chapter examines the Japanese Art Song form Kakyoku using the example of Rentarō Taki’s song, Kōjō no Tsuki. This chapter presents an argument to illustrate, from an anthropological viewpoint, why this new form of Japanese Art Song could have its own identity based on Western ideas and not be categorised as a Japanese Folk Song known as Minʹyō or Shin Minyō.
    [Show full text]
  • TOKYO FIELD TRIP Dialogue with Cabinet Ministers
    TOKYO FIELD TRIP Dialogue with Cabinet Ministers History Of Japan’s Environmental Policy Kenji Someno, Research Fellow, Tokyo Foundation am speaking here today in place of former ronmental pollution. From 1955 to 1965, en- IEnvironment Minister Sakahito Ozawa, ergy consumption tripled, and the industrial who unfortunately is unable to attend due to structure shifted toward heavy industries. This Diet obligations. resulted in air, water, and soil pollution, which I’ve been involved in pollution measures became serious health hazards. and climate change for over 20 years as a People’s perceptions of economic growth former official of the Environment Ministry, also changed. In the early 1970s, a majority, where I headed the government’s Team Minus for the first time, came to view growth nega- 6 Percent campaign to lower the country’s car- tively as being a threat to their health. bon dioxide emissions. The Basic Pollution Control Law was en- Japan experienced high economic growth acted in 1967. The business community was from the late 1950s to early 1970s. People opposed to the law, as it feared that the higher became more affluent, the material symbols of costs for pollution countermeasures would such prosperity being purchases of the “three hurt their competitiveness. They called for sacred treasures,” namely, the black-and-white balance between business growth and pollu- TV, washing machine, and refrigerator. Later, tion measures. as the country grew richer, the color TV, au- If you replace the word “pollution” with “cli- tomobile, and air conditioner emerged as the mate change,” I think it pretty much sums up “new sacred treasures.” the attitude of the business community today.
    [Show full text]
  • Dear Parents
    Dear Parents/Guardians, Welcome to the Lollipop Tree Nursery School. We hope that you and your child have a wonderful year ahead filled with many new learning experiences as well as many new friends. This handbook has been assembled to help answer any questions that you may have. However, if any other questions arise, please feel free to ask any staff member. Debbie Degagne - Director Marie Mullin Wendy Joyce - Director Robin Colucci Peggy Orlando Andrea Marston Joan McMasters Michelle Ryan Robin Wynot Virginia Harrington Department of Early Education and Care is the licensing agency. Parents may contact EEC for any information regarding our program’s regulatory compliance history. 1250 Hancock St. Suite 120, Quincy, MA. 02169 - 617-472-2881 The Lollipop Tree is also NAEYC accredited www.NAEYC.org 1. Philosophy & Goals: “There are only two lasting things you can give your child... One is roots, the other is wings.” The Lollipop Tree Nursery School offers an innovative program to stimulate your child’s social, emotional and intellectual development. We strive to foster self confidence, independence and self-control while stressing respect for others. The children are encouraged to make choices which are important in learning decision-making and independence as well as responsibility for their own actions. 2. School Calendar: A school year calendar is on our website by September. Our school year coincides with the Braintree Public Schools for holidays, snow days and vacations. We do not comply with Braintree in-service days off. A monthly newsletter will be emailed at the beginning of each month. If you do not receive it please ask for a copy in the office.
    [Show full text]
  • Roster of Winners in Single-Seat Constituencies No
    Tuesday, October 24, 2017 | The Japan Times | 3 lower house ele ion ⑳ NAGANO ㉘ OSAKA 38KOCHI No. 1 Takashi Shinohara (I) No. 1 Hiroyuki Onishi (L) No. 1 Gen Nakatani (L) Roster of winners in single-seat constituencies No. 2 Mitsu Shimojo (KI) No. 2 Akira Sato (L) No. 2 Hajime Hirota (I) No. 3 Yosei Ide (KI) No. 3 Shigeki Sato (K) No. 4 Shigeyuki Goto (L) No. 4 Yasuhide Nakayama (L) 39EHIME No. 4 Masaaki Taira (L) ⑮ NIIGATA No. 5 Ichiro Miyashita (L) No. 5 Toru Kunishige (K) No. 1 Yasuhisa Shiozaki (L) ( L ) Liberal Democratic Party; ( KI ) Kibo no To; ( K ) Komeito; No. 5 Kenji Wakamiya (L) No. 6 Shinichi Isa (K) No. 1 Chinami Nishimura (CD) No. 2 Seiichiro Murakami (L) ( JC ) Japanese Communist Party; ( CD ) Constitutional Democratic Party; No. 6 Takayuki Ochiai (CD) No. 7 Naomi Tokashiki (L) No. 2 Eiichiro Washio (I) ㉑ GIFU No. 3 Yoichi Shiraishi (KI) ( NI ) Nippon Ishin no Kai; ( SD ) Social Democratic Party; ( I ) Independent No. 7 Akira Nagatsuma (CD) No. 8 Takashi Otsuka (L) No. 3 Takahiro Kuroiwa (I) No. 1 Seiko Noda (L) No. 4 Koichi Yamamoto (L) No. 8 Nobuteru Ishihara (L) No. 9 Kenji Harada (L) No. 4 Makiko Kikuta (I) No. 2 Yasufumi Tanahashi (L) No. 9 Isshu Sugawara (L) No. 10 Kiyomi Tsujimoto (CD) No. 4 Hiroshi Kajiyama (L) No. 3 Yoji Muto (L) 40FUKUOKA ① HOKKAIDO No. 10 Hayato Suzuki (L) No. 11 Hirofumi Hirano (I) No. 5 Akimasa Ishikawa (L) No. 4 Shunpei Kaneko (L) No. 1 Daiki Michishita (CD) No. 11 Hakubun Shimomura (L) No.
    [Show full text]
  • M^Jwaww* Department of Parks ^ City of New York Trtf Arsenal, Central Park I VI
    524 3/21/68 Plans for St. Janes Golden Age Center Revealed 525 3/21/68 Press Memorandum: Park Department Heroes Set Awards from Heckscher 526 3/22/68 Dyefcman House Closed for Refurbishing 527 3/25/68 Heoksoher Gives Awards to Park Department Heroes 528 3/26/68 Diane Wolkstein Storytelling 529 3/26/68 City Golf Course Opens Saturday 530 3/26/68 Schedule of Speoial Danoe Performances for Pre-Sohool Children and Parents 531 3/27/68 Soap Box Entrants to Visit the International Auto Show 532 3/28/68 Circus Comes to Central Park 533 3/28/68 Press Memrandum: Lindsay, Heoksoher Open New Playground 534 3/28/68 Buffalo Bill born to Mary and Louie Buffalo 535 4/5/68 Third Annual Brooklyn Kite Plying Contest 536 3/28/68 First Bike Train Heads for Southampton on May 5th 537 3/29/68 Danoe Classes to be Held 538 3/29/68 Award Contract to Install Portable Swimming Pools 539 3/29/68 Bioyole Demonstration 540 4/1/68 Lindsay, Heoksoher Open Jointly Operated Playground P$£tbb 541 4/8/68 Egg Rolling Contest } 542 4/11/68 Commissioner Heoksoher Leads Hike through Indian Territory on April 20th 543 4/11/68 Wave Hill Nature Walks 544 4/11/68 Parks Department Initiates Jogging Programs 545 4/12/68 Alfred E. Smith Creative Arts Workshop to Hold Exhibit 546 4/12/68 Three Baby Raccoons at Central Park Zoo 547 548 4/17/68 Commissioner Heoksoher Leads Hike through Indian Territory on April 20th (AMENDED) 549 550 4/22/68 New Sculpture to be Installed at 59th Street and Fifth Avenue M^jwaww* Department of Parks ^ City of New York TrtF Arsenal, Central Park I VI UPON RECEIPT PLANS FOR ST.
    [Show full text]
  • Detecting Japanese Vernacular Modernism: Shinseinen Magazine and the Development of the Tantei Shôsetsu Genre, 1920-1931
    DETECTING JAPANESE VERNACULAR MODERNISM: SHINSEINEN MAGAZINE AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE TANTEI SHÔSETSU GENRE, 1920-1931 DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Kyoko Omori * * * * * The Ohio State University 2003 Dissertation Committee: Professor William J. Tyler, Adviser Approved by Professor Richard Torrance Professor Mark Bender Adviser Department of East Asian Languages and Literatures ABSTRACT The post-war discourse on modern Japanese literature has presented the binary opposition between “pure” versus “popular” literature as a historical fact, configuring popular literature as the disposable “other” of “pure” literature. Consequently, Japanese literary studies have paid relatively little attention to popular forms such as mystery fiction, samurai “period” fiction, the romance novel, and “nansensu” humor. This dissertation examines the discursive formation of the Japanese modernist popular genre known as “tantei shôsetsu” or “detective fiction.” Focusing on the popular monthly magazine Shinseinen and several of its writers, it discusses the theoretical and practical dimensions of “tantei shôsetsu” as a vernacular form of modernist literary production. In doing so, it situates the genre within contemporaneous debates about the meaning of both modernity and literature in Japan during the 1920s. Chapter One establishes the theoretical terms for “vernacular modernism” by illuminating the ways in which popular literary production engaged with the forces of commercialism and Westernization that also shaped the development of canonical Japanese literature during the early twentieth century. Chapter Two surveys established critical views of Modernism in Japan and shows that they fail to account for the significance of vernacular expression.
    [Show full text]
  • March 26, 2021 File No. 20.0153134.30
    March 26, 2021 File No. 20.0153134.30 Mr. Randal Goddard 146 Larabee Street Horicon, Wisconsin 53032 Re: Post‐Mitigation January and February 2021 Indoor Air and Cabinet Air Test Results Dear Mr. Goddard: With this letter, GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc. (GZA) follows up on our February 2, 2021 and February 26, 2021 telephone conversations regarding the indoor air sampling at 146 Larabee Street in Horicon, Wisconsin between January 18 and 19, 2021 and on February 23, 2021. As set forth below, that sampling did not show evidence of trichloroethylene (TCE) originating from vapors beneath the basement of your home, which is where TCE would be expected to be found if TCE vapors were entering from an underground source. TCE was detected in the first and second floor levels and traced specifically to a storage cabinet on the second floor that previously contained cleaning agents that off‐gas TCE. Outside of that cabinet, the concentrations measured in the first and second floors were detected, but below the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources’ (WDNR’s) applicable adverse carcinogenic effect threshold of 0.89 parts per billion by volume (ppbv). The applicability of the carcinogenic effect threshold for your home is described in the discussion section below. INDOOR AIR SAMPLING Because of the extensive past efforts taken to assess and update the sub‐slab depressurization system installed to address the vapor intrusion pathway and the pre‐ and post‐mitigation sampling efforts, the January 24, 2020 summary report1 documenting assessment and mitigation of the vapor intrusion pathway is provided in Attachment 1 for your convenience.
    [Show full text]