Introduction 1 Introduction Mesoamericanist And

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Introduction 1 Introduction Mesoamericanist And introduction 1 IntroductIon Mesoamericanist and historian of religions, davíd carrasco, has comment- ed upon the paradox that whereas history of religions and anthropology have recognised the importance of analysing ritual practice in order to understand culture, this emphasis has not been appreciated—with some exceptions—in the same way in Mesoamerican studies (carrasco 2002: 277-278). one of the most fascinating aspects of the civilisations in Mesoamerica is the concept of time and the many calendars. In their sophisticated writ- ing (so-called hieroglyphic or more correctly logosyllabic), narrative visual (including logograms) aka pictorial, semiotic, symbolic and icono- graphic systems, Mesoamerican civilisations recorded several calendars (i.e. a organised computed number of time units and/or of time) founded upon meticulous astronomical observations and mathematical epistemol- ogy. the organised and systematised (calendar) time was and is today sub- jected to particular ritual practices, of which I characterise by the analytical category: “ritual practice of time”. A comprehensive systematic investigation—by the use of methodology and theories from the discipline of history of religions—of the ritual practice of time of the Mesoamerican calendar systems has, however, so far not been executed. there are a quite a few publications about Mesoamerican calendars but many of these are not relevant to the present subject matter, which relate to an analysis of the ritualisation of (calendar) time.1 I therefore call attention to that the central topic of the book is not an analysis of Mesoamerican calendars or time per se but of the different ritual practices of calendar time. the general theory is that calendar time, like any cultural and social element becomes philosophically meaningful because it is practiced. time is given a particular significance not because it is measured but because time is practiced in certain rituals. or, alternately, time is effectively mea- sured through the ritual practice.2 the theoretical and empirical objective 1 cf. for instance: Aveni (1980; 1989); Boone (2007); Bricker and Vail (1997); Broda (1997); Brotherson (1982); Malmström (1997); Milbrath (1999); Paxton (2001); read (1999); rice (2004; 2007); ruggles and urton (2007); Vail (1989; 2002); Vail and Aveni (2004); Vail and Bricker (1998); Vail and Hernández (2007; 2010); Van Stone (2011). 2 davíd carrasco has inspired this formulation. 2 introduction of this book is to investigate and analyse the ritual practice of time of cer- tain calendars observed by a selection of cultures in Mesoamerica. In this way, it is my aspiration to contribute not only to the theory and methodol- ogy of ritual studies in general but to enhance the knowledge of Meso- american ritual temporal practices, religion, and in addition it’s various social, political and intellectual systems.3 I commence by making some essential definitions. Mesoamerica and Ritual Calendars of Time despite the numerous particular traditions and languages, the people of Mesoamerica had several cultural and religious traits in common. Meso- america has been defined as a cultural-geographical region incorporating northwestern, central and southern Mexico, Guatemala, Belize, and the western part of Honduras, El Salvador and nicaragua. In this area various cultures—for instance: Maya, nahua (Aztec), olmec, Zapotec, toltec, tlapanec, teotihuacano, tarasco, otomí, Mixtec etc.—lived in advanced civilisations before the European arrival, i.e. c. 1000 BC – 1521 AD (fig. 1).4 contacts existed between the different Mesoamerican cultures through migrations, pilgrimage, trade, diplomacy, war, tribute and conquest. to some extent, the Mesoamericans shared principles of writing and narrative visual systems, which were for instance employed in screenfold books, called codices by contemporary scholars. Many civilisations had a ball game, monumental architecture, certain religious symbols, deities, rituals and stories in common. What interest us here is that several Mesoamericans cultures, apart from a vigesimal counting system, also had quite a few calendars in common— in particular a 260-day calendar and a 365-day calendar, which together is permutated into a 52-year calendar cycle called the calendar round.5 the civilisations of Mesoamerica represent an especially interesting case in 3 Important note to the reader: the present book is about half the length of the original doctoral dissertation (2006)—where due to the size some empirical data, overview informa- tion and illustrations have to be left out. on the other hand, the manuscript of the doctoral dissertation has been revised and updated. 4 Paul Kirchoff originally outlined Mesoamerica as a cultural and geographical unity (Kirchoff 1943). other definitions of this region have been suggested as well (cf. carrasco 2001: ix,. xiii). 5 cf. Prudence M. rice about various theories of the origin of calendars in Mesoamer- ica (rice 2007)..
Recommended publications
  • The Codex Mexicanus: a Guide to Life in Late Sixteenth-Century New Spain'
    H-LatAm DiCesare on Diel, 'The Codex Mexicanus: A Guide to Life in Late Sixteenth-Century New Spain' Review published on Friday, April 17, 2020 Lori Boornazian Diel. The Codex Mexicanus: A Guide to Life in Late Sixteenth-Century New Spain. Austin: University of Texas Press, 2018. Illustrations. x + 216 pp. $55.00 (cloth), ISBN 978-1-4773-1673-3. Reviewed by Catherine DiCesare (Colorado State University) Published on H-LatAm (April, 2020) Commissioned by Casey M. Lurtz (Johns Hopkins University) Printable Version: http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=54507 Lori Boornazian Diel’s recent study of the colonial book known as the Codex Mexicanus is a welcome addition to the literature on sixteenth-century manuscripts from central Mexico. Nahua intellectuals created the Codex Mexicanus in Mexico City in the last quarter of the sixteenth century. It is part of a large corpus of pictorial manuscripts created in the century following Spanish incursion, a compendium of information of special interest to the indigenous inhabitants of New Spain. The manuscript is a bound codex painted on native bark paper. Its format draws on both Aztec pictorial writing systems and European alphabetic text and images. The Codex Mexicanus is a valuable resource for scholars studying pre-Columbian and early colonial Mexico because it contains a wide variety of information. Its contents range from calendrical matters to astrology, beliefs about the natural world, the ancient lineage of Mexica rulers, and the history of the Mexica from their pre- Columbian migration to the arrival of Spaniards and Christianity. However, as Diel notes in the introduction (chapter 1), because of the seemingly disparate nature of its contents, scholars have not generally investigated the Codex Mexicanus in its entirety.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Book of Mormon Chronology
    Understanding Book of Mormon Chronology Alan C. Miner (Updated May, 2020) Contents 1. The Problems p. 1-10 2. The Theories p. 11-38 3. The Sources p. 39-68 1. The Problems Contrary to what might be assumed by reading a “historical” book with the year seemingly footnoted on almost every page, the process of affixing dates to the events in the Book of Mormon, correlating those dates with known historical calendars, and establishing a compatible chronological record is an extremely complex process that hasn’t yet led to a consensus solution. Rather, this complexity has resulted in various different theoretical interpretations. My goal with this paper is not to decide who is right and who is wrong; my goal is to simply lay out the basic reasoning as I see it that supports these theories, list the sources that support the theory, provide a corresponding chronological list of events, and then ask some basic questions that have come into my mind as I have tried to assimilate the reasoning. I don’t claim to be an astronomer, or an expert on calendars, or an expert in biblical history, or a shrewd analyst that can detect every flaw in these theories. I am just seeking to go forward in my studies of the Book of Mormon and make sense of some of the complexities within the text. In other words, I am just seeking some clarification of the Book of Mormon story, not only for myself, but for those who might read this paper. To me it stands to reason that the more I (or we) establish historical correlation with some of the major events and some of the major prophecies in the Book of Mormon, the more significant the gospel message becomes.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Abstracts
    Abstracts for the Annual SECAC Conference Host Institution: Virginia Commonwealth University Convened Virtually November 30th - December 11th, 2020 Conference Chair: Carly Phinizy, Virginia Commonwealth University Hallie Abelman, University of Iowa The Home Lives of Animal Objects Ducks give pause to the DeafBlind poet John Lee Clark, who encounters them in rubber, stone, and wood while scanning aisles of gift shops and flea markets. Always perplexed by their flat bottoms, Clark notes how this perplexing design decision maintains visual (over tactile) privilege. The portal opened by this reflection exemplifies the precise intersection of animals, material culture, and disability driving Abelman’s performance-lecture at SECAC2020. Abelman treats each animal object she encounters as a prop and every mundane interaction with it as a performance, so Abelman demonstrates how the performativity of these obJects can elicit necessary humor, irony, and satire often missing from mainstream environmentalist narratives. Be they tchotchkes, souvenirs, commodities, or toys, each of these obJects has a culturally specific relationship to the species it portrays, a unique material makeup, and a history of being touched by human hands. Attending to the social construction of these realities aids an essential reconciliation between commodified animals and real animal livelihoods. Overall, the audience gains a better sense of how animal obJects can not only misrepresent a species but also contribute to that very species’s demise, be instrumentalized for the perpetuation of racist ideologies, and mobilize ableist fears. Rachel Allen, University of Delaware Nocturnes without Sky (World): FreDeric Remington Pushes Indigenous Cosmologies Out of the Frame This paper examines Frederic Remington’s (American, 1861–1909) The Gossips (1909) and the impact of his final paintings on Indigenous people and our cosmologies.
    [Show full text]
  • The Correlation Between the Colonial Northern Zapotec and Gregorian Calendars
    C H A P T E R O N E JOHN JUSTESON A N D DAVID TAVÁREZ The Correlation between the Colonial Northern Zapotec and Gregorian Calendars INTRODUCTION This paper provides evidence for the correlation between dates in the Gregorian calendar and dates in the Zapotec calendar, as it was in the northern Sierra of Oaxaca near the end of the seventeenth century.1 It concerns specifically the correlation of two calendrical cycles that are not only found in the Zapotec calendar system but that are widely distributed in Mesoamerica: the 260-day ritual calendar and the 365-day calendar (the VAGUE YEAR). Based on the data provided by Córdova (1578a: 204–212), the sixteenth- century Zapotec ritual calendar can be seen as a permutation of two inde- pendent cycles, each of which advances once a day: a thirteen-day cycle (the TRECENA, referred to by Córdova as the cocii¯), whose successive days are named by successive numerals from 1 to 13; and a twenty-day cycle (the VEIN- TENA), whose successive days are named by a fixed sequence of roots, mostly of 17 JOHN JUSTESON AND DAVID TAVÁREZ TABLE 1.1. Colonial Zapotec day names, mostly as extracted by Kaufman (2000a) from Córdova (1578a), and from calendars reported by Alcina Franch (1993) for the Villa Alta and Choapan regions of Northern Zapotec. Capital E transcribes a letter that appears sometimes as e¯ and sometimes as I¯; EE is for ee¯ varying with ii¯. The symbol = joins the compounded units within a compound word. Meanings are due to Kaufman, informed by Urcid (1992, 2001).
    [Show full text]
  • The Dark Room Collective Kindling a Literary Movement Move Forward
    Animal Law • Musical Theater • The Eugenics Era March-april 2016 • $4.95 The Dark Room Collective Kindling a literary movement Move forward. With confi dence. No matter how complex your business questions, we have the capabilities and experience to deliver the answers you need to move forward. As the world’s largest consulting fi rm, we can help you take decisive action and achieve sustainable results. www.deloitte.com/confi dence Audit | Tax | Consulting | Advisory Copyright © 2016 Deloitte Development LLC. All rights reserved. 160307_Deloitte_ivy.indd 1 1/15/16 11:59 AM MARCH-APRIL 2016 VOLUME 118, NUMBER 4 FEATURES 32 Elbow Room | by Sophia Nguyen The Dark Room Collective and a generation of African-American writers 40 Are Animals “Things”? | by Cara Feinberg p. 16 The evolving law of animal welfare—and rights 46 Vita: Caleb Strong | by Richard D. Brown Brief life of an exemplary politician: 1745-1819 48 Harvard’s Eugenics Era | by Adam Cohen When the academy embraced scientific racism, immigration restriction, forced sterilization, and suppression of “the unfit” JOHN HARVard’s JournAL 16 The Kennedy School’s crane, debating diversity and inclusion, laugh-out-loud computer scientist, the crew on ice, an Overseers’ challenge slate, augmenting the Corpora- tion’s academic ranks, “flyover-state” students, netminder from Alberta, and an up-and-down season for men’s basketball p. 40 DEPARTMENTS 2 Cambridge 02138 | Letters from our readers—and comments on the College’s curricular challenges 3 The View from Mass Hall AVILLA 8 | Scarcity and
    [Show full text]
  • To Print the September at Penn Calendar
    based artists; reception: 5 p.m.; Esther di tion; Af ri ca: The Cra dle of Hu man kind; ACADEMIC CALENDAR Klein Gallery. Through October 28. Polynesia: ʻahuʼula + lei niho palaoa. 6 New Student Convocation and 10 Veraʼs Room; painting and sculpture Museum Tours Opening Exercises. from British visual artist Maria Chevska; Meet at Trescher Main Entrance; 1:30 reception: October 8, 6:30 p.m.; Slought p.m.; free with Museum admission dona- 7 First Day of Classes. Foundation. Through October 22. September tion; info.: www.museum.upenn.edu. 23 Course Selection Period Ends. Comicology: The New Magical Real; comic artwork by Charles Burns, Marc 17 Egypt: Deciphering the Hiero- CHILDRENʼS ACTIVITIES Bell, Anders Nilsen and others; reception: glyphs. September 24, 6:30 p.m.; Slought Foun- 18 Highlights of the Collection. A T P E N N 10 Childrenʼs Gymnastics Classes; dation. Through October 22. 24 Etruscan/Roman: Variety in Votive Whenever there is more than meets the eye, boys and girls ages 5-12; session I: 9- Paper Architecture/Architecture de Offerings. see our website, www.upenn.edu/al ma nac/. 10:30 a.m.; session II: 10:30 a.m.-noon; Papier; a dialog through working draw- Hutchinson Gym; $175/session; info.: ings featuring Marjorie Welish and Oliver 25 Ravenʼs Journey: Alaskaʼs Native (215) 898-5316; register by September Gourvil; reception: September 24, 6:30 People. 8. Sessions continue every Saturday p.m.; Slought Foundation. Through Octo- through November 12 (Athletics). ber 22. FILMS Peanut Butter and Jams Rodney Graham: A Little Thought; fi lm, video and sound works spanning a International House Music for children at World Cafe Live; Screenings w/English subtitles.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sacred Calendar Among the Ayöök People of Oaxaca, Mexico Indiana, Vol
    Indiana ISSN: 0341-8642 [email protected] Ibero-Amerikanisches Institut Preußischer Kulturbesitz Alemania Rojas, Araceli Time and Wisdom: A Sacred Calendar Among the Ayöök People of Oaxaca, Mexico Indiana, vol. 30, 2013, pp. 219-245 Ibero-Amerikanisches Institut Preußischer Kulturbesitz Berlin, Alemania Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=247029853012 How to cite Complete issue Scientific Information System More information about this article Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal Journal's homepage in redalyc.org Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative Time and Wisdom: A Sacred Calendar Among the Ayöök People of Oaxaca, Mexico Araceli Rojas Universiteit Leiden, Netherlands Abstract: The calendar of 260 days, made up of the combination of 20 signs and 13 num- bers, was one of the essential traits of ancient Mesoamerican civilizations. Interestingly, this calendar system persists in some contemporary communities in Mexico and Guatemala, where it is still utilized by daykeepers, also experts in ritual, divination and medicine. The present article offers a brief documentation of one of these calendars, among the Ayöök (Mixe) people of Oaxaca, Mexico. Derived from this, an analytical view is offered to provide a better understanding of its function and social significance. This work attempts to shed light on the study of Mesoamerican calendars as well as to approach the calendrical and mantic pictorial manuscripts of the Teoamoxtli (Borgia) Group. Keywords: Mesoamerican calendars, Ayöök, Mixe, ritual, codices, Mexico, Guatemala. Resumen: El calendario de 260 días, formado por la combinación de 20 signos y 13 núme- ros, fue uno de los rasgos esenciales de las antiguas civilizaciones de Mesoamérica.
    [Show full text]
  • Graduate School of Arts and Sciences 2016–2017
    BULLETIN OF YALE UNIVERSITY BULLETIN OF YALE BULLETIN OF YALE UNIVERSITY Periodicals postage paid New Haven ct 06520-8227 New Haven, Connecticut Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Programs and Policies 2016–2017 Graduate School ofGraduate Arts and Sciences 2016 –2017 BULLETIN OF YALE UNIVERSITY Series 112 Number 5 July 15, 2016 BULLETIN OF YALE UNIVERSITY Series 112 Number 5 July 15, 2016 (USPS 078-500) The University is committed to basing judgments concerning the admission, education, is published seventeen times a year (one time in May and October; three times in June and employment of individuals upon their qualifications and abilities and a∞rmatively and September; four times in July; five times in August) by Yale University, 2 Whitney seeks to attract to its faculty, sta≠, and student body qualified persons of diverse back- Avenue, New Haven CT 0651o. Periodicals postage paid at New Haven, Connecticut. grounds. In accordance with this policy and as delineated by federal and Connecticut law, Yale does not discriminate in admissions, educational programs, or employment against Postmaster: Send address changes to Bulletin of Yale University, any individual on account of that individual’s sex, race, color, religion, age, disability, PO Box 208227, New Haven CT 06520-8227 status as a protected veteran, or national or ethnic origin; nor does Yale discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity or expression. Managing Editor: Kimberly M. Go≠-Crews University policy is committed to a∞rmative action under law in employment of Editor: Lesley K. Baier women, minority group members, individuals with disabilities, and protected veterans.
    [Show full text]
  • Tiie Calendar of the Loxicha Villages: the Culture History of a Present-Day Mesoamerican Ceremonial Almanac
    TIIE CALENDAR OF THE LOXICHA VILLAGES: THE CULTURE HISTORY OF A PRESENT-DAY MESOAMERICAN CEREMONIAL ALMANAC by Charles W. Markman A Thesis submitted to the faculty of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Department of Anthropology Chapel Hill 1971 Approved by: Reader Reader ABSTRACT A Precolumbian ceremonial calendar recently discovered to be in use among the inhabitants of the Loxicha villages of southern Oaxaca differs in some important aspects from all previously known indigenous calendars of Mesoamerica and represents the survival of an early form of the calen­ dar in general use in Mesoamerica before the conquest. Table of Contents Preface I. Introduction 1 II. The Loxicha Calendar 4 I I I. A Comparison with the Tonalpohualli .... .. 7 IV. A Comparison with the Maya Sacred Almanacs 11 v. A Comparison with the Zapotec Piye ....... 13 VI. The Origin of the 260-Day Cycle .......... 15 VI I. The Archeological Record 19 VIII. The Ethnographic Record 23 IX. Summary and Conclusion 25 Appendix I and Table I 30 Appendix II 33 References ....................................... 43 Figure 1 48 Figure 2 53 Preface In the spring of 1954 Professor Robert Weitlaner arrive<l in the southern Oaxaca village of San Agustin Loxicha. Witl1 the aid of his assistants, Donald Brockington and Gabriel De Cicco, he gathered information on a 260-day ceremonial calen­ dar that had been reported by Moises de la Pefia (1950) to have been in use in San Agustin and several surrounding ham­ lets of the Loxicha region (Weitlaner 1956).
    [Show full text]
  • New Perspectives in Cultural Astronomy
    Contents Foreword—Davíd Carrasco ix Preface—Clive Ruggles and Gary Urton xiii A Partner’s Perspective—Lorraine Aveni xvii Acknowledgments xxi Editors’ Note xxiii Introduction—Clive Ruggles and Gary Urton 1 1. The Correlation between the Colonial Northern Zapotec and Gregorian Calendars—John Justeson and David Tavárez 17 vii PCREFACEONTENTS 2. Kirchhoff’s Correlations and the Third Part of the Codex Borbonicus—Edward E. Calnek 83 3. When Was the Dresden Codex Venus Table Efficacious?—Harvey M. Bricker and Victoria R. Bricker 95 4. Moon Woman Meets the Stars: A New Reading of the Lunar Almanacs in the Dresden Codex—Dennis Tedlock and Barbara Tedlock 121 5. Astronomical Cycles in the Imagery of Codex Borgia 29–46—Susan Milbrath 157 6. The Measure of Man—Clemency Coggins 209 7. A Multi-Year Tukapu Calendar—Gary Urton 245 8. Solar and Lunar Observations in the Inca Calendar—R. Tom Zuidema 269 9. Cosmology, Calendar, and Temple Orientations in Ancient Hawai‘i—Clive Ruggles 287 10. Calendrical Cycles, the Eighth Day of the World, and the Orientation of English Churches—Stephen C. McCluskey 331 11. High Fashion—Edwin C. Krupp 355 Contributors 375 Index 377 viii CLIVE RUGGLES AND GARY UrTON Introduction In the twenty-first century, it is possible to consider archaeoastronomy one of fifty “key concepts” in the development of archaeological thinking and method (Renfrew and Bahn 2005). This is a long way indeed from the posi- tion in the 960s and 970s, when exploring the associations between ancient monumental architecture and objects and events in the skies was largely the preserve of professional and amateur astronomers, undertaken mainly as an entertaining sideline and producing conclusions that were treated with incre- dulity (and often derision) by all but a handful of mainstream archaeologists (see Kintigh 992; Aveni 992).
    [Show full text]
  • A Sacred Calendar Among the Ayöök People of Oaxaca, Mexico
    Time and Wisdom: A Sacred Calendar Among the Ayöök People of Oaxaca, Mexico Araceli Rojas Universiteit Leiden, Netherlands Abstract: The calendar of 260 days, made up of the combination of 20 signs and 13 num- bers, was one of the essential traits of ancient Mesoamerican civilizations. Interestingly, this calendar system persists in some contemporary communities in Mexico and Guatemala, where it is still utilized by daykeepers, also experts in ritual, divination and medicine. The present article offers a brief documentation of one of these calendars, among the Ayöök (Mixe) people of Oaxaca, Mexico. Derived from this, an analytical view is offered to provide a better understanding of its function and social significance. This work attempts to shed light on the study of Mesoamerican calendars as well as to approach the calendrical and mantic pictorial manuscripts of the Teoamoxtli (Borgia) Group. Keywords: Mesoamerican calendars, Ayöök, Mixe, ritual, codices, Mexico, Guatemala. Resumen: El calendario de 260 días, formado por la combinación de 20 signos y 13 núme- ros, fue uno de los rasgos esenciales de las antiguas civilizaciones de Mesoamérica. Intere- santemente, este sistema calendárico persiste en algunas comunidades contemporáneas de México y Guatemala donde aún es utilizado por daykeepers, también expertos en ritual, adivi- nación y medicina. El presente artículo ofrece una breve documentación sobre uno de estos calendarios, entre los ayöök (mixe) de Oaxaca, México. De ello se desprende un punto de vista analítico que ofrece un mejor entendimiento acerca de su función y significación social. Este trabajo intenta contribuir al estudio de calendarios mesoamericanos así como brindar un acercamiento a los manuscritos calendáricos y mánticos del Grupo Teoamoxtli (Borgia).
    [Show full text]
  • Mariana Castillo Deball: Petlacoatl, 2018
    Mariana Castillo_ Deball 6 | arts.uchicago.eduPETLACOATL Mariana Castillo Deball: Petlacoatl, 2018. Installation view in the Logan Center Gallery. Photo: Robert Chase Heishman Mariana Castillo Deball, Fall 2018 Tinker Visiting Professor in the Department of Visual Arts, explores representations of cultures through material artifacts. The artist’s research- based practice draws on a range of fields that include anthropology, archeology, and ethnography. In considering how cultural objects are staged, mediated, and valorized in the present, the artist creates a thoughtful dialogue between our contemporary moment and ancient history. Deball has titled her first solo exhibition in Chicago Petlacoatl, taken from the Nahua word meaning “mat woven of snakes pointing in all directions.” by Clare Austen-Smith arts.uchicago.edu | 7 each colorful arm stands in for one of the cardinal directions: red for the east, yellow for the north, blue for the west, and green for the south. In addition to measuring time, the tōnalpōhualli was a divinatory system in which spatial coordinates, agriculture, and ritual sacrifices intersected. It carried augural messages, defining the way people conducted their affairs. The work in Deball’s exhibition at the Logan Center Gallery responds to these various uses of the calendar and engages the viewer’s space . A new suite of delicate watercolor drawings adorns the walls while modular concrete tiles and plaster sculptures are placed throughout the exhibition. In addition to responding to the iconography, visual schema, and color of the calendar in her drawings and floor sculptures, the days of the week are represented by 13 perforations along 20 extruded aluminum strips that criss-cross the gallery.
    [Show full text]