RT Volume 38, No. 2 Summer 2016 article text Editorial 3 National Director 4 Chapter & Member Liaison 4 RCAF HWE Hurricanes, Part 1, Jim Bates 5 1/72 1924 Atkinson 6-Ton Steam Lorry, Al Magnus 17 You Oughta Build an Otter, Barry Maddin 22 Within sight of shore - HMCS Esquimalt, Ryan Cameron 27 Cover Comment: Ryan Cameron of Langley, BC used a variety of materials and scratchbuilding techniques to produce a 1/72 HMCS Esquimalt. See page 27 for the details.. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 3 Editorial Steve Sauvé, C#0323
[email protected] “I like your model, but...” While putting in some time at our IPMS Ottawa building display at the Canada Aviation and Space Museum, I was talking with a fellow club member about the differences in how models are judged in contests, and how they are (or should be, in my opinion) constructively critiqued in person. Big difference. Serious contest judging, as has been discussed online ad nauseam , is generally ‘Find Faults First’. Judges certainly have to look at what was done well, but the winners are generally determined on whose model has the fewest basic modelling faults. If a fellow modeller asks you for a critique of their work, don’t assume that they are asking for a Nationals-level ‘reaming out’ of everything you think should have been done better. You shouldn’t be ignoring ‘areas for improvement’, but before you constructively discuss these, do what you can to say what you do like about someone else’s work. It’s not an internet ‘soccer league’ “all your models are winners” thing, but a little discretion and finding a friendly way to help someone improve their modelling will go a long way to encouraging people to stay in our chapters and in the hobby.