Critical Thinking: Its Representation in Indonesian ELT Textbooks and Education
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Critical Thinking: Its Representation in Indonesian ELT Textbooks and Education Hamzah Puadi Ilyas PhD University of York Education February 2015 Abstract My original contribution to knowledge consists in generating a new critical thinking framework that can be used to investigate the elements of critical thinking in textbooks. The framework, however, can also be used as a guideline for teachers who are concerned with the development of learners’ critical thinking skills. Critical thinking has been included in an Indonesian government document as an educational objective; however, it is currently neglected and not seriously disseminated in schools. This study attempts to investigate to what extent critical thinking has been manifested in textbooks in Indonesia and to what extent Indonesian senior secondary school students are ready for the teaching of critical thinking skills. To this end, the study investigates the elements of critical thinking contained in Indonesian ELT textbooks and students’ responses to modified materials containing elements of critical thinking. Three methods are adopted: content analysis, qualitative analysis of students’ written responses, and interviews. Predetermined analytic categories are used to analyse nine Indonesian ELT textbooks used by senior secondary schools. The categories have been created as a result of evaluating, examining, and synthesising Bloom’s and Freeman’s critical thinking taxonomies, critical thinking strategies from empirical studies, critical thinking programmes created by critical thinking authorities and critical thinking tests. The findings of the content analysis show that the textbooks examined do contain a few elements of critical thinking. Critical thinking questions occupy 15.81% of all of the questions analysed. As the literature has stated that facilitating students’ critical thinking needs to be progressive, the findings suggest that most activities in the textbooks can be used at a basic level in scaffolding to promote students’ critical thinking skills and that more critical thinking activities must be developed by teachers. Promoting Indonesian students’ critical thinking skills is possible as the findings of materials implementation and interviews indicate that the students have the potential to be critical. The findings also show that students are ready to accept the teaching of critical thinking skills. 2 Table of contents Abstract ……………………………………………………………………………2 Table of contents …………………………………………………………………..3 List of tables ……………………………………………………………………….8 List of figures ……………………………………………………………………..10 Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………….12 Declaration ………………………………………………………………………..13 Chapter 1: Introduction and thesis overview 1.1 Introduction …………………………………………………………………14 1.2 Background to the study ……………………………………………….........14 1.3 Research problem and questions ……………………………………………16 1.4 Justification for the study and its contributions to the field of education and ELT ………………………………………..………………...18 1.5 A brief overview of the methods…………………………………………….20 1.6 The structure of this thesis …………………………………………………..21 Chapter 2: Indonesian research context 2.1 Introduction …………………………………………………………………23 2.2 Educational system in Indonesia ……………………………………………23 2.3 ELT in Indonesia ……………………………………………………………28 2.4 Critical thinking and socio-political conditions in Indonesia ……………….39 2.5 Indonesian ELT textbooks ………………………………………………......43 Chapter 3: Review of the literature 3.1 Introduction …………………………………………………………………46 3.2 Critical thinking: A theoretical discussion ……………………..…………...46 3 3.3 The discussion of various constructs of critical thinking and of their use in research ………………………………………………….…………59 3.3.1 Critical thinking taxonomies ……………………………………….59 3.3.2 Critical thinking strategies …………………………………………65 i. A review of empirical studies containing critical thinking strategies ………………………………………………………65 ii. An examination of the key ideas of critical thinking strategies ………………………………………………………78 3.3.3 Critical thinking programmes ……………………………………...81 3.3.4 Critical thinking tests ………………………………………………95 3.3.5 Equation and evaluation of key ideas of critical thinking taxonomies, strategies, programmes and tests for their use in this study ………………………………………………………..97 3.4 The implementation of critical thinking in education, especially in ELT, of non-Western countries …………………………………….....99 3.4.1 A debate on critical thinking in ELT ………………………………99 3.4.2 Critical thinking in non-Western education ……………………...102 i. The importance of, and educational policies on critical thinking in non-Western countries …………………………..103 ii. Empirical studies on critical thinking in non-Western countries ……………………………………………………..112 iii. Reasons of adopting critical thinking and actual practices in non-Western countries ……………………………………116 Chapter 4: Methodology of the study 4.1 Introduction …………………………………………………………….122 4.2 Research worldviews …..……………………………………………….122 4.3 Research scope …………………………………………………………125 4.3.1 Textbooks ………………………………………………………...125 4.3.2 Participants ……………………………………………………….128 4.4 Data collection and analysis methods …………………………………..129 4.4.1 Content analysis …………………………………………………..130 4 4.4.2 Qualitative analysis of text-based responses ………………………139 4.4.3 Interview …………………………………………………………...142 4.5 Pilot study ………………………………………………………………..145 4.5.1 Content analysis ……………………………………………………145 4.5.2 Materials implementation and interview …………………………..150 4.6 Validity and reliability …………………………………………………...158 4.7 Analysis triangulation ……………………………………………………160 Chapter 5: Critical thinking activities in Indonesian ELT textbooks - Findings and discussion. 5.1 Introduction …………………………………………………………….…161 5.2 Types of questions found in the textbooks ………………………………..162 5.3 Textually-explicit questions ………………………………………………163 5.4 Elements of analytic categories found in the open questions ……………..173 i. Word clarification …………………………………………………..177 ii. Phrase/expression clarification ……………………………………...178 iii. Sentence/clause clarification ………………………………………..178 iv. Poetic expression clarification ………………………………………179 v. Supporting/arguing the answer ……………………………………...182 vi. Stating the argument/reason …………………………………………184 vii. Direct-viewpoint questions ………………………………………….186 viii. Viewpoint on yes/no questions ……………………………………...187 ix. Viewpoint on Wh-questions …………………………………………187 x. Viewpoint on literary work-related questions ……………………….188 5.5 Elements of analytic categories found in the closed questions …………………………………………………………………...195 5.6 Categories emerging outside the predermined analytic categories …………………………………………………………………..199 i. Finding antecedent …………………………………………………..203 5 ii. Finding synonyms …………………………………………………...205 iii. Text analysis ………………………………………………………...206 5.7 The critical thinking categories ……………………………………………210 5.8 Critical thinking, literature and ESOL …………………………………….215 5.9 Textbooks and critical thinking skills ……………………………………..220 5.10 The authors of the textbooks ………………………………………………221 Chapter 6: Students’ responses to modified teaching materials containing the elements of critical thinking - Findings and discussion 6.1 Introduction ……………………………………………………………….224 6.2 Students’ written responses to modified reading questions ………………225 6.3 Students’ responses to the interview ……………………………………...254 6.4 Critical thinking and non-Western students ………………………………262 6.5 Critical thinking, religious beliefs and cultural background ……………...265 Chapter 7: Conclusions 7.1 Introduction ……………………………………………………………….267 7.2 A summary of findings ……………………………………………………267 7.3 Significance of the findings ……………………………………………….271 7.4 Limitations ………………………………………………………………...272 7.5 Recommendations …………………………………………………………273 7.6 Implications ………………………………………………………………..274 Appendices Appendix 1 ……………………………………………………………………....278 Appendix 2 ……………………………………………………………………....281 Appendix 3 ……………………………………………………………………....282 Appendix 4 ……………………………………………………………………....288 Appendix 5 ……………………………………………………………………....297 6 Appendix 6 ……………………………………………………………………....298 Appendix 7 ……………………………………………………………………....303 Appendix 8 ……………………………………………………………………....311 List of abbreviations …………………………………………………………….322 References ……………………………………………………………………....324 7 List of tables Table 2.1 Competency standard of English lesson - class X semester 1 ………………………………………………………….34 Table 3.1 Key ideas of Bloom’s and Freeman’s taxonomies having the potential to promote critical thinking ……………………………...64 Table 3.2 Dantas-Whitney’s audiotaped journal assignment ………………...67 Table 3.3 Daud and Husin’s descriptions of lessons …………………………69 Table 3.4 Norris and Ennis’ list of critical thinking skills …………………...71 Table 3.5 Park’s critical engagement strategies ……………………………...73 Table 3.6 Shahini and Riazi’s PBLT strategies ………………………………74 Table 3.7 Yang and Gamble’s instructional procedure for the experimental group ……………………………………………….. 77 Table 3.8 The key ideas of teaching strategies promoting students’ critical thinking skills ……………………………………………...80 Table 3.9 Taxonomy of Socratic Questions (TSQ) …………………………..82 Table 3.10 Cognitive acceleration through the Arts …………………………...83 Table 3.11 Feuerstein’s Instrumental Enrichment ……………………………..85 Table 3.12 Top Ten Thinking Tactics …………………………………………86 Table 3.13 Six themes of CoRT programme …………………………………..87 Table 3.14 Swartz and Park’s Thinking Skills Taxonomy …………………….89 Table 3.15 Six Thinking Hats ………………………………………………….90 Table 3.16 Fisher’s story-based critical thinking activities (FSBA) …………..91 Table 3.17 Key ideas of critical