EndocrineEndocrine EffectsEffects ofof SelectiveSelective SerotoninSerotonin ReuptakeReuptake InhibitorsInhibitors ((SSRIsSSRIs)) onon AquaticAquatic OrganismsOrganisms
Marsha C. Black & Emily D. Rogers University of Georgia Athens, Georgia, USA
Theodore B. Henry University of Tennessee Knoxville, TN OutlineOutline
¾¾ SSRIsSSRIs -- MOAMOA andand clinicalclinical significancesignificance ¾¾ PresencePresence inin thethe environmentenvironment ¾¾ StudyStudy objectivesobjectives ¾¾ ResultsResults andand DiscussionDiscussion
z AcuteAcute toxicitytoxicity ((macroinvertebratemacroinvertebrate,, fish)fish)
z ChronicChronic effectseffects ((macroinvertebratemacroinvertebrate,, fish,fish, frog)frog) ¾¾ SummarySummary andand conclusionsconclusions ¾¾ FutureFuture researchresearch directionsdirections SelectiveSelective SerotoninSerotonin ReuptakeReuptake InhibitorsInhibitors ((SSRIsSSRIs))
¾¾ TreatTreat clinicalclinical depression,depression, obsessiveobsessive-- compulsivecompulsive andand panicpanic disorders,disorders, PMS,PMS, etc.etc. ¾¾ ClinicalClinical MOA:MOA: blockblock serotoninserotonin reuptakereuptake ¾¾ Examples:Examples:
z FluoxetineFluoxetine (Prozac(Prozac®® andand SarafemSarafem®®))
z SertralineSertraline (Zoloft(Zoloft®®))
z CitalopramCitalopram ((CelexaCelexa®® andand LexaproLexapro®®))
z FluvoxamineFluvoxamine ((LuvoxLuvox®®))
z ParoxetineParoxetine ((PaxilPaxil®®)) SSRI Structures
O F3C OCHCH2CH2NHCH3 FNH O O ® Fluoxetine (Prozac®) CN Paroxetine (Paxil )
F O
CH2CH2CH2N(CH3)2 Citalopram ® (Celexa ) Cl
CH2CH2CH2CH2OCH3 Cl NHCH3 F3C
N CH2CH2NH2 O
Fluvoxamine (Luvox®) Sertraline (Zoloft®) SourcesSources ofof SurfaceSurface WaterWater ContaminationContamination byby HumanHuman PharmaceuticalsPharmaceuticals
Pharmaceuticals
Disposal Metabolism, Excretion
Landfill WWTP
Groundwater Surface Waters SSRIsSSRIs:: DetectionDetection inin thethe EnvironmentEnvironment
z FluoxetineFluoxetine detecteddetected inin surfacesurface waterswaters • 0.012 ppb detected in USGS reconnaissance study (Kolpin et al. 2002) • 0.030-0.099 ppb in Canada (Metcalfe et al. 2003) • 0.031-0.076 ppb in Mississippi (Wook-Kwon and Armbrust, unpublished) z FluoxetineFluoxetine,, sertralinesertraline andand metabolitesmetabolites detecteddetected inin fishfish tissuestissues (Brooks et al., 2005) PhysicochemicalPhysicochemical PropertiesProperties ofof SSRIsSSRIs (data from Wook-Kwon and Armbrust)
a b c Compound Log KOW Log KOC Photolysis t½ (d)
Citalopram 1.39 5.63 39
Fluoxetine 1.22 4.65 122
Fluvoxamine 1.21 3.82 0.57; 29
Paroxetine 1.37 4.47 0.67
Sertraline 1.37 4.17 23
aMeasured on salt form bAverage calculated from experiments with 5 different soils and sediments c Average calculated from experiments with 2 different lake water samples WhyWhy Worry?Worry?
¾ PharmaceuticalsPharmaceuticals areare designeddesigned toto havehave aa therapeutictherapeutic (=biological)(=biological) effecteffect
z Effects on non-target organisms are mostly unknown ¾ AquaticAquatic organismsorganisms areare exposedexposed throughoutthroughout theirtheir lifetimelifetime ¾ PotentialPotential forfor multigenerationalmultigenerational exposureexposure ¾ LittleLittle isis knownknown aboutabout persistence,persistence, fatefate ofof drugsdrugs inin thethe environmentenvironment ¾ SSRIsSSRIs knownknown toto promotepromote spawningspawning inin mollusksmollusks OverallOverall ResearchResearch PlanPlan……
¾ DetermineDetermine environmentalenvironmental fatefate ofof SSRIsSSRIs
z Techniques used for pesticide registration
z Measure hydrolysis, photolysis, metabolism, etc. ¾ MeasureMeasure parentparent andand majormajor degradationdegradation productsproducts
z Wastewater effluent
z Downstream receiving water ¾ DetermineDetermine acute,acute, chronicchronic impactsimpacts toto aquaticaquatic organismsorganisms
z Ceriodaphnia dubia (macroinvertebrate)
z Gambusia affinis (Western mosquito fish)
z Xenopus laevis (frog) ToxicityToxicity TestsTests
¾ TestTest organism:organism: CeriodaphniaCeriodaphnia dubiadubia
¾ AcuteAcute toxicitytoxicity (48(48 h)h) z Single compound exposures z Binary, quaternary mixture exposures z Mortality (LC50) as endpoint
¾ ChronicChronic toxicitytoxicity z 7 day mini-chronic test z Brood size, # broods as endpoints
¾ AllAll teststests followedfollowed USUS EPAEPA protocolsprotocols AcuteAcute ToxicityToxicity (LC50)(LC50) ofof SSRIsSSRIs
SSRI LC50 ppba Citalopram (Celexa®) 3180 (220) Fluvoxamine (Luvox®) 1260 (830) Paroxetine (Paxil®) 470 (60) Fluoxetine (Prozac®) 590 (130) Sertraline (Zoloft®) 140 (20) aMean (± SD) of 3 tests
Henry et al. 2004, Environ Toxicol Chem 23:2229-2233 ChronicChronic ToxicityToxicity ofof SSRIsSSRIs
SSRI NOECa LOECa (ppb) (ppb) Citalopram (Celexa®) 800 4000 Fluvoxamine (Luvox®) 366 1466b Paroxetine (Paxil®) 220 440b Fluoxetine (Prozac®) 89 447b Sertraline (Zoloft®) 9 45 aTotal number of neonates produced over 7-8 d bNumber of broods also significantly reduced
(Henry et al. 2004, Environ Toxicol Chem 23:2229-2233) MixtureMixture ToxicityToxicity (In(In preparation,preparation, HenryHenry andand Black)Black)
Equitoxic Mixture Equal Concentration Mixture
100 100
80 80
60 60
Observed 40 40 % Mortality Model Observed
20 Model CA 20
Model IA
0 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 012345 µM SSRI (quaternary mixture) AcuteAcute ToxicityToxicity ofof FluoxetineFluoxetine toto WesternWestern MosquitofishMosquitofish
¾ 77--dd acuteacute teststests ¾ Endpoints:Endpoints:
z Mortality (LC50)
z Fish behavior
Western mosquitofish Gambusia affinis AcuteAcute ToxicityToxicity ofof FluoxetineFluoxetine toto WesternWestern MosquitofishMosquitofish
¾¾ MortalityMortality
z 77--dayday LC50LC50 == 614614 ppbppb
¾¾ BehavioralBehavioral effectseffects (0.6(0.6 andand 66 ppb)ppb)
z UncoordinatedUncoordinated swimmingswimming
z Lethargy,Lethargy, lacklack ofof responseresponse toto stimulistimuli
z LessLess aggression,aggression, interactioninteraction betweenbetween individualsindividuals ChronicChronic ExposuresExposures inin OutdoorOutdoor MesocosmsMesocosms
•110-L plastic tanks •50 fish/tank •85-d exposure •Water change 1x/wk ChronicChronic TestsTests (140(140 d)d) withwith MosquitofishMosquitofish
z TimeTime toto reproductivereproductive maturitymaturity • Fully developed gonopodium (males) • Formation of black spot (females)
z HistologicalHistological effectseffects onon gonads?gonads?
Male Female
Gonopodium Black Spot EffectEffect ofof FluoxetineFluoxetine onon MaleMale SexualSexual DevelopmentDevelopment
50
a
i 6 ppb
d 40 60 ppb
o
p Control
o
n
o 30
G
*
h
t i 20
w
t *
n
e
c
r 10
e
P
0 020406080100 Days of Exposure*
*Fish were 39-d old at t=0 EffectEffect ofof FluoxetineFluoxetine onon FemaleFemale SexualSexual DevelopmentDevelopment
t 50
o
p Control
S
k 40 6 ppb
c
a l * 60 ppb
B 30
h
t i *
w
t
n 20
e
c
r e 10
P
0 0 1020304050 Days of Exposure* *Fish were 39-d old at t=0 ResearchResearch withwith thethe AfricanAfrican ClawedClawed FrogFrog ((XenopusXenopus laevislaevis))
¾ EasyEasy toto breedbreed inin thethe lablab
z Inject with HCG ¾ TadpoleTadpole toto frogfrog inin 6060--7070 dd ¾ ManyMany measurablemeasurable endpointsendpoints
z Mortality
z Developmental malformations
z Time to metamorphosis WhyWhy StudyStudy Frogs?Frogs?
¾ ThyroidThyroid hormoneshormones (T(T3,T,T4)) cuecue metamorphosismetamorphosis ¾ TadpolesTadpoles withwith nono thyroidthyroid –– metamorphosismetamorphosis inhibitedinhibited
¾ ExposureExposure toto chemicalschemicals thatthat reducereduce circulatingcirculating TT3 willwill delaydelay oror inhibitinhibit metamorphosismetamorphosis RegulationRegulation ofof ThyroidThyroid AxisAxis inin MammalsMammals
Serotonin X X
X Fluoxetine
www.dpcweb.com/images/medicalconditions/thyroid/thyroid%20illustration.jpg
¾ Serotonin inhibits the release of TRH from the hypothalamus in rats
z Mitsuma et al. 1983; Mitsuma et al. 1996 ¾ Fluoxetine reduces circulating T3 and T4; increases TSH
z Golstein et al., 1983 DoesDoes FluoxetineFluoxetine InhibitInhibit FrogFrog Metamorphosis?Metamorphosis?
¾ ExposeExpose tadpolestadpoles fromfrom hatchhatch untiluntil metamorphosismetamorphosis
z FluoxetineFluoxetine (FL):(FL): 0.059,0.059, 0.295,0.295, 2.95,2.95, 29.529.5 ppbppb (measured)(measured)
z AmmoniumAmmonium perchlorateperchlorate (AP):(AP): 1010 ppbppb
z ControlControl (clean(clean exposureexposure water)water) ¾ ObserveObserve dailydaily forfor limblimb developmentdevelopment untiluntil metamorphosismetamorphosis isis completecomplete EffectsEffects ofof ChronicChronic ExposureExposure toto FluoxetineFluoxetine (Xenopus)(Xenopus)
Tadpoles at 57 d* ¾ DevelopmentalDevelopmental delaysdelays
z Forelimb formation
z Tail resorbtion ¾ IncreasedIncreased timetime toto metamorphosismetamorphosis ¾ MortalityMortality
Control 38 ppb FL 9.5 ppb AP
*Data from range-finder experiment. Similar effects at 29.5 ppb in 2nd experiment. EffectEffect ofof ChronicChronic ExposureExposure toto FluoxetineFluoxetine onon TimeTime toto MetamorphosisMetamorphosis
s i * s o 35
h
p r 30
mo
a t 25
e
M
o 20
t
me 15
i
T
n
i 10
e
s
a 5
e
r
c
n 0 I Control 0.059 0.295 2.95 29.5
% Fluoxetine Concentration (ppb) EffectEffect ofof ChronicChronic ExposureExposure toto FluoxetineFluoxetine onon MassMass atat MetamorphosisMetamorphosis
45 * * * 40 * 35 Mass 30 25 20 15
% Reduction in % Reduction 10 5 0 Control 0.059 0.295 2.95 29.5 Fluoxetine Concentration (ppb) EffectsEffects ofof ChronicChronic ExposureExposure toto FluoxetineFluoxetine (Exp.(Exp. 2)2)
¾ LimbLimb malformationsmalformations
z Primary rotation of hindlimbs
z Micromelia of forelimbs
z Dorsal flexure of the tail TimeTime toto OnsetOnset ofof MalformationsMalformations ConclusionsConclusions (so(so farfar……))
¾¾ SSRIsSSRIs areare acutelyacutely toxictoxic toto CeriodaphniaCeriodaphnia andand mosquitofishmosquitofish ¾¾ FluoxetineFluoxetine affectsaffects fishfish behaviorbehavior ¾¾ FluoxetineFluoxetine delaysdelays sexualsexual developmentdevelopment inin fishfish ¾¾ FluoxetineFluoxetine delaysdelays developmentdevelopment andand metamorphosismetamorphosis inin frogsfrogs
None of these effects observed at environmentally-relevant concentrations. ConclusionsConclusions (cont(cont’’d)d)
¾ ReducedReduced massmass andand limblimb malformationsmalformations observedobserved withwith chronicchronic exposureexposure toto FLFL
z Both effects occured at environmentally relevant concentrations
z Mass reductions confirmed in 2 experiments
z Malformation data not yet confirmed • Lower temperature in experiment 2 (19ºC) • Increased exposure duration, TTM • Increased susceptibility of Exp. 2 frogs to developmental disorders? ImplicationsImplications ofof thethe ResearchResearch
¾ DelayedDelayed developmentdevelopment (fish,(fish, frogs)frogs)
z ↑ Predation, dessication (frogs),(frogs), populationpopulation decline?decline? ¾ ReducedReduced massmass andand limblimb malformationsmalformations (frogs)(frogs)
z ↑ Predation, ↓ reproductive success, population decline? Future Research Questions Generated by Research
¾ Conduct additional FL exposure with Xenopus ¾ Validate apparent impact of FL on the thyroid axis by measuring TH, TSH during frog development (with/without FL) ¾ Do other SSRIs have similar effects on frog development and growth? ¾ What is the toxicity of mixtures of SSRIs in the amphibian model? ¾ What are environmentally-relevant SSRI concentrations? AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements
¾ Project Personnel (University of Georgia) z Ted Henry (now at the University of Tennessee) z Emily Rogers (MS Tox 2004; PhD student) z Ben Hale (BS EH, 2004) z Nicole Campbell (BS EH 2003) z Tricia Smith (retired)
¾ Analytical Support (Mississippi State Chemical Lab) z Kevin Armbrust (Project Co-PI) z Jeong-Wook Kwon
¾ Outside Expertise z Kay Millar (US EPA Region IV Lab, Athens, GA) z James Rayburn (Jacksonville State University, AL) AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements
R829006