Navigating Geopolitics: Australia and the Malabar Exercise - By: Tyler Whitney 1

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Navigating Geopolitics: Australia and the Malabar Exercise - By: Tyler Whitney 1 together to cooperate on military strategy, it makes China Navigating Geopolitics: ask, "who are you preparing to fight, exactly? Who is it that you think needs to be kept in check?" The possible Australia and the Malabar negative reaction from China is a good reason for India to proceed cautiously. Including Australia in the exercise Exercise would be viewed as a challenge to Chinese naval power in the region. Note that India has never floated the idea of By: Tyler Whitney including China in the exercise. Whenever countries act on their geopolitical codes, there 02/20/2020 must be an acceptable reason for it. The point of the exercise is "to enhance cooperation and inter-operability, based on shared values and principles." This notion of shared values and principles is common when it comes to how states justify geopolitical codes. The cooperative relationship between the U.S., Japan, and India has a way of making sense when thought of in terms of mutual values, as long as they can convince their domestic audience. US aircraft and missile carriers Carl Vinson, Bunker Hill, and Halsey alongside other Indian navy ships in Exercise Malabar By: Tyler Whitney Like every geopolitical actor, India must identify their allies and include plans to strengthen those relationships. One outlet for this is the Malabar exercise, an annual occasion of naval cooperation hosted by India. Whether or not India will invite Australia to participate this year is relevant because the guest list for this party is one expression of India's geopolitical code. “Exercise Malabar” consists of practicing a variety of drills, maneuvers, and scenarios in different locations in the Pacific Ocean. The content of the exercise is changed up every year. The big question this year is whether India will invite Australia to participate. In the past, participants have included Australia, Singapore, the U.S., and Japan. The U.S. and Japan are regular participants in the exercise, but the expansion of the arrangement to permanently include Australia is considered a provocative prospect by China. The annual exercise represents a mutual understanding between the US, Indian, and Japanese navies. The exercise itself isn't a large affair: a total of eight vessels participated last year. But the importance of the Malabar exercise (and the reason its challenging to China) is how it answers the questions: who are our allies now? How can we foster our relationship with them? Geopolitical codes are tricky, perhaps even delicate. When you have a position towards one country, it implies a position towards another. When seeing these countries get.

Copy Link

Recommended publications

The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue and the Indo-Pacific: Major Powers, Strategies and Future Prospects
The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue and the Indo-Pacific: Major Powers, Strategies and Future Prospects -Vishakha Patil. 06th March 2021 Contents Acknowledgments 2 Abstract 3 1. Introduction 4 2. Evolution of The QUAD and the Policy of each Partner towards it. 12-27 3. Policies of China with reference to the South China Sea littoral and the 28-41 broader Indo-Pacific region. 4. India’s interests in the littoral states of the South China Sea and the 42-51 broader Indo-Pacific. 5. Policy options for India in the short and medium term vis-à-vis the Indo- 52-57 Pacific region and the Quad 6. Conclusion 59-59 Bibliography 60-71 1 Acknowledgments I Ms. Vishakha Patil would like to express my gratitude towards Forum for Integrated National Security (FINS) for providing me the opportunity to write a paper on this very crucial topic. I thank my Professor Dr. Uttara Sahasrabuddhe for guiding me throughout the course of writing this paper and for providing her valuable inputs. I also extend my heartfelt thanks to Rajiv Gupte Sir for believing in me and allowing me to undertake this research. 2 Abstract The global order keeps on evolving. The 21st century has witnessed a shift from the Atlantic to the Pacific. The ascendency of Asia in multiple spheres has captured the global attention. The major powers in Asia have carved out a path for themselves especially in the international security architecture. The Indo-Pacifici region has become a critical component of International relations today. India and China have emerged as the major power centers in Asia.
[Show full text]
Research Article WILDMEN in MYANMAR
The RELICT HOMINOID INQUIRY 4:53-66 (2015) Research Article WILDMEN IN MYANMAR: A COMPENDIUM OF PUBLISHED ACCOUNTS AND REVIEW OF THE EVIDENCE Steven G. Platt1, Thomas R. Rainwater2* 1 Wildlife Conservation Society-Myanmar Program, Office Block C-1, Aye Yeik Mon 1st Street, Hlaing Township, Yangon, Myanmar 2 Baruch Institute of Coastal Ecology and Forest Science, Clemson University, P.O. Box 596, Georgetown, SC 29442, USA ABSTRACT. In contrast to other countries in Asia, little is known concerning the possible occurrence of undescribed Hominoidea (i.e., wildmen) in Myanmar (Burma). We here present six accounts from Myanmar describing wildmen or their sign published between 1910 and 1972; three of these reports antedate popularization of wildmen (e.g., yeti and sasquatch) in the global media. Most reports emanate from mountainous regions of northern Myanmar (primarily Kachin State) where wildmen appear to inhabit montane forests. Wildman tracks are described as superficially similar to human (Homo sapiens) footprints, and about the same size to almost twice the size of human tracks. Presumptive pressure ridges were described in one set of wildman tracks. Accounts suggest wildmen are bipedal, 120-245 cm in height, and covered in longish pale to orange-red hair with a head-neck ruff. Wildmen are said to utter distinctive vocalizations, emit strong odors, and sometimes behave aggressively towards humans. Published accounts of wildmen in Myanmar are largely based on narratives provided by indigenous informants. We found nothing to indicate informants were attempting to beguile investigators, and consider it unlikely that wildmen might be confused with other large mammals native to the region.
[Show full text]
The “Quad”: Security Cooperation Among the United States, Japan, India, and Australia
November 2, 2020 The “Quad”: Security Cooperation Among the United States, Japan, India, and Australia Overview particularly after the U.S. withdrawal from the proposed In October 2020, in the midst of a global pandemic, U.S. Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade agreement. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and his three counterparts from Australia, India, and Japan convened an in-person A Shift to Operations? meeting in Tokyo. The focus was on boosting the Skeptics of the Quad earlier pointed to the group’s lack of Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, aka “the Quad,” a four- operationalization. Shortly after the October 2020 meeting country coalition with a common platform of protecting in Tokyo, India announced that Australia would be invited freedom of navigation and promoting democratic values in to join the United States, Japan, and India for the annual the region. The gathering released no joint statement, but Malabar naval exercises slated for November. The Pompeo stated that the purpose of the group was to “protect exercises, originally bilateral between the United States and our people and partners from the Chinese Communist India, later added Japan as a permanent member in 2015. Party’s exploitation, corruption, and coercion.” Although Defense officials say that the exercise could be a potent the three other ministers framed the meeting differently in war-fighting exercise that deepens trust and interoperability their opening statements, fears of China’s growing among the four militaries in the air and sea domains. All influence and assertiveness in the region loom large. four militaries operate compatible anti-submarine warfare Tensions with China have worsened for all four countries in systems, making that a promising area of cooperation.
[Show full text]
The Rohingyas of Rakhine State: Social Evolution and History in the Light of Ethnic Nationalism
RUSSIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES INSTITUTE OF ORIENTAL STUDIES Eurasian Center for Big History & System Forecasting SOCIAL EVOLUTION Studies in the Evolution & HISTORY of Human Societies Volume 19, Number 2 / September 2020 DOI: 10.30884/seh/2020.02.00 Contents Articles: Policarp Hortolà From Thermodynamics to Biology: A Critical Approach to ‘Intelligent Design’ Hypothesis .............................................................. 3 Leonid Grinin and Anton Grinin Social Evolution as an Integral Part of Universal Evolution ............. 20 Daniel Barreiros and Daniel Ribera Vainfas Cognition, Human Evolution and the Possibilities for an Ethics of Warfare and Peace ........................................................................... 47 Yelena N. Yemelyanova The Nature and Origins of War: The Social Democratic Concept ...... 68 Sylwester Wróbel, Mateusz Wajzer, and Monika Cukier-Syguła Some Remarks on the Genetic Explanations of Political Participation .......................................................................................... 98 Sarwar J. Minar and Abdul Halim The Rohingyas of Rakhine State: Social Evolution and History in the Light of Ethnic Nationalism .......................................................... 115 Uwe Christian Plachetka Vavilov Centers or Vavilov Cultures? Evidence for the Law of Homologous Series in World System Evolution ............................... 145 Reviews and Notes: Henri J. M. Claessen Ancient Ghana Reconsidered .............................................................. 184 Congratulations
[Show full text]
India's Response to China's Assertiveness Over the Seas
India’s response to China’s assertiveness over the seas When the Chinese occupied the Paracel Islands in early 1974, attached exchange of letters, it was said that Sri Lanka will the absence of official reaction drew the attention of the not allow any activities on its territory detrimental to India’s French embassy in New Delhi. A diplomat went to interview security, including making ports available for military use by the Head of the China desk at South Block, the Indian minis- any country in a manner prejudicial to India’s interests. Rich- try of External Affairs. The senior officer analyzed that “the ard Armitage, then Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian occupation by force of the Paracel Islands must be interpret- and Pacific Affairs, noted prophetically that it didn’t “make ed as a warning sign of Beijing’s Southern seas strategy aim- sense for the U.S. not to have a congenial relationship with ing at encircling Southeast Asia and at exercising a dominant the largest democracy and the dominant military power in influence over the region, economically, politically and stra- the subcontinent – and with a country that will clearly take tegically”. Besides Beijing was asserting claims to the Sprat- its place on the world stage in the 21st century”2. The rise of ley Islands and adjacent territorial waters, not ruling out the the Indian Navy was nevertheless then in its infancy. use of armed force if necessary. In view of their rapproche- The Indian Maritime Doctrine of 2015 emphasizes the neces- ment with the People’s Republic of China and obsessed with sity to manifest a strong presence of the Navy in the Indian the containment of the Soviet Union, the United States were Ocean Region (IOR), to strengthen the coastal defense, and seen as complacent, willing to allow some kind of Chinese to display a resolve to protect sea lanes of communications.
[Show full text]
Quad Plus: Special Issue of the Journal of Indo-Pacific Affairs
The Journal of JIPA Indo-Pacific Affairs Chief of Staff, US Air Force Gen Charles Q. Brown, Jr., USAF Chief of Space Operations, US Space Force Gen John W. Raymond, USSF Commander, Air Education and Training Command Lt Gen Marshall B. Webb, USAF Commander and President, Air University Lt Gen James B. Hecker, USAF Director, Air University Academic Services Dr. Mehmed Ali Director, Air University Press Maj Richard T. Harrison, USAF Chief of Professional Journals Maj Richard T. Harrison, USAF Editorial Staff Dr. Ernest Gunasekara-Rockwell, Editor Luyang Yuan, Editorial Assistant Daniel M. Armstrong, Illustrator Megan N. Hoehn, Print Specialist Journal of Indo-Pacific Affairs ( JIPA) 600 Chennault Circle Maxwell AFB AL 36112-6010 e-mail: [email protected] Visit Journal of Indo-Pacific Affairs online at https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/JIPA/. ISSN 2576-5361 (Print) ISSN 2576-537X (Online) Published by the Air University Press, The Journal of Indo–Pacific Affairs ( JIPA) is a professional journal of the Department of the Air Force and a forum for worldwide dialogue regarding the Indo–Pacific region, spanning from the west coasts of the Americas to the eastern shores of Africa and covering much of Asia and all of Oceania. The journal fosters intellectual and professional development for members of the Air and Space Forces and the world’s other English-speaking militaries and informs decision makers and academicians around the globe. Articles submitted to the journal must be unclassified, nonsensitive, and releasable to the public. Features represent fully researched, thoroughly documented, and peer-reviewed scholarly articles 5,000 to 6,000 words in length.
[Show full text]
Def Ining the Diamond the Past, Present, and Future of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue
CSIS BRIEFS CSIS Defining the Diamond The Past, Present, and Future of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue By Patrick Gerard Buchan and Benjamin Rimland MARCH 2020 THE ISSUE • The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue among the United States, Japan, India, and Australia (The Quad) has returned to prominence after an eight-year hiatus. • Senior foreign ministry officials from the Quad nations have met bimonthly, the grouping has also convened at the ministerial level and formed the basis for a tabletop exercise • The CSIS Alliances and American Leadership Program performed an informal “temperature taking” survey of policy elites in the Quad nations to gauge possible steps forward. • The survey results inform several achievable policy proposals to help continue the momentum of the Quad in the years to come. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY in 2017 and began convening on a bimonthly basis. Since its first senior official-level meeting in 2007, the From the outset, the Quad’s ideological and geographic Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (the Quad) among Japan, foundations were envisioned by Japanese Prime Minister the United States, India, and Australia has operated both Shinzo Abe, whose “Confluence of the Two Seas” speech as a meeting format for senior officials to discuss regional provided the foundations for the grouping. Indeed, this security issues and as the basis for a single naval exercise ideological and geographic bounding has naturally led to and a single tabletop exercise. The four countries first contrasting presumptions about the intent and future of formed a “core group” during the joint response to the the Quad: that it is the genesis of an “Asian NATO,” that 2004 Boxing Day tsunami.
[Show full text]
India-U.S. Relations
India-U.S. Relations July 19, 2021 Congressional Research Service https://crsreports.congress.gov R46845 SUMMARY R46845 India-U.S. Relations July 19, 2021 India is expected to become the world’s most populous country, home to about one of every six people. Many factors combine to infuse India’s government and people with “great power” K. Alan Kronstadt, aspirations: its rich civilization and history; expanding strategic horizons; energetic global and Coordinator international engagement; critical geography (with more than 9,000 miles of land borders, many Specialist in South Asian of them disputed) astride vital sea and energy lanes; major economy (at times the world’s fastest Affairs growing) with a rising middle class and an attendant boost in defense and power projection capabilities (replete with a nuclear weapons arsenal and triad of delivery systems); and vigorous Shayerah I. Akhtar science and technology sectors, among others. Specialist in International Trade and Finance In recognition of India’s increasingly central role and ability to influence world affairs—and with a widely held assumption that a stronger and more prosperous democratic India is good for the United States—the U.S. Congress and three successive U.S. Administrations have acted both to William A. Kandel broaden and deepen America’s engagement with New Delhi. Such engagement follows decades Analyst in Immigration of Cold War-era estrangement. Washington and New Delhi launched a “strategic partnership” in Policy 2005, along with a framework for long-term defense cooperation that now includes large-scale joint military exercises and significant defense trade. In concert with Japan and Australia, the Liana W.
[Show full text]
ISSUE BRIEF Phone: +92-920-4423, 24 Fax: +92-920-4658
INSTITUTE OF STRATEGIC STUDIES ISLAMABAD Web: www.issi.org.pk ISSUE BRIEF Phone: +92-920-4423, 24 Fax: +92-920-4658 MALABAR EXERCISE 2018: IMPLICATIONS FOR PAKISTAN By Muhammad Abbas Hassan Research Associate & Noor ul Huda* Intern Edited by Najam Rafique July 12, 2018 (Views expressed in the brief are those of the author, and do not represent those of ISSI) US, India and Japan held the 22nd round of the annual Malabar Naval Exercise from June 7-16, 2018 off the coast of Guam. India declined Australia’s request to participate in the 2018 drill. The exercise took place at a time when India has already stretched itself across the Indian Ocean. It is also acting as a partner in the "Indo-Pacific" strategy of the US to contain China in the region.1 The increasing trilateral presence is a result of the growing military presence of China, and which seeks to present a direct counter to the increasing influence of China in the maritime domain. * Ms. Noor ul Huda is currently doing her BS from National Defence University, Islamabad. She is currently working under Young ISSI Professional Corner at the ISSI. © ISSI 2018 • All Rights Reserved 1 | P a g e IB Malabar Exercise 2018: Implications for Pakistan July 12, 2018 The Malabar exercises started off as bilateral war games conducted by the US and India in 1992. They were held annually, but were suspended from 1998 to 2002 after India conducted its nuclear tests in 1998. Japan Maritime Self-Defense Forces (JMSDF) entered the war games officially in 2015; however, it participated in several drills since 2007.
[Show full text]
MALABAR 2017 by Lalit Kapur, Senior Fellow, Delhi Policy Group
DPG BRIEF| Vol. II. Issue 4 | August 2017 DELHI POLICY GROUP Advancing India’s Rise as a Leading Power DPG BRIEF Vol. II, Issue 4 August 1, 2017 MALABAR 2017 by Lalit Kapur, Senior Fellow, Delhi Policy Group The 21st edition of the week long Exercise Malabar CONTENTS ended on July 17, 2017, bringing to a close an annual event that has become one of the Malabar 2017 highlights of the Indian Navy’s engagement with - Commodore Lalit Kapur (Retd.), Senior “friendly maritime forces in the Indian Ocean and Fellow, Delhi Policy Group beyond, through port visits, bilateral interactions, training initiatives, operational exercises and technical support arrangements, in order to establish a cooperative framework that DPG Brief is produced by the Delhi Policy Group, an independent and autonomous, not for profit promotes mutual understanding and enhances security and stability think tank which focuses primarily on strategic 1 in the region” . Exercise Malabar inevitably attracts much media issues of critical national interest. speculation about geopolitical realignments, strategic signalling and efforts at countering a rising China. How much of this is real and how In keeping with the growing dynamism of much imagined is to be seen. India’s foreign and security policy, the DPG is expanding its focus areas to include India’s broader regional and global role and the strategic First, the event itself. The scale in Malabar 2017 was impressive, with partnerships that advance India’s rise as a leading USN presence including USS Nimitz with the embarked Carrier Air power. To support that goal, the DPG undertakes Wing 11, the Ticonderoga class cruiser USS Princeton, three Arleigh research and organizes policy interactions across a Burke class Destroyers with their embarked helicopters (USS Howard, wide canvas, including strategic and geo-political Shoup and Kidd), one Los Angeles class nuclear submarine and one issues, geo-economic issues and defence and P8A LRMP aircraft.
[Show full text]
The Quad: an Emerging Multilateral Security Framework of Democracies in the Indo-Pacific Region
BRIEFING The Quad: An emerging multilateral security framework of democracies in the Indo-Pacific region SUMMARY The Indo-Pacific region houses the largest share of global GDP, the world's busiest trade routes, largest population and most powerful militaries. After having successfully worked side by side in coordinating the 2004 tsunami relief, in 2007 Australia, India, Japan and the US (the Quad, short for Quadrilateral Security Dialogue) held meetings with each other to discuss security-related issues, and their navies held a military exercise. Although the grouping ended its activities prematurely in 2008, China's growing assertiveness in the region prompted it to remain active in bilateral and trilateral cooperation on security issues. Meetings among senior officials resumed in November 2017 in Manila. In November 2020, the Quad navies held a major military exercise. The first Quad summit took place in March 2021. The grouping has emphasised that its goal is to maintain the liberal rules-based international order, which China seeks to undermine through a revisionist challenge of the status quo. Its efforts are not focused on creating institutions or military alliances, but rather, on generating gradual convergence of cooperation on multiple issues, including Covid-19, climate change, critical and emerging technologies, counterterrorism, cybersecurity and disaster recovery. Establishing further cooperation with other like-minded countries in the region and co-existing with ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) are among the Quad's future challenges. The EU is not a traditional security player in the Indo-Pacific; however, as the region is particularly relevant to its trade, it has a strong interest in avoiding disruption of the sea lanes.
[Show full text]
E 防衛2020 Ⅲ-2-3 .Indd
Strengthening and Expanding Cooperation in a Wide Range of Areas Section 3 Section 3 Strengthening and Expanding Cooperation in a Wide Range of Areas ❶ Creation of a Desirable Security Environment ● The NDPG provides that in order to create a desirable 2 Humanitarian Assistance/Disaster Relief security environment including maintaining and enhancing free and open maritime order, and with an eye on increasing The SDF has conducted activities in close cooperation with Japanese and U.S. presence in the Indo-Pacifi c region, Japan the United States and other participating countries through will conduct bilateral activities. activities pursuant to the former Anti-Terrorism Special Measures Act, and international disaster relief activities and Chapter international peacekeeping operations in the Philippines and 1 Maritime Security Haiti. 2 Both Japan and the United States have made efforts as Japan and the United States worked closely together at maritime nations to maintain and develop “open and stable local multilateral coordination centers to respond to the Alliance Japan-U.S. seas” according to fundamental rules such as securing typhoon disaster that hit the Philippines in November 2013. the freedom and safety of navigation, and the rule of law To respond to the outbreak of the Ebola virus disease, including peaceful dispute resolution based on international Japan started to dispatch liaison offi cers to the U.S. Africa law. Command in October 2014, coordinating efforts and For example, Japan and the United States have worked collecting information with relevant countries including the closely together in various multilateral maritime security United States, for close cooperation. cooperation frameworks with such countries as those along the sea lanes, including Proliferation Security Initiative (PSI) 3 Trilateral and Multilateral Training and Exercises maritime interdiction exercises.
[Show full text]