Reading Jin Yong's Martial Arts Fiction and Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Ethics of Love and Heroism: Reading Jin Yong’s Martial Arts Fiction and Lacanian Psychoanalysis Yen-Ying Lai MA in Humanities BA in Anthropology, Chinese, and English A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at The University of Queensland in 2016 School of Communication and Arts Abstract Jin Yong, the best-known novelist of the wuxia, or martial arts genre, asks different questions of ethics about love, duty and honour in each of his novels. Lacan’s writing is also a journey of ethics, which is relentless in re-shaping the ground upon which any thinking, including its own, is defined. This thesis reads Jin Yong and Lacan together, to extend the Lacanian insight by bringing in materials that have remained foreign to psychoanalytic theory until now. In so doing, it reconfigures criticisms regarding romance, sexuality, and tragedy as a contribution to the field of Chinese literature. The thesis starts with a brief history of Chinese literature, focusing on martial arts fiction. Lacan’s arguments on the master signifier provide insight into crucial themes of the genre, such as xia (chivalry, heroism), zhong (loyalty to the leadership), and yi (allegiance to equals). Each of the following three chapters introduces one key set of Lacanian terms, focused on a diagram: the four discourses, the schema L, and the diagram of sexuation. Each of these presents a different take on Jin Yong and the martial arts genre. The second chapter looks at the circulation of Jin Yong’s novels. It focuses on “Jinology,” the Jin Yong scholarship that consists mainly of fan letters and fan writings, which I examine as a discourse in Lacan’s quite specific use of that term, as a social link that runs on its own excess and incompleteness.
[Show full text]