ௐ 1 ഇ! ࢱ 271-94! 2021 ѐ/ߋ؞ཱི !ס έ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώ! ௐ 17 Taiwan International Studies Quarterly, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 271-94 Spring 2021
挪威的百年獨立努力
߉ϒዡ ර̂ጯϔְચၱ൴णጯրିڌ
ၡ ࢋ
።ΫࡦഀĂତᑭෛӵд̜౪۞ރԧࣇАԧࣇАᖎಏаᜪॗ ග༄ĂރтңҋĂГֽ҂၅тң̜౪౷ឰॗރᄃ༄̝ม۞ॗ ϲĄ۞ރдೡॗޢĂڡ̶۞ڱछӀৈ࠻઼ٺଣտ̰ొ၆҃
ă̜౪ă༄ăϲރᙯᔣෟĈॗ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 272
壹、前言
дჯִॡĞ793-1066ğĂࣧώҌ͌ѣ 20 ࣎̈ͳ઼Ğpetty kingdomğĂރॗ ጀݣٛႬĞHarald Fairhair, 872-930ğ˘Ҙొă̈́ܛזጼ̙̏Ăۡفѩك ͵˟ͳ઼ĞKingdom of Norway, 872-1397ğĄдȈރϲॗޙঔгĂڻݑొ ϤޢౝˢѺѐ̰ጼĞ1130-1240ğĂރĂॗܒฯă࠹้̢ۋѩكࡔ̚Ăிͳ ݣα͵ĞHaakon IV of Norway, 1217-53ğ౼˘͇˭Ąҋଂ̚͵ࡔฟؕĂ ӵд̜౪ᄃ༄̝มĂᄃ༄ăͽ̜̈́౪۬ᜇ̙Ă̶̶ЪЪ1ĂٺϤރॗ ᄃ༄ВĞjointޘˬд።Ϋഅགྷރ౪ă̈́༄Ąॗ̜ٺڇҊޢА ˞זmonarchyğĂ݈Ѩ2Ğ1319-43, 1449-50ğߏࠎ˞၆ԩВТᇲˠ̜౪Ă ᑓྃҋ̎д 1809ֽރௐˬѨĞ1814-1905ğߏ༄࿀Ăݓᗞྫྷ̜౪ૻ৶ॗ ѐεΝ܆ᜋ̝൭Ą ڇᄃ̜౪ඕЪĂԛё˯ჯͳ઼ă၁ኳ˯Ҋރд 1397-1814 ѐมĂॗ ѐ 1 ͡ 14 ͟జ࢝ᘪࢎ 1814 ٺĞ1803-15ğརୀĂۋ౪Ą̜౪дो૬ጼ̜ טˠ١జĂރග༄ĄॗރĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of Kiel, 1814ğ౷ឰॗ ο௲ᗓ̜౪ϲĂᄃ༄ކĻĞEidsvoll Constitution, 1814ğăڱጳރࢎĺॗ ,Ăᗕ͞տд 8 ͡ 14 ͟ᘪࢎઃጼĺంࡗĻĞConvention of Mossۋणฟጼ ,Тຍ࣒ጳତৼ༄ͳΙႬȈˬ͵ĞCharles XIII of Swedenރ1814ğĂॗ ᓑЪͳ઼ķĞUnited Kingdoms ofރ1809-18ğࠎВĂ˵ಶߏĶ༄ॗ ķރSweden and Norway, Twin Kingdoms, 1814-1905ğĂᖎჍĶ༄ॗ Ҷ̶ᗓĂѺ̳ؖԸކᛉົͯࢬރѐĂॗ 1905 זۡ˘ĞSweden-NorwayğĄ ၁ĄְצϲĂ༄జ࢝ତ ,д 1397 ѐྫྷ̜౪ă̈́༄ඕЪࠎĶΙႬᓑ༖3ķĞKalmar Unionރॗ
1 ֍ჯૄѺࡊĞ2019ĈॗރӖЕܑğĄ д 1319 ѐĂݣ̣͵ĞHaakon V of Norway, 1299-1319ğѪ˸Ăࣣజଯࠎ༄઼ͳ 2 ॾӅα͵ĞMagnus IV of Sweden, 1319-64ğ۞γगତҜࠎॾӅ˛͵ĞMagnus VII of ͳĞHaakon VI of Norway, 1343-80ğă˵ߏ༄઼઼ރNorway, 1319-43ğćݣ̱͵ߊߏॗ ,ߊߏ༄઼ͳΙႬˣ͵ĞCharles VIII of SwedenڗͳĞ1362-64ğĄТᇹгĂΙႬ•ҹӅপ 1448-57ă1464-65ă1467-70ğă˫ߏॗރ઼ͳΙႬ˘͵ĞCharles I of Norway, 1449-50ğĄ ᘲཏफĞFaroe IslandsğăᔁᇇᜋཏफĞShetlandğă̈́ҹκڱΒӣДफăॾᜋăރॗ 3 ΙႬᓑ༖۞ᎸĂ֍ GustafssonĞ2006ğĄٺᜋĄѣᙯ܆ཏफĞOrkneyğඈᅳгĂ༄Βӣ ѺѐϲӅ˧ 273۞ރॗ
1397-1523ğĂߏ็Ϥͳ઼̝มј۞Ķ֗Ъ઼4ķĞpersonal unionğĈܑ ᔘჯҋ̎۞ͳ઼Ă҃д၁ኳ˯Ϊਕზߏ̜౪۞˘࣎࠷̶Ă̙ރࢬ˯ॗ ͵˘ਕѣҋ۞γϹ߆ඉĄ༊ॡâܳ͘јᓑ༖۞ᛷ߆͉ЬႳॾᚊপ δะ̚פĞMargaret I of Denmark, 1387-1412ğ࠹༊ૻ๕ă͘ඦᎵĂсଳ ༄ˠᇴྵ͌ă˧၆ԩćсШ̈́ރĂ߆ඉ˯ͧྵᜪ̜౪ˠĂॗڼᝋ ˠͅԩĂ̙࿅Ăރໂυͅă͔ॗۏăᆧΐኝඁĂٽᗆދጼĂކતˠ҅͟ ੜᓑ༖Ą̙˭ރચੰĞCouncil of Stateğ͉ऴĂ઼۞ރॗ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2016: File:Scandinavia1219.pngğĄֽ
Ĉ Norway Sweden 1330s–1350s Denmark Conquered by Denmark in 1219ځᄲ Livonia before 1343。 ဦ 1Ĉ̚͵ࡔ۞ಝг֤ჯֲĞ 1219ğ
GustafssonĞ2006: 205, 207-208ğᄮࠎߏౚวम˭۞Ķͳഈᓑ༖ķĞdynastic unionğĂ 4 ,࡚ٛκֲ۞ғ༄ҹĞEric of Pomerania, Eric VIIگಶߏЧҋჯࣧѣ۞ͳഈćତЇ۞˵ ĞEric III, King of Norway, 1389-1442ğă̈́༄ރKing of Denmark, 1396-1439ğ֗ࣘॗ ĞEric XIII, King of Sweden, 1396-1434, 1436-39ğ઼ͳĂΙႬᓑ༖д1397 ѐϒёјϲĂ ,ҹ֧кˬ͵ĞChristopher III, King of Denmarkזۡ˘జቪᕈćڠտЯࠎһ៧ Ğ1442-48ğ઼ͳĂ̖ቁϲ֗Ъ઼Ąރ1440-48ğ֗ࣘ༄Ğ1441-48ğă̈́ॗ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 274
ĈWHKMLAĞ2004ğĄֽ ဦ 2ĈΙႬᓑ༖Ğ1430ğ
ރ༄ซᓑ༖кѨĂտд 1523 ѐϖ˳௲ᗓĂΙႬᓑ༖ྋវĂॗ 5ķĞDemark-Norway, 1523-33, 1537-1814ğ۞̈ҁԙĂރјࠎᒺͪ۞Ķ̜౪ॗ ͳτᇇ֧ҹ˘͵ĞFrederick I of Denmark, 1523-33ğዸ༼࣯ώݣॲĄτ઼ 6Ă̂ି͈ٛąाॾܓˠᝌރॗצᇇ֧ҹ˘͵ࢴ֏҃۲͔ˢາିĂ̙ а߹˸дఈᜋܓĂ֭ͷۋοҹĞOlav Engelbrektsson, 1523-37ğᅳԩ ˟ҁͳҹ֧འщ˟͵ĞChristian II of Denmark, 1513-23ğĄҹ֧འщ۞ ؈ĂѪזዎܮث˯˘τᇇ֧ҹ˘͵͘̚ຬаͳҜĂץץྏဦа઼ଂ͵ ဳͳҜ̰ጼĂाॾοҹ፟ᅳۋ̄ˬĂޢႯ̚Ąτᇇ֧ҹ˘͵Ѫٺ ؇ྮᇇିࠁ۞າͳҹ֧འщˬ͵ĞChristianܫጱཌྷĂ֭ϏᒔሤধͅᜩĂ
5 ѣॡ࣏ᖎჍ̜౪ͳ઼ĞKingdom of DenmarkğĄॡ࣏ĂॗރΒӣДफăॾᜋă ߏ൴णࠎͧྵღ۞Ķ߆ֽޢฟᐝߏ֗Ъ઼Ğ1523-33ğâރᘲཏफĄ̜౪-ॗڱ̈́ Ъ઼ķĞreal union, 1537-1814ğĄ ళĂି̀՟ѣ፟ົჺ̼Ąٺࣇ࿅ٺࢋߏࣇ̏གྷѣҋ̎۞Б઼ّିົĂΩγĂϤ 6 ѺѐϲӅ˧ 275۞ރॗ
ͳ઼జҹ֧འщˬ͵ރుĄд 1536 ѐĂॗٸIII of Denmark, 1534-59ğ ҘଟڌૻҖາିĂ֭ԯିົ۞ෳࢦރࠎ̜౪۞˘࣎࠷̶ćѨѐĂ̜౪дॗ ᄬјࠎ͞֏Ąд 1660 ѐĂރ࣯ώݣॲĄତĂ̜౪ᄬ३ᆷ͞ё͔ˢĂॗזဳ ăޠڱᔵΞͽܲѣҋ̎۞ฤăރͳഈĞabsolutismğĂॗט౪јࠎ̜ Ąڼͽ̈́။Ăݒజ˘̶ࠎˬ࣎࠷Ă၁ኳ˯ߏϤ 1,600 Щγֽ۰
貳、夾在丹麥與瑞典之間的挪威
༄ᔵд 1523 ѐੜΙႬᓑ༖Ăᄃ̜౪ᔘߏ˘̙ۡĂଂᛳ۞ॗ Ăރॗܬˢޘд 1567ă1644ă1658ăͽ ̈́ 1716 ѐαޢјࠎঈଡ଼Ą༄Аރ ˯ӌăٕߏҌ͌ԛё׀௲ᗓᄃ̜౪۞ඕЪĂሹზ۞ߏտౣࢋۡତރԓ୕ॗ :༄࠹༊ͅຏĞWikipedia, 2020ٺҁѺؖ၆ރரឰॗܬጼ̈́فඕЪĂֱ۞ Union between Sweden and NorwayğĄপҾߏдȈ˛͵ࡔĂ༄ອ֗˘តј ࠎડાૻᝋĂᄃ̜౪-ॗރϹጼ̙̏Ăॗރˠᅁᐲ̄˯ߛһ၆ԩĄࢵАĂ ౪઼ͳҹ֧འщα͵ĞChristian IV of Denmark, 1588-1648ğၷ͕ү̜ ϔజᇈΡΝχ༄ྺރĞKalmar War, 1611-13ğĂ8,000 Щॗۋ߄ΙႬጼ ˠ۞ͅຏĄତĂ̜౪ࠎ˞ણΐˬȈѐރĂ่̙व౻ΑĂࣆߏ͔ॗ д̰ထ̶ࠎ 6,000 ࣎ડĂރĞThirty Years’ War, 1618-48ğĂΒӣॗۋጼ ͵ˬĂτᇇ֧ҹޢୀග༄ĄڍՏડυืࠁ˘࣎ˠΝ༊һĂඕ Ğ7 Second NorthernۋĞFrederick III of Denmark, 1648-70ğણΐௐ˟ѨΔ͞ጼ War, 1657-60ğĂ̜౪˫རୀĂАޢᘪࢎĺᘲૄઙ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of Roskilde, 1658ğă̈́ĺ࣯ώݣॲ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of Copenhagen, 1660ğĂజ࢝౷ឰ࠹༊ к۞ᅳ˿Ă༄ᐝ֎૨ᑑă̜౪࠹႙ᜨĞDerry, 1979: 127-35ğĄ ᄃ̜౪дۤົ˯۞ᛪు႙ঙனĄੵ˞ྺϔԩᛉͅރдȈˣ͵ࡔĂॗ ᑿᝋĂ̚யล৺ኳႷࠎ̦ᆃ̙ਕѣҋ̎۞થຽᅙءг͞ۋ၆ˠᐝඁă̈́ԩ
ĞLittle Northern WarğĂϡֽડឰ༄རୀ๕۞ۋăٕߏ̈Δ͞ጼۋჍࠎΔ͞ጼ˫ 7 ۋĞGreat Northern War, 1700-21ğĄΩγĂѝАᔘѣπ͘۞ௐ˘ѨΔ͞ጼۋΔ͞ጼ̂ ĞNorthern Seven Years’ War, 1563-70ğĄ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 276
ڡăٕੑ߆ొĞDerry, 1979: 192-93ğĄտĂᗕ͞۞̶ੰڱҖă̂ጯă Яࠎ͢Մγዚ҃གྷᑻᓄၷĂгҜ႙႙ͪႚ௺ĄރགྷᑻӀৈ۞ࡎĄॗٺд ֽĂ֕ྮѣࢲ۞གྷᑻາෳ̙ҺኳႷ࣯ώݣॲ۞߆ܫˠฟؕѣҋރॗٺϤ Ϊ҂ᇋ̜౪ҋ֗۞Ӏৈć࠹၆̝عᄮࠎ̚δ߆ٺซՎ۞ᅪᘣĂࠤރඉߏॗ Ă༊ॡٙᏜ۞Ķ͢ՄෳķĞtimber aristocracyğͅࣆߏᄮࠎ༄ͧྵည˭ ᙯܼĞWikipedia, 2020: Union betweenڼă̈́߆ٽߏϾҡĂΞͽซ˘Վ൴ण ރϏ࿆Ă̙͌ॗإSweden and NorwayğĄซˢȈ˝͵ࡔĂᔵϲྻજ Ąޞᝋෳ̏གྷռ˭ܑ྿ࢋྫྷ̜౪̶ೳធ۞ഇ۞ дȈˣ͵ࡔϐഇĂ༄઼ͳΟ͈ˬ͵ĞGustav III of Sweden, 1771-92ğ ۋ൴જܻᘲů༄ጼޤజ١Ă௧јރࢋՐܻᘲᑒӄӌଫॗ Ğ1803-15ğĂ༄ۋĞRuss-Swedish War, 1788-90ğĂव౻ΑĄдो૬ጼ ࡻ઼ٺࣧώԓ୕ܲ̚ϲĂ̙࿅ĂϤރ৭дᇲ၆۞͞Ă̜౪ůॗ઼ڱᄃ ĂΪрඕЪͪ˭ٳజ̜౪ރঔĂॗ۞ރд 1807 ѐࡎᑝ࣯ώݣॲăॗ ጼĞDano-Swedish War ofކͽ၆ԩࡻ઼ăд 1808 ѐШᄃࡻ઼ඕ༖۞༄઼ڱ ҋعјϲᓜॡ߆ރม۞ᓑᘭĂॗ̝ރࡻ̷઼ᕝ̜౪ᄃॗٺ1808-1809ğĄϤ ĂТॡ˵ᙋعѣҋ̎۞ϔ߆ޘାᑻĂߏ̜౪Ӗᓜೀ࣎͵ࡔͽֽĂࢵ˧ ڠĂ͛ރॗܬѐˢ 1808 ٺᗆ˭ѣਕ˧ྋՙᖏࢴયᗟć༄ދҋ̎дְځ ᓁ༛ĞGovernor-general of Norway, stadtholderğߤ Ⴌ ą Ο ރࣘ౯۞ॗ পͳᐼĞCharles August, Crown Prince of Sweden, 1809-10ğᅳ၆ԩᐹ๕۞ ᇲĞWikipedia, 2020: Union between Sweden and NorwayğĄ क़Ăд 1809 ѐྫྷॗצᜋĂ༄ࢬүጼ܆ܬᘲд 1808 ѐˢܻٺϤ :ĞWikipedia, 2020ۋᘪࢎĺؼౠπ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of Jönköpingğઃ̜ͤ༄ጼރ Dano-Swedish War of 1808-09ğć˫ྫྷܻᘲᘪࢎĺݣѼৼ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of ᜋăٛᜋĞLaponiağă̈́ᜋཏफĞÅland Islandsğ܆Fredrikshamnğ౷ឰ ĞWikipedia, 2019: Treaty of FredrikshamnğĄ༄ˠЯࠎ̙႕઼ͳΟ͈ ͈ĞGustav IV Adolf of Sweden, 1792-1809ğ۞ܑனĂർߏܠα͵ą Οপࠎ༄ͳΙႬܓˠĂࣇАд 1809 ѐރቪᕈĄТॡĂࠎ˞рॗ Ȉˬ͵۞ᐼӖĂԓ୕ਕࠎ࣎ͳ઼۞ඕЪዛྮĂಶ̚ࢲᆩăࡻѐѝీĄ
ѺѐϲӅ˧ 277۞ރॗ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2019: File:Skielober 1811.jpgğĄֽ ౠгүጼ̀һރॗ۞̚ۋဦ 3Ĉो૬ጼ
參、丹麥割讓挪威給瑞典
઼ޓ઼ڱ༄д 1810 ѐଯᏴА݈జो૬ϋయүጼ̙˧ăҋӘጬ۞ ̮ޔឰ͐འপąұৼкপĞJean Baptiste BernadotteğࠎͳᐼĂԼЩĶΙ ͳΙႬȈα͵ąࡗᎰ઼ރ༄ॗ۞ޢႬąࡗᎰķĞKarl JohanğĂ˵ಶߏ͟ ӌ׀ĞCharles XIV John of Sweden, 1818-44ğጱ༄۞γϹă͕᎕ᇋ ಢ୧ࡗĻĞTreatyكĂАд 1812 ѐྫྷ༄۞ᇲܻᘲ৪ᘪࢎĺཐރॗ of Saint PetersburgğĂ˫д 1813 ѐྫྷࡻ઼ᘪࢎĺᇇ࣯Ⴌᇝ୧ࡗĻĞTreaty of ॗפĂϹೱ୧Іߏރă̜̈́౪ॗ઼ڱStockholmğĂྫྷ઼ඕ༖ВТ၆ԩ үࠎጼӀݡĄރ տጼୀĂ̜౪઼ͳτᇇ֧ҹ̱͵ĞFrederick VI ofރ౪ॗ̜ ˿Denmark, 1808-39ğдࡻ઼ăጆ̀ăͽ̈́гӀ۞ᑅ࢝˭Ăࠎ˞ᔖҺώ ౷ 8ރѐ ᘪࢎĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻĂ͕ࠛॗ 1814 ٺᇇᜋΗफĞJutlandğజ ҫ ᅳĂ͟ ༄ͳ઼ Kingdom of SwedenğĄ༊ ॡĂܧឰග༄઼ͳĞKing of Swedenă҃ ᓁ༛۞ރĂజЇࠎॗރࠁซዸॗރ༰ྻăТॡۏ༄˘͞ࢬซҖ ͳᐼҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹĞChristian Frederick, 1813-14ğ̙ރ౪ॗ̜ ރĄҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹԱֽ 21 ЩॗۋˠԩރᙸຍಶቑĂࢬᅳጱॗ
:ᛳгĞKnutsen, 1997ރᘲཏफĂЯࠎ༄ኘҿֱܑ̙ۢߏॗڱӣДफăॾᜋă̙ 8 226ğĄ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 278
ˠഽ୕˘ొҋϤރϲ၆ͳഈć̙࿅Ăॗޙᚶֽٚ۞ވĂԓ୕ॲፂͳ 9 ϲă̈́ϲጳ۞ૄރĂᜪયࣇᄮࠎᔘߏֶፂϔҋՙᝋ ֽүࠎॗڱё۞ጳ ѺѐϲྻજϒёणฟĄ۞ރᖂͧྵрĂଂචт߹10Ăॗ ĂཌྷᇙᓕĂሤ̷͚ϲྻજĄצѺ̜ؖۢ౪ᄃ༄ռ࠹ރॗ ጳטᛷ߆ͳĂࢋՐЧгଯࠁܑણΐރҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹజଯࠎॗ ᛉĂБ઼Ᏼ۞ 112 Щܑд 1814 ѐ 4 ͡ 10 ͟ΡฟົᛉĄᔵ̂छТົ тңซҖ֭՟ѣВᙊĈҫкᇴ۞ٺຍϲߏр۞ᏴีĂ҃Ă̂छ၆ થϲĂ҃͌ᇴ۞ᓑЪᛨĞUnionםϲᛨĞIndependence Partyğૺᄃ̜౪ ߏ 78 ͧ 33 ைĄགྷ࿅̱ڍԸைඕޢPartyğᄮࠎᑕྍᄃ༄ᗫඕЪĂ ĻĂڱጳރጳົᛉд 1814 ѐ 5 ͡ 17 ͟˘Тຍ఼࿅ĺॗט࣎ᖃ۞ኢĂ ͳ઼ĞKingdom of Norway, 1814ğĂ֭ଯᓝҹ֧འщąτރҶјϲॗކ ͳĞChristian Frederick, King of Norway, 1814ğ11Ą઼ރᇇ֧ҹࠎॗ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2019: File:Eidsvoll riksraad 1814.jpegğĄֽ ጳົᛉĞ1814ğטރဦ 4Ĉॗ
ᗓ۞ּ̄ĂԲҿᘲ.ᎊಢĞRosa Luxemburgğ۞ኢᕇĄ̶ރЕှĞLenin, 1914ğᔘপҾᓝॗ 9 ࢭ۞ᇆᜩĂ˵ಶ઼̂ڱ઼࡚ă̈́צஎڱᅳጱ۰࠻ރҹ֧འщ.τᇇ֧ҹ൴னĂॗ 10 ĞDerry, 1979: 212-13ğĄهߏˠϔᝋ۞ந ౪઼ͳҹ֧འщˣ͵ĞChristian VIII of Denmark, 1839-48ğĄ̜۞ޢߏ͟˵ 11 ѺѐϲӅ˧ 279۞ރॗ
ጳົᛉ˯Ğ1814/4/10-5/17ğĂטт݈ٙĂдऄਬЄႬĞEidsvollğ۞ ᄃົܑ12 ۞ϲಞ̂˯Ξͽ̶ࠎҫ˞၆кᇴ۞ࠁăͽ̈́ 25-30 Ҝ ॲώ˧၆ԩ༄ăރࠁĄࠁ͚ྫྷ༄ඕЪĂࢋ۞நϤߏ̶ᗓ۞ॗ ߏγ઼˧ณ۞̒ĄᄿႬતąࢮᇇႬąྥႬұॾĞHerman Wedelٕ Jarlsbergğૺᄃ༄۞ᓑЪΞͽܳјღ۞֨ЪүĂ҃ͷ˵Ξͽྫྷࡻ઼ रκΟٛąێćૺᓑЪ۰ѣ̙Т۞જ፟Ăᛊтٽ҃ޭೇҋϤ ΞਕјࠎԆБϲ۞઼छĂЯѩှ̙ރࢮॾᜋĞNicolai Wergelandğᄮࠎॗ ጳቁϲᝋăଯᓝ઼ͳĂГֽྫྷ༄ኘטАރᙸᏴፄྫྷ༄ඕЪĂૺॗ Ăܕ࠹ࢦă̈́ЪүćฮЧοąႬĞJacob Aallğ۞நϤྫྷࢮॾᜋ࠹̢ т࠷˭ྤֽ͕̙ރநϤߏ˘̙ΞᔖҺĂߊтѩĂүࠎ઼̈۞ॗ۞ ĞLindgren, 1959: 11ğĄטтңԩ١༄۞ࡗ кΞͽӅ˧۞͞ШĂপҾߏдૻޝੵ˞ᓑЪĂᔘѣܫ࠹၆гĂࠁ࠹ Ăރү˭Ăࡻ઼ᄃܻᘲᄻЪৠᗓĂ݈۰ٕధΞਕ̬ˢᑒӄॗྻ۞ڼᝋ߆ རୀĂ༄ͳᐼΙႬąࡗᎰѣ઼ڱ˘Һѣᗓม۞۩มć˵ѣˠҿᕝĂ༱̙ ҃פͳĂ֤ᆃĂҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹಶѣΞਕ઼઼ڱΞਕజଯᓝࠎ ϲ˘࣎၈າ۞ޙॡಶΞͽޭೇ።Ϋ˯۞ΙႬᓑ༖ăبࠎ༄ͳᐼĂ̝ ಝг֤ჯֲͳ઼ć˘ֱˠ҅ჷгӀγϹ̂ҊপঠĞKlemens von Metternich, 1809-48ğ̙֭ಈᝌΙႬąࡗᎰྫྷܻ࠱ֲ።̋̂˘͵ĞAlexander Ꮚ༄טϲֽރĂЯѩĂ઼ѣΞਕ͚ॗܕI of Russia, 1801-25ğ͉֕ ĞLindgren, 1959: 12ğĄ ᄲаֽĂጐგҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹೌӴгᄰ֏ᙸຍࠎ˞ܲ˫ྖ Ξਕ13Ă۞ۋˠ۞ҋϤ҃ॕᖻĂࢬ၆༄۞ᑅ˧Ă̙Һ൘ᏢߏӎѣᔖҺጼރॗ дᄃރЯѩĂྫྷαૻܑ۞ኘҿ̙Гग़ҋ̎۞ͳҜĂ҃ߏтңܲᅪॗ ރॗז༄ඕЪ˭۞ϲă̈́ᝋć༊Ăαૻܑă̈́ΙႬąࡗᎰᜪᇋ ᘪࢎܐឰ၆͞ѣέล˭Ăְ၁˯ĂΙႬąࡗᎰдѐڱˠ۞ࢬ̄Ă˵ຐႽᏱ
12 Β߁ 32 Щܑ͞ă27 Щ̳ચˠܑࣶă16 ЩЋຽܑࠧăͽ̈́ 37 ЩྺϔܑĞLindgren, 1959: 10ğĄ ϲ۞જ፟Ϗυ֤ᆃރKnutsenĞ1997: 226-27ğ೩ᏹĂҹ֧འщ.τᇇ֧ҹᅳጱॗ 13 ಏ৷Ą ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 280
۞ރೳڠᅳఞᚹڼĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻ̝ᅫ˵ߏрྖᄲႽĂտ˧ԩ١༄߆ ĞLindgren, 1959: 13ğĄۋၷ͕Ăᔘߏχ˞˘ಞ՟ѣυࢋ۞࣎ᖃጼ ጳ̝ᅫĂҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹࠁΙሞąщҹĞCarsten Ankerğטд ˯Ăᒔ̯д˭ᛉੰ൴֏ĂٽϲăԼචᗕᙝރࣖྼᄲࡻ઼ٚᄮॗـ݈ ࡻ઼ᄃ༄ٺᛉੰ˵ኢߏӎ͚ĞRedvaldsen, 2014: 186-87ğĄ҃ĂϤ ڠϲăՀߏރѩ֭۷үጼĂ̙ਕࢴ֏҃۲Ăિՙͅ၆ॗكࡗă҃ͷםѣ Ķፍͽ̂ཌྷķĂࢋՐ༊гރॗז༄14ĂࠤҌࠁপֹٺڇυืҊރॗރ˧ ౌ˵ϲಞ15Ą˘̝ྡྷ۞ጆ̀ăгӀăͽܻ̈́ᘲ۞عಡ৽ಡጱࡻ઼߆ Ă̙ࢋྫྷٙѣለ߷۞઼छࠎᇲĄރᛋӘॗٺ͚༄ĂܻᘲࠤҌ ڍĂԩҖࠎߏᄃૻᝋࠎᇲĂඕރॗރ˧ڠдγϹ؝ϲ̝ᅫĂ༄ ރĂॗܬߏਣ̈́யĂՀ̙ϡᄲ̂ᑅဩ۞ 65,000 ЩฤΞͽᐌॡˢ ୢͳҜĂ̙࿅ࢋٸࠎٙજซҖજࣶĄҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹܑϯΞͽ̙ ྿ॗٯ͟ ˠҌ͌Ξͽ࿅ᛉົܑ྿ҋՙ۞ຍᙸćαૻܑд 6 ͡ 30ރՐॗ ၭĂृ١ĄгӀপֹ August Ernst Steigentesch ̝ͽᆄĈĶࠤᆃރ ಶߏԯፋ࣎͵ࠧڍ۰۞ຍԠĂᔘѣࠤᆃрᄲ۞ĉඕڼˠϔĉ༊ࣇ࿁ࡦ ҋ̎۞ᐝ˯ķ(What people? What do they have to say against the will ofזᑅ their rulers? That would be to put the world on its head.) (Wikipedia, 2020: Union between Sweden and Norway)Ą གྷ࿅ೀ࣎͡۞ৠགྷጼĂ༄д 7 ͡ 27 ͟ϤᐼӖΙႬąࡗᎰதᅳঔౙ ؠםүүᇹ̄ಶୢϥѢһԸࢫĂజ࢝ኘҿĞ8/10-14ğᘪࢎઃͫރซԽĂॗ ͳĂ݈҃೩઼۞ރ༄ͳࠎॗצТຍ࣒ጳĂҋᙸତރĺంࡗĻ16Ĉॗ
ĂপҾߏд 1812-13 ѐมౄјֽܕڱۏঔĂڻރᗆॗދࡻ઼࠱छঔଂ 1808 ѐಶ 14 ,ˠ̫֞ᙱͽԞᘃćࡻ઼ར̡˭ϮĂγચ̂ҊᘲұপđΫౌරĞRobert StewartރਣĂॗ ᝋ෦Ր۞ރॗצᗆĂᔘྫྷ༄઼ͳܲᙋĂ၆̙ົତދ1801-1804ğੵ˞ޭೇ၁߉ ĞWikipedia, 2020: Kingdom of Norway (1814)ğĄ ,ᅊĞRobert JenkinsonܛĂᘲұপąҹąྜރ၆ᛨዂॾᛨĞWhigsğۡ֏̙ᏕТଐॗͅ 15 ᄰ֏ᆹҖĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻĂ̙࿅Ă۞ᅦࣶع2nd Earl of Liverpoolğ۞ܲчᛨĞToriesğ߆ ĞDerry, 1979: 213ğĄڼҋރѣ̙ᙸຍឰ༄дΔለӱ̂ĂЯΪ͚ॗ ࡻ઼١ࣄᚻྻһĂΙႬąࡗᎰҿᕝᑕྍѣؽγ̝ࢰćΐ˯҂ณჯ˵ৼົᛉٺϤ 16 ,ေкĂԓ୕ిጼిՙౄјߊјְ၁ĞRedvaldsenܜĞCongress of ViennağΡฟдӈĂࠎҺ؆ 2014: 185, 187-88ğĄ ѺѐϲӅ˧ 281۞ރॗ
ćૄώ˯Ăߏ˘࣎Ϥ࣎ᝋ઼छڱጳ۞ރߏ༄υืТຍٚᄮॗ វրăͽڱᔵܲѣҋ̎۞ᛉົăΦރ࿅ВТ઼ͳඕЪ҃ј۞֗Ъ઼17Ăॗ ѺؖۢεΝϲރҖ߆ᝋĂγϹϤ઼ͳ࿅༄γϹొֽેҖ18Ąॗ̈́ ͽઉޢ࠹༊ϠঈĂᄮࠎ͞ᑘऴăݔ઼Ăҹ֧འщąτᇇ֧ҹޢ οᅊҜĄކЯ৵ࠎϤĂֶĺంࡗĻ۞ࡗՁд 10 ͡ 10 ͟ ˫ᛉົдઃͫඕՁ݈Ğ11 ͡ 4 ͟ğĂͽ 72 ͧ 5 Тຍྫྷ༄ඕЪĂރॗ ༄͘˯ĂߏϏ̶ֽ͘۞ᚨඕĄΩγĂᛉົזͽ 52 ͧ 25 ТຍᅳְϹ ١ĶቁᄮķĞacknowledgeğ༄ΙႬȈˬ͵Ă҃ߏĶளᛉଯᏴ̈́ٚᄮ19ķ Ğunanimously elected and recognizedğࠎॗރ઼ͳĞΙႬ˟͵ Charles II of тٺᓺᏑ۞ރॗٺNorway, 1814-18ğĂზߏ֏۞ԩᛉĄ༄ೀѺѐֽ၆ гĄᐼӖΙႬąࡗᎰᅟ݈˿ރᙸͽᐺĂ҃ĂҜ઼ͳϠଂϏኼˢॗ ˠ൭ެ۞ĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻүࠎඕЪ୧ІĂૻአߏඕރᛖචຍĂୢॗֽ Ļ΄ڱд 1815 ѐआ఼͇࿅ĺᓑЪޢă̈́༄۞ᛉົ˵Аރ༖۞ᙯܼĂ҃ॗ ĞAct of Unionğΐͽࡦ३Ąጼୀ۞ˠ՟ѣᓾྖ۞ዶгĂ͛фౌߏ༄ՙؠĂ чٚᏚĄܑࢬ˯Ăܫ၆͞ޞҜล20ĂΪਕഇ۞ڱ೩̿ࠎጳڱᛉົԯྍރॗ ˘˞༊үጼӀݡĂ˵ಶߏ༣ރߏҰଐԧᙸ۞ЪຍᓑЪĂ༄̄྆ᐝԯॗ ރତҜ۞ΙႬąࡗᎰĂߊ̙ົᓾ༄ྖăՀ̙ϡᄲጯॗֽޢၟ۞̈ҁԙĄ ᄬĞDerry, 1979: 214ğĄ
肆、國家利益的分歧
ڱдރॗٺѺѐĂ̂˯՟ѣࢦ̂۞ࡎĄϤ˘ܕᓑЪރ༄ᄃॗ ăฤă̈́ੑ߆҃Ăعந˯ᔘߏϲ઼छĂ̰߆ჯቅ۞ҋĂΒ߁߆
17 HolmøyvikĞ2005: 137ğᄮࠎߏ߆Ъ઼ĂFossum ᄃ HaglundĞ2006: 5ğ˵ͽࠎͧ࠷ă ᓑЪĞlegislative unionğĄڱതϔгăٕߏߐ઼Հр۞߆Ъ઼ĄVedungĞ1971: 440ğჍ̝ࠎϲ ѣ̰ొᝋă౷ឰγొᝋග༄ĄܲރĂॗڱ Fossum ᄃ HaglundĞ2006: 4-5ğ۞ᄲֶ 18 ٙᅮĈĶٚᄮķߏ˾ᐝᑕ;༄۞ࢋՐĂפॲፂ DerryĞ1979: 214ğĂᇹ۞ϡфᅋෟߏЧ 19 ރĶଯᏴķĂᔳӣΙႬąࡗᎰᐵᄮॗٺĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻćҌٺᝋ˧ֽҋ۞ރಶߏ༄дॗ˵ ᛉົٙᄃĄރˠϔ࿅ॗރॗٺϲಞĂ˵ಶߏֱᝋ˧ֽҋ۞ Ļ၁ಶߏ઼۞୧ࡗĄ΄ڱHolmøyvikĞ2005: 137ğᄮࠎĂĺᓑЪ 20 ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 282
γϹͽ༄ࢵߏᖀĄጐგ઼ͳҋؕᄰ֏ົ৭д࣎ͳ઼۞ϲಞֽ҂ᇋ ѩ۞Ӏك߆ඉĂѺؖ˵ܑ྿චຍĂ҃Ăᐌॡม۞ଯொĂΞͽ႙႙࠻ дགྷᑻ˯ࢦҋϤރৈमĄᗕ͞ࢋ۞Ϭ࠼т˭ĈĞ˘ğያঔࠎϠ۞ॗ Ꮠࡻ઼Ă༄Ꮠᇇ઼ćĞˬğރ༄۞᜕ܲཌྷ࠹༊ຏ݂ćĞ˟ğॗٺĂ၆ٽ Ш้ރ൴णᆸࢬĂॗڼ༄ĄΩγĂд߆ٺለ߷ͽγ۞Ꮈᅈ̂ٺ၆ރॗ чĂܲྵͧڼĞparliamentarismğĂ࠹၆̝˭Ă༄۞߆טҋϤཌྷĂ̰֕ᅦ ᝋ۞༄႙Җ႙ᅈĄރᄃރͷᝋ˧ะ̚д઼ͳ͘̚ćտĂϔ̼۞ॗ҃ ᛉົݒރࣇ۞γϹӀৈĂ҃ॗזˠᛇ༄γϹొ֭ϏᜪރপҾߏॗ ՟ѣΗᕇཉಚ۞ዶгĂ̙ညˠछ۞༄ᛉົᔘΞͽ൴೭ᇆᜩ21ĄΩγĂѣᙯ གྷᑻౝˢགྷ۞ރጼୀኪഠ۞நĂ༊ॡॗރĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻ༊̜̚౪ůॗٺ Ăޢಶቑćރ߆តĂ࿀֭࢝Ϗᘪࡗ۞ॗރᑻП፟Ăॲώ˧ᐺᔘĂ઼ͳ ֏Җ̙˘۞઼ͳ՟ٺѩᄻЪৠᗓĂѺؖ၆ك̙ྫྷγ઼ഠᔘĂ̙ރॗ ĂڼࣶдءߏϤ 2,000 Щ༄ރѣрຏĄૄώ˯ĂȈ˝͵ࡔ˯Ηཧ۞ॗ ߏݭ۞γֽ߆ᝋĄ পّĂ͍۞ރϔཌྷᎸ22ĂૻአॗރȈ˝͵ࡔ˭ΗཧĂॗ˞ז ᑔৼˢ༄۞઼઼۞ރߏ઼छ۞෪ᇈཱིĄᛊт༄ϏགྷТຍూҋԯॗ གྷ̏ރĂрညॗڇˠ࠹༊̙නރᑔă။ăͽ̈́͛ІĂᇹ۞ຍĂឰॗ ͳķĂރតј༄Ԇፋᅳ˿۞˘ొЊćΩγĂ઼ͳ۞ϒёჍཱིࠎĶ༄̈́ॗ Ι˘͵ĞOscar I of Sweden, 1844-59ğזˠ˵ҁ̙̂Ꮈâۡࢋރॗ ˠ۞ᇙރ༄ͳķĂ̖ൾπिॗ̈́ރԼࠎĶॗޠ˘͛І۞ރಶҜĂ࠹ᙯॗ ˠ۞֏ԩރĞWikipedia, 2020: Union between Sweden and NorwayğĄॗޤ ᛉܑனд෪ᇈّ۞ҖજĂᛊт̈छ̄ঈ۞઼ͳΙႬąࡗᎰԓ୕ͽ 11 ͡ 4
ѐĂ༄ͳΙ˟͵ĞOscar II of Sweden, 1872-1907ğ΄γϹొШ 1885 ٺጱͫቢд 21 ༄િ̙ឰՎĂᗕ͞ٺγϹ߆ඉ۞ᇆᜩ˧ćϤٺᛉົ၆ރ༄઼ົయĂЯѩࣤဳॗ ΪрԯᐝᖼШ̶ϲ۞ᅳְ፟ᙯĞMorris, 1904: 142ğĄރĂॗڍኘҿ՟ѣඕ ĺૄႬ୧ࡗĻĞ1814ğĂٺϔౄĞnation-buildingğ൴۞ރElgeniusĞ2011: 398ğᄮࠎĂॗ 22 ༄۞ϔᄮТٺฟؕѣિؠ۞ĞassertiveğϔྻજĄHjermĞ1998ğૺ࠹ྵ̖ޢѩ ҋՙᝋ۞ϲྻٺϔᄮТͧྵϒࢬĂߏૄ۞ރ۰۞मளࢬО෪Ăॗٺϲд၆ޙߏ જĄBartonĞ2005: 502-503ğૺĂߏϔྻજᄃϔྻજ۞ඕЪĄFossum ᄃ Haglund ϲдጳ߆ཌྷă̈́ϔ۞ᆊࣃ˯Ąޙϔ઼छĞnation-stateğރĞ2006: 5ğ˵ͽࠎߏॗ ѺѐϲӅ˧ 283۞ރॗ
ט͟ ˠઐઐಈᝌͽ 5 ͡ 17ރ࣒ጳඕЪ֤͇ࠎ઼ᇉ͟Ğnational dayğĂॗ͟ འщąτᇇ֧ҹ֧هдຏقጳ֤͇ĞConstitutional Dayğࠎ઼ᇉ͟ĂԜ ᅳጱϲĄд 1829 ѐ 5 ͡ 17 ͟Ăᓁ༛ᐮР౻ąąٛұᒑĞ Count ጯϠ23ĂΗ۞͟هጳࡔטBaltzar von Platen, 1827-29ğ˭΄ᗨһᗉᑅᇉৡ Ї̰Ă̏གྷः˭ᛪĄٺѪޢѐ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2019: File:Torvslaget den 17 Mai 1829 i Kristiania.jpgğĄֽ ߿જ͟هጳࡔטރᗉᑅॗعဦ 5Ĉ߆
ߏৠཐ۞24ĂڱˠֽᄲĂጳރॗٺᅟତĄ၆۞ڱѩጳكٺ̂۞ࡎд ҃ĂΙႬąࡗᎰд 1818 ѐ˘ତЇͳҜಶᜨணᒓ۞ࢬϫĂଂѩ̙ॡͽ ᛉົ࣒ጳĞ1821ă1828ă1836ğĂྏဦͽҖ߆ᝋ۞ᕖૺឰރႊ௫࿀࢝ॗְ ט༼Ğrule by decreeğăڼՀΐღඕЪĂΒ߁۞၆ӎՙᝋăୄ΄઼ Ѫ̙ಶĂᛉົགྷ࿅·̶ኢଉٯˠރॗ۞קҋϤൄזᛉົඈĂ̏གྷᑀރॗ ރᇴӎՙĞWikipedia, 2020: Union between Sweden and NorwayğĄ͍ߏॗ ᛉົĞStortingğͧ༄۞઼ົĞRiksdagğҋϤâฟᐝಶឰ༄઼ͳᛇ ᜈాبˬ྿̣ѐćѩγĂ݈۰Ϊࢋܜ۰ޢдࡦĈ݈۰ˬѐฟᛉ˘Ѩăו֊
ჍࠎĶᇃಞጼԝķĞBattle of the SquareğăٕߏĶξಞ̝ԝķĞBattle of the MarketplaceğĄ 23 ĂΪ̙࿅Ăࢋߏ۞ٽߏ̙ΞՀڱˠࣧώ˵ϏυᄮࠎጳރKnutsenĞ1997: 230ğĂॗ 24 Ąغ༄઼ͳ۞၆ӎՙᝋĂ၁ᅫ˯ಶߏटధ༄ᑅརٺಶئ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 284
Ăಶ̙ϡ઼ُͳ۞ӎՙĞDerry, 1979: 217-18ğĄڱϲ ֽࣧ۞ˬѐ˘ѨĂܧఢؠՏѐฟᛉă҃ڱᛉົซ˘Վϲރд 1869 ѐĂॗ ᛉົ᜕߆ඉĞ1872ă1874ă1880ğćጐგ઼ـᅦࣶ݈טૻڱϲޘˬ˫ତ ᇦĞ1873ă1876ăܡኬ̟۞ӎՙᝋĂΙ˟͵ݒాᜈˬѨፖΐڱͳ՟ѣጳ д 1882 ѐᏐҋྋᛉົĂཏଐᙈ25Ąд 1882 ѐ۞̂ᏴĂٺ1879ğĂࠤҌ Ϗֽ۞̂߆ᛨҋϤᛨĞLiberal Party, Venstreğ̈́ܲчᛨ26ĞConservative Party, HøyreğԸˢᏴጼĞ83 ͧ 31 यğĂкᇴᛨͽҹ֧འщ·Οপą ႬĞChristian August Selmer, 1880-84ğ̰ᅦྫྷ઼ͳຳޘౘࣗӎՙԼࢭࠎϤ ĞWikipedia, 2020: Johan SverdrupğĄտĂΙ˟͵జ࢝д 1884ךјΑᇅ ѐЇкᇴᛨᅳఞࡗᎰąჯႬᇇጆĞJohan Sverdrup, 1884-89ğࠎ ࢵ ࠹ Ă छĂӈ̰ᅦυื၆ᛉົయ઼۞טΞͽᄲለ߷ௐ˘࣎д၁ኳଳҖ̰ᅦ ĞToyne, 1996: 283-84; Knutsen, 1997: 235ğĄࣧώ۞ϡຍߏͽᛉົϔҋ Ăݒజෛࠎ߄ጼͳᝋĞFossum & Haglund, 2006: 5-6ğĄܲ ރΙ˘͵дፉЇͳᐼ̝ᅫಶဘྏ˘ֱ๋̂ฮ۞ନ߉ֽрॗ ˠĂᛊтд 1839 ѐనཉĶᓑЪ؎ࣶົķĞUnion CommitteeğĂԓ୕࿅ᗕ ѩ۞ᗓĂΞଓ߹ك֏тңአፋგந۞͞ёֽᒺൺޙᅦࣶ۞ኢĂ೩ֻ͞ ࢬĂ઼ͳѪ݈ᔘ೩̙ಡӘĞDerry, 1979: 234; Lindgren, 1959: 48ğĄତܝٺ Ҝ۞ΙႬỊ̏͵ĞCharles XV of Sweden, 1859-72ğຍᎸᔰࠞĂௐ˟ѨᓑЪ ĻĂఢထనཉٙᏜ۞ĶᓑЪ̰ᅦķĞunion΄ڱĺᓑЪ۞ۍߏਨᑢາڍࣶົ۞ј؎ ڟcabinet27ğĂᗕ͞јࣶЧΗĂநԾᙯ࠹̢Ӏৈ۞ְચćጐგ༄઼ົ ᄋ۞ჯႬܠ˭ӓܧᛉົӎՙĞ92 ͧ 17ğĂ̏ރĂݒд 1871 ѐၝዎॗצତ Ăѩᓝ̏གྷᛈ̈́ৠཐ̈́Ҍۏٽۏᛉົͽރᛉॗޙᇇጆ൭ϋćĶ༄ᓙ ˯۞ᝋķĞ a nation which dares to offer the Norwegian Storting a proposition of barter and trade touching the nation’s holy and supreme right of sovereigntyğĂೱήྖᄲĂ࿅፟ၹֽ࣒࣒ྃр۞ॡ፟̏࿅Ăࢋચߏ̶͘۞
:९ăٕზ९Ăᝋӎՙጳ߆ְચĞWikipedia, 2020ڱӎՙ˘ਠޘˬĂ઼ͳΞͽڱॲፂጳ 25 Johan SverdrupğĄ ؼ᭸Ğsuspensiveğ҃̏ĞDerry, 1979: 261ğĄܧчᛨᄮࠎ઼ͳ۞ӎՙᝋߏ၆۞ă҃ܲ 26 27 ̙ߏ coalitional cabinetĄ ѺѐϲӅ˧ 285۞ރॗ
͞ёĞDerry, 1979: 268-69; Lindgren, 1959: 51ğĄΙ˟͵઼ͳЇ̰Ăௐ Ѻؖᙯ͕۞ރĞ1898ğĂ̙࿅ĂॗܔᛉҬͼਫ਼ЍޙѨᓑЪ؎ࣶົٙ೩۞ˬ ϲ۞ሗ߹ć༄дރ࣒ྃ̏གྷጿ̙ҝॗ۞༼༼ڑڑߏనཉҋ̎۞ᅳְĂ ͵˟ѐΡฟ۞ௐαѨᓑЪົᛉҬͼྕᑗăݒߏ˘ೃଐᙸĂጐგΙ 1902 ;ᅳ̶ְϲĂ̏གྷቤ̙ᑻާĞDerry, 1979: 270-71צд 1903 ѐܑϯᙸຍឰՎତ Lindgren, 1959: 70, 77-79; Morris, 1904: 412-43ğĄ
伍、挪威的獨立
ྋྫྷ༄۞ᓑ༖ĂΠࠁ۞ܲރд઼छؠҜ˯Ăνࠁ۞ҋϤᛨ࣍ᛉॗ чᛨૺπඈгҜ۞ᓑЪᙯܼĈҋϤᛨࢵА೩ૻർ۞Ķॉᐝ߆ඉķĞfist ĂૺҌ͌ࢋѣ၁ኳ۞ϲăТنpolicyğĂࢋՐϲγϹćܲчᛨ̙ᅅ Ąд 1891ޢ·ॡྫྷ༄ππӱĂҭᏴϔ̏གྷ̙ࠎٙજĂপҾߏ̳ϔᝋᕖ ඈࢦ̂Լࢭ෦Րଡ˿ࢦֽĞ63טѐ̂ᏴĂҋϤࠁͽᕖ̳̂ϔᝋăͽ̈́ᇈһ ͧ 35 यğĂࡗᎰκąΫոĞJohannes Steen, 1891-93ğଯજγϹ̶ϲĄጐ ֍࿅எĂΐ˯߆ᝋᖼڡᗕ͞ٺგᄃ༄੫၆̶ϲᅳְ۞ኘҿ̏གྷणฟĂϤ ҁѺؖ̏གྷ͕ᐝ̏ؠĂރĄ̙࿅Ăॗ̙̂ޘĂซރொᐛᓄ28ă̈́༄۞ְ ϟϯऴĂ˵ᆧΐ౯ăΐღዮᙝ֨Ą̙ع߆ރ࠼۞ॗޢѣϔຍү ˠ͚ᚶᜈྫྷ༄ჯᓑ༖ᙯܼ۞ᓏࢰֽރȈ˝͵ࡔϐĂॗ˞ז Ăޢؠă֕Ш᜕ܲཌྷ̝םٽҋϤ۞ރĂপҾߏ༄д 1897 ѐᆿੵྫྷॗ͌ ,ѩඕ༖۞ቅགྷᑻᙯܼ̼ࠎำ29ĞWikipediaكͽͰᔘͰ೩ᙯඁĂރॗ ਕѣҋ̎۞γϹ̙ރॗٺUnion between Sweden and NorwayğĄᚨඕд :2020 ˠдঔγ۞ӀރࠁˠᏴВϡ30ĂͻγϹҋّĂॗܜĂᅳְϤ༄γొ
ѐĂᓁВᓝҖ 5 Ѩ̂ᏴĞ1891ă1894ă1897ă1900ă1903ğĂೱ˞ 7 ࣎ 1905 ז ଂ 1891 28 ߆Ă֍ WikipediaĞ2020: List of heads of government of NorwayğĄ ҁ̙̂ރؠĞMellomriksloveneğĂ҃Ă༄д 1895 ѐΐͽᆿੵĂॗםٽᗕࣧ͞ώѣ 29 ᎸĞFossum & Haglund, 2006: 6; Vedung, 1971: 443; Wikipedia, 2014: MellomrikslovenğĄ ĞsingleܜVedungĞ1971: 440ğ۞ϡфߏĈВТγϹొĞjoint foreign officeğăಏ˘γϹొ 30 minister for foreign affairsğă˘γϹˠࣶĞunified foreign corpsğă̈́ВТᅳְ፟ᙯ Ğcommon consular authorityğĄ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 286
ৈ̙ਕᒔग़Ă͍ߏ௺ྻĄՀࢦࢋ۞ߏĂಶ෪ᇈຍཌྷ҃֏Ăϲ۞ᅳ ༄ᓑЪᙯܼ۞͑ໝĂՀܑ˘࣎ϲ۞઼छĄдྫྷٺ፟ၹ̙ͤͅߍ၆ְ ࢋՐѣҋ̎۞γϹొރᛉĂͅߍдॗۋᝋ۞ٺѐมĂᗕ͞၆ 1895-1905 ĞHolmøyvik, 2005: 137ğĄ ઃдයࡻ۞ຐညᆸܧѺؖ۞ϔཌྷႚĂ̏ރซˢ˟Ȉ͵ࡔĂॗ ѿྃկĂͳᐼΟ͈ĞϏֽ˸عѨĂᅳְᛉᗟјࠎ̶͘۞˾Ă༄߆ ͳΟ͈̣͵ Gustaf V of Sweden, 1907-50ğဘྏͽᅳ̶ְϲ઼۞ Ğseparate consular servicesğϹೱВТγϹĞcommon foreign servicesğĂͭ ,ᙸຍᕝਖ਼ϲγϹ۞፟ົĞWikipedia̙˵ރͳΙ˟͵̙ࣚីĂ҃ॗ 2020: Union between Sweden and Norway; Morris, 1904: 143; Fossum & ҹ֧འщą۞عHaglund, 2006: 7ğĄд 1905 ѐ 5 ͡ 23 ͟Ăତ͘αᛨᓑЪ߆ Ļڱᛉົ఼࿅ĺᅳְރѼ̷ႬĞChristian Michelsen, 1905-1907ğ࿅ॗ дن͵˟ĞKonsulatsakenğăՙؠјϲҋ̎۞ᅳְᐡĂҁঽ۞઼ͳΙ 5 ͡ 27 ͟ೇΐͽӎՙćѼ̷Ⴌ˯ࢍ൪ކοᓁᙜ࿀झĂ઼҃ͳ ϯĶĺ༊˭Ļ˧ᅦķĞcould not now form a new government31ğ҃١ܑ ăٕҁޥĂ឵јጳ߆۩П፟32ĞDerry, 1979: 272ğĄ̙ۢ༄ࢍΞצତ ο̷ᕝྫྷ༄۞ᓑ༖ᙯܼĂ֞ކᛉົд 6 ͡ 7 ͟˘ՙᛉĂރৠддĂॗ ćՙᛉ۞நϤߏΙ˟͵ߊ͟هϲҋϤ۞ࡔރâ͇జ༊үߏॗ̫ :ͳ۞ᖚч33ĞWikipedia, 2020઼ރॗم١Їາ۞̰ᅦĂԛТϏਕႽ
ώߏĞLindgren, 1959: 125ğĈۍΩ˘࣎ͧྵԆፋ۞ 31 Since it is clear to me that no other government can be formed now, so I do not agree to accept the resignations of the council members. ரΙ˟͵ٙ೩۞ߏĶ༊˭ķĞnowğĄنຍגDerryĞ1979: 272ğĂѼ̷Ⴌ 32 ώߏĞLindgren, 1959: 131ğĈۍΩ˘࣎ 33 When the ministerial council’s members have resigned their functions, When His Majesty the King has declared himself unable to form a new government for the country, When the constitutional royal powers thus have ceased to function, The Storting authorizes the members of the resigned ministry to continue until further as the Norwegian Government and to administer the authority granted to the King in agreement with the Royal Norwegian Constitution and applicable laws, with the alterations that are necessary thereto, and that the union with Sweden under one king is dissolved in consequence of the king’s ceasing to function as King of Norway. ѺѐϲӅ˧ 287۞ރॗ
Dissolution of the union between Norway and SwedenğĈ
Since all the members of the cabinet have resigned their positions; since His Majesty the King has declared his inability to obtain for the country a new government; and since the constitutional monarchy has ceased to exist, the Storting hereby authorizes the cabinet that resigned today to exercise the powers held by the King in accordance with the Constitution of Norway and relevant laws – with the amendments necessitated by the dissolution of the union with Sweden under one King, resulting from the fact that the King no longer functions as a Norwegian King.
١ᅊ͵˟֏ෛࠎݔใĂΙކĶࢭķ۞ރॗٺฟᐝĂ༄၆˘ ĄտĂ༄̝ٙͽឰސҜĂ҃༄઼ົ˵̙ϟрჸрĂдᙝࠧ၆ ćރҝॗۋՎĂࢋߏЯࠎ༊ॡ઼̰۞ۤົϔྻજ̏གྷ૦Ăͅ၆ͽጼ ϔۤٺѝд 1905 ѐ 2 ͡ĂүछщऌąႳᚊֲąΙ൞ऌĞKata Dalströmğ ĈĶᗫฟᓑЪͳ઼ӐĊဥඕ઼౻જ۰۞ሇϖᅈ̙ົᕝଫķײ়˯ᛨ̂ົ ĞLet the union go. The bridge uniting the workers of our two countries will ,ᛨᅾΙႬąֲႬąοᜋԗĞHjalmar Branting۞ֽޢnever break down.ğĂ ķĞHandރ͘ॗٸˠ˾۞˾ཱིĶ઼ͳۉ1907-25ğд 5 ͡ 1 ͟۞ะົ˵಄ᓛ off Norway, King!ğĞClyne, et al.: 2005ğĄ ă߆Ԋ̙ᘦ۞ଐ๕˭34Ăጐგ༄Πࠁૺૻർ߱͘Ă઼ͳڡд̰ొ̶ ઼ˠϔϹೋĂͽҺฟጼćѩγĂ༄˵ፉ͕ᗉᑅົౄј઼ᅫזᙸຍ࠻̙ ኘҿ۞͞ёந̶͘35ĂᘪࢎĺΙႬᇇĻĞTreaty ofפଳٺ؝ϲĂ۞˯ ˠϔ̳Ըՙؠ݈Ąдኘҿ̝ᅫĞ8/31-9/23ğĂᗕރKarlstad, 1905ğĂឰॗ
༊ү̂Ᏼ۞ጼఙĂ˵ಶߏोֽރĂഈ߆ᛨᙱҺԯॗعд 1905 ѐĂ༄ಶೱ˞ˬѨ߆ 34 ༊઼̰ঐϡĞWikipedia, 2020: List of prime ministers of Sweden; Vedung, 1971: 445ğĄ ĂᓑЪ՟ѣ̦ᆃϡķĞOf little useצυืజ࢝ତރహ̼ᄲćĶࢋߏॗٺΙ˟͵ 35 ăܜwould the Union be if Norway had to be forced into itğĞMorris, 1904: 143ğĄ઼֨ొ ҹႬąٛĞAxel Rappeğܠܑᛖπྋՙ۞චຍĂౙރణ۞ॗֽྫྷܜણᏖᓁ̈́ ˠ֗ԽᑝĂӎĂזዎރА൴જԽᑝĂٕࢋߏ઼ͳٕͳᐼдॗރॗܧ˵ܲᙋĈĶੵ ķĞLindgren, 1959: 115ğĄރซˢॗל˘༄̙ົѣ˘һ ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 288
νࠁϔރдᙝࠧొཌһ˧Ă࠹̳֧Ąጐგ༄дְ˯ҫᐹ๕Ăॗ͞ ຍ͚̙ଓ˘ጼՐϲĄ ѝಶࢍ൪д 8 ͡ 13 ͟ᓝᏱ̳ԸĂͽҺឰˠᛇߏع߆ރ၁Ăॗ ϲķĂ҃ߏĶߏӎቁᄮ̏གྷౄјރĶߏӎ͚ॗܧ༄Ą̳Ը۞ᗟϫ֭ٺ ߊؠְ၁۞ྋវķĞDo you approve the “ratified dissolution of the union”?ğć Ѩ̳Ը۞Ըைத 85.42%Ă368,208 ˠĞ99.95%ğ͚ϲĂΪѣ 184 ˠ Ğ0.05%ğ͚ᚶᜈჯᓑЪᙯܼĂԸைத྿ 85%Ą༊ॡẴّᔵ՟ѣ ԸைᝋĂВѣ 279,878 ˠాཌ͚ϲĞWikipedia, 2020: 1905 Norwegian union dissolution referendumğĄ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2020: File:Norwegian Army guarding Swedish border 1905.jpgğĄֽ ౙїч༄ᙝࠧރဦ 6Ĉॗ
ᛉົАд 10 ͡ 9 ͟ԸைТຍ̶͘۞୧ІĂତĂ༄ރĂॗޢኘҿԆј ކ͟ Ă༄઼ͳΙ˟͵д 10 ͡ 26ޢĄצ઼ົ˵д 10 ͡ 13 ͟ତ ϲćд 11 ͡ 12-13 ͟۞̳ԸĂˠϔజރͳҜăϒёٚᄮॗ۞ރୢॗٸο ߏӎჯӖϲጳĞDo you agree with the Storting’sعߏӎ߆זય authorization to the government to invite Prince Carl of Denmark to become ѺѐϲӅ˧ 289۞ރॗ
King of Norway?ğĂԸைத 75.32%Ă259,563 ˠĞ78.94%ğᙒјă69,264 ˠ Ğ21.06%ğͅ၆ğĞWikipedia, 2020: 1905 Norwegian monarchy referendumğĄ Ᏼ̜౪ͳ̄ΙႬĞPrince Carl of Denmarkğࠎ઼ͳݣ˛͵ĞHaakonົ઼ ѐௐ˘Ҝৌϒҋ̎۞઼ͳĄдݣ 518 ރVII of Norway, 1905-57ğĂߏॗ 1905 ٺă̜౪ăࡻ઼ă̈́ᇇ઼ጼᚻ۞᜕˭ĂރϤ࣯ώݣॲ൴Ăॗ͵˛ ࢵౌҹ֧འщκֲĞChristianiaĂனд۞ރ྿ॗٯѐ 11 ͡ 25 ͟জজᎿᎿ ĞMorris, 1904: 144ğĄܓऽـౙğĂᓁநѼ̷ႬᏐҋ݈
ĈArnesenĞn.d.ğĄֽ
ତҜĞνğރॗـ݈͵˛ဦ 7Ĉα઼ጼᚻ᜕ݣ
ĈWikimedia CommonsĞ2020: File:Statsminister Christian Michelsen mottar kong Haakon 7ֽ og kronprins Olav ombord det norske marinefartøyet “Heimdal”, 25. november 1905.jpg.ğĄ
Ğ1905ğĞΠğރ྿ॗٯ͵˛ତ઼ͳݣܓဦ 8ĈᓁநѼ̷Ⴌ
ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 290
附錄 1:中世紀末統一前的挪威諸小王國(850)36
ĈjkvatterholmĞ2014ğĄֽ 36 ѺѐϲӅ˧ 291۞ރॗ
參考文獻
ჯૄѺࡊĂ2019ĄIJॗރӖЕܑijĞhttps://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/ॗރӖЕܑğ Ğ2020/5/6ğĄ Arnesen, Vilhelm Karl Ferdinand. n.d. “Prince Carl and Princess Maud Arriving in Oslo Fiord as King Haakon VII and Queen Maud of Norway in 1905.” (http://www. artnet.com/artists/vilhelm-karl-ferdinand-arnesen/prince-carl-and-princess-maud-arri ving-in-oslo-1vtN703ikym3sFIq0PDECg2) (2020/5/10) Barton, H. Arnold. 2005. “The Norwegian-Swedish Union and Its Dissolution 1814-1905: A Review.” Scandinavian Studies, Vol. 77, No. 4, pp. 501-506. Clyne, Jonathan, Kerstin Alfredsson, and Lena Höijer. 2005. “Norway- Sweden 1905: How the Labour Movement Prevented War.” (https://www.marxist.com/norway- sweden-1905-war150405.htm) (2020/5/10) Derry, T. K. 1979. A History of Scandinavia: Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Finland and Iceland. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Elgenius, Gabriella. 2011. “The Politics of Recognition: Symbols, Nation Building and Rival Nationalisms.” Nations and Nationalism, Vol. 17, No. 2, pp. 396-418. Fossum, John Erik, and David G. Haglund. 2006. “1905 and All That: Quebec and the Issue of Chronological Symbolism.” (https://www.cpsa-acsp.ca/papers-2006/ Fossum-Haglund.pdf) (2020/5/10) Gustafsson, Harald. 2006. “A State That Failed? On the Union of Kalmar, Especially Its Dissolution.” Scandinavian Journal of History, Vol. 31, Nos. 3-4, pp. 205-20. Hjerm, M. 1998. “Reconstructing ‘Positive’ Nationalism: Evidence from Norway and Sweden.” Sociological Research Online, Vol. 3, No. 2 (http://www.socresonline. org.uk/3/2/7.html) (2020/5/10) Holmøyvik, Eirik. 2005. “The Theory of Sovereignty and the Swedish- Norwegian Union of 1814.” Journal of the History of International Law, Vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 137-56. Jkvatterholm. 2014. “The Viking-age Fylki (Petty kingdoms) in Norway before the Unification.” (https://mapsontheweb.zoom-maps.com/post/81379550773/the-viking- age-fylki-petty-kingdoms-in-norway) (2020/5/6) Knutsen, Jan Normann. 1997. “Aspects of the Union between. Sweden and Norway (1814-1905).” Folia Scandinavica, Vol. 4, pp. 225-39. ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 292
Lenin, Vladimir Ilyich. 1914. “Norway’s Secession from Sweden,” in The Right of Nations to Self-Determination (https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1914/ self-det/ch06.htm) (2020/5/10) Lindgren, Raymond E. 1959. Norway-Sweden: Union, Disunion, and Scandinavia Integration. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press. Morris, Charles. 1904. Historical Tales: The Romance of Reality. Los Angeles: Angelus University. Redvaldsen, David. 2014. “Great Britain and the Norwegian constitution of 1814.” Parliaments, Estates and Representation, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 182-202. Toyne, S. M. 1996 (1948). The Scandinavia in History. New York: Barnes & Noble. Vedung, Evert. 1971. “Unionsdebatten 1905: En jämförelse mellan argumenteringen i Sverige och Norge.” (The Dissolution of the Union in 1905: A Comparison between Swedish and Norwegian Arguments). Ph.D. thesis, Uppsala University (http:// www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:170490/FULLTEXT01.pdf) (2020/5/10) WHKMLA. 2004. “Kalmar Union.” (https://www.zum.de/whkmla/histatlas/scandinavia/ finkalmar.gif) (2020/5/5) Wikimedia Commons. 2016. “File:Scandinavia1219.png.” (https://commons.wikimedia. org/wiki/File:Scandinavia1219.png) (2020/5/6) Wikimedia Commons. 2019. “File:Skielober 1811.jpg.” (https://commons.wikimedia. org/wiki/File:Skielober_1811.jpg) (2020/5/4) Wikimedia Commons. 2019. “File:Eidsvoll riksraad 1814.jpeg.” (https://commons. wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Eidsvoll_riksraad_1814.jpeg) (2020/5/4) Wikimedia Commons. 2019. “File:Torvslaget den 17 Mai 1829 i Kristiania.jpg.” (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Torvslaget_den_17_Mai_1829_i_Kristian ia.jpg) (2020/5/5) Wikimedia Commons. 2020. “File:Norwegian Army guarding Swedish border 1905.jpg.” (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Norwegian_Army_guarding_ Swedish_border_1905.jpg) (2020/5/4) Wikimedia Commons. 2020. “File:Statsminister Christian Michelsen mottar kong Haakon 7 og kronprins Olav ombord det norske marinefartøyet “Heimdal”, 25. november 1905.jpg.” (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Statsminister_ Christian_Michelsen_mottar_kong_Haakon_7_og_kronprins_Olav_ombord_det_nor ske_marinefart%C3%B8yet_%22Heimdal%22,_25._november_1905.jpg) (2020/5/8) ѺѐϲӅ˧ 293۞ރॗ
Wikipedia. 2013. “Mellomriksloven.” (https://no.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mellomriksloven) (2020/5/10) Wikipedia. 2019. “Treaty of Fredrikshamn.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_ of_Fredrikshamn) (2020/5/9) Wikipedia. 2020. “1905 Norwegian monarchy referendum.” (https://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/1905_Norwegian_monarchy_referendum) (2020/5/4) Wikipedia. 2020. “Dano-Swedish War of 1808-09.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Dano-Swedish_War_of_1808%E2%80%9309#Treaty_of_J%C3%B6nk%C3% B6ping) (2020/5/9) Wikipedia. 2020. “Dissolution of the union between Norway and Sweden.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissolution_of_the_union_between_Norway_and_Sw eden) (2020/5/4) Wikipedia. 2020. “Johan Sverdrup.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johan_Sverdrup) (2020/5/7) Wikipedia. 2020. “Kingdom of Norway (1814).” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Kingdom_of_Norway_(1814)) (2020/5/7) Wikipedia. 2020. “List of heads of government of Norway.” (https://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/List_of_heads_of_government_of_Norway) (2020/5/7) Wikipedia. 2020. “Union between Sweden and Norway.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Union_between_Sweden_and_Norway) (2020/5/5) Wikipedia. 2020. “List of prime ministers of Sweden.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/List_of_prime_ministers_of_Sweden) (2020/5/10)
ăௐ 1 ഇĞ2021/ߋ؞ཱིğס Įέ៉઼ᅫࡁտ؞Ώįௐ 17 294
Norway’s One Hundred Years of Independence Struggle
Cheng-Feng Shih Professor, Department of Indigenous Affairs and Development National Dong Hwa University Shoufeng, Hualien, TAIWAN
Abstract
We shall begin with a brief review of the historical background of Norway. And then examine how Norway had maintained itself between Denmark and Sweden. We then look into how Demark had given away Norway to Sweden. Next, we will explore the divergent views of national interests among the Norwegians themselves. Finally, we will describe the process how Norway had obtained its independence.
Keywords: Norway, Denmark, Sweden, independence