DOCSLIB.ORG

Università Degli Studi Di Milano Scuola Di Dottorato in Scienze Giuridiche

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Università Degli Studi Di Milano Scuola Di Dottorato in Scienze Giuridiche 1 Università degli Studi di Milano Scuola di dottorato in Scienze Giuridiche International PhD Programme in Law and Society "Renato Treves” Effectiveness of human rights and state Immunity: improving the theoretical socio-legal background concerning human rights rise and protection. Candidate Camila Vicenci Witt Supervisor Prof. Dr. Maria Cristina Reale 2 UNIVERSITÀ DEGLI STUDI DI MILANO – SCUOLA DI DOTTORATO IN SCIENZE GIURIDICHE Effectiveness of human rights and state Immunity: improving the theoretical socio-legal background concerning human rights rise and protection. Camila Vicenci Witt Thesis presented for International PhD Programme in Law and Society "Renato Treves”- Università Degli Studi di Milano - Italy 3 To Thomas 4 ABSTRACT This thesis shall study the relationship between effectiveness of human rights and state immunity from a socio-legal perspective. The first chapter will focus on international law as a legal system, addressing its origins, functions and characteristics. The second chapter will examine the framework of state immunity, analyzing its conceptual configuration, historical development and differentiating it from similar notions. In the third chapter, the construction of human rights will be addressed, starting by their historical affirmation, studying their implementation and examining the right to reparations. The fourth chapter will focus on challenging immunity to make human rights effective, and it will analyze the case law on the matter, as well as the most significant theoretical approaches to the subject. The fifth chapter will present two original contributions to the discussion: one deconstructing the foundations of state immunity and another one focusing on the victim’s perspective, to finally draw some conclusions and try to balance the primacy granted to the protection of Human Rights in the 21st Century with traditional norms and institutes of International Law, such as State Immunity. Key- words: State Immunity – Human Rights – International Law – Socio-Legal Perspective 5 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This thesis’ idea actually started in 2008 when, in my masters programme in Brazil, my former supervisor assigned me a seminar on state immunity in cases of violations of human rights before domestic courts. At that time, I knew very little about the subject, but realizing how people who suffered grotesque violations of their dignity, who were sometimes tortured, persecuted and who often lost their beloved ones could not, in the majority of the cases, obtain redress, left me with a profound feeling of injustice. Yes, I was naïve enough to believe, even after five years of Law School, that Law should be about justice, and I do not have words to thank my parents, Sandra and Marcio, for keeping what many call an “illusion” alive in me. My parents have always fought injustice in their own way, and they never ceased to be shocked by it. They have my eternal gratitude for teaching me that one should never see injustice as something normal, and that one should act upon it in its own way. My parents have also supported me financially when I chose the academic life instead of getting “a real job”, and even when I finally started teaching at the university, travelling 6 hours each way every week, they were always proud, encouraging and supportive. Moreover, it was a relief to be able to talk to a mother that understands that inexorable need of hand-washing your jeans or the irresistible urge to re-organize your Tupperware supply that comes when you have to sit and write your thesis. I also have to thank my “ad hoc” father, my dear uncle Fernando, who has always been present, helping in any way possible to make my life easier. He is the best airport chauffer, hospital companion, plumber, electrician and cultural guide one could ask for. He is also a wonderful friend and the one our family can always count on. 6 My gratitude goes to dear friend Anatercia Rovani too, with whom I shared so many unforgettable moments and so many human rights ideals in Law School, and who told me that I should enroll for the Renato Treves Ph.D. Programme in Milano. Coming and going from Brazil to Italy required a lot of understanding from my dear students at Unijui and IDC, who were always so inspiring and caring despite the fact that I was not as available to them as I should. Thank you, guys, for teaching me way more than I could ever taught you. A special thanks to Kellen, Claudio and Johnny, beloved friends who always managed to find some time for me, and who also forced me to find some time for them. And then it comes him, Thomas, who made me believe that where there is a will, there is a way. Despite all adversities of an intercontinental relationship, he fought for us and for making me happy every day. Thomas is so caring, so understanding and so supportive that I have no words to express how much I love him and how grateful I am for having the world’s best husband. Because of Thomas, Denmark was added to the Ph.D. and working-life equation. Moving to yet another country was not easy, and between the visa application desperation, the daily Danish classes nightmare, the job search and job finding, I met some special people who made my dark days here brighter: Catia, Delcilene, Marie, Morgan&Ana Paula, Cristina&Vassilis, Rebecca&Benny, Marie-Alice&Phil, Keith&Mathieu, Sayeh&Reza, thank you so much for everything! A special thanks also goes for Thomas’ family: Tove (a.k.a mormor), Bettina, Nanna, Lene, Helle, Poul, Tim, Stine, Therese, Ben, Bedstefar, Søren&Tita. 7 Here in Denmark, I was very fortunate to find a place that does a tremendous effort to defend human rights by fighting racial discrimination, and I am very grateful to Niels-Erik for letting me a part of Dokumentations og Rådgivnings Centeret om Racediskrimination (DRC). Finally, I am incredibly grateful for all the help and patience from Prof. Luigi Cominelli, and for the inestimable help, assistance, understanding, inspiration and trust from my supervisor, Prof. Maria Cristina Reale, without whom this would never be possible. 8 INDEX INTRODUCTION 11 1 INTERNATIONAL LAW AS A SPECIFIC LEGAL SYSTEM 18 1.1 The Origins of international law 19 1.2 The Functions of international law 23 1.3 The Lack of a Central Power Guaranteeing the Rule of 25 Law 1.4 No distinction between formal and material sources 27 1.5 Absence of a hierarchy among the sources of 28 international law 1.6 Emergence of an international norm 35 1.7 International responsibility of the state 38 2 THE FRAMEWORK REGARDING STATE IMMUNITY 43 2.1 Conceptual Configuration 44 2.1.1 Jurisdiction 44 2.1.2 International Competence 48 2.1.3 Immunity 51 2.1.4 Individualizing state Immunity 52 2.2 Evolution of state immunity 61 2.2.1 2.2.1 State Immunity’s Remote Roots 61 2.2.2 State Immunity Before Domestic Courts: First Developments 64 2.2.3 First Steps Towards a Relative Approach 74 2.2.4 Consolidating of the Relative Approach 77 2.3 Similar Notions: Act of state, Political Question and Non- 81 Justiciability 2.3.1 Act of state Doctrine 81 2.3.2 The Political Question 86 2.3.3 Non-Justiciability 87 3 THE CONSTRUCTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS 90 3.1 Historical affirmation of human rights 92 3.1.1 Remote Antecedents 92 3.1.2 From the XVIth Century to the First World War 95 3.1.3 Between the two World Wars 106 3.1.4 The Second World War 108 3.1.5 The Post War Period 109 3.2 Human Rights, the Global and the Regional 110 3.2.1 The Global System of Human Rights 113 3.2.2 Regional Systems of Human Rights 114 3.3 The right to a reparation as a human right 118 3.4 Forms of reparation 123 3.4.1 Restitutio in integrum 124 3.4.2 Compensation 126 3.4.3 Satisfaction 128 3.4.4 Guarantees of non- repetition 130 3.4.5 Lump sum agreements 131 4 CHALLENGING IMMUNITY TO MAKE HUMAN RIGHTS 134 EFFECTIVE 4.1 Case Law regarding state immunity in cases of violation 135 9 of human rights 4.1.1 Decisions concerning states WITHOUT specific legislation on 138 the matter 4.1.1.1 Italy 138 4.1.1.2 Greece 141 4.1.1.3 Brazil 144 4.1.2 Decisions concerning states WITH specific legislation on the 147 matter 4.1.2.1 United States of America 147 4.1.2.2 United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland 151 4.1.2.3 Argentina 154 4.2 Theoretical Approaches Challenging State Immunity 157 4.2.1 The Implied Waiver Theory 157 4.2.2 The Normative Hierarchy Theory 161 4.2.3 Universal Jurisdiction 164 4.2.4 Option and Risk Calculability Theory 167 4.2.5 Mutual Benefit Theory 171 5 TENTATIVE CONTRIBUTIONS FOR AN ENHANCED 177 EFFECTIVITY OF HUMAN RIGHTS 5.1 Why not questioning the foundations of state immunity? 177 5.1.1 Sovereignty 178 5.1.2 Independence 181 5.1.3 Equality 184 5.1.4 Dignity 186 5.2 Social contributions for the enhancing the debate on 188 human rights and state immunity 5.2.1 Victims and victimology: what can we learn from them? 189 5.2.2 The victim- or who are we talking about? 197 5.2.3 The need for justice in a victim’s perspective 204 CONCLUSION 207 REFERENCES 214 10 Tous ces crimes d'Etat qu'on fait pour la couronne, Le ciel nous en absout alors qu'il nous la donne, Et dans le sacré rang où sa faveur l'a mis, Le passé devient juste et l'avenir permis.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Radical Potential of Chavismo in Venezuela the First Year and a Half in Power by Steve Ellner
    LATIN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVES Ellner / RADICAL POTENTIAL OF CHAVISMO The Radical Potential of Chavismo in Venezuela The First Year and a Half in Power by Steve Ellner The circumstances surrounding Hugo Chávez’s pursuit of power and the strategy he has adopted for achieving far-reaching change in Venezuelaare in many ways without parallel in Latin American politics. While many generals have been elected president, Chávez’s electoral triumph was unique in that he was a middle-level officer with radical ideas who had previously led a coup attempt. Furthermore, few Latin American presidents have attacked existing democratic institutions with such fervor while swearing allegiance to the democratic system (Myers and O’Connor, 1998: 193). From the beginning of his political career, Chávez embraced an aggres- sively antiparty discourse. He denounced the hegemony of vertically based political parties, specifically their domination of Congress, the judicial sys- tem, the labor and peasant movements, and civil society in general. Upon his election in December 1998, he followed through on his campaign promise to use a constituent assembly as a vehicle for overhauling the nation’s neo- corporatist political system. He proposed to replace this model with one of direct popular participation in decision making at the local level. His actions and rhetoric, however, also pointed in the direction of a powerful executive whose authority would be largely unchecked by other state institutions. Indeed, the vacuum left by the weakening of the legislative and judicial branches and of government at the state level and the loss of autonomy of such public entities as the Central Bank and the state oil company could well be filled by executive-based authoritarianism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Americas: Venezuela
    Venezuela National Affairs TUE CHAVEZ PHENOMENON HugoChavez was first elected president ofVenezuela in December 1998 with 56 percent of the vote, andtook office in February 1999, launching what he termed the "BolivarianRevolution," named after Simon BolIvar, the nineteenth-centuryliberator of Venezuela. Reelected in 2000 under a new constitution of his owndevising, he won a third term in the national election of December 3,2006, receiving 63 percent of the vote, as against 37 percent for theopposition candidate, Manuel Rosales, governor of Zulia, the richest statein Venezuela and the country's main producer of oil. The result had been a foregone conclusion,and many Venezuelans op posed to the incumbent stayed home onelection day. Although no evi• dence of outright election fraudsurfaced, the president enjoyed the. advantages deriving from unlimitedpolitical power. His advertising and campaign costs were funded by the government,which also kept the reg- istry of those eligible to vote, and did notshare it with the opposition The attention that the world press lavished onChavez almost on a daily basis dwarfed all previous interest thatVenezuela had attracted in its 174 years as an independent country.Who really was Hugo Chavez? Sincebe. coming president Chavez had beencompared to Argentinean dictator Juan Domingo Perón, a paradigm offascist populism; with Juan Velasco Alvarado, the military strongman whoinstituted a leftist dictatorship in Peru that lasted from 1968 until 1975;and with all three of the legendary twentieth-century despots—Mussolini, Hitler,and Stalin. And yet his friends and enemies—even Chavez himself,in fact—tended to agree that the best comparison was with FidelCastro, who had been not only a political mentor, butalso a kind of father figure.
    [Show full text]
  • In Recent Years, the Jewish Communities in Latin America Have
    ABSTRACT In recent years, the Jewish communities in Latin America have felt the impact of a series of profound transformations in their social, economic, and political situations. One of the most recent cases concerns the community of Venezuela, under the Bolivarian Revolution led by President Hugo Chávez Frías. This study analyzes the effect of national and transnational factors that have impacted the life of that community. The central claim of this work is that, under shifting articulations between political forces in Venezuela and between the Venezuelan state and international actors, the Jewish community of that country has been under increasing pressure and subject to unprecedented constraints. These constraints have been the result of both processes of political confrontation in Venezuela and processes generated by the interplay of national and transnational forces, which have greatly affected and will likely continue to impact the Venezuelan Jewish community. Beyond shifting the balance of power in Venezuelan society, these changes and choices have transformed the environment in which the organized Jewish community of Venezuela exists. While this paper does not support the view that the new Venezuelan regime intends to promote a systematic atmosphere of hostility toward Jews, its findings suggest that its rhetoric, coalitional dynamics, and strategic international positioning have narrowed the public space that the Jewish community enjoys legitimately, have created serious concerns and has already affected that community, which has recently suffered from acts of antisemitic vandalism. The Venezuelan leadership should certainly be more cautious of the social consequences of its statements and the way in which addresses its society’s multiculturalism.
    [Show full text]
  • Holocaustul Gogoriţa Diabolică
    FUNDAŢIA ACADEMIA DACOROMÂNĂ „Tempus DacoRomânia ComTerra“ Vasile I. Zărnescu HOLOCAUSTUL GOGORIŢA DIABOLICĂ 1 S.C. TEMPUS DACOROMÂNIA COMTERRA S.R.L. Bucureşti, Drumul Taberei nr.26/119; Tel.: 4 0214138434; 0722972522, [email protected], O.P. - 58, C.P. - 14, Cod poştal 061355; www.tempusdacoromania.ro, www.academiadacoromana.ro Copyright 2014 All rights reserved Vasile I. Zărnescu Coperta: Vasile I. Zărnescu Culegere şi tehnoredactare: Vasile I. Zărnescu Descrierea CIP a Bibliotecii Naţionale a României Vasile I. Zărnescu, Holocaustul – gogoriţa diabolică / Zărnescu, Vasile I., - Bucureşti: Editura Dacoromână TDC, 2014 ISBN 978-606-601-061-0 Toate drepturile şi răspunderea asupra textului aparţin autorului. T E M P U S D A C O R O M Â N I A C O M T E R R A - o editură dacoromânească pentru timpul dumneavoastră ! Printed in DacoRomânia 2 VASILE I. ZĂRNESCU HOLOCAUSTUL GOGORIŢA DIABOLICĂ Bucureşti 2014 3 Vasile I. ZĂRNESCU s-a născut la 24 februarie 1947, în satul Mihai Viteazul, comuna Vlad Ţepeş, Judeţul Călăraşi. Este de naţionalitate română şi de religie ortodoxă. Este căsătorit şi are doi copii: o fată studentă la U.A.T.C. şi un băiat student la Facultatea de informatică managerială. Este absolvent al Facultăţii de filozofie, secţia sociologie. Politologul Ovidiu Trăsnea i-a fost conducător ştiinţific al diplomei de licenţă. A lucrat ca sociolog-principal la Întreprinderea de Confecţii şi Tricotaje Bucureşti – I.C.T.B. (1972-1989), de unde a fost concediat cu art. 64, lit “t“ din Legea 5/1978 republicată în 1982 – articol introdus special contra oponenţilor regimului; apoi a lucrat la Oficiul de relaţii publice al Televiziunii Române – TVR (1990-1991) şi, în final, ca ofiţer analist- sintezist în cadrul Serviciului Român de Informaţii (1991-2002), de unde a fost trecut în rezervă cu gradul de colonel.
    [Show full text]
  • Terrore Internazionale E Antisemitismo Due Maledizioni Dei Tempi Moderni: C'e' Un Collegamento?
    1 TERRORE INTERNAZIONALE E ANTISEMITISMO DUE MALEDIZIONI DEI TEMPI MODERNI: C'E' UN COLLEGAMENTO? di Ely Karmon (Senior Research Scholar, Interdisciplinary Center (IDC), Herzlyia, Israele) Le coalizioni basate sull’antisemitismo negli anni ’70-’80. Pregiudizi razzisti e antisemiti furono elementi influenti nell’indurre alcuni capi terroristi di entrambe le estremità dello spettro politico europeo – la sinistra radicale e la destra radicale – ad abbracciare una politica di collaborazione con le organizzazioni palestinesi e/o ad effettuare attacchi contro bersagli israeliani ed ebraici. Questa tendenza fu particolarmente evidente nel caso della Rote Armée Fraktion tedesca – RAF- e delle Revolutionare Zellen (RZ), i cui capi cercarono di legittimare i loro attacchi agli Ebrei inserendo temi antisemiti nei loro trattati ideologici e strategici (2) Ne è esempio il documento con cui la RAF espresse il proprio sostegno all'attacco terrorista di Settembre Nero contro gli atleti israeliani alle Olimpiadi di Monaco del 1972. L'operazione vi è descritta come “ un'azione anti-fascista (intesa) a spazzare via il ricordo ...delle Olimpiadi del 1936 (a Berlino), il ricordo di Auschwitz e della Kristallnacht”. Israele fu addirittura considerata colpevole della morte degli atleti come i Nazisti della morte degli ebrei. (3). Horst Mahler, il capo della RAF che scrisse quel documento in prigione, commentò: “per quanto sembri macabro, il Sionismo è diventato l'erede del fascismo tedesco, con la crudele espulsione del popolo palestinese dalla terra dove ha vissuto per migliaia di anni (4). In un incontro dell'estrema destra austriaca del novembre 1999 Mahler parlò della necessità di liberare la Germania da “ Judischen Principien ” (princìpi giudaici) e dalla ‘ venerazione ebraica per il denaro.
    [Show full text]
  • Antisemitism in Venezuela's Presidential Election, by Lidia Lerner
    KANTOR CENTER, TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY Papers on Antisemitism and Racism Editors: Roni Stauber, Beryl Belsky September 2012 ANTISEMITISM IN VENEZUELA'S PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION Lidia Lerner1 Since the 1998 presidential elections, Venezuela has undergone a political transformation which has had a significant impact on its tradition of cultural and religious tolerance. Following the election of Hugo Chavez as president, official attitudes in the country toward Jews, which till then had been basically positive, gradually turned into suspicion and hostility. While not concealing their sometimes virulent anti-Zionist rhetoric, Chavez and his government have denied charges of antisemitism, and have attempted to distinguish between their policy toward Israel and the Middle East, and their attitude towards Jews in general.2 However, recent years have witnessed a rise in antisemitic manifestations, including vandalism, media attacks, caricatures, and physical attacks on Venezuelan Jewish institutions.3 The roots of Chavez's antisemitism, and that of his followers, are various: racist, political, opportunistic, and in some cases, religious. Chavez was strongly influenced by the late Norberto Ceresole, an ultra-nationalist Argentinean antisemite and Holocaust denier, who served as his advisor and mentor from 1994. Chavez's strong links with Iran and the Arab world also play a significant role in his attitude towards Israel and Jews (despite his attempts to differentiate between them).4 1 Researcher, Kantor Center, specializing in antisemitism in Latin America. 2 RNV, September 17, 2010, http://www.rnv.gov.ve/noticias/?act=ST&f=2&t=137301; letter from President Hugo Chavez to the Secretary General of the United Nations, September 21, 2011, http://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/6507.
    [Show full text]
  • Iran and Its Proxy Hezbollah: Strategic Penetration in Latin America
    Iran and its Proxy Hezbollah: Strategic Penetration in Latin America Ely Karmon Area: International Terrorism Working Paper 18/2009 8/4/2009 Elcano Royal Institute Madrid – Spain www.realinstitutoelcano.org 1 Iran and its Proxy Hezbollah: Strategic Penetration in Latin America Ely Karmon * ‘Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad must love the tropics’, commented ironically The Miami Herald.1 He has spent more time in Latin America than President Bush. Since his inauguration in 2005, Iran’s foreign policy focus has shifted from Africa to Latin America in order to, as Ahmadinejad puts it, ‘counter lasso’ the US.2 Iran’s Goals in Latin America Farideh Farhi argues that while Iran’s increased attention to Latin America as a region is a relatively new development, its bilateral ties with some individual Latin American nations are of long standing and relatively robust. Iran has shared an ideological relationship with Cuba since the end of the Iran‐Iraq War, and a political relationship with Venezuela since their co‐founding of OPEC in the 1960s. The impetus behind these long‐standing bilateral relationships is three‐fold:3 (1) Iran’s non‐aligned position in foreign policy has compelled it to seek out countries with similar ideological outlooks. (2) US efforts to keep Iran in diplomatic and economic isolation have forced it to pursue an active foreign policy. (3) The election of a reformist President in 1997 made it possible for countries like Brazil to engage Iran with enough confidence to withstand pressures from the US. The shift to the left in many important Latin American countries in the first decade of the new millennium has allowed Iran to be more successful in its attempt to improve relations with particular countries.
    [Show full text]
  • The War of a Million Cuts
    9 “I warmly recommend this well-documented book to all friends of Israel in Europe (and others!) for effectively combating the surge of anti-Semitism and anti-Israelism on their continent.” —MEP Bastiaan Belder, Committee for Foreign Affairs/vice-chair of Israel delegation, European Parliament “Delegitimizing Israel is a critical objective for its most determined enemies. Gerstenfeld explains what the dangers are and what to do about them in this important book.” —John Bolton, former U.S. ambassador to the United Nations “Manfred Gerstenfeld not only carefully documents the plethora of current expres- sions of hatred of Jews and Israel, its instigators and promoters; by connecting the bits and pieces, he confronts the reader with a chillingly accurate picture. It is a book not just to read but to act upon.” —Daniel Herman, minister of culture, Czech Republic “This is a must-read book that unravels the complex process of the delegitimiza- tion and demonization of the Jews and Israel. It lucidly exposes the perpetrators and suggests how to combat them successfully. I recommend it to anyone who cares about effectively presenting Israel’s case.” —Steve Linde, editor in chief, The Jerusalem Post “I hold to this inescapable historical truth: it will never be time to forget Israel. There will never be a time when we can abandon the cause of justice for the Jewish people: the right to be. Peace in the Middle East, to which we all aspire, will only be possible when all, and I mean everyone, effectively recognize and respect the right to the existence of the state of Israel.
    [Show full text]
  • VENEZUELA ALERT My Travels with Hugo
    Volume VIII, Issue XVII October 17, 2000 VENEZUELA ALERT My Travels with Hugo A Book Review of Richard Gott, In the Shadow of the Liberator: Hugo Chavez and the Transformation of Venezuela (London: Verso, 2000). 246 pages. Scott B. MacDonald Editor's Note: With this issue we inaugurate a new feature - an occasional book review. These essays will highlight "should-read" publications about "need to know" subjects. Reader feedback is most welcome ([email protected]). The Bolivarian World On September 27-28th, 2000, Caracas hosted a summit for the leaders of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). While the OPEC meeting was taking place, international economic policy makers, including the G7 industrial nations, met in Prague at the annual IMF/World Bank meetings. Anyone with an interest in how the post-Cold War order is shaping up should take note: two different organizations, two different venues, and two different objectives. While it would not be fair to characterize OPEC as an anti-Western, and in particular, an anti-U.S. organization, a number of OPEC members are hardly on close terms with Washington, including Iran, Iraq, Libya, and most recently, Venezuela. In fact, it is Venezuela's leader, President Hugo Chavez, who has sought to instill greater discipline within OPEC and make it more aggressive in terms of pricing. He is also using OPEC as a leveler of what he regards as a too powerful United States. Indeed, he has stated: "The 20th century was a bipolar century, but the 21st is not going to be unipolar. The 21st century should be multipolar, and we all ought to push for the development of such a world.
    [Show full text]
  • El Proyecto Regional Bolivariano Y Las Consecuencias De La Muerte De Hugo Chávez Para América Latina
    Agenda Internacional Año XX, N° 31, 2013, pp. 9-30 ISSN 1027-6750 El Proyecto Regional Bolivariano y las consecuencias de la muerte de Hugo Chávez para América Latina Sebastien Adins Vanbiervliet Después del anuncio que hizo pública la muerte de Hugo Chávez, tanto partidarios como adversarios del expresidente coincidían en que había desaparecido un personaje histórico en Venezuela y el conjunto de América Latina. Aunque todavía es muy tem- prano evaluar el significado histórico del chavismo, este artículo pretende determinar los principales efectos que ha generado el líder venezolano en el subcontinente. Para este fin, analizaré primero las fuentes del protagonismo venezolano durante la década pasada en gran parte de América Latina y el Caribe. Luego, en un segundo capítulo distinguiré la particular dinámica de este proyecto regional, tomando en cuenta sobre todo la política interna de Venezuela y el precio del petróleo —dos factores que his- tóricamente han influido en la política exterior del país—. El tercer capítulo intenta medir de alguna forma la influencia que ha tenido el chavismo en los principales países de la región y en los esquemas de integración regional. Por último, consideraré qué cambios podrá sufrir la política exterior en general, y la regional en particular, después del deceso del exmandatario venezolano. 1. Las fuentes del protagonismo de Chávez en la región Antes de analizar las políticas e iniciativas de Hugo Chávez con respecto a la región, me detendré en las fuentes del protagonismo venezolano en América Latina: la ideo- logía bolivariana y su visión del mundo; el carisma de Chávez; y el particular con- texto de la primera década del siglo XXI, caracterizada por altos precios de petróleo y el éxito electoral en la región de líderes izquierdistas y/o nacionalistas.
    [Show full text]
  • Venezuela: Hugo Chávez’S Revolution
    VENEZUELA: HUGO CHÁVEZ’S REVOLUTION Latin America Report N°19 – 22 February 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................... i I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 II. THE CHÁVEZ PHENOMENON ................................................................................. 2 A. THE PUNTO FIJO REGIME (1958-1992) AND CHÁVEZ’S RISE ................................................2 B. THE 1999 CONSTITUTION......................................................................................................5 C. ON THE DEFENSIVE...............................................................................................................7 III. UNDERMINING DEMOCRACY .............................................................................. 11 A. STATE INSTITUTIONS AND PARALLEL POWERS....................................................................11 1. The judiciary and the public control entities ...........................................................11 2. The National Electoral Council (CNE) and the selection of its members ...............12 3. Weakening regional government.............................................................................13 4. Communications, media and transparency ..............................................................13 5. Targeting of opposition figures................................................................................15
    [Show full text]
  • Norberto Ceresole Nació En Buenos Aires En Agosto De 1943
    Revista de Ciencias Sociales (Cl) ISSN: 0717-2257 [email protected] Universidad Arturo Prat Chile Boscán Carrasquero, Guillermo CERESOLE Y LA REVOLUCIÓN DE HUGO CHÁVEZ: LA RELACIÓN CAUDILLO, EJÉRCITO Y PUEBLO Revista de Ciencias Sociales (Cl), núm. 25, 2010, pp. 57-73 Universidad Arturo Prat Tarapacá, Chile Disponible en: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=70817741004 Cómo citar el artículo Número completo Sistema de Información Científica Más información del artículo Red de Revistas Científicas de América Latina, el Caribe, España y Portugal Página de la revista en redalyc.org Proyecto académico sin fines de lucro, desarrollado bajo la iniciativa de acceso abierto Departamento de Ciencias Sociales Universidad Arturo Prat. Iquique REVISTA CIENCIAS SOCIALES Nº 25 Segundo Semestre 2010 pp. 57-73 ISSN 0717-2257 CERESOLE Y LA REVOLUCIÓN DE HUGO CHÁVEZ: LA RELACIÓN CAUDILLO, EJÉRCITO Y PUEBLO Guillermo Boscán Carrasquero1 La historia venezolana ha estado claramente caracterizada por una visión jerárquica del poder político. Dicha circunstancia, que constituye un legado de la colonización española, se ha materializado, fundamentalmente, en la presencia reiterada de líderes carismáticos, generalmente proveniente del ámbito castrense. Bolívar, Guzmán Blanco, Gómez y, ahora, Chávez representan a un conjunto de gobernantes militares que abarcan más de 150 años en apenas dos siglos de historia independiente. Este aspecto importante de la cultura política del venezolano, ha hecho de este país el escenario apropiado para la propagación de las ideas de Ceresole. Esto explica la rapidez con que su trabajo, especialmente su visión sobre la relación caudillo, ejército y pueblo, ha ocupado un lugar relevante en el discurso de los impulsores de la revolución bolivariana.
    [Show full text]