RECENT PUBLICATIONS in LITURGY Prior to Edmund Bishop's Death in 1917, Englishmen Could Know Vaguely That a Layman of Fabulous L
RECENT PUBLICATIONS IN LITURGY Prior to Edmund Bishop's death in 1917, Englishmen could know vaguely that a layman of fabulous liturgical erudition, perhaps connected with Downside Abbey, was nearing the term of life with little of that learning, in connected fashion, available in English. On the Continent his name wore the lustre of researches, liturgical and antiquarian, going back into the 1880's, worked out at the British Museum, and published piecemeal far and wide. In England, now and again, chiefly in connection with some publication by a monk, he would raise the curtain enough to publish some of his notes, with querulous hints of much more in reserve. Nigel Abercrombie, in his new Life,1 quotes a critic of Bishop's style, that "he seemed to regard clarity as a personal enemy" (p. 346). Luckily he did select some of his papers for book publication: death overtook him with the work in proof stage; it issued as Liturgica histórica (1918). It slights his career as anti quarian to view him, as I do, as liturgist only. Students found the book both precious and puzzling. Its opening chapter, "On the Genius of the Roman Rite," a paper read to historians in 1889, so took popular fancy that its key concept, sobriety, has since passed into general usage. His masterly paper, "On the Earliest Roman Mass Book, the Gelasian," is as irrefutable now as in 1894; his handling of the early texts of the Canon of the Mass still holds first place in all later treatments of it. These and similar papers made Bishop the British bulldog in liturgy, finding facts and holding on.
[Show full text]