The Molecular Origins of Chiral Growth in Walled Cells
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COMICR-1050; NO. OF PAGES 8 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com The molecular origins of chiral growth in walled cells 1,2 3 4 Kerwyn Casey Huang , David W Ehrhardt and Joshua W Shaevitz Cells from all kingdoms of life adopt a dizzying array of In these walled cells, growth occurs through the spatially fascinating shapes that support cellular function. Amoeboid and regulated insertion of new material into the exoskeletal spherical shapes represent perhaps the simplest of geometries cell wall. Local insertion of material, performed by a host that may minimize the level of growth control required for of proteins, must be coordinated on the cellular scale so survival. Slightly more complex are rod-shaped cells, from that cell shape and the mechanical integrity of the wall are microscopic bacteria to macroscopic plants, which require maintained. While molecular experiments have led to the additional mechanisms to define a cell’s longitudinal axis, width, characterization of many of the players in this process, and length. Recent evidence suggests that many rod-shaped, understanding the regulation of shape requires walled cells achieve elongated growth through chiral insertion of approaches that can bridge the molecular and cellular cell-wall material that may be coupled to a twisting of the cell scales. Two key issues we address in this review are first, body. Inspired by these observations, biophysical mechanisms how individual molecules can organize into chiral fila- for twisting growth have been proposed that link the mechanics ments to generate a spatially coordinated pattern of of intracellular proteins to cell shape maintenance. In this review, growth, and second, the biophysical interactions required we highlight experimental and theoretical work that connects for robust, rod-shaped growth. molecular-scale organization and structure with the cellular- scale phenomena of rod-shaped growth. Cell-wall growth in bacteria Addresses Cell shape in nearly all bacteria is governed by the 1 Department of Bioengineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA peptidoglycan cell wall, a meshwork of glycan strands 2 Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Stanford University crosslinked by short peptides [2,3]. During growth and School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA 3 division, newly synthesized peptidoglycan subunits are Department of Plant Biology, Carnegie Institution, Stanford, CA, USA 4 incorporated into the wall through the concerted effort of Department of Physics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, USA a number of enzymes including the murein (Mur) and Corresponding authors: Huang, Kerwyn Casey ([email protected]), penicillin binding proteins (PBPs). These enzymes con- Shaevitz, Joshua W. ([email protected]) struct the cell wall through synthesis of new subunits, breakage of existing linkages in the wall, and insertion of new subunits to grow the peptidoglycan network. Current Opinion in Microbiology 2012, 15:xx–yy This review comes from a themed issue on Growth and development: While many of these enzymes have been characterized prokaryotes biochemically, several important biophysical questions Edited by Orna Amster-Choder and Taˆ m Mignot about their method of action remain unanswered. For example, severing individual linkages will promote the wall to expand under turgor, leading to a weakened state [4]. However, as new units are added, they can also have a 1369-5274/$ – see front matter, # 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights rigidifying effect on the wall if they are actively stressed reserved. before insertion in order to resist expansion [5]. It is not http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mib.2012.11.002 currently known to what extent wall enzymes must coordinate their activities, in either space or time, in order for growth with a maintained shape to proceed. Introduction Biochemical measurements of in vitro peptidoglycan Cell shape is dictated physically by the balance of forces polymerization suggest that at least some of the enzymes on the cell envelope. Turgor pressure due to the high may be processive [6–9]; however, how this processivity concentration of osmotic solutes inside cells generates an manifests in vivo [10] and whether it is coupled between outward pressure on the envelope. To maintain a non- enzymes remain under current investigation. spherical shape, cells must surround themselves with an anisotropic elastic structure that expands to counterba- Rod-shaped growth lance this pressure. In animal cells, this is largely achieved Perhaps the simplest systems for studying complex cell through the construction of intracellular cortical networks growth are elongated rods, which must encode, at the of actin filaments, although other elastic filaments such as molecular level, a three-dimensional coordinate system spectrin can also be used. On the other hand, bacteria use that defines the longitudinal cell axis and division plane in a rigid, extracellular cell wall composed of a network of addition to the cell length and width. Rod-shaped cells peptidoglycan while plants use a wall composed of cellu- are common in both bacteria and plants. Prokaryotic rods lose and other polysaccharides [1]. are thought to possess several biophysical advantages over www.sciencedirect.com Current Opinion in Microbiology 2012, 15:1–8 Please cite this article in press as: Huang KC, et al.: The molecular origins of chiral growth in walled cells, Curr Opin Microbiol (2012), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mib.2012.11.002 COMICR-1050; NO. OF PAGES 8 2 Growth and development: prokaryotes Figure 1 non-elongated cells for functions such as motility and in certain environmental niches [11–13]. In plants, rod- shaped cell growth is coupled directly to the elongation (a) (b) of roots, stems, and other tissues. Because of their small size and the fast speed of diffusion α γ within the cytoplasm, it is difficult for a bacterial cell to establish precise cytoplasmic gradients with which to β define a cellular coordinate system [14,15]. Instead, it has been proposed that geometric cues such as curvature may provide information about orientation within the cell that can be processed through local binding interactions between inherently curved polymers and a curved surface (c)(d) (e) [16–18]. The determination and maintenance of cell shape are governed by the cellular-scale pattern of wall insertion and the balance of forces on the cell wall [19,20]. To query whether local geometric cues can guide cellular-scale patterning that robustly generates the correct cell shape requires experimental and computational tools to quantify and connect molecular organization to wall patterning. While some rod-shaped bacteria insert material at the poles or mid-cell, most model bacteria with a rod shape Current Opinion in Microbiology appear to insert material in a roughly uniform distribution along the cylindrical portion of the cell wall. However, (a) Three angles, often referred to as Euler angles, are needed to computational simulations studying the consequences of describe an arbitrary rotation between adjacent monomers in a polymer. random insertion predict a loss of both cell shape and (b) Different combinations of the Euler angles a, b, and g yield different filament geometries including straight rods, helices, and rings. (c) X-ray mechanical integrity [5], suggesting that the orchestration crystallography has revealed that MreB monomers polymerize into linear of growth is required for rod-shape maintenance. In protofilaments (adapted from [61]). (d) MreB binds directly to lipid elongating bacteria, recent evidence suggests that fila- membranes in a double-protofilament geometry (adapted from [33]). (e) ments with chiral (left- or right-handed) positioning along In live cells, MreB labeled with YFP at the N-terminus forms polymeric the membrane are used to coordinate insertion, producing structures with a left-handed chirality. both a rod-like shape and a robustly cross-linked cell wall that twists as it grows [21]. particularly interesting property of these filaments in a Protein filaments are inherently chiral biological context is that resultant shapes can have features Biopolymer filaments such as actin, microtubules, and on length scales much larger than the size of an individual bacterial flagellar filaments are linear assemblies of indi- monomer. Examples of these include the radius of vidual monomeric units. The molecular binding inter- curvature for a ring and the pitch of a helix, both of actions between protein monomers define the spatial which can be arbitrarily large compared to the scale of relationship between adjacent monomers in a filament. the proteins themselves. These features are independent In general, three angles that encapsulate the relative of the chemical kinetics that affect the length of filaments orientation of neighboring monomers along the filament through assembly and disassembly. Thus, polymeriz- define this relationship (Figure 1a). Different combi- ation of filaments can generate cellular-scale ‘order’ nations of angles between monomer subunits lead to a independent of the monomer size or chemical kinetics. variety of beautiful and complex filament shapes Outstanding questions surrounding this topic are the (Figure 1b) whose geometry has been the subject of extent to which this order is established for filaments study as far back as Euler. A common feature of all of in living cells, and the mechanisms through which this these shapes is their helicity, due to the fact that a order can be maintained and utilized for cellular-scale constant bend and twist per monomer leads to chiral phenomena such as growth. backbones [22–24]. Indeed, as early as 1950, the helical nature of biological chains was recognized, with a pres- In bacteria, a number of cytoskeletal polymers have been cient focus on biological growth [24]. described as helical. Filament bundles of the tubulin homolog FtsZ form tightly wound circumferential rings Of the observed classes of filaments, simplified shapes at the division plane in nearly all prokaryotes, and have such as straight lines and rings are extreme limits in which been observed to form helical structures away from the some of the relative orientation angles are zero.