Doctor of Philosophy Riyaz Ahmad Kumar Professor Shugufta Shaheen
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Themes and Trends in Contemporary Indian Children’s Literature in English: A Critical Survey Thesis submitted for the award of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English By Riyaz Ahmad Kumar Under the Supervision of Professor Shugufta Shaheen Department of English School of Languages Linguistics and Indology MAULANA AZAD NATIONAL URDU UNIVERSITY Hyderabad-INDIA 2017 D E C L A R A T I O N I do hereby declare that this thesis entitled Themes and Trends in Contemporary Indian Children’s Literature in English: A Critical Survey is original research carried out by me. No part of this thesis was published, or submitted to any other University/Institution for the award of any Degree/Diploma. (Riyaz Ahmad Kumar) Place: Date: C E R T I F I C A T E This is to certify that the thesis entitled Themes and Trends in Contemporary Indian Children’s Literature in English: A Critical Survey, submitted for the award of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English, Department of English, School of Languages Linguistics and Indology, Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Hyderabad, is the result of the original research work carried out by Mr. Riyaz Ahmad Kumar under my supervision and to the best of my knowledge and belief, the work embodied in this thesis does not form part of any thesis/dissertation already submitted to any University/Institution for the award of any Degree/Diploma. Signature of Research Supervisor Dr. Shugufta Shaheen Dr. Shugufta Shaheen Head Department of English Prof. Naseemuddin Farees Dean School of Languages Linguistics and Indology (SLL&I) Place: Date: Contents Chapter 1: Defining Children’s Literature, History and Its Ambiguities 01- 67 Chapter 2: Journey through the Tradition and Genesis: Overview of Indian Children’s 68- 115 Literature in English Chapter 3: Contribution of Publishers to Indian Children’s Literature English 116- 142 Chapter 4: Themes and Trends in Children’s Literature in English in India 143- 317 4.1: Science through Children’s Literature 4.2: Eco-Consciousness and Contemporary Indian Children’s Literature 4.3: Gender Role, Representation of Girl Child and their Voices in Indian Children’s Literature in English 4.4: Mystery, Detective and Adventure Tales in Indian English Children’s Literature 4.5: Bibliotherapy: Children’s books in India Chapter 5: Conclusion 318- 345 Bibliography 346-351 DEDICATED TO My Parents A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T First of all I owe my thanks to Almighty Allah for sustaining me all these years. This thesis would not have been possible without the poise and contentment granted to me by His blessings. I owe my thanks to my parents Gh. Hassan & Jana Begam for their support in the entire journey of my life. I thank them for allowing me to be myself I owe my thanks to my supervisor Dr. Shugufta Shaheen for the work I have done and for guiding me in accomplishing this task. I owe a lot of gratitude to her for always being I thank Prof. Syed Mohammed Haseebuddin Quadri for his guidance since my arrival here. Thanks to the entire Department of English for being cooperative. I thank my brother Mohd Amin and sister-in-law Hafeez-un-Nisa. Thanks to my late Grand-father Haji Maqsood Kumar who considered me his entire world. He would have been the happiest person today. I thank Huzaif Amin and Aiman Amin, my nephew and niece for all the happiness around my home. Special thanks to Shahzada for her special kindness, care and affection towards me. You have been a smile in the times of my distress. I thank my awe-inspiring friends and roommates Imtiyaz Ahmad Wani and Tajamul Islam for all their support, fun and cooperation, and I also thank them for providing me a conducive environment to study in our room with feasible atmosphere. I thank Bilal Ahmad Kumar, Muzamil Ahmad Baba, Fouzia Afaq and Showkat Ahanger for always extending their support, encouragement, and assistance in the times of need. I thank them for always enquiring and appreciating my work. My thanks also go to Kirit Bhavsar Sir from Ahmadabad and Rekha Garg from Haryana for their help in my research. I also thank to friends here in MANUU, Altaf Lone, Zaffar Abdullah, Mir Showkat, Masrook Dar, Tehwar Iqbal, Gulzar Wani, Anayat Shah, Waseem Paray, Pir Jaleel, Rizwan Wani, Mudasir, Imtiyaz, Hilal, Nisar, who always remained with me. Finally I thank my senior and adorable friend Shouket Ahmad Tilwani for editing my bibliography from overseas, a help that will always be remembered. Thanks to my entire University and its central Library for providing me an opportunity to study here. It has been a rewarding experience for me. Thank you all!!!!! Kumar 1 Chapter 1 Defining Children’s Literature, History and its Ambiguities Children’s literature is confronted with the difficulty of working definitions. Therefore, the starting point of this stage must be the drawing of some margins and the lining and connecting of individual terms with concepts. At the outset let us define, child, childhood, children’s literature in the broader perspective. B. Mayall writes, “Both textually and semiotically, ‘child’ is very much a floating signifier – one whose mundane usage is so seemingly ubiquitous that it invites little if any critical introspection and elides the inherent complexity and diversity of childhoods, whether in conceptual formulation or as lived experiences” (qtd in Beier 4). Defining Children’s Literature The 'literature' of 'children’s literature' is a distinct thought, which is miscellaneous from any other form of 'literature' written for other groups of readers. Children’s literature is an educational discipline. It is not easy to define what Children’s Literature is, because there is a lot of mixed up thinking and discussions concerning Children’s Literature. According to Roger Sale ‘‘Everyone knows what children’s literature is until asked to define it. We are better of saying we all have a pretty good idea of what children’s literature includes and letting the matter rest there’’ (155). Loosely defined, in the term ‘Children’s Literature’ the word ‘children’ is generally used to designate for teenagers under the age of adolescence, while the additional word that is ‘literature’ indicates a piece of writing having finesse of form. So this literature belongs to children and meant for their use. The term is commonly used for the sort of literature which is of attention to children and draws them towards it. Additionally this writing some at times comes with illustration, particularly written for young people. Children’s Kumar 2 Literature is defined as, writes Karin Lesnik- Oberstain, “a category of books the existence of which absolutely depends supposed relationship with a particular reading audience: children” (15). In some way or other Children’s Literature is an ambiguous term, and most of the critics are of the view that the genre is not homogeneous and it has not been defined precisely and accurately. The main argument here is that of the position of child in children’s literature. The ambiguity lies in, according to Anne-Kathrin Höfel Who exactly can be designated by this term? What are the characteristics of the members of this group? How and where can we draw a line between “child”, “young adult” and “adult”? What if there is no clear-cut difference? All these problems have immediate repercussions on the next key term, “children’s literature”. Which area is covered by “children’s literature” if the construct “child” itself might not be too stable an entity? In which respect then, if at all, does “children’s literature” differ from that for “young adults” and “adults”, and why? (17). The ambiguity is defined by Saunak Samajdar in the chapter, ‘Homely Children and Unhomely Literature’ The mode of literary praxes, including the writing, reading, misreading, circulation, reception, promotion, censor, mediation, canon-formation and criticism, that focuses upon the texts, inter-texts and peri texts that pass through hypothetical, targeted, and/or actual" child-readers is broadly identified as the domain of "children's literature (1). Kumar 3 Peter Hunt Comments, “Children's literature is an amorphous, ambiguous creature; its relationship to its audience is difficult; its relationship to the rest of the literature, problematic” (“Introduction” 1). Scholars in the field of Children’s Literature cannot even concur on when or where Children’s Literature was coined. Torben Weinreich says, it (Children’s Literature) is ‘‘an area of research and an endless debate that is as old as research into children’s literature itself. It is both the simplest and the most complex question we can ask: What is children’s literature? The answers to this question are many and various. There are not quite as many answers as there are researchers, but it is a close call.’’ (qtd. in Nodelman 136). There is a great deal of discussion as to whether there was a Children’s Literature in the medieval period. Undoubtedly it is clear that once the printing press was invented in the 15th century, some texts and books were published exclusively for children even if the books were mostly geared to educate the children and transfer them into literate citizens of a particular culture. Perry Nodelman writes Obviously, I don’t agree. I believe that the term children’s literature creates confusion because children’s literature as a genre is confusing—richly and complicatedly so. The confusions make the genre seem impossible only with the assumption that the differing definitions must be mutually exclusive and that one must be right in ways that makes the others wrong, which makes them all mutually defeating.