How Does Variation Count? Using Improved Molecular Technology, Particularly the Ready Amplification of Alice S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NEWS AND VIEWS VIROLOGY---------------- (M, Nowak, University of Oxford). How does variation count? Using improved molecular technology, particularly the ready amplification of Alice S. Huang and John M. Coffin nucleic acid sequences by the polymerase chain reaction, mutational WHAT do virologists, evolutionary could account for altered virulence in the heterogeneity is easily detected among biologists, population geneticists, mathe infected host. Sparked by what seems to different specimens taken at the same matical modellers, epidemiologists and be a remarkable genetic plasticity among time and place from different patients, physicians have in common? At a recent human immunodeficiency virus and the and in sequential specimens taken from EMBO workshop* an area of overlap annual emergence of threatening new the same patient. Although genetic emerged that could grow into a powerful influenza virus strains, a closer inspec variation may itself be important for scientific interface. New approaches tion was made of what is currently pathogenesis, the immune system pro were reported for analysing viral disease known about mutation rates for viruses. vides an important selective force (R. processes and evolutionary relationships, Rates of mutation for RNA genomes are Zinkernagel. University of Zurich; R, in which computer simulations were com now estimated to be 1,OOO-fold higher Phillips, John Radcliffe Hospital, Ox bined with the wealth of molecular data than for DNA genomes (J. Drake, ford; S. Carpenter. Iowa State Universi being generated by the sequencing of National Institute of Environmental ty; A. Leigh-Brown, University of Edin viral genomes. Complex but manipulat Health Sciences), Furthermore, the rates burgh). Disappointingly. there were no able experimental viral systems were are highly variable from site to site in the clear-cut correlations between the de used to test theories of population dy same genome (T. Kunkel, National gree of heterogeneity and the course of namics. And, almost as an aside, it was Institute of Environmental Health disease, It may well be that genetic firmly established that all RNA viruses, Sciences; B. Preston, Rutgers; M, change among viruses is intrinsic and the not only human immunodeficiency virus, Ricchetti, Pasteur Institute). This micro number of mutations simply related to mutate - but do not necessarily evolve heterogeneity leads to a population of the number of replication cycles (S. - at a high rate, and that recombination viral genomes known as quasispecies, Wain-Hobson, Pasteur Institute). result IS relatively common among RNA which are closely related but different ing in a genetically diverse population viruses. from one another. The proportions of capable of responding to very small Ever since von Magnus described these quasispecies change. depending on selective forces. changes in influenza virus populations both intrinsic error rates in polymerases Besides the heterogeneity resulting almost 40 years ago, investigators have and selective forces that may vary from single base mutations, a range of sought the cause of these changes. They according to the host environment. From strange and wonderful variations among have wondered whether such variations, the composition of different quasi viruses was presented. These included so easily detected in cell culture systems, species. viral replication rates, fitness satellite viruses of plant and animal *EMBO Workshop on Variation and Molecular Evolution of selection and mutation rates can all be viruses, where there is no commonality Viruses, Grignon, France. 7-11 July 1992. estimated In that ViruS population of sequence between the parasite and its Lifting the lid on enzymatic breakdown of lipids LIPASES are enzymes that hydrolyse triacylglycerol lipids into free fatty acids and glycerol - a crucial step in break ing down ingested fats in the gut. The pancreatic lipase enzyme's activity is greatly increased at the lipid-water in terface, when a short amphipathic helix, or lid (A), in the amino-terminal domain of the lipase (8), pops open and exposes the active site (C) of the enzyme to its lipid substrate (a phenomenon known as interfacial activation). The interaction of the lipase enzyme with the lipid inter face is very sensitive to the chemical nature of the lipid surface; in the pre sence of amphiphiles such as bile salts and phospholipids, the binding of the lipase to the lipid surface requires a small protein cofactor, colipase. The complex of these two molecules reveals that colipase binds to the carboxy terminal domain of the pancreatic lipase molecule (see the paper by H. van TiI beurgh et al. on page 159 of this issue). ® The co lipase's three hydrophobic fingers (F), here ball-and-stick groups, are sample hydrophobic presence of such inhibitors, then, the colipase cofactor may amino-acid side chains that point away from the lipase bring the larger lipase enzyme into close contact with the molecule but are on the same face of the complex as the lid Interface and allow opening of the lid to expose the active that covers the active site of the lipase molecule. The site, so facilitating the enzymatic breakdown of lipids. binding of lipase, but not colipase, to the lipid-water (Figure adapted from P. J. Kraulis J. appl. Ctystal/ogr. 24, interface is inhibited by amphiphiles (like bile salts). In the 946-950; 1991.) G. R, NATURE· VOL 359 . 10 SEPTEMBER 1992 107 © 1992 Nature Publishing Group NEWS AND VIEWS -DAEDALUS ~~~~~~~-, helper (G. Bruening, University of Cali One group is even attempting, so far fornia at Davis; W. Carman, Institute of without success, to approach this issue Know thyself! Virology, Glasgow); viroids, which are by analysis of monkey bones from Egyp THE victorian art of phrenology divided small RNA replicons, containing dupli tian tombs for simian immunodeficiency the brain into compartments. One part cated sequences (P. Keese, CSIRO, virus-like sequences (A. van der Kuyl, dealt with hope, another with Canberra); illegitimate recombinants University of Amsterdam). constructiveness, another with language among viruses containing either RNA or To population theorists, quasispecies, and so on. The strength of each faculty DNA genomes (H. Temin, University of recombinations and deletion mutants, could be judged by the enlargement of Wisconsin; M. Lai, University of South coupled with the relatively short genera the skull at that point. Feeling their eI11 California; G. Smith, University of tion times of viruses, offer interesting clients' skulls with sensitive fingers, Oxford); hypermutation of G to A in systems to test hypotheses vis a vis real popular phrenologists provided retrovirus genomes (J.-P. Vartanian, data. For instance, there is Muller's vocational guidance, character Pasteur Institute); nonreplicative mod ratchet, a hypothesis that states that assessment and psychiatric diagnosis. ification of nucleotides in RNA of para mutation will move a small population They even tried to detect an overactive myxoviruses (M. A. Billeter, University inexorably more distant from the most faculty from the warmth of the skull over of Zurich); and the insertion of host fit genotype; to ensure survival, such the relevant region. Nowadays, these sequences into the RNA of a flavivirus, driven populations gain stability through skills have practically died out. bovine viral diarrhoea virus. The inser increasing their population size or Daedalus plans to revive them. He tion introduces a change in a cleavage through recombination. Continuous pas points out that modern techniques such as computed X-ray tomography give us site, producing a new protein that saging of an RNA phage under nonselec direct access to the shape and size of changes the course of disease in persis tive conditions and measuring mutants the brain. Nuclear magnetic scanning, tently infected cows to death from and recombinants led to complete sup and especially positron-emission mucosal peeling within a few hours (N. port for this hypothesis (L. Chao, Uni imaging, can even map Its metabolic Tautz, Federal Research Centre for versity of Maryland). activity. So DREADCO technicians are Virus Disease of Animals, Tiibingen). Another successful use of mathematic now setting up a laboratory of Positron Results like these promise that differ al modelling was based on the predator Emission Phrenology to test the old ences in disease potential may indeed be prey relationship described for a defec ideas with modern rigour and explore due to heterogeneity in viral populations tive interfering particle and its helper new ones. in which chunks of genetic material are standard virus. Rather than regular cycl Volunteers for the new study will being inserted, deleted or otherwise ing between defective interfering parti simply lie In the PEP machine and altered. The challenge will be to dissect cles and standard virus, there was chao respond to requests to think about a out population changes in hosts during tic unpredictability even in a determinis particular topic or exercise some the evolving pathogenic events and to tic model (T. B. L. Kirkwood, National specific emotion. The site of sudden relate attenuation or virulence to each of Institute for Medical Research, Mill metabolic activity, or raised the particular variations found in these Hill). When mutations were added to concentration of the implicated viruses. the model, computer-simulated viral pas neurotransmitter, will then be displayed Hundreds of sequences from