DOCSLIB.ORG

~0T L('11 O )Ff'&Tu Jjww

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
~0T L('11 O )Ff'&Tu Jjww 1 _ Introduction In Search of Freaks ~0t o l('11 )ff'&tu jJww: r -for H~~(' oJcL'f &5 ~+ I o(V\ V\ lL ) fro f-I't. lA", vUr'r'+J 01 OTIS JORDAN, a man with poorly functioning and lIndelfornlPd limh~ who is helter known in tilt' carnival world as "Olisthe Frog Man." C ~\ LR-Y Pre) was banned in 1984 from appearing as part of the Sulton Side­ show at the New York State Fnir. A voral citizen had ohjecteo. calling the exhibition of people with deformities an "intolerable anachronism." The protester contendeothat handicapped people were being exploited and that tlw state's fair funos could he put to better lise by helping people with disahilities instead of nwking them freaks. As a result of the complaint. and in spilf' of .Ionian's ubjel'­ tions, Sulton's "Incredible Wanoprs of the World" was moved from the heart of the midway. wlwre husiness and visibility' were best, to the back of the fair. The showmen were asked not to use the terrn freak or allow perfonnances of I)('ople like Otis lorrlan. people the puhlic would consider disabled (Kaleina 19841. I On September 8, 1984, the Associated Press released a story ("City to Cite" 1984) about a committee formed in Alton, illi­ nois, to erect a statue in honor of Robert Wadlow, a local boy who had reached the height uf eight f'<>ct eleven inches beforl:' his death in 1940 at the age of twenty-two. Wadlow had appeared in the circlIs in the 19:30s and. u;;ing Ihe novell)' of his height. had gotten a job promoting shoes at stores throughout the United Slales (Fadner 1944). But a committee spokesperson wanted to clarify: "He was not a circus freak as a lot of people might think. He was an intelligent. caring man." During the past twenty years numerous intellectuals and art­ ists have confronted us with freaks. l Yet the frequent mention and coffee-table display of art-photography books, which in­ '.;J clude pieturps taken at freak shows. are no indication that freak IJl shows are now accepted. Hat her. as tlw work of Diane Arbus personifies, "freak" has become a metaphor for estrangement, aliena­ show's famous manager, spotted Earle in the audience; after the show tion, marginality, the dark side of the human experience (Arbus 1972; he approached the young man to ask. "How would you like to be a Sontag 1977). Indeed, Arbus's biographer suggests that her flirtation giant?" (Fig. 1). with freaks was but one dimension of her odyssey through the bowels While it is uncertain how much of this story changed on becoming of society-her suicide being the last stop on the trip (Bosworth 1984). incorporated into circus lore, it clarifies a point that freak show per­ Otis Jordan and the spokesperson for Robert Wadlow's statue com­ sonnel understood but outside observers neglect: being extremely tall mittee remind us of what we all sense when we hear the word freak is a matter of physiology-being a giant involves something more. and think of "freak shows." Seen by many as crude, rude, and ex­ Similarly, being a freak is not a personal matter, a physical condition ploitive, the freak show is despicable, a practice on the margin, lim­ that some people have (Coffman 1963; Becker 1963). The onstage ited to a class with poor taste, representing, as one disability rights freak is something else off stage. "Freak" is a frame of mind, a set of activist put it, the "pornography of disability."3 practices, a way of thinking about and presenting people. 7 It is the Although freak shows are now on the contemptible fringe, from ap­ enactment of a tradition, the performance of a stylized presentation. proximately 1840 through 1940 the formally organized exhibition for While people called "freaks" will be included in this discussion, amusement and profit of people with physical, mental, or behavioral the people themselves are not of primary concern. Rather, the focus anomalies, both alleged and real, was an accepted part of American is on the social arrangements in which they found themselves, the life. Hundreds of freak shows traversed America in the last quarter of place and meaning of the freak show in the world of which they were a the nineteenth and first quarter of the twentieth centuries. Yet only part, and the way the resulting exhibits were presented to the public. five exist today,4 and their continued existence is precarious. Per­ The social construction-the manufacture of freaks-is the main sonnel, plagued by low-priced admissions, poor attendance, and at­ allraction. tacks from indignant activitisls, cannot tell from week to week whether But don't leave! There will be exhibits (and it will be okay to look!). they can last the season. Barely alive, the freak show is approaching For we need examples-flesh on the bones of institutional analysis. its finale. We need to understand what it was like to participate in the freak Given the tradition of the study of deviance and abnormality, one show and what meanings emerged to make the enterprise coherent to would expect a large body of social scientific literature on freak the exhibits, the promoters, and the audience alike. shows. There is none. S The low status of the convention, combined with the decline in the number of such businesses. llIay explain this VOCABULARY lack in part. In addition, until the relatively recent interest in the Many terms have been' used to refer to lhe practice of exhibiting natural history of social problems (Conrad and Schneider 1980: Spec­ people for money and to the various forms that such exhibits took. tor and Kitsuse 1977), social scientists interested in deviance seldom "Raree Show" and "Hall of Human Curiosities" were early-nineleenth­ turned to the past for their data (see Erikson 1966 and Mjzruchi 1983 century terms. "Sideshow," "Ten in One," "Kid Show," "Pitshow," cil~- for exceptionsl. Thus freak shows have remained in the hands of "'Odditorium,'" uConl';ress of Oddilies ...... HCongress of Human Won­ ellS buffs and afew nonconformists in the humanities. Ibelieve, how­ ders," "Museum of Nature's Mistakes," ''freak Show," and a host of ever, that these displays of human beings present an exciting op­ variations on these titles were late-nineteenth- and twentieth-century portunity to develop understanding of past practices and changing designations. conceptions of abnormality, as well as the beginnings of a grounded A broad range of terms were applied to the peopte exhibited, the theory in the management of human differences. freaks. Because natural scientists and physicians were interested in many exhibits, and because showmen exploited scientific interest in The Social Construction of Freaks constructing freaks, the lexicon is a complex hodgepodge of medical In the mid 1920s, Jack Earle, a very tall University of Texas student, terminology and show-world hype. The more recent proliferation of visited the Ringling Brothers circus sideshow. 6 Clyde Ingalls, the euphemisms generated by the freak show's decline in popularity and 'J-) 00 Q\ 2 INTRODUCTION IN SEARCH OF FREAKS .~ FIG. 1. Jack Earle in the Rin~ling Brolhers. Barnum and Bailey Sideshow. Earle is in the top row, third from the right, wearing atall hat and military outfit. Other well· known exhibits in lilt' picture include the Doll Family, Koo-Koo the Bird Girl, Clicko Ihe Bushman, and Ik" and Eko. Photo hy Cenlury, c. 19:H·. (Hertzberg Coil., Sail Antonio Public Libral") ,~ 00 4 INTRODUCTION s 'J IN SEARCH OF FREAKS the moral indignation surronnrling the exhibition of human anomalies ticular exhibit actually represented a new species or was simply a creates a long list of imprecise terms. 8 "Curiosities," "lusus naturae," Illsus naturae. "freaks of nature," "rarities," "oddities," "eccentrics," "wonders," In the last quarter of the ninet('enth century the blurr('d distinction "marvels," "nature's mistakes," "strange people," "prodigies," "mon­ between species and freaks of nature became moot: all human ex­ slers,"9 "very special people," and "freaks" form a partial list. The hibits, including tribal people of normal stature and body configura­ exact use and definition of these words varies from user to user and tion, as well as people who performed unusual feats ;;uch as swallow­ from time to time. They do not, however, all mean the same thing; ing swords, fell under the generic term freak. indeed, some have very exact meanings when used by particular Those twenlieth-century authors who have wrillen about the side­ peopJe. The terminology wi" be clarified as this discussion proceeds. show, mainly popular historians and humanities scholars. address the question "What were the various kinds of human freaks'?" by concen­ TYPES OF FREAKS trating on the physical characteristics of exhibits with anomalies What were the various kinds of human freaks? In discussions of hu­ (Drimmer 1973; Durant and Durant 1957; Fiedler 1978; Howard man oddities in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, there devel­ 1977). Their books and articles are organized like medical or special oped an important and revealing, albeit blurry and noninclnsive, education textbooks, with headings covering such topics as lillIe distinction between two types of exhibits. The distinction is revealing people (dwarfs and midgets), giants, hairy people, human skeletons. because it illustrates the connection between science and freak shows, armless and legless wonders, wild men, fat people, albinos. Siamese a connection that showmen profited by and tried to maintain well into twins, people with eXira limbs, half men/half women. people with the twentieth century. The distinction was between so-called ex­ skin disorders, and anatomical wonders. They are eager to provide <lmples of new <lnd unknown "races" and "lusus naturae" or nature's readers a quick course in genetics, endocrinolol!J', and embryology.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Archiving Possibilities with the Victorian Freak Show a Dissertat
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE “Freaking” the Archive: Archiving Possibilities With the Victorian Freak Show A Dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English by Ann McKenzie Garascia September 2017 Dissertation Committee: Dr. Joseph Childers, Co-Chairperson Dr. Susan Zieger, Co-Chairperson Dr. Robb Hernández Copyright by Ann McKenzie Garascia 2017 The Dissertation of Ann McKenzie Garascia is approved: Committee Chairperson University of California, Riverside ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation has received funding through University of California Riverside’s Dissertation Year Fellowship and the University of California’s Humanities Research Institute’s Dissertation Support Grant. Thank you to the following collections for use of their materials: the Wellcome Library (University College London), Special Collections and University Archives (University of California, Riverside), James C. Hormel LGBTQIA Center (San Francisco Public Library), National Portrait Gallery (London), Houghton Library (Harvard College Library), Montana Historical Society, and Evanion Collection (the British Library.) Thank you to all the members of my dissertation committee for your willingness to work on a project that initially described itself “freakish.” Dr. Hernández, thanks for your energy and sharp critical eye—and for working with a Victorianist! Dr. Zieger, thanks for your keen intellect, unflappable demeanor, and ready support every step of the process. Not least, thanks to my chair, Dr. Childers, for always pushing me to think and write creatively; if it weren’t for you and your Dickens seminar, this dissertation probably wouldn’t exist. Lastly, thank you to Bartola and Maximo, Flora and Martinus, Lalloo and Lala, and Eugen for being demanding and lively subjects.
    [Show full text]
  • New Acquisitions in Americana October 2020
    William Reese Company AMERICANA • RARE BOOKS • LITERATURE AMERICAN ART • PHOTOGRAPHY ______________________________ 409 TEMPLE STREET NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT 06511 (203) 789-8081 FAX (203) 865-7653 [email protected] New Acquisitions in Americana October 2020 The Negro Civic League Reacts to Elections in Florida 1. [African Americana]: [Negro Civic League]: NEGRO VOTERS SOLD OUT IN JUNE 2, PRIMARY. YOU HAVE BEEN SOLD AGAIN AND THIS TIME BY YOUR OWN LEADERS. [Jacksonville, Fl.? N.d., ca. 1946-1956]. Handbill, 9 x 6 inches. Three small chips at top and right margins (no text af- fected). Tanned. Good. Handbill issued by the Negro Civic League referring to an election we could not identify, but which was one of a series of controversial elections in Duval County, which at the time had the largest percentage of African-American registered voters in Florida. The text states: “You have been sold again and this time by your own Leaders. If you want the truth as to what you are worth, and who sold you Out, attend the Mass Meeting at the Odd Fellows Hall, Odessa & Florida Ave. Thurs. June 11, 8p.m. Karl Westphall & Harry Courtney will speak.” The officers of the Negro Civic League are given at the bottom: “Arthur Reynolds, Pres.” and “Bessie Robinson, Sec.” Elston E. Roady, “The Expansion of Negro Suffrage in Florida” in Journal of Negro Education, Vol. 26, no. 3 (Summer, 1957), pp.297-306. $225. An Unrecorded Chicago Cattle Auction Catalogue from 1888 2. [Cattle]: [Huston, Rigdon]: CLOSING OUT SALE OF THE HILL- A substantial and unrecorded cattle auction catalogue advertising the sale of the DALE HERD OF SHORT-HORN CATTLE PROPERTY OF THE LATE late Rigdon Huston’s Hilldale Herd in Chicago in 1888.
    [Show full text]
  • Number 3 Fall 2005
    HE SPECIAL COLLECTIONS RESE FROM T ARCH CE NEWS NTER NUMBER THREE FALL 2005 THE COURANT Sponsored by the Syracuse University Library Associates ISSN 554-2688 UNDERGROUND RAILROAD CLRC FUNDS DIGITIZATION EXHIBITION UNVEILED PROJECTS During the decades-long struggle to abolish slavery, thou- “Jo-Jo the Dog-Faced Boy,” General Tom Thumb, and the sands of African Americans risked their lives to escape Bearded Lady were among the hundreds of circus and side- from their bitter bondage in the South to seek freedom in show performers whom New York photographer Charles the northern states, or beyond in Canada. One by one or Eisenmann photographed in his studio in the Bowery in in small groups, runaway slaves were aided in their peril- the last decades of the nineteenth century. A lower-class ous journeys by a clandestine network of fellow African area that was the hub of popular entertainment, the Bowery Americans and sympathetic whites that came to be known continued on page five, column one as the Underground Railroad. Syracuse served as an important station along this free- dom trail because of its central location on the Erie Canal and its associated waterways and travel routes. Central New York was also home to many of the most outspoken and defiant opponents of slavery. Jermain Loguen, himself a refugee from slavery, publicized the address of his home at East Genesee and Pine streets as a shelter. He sought and obtained support for his efforts from local abolitionists and reformers, such as Matilda Joslyn Gage and Samuel J. May. Gerrit Smith,
    [Show full text]
  • Nineteenth Century New Jersey Photographers Revision of Illustrated Article in New Jersey History, Fall/Winter 2004
    Nineteenth Century New Jersey Photographers Revision of illustrated article in New Jersey History, Fall/Winter 2004 by Gary D. Saretzky By 1900, approximately 3,000 individuals had worked in New Jersey as professional or serious amateur photographers but only a handful have reputations that have survived into the 21st century.1 Most of us have seen an imprinted name on the back an old photograph and wondered who that person was who took the photograph. Where did the photographer come from? Did he or she have a family? Was photography just a short-term vocation or a long-term career? If an address is also imprinted, when did the photographer work at that location? To some extent, this essayCwhich provides selected information about approximately 10 percent of the photographers known to have worked in the state in the 1800sCis a work in progress that aims toward a biographical directory of nineteenth century New Jersey photographers. Included is information about, and examples of, the work of these photographers, most of whom achieved notable success in their lifetimes. The directory will include data about all the photographers that have come to my attention with the help of numerous archivists, librarians, researchers, and collectors.2 This article begins with an overview of photography in New Jersey, on both the professional front, with a subsection on stereographic view makers, and on the amateur front, featuring the development of camera clubs. It will then examine professional photography in New Jersey=s seven largest cities, particularly the largest, Newark, which had numerous photographic establishments. (While some residents of Essex, Hudson, and other counties near New York patronized Manhattan portrait studios, they had ample and often lower priced alternatives closer to home.) Newark also was nineteenth century New Jersey's center for manufacturing photographic materials for local, New York, and even national markets.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide to the PT Barnum Research Collection
    Guide to the P.T. Barnum Research Collection (BHC-MS 0001) By Meghan Rinn January 2017 Descriptive Summary Creator: P.T. Barnum; Nancy Fish; Jenny Lind; Charles S. Stratton; M. Lavinia Warren; others Title: P.T. Barnum Research Collection Dates: 1735-1988 [bulk 1830-1921] Quantity: 18 manuscript boxes, 10 oversize drawers Abstract: The P.T. Barnum Research Collection represents archival materials collected by the Bridgeport History Center over the years relating to the life and ventures of P.T. Barnum. Barnum himself was deeply connected to Bridgeport, building four homes there, serving as mayor, and hosting his circus' Winter Quarters in the city. As a result, this collection represents both national and local history. The series in the collection relate to his personal life, the American Museum, Barnum's circus ventures, Jumbo the Elephant, Jenny Lind, and Charles S. Stratton and Lavinia Warren. Each series contains manuscript material including an extensive correspondence series in Barnum’s own hand, programs, tickets, artifacts, illustrations, and photographs, as well as clippings and examples of promotional material in the form of booklets, trading cards, and even paper dolls. This collection is artificial, and has grown over the years. The series themselves were formed by researcher needs, and as such have been kept intact at the time of arrangement. Collection Number: BHC-MS 0001 Language: English Repository: Bridgeport History Center Biographical Information or Administrative History P.T. Barnum Phineas Taylor (P. T.) Barnum was born in Bethel, Connecticut on 5 July, 1810. Barnum’s name is popularly associated with the Barnum & Bailey Greatest Show on Earth, but the circus was only one facet of his career.
    [Show full text]
  • The Oddity As Commodity: Television and the Modern Day Freak Show
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Aquila Digital Community The University of Southern Mississippi The Aquila Digital Community Dissertations Spring 5-2011 The Oddity as Commodity: Television and the Modern Day Freak Show Robin Marie Cecala University of Southern Mississippi Follow this and additional works at: https://aquila.usm.edu/dissertations Part of the Broadcast and Video Studies Commons, Critical and Cultural Studies Commons, and the Mass Communication Commons Recommended Citation Cecala, Robin Marie, "The Oddity as Commodity: Television and the Modern Day Freak Show" (2011). Dissertations. 688. https://aquila.usm.edu/dissertations/688 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by The Aquila Digital Community. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of The Aquila Digital Community. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The University of Southern Mississippi THE ODDITY AS COMMODITY: TELEVISION AND THE MODERN DAY FREAK SHOW by Robin Marie Cecala Abstract of a Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate School of The University of Southern Mississippi in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy May 2011 ABSTRACT THE ODDITY AS COMMODITY: TELEVISION AND THE MODERN DAY FREAK SHOW By Robin Marie Cecala May 2011 A new genre of documentary and reality program has appeared on cable television in recent years. Suddenly, little people, conjoined twins, the morbidly obese, Treeman and Mermaid Girl are the new stars of cable. This latest genre features people with medical conditions once exhibited in the turn of the century freak shows.
    [Show full text]
  • Fabricating Freakery: the Display of Exceptional Bodies in Nineteenth-Century London
    Fabricating Freakery: The Display of Exceptional Bodies in Nineteenth-Century London John Jacob Woolf Goldsmiths, University of London Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD 1 Declaration I declare that the work in this thesis is my own. John Jacob Woolf Date: 2 Acknowledgements This thesis would have been inconceivable without the work of others in the field of Disability Studies, ‘Freak Studies’ and beyond. Nor would it have been realised without the generous funding from Goldsmiths College, University of London and the Arts and Humanities Research Council. I would also like to thank all the archivists, librarians and staff at the consulted collections, in particular Adrienne Saint Pierre at the Barnum Museum and Elizabeth Van Tuyl at the Bridgeport History Centre. I owe special thanks to Mat Fraser, Dr. Colin Shindler at Cambridge University, Dr. Erica Wald and Professor Jan Plamper at the University of London. To Dr. Vivienne Richmond who tirelessly read, marked, advised and supported me—both emotionally and intellectually—I am eternally grateful. Without her support, this thesis would never have materialised. I am beholden to my Dad and brother for reading the whole thesis and offering comments and corrections. Finally, thanks are due to my family and fiancée for indulging my obsessions and reminding me that while the past is filled with wonder the present is just as enriching. To them this work is dedicated. 3 Abstract This thesis examines five individuals in the tradition of freakery: the performance of constructed abnormality as entertainment. Departing from a tendency to explore the ‘freak’ and the ‘freak show’ from the mid-nineteenth century, this thesis starts at the beginning of the 1800s to explore the diachronic evolution of freakery as it went from small-scale transitory exhibitions to large-scale commercial enterprises tied to the burgeoning entertainment industry.
    [Show full text]