Part I – David's Life This part of the book contains a chronological account of David's life. It also includes, in appropriate places, much of David's written work, such as: compositions, essays, book plans, presentations, and the like, and some pictures of his art, notably, the windows. However, because of the sheer volume of what he left and I chose to record, I have decided to include much of his art work in a separate section, at the end, called Part II. Growing Up This section covers David's life through high school graduation.
Newark, New Jersey at St. Michael's ,(ד' טבת התשכ"ד David was born on December 19, 1963 (corresponding to hospital, in Newark, New Jersey. He weighed 8 pounds and 6 ounces at birth, and was 22 inches long. For the record, it also became clear later that he was left handed. The Sandek at his Brit was Rabbi David Lifshitz, who had been Saba Wolicki's teacher in Yeshiva University. His godmother was his grandmother (my mother) Pearl (Peshe Rachel Etshokin DuBow) Dwork. David was named after my father, David Daniel DuBow. The mohel was Rabbi Mordecai Zimmerman. David was a hungry baby, who ate eagerly and slept a lot. He found and started sucking his thumb by the time he was three weeks old. Maybe that was the reason that he did not cry a lot. When he first stirred, he sucked his thumb and only started to cry when he was really hungry. Then, he had to be fed right away. After eating, he also sucked his thumb. This helped him settle down and go to sleep easily. In any case, I remember him as a very easy and predictable baby. It was a good thing, because I was a very inexperienced mother, having had little exposure to babies before my own. When David was born, we lived in a two bedroom apartment at 240 Mt. Vernon Place, in the Ivy Hill apartment complex, on the outer city limits of Newark, New Jersey, and across the street from a lovely park. 1964, Three Months I went for long walks with David almost every day, for a number of reasons. I liked to walk, David liked the walks, and it enabled me to run errands. As a baby, David smiled readily at everyone. As a result of his enchanting a group of elderly ladies in the park, they got together and bought him a highchair. Another gift that David received when he was born was a multi-colored, zigzag crocheted afghan blanket. A lady named Mrs. Clumpus made it for him. He kept that blanket on the end of his bed for years. Around the time of his death, it was still used as a throw in his living room. I repaired it a few times. The last repair was a new white crocheted edge. David stood up quite early. He first learned to stand up by himself in the crib when he was about six months old. For a short time, he would stand up and then cry because he couldn't figure out how to sit down. But, he soon solved that problem. At that time, we had no carpet, but we did have a lightweight coffee table that was just the Growing Up, Wallingford, Connecticut right height for David. He would stand up at one end of it and start taking steps. As a result, one end of the coffee table would start to slide on the floor. However, since the other end did not move, David would end up going around in circles, much like oxen did centuries ago at grinding wheels.
Wallingford, Connecticut In July, when David was seven months old, we moved to 93 Constitution Street in Wallingford, Connecticut. David was already standing up by himself by this time. By ten months, he was walking without holding onto anything. This was good for me, because I was already expecting his brother Zvi in March. We continued to take frequent walks. We lived in a three bedroom, split-level house that was surrounded by lots of very tall trees. There was no sidewalk in front of the house. There was a steep hill from the front of the house down to the street. In back of the house, the land extended uphill. A small piece was grass and the rest was untouched forest. It was in this house that David first encountered stairs. One day, on the way into the house, when he was just learning to talk, he proudly announced, "I gupping the stairs". Just outside David's bedroom window there was a large bush in which some robins chose to build a nest. We were able to see the sky blue eggs and watch the young birds hatch, eat, grow and fly away. David loved to watch them. This love of nature continued all his life. David was very aware of the world around him and loved to observe the sky, trees, animals and everything in nature. 1964, Nine Months In the fall, we had huge piles of brightly colored leaves. David loved to play in the leaves while I raked them into piles. We purchased a swing-set for the backyard and David (and later Zvi) often played on it. A friend offered us a small gray kitten. It was very cute, so we accepted it. We called it Smokey. However, as the kitten grew, it needed places to sharpen its claws. Also, it learned that there were many small animals living in the trees that surrounded our house. By the time Zvi was born (when David was almost 15 months old), we had to give the (by now) cat to a local farm. Smokey stayed out all night and caught his own food anyway. We were afraid the cat would bring home fleas and give them to Zvi in his playpen. One morning (before Zvi was born), David was following me around my bedroom and fell. He hit himself on the footboard of my bed and needed stitches just above his eye. It was very frightening for me, but it turned out to be not very serious, although it could have been. I also remember David having a bad bout of croup, which wasn't really serious either. However, as I said earlier, I was an inexperienced mother and his loud barking coughs and high temperature made a strong impression on me. Other than these incidents, I remember David as a sturdy, healthy child, who was always on the upper end of the size charts and ate well. He especially loved yoghurt. His favorite flavors were strawberry, prune and coffee. Growing Up, Mt. Clemens, Michigan
Zvi was born when David was 14 and a half months old. David was a calm baby, who woke up at six in the morning, took regular long naps and was asleep for the night by six in the evening (with the help of his thumb and his favorite yellow thermal blanket). Since Zvi's addition to the family did not upset his routine very much, he did not show any noticeable reaction to his new brother. David, Zvi and I spent a lot of time out of doors. When we moved to Connecticut, we purchased our own washing machine. However, since we did not yet have a dryer, I hung the clothes outside on lines most of the time. While I hung and took in the clothes, David and Zvi played outside with me. We also continued our long walks (we would be out for an hour or two), with Zvi in the carriage and David sitting on a seat resting across it or walking. 1965, One Year and a Half We would go into the center of town (a 15 minute walk away) to the library, shopping or just enjoying the weather. At that time, David and Zvi were both very nervous around dogs. The family across the street from us had some very large, noisy, and aggressive dogs. However, another family not too far from us had two young playful dogs that were also noisy, but friendly. These dogs were kept tied in front of their house on chains. So we spent several afternoons sitting just out of range of those dogs, just watching them jump and play. Eventually, the boys got used to them and recognized that their barking and jumping was just playfulness. From that time on, neither was afraid of dogs anymore.
Mt. Clemens, Michigan In May of 1966, when David was just under two and a half years old, David's second brother, Eliav was born. Then, in July of that same year we moved again, this time to Mt. Clemens, Michigan. We moved into a three bedroom home that had been built before indoor plumbing. We had big flat lawns in the front and back of the house, several huge lilac bushes, very tall walnut trees in the back, plum trees, a climbable apple tree, and dirt that provided many hours of fun for the boys, especially after a rain. While the boys played outside in the dirt with their trucks, I began working on an old round wood table that we found in the garage. When I first discovered it, it had the remains of several coats of peeling paint, but it was very sturdy. I started removing the paint and later, sanded, stained and refinished the table. We used it for years and later gave it to Zvi. He used it for a few years and passed it on to David. The table held his fish tank in his home in Ginot Shomron for many years. As I write this, it is still in use, now in Benjie's living room. I suspect this and my many other do-it-yourself projects may have been partly responsible for the interest in this kind of thing on the part of my sons, especially David. Also, the fact that we took so many walks and were surrounded by so many magnificent trees and much nature may have heightened David's awareness and interest in his natural environment. By this time, when I walked with the three boys, David was on foot. It didn't seem to faze Growing Up, Mt. Clemens, Michigan
him. He was always a good walker and we all enjoyed it as we explored our neighborhood and ran errands. While we lived in Michigan, when David was four years old, his third brother, Benjie was born. In Michigan I started taking the boys to shul. I arranged for a non-Jewish baby sitter to come to the house for a few hours on Shabbat morning. Then I would walk with David (usually) to shul, just in time for the closing communal singing. One Simchat Torah, when David was four and a half years old, we went to shul. There was a table set up in the shul for the men to make Kiddush after getting an Aliyah. David approached the table and helped himself to what he thought was apple juice. He liked apple juice very much so he drank it right down. It turned out to be whiskey. David never learned to like whiskey, or any alcoholic beverages for that matter, including dry wine. He did use sweet wine for Kiddush on Shabbat and Chagim. 1966, Two and a Half Years In Mt. Clemens, David attended story hour at the local library every week and a morning nursery program. He also liked watching TV. As a young child, his favorites were Mr. Rogers, the Friendly Giant and Sesame Street. He always watched very intently, almost hypnotized. He would become extremely annoyed if others made noise or distracted him. This "TV watching style" was uniquely his and notably different from the TV watching style of some of his brothers. It lasted all his life. Around this time, I noticed that David only sucked his thumb when he was very tired. So, I suggested to him that if he continued to suck his thumb, it would make his teeth grow crooked. From that time, he stopped. I was amazed. It is usually very hard to get a child who sucks his thumb to stop. My guess is that he must have been almost ready to stop anyway. However, it is also possible that he simply took what I said very seriously. It is only with hindsight and later knowledge of David as an adult that I became aware of just how deeply he pondered and thought about things, especially himself. Although he didn't express his thoughts and feelings very much as a child, I know that the adult David was extremely critical of himself, aware of the gaps between reality and what he thought he should be, and always conscious of his position as the oldest child. This focus on himself and on the wish for the ideal (in this case, to do the right thing) may have been partly responsible for his stopping his thumb-sucking so readily. David loved all kinds of music. I frequently played a wide variety of music on our phonograph – Jewish and secular children's and popular songs, classical Jewish and Hassidic music, light classical, country, and other. Years later, in Israel, when the phonograph was becoming obsolete, David undertook the job of transferring all of our favorite records onto tapes. After completing the task, he told me how much he enjoyed doing it because it brought back to him music that he remembered from his childhood. In our last year in Mt. Clemens, when he was four and a half, David started attending kindergarten every morning in Detroit. Saba drove him there every day. A Mother's Day present that he made the following May (age five and a half) records his height as 44 and a Growing Up, Cleveland, Ohio half inches tall (1.13 meters) and his weight as 50 pounds (22.5 kilograms). It also shows full hand prints and includes the following poem (written by the teacher): You clean my prints from wall to door for I'm not careful when I play. But here's a pair you'll want to keep. They're made for you this Mother's Day. Love, David W.
Right hand actual size: • Tip of thumb to tip of pinky,14.3 cm (5 5/8") • Tip of pointer to outside corner of palm, 12.7 cm (5") Left hand actual size: • Tip of thumb to tip of pinky 14.6 cm (5.75") • Tip of middle finger to base of palm 12.7 cm (5")
Cleveland, Ohio In 1969, when David was five and a half years old, we moved to 3662 Bendemeer Road in Cleveland Heights, Ohio. The move to Cleveland brought a number of changes in David's life that were probably significant for him. The first was the death of his paternal grandfather (and the subsequent frequent visits of Grandma Wolicki). The second was the fact that he started first grade at a school to which he walked by himself. In addition, we were now living in a religious Jewish neighborhood, which meant that David and his brothers now had Jewish children as playmates. Finally, in February of 1970, David's brother Pesach was born. When Pesach was born, and for a short while after, Grandma Wolicki (Saba's mother) came to help. This was the first of many extended visits she spent with us. She was a very special person and I believe she had a strong impact on David and his brothers. (David named his first daughter Miriam after her.) Later, David always got along very well with people at least a generation older than he was - the older the better. I think it was a combination of the facts Growing Up, Cleveland, Ohio that older people tend to be more honest, and they make fewer demands, that made him so comfortable with them. (See also "My Grandmother" on page 28 and "On Who He Is" on page 47.) Ours was a lively household, but disciplined. Everyone was wide awake by six a.m., ate breakfast by 6:10, and went to bed at fixed times. David, Zvi, and Eliav slept in the same room (David and Zvi in a bunk bed), and went to bed at almost the same time. I would read stories every night before bedtime. When they were in bed, I would say Shma with them. Often, I would sit on the floor outside their room until they quieted down and fell asleep. Sometimes, I would sing songs to them while they were falling asleep. David started wearing glasses in 1971 when he was seven. I don't remember it being an issue with him. After all, all the adults around him wore them. One summer, David went to a day camp. One day, while playing on a slide at this day camp, David fell and landed on his head. We were very frightened and David was hospitalized over night. The diagnosis was that he had had a hairline fracture in his skull and no other noticeable ill effects. However, we were cautioned to keep our eyes open for other possible problems, such as seizures. In retrospect, that event may have had some relevance to the headaches he suffered later and, subsequently, to the hemorrhage that caused 1971, Seven Years Old his death. It was in Cleveland that the older boys started taking breakfast for themselves. In the summer, they also often took lunch for themselves. At the beginning they often left a mess, so I didn't watch. But, they took the first step toward self-reliance by learning to make simple meals for themselves. In later years, David thanked me for teaching him his way around in the kitchen. David got his first bicycle in Cleveland. He would play on the street with all the other kids. Some had bikes and knew how to ride and some didn't. At first David couldn't seem to get the hang of it. In fact, his brother Eliav was the first of the boys to learn to ride without training wheels. Zvi learned the same summer, soon after Eliav. Then, one day all the kids were playing and David, as usual, was on his bike, pushing himself along with his feet on the ground. At some point, in his eagerness to keep up with the others, he must have picked up his feet and started pedaling. He ran into the house very excited yelling, "I can ride, I can ride." He hadn't been trying at that point in time, but learned almost by accident. Throughout David's childhood, David was tall for his age. Because he was bright, he was deemed ready to start school the September before he turned five. However, even allowing for the fact that he started school early (his birthday was in December), he was usually the tallest in his class. Consequently, teachers in school and others outside of school all expected him to behave as though he were older. To this day, I believe that this had an impact on his self-image. He agonized for years about not meeting the expectations of first his parents, then his teachers, and finally of himself. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
We stayed in Cleveland while David was in first, second, and third grades. As a student, David was unpredictable. Sometimes he was very good, and sometimes he just tuned out. He was not a troublemaker, but he didn't always do what he was asked to do. I sat with him often while he did his homework. Neither of us enjoyed the experience.
1972, Eight Years Old
Montreal, Quebec In September of 1972, we moved to 2515 Badeaux Street in Ville St. Laurent, Montreal, Canada. David was eight years old. In Montreal, David had some major adjustments to make. The boys now went to school by car. We did not live in a neighborhood that was walking distance from the school and all of their friends from school lived far away. As a result, they spent most of their time playing with one another. This was mostly on Shabbat afternoon because during the week, the boys spent long hours in school and there was very little time for playing after they got home. In the early years in Montreal, we allowed some television watching in the evening. I would provide critical comment, a practice not appreciated by my sons at that time. David was one of those most annoyed by my interruption of his concentration. I was particularly annoyed by the foolish behavior of adults and smart-alecky children in what was classified as "sitcoms" and therefore, suitable for the young. To this day, I believe that my comments played a part in developing the ability in my sons to not accept blindly Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
what they see, but instead to think independently and draw their own conclusions. This ability to think critically and independently sometimes got them (especially David) into trouble, but more often (I believe), proved valuable.
School
Another change in the school situation was that in Montreal, French was a serious part of the school curriculum. Most of David's classmates had already had some exposure to the language, both in school and from the environment. Although David learned enough French to meet the government requirements, he never overcame his initial disadvantage. In addition, it was in Montreal that one of his teachers noticed that although David could see what was on the blackboard, he had trouble with work at his desk, especially keeping his finger on the place in texts. It turned out that, although he had glasses that enabled him to see distance, he was having trouble with his vision for things that were close. In other words, he needed bifocals. Getting the right glasses helped his vision problem. Unfortunately, it was harder to correct the cumulative effect of not pleasing the teacher and not knowing what was going on for an unknown period of time. 1972, Eight Years Old David remained an erratic (sometimes excelling and sometimes failing) student, with a tendency to daydream until he was out of formal schooling. He did well in subjects he liked, but refused to apply himself when faced with a challenge. He was strong in English Composition and Sciences, but weak in Math and French. He got top grades in Biology, but failed Canadian History (he said the book was boring and never read it) and Math. The result was that he, and his brother Zvi graduated high school in the same year, 1981. (In Quebec, graduation from high school is after 11th grade.) When he was finally able to decide for himself what, how, and when he would learn, he did it intensely and thoroughly, retaining whatever he learned and taking every opportunity to share with others what he learned.
Summers The first few summers we were living in Montreal, we took family vacations. We would all pile into our station wagon and drive first to Chicago where the Dwork grandparents lived. Then we would drive to Rockaway in New York where Grandma Wolicki lived. In Chicago we visited the zoo, museums, family, and restaurants (a treat that we seldom enjoyed in Montreal). On the way to New York we would make stops, stay in motels, and do some sightseeing. In New York, we played in the Atlantic Ocean (Grandma Wolicki's house was a short block from the beach), visited friends (the Wieders, mostly), and shopped. One summer we went to the White Mountains of New Hampshire where we hiked, toured, and stayed in motels. Another summer, we rented a summer house at Trout Lake in the Laurentian Mountains in Quebec. At Trout Lake there were many other children from Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec religious families for the boys to swim and play with. Two summers David went to sleep- away camp for a month.
Bar Mitzvah In the summer of 1975, when David was 11 and a half years old, he went with his father on a trip to Israel for three weeks. We wanted to introduce him to Israel in the hopes that some day we and he would make Aliyah. We also wanted him to have some time alone with his father, who was often too busy to spend quality time with his sons. They also purchased his Tephilin at that time. At that time, we had no way of knowing what impression the trip made on David. Hindsight suggests we succeeded. As a Bar Mitzvah boy, David was average. He learned what he had to learn, did it well and suffered afterwards writing "Thank You" cards. When David was 13, he changed schools from an all-boys, non-Zionistic environment to a co-ed Zionistic one. He had seemed to be tuning out in his religious studies in the more intense and rigid school he had been attending. We hoped that he would find a way to express himself in a more open environment. Eventually, David did find his way. I am not sure if what we did had any impact one way or the other. However, it probably did influence the choices he made in the next few years. 1976, Bar Mitzvah
Music David was very talented musically. At one point we bought a piano and arranged for David to take piano lessons. After a few years of friction over practicing, we gave up and exchanged the piano for a china cabinet. A number of years later, David was playing the piano on the stage in one of the halls in our shul in Montreal, behind a closed curtain. We were told by the man who maintained the building that David frequently came there to play the piano. He played from his head, without music. As with many other talents he had, he was most successful when he did it his way, privately, and without anyone directing him. David also had a good baritone voice. Our family always sang many zemirot at the Shabbat table. As the years passed, David would improvise harmonies. I, personally, loved to hear him sing. Initially, he did not show the personality of a performer, that is, someone who is eager to show off what he could do. However, when encouraged, he enjoyed it and threw himself into it. He learned the words to many Broadway shows and loved to sing them at the top of his lungs in the shower. He also liked the songs of Harry Belafonte and especially the song "16 Tons", all of which were appropriate for his deep rich voice. Our shul (Beth Ora) always had a world-class, professional, full time Chazan and a men's choir with a professional choir leader. On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, the Chagim and on special occasions, they would sing to enhance the service. Saba Wolicki introduced a Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec practice in our shul (Beth Ora) of having a communal Seudah Shelishit at which they sang zemirot. The leader of the choir used to attend. One Shabbat, when David was improvising harmonies, both the Chazan and the choir leader heard him. They were so impressed, that they invited him to join the choir. He sang in the choir for a few years and learned an appreciation for chazanut in the process. Later, men in many minyanim in which he participated learned of his pleasant voice and he was frequently asked to be the Shaliach Tzibur. Before accepting, he always warned them that he didn't like to daven fast. If they could accept his pace, he went to the Amud. Even then, his style was to immerse himself in what he was doing, and not to show off. He was concerned with enhancing the prayers for others, and keeping them with him. He knew and kept to the Nusach. However, whenever he permitted himself to open up a little, it was always impressive and appreciated.
Art David was constantly drawing cartoons and illustrating his notes in school. He even got in trouble once when, in answer to a question on a test, he drew an illustration. It was marked wrong. Later he brought the paper home and showed it to us. The illustration answered the question fully. Saba took the paper to the principal of the school who agreed that David had answered the question completely and correctly. Unfortunately, the teacher was very rigid and did not know how to relate to David's innovative way of expressing himself. David also drew caricatures. At first, he just practiced different characters that he made up. A few were so charming (to me) that I kept them. He drew his teachers, his classmates, people on public transportation, anyone in his vicinity. David spent a lot of time experimenting with different media. In addition to pencil and pen, he practiced with water colors, charcoal and pastels. One day, when I was helping him clean his room for Pesach, I noticed a small watercolor of trees on the floor. I liked it and asked if I could have it. He shrugged and said okay. I framed it and still have it hanging on my wall. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
1979, Trees, Watercolor Rescued from Floor of David's Room Original size: 10 x 14 cm (4" x 5.5") All of these attempts were without guidance and completely on his own. Also, he rarely showed the results to anyone. I gave him a few art books that I had used in my art classes when I was growing up. He used them to practice drawing parts of the body in various positions and perspectives. At any point in time you could find papers around full of noses, ears, knees, feet and hands. We had a professional painter/artist in the community who taught art classes and with whom we were very friendly. In addition, she had a son David's age with whom David was moderately friendly. We arranged for David to go to her for lessons. It didn't work. Later, David developed his artistic skills, one at a time, learning different media and techniques in his own time and his own way (usually from books), and producing material as the spirit moved him.
Drama I have a picture of David dressed as a lady for a French play when he was about eight or nine years old. Later, in high school, he played the king in a Purim play. He always liked to clown and enjoyed dressing up for Purim. In costume, he always acted the part to the fullest. His dramatic skills became more evident when he was in Yeshiva University, in New York. At that time he made a very strong impression on many people when, as a member of the Drama Society, he won a number of awards for his dramatic abilities. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
Pets We started with goldfish in a bowl, when David was quite young. That was not a successful experiment. Probably because I was not particularly interested and did not bother finding out what it took to keep them alive. When David was 10 years old, he had to have teeth pulled. His teeth were very crowded and some were pulled for orthodontia. As compensation, David got a parakeet that he called Simcha. Unfortunately, Simcha was the most unhappy and neurotic parakeet I have ever seen. I had had a parakeet when I was a young girl that I had trained to take baths in my hand. So, I thought I knew something about parakeets and could help David train this bird. Nothing worked. David had no pleasure from Simcha. When Simcha died, everyone was relieved. One summer, when David was in his early teens, some very good friends of ours who lived in the community and owned a black Labrador retriever went on vacation. They asked David to "dog sit". Since their dog was very intelligent and well-behaved we agreed. David took the dog for walks and enjoyed its company very much. When David was a little older, he bought a fish tank. He started with a small one and worked his way up to the biggest tank he could fit into his room. He even had to get a special table that was strong enough and big enough to hold it. It was approximately four feet (1.22 m) long, a foot and a half (46 cm) wide and two feet (61 cm) high. In a pattern that proved to be the same for many of his interests, David acquired books about the equipment and contents of aquaria, and made himself an expert on the subject. He did not share this information unless someone happened to show an interest in the subject. When this would happen, it opened the floodgates as David eagerly shared what he knew until the listener's eyes would glaze over. There were few who could match him in his enthusiasm for detail and thoroughness about the subjects that took his fancy. What is interesting is that David understood that many others did not match him in their desire to know everything about everything. As an adult, he learned to recognize when his audience had reached the saturation point and could no longer absorb any more information. He even developed a sense of humor about it so that when I talked to him on the phone, and I had reached my limit on a particular subject, I could call "Time" and he would good- naturedly change the subject. See also, "Why Someone Should Have a Pet (Especially Fish)" on page 23.
Miniatures David was fascinated by miniatures. A number of his school projects involved making miniature buildings or scenes. He also collected miniatures of all sorts and materials, e.g., blown glass figures, small animals from brass, wood, onyx, and other materials. He even kept plastic and china figures that came in cereal boxes. Some of these had been mine. I, too, found them interesting. However, as with everything else, he took it further than I ever had. Later, when he had his own home, he made a special cabinet for his collection. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
David's Miniatures in the Display Cabinet He Made
Gardening We had a big backyard in Montreal. David's first attempts at gardening on his own were not very successful, but not for lack of trying. He tried planting strawberries but was frustrated by the short growing season in Montreal and the poor soil in our backyard. Given a choice, David preferred chores that kept him physically active and outside. He would eagerly cut or water the grass, shovel snow or help plant flowers in the spring. It was a little harder to get him to participate in indoor chores. David and his brothers made friends with a number of adult members of the community. David learned a lot about gardening from books (as was his style) and from discussions with some of these adults. One of his dreams for when he was an adult was to have a yard which he could plan and plant as he chose. Although he lived to have his own yard, his dreams had by that time expanded so that he never had enough time and space for what he wanted to do.
Reading David always read voraciously. Initially, I read bedtime stories to him and his brothers. Later he read to his brothers. Libraries in Montreal were free and we (the family) visited regularly to take out the maximum number of books. When he started to handle some of his own Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
money, he would purchase his own books, mostly nonfiction. It was at this stage that he purchased "The World of Disney" (a kind of encyclopedia for children), one book each month. The amazing thing is that he actually read every book, cover to cover and retained what he read. David's interests covered a wide range of subjects. In addition to fiction, he read books on art and drawing, gardening, fish, carpentry, history, philosophy and many other subjects.
Sports Montreal had free city swimming pools. One summer I decided the boys needed to learn how to swim. I started with David, Zvi and Eliav and took them to a pool every day until they were comfortable in the water. David was the first to learn how to swim. From that time on, David swam whenever he had the opportunity. David also loved to walk. As a teenager, he would go for long walks very late at night, by himself. I suspect he enjoyed the opportunity to think as well the physical exercise. He also found it hard to part with clothing that he felt still had some wear left in it. On one of his walks he was stopped by the police. He looked scruffy, it was the wee hours of the morning and he had no identification on him. It didn't stop him from walking or wearing the clothes. Partly because of his growth pattern, as a small boy, David was not well coordinated. During his biggest growth spurt in adolescence, he suffered through a very clumsy period when he seemed to often stumble over his own feet. The doctor said that it was caused by the various parts of the joints (especially the knees) not growing at the same pace. What is interesting, is the impact that this might have had on his personality. As a young boy, he was not particularly good at sports that involved running and throwing, or catching a ball. As a result, in the early years, he was not in demand as a team player, although later, David did make the basketball team in high school, where his height was an advantage. Possibly because he knew how it felt to be on the fringes, he often reached out to those who had a different style from the norm.
Temperament David was impatient with injustice, falseness, and mediocrity. He had a low tolerance level for people who were not experts in their field, but pretended to be (including some teachers he had). He had only kindness and patience for the elderly and people who were truly disadvantaged. He focused on essentials, and had no patience for empty words. He hated waste, and kept everything in the expectation that he would use it some day. When he wasn't really sorry, he couldn't apologize. When events upset him, he lashed out at anyone around in anger. As a teenager, he was incapable of speaking diplomatically (in his opinion, deviously or falsely). Later, as an adult, he found it extremely difficult to keep silent when he disagreed, even when it would have been to his advantage (for example, at work). But, he was really a softy. He cared deeply and was alert and sensitive to the feelings of others, though he often didn't know how to show it. He was a man of action, not (spoken) words. He often befriended others that he sensed needed befriending, for whatever reason. He felt the weight of responsibility especially in two areas: developing his own potential and, as the eldest, concern for his brothers (in spite of the fact that they neither wanted nor needed it). David, in his teen years, had no clear direction of where he wanted to go in his life. He knew he was smart and had many talents, but had trouble deciding what path to take. He worried about finding his way and being able to support a family. Although many of his talents were in artistic directions, he was afraid of the economic instability of those options. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
David was stubborn. On one occasion this was beneficial. He decided that he wanted to learn to touch-type. I gave him a book from which a person could teach himself to type. He completed it. This skill served to be very useful to him throughout his life whenever he felt like dumping his thoughts onto paper, for assignments in school and later, when he worked as a technical writer. David was very careful with his money. Once, when he received some money for his birthday, we went to a store so he could buy something. He walked around for some time before he came and said he couldn't decide what to get. I told him that he didn't have to spend it if he couldn't find anything that he wanted more than the money. We went home, his money intact. It was only as an adult, near the end, when he began to feel a greater sense of economic security, that he began to indulge himself and spend a little more freely on his hobbies and interests. (He never stopped wearing the most outrageous old clothes when he worked around the house, although he did finally upgrade those he wore to work.)
Humor David had a marvelous, wry sense of humor. His best jokes were clever and original, usually word plays and corny puns, delivered deadpan. We would be sitting around the table talking (mostly on Shabbat or Chag) and he would insert a line that would break us all up. His letters were witty and entertaining, filled with illustrations of whatever he was expressing in words. He rarely guffawed. When amused, he showed a slightly crooked smile and a twinkle in his eye. He had a beautiful smile and it used to annoy me that he always kept his mouth closed (teeth hidden) when he smiled, especially for pictures. They say that body language is a strong indicator of a person's feelings. I believe that this closed-mouth smile was a reflection of his trying to keep his inner thoughts to himself.
On Being a Rabbi's Son It is impossible for me to know how much being the oldest son of a Rabbi who served in different communities affected David, and his brothers too, for that matter. However, there is no question that it did. I know that David often spoke of the difficulty of having to change communities and friends. It doesn't matter that other people moved more. What was important, was that David didn't like it. In addition, our community in Montreal numbered close to one thousand families. Although the shul was a fully Orthodox one, most of the members of the congregation were not Sabbath observant. Consequently, although David and his brothers went to schools with fully observant classmates, they lived among people who were not. Because Saba was the Rabbi of the congregation, he had a fixed seat up front, on the Bima. When we came to Montreal, the atmosphere in shul was still very formal, closer to the old British style than the American. The boys couldn't sit with their father, although on Friday night they sat with him, not on the Bima. All of the boys learned to fend for themselves. They each made friends with different men in the community, according to their personalities. We tried to teach them that they had to behave properly because they were religious Jews and Bnei Torah. They had a responsibility to behave so that people would praise the lifestyle we represented and cause a Kiddush Hashem. Of course, though we personally never said it, they probably thought it was because they were "the Rabbi's kids". Although it was probably difficult for them at the time, they didn't verbalize it and I didn't notice it. Growing Up, Montreal, Quebec
However, I believe that the fact that all of my sons as adults handle themselves well with strangers and with people of all backgrounds is one of the results of the environment in which they lived as children and teenagers. Growing Up, Childhood Ends
Childhood Ends In June of 1981, when David graduated high school, the whole family went to Israel for a year. We had been talking about wanting to make Aliyah for many years. In preparation, we arranged to go to Israel on Sabbatical. We exchanged homes with a family we knew who lived in Bayit Vegan, in Jerusalem. In addition to packing for the trip, the boys also had to pack away anything that they didn't want the other family to use. During this year, we hoped to upgrade our memories of Israel and to explore the possibilities for our own Aliyah. In addition, we hoped that each of the boys would get to know Israel and come to some conclusion about whether or not he personally wanted to make Aliyah. Both David and Zvi were going to programs that took them out of the house. Eliav was going to be in a dorm during the week, and come home for Shabbat. The other boys would attend schools in Jerusalem, and live at home. This marked the end of an era and a dramatic transition for the whole family.
1981, Seventeen Growing Up, In the Words of a Friend
In the Words of a Friend Submitted by Irwin Yellin (and slightly edited by me, David's mother) I first met David in 1972, when he and his family moved to Montreal. I was 10 years old, and David, the son of the new Rabbi was almost 9. I was in a particularly fragile state at that time, having lost my father a few months previously. David was the “new kid” in the area, looking for new friends. Of course, being the Rabbi’s son carried a certain amount of stigma associated with it, and many others did not really want to be his friend. I, on the other hand, had been friends with the previous Rabbi’s son, and had no problem associating with David. One drawback to our friendship was that we did not go to the same school. I did make several attempts to switch to his school, although for certain technical reasons, it was not possible. His school was more religious, mine was more labour-zionist. Our friendship lasted for many years, and through a lot of trials and obstacles. While we were in grade school, and most of high school, we belonged to the same youth group, and went to the same (occasional) Shabbat groups. One part of our friendship was made possible by the fact that I did not spend time trying to bother him. We would sit together in shul, and spend a lot of time talking, (to the consternation of the gabbais, and I assume, David’s father).
On David's Intensity I do remember that whenever he was discussing something, he became focused on the topic and the person he was talking to. There was seemingly no outside interference, no distractions. As I look back and think about it, I realize that many adults do not have this skill – to filter out all distractions. I recall one incident, when he was telling a few of us how he cleaned out his fish tank. It was not an interesting topic and the other fellows just walked away. David continued, describing in detail exactly the procedures he used. I still remember listening to every word, enthralled by the detailed, exact description. He made it sound interesting. It is no wonder he chose technical writing as a profession. He once told me that he wanted to be a cabinet maker or a carpenter. I think he was 15 or 16 at the time. I remember he told me that he wanted to have a job where he could be creative all of the time. After seeing his home in Israel, I saw the full extent of his skills, when his brothers pointed out all the work that he had put into the house. I was also impressed with the array of professional tools and equipment he possessed for working with wood. It dawned on me that based on his total focus on whatever he was doing, I should not have been surprised. His focus would have directed him to find the best tools available. We were both members of NCSY. We participated in dozens of events together. Sadly, due to the passage of time, most of them have blended together. There are some incidents that do stand out in my mind: We had both worked at a Purim carnival in the shul on a particular Sunday. Both of us had been there from about 9:00 in the morning, setting up. David and I were each in charge of at least two or three booths. By 5:00 p.m., we were both exhausted. Someone asked us if we were interested in going to Cornwall, Ontario (about an hour’s drive from Montreal) to help with an outreach program. We both went, and I remember both of us breaking the ice with the Cornwallers by grabbing people and starting to dance. David was like a dynamo; despite the fact that he was exhausted, he did not take a break. He seemed to gain energy with every passing second. I remember we were once at a Shabbaton. If I remember correctly, I was 15, and David was 14. It was a warm Shabbat afternoon, after a good lunch. We were sitting in a discussion Growing Up, In the Words of a Friend
group, and David was arguing some point. I do not remember what we were all discussing, but I remember everyone listening to him rebut point after point, declaring most of them irrelevant to the discussion. Even the advisor was not willing to intervene. On another occasion, on Shavuos, we were chatting at about 2:30 am. He looked kind of worried, so I asked him what was wrong. He told me that he had a Chumash question. "When Moshe went to get the Torah, he learned something from every angel. So what did he learn from the Angel of Death?" We both started looking up sources, points and ideas. After about an hour and a half, I came up with an answer. He listened to what I had to say, smiled and said, “That’s a good answer. I wanted to see if you could find one.” Teens were regularly invited to attend Ongei Shabbat at the Rabbi’s (David's also) house. They were a lot of fun, being casual, informal affairs. We spent the time listening to stories, singing, eating and playing games. At one of these, one of the games that David pulled out had a lot of marbles. The game itself was not very interesting, but David and I began playing marbles on the living room carpet. We set up a small tournament, although David spent a lot of time making new rules and redefining the game.
On the Light Side One thing we did was play harmless practical jokes on each other. I remember one time, at a Shabbaton dinner. We were sitting next to each other. I was leading him on with an idea that we should be more personal with the food we were about to eat. In order to become more personal, I named my food. I carefully waited until he had a mouthful of food and said "This is my chicken. His name is Fred." David burst out laughing. The result was not pretty. We both had a great laugh, and we both forgot about it, or so I thought. Occasionally, when we were older, a group of us would go to Lake Placid, New York for the weekend. Several members of the shul owned country houses there. Our group, of about 6 to 8 people would take over the house belonging to one of them. One Shabbat evening, we were invited to someone else’s house for dinner. We all sat down to a huge dinner, and it just happened that David was sitting next to me. We were having a pleasant meal, and had just started on second helpings, when David turned to me and said: "You know, I have a great memory." "So?" I asked. "This is my chicken." he said. “His name is Fred." "Oh, really?" I replied. "My chicken’s name is Bill." He burst out laughing again, with the same result as 10 years earlier. I told him not to shoot me with my own weapon. During that same series of weekends away, we would sometimes go to Lake Placid on Saturday nights to have a drink. We went to some hotel, and David started sketching on a pile of napkins. Within about 20 minutes, he sketched all the members of the band and the waiter, and gave them the sketches. I did not know that he could draw. None of us knew that he could. He was extremely modest. When the waiter started thanking him, David started blushing and wanted to leave (which we did, shortly afterwards). On the way to Lake Placid one Friday, we stopped in Plattsburg to pick up some supplies. One item we picked up was a bottle of a smooth liqueur appropriately called "Loshon Harah." (gossip). On Sunday, we were preparing a barbeque dinner before the trek home. We quietly added a generous amount of the liqueur to the raw hamburger meat. We grilled the meat, and started eating. David took a bite, looked up, staring off into space, and said “There is Growing Up, In the Words of a Friend something in the meat that is not supposed to be there." We all laughed, and told him that we had spiked the meat. He looked up again, sighed and said, "What a waste of a good drink."
On Being True to Himself I just want to add that David rarely drank more than enough to be polite. In fact, the few times when alcohol was available, he would rarely more than taste it. One of the last incidents I remember was on Shavuos, 1987. (David was then 23 years old.) We were among the few people who managed to stay up all night. David was the chazzan for Musaf. Someone told him to daven fast, so we could all go home and get some sleep. David turned to us all before he started and said, "It is a Yom Tov; we are going to have a Yom Tov davening." With that, he began, using some very nice niggunim. To his credit, however, he did pick up the pace, and tried to finish a bit quicker. Growing Up, In His Own Words
In His Own Words David was a saver. Among the things he kept were some compositions he had written in school. On the assumption that he intended to share them, I include them here. Some are dated and some are not. I have arranged them in what I think is chronological order, based on the handwriting. Almost everything in this section was a school assignment. (A few were not.) We have no way of knowing what instructions the teacher gave and to what extent they had an impact on what he wrote. However, the creativity, ideas and expressions are David's.
The Angry Bear One morning, Ranger Person set out some wolf traps, which had a chicken hanging above them. A pack of wolves came, but they saw the traps and did not know what to do. Then, Waub the grizzly bear came. He also saw the free meal. But he did not see the traps. He started pulling one of the logs that held up the chicken. He was getting a little tired, so he sat down. But, oops, what is this? He had sat down on one of the traps. That sent him running and that was the end of him.
Now You See Him, Now You Don't December 16, 1973 Mr. Green was the best golfer in New Gilsburg. But, how did he get to be the best golfer? It was his friend Gilbert who helped him. Once, when Gilbert was experimenting to see what would happen if he mixed sulfur with salt water, he discovered an invisible spray. Whenever Mr. Green shot the golf ball, Gilbert (while he was invisible) would roll the golf ball into the hole. (When Gilbert was not with him, Mr. Green was very bad at golf.)
The Magic Elephant Jumbo the elephant's mother is the pet of Wizard Wonka. Wizard Wonka is a midget who lives in the outskirts of Valgaria. Their king was the meanest man on earth, Baron Bomburst. Nobody liked him, especially because of his worst law. He hated children. Whenever he heard that there were children around, he sent out his child catcher. Wizard Wonka wanted to solve this problem. He couldn't change Baron Bomburst's mind, or could he? Then he remembered that his aunt gave him a magic potion to change people's minds. He gave it to Jumbo. With his trickery, Jumbo slipped it into Baron Bomburst's mind and they lived happily ever after. Growing Up, In His Own Words
Some Big Problems (Editor's note: The moral at the end is part of the composition that David wrote.) This is Timmy. He lives on Cornfield Road. It was on August 3rd when it happened. Mrs. Topman, Timmy's mother, was ironing the clothes and Mr. Topman was reading the newspaper. Then the doorbell rang. It was the postman. Timmy rushed to the door, because he loved to look through the mail. There was one letter for his father, one letter for his mother and one for him! Quickly he ripped it open and read it. It said, "You, Timmy Topman, are invited to the school's dinner of the year!" Timmy jumped in the air as he hardly ever got mail and the dinner was to be made by the world's best cook. Timmy couldn't wait and he went to bed dreaming of a thirty inch pizza. The next day he dressed up in his best clothes and went to school. That day, most of school was to be delayed because of the dinner. Timmy was first in line down to the assembly room where there was a luscious dinner waiting for them. In the middle of the dinner, there was to be a pie eating contest, which Timmy was looking forward to very much. Timmy was selected by his class to go against the ones selected by the other grades. Now they were ready! Each one had a pie in his hand ready to start. Timmy had two in his hands because he had such an appetite. Ready, set go! They started – zoom, at the pies. Timmy's hands were going at the speed of lightning. At last, the three minute period ended. The scores were down on paper. Tommy, from grade one, had eaten ten pies. John, from grade two, had eaten twenty pies. Yanky, from grade three, had eaten twenty-six pies. Timmy, from grade four, had eaten 100 pies! David, from grade five, had eaten thirty pies. Dennis, from grade six, had eaten thirty- two pies. So Timmy won by sixty-eight pies. He must have been very full. Yes, he was full and fat! Timmy went to weigh himself. He weighed twelve tons. He was four feet tall and twelve feet wide. He had to lose weight, and how! Then, he knew he needed a doctor. Maybe he would know what to do. But the doctor didn't. Neither did any other doctor. So he had to stay that way. He couldn't fit in the car, so he had to walk. He needed unicycles to hold his fat all the way home. He had a little league game in football the next day, and he had to go. He thought he would lose for sure, but it was a sure win. All he had to do was run through them, and they all were down. (The moral of this story is not everything is bad about being big.) Growing Up, In His Own Words
The Stowaway (Editors note: This composition was not finished.) Johnny couldn't wait for the next day. He and his father were going to their cousins who lived in the country. They had many animals and Johnny couldn't wait to ride them. But one thing bothered him - his dog Rufus. He had told his cousins that he had a dog, but his cousins laughed at him because he wouldn't show them Rufus. Now why didn't he want to show them Rufus? Because they went to their cousins by train and dogs weren't allowed on trains. So this time Johnny had made up his mind. Rufus was coming, allowed or not allowed! Johnny had already figured out a way to stowaway Rufus on the train. He was going to bring his checkered blanket with him and in the blanket he would roll up Rufus. To make sure Rufus would be quiet on the trip, he would put Rufus right next to him where he could shut Rufus up when necessary. But right now, he had to go to bed! The next morning he felt great. He had just one problem, how to get up. Rufus had jumped up on his bed and was pulling the red checkered blanket off the bed. Johnny wondered why he was acting like that. Then he remembered. So, he got out his suitcase, packed it and rolled up Rufus in the blanket. He reached the car just in time to leave. When they got on the train, he covered Rufus' face so the inspector wouldn't see him. When they were finally on the train, the action began. When a man was walking to his seat, Rufus began to growl. Though Johnny didn't know it, Rufus wasn't what he was leaning on. He was leaning on a plain blanket! When Johnny woke up from his nap on the train, he realized that. But it was too late. There were people on the floor who Johnny thought had been knocked down by Rufus. But, where was Rufus? Johnny looked all over, under the chairs and on the luggage racks. Soon he became tired and fell asleep. When he woke up, the train had stopped. The men were unloading the luggage, but, what was that scratching up there? ...
Why Someone Should Have a Pet (Especially Fish) December 6, 1979 To some, a pet may seem to be a luxury, but I consider it a necessity. Having a pet gives the owner a sense of responsibility for the creature, besides the fact of having a friend. It's a fine feeling, because the pet is totally dependent on you and you can do with its life as you wish. When the being in your care lives a long, healthy and happy life, it means that you have done the right things for it. This can give a great sense of satisfaction. Fish may not be able to go with you and cannot play with you in the backyard like a cat or dog. However, all the other things I mentioned in the fist paragraph apply even more so in the case of fish. Other important facts about fish are the following. The movements of the fish are restricted to the tank in which they are kept. There are about thirty or forty different sizes and shapes of tanks and countless ways you can decorate them. There are also thousands of different kinds of fish that you can put in your tank. The good thing about this is that no matter how you decorate your tank, it will always be like another world sitting on your desk, dresser or wherever you have your aquarium. One common joke about having any pet is that it can never say a hostile word. Some people are afraid that a living pet might bite. This is where the pet rock idea comes in. The main reason for loving a pet is usually not for its quietness. The more one gives and the more time Growing Up, In His Own Words one spends with his or her pet, the more he or she gets to like the cat, dog, bird, fish or whatever. All I have said is from personal experience and I honestly do not know how I ever managed to live without a pet.
The Great Boredom September, 18, 1980 In the land of Gorn there was a great king by the name of Notindoin. Notty, as his friends called him, had one very great problem. He had a boring kingdom. In order to liven up the kingdom, Notty tried all sorts of things. At first, what he tried was innovative and a little bit interesting. But, the effects usually wore off within a week or so, and the people in the kingdom found themselves as bored as they were before. Since they were so bored, the people in Gorn tended to do strange things to keep themselves occupied. They would gamble, eat and paint their toes pretty colours. Some would even beat others up, just to keep from getting bored. One day, Notty called in his chief adviser, Mr. Takalatin, for their daily discussion on how things were in the various states within the kingdom. Eventually, their discussion led the great boredom that had been causing all the problems throughout the land. Said the king, "I understand why my countrymen are bored and listless, but why don't you and I get bored and therefore, act strange?" "I've noticed that very few people talk as much as we do." said the adviser. "That's it!" cried the king. The next day the wise king sent forth this proclamation, "From this day on, all work shall be stopped at the hour of four, and people should retire to their homes. From four until five o'clock, everyone shall find a partner. They should talk to one another until the hour is done." From this day on, all boredom vanished from the land of Gorn and the crime rate dropped drastically. It is a great shame that other lands never tried this method of boredom removal. Perhaps there is still hope. Who knows?
Expository Composition October, 1980 Madame Flutesnoot's annual cocktail and corn chip party is known as the social event of the season. People come from all over the country to meet this great "high-hatted" hostess. The unique factor in Mrs. Flutesnoot's parties is that she gets to shake hands with every one of her guests. This is probably helped by the fact that she has four arms. As for last night's party, the high point was probably when the famed professor Blob choked on his corn chips. The audience included all the famous actors and writers from around the globe. Mrs. Flutesnoot says that there will be many more parties to come. The parties liven up her house in which she lives alone most of the time. Since her husband's death, Madame Flutesnoot had been a bit of a hermit in her eighty-five room house. This is why I am sure all her friends are glad that "Snooty" is back out in society. Sorry. No drawing with this one. (Editors note: The teacher wrote, "Aw". David often illustrated what he wrote.) Growing Up, In His Own Words
On Winter in Montreal November 20, 1980 The cold wind blows through the empty city. All windows are boarded, doors are locked. Winter is coming! The call is buried by silence. A mouse scurries across the road, looking for shelter from the snows. The town has been abandoned. It is a cold November. The clouds darken on the horizon. Winter is coming, And everyone has gone to Miami.
Fame January 23, 1981 Everyone, at one time or another, wishes to be famous. In this composition, I will ask if fame is as desirable as we think it is. Recently, a movie called "Fame" was introduced to the public. This movie was not a happy one. It was one of frustration and the need for recognition. If fame is so desirable, why do we associate it with such sadness? It is true that in the movie, the ones in search of fame did not get it. But, I believe that one of the most important factors about the subject of fame is the need for it and the lengths to which some will go to achieve it. Once one has become famous, there are several ways to react (emotionally). The first is to get swell-headed and think that nothing is good enough for him. This person will not make many friends. The second response is much more common. The person in question becomes afraid of losing his "fame" status and may turn to drugs or liquor, or keep changing to please the public. Last but not least are the few people who managed to keep themselves emotionally stable and do their jobs, purely out of enjoyment. These people do their jobs best. Desire for fame comes from the need to be remembered. Fame can be achieved by doing one thing or many. It can happen, not only in show business, but also in business and politics, science or just about any other field. Fame can be used for good or bad. Above all, fame should only go to those who can handle it, for if the person loses control, he/she can bring him/herself to a disastrous end. Growing Up, In His Own Words
Should I Jump? January 23, 1981 Should I jump? I don't know. What if I missed the net? Why should I jump? Even if I were to survive the fall, what would I have to live for? All my worldly possessions will have gone up in smoke. They are yelling for me to jump. Why can't one of them come up on a ladder, the way they do it in the movies? I don't want to jump! Maybe the net isn't strong enough. Maybe I'll just fall right through it. I think it would be safer just to stay here and suffer a little smoke inhalation. It's such a long jump! What will I do? I wish Harry was here. He would know what to do; he always knew what to do. Oh Harry, where are you? I knew I should have renewed my insurance last month. I'll have nothing. I'll have to start over from scratch. All my things are here. What shall I do?
On Artists as World Leaders January 23, 1981 It has been said that there are people who could act much wiser than our present politicians, but that all those who qualify are too smart to get themselves involved. A great artist would definitely qualify for this category. Be he a portrayer in the performing arts, creative arts, fine arts or literary arts, all artists must have insight. In order to become successful, an artist must be able to understand how people think. A great artist has been accepted by the public and therefore, were he to become president, we could not insult him. [Note: Ronald Reagan was not a great actor at all. Therefore what I say in this composition does not apply to him!!!] Since an artist is a portrayer of people (characters, if you will) he learns to understand different kinds of people. As a result, when he meets with another political leader, he would be more likely to understand the other's way of thinking This would help in negotiating treaties and settlements between countries. The artist will also be able to understand his critics, his public and reasons for their behaviour, important factors in public relations. Indeed, I feel that a great artist as a leader would lead to a more effective government. Growing Up, In His Own Words
Unmasking (Editors note: This was not a school assignment.) Feb. 22, 1981 I've discovered in myself a new problem. I am too honest. Scratch that. I was getting mixed up. I have been doing a lot of that (forgetting what I was saying). What I meant was that I have been thinking too much. I am a firm believer that the world is in a state so drastically hopeless that the more intelligent a person is, the more of this confusion he "understands" and the more depressed he becomes consequently. On this line of thought, I said that I had been thinking too much. I mean that I have been studying the world too much. I have discovered a depressing outlook from a great number of different vantage points. This tends to be rather upsetting. Maybe one of the more surprising words which I prefer to use is the word "confused". I say this because this is the way I feel. I refuse to accept that this world can survive without any good whatsoever, and yet I believe that, socially especially, the world is in a hopeless state. On the other hand, I maintain that if indeed there was some good in the world, it would be impossible for the world to be entirely without hope. This could tie in with my view on the mask syndrome. It is feasible that everybody could be hiding whatever good they have in them behind their masks. When the average person looks at another average person, all that he sees is the other person's mask. Because he sees only the mask, he thinks that the person is his mask. The only possible way I can see to get past these masks is by introducing extremely open honesty between everybody, especially with people whom we have never met before. Just about the most effective way of establishing good relations between one man and another is to sit them both down together in a situation about which both men feel the same, and getting these two men to talk about anything except the obvious differences. Once this is accomplished, you may rest assured that these two men will find that they are very much alike in their thinking. Unfortunately, the ideal circumstances for such an encounter are not easily found. You need to be certain that the two (or more) subjects are completely willing and open-minded. Here is where you must start with the difficult task of the unmasking. Unmasking Psychoanalyzing somebody is one thing. Treating them is a totally different matter. This is something that I have found many psychiatrists and psychologists have forgotten. They think that once the problem is identified, it is solved. Identifying a patient's mode of disturbance is merely the first step towards helping this person to cope with him or herself. After a psychiatrist has identified his patient's problem, the next step is to make sure that the patient knows what is wrong with him, and even more, that he understands. In order to find out what is wrong with someone, you first have to get him to open up. Because of society's tendency to take advantage of the person who is open, when trying to get a patient to open up, you will have to be ready and able to pierce his protective shield, or as I like to call it, mask. The people around us develop these protective shields in order to save themselves from being hurt too easily (emotionally). To erase this mask, you have to convince the patient that you are on his side and that opening up to you would and could help him. Growing Up, In His Own Words
My Grandmother April 2, 1981 My grandmother is one of the most interesting and entertaining people I have ever met. The difference between her and other interesting and entertaining people is that she is interesting by being her same old self, whereas others learn a wide variety of special skills and expressions to be entertaining. As I remember, my grandmother has not changed much since I was very young. I used to think of my grandmother as the "fun" old lady who would visit us three or four times a year. I suppose that she has grown cynical with age, though to me it is amusing. I enjoy talking wih my grandmother. She somehow manages to always have her own unique way of putting things. My grandmother often tells me about my father and his two sisters. Since she runs a boarding house, she also often speaks of her former tenants. This is what makes my grandmother an interesting person. She talks about people, not things. Politics, sports, entertainment – none of these interest her. It is all people, past and future. Lately, her favorite topic has been her first great-grandchild. The last time she visited us, she was forever parading around the house exclaiming, "I'm a great-grandma." She likes to tell me how my father loved her strudel. I can safely predict that my grandmother will never change and I'm glad.
The Holocaust We cannot conceive the horror, and yet it was conceived by human minds. We try to understand it. Was it done by other kinds of people, were they different? Did they think while killing the weak and lame? And in the circumstances, would we have done the same? Such questions are quite difficult for ones like us, so small. For us, we must remember, and not let Judaism fall.
The World's on a String The world's on a string. It is a fragile thing. For it to hold fast, it must have a past. What's been forgotten and what's not yet come. Young Adult, Hachshara - Tochnit Shituf, Israel
Young Adult This section covers David's life from high school graduation in 1981, until he married in 1990. It includes his first year in Israel, his years in Yeshiva University and his single years after he made Aliya.
Hachshara - Tochnit Shituf, Israel While in high school, David had participated in whatever youth activities were available. He attended NCSY events and Shabbatonim, and also was moderately active in the Bnei Akiva youth movement in Montreal. However, because we lived far from the major neighborhoods where Bnei Akiva was active, David did not participate on Shabbat. As a result, he was considered on the fringes of the organization. This had an impact when it came time to decide what David would do the year after high school graduation, when the family went to Israel. Since at this stage in his life David had not yet developed a desire to learn intensively in a Yeshiva, and he had a strong interest in gardening/farming, he chose Bnei Akiva's Hachshara program. However, because he had not come up through the ranks and was only marginally a Bnei Akiva person, he was steered to a new program being run by the organization, in parallel with the regular Hachshara program. At that time, it was called Tochnit Shituf. The structure of the year and the nature of the activities were the same as the regular Hachshara program. The difference was in the participants, and in the fact that they worked on a Moshav Shitufi (co-operative only economically) instead of a Kibbutz. The year was divided into three portions. The first and third took place on the home ground of the group, in David's case, moshav Bnei Darom. The participants performed whatever tasks were needed by the moshav, that were also appropriate for the individual. In David's case, that was working with the chickens and in the avocado orchards, and fixing sprinklers and pipes for the irrigation systems. In addition, they had classes and looked after themselves (keeping their quarters clean, cooking, etc.). During the middle portion, called seminar, David's group was combined with a number of other regular Bnei Akiva Hachshara groups at Kfar Etzion, where they had lectures on the Shoah (a week), Hadracha (how to be a Madrich in general, with emphasis on Bnei Akiva - two weeks), and Jewish studies, e.g., Mishnah, Torah, Zionism, etc. (four weeks). Participants in the Hachshara program could choose to study in Yeshivot during this time, in lieu of these seminars. After the seminars, they went on tiyulim all over Israel. The eight members of David's group came from widely different backgrounds, religiously and educationally, and had very different reasons for participating in the program (unlike most of the regular Hachshara participants). David, who took everything seriously and who chose the program because he was genuinely interested in learning about the land and working it, found himself in conflict with some of the others who joined the program for what he considered frivolous reasons. He was highly idealistic and critical of those who seemed only interested in having a good time and whose religious standards were sloppy. After failing to get transferred to a different group, in typical David fashion, he withdrew into himself and went his own way. While on Bnei Darom, he introspected a lot, worked seriously on the tasks he was assigned to do, got along well with the adults on the moshav, concentrated on improving himself (e.g., getting to minyan regularly and on time) and continued his reading and artistic activities. He bought colored pencils and water colors in the local store and started by drawing scenery and the shul of Bnei Darom. Young Adult, Hachshara - Tochnit Shituf, Israel
David poured out his feelings and frustrations in journals. Sometimes, he would digress. In November of 1981, he wrote the following in one of his diaries: Today my discussion centers on the pet syndrome, though I can't hope to cover all the pertinent points. There are many reasons given (and some not officially) as to why people often find a need to adopt a creature of some sort. Among the explanations given are: sport, amusement, companionship, to do a specific job, curiosity about fellow creatures, need to feel superior, to relieve boredom. If I have enough time, I will explain each item on the list. Sport: This is a very simple one to explain. Man long ago discovered that he would need to establish certain activities to keep himself occupied and to exercise his competitive instincts. Unfortunately, in his competitive zeal, he often harms the animal by experimenting to make it run faster, stronger, jump higher, etc. even at the expense of the longevity of the animal. Still, through the strange and sometimes cruel world of "meaningless" rituals of animal sport, many actually develop a sort of affection for their dependent "pets". The major problem here is that if the animal does not win, its sentimental and monetary values sink rapidly. No, I would not recommend the world of sport to any animal I knew. Amusement: This situation is very similar to sports, but is much more light hearted. Let's be realistic for a moment. This section has many subsets. Consequently, it is indirectly tied to almost all the other sections. For some reason, amusement is one of man's major objectives. Sport is for amusement, at least that's how it started. Entertainment and music are for amusement. Because of the width and depth of this part, I am afraid I must not pursue this part for now. Companionship: This reason for having a pet is touching, interesting and also, slightly depressing. This is because I think that it is sad when a human cannot turn to his own kind for companionship. There is, however, a cheerful or at least pleasant side to this also. to be continued . . . (Editor's note: I consider this entry from David's journal relevant, because I think it shows how his digressions were a product of his social situation at that time. He yearned for a close friend to whom he could pour out his heart and who would share his feelings. Instead, he was among people with whom he was incompatible. Some in the group chose to amuse themselves at his expense. One result is this partial essay on the concept of pets, which he left unfinished.) During the seminar portion of the program, David participated actively and often debated the issues hotly. Once, during the seminar on the Shoah, David became really involved and excited when they were given garbage (e.g., egg cartons, broken plastic, newspapers), told to imagine that they were children during the Shoah, and asked to create something from it. (This was told to me by a fellow participant in that seminar.) On tiyulim, for example to the Negev, he was continually impressed and awed by what he saw and the fact that there was ancient Jewish history (shards of pottery, coins, ancient cities, and so on) everywhere in Israel. On his return from a three day hike to the Judean dessert, he wrote in one of his journals, "Until now, I did not realize the extent of the archeological Young Adult, First Year in College (CEGEP, Montreal) treasures in this land. Even in the mountains and old, dried up river beds, there are numerous proofs of inhabitants from other time periods." His life-long love of nature and appreciation of the physical world in which he found himself also had ample opportunity for expression, especially on the tiyulim. He enjoyed and marveled at the scenery, rock strata, trees, deserts, flowers, waterfalls, in fact everything that he saw. During this year in Israel, David exchanged letters with a number of people, including some of his high school classmates, men in our community with whom he had become friendly, his grandparents, and his cousins. In them he expressed concern about the future and how he would ultimately earn a living. He wrote about some of his frustrations with his roommates and his problems with the program. This was David's first year of not living with his family, although we did see him from time to time where we were living in Jerusalem. We also visited him once on the moshav. For the first time, his parents were not breathing down his back. It was the beginning of his starting to push himself. I also think that it was during this year that David became personally committed to making Aliya. By the end of the year, the short term plan was to return to Montreal and complete his schooling. Since David had no idea what he wanted to do in the long run, he decided to start in the local CEGEP (a pre-university community college).
First Year in College (CEGEP, Montreal) From September 1982 to June 1983, David attended Vanier CEGEP in St. Laurent (our neighborhood of Montreal). Fortunately, he was able to get a year of credit for the courses he took as part of the Hachshara program.
1983, The Family at Pesach's Bar Mitzvah Young Adult, Yeshiva University (New York)
At Vanier, he pursued a general program that included courses in psychology and anthropology, film and theater, English composition and literature, and the usual obligatory math and physical education courses. David did very well in his studies in the Community college. However, this was his first experience in a non-Jewish school and he did not feel at home. During the year, he socialized with some of his former high school classmates and friends in the community, but applied to Yeshiva University in New York (his father's alma mater) for the coming year. It goes without saying, that even while pursuing his studies and socializing, he pursued his other interests as well. He drew constantly and on anything that came to hand, both out of boredom (in some classes or to while away the time while waiting for something) and to develop new skills. He continued to dabble in gardening, although he was severely limited by the short growing season in Montreal. He corresponded with his brother Zvi who had stayed in Israel. He read voraciously, sang in the synagogue choir, tried his hand at woodworking and went for frequent long walks. During the summers, he worked for one of the men in our community who had an import/export business. In my opinion, the primary benefits of this year, in addition to what he learned in class and the credits he was able to accumulate, were his improved self-confidence and belief in his own ability to excel.
Yeshiva University (New York) David entered Yeshiva University in September, 1983, as a Junior (third year university) because of the credits he had accumulated from both Hachshara and CEGEP. He chose Psychology as a major. David was at Y.U. for four years, two as an undergraduate and two as a graduate student. He spent the first year in the dorm and during the last three years, he shared a rented apartment with a number of fellow students. He took two summer courses in Psychology at McGill university in Montreal. In 1985 he completed his BA degree. He then entered a program towards a doctorate, which skipped the master's degree. After two years, he dropped out and made aliya. He had completed the courses for a master's degree and had been told that he could complete the papers for it from Israel. Later, he found out that that was not 1985, College Graduation the case. During his four years in Yeshiva University, in parallel with his studies, David: was elected to the Psi Chi National Honor Society in psychology continued his painting and drawing was active in the Yeshiva College Dramatics Society Young Adult, Yeshiva University (New York)