Are Fluorescent Silicon Nanoparticles Formed in a One-Pot Aqueous Synthesis? Bohdan Oliinyk, Dmytro Korytko, Vladimir Lysenko, Sergei Alekseev
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Are Fluorescent Silicon Nanoparticles Formed in a One-Pot Aqueous Synthesis? Bohdan Oliinyk, Dmytro Korytko, Vladimir Lysenko, Sergei Alekseev To cite this version: Bohdan Oliinyk, Dmytro Korytko, Vladimir Lysenko, Sergei Alekseev. Are Fluorescent Silicon Nanoparticles Formed in a One-Pot Aqueous Synthesis?. Chemistry of Materials, American Chemical Society, 2019, 31 (18), pp.7167-7172. 10.1021/acs.chemmater.9b01067. hal-02236812 HAL Id: hal-02236812 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02236812 Submitted on 31 May 2021 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. This is an open access article published under an ACS AuthorChoice License, which permits copying and redistribution of the article or any adaptations for non-commercial purposes. Article Cite This: Chem. Mater. 2019, 31, 7167−7172 pubs.acs.org/cm Are Fluorescent Silicon Nanoparticles Formed in a One-Pot Aqueous Synthesis? † ‡ † § ∥ † Bohdan V. Oliinyk,*, , Dmytro Korytko, Vladimir Lysenko, , and Sergei Alekseev † Chemistry Department, Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Volodymyrska Street, 64, 01601 Kyiv, Ukraine ‡ Institute of Analytical Sciences, UMR-5280, Claude Bernard University of Lyon, 5 rue de la Doua, 69100 Villeurbanne, France § Lyon Institute of Nanotechnology, UMR-5270, INSA Lyon, 7 avenue Jean Capelle, 69621 Villeurbanne, France ∥ Light Matter Institute, UMR-5306, Claude Bernard University of Lyon, 2 rue Victor Grignard, 69622 Villeurbanne, France *S Supporting Information ABSTRACT: Critical analysis of the data reported by Zhong et al. (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2013, 135 (22), 8350−8356) is carried out. In particular, one of the main results of Zhong et al. concerning the formation of photoluminescent silicon nanoparticles (Si NPs) in an aqueous solution of (3- aminopropyl)trimethoxysilane (APTMS) and trisodium cit- rate dihydrate (Na3Cit) under microwave heating is impugned. These results are reconsidered here because of what appear to be significant inaccuracies and misinter- pretations that have been spread through a wide number of other subsequent publications. − eing stable, environmentally benign, and inexpensively knowledge in the field of silicon chemistry,52 54 low B synthesized, silicon-based nanomaterials have versatile temperature formation of crystalline Si0 nanoparticles (as and wide-ranging optical, electronic, and biocompatible/ − reported by Zhong et al.) from the water solutions of biodegradable properties.2 4 In particular, due to their unique alkoxysilanes seems very doubtful. Indeed, it remains entirely optical characteristics, silicon-based colloidal nanoparticles unclear which reactants in the reaction mixture are remotely (NPs) are well-known to be extremely promising for various capable of reducing a silicon atom bound to oxygen. Moreover, 5,6 multidisciplinary applications, such as bioimaging, drug silicon nanoparticles of the claimed size are extremely difficult 7 8 9−12 delivery, photoinduced therapy, and many others. A to passivate and would be very rapidly oxidized to SiO2 under variety of physical, chemical, physicochemical, and electro- the action of water.5 If the reported reduction of the Si−O Downloaded via 90.65.45.137 on May 31, 2021 at 06:12:11 (UTC). chemical techniques have been developed to produce bonds by citrate were reproducible by other groups, the impact dispersions of luminescent nanometer sized silicon crystal- 13,14 of this discovery would be much more important than just an lites. easy and scalable method for preparation of Si NPs for In 2013, a new aqueous synthetic approach based on one- biological applications. It would represent a new page of silicon pot synthesis of fluorescent Si NPs, using of (3-aminopropyl)- See https://pubs.acs.org/sharingguidelines for options on how to legitimately share published articles. chemistry that opens the door to the preparation of trimethoxysilane (APTMS) as the silicon source and trisodium 1 inexpensive silicon and silicon-based materials manufacturing. citrate dihydrate (Na3Cit), was reported by Zhong et al. This Thus, it deserves to be further investigated to avoid any work has attracted a great deal of attention from the scientific incorrect speculation on that theme. community since 2013 and has accumulated 227 citations First of all, the TEM micrographs presented by Zhong et al. according to Google Scholar (June 6, 2019), 203 citations (Figure 1a) as well as a similar image from ref 17 show (i) a according to Scopus (May 18, 2019), and 191 citations number of spherical particles without any evidence of according to SciFinder (June 6, 2019). Among all these papers, special attention should be paid to those that specifically crystallinity at a 5 nm scale and (ii) a single obviously mention use of the approach described in this paper for the crystalline particle at a 1 nm scale. However, if the lattice − basis of or jumping off point for their own work.15 51 At first fringes are clearly visible at a 1 nm scale, they should be also inspection, the proposed technique seems to have many visible at a 5 nm scale at least for a few particles having the advantages in comparison with most other approaches correct orientation with respect to the incident electron beam reported earlier. Of these advantages, one can emphasize in (e.g., see Figure 1b). Furthermore, taking into account the particular the following: (i) water is used as a solvent, (ii) short reaction times are sufficient (15 min), (iii) low temperatures Received: March 16, 2019 are needed (160 °C), and (iv) inexpensive precursors work Revised: July 2, 2019 well. However, taking into account common accepted Published: July 2, 2019 © 2019 American Chemical Society 7167 DOI: 10.1021/acs.chemmater.9b01067 Chem. Mater. 2019, 31, 7167−7172 Chemistry of Materials Article Figure 1. (a) HRTEM images of the Na3Cit + APTMS reaction product. Reprinted with permission from ref 1. Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society. (b) HRTEM images of plasma synthesis Si NPs. Reprinted with permission from ref 56. Copyright 2009 American Chemical Society. (c) Powder XRD patterns of the Na3Cit + APTMS reaction product. Reprinted with permission from ref 1. Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society. (d) Powder XRD patterns of crystalline Si and H-terminated Si NPs of different sizes. Reprinted with permission from ref 57. Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society. scale bar (1 nm) in Figure 1a, the lattice spacing cannot mmol of trisodium citrate was added. In the case of n- correspond to 0.19 nm as is indicated, but rather to 0.057 nm, C3H7NH2, 15 mmol of methanol was added to simulate the which seems doubtful for Si NPs. same conditions as in the case of APTMS, which hydrolyzes in An XRD pattern of the particles prepared by Zhong et al. water to produce methanol. At this point, the solutions were (Figure 1c) differs significantly from typical XRD patterns of Si transferred into 25 mL PTFE-lined stainless steel autoclaves. NPs (Figure 1d). Indeed, no characteristic broad peaks The sealed autoclaves were heated to 180 °C in an electric inherent to the nanoscale crystallites55 can be seen on Figure oven and left for an additional 5 h at this temperature. The 1c. The narrow and barely visible peaks at 2θ = 28 and 47° in final solutions were centrifuged at 10 000 rpm for 5 min, but Figure 1c can be related rather to traces of some crystalline no precipitate was observed to form, as had been reported. admixtures (inorganic salts, for example), residual peaks from Products of the reactions of Na3Cit with both Si-containing “ the zero-background sample holder made of monocrystalline APTMS and Si-free n-C3H7NH2 appeared as yellowish silicon plate”1 or other artifacts. Furthermore, no data (colorless upon dilution) clear solutions with bright blue regarding the X-ray source is given in the original paper. photoluminescence (PL) under UV excitation (Figure 2a). Thus, the XRD data does not provide solid evidence of the Steady-state PL and absorption spectra were collected using an formation of the 204 nm crystalline Si NPs. Edinburgh Instruments Ltd. FLS920 spectrometer with a Xe Finally, according to the best practices of NP character- lamp (150W, Hamamatsu) as the excitation source. The PL, ization,58 provision of XPS data is absolutely necessary. Indeed, PL excitation, and optical absorbance spectra were found to be it could shed light on the oxidation state of silicon atoms in the identical (Figure 2b,c), independent of the presence or absence particles. However, no thorough XPS analysis was provided in of silicon in the organic amine. Furthermore, the general this publication, and thus, the compositional identity of the appearance and the spectral properties of the “Si NPs sol” NPs is still questionable. described by Zhong et al. are also identical to those shown In order to check the assumption expressed by Zhong et al. here in Figure 2. regarding the formation of Si NPs, the following control In addition, to further confirm the similarity of the reaction reactions between sodium citrate and organic amine (one products, time-resolved PL and PL photostability experiments λ containing silicon, APTMS, and one without silicon, n- were carried out. A picosecond pulsed laser EPL-375 ( em = propylamine) have been carried out. 377.2 nm, 76.4 ps pulse width) was used as an excitation The reaction conditions were chosen to be the closest to source for the time-resolved PL measurements. Figure 3a those by Zhong et al., as described here. In particular, 5 mmol shows time-resolved PL of the both samples. The degree of the of amine was added to 10 mL of deionized water.