Mechanistic Characterization of Isoform Selective Inhibitors Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MECHANISTIC CHARACTERIZATION OF ISOFORM SELECTIVE INHIBITORS OF MAMMALIAN PHOSPHOLIPASE D By PAIGE ELIZABETH SELVY Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Vanderbilt University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in Pharmacology December, 2011 Nashville, Tennessee Approved by Professor H. Alex Brown Professor Craig W. Lindsley Professor Vsevolod Gurevich Professor Tina M. Iverson Professor Ethan Lee i TO MY DEAR FAMILY FOR THEIR CONTINUED SUPPORT AND LOVE, AND TO MY WONDERFUL HUSBAND WHO IS MY BEST FRIEND AND CONSTANT SOURCE OF ENCOURAGEMENT ii TABLE OF CONTENTS DEDICATION……………………………...………………………………………..…...….ii LIST OF TABLES………………………….…..……………………………………………v LIST OF FIGURES…………………..………..……………………………………....…...vi Chapter I. INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW OF PHOSPHOLIPASE D SUPERFAMILY……….…….1 Enzymes with phospholipase D activity……………………………….....…4 Non-HKD enzymes…………………………….……………….……...5 Streptomyces chromofuscus PLD…………………….…..….5 Autotaxin…………………...…………………………….…..…8 HKD enzymes.………………………………………...…...…….……12 Sequence…………………………………………………...…13 Structure…………………………………………………...…..15 Mechanism: hydrolysis versus transphosphatidylation......18 Interfacial kinetics………………………………………….…24 In vitro activity assays……………………………………..…26 Cellular activity assays………………………………….....…30 Prokaryotic PLD………………………………………………………...…….31 Bacterial endonucleases………………………………………........31 Bacterial PLD as virulence factors…………..……………………..34 Streptomyces PLD……………………………………………………35 Plant PLD………………………………………………………………………40 Classes of plant PLD enzymes………………………….…...……..42 Signaling………………………………………………………………47 Fungal PLD……………………………………………………………………48 Budding yeast Spo14………………………………………………..50 Dictyostelium PLD………….…………………………………………56 Zebrafish PLD………………………………………..………………………..59 Mammalian PLD………………………………….……………………….…..61 Isoforms…………………………………..………………….…...…...61 Tissue expression and subcellular localization……….………….. 66 iii Regulation…………………………………………………......……..70 Recombinant protein expression and purification….…………….87 Signaling pathways………………………………...………………..89 Receptor-mediated signaling………………………………...…….90 Vesicular trafficking …………………………………..……………100 PLD inhibitors………………………………………………...……………..101 Indirect inhibitors of PLD activity………………………………….103 Direct inhibitors of PLD activity……………………………...……105 PLD as a potential therapeutic target………………….………..………..108 II. IDENTIFICATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF NOVEL ISOFORM-SELECTIVE PLD INHIBITORS………………………………………..…...110 Halopemide………………………………………………………………….111 Development of novel isoform-selective compounds……..…..……...…112 Structure-Activity Relationship Characterization of Novel PLD Inhibitors………………………………………….…………..…117 Initial Demonstration VU-series Inhibitors Act Directly…………..…..….120 Cellular Ramifications for use of VU-series PLD Inhiibitors…….…..….123 III. MOLECULAR MECHANISM OF ISOFORM-SELECTIVE PHOSPHOLIPASE D INHIBITORS………………………………..……………….....124 Backscattering interferometry measures protein-ligand interactions……………………………………………………...…………….126 Development of novel human PLD1 construct facilitates in vitro studies……………………….…...……………………………….…129 VU-series PLD inhibitors directly interact with enzyme……..….……….131 Small molecule PLD inhibitors block lipid binding……….…..…..…..…..131 VU-series compounds inhibit catalytic activity…..……………..………...136 Protein truncation constructs illuminate the small molecule binding site……………………………………………..……...….138 Confirmation of small molecule binding site with point mutation constructs………………………………………..………………...141 Small molecule PLD inhibitors block cell signal-mediated translocation……………………………………………………………….…145 Model of VU-series mechanism of inhibtion……………………………….146 IV. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS……………………………….………..155 iv LIST OF TABLES TABLES PAGE 1. Non HKD PLDs………………………………………………… …….…….6 2. Alignment of catalytic motifs for PLD superfamily…….……………….14 3. Bacterial and viral PLDs………………………………………....….…….32 4. Plant PLD enzymes…………………...……………… ……………….…44 5. Mammalian PLD regulatory domains…………...….……...………..…..82 v LIST OF FIGURES FIGURES PAGE 1. Schematic of the various enzyme-catalyzed reactions that form PA……………………………..…………………….…3 2. Mechnism of PLD enzyme activities.…………………..…………………9 3. Comparison of domain alignments for different PLD superfamily enzymes……………………………………..16 4. Crystal structure of PMF PLD………………...………….………………19 5. Proposed PLD superfamily reaction mechanism………….......………21 6. Substrate presentation……………………………………………..……..27 7. Conserved domains of mammalian PLD………………………..………64 8. G-protein coupled receptor activation of PLD…………..…..………….93 9. Activation of PLD through epidermal growth factor receptor……….…97 10. The role of PLD in endocytosis and receptor internalization..…….…102 11. Reported indirect PLD inhibitors………… ………………..………….104 12. Reported direct PLD inhibitors……………………………...…………..107 13. In vitro inhibition of recombinant PLD with select compounds…..…113 14. Focused lead optimization to improve isoform potency and selectivity…………………………………………………...……….115 15. Inhibition of Cell Based Activity with Select Compounds……...…....116 16. Progression from halopemide to PLD1-selective inhibitors…......….119 17. Progression from halopemide to PLD2-selective inhibitors..…...…..119 vi 18. Direct small molecule inhibition of PLD………………...……………..121 19. Backscattering interferometry technique…….……………..………...127 20. Illustration of the domains of the human PLD1 splice variants…..…130 21. PLD1.d311 directly binds VU-series PLD inhibitors….……….….....132 22. VU-Series PLD inhibitors block lipid binding…..…...…………..……135 23. VU-Series compounds inhibit PLD1 regardless of substrate presentation…………………………………...137 24. Truncation constructs suggest VU-series PLD inhibitors directly bind PLD in a loop region……………………………….……...140 25. Point mutations confirm VU-Series PLD inhibitors directly bind PLD in a loop region………….…………………………………….144 26. PLD1 subcellular localization with VU-series inhibitors………….…..147 27. Model of molecular mechanism of action for the VU-series PLD inhibitors…………………………………..……………149 28. Crystal structures demonstrate the mechanism of orthosteric or allosteric Akt ihibition……............................................151 29. Homology model of human PLD1………………..……..……………..158 30. Preliminary mechanistic studies performed with the SERM class of PLD inhibitors…………………...…..…………………160 vii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW OF PHOSPHOLIPASE D SUPERFAMILY Phosphatidic acid (PA) is a critical phospholipid constituent in eukaryotic cell membranes, that accounts for 1-4 % of the total lipid [1]. This lipophilic glycerophospholipid has a phosphate head group, and as such serves not only a structural capacity in lipid bilayers, but also participates both as an intermediate in lipid metabolism and as a signaling molecule. Because of the small head group, PA facilitates changes in lipid bilayer curvature that are important for membrane fusion events, such as vesicular trafficking and endocytosis [2]. PA is also a precursor to other lipid signaling molecules including diacylglycerol (DAG) and lysophosphatidic acid (LPA). As a lipid second messenger, PA activates signaling proteins and acts as a node within the membrane to which signaling proteins translocate. Several signaling proteins, including Raf-1 [3], [4] and mTOR [5], directly bind PA to mediate translocation or activation, respectively. PA has been implicated in signaling cascades involving cell growth, proliferation, and survival. Aberrant PA signaling has been identified in multiple cancers [6], neurodegeneration [7], and platelet aggregation [8], which makes proteins that mediate cellular levels of PA attractive as potential therapeutic targets. 1 PA can be generated de novo [9], [10], [11] by sequential enzyme- catalyzed acylations of glycerol-3-phosphate, or in response to cell signaling pathways (Figure 1). Every glycerophospholipid generated in eukaryotic membranes transitions through PA, a pathway characterized by Eugene Kennedy and his colleagues more than half a century ago [11], [12]. Signal generated PA is formed by enzymes that modify existing lipids. These enzymes include lysophosphatidic acid acyltransferase (LPAAT) which acylates LPA, DAG kinase which phosphorylates DAG at the sn-3 position, and phospholipase D (PLD) which hydrolyzes the headgroup of a phospholipid, generally phosphatidylcholine (PC), triggering the release of choline. PLD activity, enzyme catalyzed hydrolysis of a phosphodiester bond, was first described in plants [13], [14], [15], [16] and subsequently many enzymes from a range of viral, prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms have been described as possessing PLD activity. To date, more than 4000 PLD enzymes have been entered in NCBI GenBank. The majority of these enzymes hydrolyze phosphodiester bonds within phospholipids such as PC (classified as EC 3.1.4.4 [17]), but there are other enzymes ascribed to having PLD activity that hydrolyze neutral lipids and even polynucleotide backbone. A large subset of enzymes with PLD activity share a conserved HxKxxxxDx6GSxN motif (HKD motif) [18], or a variation thereof, that is responsible for catalytic activity. These enzymes are members of the PLD superfamily, and are proposed to follow a similar reaction mechanism in which a nucleophilic histidine residue initiates the reaction and generates a covalent intermediate, and a water or short alcohol completes the 2 Figure 1. A schematic of the various enzyme-catalyzed reactions that results in the formation of phosphatidic