Global History VOLUME 13 PART 2 ᭿ JULY 2018 ᭿ ISSN 1740-0228 Global History

Journal of Journal of Global History VOLUME 13 PART 2 ᭿ JULY 2018 ᭿ ISSN 1740-0228 Global History

VOLUME 13 PART 2 ᭿ JULY 2018

Contents

157 Editorial – the theory and practice of ecumenism: Christian global governance and the search for world order, 1900–80 Elisabeth Engel, James Kennedy and Justin Reynolds

165 In the shadow of empire: Josef Schmidlin and Protestant–Catholic ecumenism before the Second World War Journal of Albert Wu

188 ‘A Christian solution to international tension’: Nikolai Berdyaev, the American YMCA, and Russian Orthodox influence on Western Christian anti-communism, c.1905–60 Christopher Stroop Global History 209 The ecumenical origins of pan-Africanism: Africa and the ‘Southern Negro’ in the International Missionary Council’s global vision of Christian indigenization in the 1920s Elisabeth Engel

230 From Christian anti-imperialism to postcolonial Christianity: M. M. Thomas and the ecumenical theology of communism in the 1940s and 1950s Justin Reynolds

252 From religious freedom to social justice: the human rights engagement of the ecumenical movement from the 1940s to the 1970s Bastiaan Bouwman VOLUME 274 Between context and conflict: the ‘boom’ of Latin American Protestantism in the ecumenical movement (1955–75) Annegreth Schilling

13 294 REVIEWS

PART

᭿

JULY

2018

® Cambridge Core MIX For further information about this journal Paper from responsible sources please go to the journal web site at: ® cambridge.org/jgh FSC C007785

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.33.19, on 26 Sep 2021 at 06:46:29, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1740022818000013 Journal of Global History

Instructions to Contributors Chief Editor Editorial Board Professor Dominic Lieven University of Cambridge, UK Professor William Gervase Professor Ravi Ahuja Editorial Policy Illustrations: should if possible be digital, of high Chapters in books fi rst: Clarence-Smith University of Göttingen, Germany Professor Mary Jo Maynes The Journal of Global History seeks scholarly articles resolution (300 dpi), and transmitted electronically. Yacine D. Addoun and Paul E. Lovejoy, SOAS, University of London that explore global change. Conscious of past In some cases, they may be sent on a computer disk ‘Muhammad Kaba Saghanughu and the Muslim Professor Gareth Austin University of Minnesota, USA historiographical inequities, the journal particularly (Macintosh or PC) to the above address. If community of Jamaica,’ in Paul E. Lovejoy, ed., Department of History University of Cambridge, UK Dr Anna-Maria Misra welcomes contributions from Asia, Africa and Latin photographs are sent by post, they should be black Slavery on the frontiers of Islam, Princeton: Thornhaugh Street America. The editors appreciate submissions from and white glossy prints. Maps sent by post must be Markus Wiener, 2004, pp. 199-202. Professor Maxine Berg London WC1H 0XG, UK University of Oxford, UK both senior fi gures in the fi eld and younger scholars submitted in camera-ready form. All illustrations Warwick University, UK wishing to situate detailed research in a wider context. should be clearly referenced in the text, and Chapters in books subsequent: E-mail: [email protected] Professor Kenneth Pomeranz The journal also publishes survey articles, think-pieces references to sources and descriptive headings must Yacine and Lovejoy, ‘Muhammad Kaba Dr John Chalcraft University of Chicago and selected book reviews. The editorial philosophy be attached. Saghanughu’, pp. 204-5. is to encourage disciplined diversity, disciplined London School of Economics and A mailing address: should be supplied separately for through rigorous peer-review, and diverse in points Unpublished theses fi rst: Editors Professor Shalini Randeria the author(s). Political Science, UK of view. Every yearly volume of the journal consists of Azyumardi Azra, ‘The transmission of Islamic Graduate Institute of reformism to Indonesia: networks of Middle Professor Barbara Watson Andaya Professor David Christian three parts. 3. Text conventions Eastern and Malay-Indonesian ulama in the University of Hawai‘i International and Development Reviews of books: The journal only publishes reviews Spelling: British with ‘ize’ preferred over ‘ise’. Macquarie University, Australia seventeenth and eighteenth centuries,’ PhD Thesis, that centrally address problems of global history. Where foreign language words have achieved Center for Southeast Asian Studies Studies / Institut de hautes University of Columbia, 1992, p. 123. Professor Felipe Fernández-Armesto Publishers are invited to send to the Reviews Editor common currency, they should not be italicised and Moore Hall 411, études internationales et du announcements of forthcoming or recently published accents should be omitted – e.g. elite. Foreign words Unpublished theses subsequent: University of Notre Dame, USA books that they think would be of interest to global 1890 East West Road Honolulu, développement, Switzerland not assimilated into English (e.g. santri) should be Azra, ‘The transmission’, pp. 214-17. HI 96822, USA Professor Ulrike Freitag historians. They are asked not to send books for re- italicised throughout, not just where they occur for Professor Patricia Seed view unless specifi cally required to do so. Unrequested E-mail: [email protected] Free University of Berlin, Germany the fi rst time, and should have the necessary accents Unpublished papers fi rst: University of California, books will not be returned. Requested books should or diacritics. Capitals should be kept to a minimum, Gulay Yarikkaya, ‘Becoming a devsirme in the Professor Olivier Grenouilleau be sent to the LSE address indicated below. but should always be used where individual people or Ottoman empire,’ unpublished paper for ‘Children Irvine, USA Professor Merry E. Wiesner-Hanks Centre Roland Mousnier, Paris-IV Reviews Editor places are referred to specifi cally. in Slavery’ conference, Avignon, 19-21 May 2004, pp 1-4. University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Sorbonne, France Dr Gagan Sood Dr Ronald C. Po Numbers: up to 100 should normally be spelled in full. Days of the week and months of the year should Department of History Department of International History Unpublished papers subsequent: Professor Nelly Hanna London School of Economics and appear in full, as should centuries, thus eighteenth Holton Hall 2442 E. Hartford London School of Economics and Political Science Yarikkaya, ‘Becoming a devsirme’, p. 6. American University in Cairo, Egypt Political Science, UK Houghton Street century. In citations, the least number of fi gures Milwaukee WI 53211 London WC2A 2AE, UK should be used in connection with dates and Internet references fi rst: USA Professor Marnie Hughes-Warrington Professor Kaoru Sugihara E-mail: [email protected] pages - thus 241-5, except with the numbers 10-19 Hasan al-Banna, ‘Peace in Islam’, 1997, http:// in each hundred, which should be cited as 112-13, www.youngmuslims.ca/online_library/books/ E-mail: [email protected] Australian National University, National Graduate Institute for 1. Submission not 112-3. peace_in_islam/ (consulted 29 October 2004) Australia Policy Studies, Japan If at all possible, articles submitted for consideration should be e-mailed, as Microsoft Word attachments Abbreviations: should be followed by a full point; Dr Ronald C. Po Professor Joseph E. Inikori contractions should not. Full points should be omitted Internet references subsequent: (please do not use pdf fi les), to: [email protected] Banna, ‘Peace in Islam’ London School of Economics University of Rochester, USA Managing Editor in initials which are read as words, as in USA, BBC, Length: Articles should be no longer than 12,500 but retained for authors’ initials, thus J. G. A. Pocock. and Political Science Archives fi rst: Pauline Khng words, including footnotes, unless authors obtain Quotations: of more than 60 words should be Professor Li Bozhong Arsip Nasional Republik Indonesia, Jakarta, Department of International History previous permission from the editors. The length of separated out from the text and indented, without Tsinghua University, China Journal of Global History Residency Records (henceforth ANRI, RR) 29, Houghton Street review articles and reviews will be set on a case by quotation marks. All citations in a language other than 580, Gouverneur van Amboina, ‘Algemeen E-mail: [email protected] case basis by editors. English should be translated into English, and should London WC2A 2AE, UK Professor Victor Lieberman verslag’, 29 December 1839. E-mail: [email protected] University of Michigan, USA Website: cambridge.org/jgh Language: All material should be written in English, thus be kept short. and an English translation of all quotations in another Footnotes: should be numbered in one sequence, Archives subsequent: language must be provided. identifi ed by a superior number in the text, and appear ANRI, RR, 30, 121, H. P. van Duyvenboden to H. Conditions: Submission will be taken to imply that at the foot of the page. They should not contain any van der Twist, Ternate, 18 August 1879. Journal of Global History is published by Canada and Mexico) plus postage. EU not extend to multiple copying for promotional substantive text, but should be used to indicate material is unpublished in an academic journal or 4. Copyright Cambridge University Press. subscribers (outside the UK) who are not or commercial purposes. Code 1740-0228/18. book, and is not being considered for publication sources. The author(s) will be asked to assign copyright (on registered for VAT should add VAT at their ISI Tear Sheet Service, 3501 Market Street, elsewhere, even in a language other than English. Journal of Global History is indexed and References should take the form of a full citation certain conditions) to Cambridge University Press. country’s rate. VAT registered members should Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA, is authorized Exceptions may be made for articles published abstracted in the following Thomson-Reuters in the fi rst instance, followed by short citations. Contributors are responsible for obtaining provide their VAT registration number. to supply single copies of separate articles for elsewhere in minority languages. product services: Arts and Humanities Citation Do not abbreviate journal titles. Ibid. should only permission to reproduce any material in which they do ® ® Japanese prices for institutions (including private use only. Organizations authorized by be used to refer to the immediately preceding citation. Index ; Current Contents /Arts & Humanities; 2. Manuscript preparation not hold copyright for world-wide publication in all ASP delivery) are available from Kinokuniya the Copyright Licensing Agency may also copy Do not use op. cit. Please use the following Current Contents®/Social and Behavioral Once an article has been accepted for publication in forms and media, including electronic publication, and Company Ltd, P.O. Box 55, Chitose, Tokyo material subject to the usual conditions. For all conventions (note that these examples are in Sciences; Journal Citation Reports/ Social principle, authors should make any revisions requested for ensuring that the appropriate acknowledgements British English): Sciences Edition; Social Sciences Citation Index® 156, Japan. other use, permission should be sought from by editors. The fi nal version should be sent as an e-mail are included in their text. Cambridge or from the American Branch of Orders, which must be accompanied by attachment in Microsoft Word, to the e-mail address Books fi rst: Subscriptions Cambridge University Press. 5. Proofs payment, may be sent to a bookseller, given above. In cases of hard copy, two copies should Masykuri Abdillah, Responses of Indonesian Typographical or factual errors only may be changed at Journal of Global History (ISSN 1740-0228) is subscription agent or direct to the publisher: Journal of Global History is available on be sent to the above address, double-spaced Muslim intellectuals to the concept of democracy, proof stage. The publisher reserves the right to charge published three times a year in March, July and Cambridge University Press, UPH, Shaftesbury Cambridge Core which can be found at http:// throughout, including notes. 1966-1993, Hamburg: Abera, 1997, pp. 181-7. authors for correction of non-typographical errors. All November. Three parts form a volume. The An abstract: of 100-150 words should be provided. Road, Cambridge CB2 8BS; or in the USA, cambridge.org/jgh. For further information on amendments need to be agreed by the journal editors. subscription price which includes delivery by air Bibliography: Do not include a consolidated list of Books subsequent: Canada and Mexico: Cambridge University other Press journals access http://cambridge.org Any corrections that contradict JGH house style will where appropriate (but excluding VAT) of references at the end of the article. Abdillah, Responses, pp. 190-1. Press, 1 Liberty Plaza, Floor 20, New York, © Cambridge University Press, 2018 not be transferred. Authors are not shown second volume 13, 2018, which includes print and NY 10006, USA. Footnotes: should be numbered consecutively Articles fi rst: page proofs which are checked by journal. online access, is £252 (US $432 in USA, Canada This journal issue has been printed on throughout and appear at the foot of the page, or at Sultana Afroz, ‘From Moors to marronage: The editors reserve the right to make fi nal editorial and Mexico) for institutions; £31 (US $57 in Copying FSC™-certifi ed paper and cover board. FSC is an the end of the article. the Islamic heritage of the maroons of Jamaica’, decisions. USA, Canada and Mexico) for individuals, This journal is registered with the Copyright independent, nongovernmental, not-for-profi t Tables: should be placed at the end of the article, and Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, 19, 2, which includes print only. Students ordering Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, organization established to promote the clear instructions should be provided for the typesetter 1999, pp. 114-15. 6. Off prints direct from the publishers and certifying that the Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Organizations in the responsible management of the world’s forests. as to where each one should be inserted in the text. Authors will receive a link to the PDF of their article journal is for their personal use can subscribe USA who are also registered with the C.C.C. Please see www.fsc.org for information. A descriptive heading and references to sources must Articles subsequent: after publication. Offprints may be purchased at to the print version at £21 (US $38 in USA, may therefore copy material (beyond the limits accompany each table. Afroz, ‘From Moors to marronage’, pp. 121-3. proof stage. Canada and Mexico). The online-only price permitted by sections 107 and 108 of U.S. available to institutions is £227 (US $391). Copyright law) subject to payment to the C.C.C. Single parts are £97 (US $166 in USA, of the per copy fee of $15.00. This consent does Printed in the UK by Bell & Bain Ltd

CONTENTS 157 Editorial – the theory and practice of ecumenism: Christian global governance and the search for world order, 1900–80 Elisabeth Engel, James Kennedy and Justin Reynolds 165 In the shadow of empire: Josef Schmidlin and Protestant–Catholic ecumenism before the Second World War Albert Wu 188 ‘A Christian solution to international tension’: Nikolai Berdyaev, the American YMCA, and Russian Orthodox influence on Western Christian anti-communism, c.1905–60 Christopher Stroop 209 The ecumenical origins of pan-Africanism: Africa and the ‘Southern Negro’ in the International Missionary Council’s global vision of Christian indigenization in the 1920s Elisabeth Engel 230 From Christian anti-imperialism to postcolonial Christianity: M. M. Thomas and the ecumenical theology of communism in the 1940s and 1950s Justin Reynolds 252 From religious freedom to social justice: the human rights engagement of the ecumenical movement from the 1940s to the 1970s Bastiaan Bouwman 274 Between context and conflict: the ‘boom’ of Latin American Protestantism in the ecumenical movement (1955–75) Annegreth Schilling

BOOK REVIEWS 294 David MacKenzie on Susan Pedersen’s The guardians: the League of Nations and the crisis of empire 296 David Abulafia on David Armitage’s Oceanic histories 299 Rachel Steely on Ina Baghdiantz McCabe’s A history of global consumption, 1500–1800 301 April Merleaux on Michael Fakhri’s Sugar and the making of international trade law 303 Nelida Fuccaro on Carol Shammas’s Investing in the early modern built environment: Europeans, Asians, settlers and indigenous societies