Household Hazardous Waste Facility Feasibility Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Household Hazardous Waste Facility Feasibility Study Prepared for: Peoria County Office of Health and Human Services Recycling and Resource Conservation 3116 N. Dries Lane, Suite 200 Peoria, IL 61604 By Patrick Engineering, Inc. 300 W. Edwards Street, Suite 200 Springfield, IL 62704 Project # 20903.013 December 2009 HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITY FEASIBILITY STUDY TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................1 INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................3 OVERVIEW OF HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE ....................................................4 Definition and Composition of Household Hazardous Waste..........................................4 Regulations and Guidelines..............................................................................................6 EXISTING HHW COLLECTION PROGRAMS IN ILLINOIS.........................................11 IEPA-Sponsored Single-Day Collection Events.............................................................11 Permanent HHW Facilities .............................................................................................12 AMOUNTS OF HHW COLLECTED ....................................................................................16 HHW OPTIONS FOR PEORIA COUNTY...........................................................................19 Single Day Events...........................................................................................................19 Curbside Pickup..............................................................................................................20 Mobile Collections..........................................................................................................21 Satellite Collections........................................................................................................22 Permanent Facilities........................................................................................................23 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS FOR A PEORIA COUNTY PERMANENT HHW FACILITY......................................................................................25 Sizing and Capacity........................................................................................................26 Location ..........................................................................................................................38 General Operating Aspects .............................................................................................39 Health and Safety Aspects ..............................................................................................43 PRELIMINARY ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF PERMANENT FACILITIES.................44 Probable General Layout of Facility...............................................................................44 Estimated Facility Capital Costs.....................................................................................49 Estimated Facility Operating Costs ................................................................................49 Estimated Program Effectiveness ...................................................................................54 Potential Funding Sources ..............................................................................................55 Implementation Steps......................................................................................................56 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS..................................................................57 i HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITY FEASIBILITY STUDY TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d) TABLES 1 – Peoria County HHW Collection Events ...............................................................................16 2 – Naperville HHW Collection Facility Data............................................................................17 3 – Rockford HHW Collection Facility Data .............................................................................17 4 – Lake County HHW Collection Facility Data........................................................................17 5 – Chicago HHW Collection Facility Data ...............................................................................17 6 – Average Collections of HHW Per Participant at Selected Out-of-State Facilities ...............19 7 – Participation Rate Data (Summary)......................................................................................32 8 – Peak vs. Average Monthly Collections.................................................................................34 9 – Generation Rate Data (Summary).........................................................................................35 10 – Staffing Analysis.................................................................................................................40 11 – Estimated Facility Capital Costs.........................................................................................49 12 – Annual Operating Cost Data (Summary)............................................................................50 13 – Peoria County HHW Facility Annual Costs (Peoria Only) ................................................51 14 – Peoria Regional HHW Facility Annual Costs (3-County Area).........................................52 15 – Peoria Regional HHW Facility Annual Costs With Satellite Operations...........................53 16 – Collection Options ..............................................................................................................55 FIGURES 1 – Types of HHW Collected at Illinois One-Day Events Statewide ..........................................5 2 – Types of HHW Collected at Peoria County One-Day HHW Collections ..............................6 3 – HHW Collections at Selected Facilities Servicing 50k to 250k Households .......................18 4 – Population Centroids.............................................................................................................27 5 – Potential Satellite Collection Locations................................................................................29 6 – Participation Rates for HHW Facilities Serving 50K-250K Households ............................33 7 – Facility Average Monthly HHW Disposal ...........................................................................34 8 – Peoria Regional HHW Facility Required Storage Capacity.................................................36 9 – Peoria County HHW Facility Required Storage Capacity....................................................37 10 – Conceptual Site Diagram ....................................................................................................47 11 – Conceptual Facility Layout.................................................................................................48 12 – Annual Operating Costs for Selected HHW Collection Facilities......................................50 APPENDIX A– Hazardous Chemicals in Household Products B – List of Equipment for Permanent HHW Collection Facility C – References i EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Patrick Engineering Inc. (Patrick) has completed a household hazardous waste (HHW) facility feasibility study for Peoria County, Illinois (County). The objective of the feasibility study is to provide an evaluation of HHW collection and disposal options in order for the County to make informed decisions about its involvement in establishing an HHW facility in Peoria County. HHW presents a potential safety and environmental hazard to the citizens of Peoria County through improper storage and disposal. A comparison of records of previous HHW collection events in Peoria County and other Illinois communities and data from permanent collection facilities in Illinois and other states show that Peoria County generates HHW in types and quantities similar to state and national averages. Depending on participation rates from the three-county area, including Peoria, Tazewell and Woodford Counties, a permanent facility could collect between 150,000 and 820,000 pounds of HHW annually. The household exemption under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) would allow operating a permanent facility without permitting it as a hazardous waste facility as long as only residential waste is accepted. The Illinois siting process for pollution control facilities is also exempted for HHW provided the host community waives the siting approval process. However, the facility should maintain insurance for any future clean-up and remediation liability costs under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA or Superfund). The facility will also require State permitting as a “solid waste treatment and/or storage facility”. If the facility were to accept hazardous wastes from small business generators, both the RCRA permit and State siting process would be required. The Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (IEPA) currently provides State support for regional HHW collection facilities through agreements in which IEPA assumes “generator status” under CERCLA and all costs and responsibilities for transportation and disposal of the collected HHW. The IEPA disposal contractor will also provide training for facility staff. It is uncertain, however, whether future State budgets will allow the expansion of this program to additional facilities. Patrick compared the advantages and disadvantages of a permanent