COUNCIL 88 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 89

Wednesday, 12 August 1992

QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

The following answers to questions on notice were circulated - INACTIVE LIST - LABOUR

Question No. 949 Hon. G. B. ASHMAN asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Labour: For each deparbnent and agency, how many officers are on the "inactive list", indicating - (i) their names; (ii) the agency paying the salary Iwages; (iii) the date they were first placed on the list; (iv) the value of salaries paid to each officer; and (v) the value of other benefits paid or provided to each officer. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) -The answer supplied by the Minister for Labour is: There is no list of inactive public service officers within the Deparbnent of Labour. As at 30 September 10 officers were on the redeployment register and details in respect of parts (ii) to (v) of this question are listed below.

OTHER AGENCY PAYING DATE FlRST ANNUAL BENEFITS SALARY /WAGES PLACED ON LIST SALARY PAID

Employment/DOLI 23.1.91 $57471 $2109 EOA EPA/DOL2 9.90 $42180 N/ A Premier & Cabinet 15.6.90 N/ A OHSA 12.11.90 $41693 WMU/DOLI 2.10.90 $41693 Employment/DOLI 5.5.88 $37492 lRCV /DOL I 5.5.88 $37492 Employment/DOLI 28.3.88 $30014 Employment/DOLI 3.10.91 $34 069 DMlI}' 7.1.91 $81075 $4107 EOA Training has been provided where appropriate in accordance with redeployment provisions and guidelines. The names of the officers concerned have not been provided to avoid a breach of personal confidentiality. I. Intend redeployment placement 2. Shared costs for salary 3. Salary paid by DMID 11.8.91

VICIMAGE - PREMIER AND CABINET

Question No. 1244 Hon. HAD DON STOREY asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Premier: (a) Has the Premier or the Premier's department made use of the services of VICIMAGE at any time since 1 January 1990; if so, what services were performed by VICIMAGE and did any part of the services include taking photographs of the Premier. (b) What was the cost of each service provided by VICIMAGE and who met such cost. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

90 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Premier is: 1. The use of VICIMAGE services are listed below in two categories. The first concerns instances when photographs were taken of the Premier and the information has been collated by the Premier's Press Office. 2. The second category is the general use of VICIMAGE's services by various branches in the Premier's department. Whilst this information has been assessed as being reasonably accurate, based on a scanning and sample check, it is information that was provided to the department by VICIMAGE for the period 1 January 1990 to 4 December 1991. The information cannot readily be provided from sources in the department as it would require a search of all accounts received from the (former) Department of Property and Services, the Ministry of Finance and VICIMAGE. 3. The branch requesting the service is shown where it was identified in the information provided by VICIMAGE. The costs of the services were met from the budget of the branch requesting the service. In the case of the Premier's portraits, the cost was met from the Premier's office budget.

VICIMAGE PHOTOGRAPHY SERVICES USED BY PREMIER'S OFFICE JAN 1990-MARCH 1992

18.05.90 Portrait photographs of Premier John Cain $859.77 General Press/Public distribution 11.04.91 Portrait photographs of Premier Joan Kimer $ SO.50 Parliamentary Library 11.04.91 Launch of Senior's Card $204.60 General Media distribution 03.06.91 Portrait photographs of Premier Joan Kimer $240.00 General Press/Public distribution on request 24.06.91 Portrait photographs of Premier Joan Kimer $438.00 General Press/Public distribution on request 31.07.91 Premier presenting June Economic Statement $217.30 Contact Print &: selected photo for Media distribution 09.08.91 Premier &: visiting priests $ 97.00 For distribution to Ethnic Press 16.08.91 Contact Print Premier with Waiter Sisulu &: Wife $ 81.30 Selection of print 20.08.91 Portrait photographs of Premier Joan Kimer $576.00 General Press/Public distribution on request 27.08.91 Prints of Premier with Waiter Sisulu &: Wife $ 40.00 Official record of meeting. Copies to Ethnic Affairs 12.09.91 Portrait photographs of Premier Joan Kimer $ 40.00 Press requirement 12.09.91 Premier presenting award $ 91.30 General Media distribution 27.09.91 Premier presenting award $ 81.30 General Media distribution 12.09.91 Photographs of Premier with visiting Priests $360.30 DPC reimbursed full amount by Priests

Nature of Service Cost Branch $ Laminating 261.05 Social Justice Unit Duplicates 235.76 Projects Branch Photographs and Printing 286.60 Photographs and Printing 152.00 Photographs and Printing 81.30 Printing 121.00 Processing 70.00 Photographs and Printing 2627.40 Printing 95.00 Photographs and Printing 120.00 Photographs and Printing 106.30 Printing 24.00 Printing 740.00 Printing 14.00 Photographs and Printing 630.90 Photographs and Printing 485.40 Photographs and Printing 1091.00 Photographs and Printing 331.00 Photographs and Printing 505.00 Printing lSO.50 Photographs and Printing 97.00 Photographs and Printing 122.00 Studio Portrait 31.30 Photographs and Printing 71.30 Printing 242.50 Premiers - Photographs and Printing 111.00 Premiers - Laser copies and Photography 81.00 Photography and Printing 206.70 Photography and Printing 178.70 (Children's Week) - Photography and Printing 109.75 Photography and Printing 492.12 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 91

Photography and Printing 659.20 Printing 124.20 Printing 754.75 Printing 128.00 Photography and Printing 142.00 Printing 282.10 Re-Prints I. Baker & T. Sheehan 27.60 Printing 32.21 Photography and Printing of Ministry 158.75 Printing 48.30 Photography and Printing 167.10 Printing of (of Ministry) 100.10 Photography and Printing 806.50 1 Dupe Transparency 25.00 Photography and Printing 71.10 Photography and Printing - J. Cain 128.05 Laminating 16.00 Laminating 190.65 Laser Copies 90.00 Slides 331.00 Processing and Printing 26.00 Cabinet Secretary Printing 369.00 Executive Council Photography and Printing 159.00 Projects Printing 507.00 Projects Branch Printing 304.00 Projects Branch Printing 16.00 Projects Branch Photography and Printing 63.60 Publicity Printing 175.30 Publicity Printing 393.00 Social Justice Unit Printing 66.50 Social Justice Unit Printing 328.00 Social Justice Unit Studio Portrait 31.30 Social Justice Unit Printing 104.00 Social Justice Unit Printing and Mounting 418.73 Social Justice Unit Printing and Mounting 322.10 Social Justice Unit Processing and Printing 31.10 Social Justice Unit Laser Copies 315.00 Social Justice Unit Photographs and Printing 31.30 V.W.CC Photographs and Printing 143.90 V.W.CC Photographs and Printing 91.30 V.W.CC Photographs and Printing 56.30 S.P. Coord Unit Photographs and Printing 811.65 Senior Citizens General Photography Prints 74.81 Printing 148.10 Library Printing 48.30 Library Photography and Printing 426.60 Australia Day Printing 859.77 Laminating 261.05 Social Justice Unit Duplicates 235.76 Projects Photographs and Printing 286.60 Photographs and Printing 152.00 Photographs and Printing 81.30 Printing 121.00 Processing 70.00 Photographs and Printing 2627.40 Printing 95.00 Photographs and Printing 120.00 Photographs and Printing 204.00 Photographs and Printing 106.30 Printing 24.00 Printing 740.00 Printing 14.00 Printing 80.00 Photographs and Printing 630.90 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

92 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

JOURNALISTS -TRANSPORT

Question No. 1370 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) How many journalists, media personnel or similar staff are employed by each Ministry, department or agency that reports to the Minister. (b) What is the name of each person and what costs were incurred in each case on salary, motor car and travel expenses in 1990-91, and in this year to date. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The following information is provided in respect of journalists and media personnel employed in that capacity in agencies within the transport portfolio. The names of officers have not been included, as it would, with other information sought in this question, breach personal confidentiality. Ministry of Transport POSmON 1990-91 1991-92 Press Secretary Salary $51271 $24 957(to 18.11.91-) Travel Expenses Nil $ 33S Relieving Salary $ 6821 Press Secretary (from 11.11.91 to 31.12.91- ) Travel Expenses Nil -Note: The Minister's press secretary went on recreation leave and leave without pay on 18 November 1991. The relieving officer commenced on 11 November, 1991. Neither officers have been provided with a motor vehicle.

Public Transport Corporation POSmON SALARY (p.a.) Manager, Corporate Communications $S6 038 Journalist $38 011 Photo Journalist $32980 Communications Officer $20 129 A corporation motor vehicle is shared for work related travel where public transport cannot be used. Travel expenses are nil.

Roads Corporation VIC ROADS does not employ any professionally qualified jOurnalists. The functions of providing information in response to media inquiries and issuing news releases is included in the duties of officers in VIC ROADS corporate affairs section. The officers are not provided with a motor vehicle. Travel expenses in relation to specific events are negligible.

Grain Elevators Board The Grain Elevators Board does not employ any journalists, media personnel or similar staff.

Transport Accident Commission The Transport Accident Commission does not employ an officer specifically to carry out the functions of a journalist or media liaison. These functions are included in the duties of the corporation's corporate affairs section. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 93

LIBRARY FUNDING

Question No. 1431 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for the Arts: With reference to the Minister's press release dated 18 September 1991 entitled "Public Library funding to the South Inner Region totals $1.5 million", what funding was made available to the following municipal libraries- (i) Caulfield; (ii) Moorabbin; (iii) Sandringham; (iv) Mordialloc; and (v) Brighton and what is the rationale for the funding decisions made in each municipality. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for the Arts is: The following funds will be provided from 1 July 1992 to the municipal libraries named by the honourable member: Caulfield $298 259 Moorabbin $418293 Sandringham $133323 Mordialloc $119 071 Brighton $142758 The Ministry's Public Library Funding Program is based on a standard formula aspects of which include performance, needs and disability components. This formula is applied to all municipalities.

EMPLOYMENT OF FORMER MEMBER

Question No. 1451 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Labour: Is Mr Graham Ihlein, former member for the electoral district of Sandringham, currently employed by the Minister or any agencies for which the Minister is responsible, indicating - (i) his status as a public servant; (ii) whether he is on contract; (iii) any other basis on which he is employed; (iv) his salary and allowances, if any; and (v) his duties. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Labour is: Mr Ihlein is not currently employed within my portfolio.

EMPLOYMENT OF FORMER MEMBER

Question No. 1455 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Small Business: Is Mc Graham Ihlein, former member for the electoral district of Sandringham, currently employed by the Minister or any agencies for which the Minister is responsible, indicating - (i) his status as a public servant; (ii) whether he is On contract; (iii) any other basis on which he is employed; (iv) his salary and allowances, if any; and (v) his duties. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Small Business) - The answer is: Mc Graeme Ihlein has never been employed by the Department of Small Business or its agency, the Small Business Development Corporation.

PUBLICATIONS -SMALL BUSINESS

Question No. 1458 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Small Business: In respect of each department or agency under the Minister's administration: (a) How many and what publications are produced. (b) What is the unit cost, including the cost of production and distribution, of each publication. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

94 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

(c) What income is derived from the publication. (d) What is the purpose of the publication. (e) Are the publications printed solely in Victoria; if not, why. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Small Business) - The answer is: (a) Three publications are produced: (i) the Small Business Development Corporation's annual report; (ll) the Department of Small Business' annual report; (ill) the Small Business Bulletin commenced publication September 1991. (b) The cost of production for the 1990-91 year is: (i) $16569 for 1100 copies; (ll) $4570 for 2000 copies; (ill) $13 000 for 6 editions with an average of 2000 copies per edition. (Note: production period from September 1991 onwards). (c) There is no income derived from any of the publications. (d) The reports and the Small Business Bulletin are distributed to members of Parliament, municipal libraries, government departments, industry organisations, government and reference libraries, industry training boards, small business and other interested parties. (e) The reports are produced in Melbourne.

PUBLICATIONS - CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1470 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: In respect of each department or agency under the Minister's administration: (a) How many and what publications are produced. (b) What is the unit cost, including the cost of production and distribution, of each publication. (c) What income is derived from the publication. (d) What is the purpose of the publication. (e) Are the publications printed solely in Victoria; if not, why. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is: (a) A listing of the publications available from the Office of Corrections can be found on pages 59-60 of the 1990-91 annual report of the Office of Corrections. (b) Most of the publications are produced and distributed in-house, utilising existing Office of Corrections word processing, photocopying, printing and mailing facilities. It is not practical to determine the unit costs of such publications. However, information on some of the publications which have been printed outside the Office of Corrections, for example by the Law Printer, showing the number of copies printed and the cost of printing, is provided below:

TITLE: OFFICE OF CORRECflONS ANNUAL REPORT, 1990-91 No. of Copies 1500 Cost of Printing $6925

TITLE: KEYPOINTS No. of Copies 4300 per quarter Cost of Printing: Nil (the cost is borne by the printing company, which recoups its cost by selling advertising space)

TITLE: THE WAY AHEAD: CORPORATE DIRECflONS 1990-95 No. of Copies 4000 Cost of Printing: $3690 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday. 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 95

TITLE: STANDARD GUIDELINES FOR CORRECTIONS IN AUSTRALIA No. of Copies: 1200 Cost of Printing: $1004

TITLE: WOMEN PRISONERS AND OFFENDERS :THE AGENDA FOR CHANGE No. of Copies: 1000 Cost of Printing $4169

TITLE: UNIT MANAGEMENT GUIDELINES: ACHIEVING LEADERSHIP EXCELLENCE IN VICTORIAN PRISONS No. of Copies: 3000 Cost of Printing: $16 300

(c) The publications are made available free of charge to interested organisations and persons, with the following three exceptions: - Standard Guidelines for Corrections in Australia ($5) - Women Prisoners and Offenders: The Agenda for Change ($5) - Unit Ma7Ulgement Guidelines: Achieving LeIldership Excellence in Victorian Prisons ($12) (d) The publications provide a comprehensive range of information on the operations and activities of the Office of Corrections, as well as important correctional issues. An outline of the content of each of the publications is provided on pages 59-60 of the 1990-91 annual report of the Office of Corrections. (e) All publications are printed solely in Victoria, except for the quarterly magazine Keypoints referred to above. However, while this publication is printed in Sydney by the Pereival Publishing Co. Ply Ud, it is in fact printed at no cost to the Office of Corrections, as the printing company offsets the costs incurred in printing the magazine through revenue gained from selling advertisements which appear throughout the magazine. These advertisements are arranged by the publishing company's Melbourne office.

In respect of the Victorian Prison Industries Commission the response is: (a) During 1991-92 the commission produced the following publications: (i) Annual report for the year ended 30 June 1991-250 copies. (ii) Promotional brochure ''The Prison Industry Story" -5000 copies plus an additional print run of 5000 copies of brochure inserts. (ill) Mail-out leaflet /lA Production Alternative" - 20000 copies. (b) The unit cost of each publication was: (i) $6.50 (ii) $5.84: inserts $0.24 each (ill) $0.22 (c) Income derived from publications was: (i) No income derived (ii)(ill) No direct income derived however as a marketing tool are aimed at generating commercial inquiries leading to orders. (d) The purpose of the publications is: (i) To report the fmancial and operational performance of the Commission as required under the Annual Reporting Act 1983 and the Victorian Prison Industries Commission Act 1983. (ii)(ill) To generate new clients, prisoner employment opportunities and product sales. (e) All publications were printed within Victoria.

PUBLICATIONS - GAMING

Question No. 1473 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Gaming: In respect of each department or agency under the Minister's administration: (a) How many and what publications are produced. (b) What is the unit cost, including the cost of production and distribution, of each publication. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

96 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

(c) What income is derived from the publication. (d) What is the purpose of the publication. (e) Are the publications printed solely in Victoria; if not, why. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Gaming is: I have not included licensing forms in my reply. (a) There were 6 publications: Newsletter (3 issues) Electronic Gaming Machines in Victoria Gaining a Licence Victorian Gaming Commission Rules Security in Gaming Venues Gaming Machines: Timetable for Installation (b) Newsletter. 3 issues - $1070.00; $254.00; $1476.00. Electronic Gaming Machines in Victoria and Gaining a Licence: 1500 of each = $1564.00; reprint of 700 = $530.00. Victorian Gaming Commission Rules: 6000 copies =$1664.25. Security in Gaming Venues: 3000 copies = $759.06; reprint of 3000 = $759.06. Gaming Machines: Timetable for Installation: 4000 copies = $610.00. (c) No income is derived from them. (d) The purpose is to provide information. (e) Yes. They are printed in Victoria.

PUBLICATIONS - SCHOOL EDUCATION

Question No. 1476 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for School Education: In respect of each department or agency under the Minister'S administration: (a) How many and what publications are produced. (b) What is the unit cost, including the cost of production and distribution, of each publication. (c) What income is derived from the publication. (d) What is the purpose of the publication. (e) Are the publications printed solely in Victoria; if not, why. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for School Education is: Information about policies and programs is critical to both educational debate and to the community making informed decisions about schooling. The eight regions of the department and within these, 37 school support centres, all produce publications in order to keep their clients informed. These often take the form of regular newsletters and bulletins, with local curriculum documents and reports of educational initiatives being published from time to time. Within the central administration, School Programs Division and Resource Management Division, the Office of the Chief General Manager and the Community Relations Unit publish educational documents and material for schools and the community as deemed appropriate and necessary. Two publications which go to schools regularly are: Educationlll Quarterly, a magazine designed to promote debate; and Schools Bulletin, a fortnightly publication which contains important administrative information for schools. The Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Board, the State Board of Education, the Registered Schools Board, the Teachers Registration Board and the Institute of Educational Administration, all produce publications appropriate to their work and designed to provide necessary information to their clients. The Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Board has a considerable publishing program, given its role in administering the Victorian certificate of education. Not all publications are listed in the annual report. Given the wide range of matters which have to be reported on, not all publications are automatically included. For example, in the 1990-91 annual report, the State Board of Education provided a full list of its publications while other agencies referred only to those publications which stemmed from major initiatives for the year. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 97

To obtain information, of the kind requested and in the time allowed, on the diverse publications produced by all the agencies and organisations which are part of the Department of School Education, would require the use of an inordinate amount of time and resources. It would be possible, however, to provide information on specific publications or on publications in particular areas, if this were requested.

PUBLICATIONS - MAJOR PROJECTS

Question No. 1482 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Major Projects: In respect of each department or agency under the Minister's administration: (a) How many and what publications are produced. (b) What is the unit cost, including the cost of production and distribution, of each publication. (c) What income is derived from the publication. (d) What is the purpose of the publication. (e) Are the publications printed solely in Victoria; if not, why. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Major Projects is: The publications produced in the period 1 July 1990 to 31 March 1992 are as listed in the attached schedule.

Agency/ Publication No. of Unit Income Purpose of Was Publication Authority Copies Cost Derived Publication Printed in Victoria

Docklands Docklands Brochure 2500 $10.94 Nil Promote interest in development Yes Authority Major Brochure 1992 1000 $23.92 Nil To encourage property investment in Yes Projects Melbourne. Unit Brochure 1991 2000 $1.36 Nil Provide an overview of the unit's Yes projects. Annual Report 1990-91 850 $9.32 Nil Present unit's financial statement Yes and provide an overview of the unit's operations for the year. Annual Report 1989-90 SOO $22.36 Nil Present unit's financial statement Yes and provide an overview of the unit's operations for the year. Brochure 3000 $1.33 Nil To mark the official opening of Yes "Living History" Newmarket and launching of the housing development at Lynch's Bridge. Booklet 5(XXJ $1.83 Nil Provide information on Lynch's Yes Bridge project. Docklands/ Progress Report 5(XXJ $9.84 Nil Progress report on planning for Olympic Yes Olympics facilities m Dock\ands.

SALARIES - SMALL BUSINESS

Question No. 1487 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Small Business: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (il) salary package; (ill) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Small Business) - The answer is: With respect to the Department of Small Business and its agency three employees are paid more than the base rate of a Victorian member of Parliament. (i) (a) CEO 1; (b) SES 5; (c) SES 4. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

98 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

(ll) As provided for by the Victorian Public Service Board for various levels, plus a vehicle in accordance with Victorian government car policy, plus standard expense of office allowance. (ill) The positions are (a) Director-General, (b) Director, Special Projects (on secondment to DMID) and (c) General Manager, SBOC. (iv) (a) Overall management of the Department of Small Business; (b) Management of special projects on secondment to DMID; (c) Overall management of the SBOC.

SALARIES - CONSUMER AFFAIRS

Question No. 1489 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (iii) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer is: (i) Classifications The answer to part (i) includes substantive public servants and statutory appointees who are subject to the Public Service Act who are paid a base salary rate greater than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament. It does not include public servants who are currently acting on higher duties. 2 - SES Level 3 1 - Chief Administrator (ii) Salary package Performance pay is not provided for reasons of personal confidentiality. SES Level 3 Salary $66 978. Expense of office allowance $3284 plus car (subject to payment of $24.38 per fortnight from net salary) Chief Administrator Salary $93 265. Expense of office $5619 plus car (ill) Positions Assistant Director, Development; Assistant Director, Legislation and Regulation; Director of Consumer Affairs (iv) Responsibilities Assistant Director, Development: Manage the Ministry's planning, research and program review functions; provide authoritative advice to the Minister, Director and other assistant directors; develop and manage the community funding, industry liaison and public information programs; provide policy and research support to the Prices Commissioner and government; contribute to the formulation and achievement of corporate objectives, priorities, strategies; develop policies, practices and programs for the division. Assistant Director, Legislation and Regulation: Manage and be responsible for the functions and activities of the Legislation and Regulation Division; ensure that the Ministry's legislative program is developed in a cohesive and strategic manner; ensure legal advice provided to the Minister, director and other assistant directors is timely and authoritative; ensure compliance with established standards through a program of enforcement; minimise the risks to the public from trading in hazardous products; contribute to the formulation and achievement of corporate objectives, priorities and strategies; develop policies, practices and programs for the division. Director of Consumer Affairs: The director is directly responsible to the Minister for the management of the operations of the Ministry. The Ministry is involved in the ongoing development and operation of an effective legislative framework; development of major targeted education and promotion programs; development of effective consumer policies; and the operation of conciliation and adjudication systems for complaints. The Ministry is also actively involved in monitoring and reviewing consumer/trader activities in all industries including finance, motor car trader, travel agent, building and residential tenancy. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 99

SALARIES -CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1499 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (ill) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. M. A. LYSTER (Minister for Health) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is: Seven officers are employed as follows: (a) (i) Senior Executive Service Level 4: 1 officer (ii) Senior Executive Service Level 2: 6 officers (b) (i) The annual salary package payable comprises of: - salary $71 801 - expense of office allowance $3284 - a performance premium in the range of $0 to $13 369 is payable but not provided in this instance for reasons of personal confidentiality - motor vehicle valued at $4980 (ii) The annual salary packages payable comprise of: - salary $62 499 - expense of office allowance $2109 - performance premium: 5 x $7299, 1 x $3649 - motor vehicle valued at $4980 (c)(d) The positions and responsibilities are: (i) Director of Prisons To manage the prison system in an effective and efficient manner to ensure the delivery of correctional programs is achieved in a way consistent with the maintenance of public safety and confidence; to optimise the use of capital and human resources; and to act as principal adviser to the director-general in all matters pertaining to the planning and operation of custodial services. (ii) Director, Community-Based Corrections To direct the Community-Based Corrections Division in the provision of non-custodial, community-based correctional services to adult offenders; to promote these services as sentencing options; to ensure the effective delivery of community correctional programs in a manner consistent with the maintenance of public safety and confidence; and to act as principal adviser to the director-general in relation to all matters pertaining to the planning and operation of community corrections. Director, Management Services To direct the Management Services Division, incorporating staff training and development, finance and accounting, personnel administration, information systems and freedom of information; to develop, implement and maintain systems, standards and procedures pertaining to these functions; and to provide expert advice and assistance to the director-general on the effective and efficient use of financial, physical and human resources. Director, Operational Review and Inspections To conduct management reviews and institutional inspections in the Office of Corrections; to review major incidents and examine specific issues of concern to the director-general; to provide findings and advice to the director-general on system changes; and to initiate change processes. Executive Director To provide executive support to the director-general and executive; to provide policy advice to the director-general and Minister enabling effective planning of operations relating to government objectives and priorities; to provide liaison and policy direction on correctional issues involving inter-agency developments; and to manage the work of the legal unit. Assistant Director of Prisons (Operations and Emergency Services) To undertake executive oversight and liaison, prison management development, resource co-ordination and allocation, and development projects for Victoria's maximum security prisons - Pentridge, Metropolitan Reception, Melbourne Remand Centre and Barwon and to manage security and emergency management services including drug surveillance and Dog Squad activities in all prisons. Assistant Director of Prisons (Strategic Services) To manage policy and program development and implementation across all prisons; to manage and review the progressive implementation of unit management within all prisons. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

100 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

The response in respect of the Victorian Prison Industries Commission is: No public servant is paid more than the base salary rate for Victorian members of Parliament.

SALARIES - POLICE AND EMERGENCY SERVICES

Question No. 1500 Hon. B. A. Eo SKEGGS asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (iii) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. M. A. LYSTER (Minister for Health) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Police and Emergency Services is: Classification Salary Package Position/Responsibilities

Ministry for Police and Emergency Services

Statutory $101 226 pa plus $5619 expense Secretary Appointee (1 pas) of office allowance + car Chief Executive Officer of the Ministry for Police and Emergency Services

SES 3 (4 pas) $66 978 pa plus $3284 expense of Director, Project Implementation Division of office allowance + car • Responsible for proViding policy advice and for the review, development, implementation and evaluation of programs within the operational/ administrative and financial areas in Victoria Police, including issues relating to industrial relations, personnel and budget.

Director, Strategic Planning and Programs Division Responsible for the implementation and development of integrated anti-crime strategies including areas of road safety and law enforcement and crime prevention issues. Manage and coordinate the planning and development of crime prevention programs and the administration of grants as part of the Public Safety and Anti-Crime Council.

Director, Policy and Resource Management Division Responsible for adviSing the Minister in areas of criminal justice, ,lationai police affairs, drugs and other law enforcement issues; analysing crime statistics; and administering the Fol Act. Also responsible for developing and managing infonnation systems, EDP services and records, human resources and implementation of equal employment opportunity policies and practices, financial accounting systems and coordinating budget estimates and works programs and proViding general administrative, keyboard and building and equipment services.

Director, Fire and Emergency Services Division Responsible for providing policy advice, and implementing programs, in respect of Victoria's emergency management arrangements, and issues relating to the effectiveness and efficiencies of the CFA, MFBB and VICSES.

SES2 (2pos) $62 499 pa plus $3284 expense Assistant Director, StrategiC Planning and Programs Division of office allowance + car • To develop and implement a range of crime prevention programs on a Statewide basis including, major public safety initiatives, the promotion of the technology in respect of traffic camera operations and other general issues relating to road safety. Assistant Director, Road Safety To oversee and promote road safety policies, programs and strategies. To promote the development of a national crime prevention strategy. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 101

Victoria Police

SES4 (1 pos) $71 801 pa plus $4107 expense Director, Integrated Workforce Project of office allowance + car • Responsible for the effective implementation of an integrated workforce of sworn and unsworn personnel within Victoria Police.

SES3 (2 pos) $66 978 pa plus $3284 expense Director, Financial Services Division of office allowance + car • Responsible for the efficient management of finances within Victoria Police.

Director, Corporate Services Responsible for the administration and management of corporate services within Victoria Police.

M0-5 (1 pos) $107 445 pa (includes base salary, Senior Forensic Physician out of hours allowance and 10% Responsible for the Office of Forensic Medicine commuted on-call allowance)

M0-4 (4 pos) $98 807 pa (includes base salary, Forensic Physicians out of hours allowance and 10% Responsible for provision of forensic medical services commuted on-call allowance)

Victoria State Emergency Service

Statutory $71 768 pa plus $4107 expense Director Appointee (1 pos) of office allowance + car Responsibilities detailed in section 9 of the Victoria State Emergency Service Act 1987

Country Fire Authority

Statutory $109 185 pa plus $5619 expense Chairman Appointee (1 pos) of office allowance + car Chief executive officer of the authority and chairman of the authority board Statutory $71 801 pa plus $4159 expense Deputy Chairman Appointee (1 pos) of office allowance + car Deputy to the chairman with specific responsibilities in the human resources and volunteer support areas, corporate communications. SES 3 (1 pos) $66 978 pa plus $3284 expense Director, Corporate Services of office allowance + car • Senior Executive in charge of financial and corporate administration of authority, including general management of authority's commercial activities

Metropolitan Fire Brigades Board

SES 2 (1 pos) $67073 + $3284 expense Director, Finance and Administration of office allowance • Responsible for the executive management control and coordination of the division, providing financial, accounting, information systems, administrative support services, building services maintenance and property management services to the board.

Senior Officer $68135 Corporate Secretary Level 2 Provides full secretariat support to the board, advice relating to all legal, statutory and corporate requirements of the board, and oversees the provision of the freedom of information services by the board.

Note: • Performance pay against the salary package is not provided for reasons of personal confidentiality.

SALARIES -TREASURY

Question No. 1501 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Treasurer: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (ill) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

102 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Treasurer is: The classification levels of public servants whose base salary levels exceeds that of members of Parliament ($65 877) are listed below. The response includes the Department of Treasury and it's agencies and was provided as at 24 March 1992: POSmON LEVEL NUMBER(S) Chief Executive Level 4 1 Managing Director 1 Deputy Managing Director 1 SES6 3 SES5 4 SES4 11 SES 3 (or equivalent) 16 Specific information concerning remuneration packages and position details of officers is considered confidential and that disclosure would breach the personal privacy of the officers concerned.

SALARIES - SCHOOL EDUCATION

Question No. 1505 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for School Education: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (iii) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for School Education is: PUBUC SERVANTS WHOSE BASE SALARY RATE IS MORE THAN $65 885 (p.a.)

CLASSIFICATION NO: SALARY(S) POSmON /RESPONSIBILITIES

CA7 109185 Chief General Manager CEl 90990 Chairperson, Ministerial Teacher Education Reference Group CA4 80475 Chainnan, State Board/ Asst Chief G.M. School Programs CA4 80475 Chairperson, VCAB SES6 1 83 512 Deputy Chief General Manager SES5 3 76978 General Manager (Metro. Regions) SES4 5 71801 General Manager (Country Regions) SES9 1 71753 Director, Audit &: Review SES3 1 66978 General Manager, VCAH SES3 6 66978 Assistant G.M. (Regions) SES3 1 66978 Director, Human Resources SES3 66978 Director, Resource Coordination SES3 66978 Director, Infonnation Technology SES3 66978 Director, Industrial Relations SES3 1 66978 Director, School Improvement SES3 1 66978 Director, Curriculum Provision TOTAL 27 In addition to base salary the salary package afforded to individual officers in Senior Executive Service positions includes expense of office allowance as detailed in Public Service Board Determination 22.3 and an annual performance premium payment between 0 - 15 per cent based on the total employment cost of the SES position. The total employment cost is comprised of the base salary rate, the employer cost of a private motor vehicle where provided, employer contributions superannuation and the expense of office allowance. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 103

SALARIES - ARTS

Question No. 1512 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for the Arts: How many public servants within departments or agencies within the Minister's administration are paid more than the base rate of Victorian members of Parliament indicating - (i) the classifications; (ii) salary package; (ill) positions; and (iv) responsibilities. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for the Arts is: The Ministry for the Arts has advised that there are seven positions within the Ministry and its associated agencies which fall within the scope of the honourable member's question. In respect of the particular parts of the question, the answers are: - (a) Classifications: CE-2 (1 position), CE-1 (1 position), SES-5 (2 positions), SES-4 (1 position) and SE5-3 (2 positions). (b) Salary packages: CE-2 -$101226 plus $5619 expense of office allowance CE-1- $93265 plus $5619 expense of office allowance SES-5 - $76968 plus $4107 expense of office allowance SES-4 - $71 801 plus $4107 expense of office allowance SES-3 - $66 978 plus $3284 expense of office allowance In addition to these salaries, a number of officers are also eligible for a performance pay allowance as prescribed under the Public Service Determinations for the Senior Executive Service and have use of a government car under the Senior Executive Car Scheme. (c) and (d) - Positions and their responsibilities: Director, Ministry for the Arts - Chief Administrator of the Ministry. Deputy Director Resources, Ministry for the Arts - Head of the Ministry's corporate operations division. Director, National Gallery of Victoria - Chief Executive of the National Gallery of Victoria. Director, Museum of Victoria - Chief Executive of the Museum of Victoria. General Manager, Victorian Arts Centre - Chief Executive of the Victorian Arts Centre. Director, State Library of Victoria - Chief Executive of the State Library of Victoria. Director, Archival Heritage - Director of the Archival Heritage Program and the Office of Library Services, Keeper of Public Records (Note - The above positions are not listed in any order of seniority or salary level)

GEELONG STAFF -SMALL BUSINESS

Question No. 1516 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Small Business: Does any department or agency under the Minister's administration intend to dispose of staff in the Geelong region; if so - (i) how many; (ii) in what areas; (ill) over what period, and for what reasons; (iv) what categories of staff are involved and how many in each category are to be dismissed; (v) what redundancy package is being offered; and (vi) how will superannuation entitlements be affected. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Small Business) - The answer is: The department and its agency does not intend to dispose of any staff in the Geelong region.

GEELONG STAFF -FINANCE

Question No. 1525 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Finance: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

104 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Does any department or agency under the Minister's administration intend to dispose of staff in the Geelong region; if so - (i) how many; (ii) in what areas; (ill) over what period, and for what reasons; (iv) what categories of staff are involved and how many in each category are to be dismissed; (v) what redundancy package is being offered; and (vi) how will superannuation entitlements be affected. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Finance is: The Ministry of Finance has no current plans which will result in a reduction of staff in the Geelong region.

GEELONG STAFF - CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1528 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: Does any department or agency under the Minister's administration intend to dispose of staff in the Geelong region; if so - (i) how many; (ii) in what areas; (ill) over what period, and for what reasons; (iv) what categories of staff are involved and how many in each category are to be dismissed; (v) what redundancy package is being offered; and (vi) how will superannuation entitlements be affected. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is as follows: In respect of the Office of Corrections it is anticipated an overall reduction in staff numbers will occur at Barwon Prison, Lara as a result of the implementation of a structural efficiency principle proposal. (i) Approximately 15 officers (ii) Broadly across the prison functions (ill) During the period July 1992 to June 1993 (iv)(v)(vi) Staff reductions are required as part of the process of implementing a structural efficiency principle proposal at the prison. Staff reductions will be achieved by way of attrition or transfer of staff. No staff will be dismissed, nor offered redundancy packages and superannuation entitlements will remain unaffected. In respect of the Victorian Prison Industries Commission, no staff reductions are envisaged in the Geelong region.

GEELONG STAFF - SCHOOL EDUCATION

Question No. 1534 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for School Education: Does any department or agency under the Minister's administration intend to dispose of staff in the Geelong region; if so - (i) how many; (ii) in what areas; (ill) over what period, and for what reasons; (iv) what categories of staff are involved and how many in each category are to be dismissed; (v) what redundancy package is being offered; and (vi) how will superannuation entitlements be affected. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for School Education is: There is no program to specifically reduce staff in the Geelong (Barwon South Western) Region of the Department of School Education. Any prospective reductions, which would minimal within the DSE, are likely to be the result of individual officers in the region taking up offers of a proposed voluntary enhanced resignation package for officers who have been on the Workforce Management Unit Redeployment list (greater than six months). As there are no officers in the Barwon South Western Region on this list there are currently no plans to reduce staff in the Geelong region other than through normal attrition (resignation, retirement, etc.) These officers would take their normal settlements under the Superannuation Act for a resignation, which includes payment of their contributions plus interest, along with a deferred pension at 55 years of age. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 105

GEELONG STAFF - ARTS

Question No. 1541 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for the Arts: Does any department or agency under the Minister's administration intend to dispose of staff in the Geelong region; if so - (i) how many; (il) in what areas; (ill) over what period, and for what reasons; (iv) what categories of staff are involved and how many in each category are to be dismissed; (v) what redundancy package is being offered; and (vi) how will superannuation entitlements be affected. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for the Arts is: The only agency within the Arts portfolio which employs staff in the Geelong region is the Geelong Performing Arts Centre Trust. The trust advises that it has no plans for reducing its present staff numbers.

TRADE UNION GRANTS - SMALL BUSINESS

Question No. 1545 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Small Business: What are the details of all grants made since the last election to trade union groups by the department and agencies for which the Minister has responsibility. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Small Business) - The answer is: Neither the Department of Small Business nor its agency, the Small Business Development Corporation, have made grants to trade union groups.

TRADE UNION GRANTS - FINANCE

Question No. 1554 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Finance: What are the details of all grants made since the last election to trade union groups by the department and agencies for which the Minister has responsibility. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Finance is: Records held by my Ministry indicate that no grants were made to trade unions since 1 October 1988 either by the Ministry of Finance or the former Department of Property and Services. .

TRADE UNION GRANTS - CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1557 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: What are the details of all grants made since the last election to trade union groups by the department and agencies for which the Minister has responsibility. Hon. M. A. LYSTER (Minister for Health) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is: In respect of both the Office of Corrections and the Victorian Prison Industries Commission: No grants have been made to trade union groups. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

106 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

TRADE UNION GRANTS -ARTS

Question No. 1570 Hon. B. A. E. SKEGGS asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for the Arts: What are the details of all grants made since the last election to trade union groups by the department and agencies for which the Minister has responsibility. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for the Arts is: The Ministry for the Arts has made a number of grants for arts related projects undertaken by various trades unions and the Victorian Trades Hall Council. These are reported each year in the Ministry's annual reports which are tabled in this House.

OVERSEAS TRIPS -ARTS

Question No. 1579 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for the Arts: Further to the answer to question No. 701 given in this House on 13 March 1991: (a) What overseas trips did the Minister make in 1990-91 and in this year to date. (b) In relation to each trip - (i) what was the purpose; (ii) what countries were visited; (iii) what was the time away from Victoria; and (iv) what total amount was paid, including allowances. (c) Was the Minister's spouse included in any trip. (d) What staff were taken on each trip and what was the cost of their travel, including expenses. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for the Arts is:

The current MinistE'~ in his capacity as Minister for the Arts, has not undertaken any overseas trips at the expense of the Victorian GoveIHment.

SEWERAGE FACILITIES

Question No. 1609 Hon. M. A. BIRRELL asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Water Resources: (a) What was the nun-. ler of unsewered properties in areas administered by the Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works and its successor, Melbourne Water in 1990-91 and in 1991-92 to date. (b) How many - (i) new; and (ii) existing properties, respectively, were provided with sewerage facilities in 1990-91 and in 1991-92 to date. (c) How many properties in Melbourne Water's area will have sewerage facilities connected in 1992-93 and in 1993-94. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Water Resources is: (a) The total number of unsewered properties in the Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works area for the year 1990-91 was 14073. As of the end of June 1992, there were an estimated 33 400 unsewered properties in the area controlled by Melbourne Water. (b) During the financial year 1990-91, in the area administered by the Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works, sewerage services were made available to the following numbers of properties: (i) 14 444 properties within new subdivisions; and (ii) 1317 properties within subdivisions existing prior to the 1972-73 financial year. In the 1991-92 financial year, in the area administered by Melbourne Water, sewerage services were made available to the following number of properties: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 107

(i) 13 447 properties within new subdivisions; and (ii) 2985 properties within subdivisions existing prior to the 19n-73 financial year. (c) As a means of helping to improve the water quality in the Yarra River, Port Phillip Bay and Western Port bay, the Minister for Water Resources announced on 16 June 1992 a plan to complete Melbourne Water's existing backlog program. The accelerated program provides for the connection of some 6SOO unsewered properties per annum, which will eliminate unsewered properties within the next 5 years. This represents an increase of some 600 per cent over the previous program for the connection of unsewered properties.

STANDARD GAUGE RAIL LINE

Question No. 1611 Hon. ROBERT LAWSON asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: What arrangements will be entered into with the Commonwealth to pay for rolling stock, signalling equipment, and maintenance of the proposed standard gauge railway line between Melbourne and Adelaide. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The Shareholders Agreement signed by the Prime Minister and the Premiers of Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia sets out the conditions for the payment of assets transferred to the National Rail Corporation. The National Rail Corporation's Corporate Plan will define which assets including rolling stock, signalling equipment and infrastructure will be required. Payment for maintenance of the proposed standard gauge railway line between Melbourne and Adelaide is dependent on who assumes ownership of the infrastructure.

STANDARD GAUGE RAIL LINE

Question No. 1612 Hon. ROBERT LAWSON asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: In respect of the proposed standard gauge railway to be built by the Commonwealth between Melbourne and Adelaide: (a) Will the new line run on its own "right of way" such as new bridges, new alignments, new earthworks, and new stations. (b) Will the new line be built on the existing broad gauge reservation and replace the existing railway. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: (a) A final decision on the route of the standard gauge railway line between Melbourne and Adelaide is expected to be taken by the National Rail Corporation in June 1992. (b) The standard gauge line is likely to remain within existing rail reservations. The existing broad gauge track is expected to be converted to standard gauge along most of the proposed route.

IICONSERVE" - CONSERVATION AND ENVIRONMENT

Question No. 1613 Hon. ROBERT LAWSON asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: In respect of the proposed standard gauge railway to be built between Melbourne and Adelaide: (a) If the new railway line replaces the existing broad gauge line how will Victoria service the lines in Western Victoria which at present depend on the broad gauge line for their viability. (b) If the proposed standard gauge is separate from the broad gauge system how will Victoria manage the cost of the broad gauge system if it no longer carries through freight or passengers.

Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

108 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

(a) & (b) A final decision on the route of the standard gauge railway line between Melbourne and Adelaide is expected to be taken by the National Rail Corporation in June 1992. The existing broad gauge trade is expected to be converted to standard gauge along most of the proposed route. In Western Victoria, railway lines between Ararat and Portland, Yaapeet and Dimboola and Murtoa to Hopetoun lead directly off the main line. Alternatives under consideration to service these rail links include construction of a dual gauge traclc between Ararat and Dimboola or conversion of some of these lines to standard gauge.

FOUR-WHEEL MOTOR VEHICLE REGISTRATION LEVY

Question No. 1622 Hon. M. A. BIRRELL asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) What funds were collected until I Apri11992 as part of the four-wheel drive motor registration levy, and what funds have been collected subsequently. (b) What funds were allocated to consolidated revenue and why. (c) What funds have been allocated to agencies, organisations and individuals, respectively, from the funds collected under the levy, indicating for what purposes and on what dates. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) -The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: (a) The following funds were collected by VlC ROADS from the four-wheel drive motor registration levy - 1 January -31 March 1992 $465 010 1 Apri11992 -30 Apri11992 $190 220 (b) All funds have been paid into the Consolidated Fund. (c) This aspect of the question falls within the responsibility of the Minister for Conservation and Environment, who provided the relevant information to the honourable member in his reply to question on notice No. 1618.

ASSET REGISTER - ETHNIC, MUNICIPAL AND COMMUNITY AFFAIRS

Question No. 1629 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities.

Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer is: (a) The Ministry of Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs (MEMCA) was established in January 1991. It consists of the Office of Local Government (formerly the Department of Local Government); the Office of Ethnic Affairs (formerly merged within the Ethnic Affairs Commission); the Older Persons Planning Office (formerly part of the former Department of Local Government); the Office of Youth Affairs (constituted from units within the Department of Labour); the Office of Rural Affairs (formerly part of the former Department of Agriculture); and Information Victoria (formerly part of the Ministry of Finance) These offices had either their own assets register or their assets were incorporated in the assets register of their former departments. These registers have now been incorporated into one central register in this Ministry. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCn. 109

(b) Real Estate The Ministry does not own any real estate assets. Non- Real Estate The Ministry is presently updating all values of non-real estate assets recorded in the register. The assets are valued, and the registration threshold determined, according to the guidelines laid down in the Department of the Treasury's accounting policy. Statement No. 4 ''Recording and Reporting of non-Current Physical Assets." This information will be finalised in time for presentation in MEMCAs annual report 1991-1992. This should be available shortly.

ASSET REGISTER - GAMING

Question No. 1634 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Gaming: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Gaming is: The Office of Gaming has made substantial progress towards completing its Assets Register and expects that the register as at 30 June 1992 will be completed on or before 31 August 1992. Figures for non-real estate (assets) owned by the Office of Gaming at 1 January 1992 will be available on or before 31 August 1992. ASSET REGISTER - TOURISM

Question No. 1637 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Tourism: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Tourism is: (a) The Victorian Tourism Commission maintains an ongoing asset register that values its non-current assets at cost. The Alpine Resorts Commission maintains an ongoing asset register that values at cost non-current assets, but excludes the value of slopes and trails used by the Commission in providing siding facilities in each of the resorts under the ARC administration. (b) Full details of accumulative figures of the asset register will be contained in the 1991-92 annual reports of the Victorian Tourism Commission and the Alpine Resorts Commission.

ASSET REGISTER -ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS

Question No. 1639 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Munidpal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

110 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs is: The Department of Aboriginal Affairs has made significant progress with the compilation of an assets register. In keeping with Victorian government requirements, information on the department's assets will be provided in its forthcoming annual report for the 1991-92 fmancial year.

ASSET REGISTER - COMMUNITY SERVICES

Question No. 1641 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for Community Services: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Community Services is: In accordance with the Treasury (Asset Register) Regulations 1988 and the Annual Reporting (Administrative Units) Regulations 1988, a computerised asset information system has been purchased to record details of non-current physical assets involving land, buildings, plant and equipment, motor vehicles, office equipment, furniture and equipment, communications and computer equipment at all office and residential facilities under the administrative control of Community Services Victoria. There are approximately 25 ()()() assets recorded on the system. The system is not yet able to report on asset values. Land and building assets have been referred to the Valuer-General for valuation. A module for recording current cost and depreciation is being developed to enable details of written down current cost and accumulated depreciation to be included as a supplement to the department's annual report for 1992-93.

ASSET REGISTER - SCHOOL EDUCATION

Question No. 1642 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for School Education: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for School Education is: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 111

(a) Real Estate Assets The Department of School Education maintains detailed records of its property ownership and leases. A computer system has been set up so that each land parcel can be linked to the administrative entity (regional office, school support centre, school, etc.) which uses the land. The entry of this data on computer is to be completed in September 1992. Computer drawings which show the site, building and rooms at each school have been produced. Area data can be obtained from these drawings for analysis of land and building assets at each school. Non-Real Estate Assets The Department of School Education has developed an asset register for recording details of the following non-real estate assets for each of its administrative units and all schools: Individual assets costing more than $500, e.g. motor vehicles, photocopiers and woodworking lathes. All computer hardware and software. All communication equipment. Aggregated assets with a total cost of more than $500, e.g. sets of library books. About 85 per cent of the data has been collected and most of this data has been loaded onto regional computer systems (b) A progress report as at 1 January 1992 is not available. As required under statutory regulations the department reports annually to Parliament on its asset holdings. Details of the accumulated asset holdings are contained in the 1990-91 annual report. This information will be updated for the 1991-92 annual report and at the same time information will be available on those agencies, including schools, which have made little or no progress.

ASSET REGISTER - EMPLOYME~TI POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION AND TKAINING

Question No. 1643 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training is: This answer is in respect of the following agencies: Office of the Adult Community and Further Education Board, which incorporates information from the Adult Migrant Education Services and the Council of Adult Education; the Department of Employment and Training, which incorporates information from the Office of Employment and the Office of the State Training Board; and the Office of Higher Education

ADULT, COMMUNITY AND FURTHER EDUCA nON BOARD During 1991-92 the Adult, Community and Further Education Board commenced a process designed to update and integrate the asset registers of its predecessor, the Division of Further Education. It is expected that this process, including computerisation of the asset register, will be completed in time for the 1991-92 annual report. Until the board's asset register is updated it will not be possible to provide an accumulated total of non-real estate assets. The board does not hold title to any real estate. Council of Adult Education The CAE maintains an asset register and uses information from that system in preparing its annual report. The written down value of Non-Current Assets was: Land, Buildings and Leasehold Improvements $ 315001 Other Fixed Assets $3022332 DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT AND TRAINING The Department of Employment and Training does not hold any real estate assets. It maintains a register of non-real estate assets. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

112 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

The value of those assets is $3 240 056.

OFFICE OF HIGHER EDUCA nON The Office of Higher Education (OHE) was established in October 1991 and at this stage has no assets in that it operates from the same premises and with the same equipment as VPSEC. The Victorian Post-Secondary Education Commission (vpsEC) has operated an assets register for many years. The value of those assets is $392 092. OHE does not hold any real estate assets.

ASSET REGISTER - FOOD AND AGRICULTURE

Question No. 1644 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Food and Agriculture: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register"; (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Food and Agriculture is: The Department of Food and Agriculture has met the requirement for public sector agencies to report on their assets in the relevant annual report. Extracts from the Department of Food and Agriculture's report relevant to the honourable member's question appear below: Classification valuations Land $62 837 500 • Buildings $57041 500 • Motor vehicles $ 8 200 ()()() Vehicles (other) $ 118533 Plant, machinery &t operating equipment $19559644 Furniture and fittings $ 684 379 Office equipment $ 1 979 644 Communications equipment $ 875 567 Computer hardware $ 8557053 Computer software $ 991 934 Scientific equipment $ 2 915 442 • A valuation for reporting purposes of all DoA controlled land and buildings was compiled by the Valuer-General during 1989-90. The above information, which applies to the Department of Food and Agriculture, does not take asset depreciation into account. However, progress is being made on systems which take account of depreciation and such systems are expected to be in place for the 1991-92 annual report reporting period. Information on the assets of agencies for which I am responsible is also contained in their respective annual reports and I refer the honourable member to those reports. If further information is required, I would be happy to consider specific requests by the honourable member.

ASSET REGISTER - WATER RESOURCES

Question No. 1646 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Water Resources: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 113

(a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Water Resources is: Department of Water Resources (a) The department has a complete assets register for all assets owned by the department. (b) The department has no real estate assets. The written down current cost of non-real estate assets at 1 January 1992 was $1.5 million. This is an estimate only as this department was then an office of the Department of Conservation and Environment and was therefore included under their assets register. Melbourne Water Corporation (a) Melbourne Water has maintained detailed asset records for more than ten years. Currently Melbourne Water has a computerised fixed assets register for the management, control and accounting for all of its assets. (b) As at 1 January 1992 the written down current cost of Melbourne Water's real estate and non-real estate assets excluding capital works in progress were: Land and buildings $254.9 million Non-real estate assets $ 3.843 billion Rural Water Corporation (formerly Rural Water Commission) (a) The Rural Water Corporation has had a detailed assets register since 1984. (b) As at 1 July 1991· the written down current cost of the corporation's assets were: Land and buildings $184.7 million Non-real estate assets $ 2.636 billion • To date the register is only updated in detail at the close of each financial year prior to completion of the corporation's annual report. With regard to water authorities within my administration, the time and resources required to provide the requested information cannot be justified.

ASSET REGISTER - CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1648 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. M. A. LYSTER (Minister for Health) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is: 1. In August 1991 the Department of the Treasury forwarded to departments Accounting Policy Statement No. 4 on ''Recording and Reporting of Non-Current Physical Assets." This requires administrative units to disclose information on assets in the 1991-92 annual reports. APS4 indicates that agencies are not required to disclose information on land and buildings until the year in which all valuations for land and buildings become available. Valuations have not as yet commenced within the office, however land and buildings are required to be valued by the Valuer-General before 30 June 1996. The Office of Corrections has made substantial progress in asset recording and has upgraded the computerised asset management system as a result of a review of the system over the last 12 months. The office is currently in the process of decentralising asset recording to each of its locations. 2. No valuations for real estate have been made as at 30 June 1991. Estimates on the value of non-real estate assets, as at 30 June 1991, were disclosed in the Office of Corrections, Annual Report 1990-91 as follows: Motor Vehicles Estimated total value of motor vehicles is $2.5 million. Plant and machinery and operating equipment Estimated total value of these assets is $4.4 million. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

114 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Furniture and fittings Estimated total value of furniture and fittings is $1.9 million. Office equipment Estimated total value of office equipment is $1.1 million. Computer and communications systems and equipment Estimated total value of these assets is $3.9 million. Other operating assets There are a number of operating assets under the control of the Office of Corrections which cannot be included in the above-mentioned categories. These consist of sports and recreational equipment, medical equipment, power tools and miscellaneous items. Estimated total value of these assets is $3.3 million.

ASSET REGISTER - SPORT AND RECREATION

Question No. 1652 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Sport and Recreation: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register": (a) What progress has been made by the Ministry or department and each of the agencies for which the Minister is responsible towards such a register, describing both real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) What are the accumulated figures for both real estate and non-real estate owned by each of the Ministry or department and its agencies as at 1 January 1992, listing those agencies which have made little or no progress in their activities. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Sport and Recreation is: The following information is supplied with regard to asset registers held by the department and its agencies. Department of Sport and Recreation (a) The department has had an assets register for all its non-real estate assets since 1989. The only involvement with real estate is through the management of five State recreation camps. This land is not owned by the department but it manages the CTown land reserves on which the camps are located including one at Howmans Gap which is leased from the State Electricity Commission. (b) The values of real estate (buildings and land associated with the camps) valued by the Valuer-General as at 1 July 1990 are as follows: Buildings $3.81m Land $3.16m Total Real Estate $6.97m Non-Real Estate Assets as at 1 January 1992 based on historical costs are as follows: Computers SO.71m Furniture SO.62m Kitchen SO.28m Motor vehicles SO.5Om Others SO.I2m Plant and machinery SO.38m Office equipment SO.16m Sporting equipment SO.26m Tools SO.03m Sub Total $3.06m Less assets acquired 1.1.92-3.6.92 SO.03m Total Non-Real Estate $3.03m

Greyhound Racing Control Board (a) The board retains an on-going asset register of all assets over $200 in value and has separate registers for Office furniture, equipment, computers and vehicles. The board doesn't own any real estate. (b) Accumulated figures for non-real estate assets as at 1 January 1992 are $769 656.

Harness Racing Board (a) The board has an assets register. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 115

(b) The gross values of real estate and non-real estate assets are: Real Estate $5.46m Non-Real Estate $2.03m

Totalizator Agency Board (TAB) (a) The TAB has a fully computerised fixed asset register which is an integral part of the computerised financial management systems of the organisation. The fixed assets register provides both financial control (asset values and depreciation) and physical control (asset description and location) of all real estate and non-real estate assets. (b) A summary schedule of the costs of real estate and non-real estate assets in the asset register as at 1 January 1992 follows: REAL EST A TE ASSETS Freehold land and buildings $4O.80m Premises improvements $23.33m Total $64.13m NON-REAL EST A TE ASSETS EDPSystems $75.02m Computer systems $3.74m Motor vehicles $1.5Om Plant and machinery $16.04m Total $96.3Om TOTAL NET ASSETS $160.43m

National Tennis Centre Trust

A detailed asset register is kept and audited in support of the following: 1992 1991 1990 $'000 $'000 $'000 Land at Valuation (@3.6 .89 by Valuer-General) 38000 38000 38000

Buildings at cost 85284 85243 85017 Less Provision for Depreciation 6514 4979 3495 78770 80264 81522

Fixtures & Fittings at cost 11838 11838 11838 Less Provision for Depreciation 3553 2764 1974 8285 9074 9864

Plant & Equipment at cost 1392 1289 1238 Less Provision for Depreciation 964 702 452 428 587 786 Furniture at cost 830 805 757 Less Provision for Depreciation 614 451 294 216 354 463

Office Machines at cost 238 207 75 Less Provision for Depreciation 84 44 24 154 163 51 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

116 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Motor Vehicles at cost 40 128 144 Less Provision for Depreciation 17 37 26 23 91 118

Total Assets 137622 137510 137069 Less Provision for Depreciation 11746 8977 6265 125 876 128 533 130804

ASSET REGISTER - CHILD-CARE

Question No. 1654 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister responsible for Child Care: With regard to the formulation of an "assets register":

MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENTS - HIGINBOTHAM PROVINCE

Question No. 1656 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) How many motor vehicle accidents have been reported to the police in each of the years 1990 and 1991, and in 1992 to date in the municipalities of Moorabbin, Brighton, Caulfield, Sandringham and Mordialloc. (b) At what location did each accident occur. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: (a) The following information on motor vehicle accidents (at 3 June 1992) in the municipalities of Moorabbin, Brigh_ Caulfield, Sandringham and Mordialloc has been provided by VIC ROADS from its Traffic Accident System database - NUMBER OF ACCIDENTS BY SEVERITY OF INJURY

YEAR NON INJURY OTHER SERIOUS FATAL ONLY INJURY INJURY ACCIDENTS 1990 1525 783 309 22 1991 • 672 260 17 1992 • 46 23 6 1501 592 45 • VIC ROADS does not maintain a record of non-injury crashes reported to police for 1991 onwards. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 117

VIC ROADS has also pointed out that a delay of 2 to 6 weeks may elapse from the time an accident is reported to police and subsequent details are received by VlC ROADS. (b) It is not practicable to provide the information showing the location of each accident with this answer. However computer lists will be provided to the honourable member indicating those details.

BOATING LICENCE FEES

Question No. 1657 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) How much money was raised from boating licence fees in each of the year 1989-90 and 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date. (b) How many boats were registered in each of those years. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: (a) An annual boating facilities and safety education fee is paid by owners of powered recreational vessels as a prerequisite to registration. The fees collected under the Marine Act 1988 are: 1989-90 $2594732 1990-91 $3 041 716 1991-92 $4 164 961 [at 31 May 1992] (b) The number of registered recreational vessels in Victoria was as follows: 1989-90 [at 30 June] 122 911 1990-91 [at 30 June] 124479 1991-92 [at 31 May] 123 754

BOATING FACILITIES

Question No. 1658 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: How much money was spent on boating or boating facilities in 1990-91 and in 1991-92 to date, delineating the program and the money expended in (i) Port Phillip BaYi and (ii) the rest of the State. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The following information is provided on expenditure within the Transport portfolio for boating: 1990-91 1991-92 Boating facilities­ Port Phillip Bay· $2243581 $1553001 Rest of Victoria $533642 $552700 Search and rescue and enforcement+ $709000 $709000 Collection and administration costs $525 000 $575000 $1992000 $1992000 • includes funds allocated to Port Phillip and Corio bays. 1 includes allocations to the Port of Melbourne Authority, through the Marine Board, for signage works ($39 008 in 1990-91 and $15104 in 1991-92). + paid to Ministry for Police and Emergency Services as contribution to Water Police. In addition, the following funds were also spent on boating activities: 1990-91 1991-92 Water safety grants to search &: rescue groups­ Port Phillip Bay $ 8295 $ 9748 Rest of Victoria $ 41705 $ 40252 Safety promotion (Statewide) $300000 $250000 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

118 COUNCIL Wednesday. 12 August 1992

$350000 $300000 Other government agencies, such as the Rural Water Commission, the Victoria Police, the Department of Conservation and Environment and the port authorities also expend funds on recreational boating facilities and activities. However as these agencies are outside the transport portfolio, no figures are available to the Ministry of Transport.

TRAFFIC BLACK SPOTS

Question No. 1659 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) What are the locations of ''Black Spots" within the metropolitan area. (b) Which "Black Spots" have received funding in 1990-91 and in 1991-92 to date. (c) Which ''Black Spots" will receive funding in 1992-93. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: It is not practicable to provide the information relating to the location of accident ''Black Spots" or program funding with this answer. However computer lists provided by VIC ROADS will be supplied to the honourable member, indicating the location of ''Black Spots" within the metropolitan area and the State and Federal funded ''Black Spot" programs for 1990-91 and 1991-92. The ''Black Spot" program for 1992-93 is currently under consideration.

CENTRAL AREA TRANSPORT STRATEGY

Question No. 1667 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: Further to the answer to question No. 1090 given in this House on 10 September 1991: (a) Who are the members of the Implementation and Review Committee delineating the criteria of their appointment (b) What is the cost of the review. (c) What are the salary, fees or allowances of each member of the committee. (d) What money has been spent on consultants, indicating their names. (e) What is the updated allocation for the closure of Swanston Street and the allocation for traffic mitigation works. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The Central Area Transport Strategy (CATS) was released by the government in March 1991. The strategy was prepared through a period of consultation and debate with many individuals and organisations over a three-year period. Implementation of the priority components of CATS has commenced with the closure of Swanston Street on 28 March 1992 and the completion of the necessary traffic management works around the city to support the closure. The following information is provided in response to the specific matters raised by the honourable member: (a) The establishment of the CATS Implementation and Review Committee has been delayed pending implementation of the strategy's first major initiative, i.e. the establishment of the Swanston Street Wallc. A number of specific committees and reference groups were in operation in the lead up to the closure of Swanston Street and it was considered that the establishment of a further committee at that time may have been counter-productive. However, following the successful closure of Swanston Street, it is now proposed to formally establish the Implementation and Review Committee in the near future to address and monitor other CATS initiatives and strategies. Membership will be drawn from the groups previously mentioned in my answer to the honourable member's question No. 1090 and other relevant organisations. (b) As the Implementation and Review Committee is not yet established, there has been no cost to date. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 119

(c) It is expected that the majority of representatives on the committee will participate as part of their existing job functions and not require the payment of extra salary, fees or allowances. However, should it be necessary to have on the committee a member or members who may be eligible for remuneration, an appropriate determination would be sought through the Remuneration Review Committee. (d) There has been no money spent on consultants in respect of the Implementation and Review Committee. (e) The State government's allocation to the Melbourne City Council for the construction of the Swanston Street Walk remains at $10m. An allocation of $4.lm was originally made for traffic mitigation works and approximately $4.lm has been spent by VlC ROADS to date.

SANDRINGHAM RAIL SERVICE

Question No. 1668 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: With regard to the Sandringham railway line for each of the periods 1 January 1990 to 1 January 1991, 1 January 1991 to 1 January 1992, and 1 January 1992 to date: (a) How many trains have run more than 5 minutes late. (b) What percentage of trains were late. (c) How many trains were cancelled. (d) What percentage of trains were cancelled. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The following table provides information regarding train running on the Sandringham line since 1 January 1990. The honourable member will note an overall trend of improvement in train availability on the Sandringham line. The Public Transport Corporation is committed to the provision of an efficient, safe and reliable public transport system and recognises the importance of service delivery to the travelling public. Having improved train availability, strategies are being implemented to again return to the reliable train running experienced by commuters earlier in the year.

SANDRINGHAM LINE (at Flinders Street Station) ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS MORNING PEAK EVENING PEAK ALL DAY LATE CANCELLED LATE CANCELLED LATE CANCELLED YEAR MONrn No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % 1990 January 24 10.3 9 3.7 19 8.8 19 8.1 77 5.6 33 2.3 February 49 20.0 18 6.8 35 15.0 27 10.3 103 7.5 46 3.2 March 38 13.3 10 3.4 33 13.3 26 95 139 9.2 55 35 April 24 11.2 11 4.9 12 6.3 19 9.1 62 4.5 2B 2.0 May 42 13.8 19 5.9 24 8.6 21 7.0 96 6.2 41 2.6 June 35 12.7 6 2.1 24 9.6 5 1.9 76 5.0 10 0.6 July 45 15.0 2.5 20 7.6 3 1.1 81 5.3 19 1.2 August 36 11.2 0.6 24 9.1 13 4.7 67 4.3 18 1.1 September 21 8.1 7 2.6 15 6.7 7 3.0 59 4.0 20 13 October 2B 8.8 5 1.5 23 8.6 9 3.2 n 4.6 15 0.9 November 26 9.0 5 1.7 22 8.9 6 2.3 n 4.7 12 0.7 December 17 6.9 3.5 16 7.7 13 5.9 37 2.5 19 1.2 1991 January 23 9.0 0.3 23 10.6 10 4.4 54 3.6 14 0.9 February 34 12.2 3 1.0 10 4.3 8 3.3 64 4.6 10 0.7 March 35 12.3 3 1.1 2B 12.6 5 2.2 97 6.3 9 0.6 April 28 10.6 0.7 11 4.9 1 0.4 56 3.7 0.3 May 30 9.8 0.9 24 9.2 3 1.1 71 4.7 7 05 June 22 8.7 0 0.0 18 85 4 1.8 52 3.7 5 0.4 July 27 8.5 7 2.1 17 6.2 3 1.1 55 3.6 11 0.1 August 31 10.1 2 0.6 23 9.0 10 3.8 71 4.6 21 1.3 September 25 9.4 0 0.0 17 75 0 0.0 55 3.9 12 0.8 October 26 8.1 1 0.4 19 6.9 2 0.7 54 3.4 3 0.2 November 27 9.7 0.4 16 6.8 0.8 60 4.0 2 0.1 December 28 10.3 1.4 17 7.6 12 5.1 64 4.3 13 0.9 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

120 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

1992 January 13 5.1 5 1.9 15 6.8 6 2.3 42 2.8 12 0.8 February 37 13.3 1.0 25 9.3 12 4.3 136 7.9 13 0.8 March 51 17.6 4 1.3 37 13.0 9 3.1 203 11.2 19 1.0 April 50 18.9 1 0.4 32 12.6 12 4.5 158 9.3 10 0.6 May 52 17.9 2 0.7 28 9.9 11 3.7 168 9.3. 16 0.9

FRANKSTON RAIL SERVICE

Question No. 1669 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: With regard to the Frankston railway line for each of the periods 1 January 1990 to 1 January 1991, 1 January 1991 to 1 January 1992, and 1 January 1992 to date: (a) How many trains have run more than 5 minutes late. (b) What percentage of trains were late. (c) How many trains were cancelled. (d) What percentage of trains were cancelled. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The following table provides information regarding train running on the Frankston line since 1 January 1990. The Public Transport Corporation is committed to the provision of an efficient, safe and reliable public transport system. The corporation recognises the importance of service delivery to the travelling public particularly in minimising train cancellations on the line. Having improved train availability, strategies are now being implemented to again return to the reliable train running enjoyed by commuters earlier in the year.

FRANKSTON UNE (at Flinden Street Station) ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS MORNING PEAK EVENING PEAK ALL DAY LATE CANCELLED LATE CANCELLED LATE CANCELLED YEAR MONTH No. % No. % No. % No. % No. 0/0 No %. 1990 January 73 19.5 33 8.1 53 16.8 n 18.6 203 12.4 91 5.3 February 103 24.1 53 11.1 63 19.1 130 28.2 260 15.1 119 6.5 March 134 29.3 32 6.5 77 18.3 49 10.5 359 18.7 89 U April 70 19.9 16 4.3 21 6.9 46 13.0 230 13.8 53 3.1 May 117 23.3 26 4.9 60 13.8 70 13.8 2n 13.8 71 3.5 June 105 23.2 8 1.7 39 9.4 26 5.9 243 12.9 29 1.5 July 112 22.7 13 2.5 45 9.7 18 3.7 245 12.5 34 1.7 August 121 23.1 6 1.1 52 10.6 16 3.1 245 12.1 17 0.8 September 61 lU 15 3.4 73 19.0 34 8.1 260 14.3 52 2.8 October 92 17.9 16 3.0 61 13.1 39 7.7 239 12.0 48 2.4 November 73 15.3 7 1.4 42 9.7 28 6.1 200 10.5 30 1.5 December 51 13.4 18 U 46 13.1 40 10.2 160 8.9 40 2.1 1991 January 52 13.3 7 1.7 53 15.2 28 7.4 169 9.4 23 1.2 February 88 19.5 9 2.0 74 18.3 36 8.2 203 11.4 28 1.5 March 104 24.1 5 1.1 56 14.3 26 6.2 245 12.6 20 }.O April 67 15.6 7 1.6 51 12.4 1.4 200 10.6 15 0.8 May 81 16.4 11 2.2 54 11.5 16 3.3 223 11.5 23 1.2 June 80 19.5 4 1.0 51 13.3 12 3.0 220 12.4 14 0.8 July n 13.1 5 1.0 43 8.7 14 2.8 181 9.0 12 0.6 August 81 16.1 3 0.6 52 10.9 5 1.0 229 11.4 6- 0.3 September 84 19.4 4 0.9 35 8.6 13 3.1 232 12.9 21 1.2 October 76 14.6 9 1.7 79 16.1 14 2.8 234 11.6 20 1.0 November 57 12.9 5 1.1 65 15.6 15 3.5 166 8.8 15 0.8 December 64 14.6 8 1.8 73 18.8 34 8.1 170 9.2 27 t.4 1992 January 37 9.4 9 2.2 55 14.8 23 5.8 146 8.1 22 1.2 February 125 27.7 9 2.0 96 22.3 30 6.5 302 16.5 36 1.9 March 131 27.6 8 1.7 65 14.0 20 4.1 311 16.0 24 1.2 April 112 25.9 4 0.9 100 23.9 19 U 301 16.3 13 07 May 127 26.5 3 0.6 71 15.5 25 5.2 331 17.0 20 1.0 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 121

MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENT FACILITIES

Question No. 1670 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: How many motor car fatalities occurred in 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date, including the location of each fatality. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer provided by the Minister for Transport is: Financial Year Fatalities 1990-91 489 1991-92 (To midnight, 2 June 1992) 429 It is not practicable to provide a list of the location of each fatality with this answer. However, a computer list prepared by VIC ROADS of road traffic fatalities in Victoria will be provided direct to the honourable member.

RACECOURSES LICENCES BOARD

Question No. 1671 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Sport and Recreation: (a) Who are the members of the board, delineating the criteria of their appoinbnent. (b) How many meetings were held during 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date. (c) What salaries, fees and allowances have been paid to each member of the board. (d) What is the budget of the board, delineating the surplus/deficit for 1990-91 and in 1991-92 to date. (e) What national and international trips have been made by members of the board, indicating the cost of each trip and the source of the funds. (f) What is the income and expenditure of the Racecourses Licences Board Fund. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Sport and Recreation is: (a) The Racecourses Licences Board is established by section 34 of the Racing Act 1958 and comprises of a Racing Division and a Harness Racing Division. The chairman of the board is Mr Tom Hogg, Director-General of Manufacturing and Industry Development and former Director-General of the Deparbnent of Sport and Recreation. Mr Hogg was appointed by the Governor in Council on the criteria that he is a person sufficiently experienced and skilled to chair a statutory agency of this nature. He has been chairman for three years and has also been a member of two other statutory boards and a government member on the boards of three companies. The criteria for the remaining membership of the board is stipulated by section 34. This membership is as follows: Appointee Criteria

Racing Division Mr David Bourke "Chairman of the Victoria Racing Club (or his nominee)" Mr Grant Downey "a person appointed by the Minister as representing in his opinion the interests of racing clubs having racecourses within the race meetings districts" Harness Racing Division MrTim Walsh "Chairman of the Harness Racing Board (or his nominee)" Mr Frank Ryan "a person appointed by the Minister as representing in his opinion the interests of harness clubs having racecourses within the race meetings districts" (b) No. of Meetings 1990-91 1991-92 (to 26 May 1992) Racing Division 17 16 Harness Racing Division 11 7 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

122 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

(c) Section 36(1) of the Racing Act 1958 empowers the Governor in Council to make regulations setting fees for the chairman and members of the board. The Racing (Racecourses Ucences Board)(Fees) Regulations 1984 prescribe the following fees at levels determined by the Remuneration Review Committee: Fee Chairman $11 126 per annum Members $153 per full day meeting $77 per half day meeting It should be noted that the chairman, Mr Hogg, is a public servant and therefore does not receive any prescribed fee. Actual fees paid to the board's members are as follows: 1990-91 30 June 1991-26 May 1992 Mr David Bourke $ 307 Mr Doug Reid (former member) $2344 $1197 Mc Grant Downey $2344 $1504 Mr Tim Walsh $1254 $ 604 Mr Frank Ryan $1254 $ 604 The board's members are also entitled to reimbursement of personal expenses incurred in the conduct of board business. These expenses are reimbursed at rates specified by the Public Service Determinations. (d) See answer to (f). (e) The members of the board have not undertaken any national or international trips in their official capacity as board members. (f) Section 126 of the Racing Act 1958 establishes the Racecourses Development Fund (RDF). The RDF is a trust fund kept by the Treasurer and its source of income is a range of bet type commissions derived from the operation of on-course and off-course totalizators. The board is empowered to authorise some payments from the RDF subject to the approval of the Minister for Sport and Recreation. Total RDF income and expenditure for the past five financial years was as follows: 1987~ 19~9 1989-90 1990-91 1991-92 Income 12 020 057 15518 490 15537 741 15 471 147 16451232 Expenditurel 6883652 14332144 18470653 16494721 17382810 Surplus/Deficit 504 656 1186 346 (2932912) (1023 574) (931578) These deficits in the past three years have been funded from unexpended funds from previous years, accumulated to pay for large capital work projects. Accumulated funds on hand as at 30 June, 1992 totalled $4297000.

BOATING FACILITIES FUND

Question No. 1672 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: With regard to the Boating Facilities Fund: (a) What was the detailed income and the detailed expenditure for 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date. (b) What grants were made to each municipality and government agency in each of those years. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Transport is: The boating facilities and safety education fees collected under the Marine Act 1988 are paid into the Consolidated Fund. The following Budget appropriations were received for expenditure under the Boating Facilities and Safety Grant Program: Contribution to Water Police for Boating Facility Search and Rescue Other Works and Enforcement $ $ $ 1990-91 758000 7090001 525000" QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 123

1991-92 708 000 709 0001 575 OOO§ 1 paid to Ministry for Police and Emergency Services paid to VIC ROADS as collecting agency § includes payment to VIC ROADS as collection agency and administration costs for boating safety activities and support cost. It should be noted that in addition to the above expenditure, funding allocations were also provided from the Special Projects Fund for boat safety, education and promotion activities and water safety grants to search and rescue groups - funds of $350 000 were allocated in 1990-91 and $300 000 in 1991-92. Details of grants made to municipalities and government agencies for boating facility works are shown in the following table:

GRANTS TO MUNICIPALmES AND AGENCIES BOATING FACILITY WORKS NAME DETAILS AMOUNT 1990-91 Alberton Shire McLaughins Beach, widen ramp $52000 Baimsdale Shire Paynesville, sewage pumpout $1827 Bellarine City Clifton Springs, safety haven $121350 Corio City A valon Beach, jetty / parking area $16000 Corio City Kirks Point, parking area $8000 D'nong Valley Auth. Patterson River, packing area $40000 Dept. Cons. & Env. Glenelg River, signage $11 000 Dept. Cons. & Env. Lakes Entrance, landing jetty $32000 Gordon Shire UtUe Lake 8oort, new ramp $27040 Hastings Shire Hastings, new jetty $51840 Heywood Shire Nelson, new ramp $31800 Marine Board Statewide signage $61202 Orbost Shire Bemm River, ramp lighting $7541 Rosedale Shire Loch Sport, jetty $80000 Rural Water Comm. Lake Lonsdale, new ramp $22400 Rural Water Comm. Lake Toolondo, new ramp $20000 S. Gippsland Shire Toora Beach, launching facility $85000 TamboShire Lakes Entrance, launching facility $77000 Warmambool Shire Jubilee Park, new jetty $12000 1991-92 Alberton Shire McLaughins Beach, widen ramp $9212 Baimsdale Shire Mitchell River, jetty and parking $51245 Baimsdale Shire King Street ramp improvement $7200 Baimsdale Shire Paynesville, Progress jetty $42000 Bellarine City Clifton Springs, safety haven $78400 CorioCity A valon Beach, jetty / parking area $9000 Dept. Cons. & Env. Brodribb River, upgrade ramp/jetty $15800 Dept. Cons. & Env. Lake RatzcasUe, toilets $12000 Dept. Cons. & Env. Cape Concan, seal on parking area $6100 Flinders Shire Tootgarook, ramp access $17600 Flinders Shire Safety Beach, ramp access $36000 Heywood Shire Glenelg Shire, extend landing $20800 Heywood Shire Glenelg River, upgrade ramp/access $14560 Karkarooc Shire . Lake Lascelles, deepen lake $20000 Kowree Shire Lake Chadegrark, extend ramp $2400 Marine Board Port of Melbourne Authority, signage $18879 Phillip Is. Shire Rhyll, ramp access $6000 Portland City Henty Beach, jetties $37600 Rochester Shire Torrumbarry, ramp access $6400 Rochester Shire Torrumbarry, ramp access $3840 Rochester Shire Wharparilla, ramp access $3840 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

124 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Rosedale Shire Seacombe, ramp access $13852 Rural Water Comm. Lake Lonsdale, toilets $36000 Rural Water Comm. Lake Nillahcootie, upgrade parking $13600 Rural Water Comm. Statewide signage and buoyage $35000 S. Gippsland Shire Toora Beach, launching facility $92000 TamboShire Lakes Entrance, launching facility $76200 Tullaroop Shire Lake Cairn Curran, extend ramp $2172 Warrnambool Shire Peterborough, replace ramp $12000 Wimmera Shire Pine Lake, lengthen ramp $8300

STATE WATER LABORATORY

Question No. 1673 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Water Resources: (a) Where is the State Water Laboratory located. (b) What are the functions of the Laboratory. (c) What is the Laboratory's budget in 1991--92 and its projected surplus/deficit. (d) What is the number of staff employed by the Laboratory, indicating the numbers employed in -(i) scientific; (ii) clerical; and (ill) support staff, categories. (e) Who are the senior scientists and what are their qualifications. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer is: (a) The State Water Laboratory of Victoria is located at 590 Orrong Road, Armadale, Victoria. (b) The functions of the laboratory are to provide analytical, research and consultancy services in the areas of water chemistry, water microbiology, aquatic biology, llmnology and geomechanics to government and semi-government agencies, the water industry and the general public. (c) The laboratory's budget in 1991-2 is $3.64 million and is projected to recover 92 per cent of total costs, including salary, consumables, superannuation, rental, building maintenance, power, telephone, equipment depreciation, EDP and administration on-costs. (d) The number of staff employed by the Laboratory is 60 full-time equivalent (FI'E) in the following categories: (i) Scientific - 29 FI'E (il) Clerical - 4.2 FI'E (ill) Technical support - 26.8 FI'E (e) Senior scientists are: Ken Fung - Chief Water Scientist, Manager State Water Laboratory (B.Sc.[Hons1, M.Ag.Sci., MBA) Anne McNeil- Principal Microbiologist, Section Leader Microbiology (B.Sc.) Ross Bannister - Principal Chemist, Section Leader Chemistry (B.Sc.) Garry Bennison - Principal Water Quality Scientist, Section Leader Aquatic Biology and Limnology (B.Sc.[Hons] M.A.I. Biology) Cos Battaglia - Executive Engineer, Geomechanics (Dip.C.E.)

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - CHILD-CARE

Question No. 1677 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister responsible for Child Care: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister responsible for Child Care is: The Office of Preschool and Child Care does not employ Ministerial staff. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday. 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 125

Ministerial staff engaged on activities for the Minister responsible for Child Care are provided through Community Services Victoria.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - GAMING

Question No. 1680 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Gaming: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Gaming is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff since it would breach personal confidentiality. No position has been allocated for gaming. Staff have advised on gaming in addition to their other responsibilities.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - CORRECTIONS

Question No. 1683 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Health, for the Minister for Corrections: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. M. A. LYSTER (Minister for Health) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Corrections is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff, however the designation of officers against which appointments have been made in respect of the corrections portfolio is as follows: 1. The Hon. P. Toner, Minister for Community Welfare Services 1982 to 1985 1 Adviser (2 occupants) 2. The Hon. J. Kennan, Attorney-General and Minister responsible for Corrections 1985-1987 1 Adviser (4 occupants) 3. The Hon. S. Crabb, Minister for Police and Emergency Services and Minister responsible for Corrections 1987-1990 1 Adviser (3 occupants), 1 Media Adviser (1 occupant) 4. The Hon. M. Sandon, Minister for Police and Emergency Services and Minister responsible for Corrections 1990- presenl 1 Adviser (3 occupants), 1 Media Adviser (2 occupants).

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - WATER RESOURCES

Question No. 1685 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Water Resources: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Water Resources is: It is not appropriate for the names of staff members to be given out as this is considered to be personal information. However, I refer the honourable member to my answer to question No. 1402 which was published in HtmSllTd; this reply will advise the titles of staff currently employed by my office. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

126 COUNCIL Wednesday. 12 August 1992

The time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation back to 1982 is beyond the resources of my department, however I refer the honourable member to the various government directories produced over the years which should provide the information required at the time of publication.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - FOOD AND AGRICULTURE

Question No. 1687 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Food and Agriculture: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appoinbnents made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Food and Agriculture is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff without their express permission. It is impractical to seek such permission from officers employed in the category specified by the honourable member's question for the time period also specified in the question. However, if the honourable member requires a list of Ministerial staff positions in addition to that provided in my answer to his question on notice No. 1401, I would be happy to consider any specific requests. Further, if the honourable member is seeking this information to make contact with my current staff, I refer him to the Victorian Government Directory which provides appropriate contact details.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - EMPLOYMENT,.t,.fOST-SECONDARY EDUCATION AND TRAINING

Question No. 1688 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appoinbnents made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training is: The answer is that it is not government practice to provide the names of staff. Recent Victorian government directories list some of these appointees. The time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation from 1982 to 1991 is beyond the resources of my department. I would be prepared, however to provide the honourable member with a list of the relevant positions.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - SCHOOL EDUCATION

Question No. 1689 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for School Education: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appoinbnents made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for School Education is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff, as this would breach the confidentiality of the staff involved. Recent Victorian government directories may list some of these appointees. The time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation from 1982 to 1987 is beyond the resources of my department. A list of recent appointments and position descriptions is as follows: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 127

1988 Ministerial Adviser Grade III Temporary Appointment Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Private Secretary

1989 Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade IT {Minister responsible for Ministerial Adviser Grade II {Post -Secondary Education Private Secretary Grade IT Private Secretary Grade II

1990 Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Private Secretary Grade III Private Secretary Grade IT Press Secretary Grade n

1991 Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Private Secretary Grade III Private Secretary Grade III Press Secretary Grade III

1992 Ministerial Adviser Grade III Ministerial Adviser Grade III Private Secretary Grade III

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - COMMUNITY SERVICES

Question No. 1690 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for Community Services: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or her predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Community Services is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff. I am prepared to provide the honourable member with a list of relevant poSitions back to 1988-89. However, the time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation back to 1982 is beyond the resources of my department. The positions listed were filled at some point during the financial year, not necessarily Simultaneously. Ministerial Staff 1988~9 Senior Executive Service Levell Ministerial Adviser Grade 3 Ministerial Adviser Grade 1 Administrative Officer Class ADM-6 Administrative Officer Class ADM-4 Private Secretary Grade 3 (3 people) Secretary Grade 3 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

128 COUNCIL VVednesday, 12 August 1992

Secretary Grade 1 (2 people)

1989-91 Senior Executive Service Levell Press Secretary Grade 2 Ministerial Adviser Grade 3 (4 people) Ministerial Adviser Grade 1 Administrative Officer Class ADM-7 (3 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-6 (2 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-S (3 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-4 (2 people) Clerical Officer Grade 5 (2 people) Clerical Officer Grade 4 (6 people) Private Secretary Grade 3 (4 people) Secretary Grade 3 (3 people) Secretary Grade 1 (5 people) Word Processing Operator Grade 1 (2 people) Ministerial Transport Officer Note: Data collection difficulties mean that this information is provided over two financial years.

1991-92 Ministerial Adviser Grade 3 (5 people) Press Secretary Grade 2 (2 people) Ministerial Liaison Officer (2 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-5 (2 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-3 (3 people) Administrative Officer Class ADM-I Clerical Officer Grade 5 Private Secretary Grade 3 Ministerial Transport Officer (4 people) Note: All positions listed were filled at some point during the financial year, not necessarily simultaneously.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS -TREASURY

Question No. 1693 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Treasurer: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Treasurer or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Treasurer is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff. I bring to the attention of the honourable member the fact that information pertaining to Ministerial advisers is published in various government directories. However, the names of advisers are limited to those who were in specific positions at the time of preparation of the directories. Further, the directories do not go back as far as 1982. A list of relevant positions may be provided if requested, however, the time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation pertaining to those pOSitions back to 1982 cannot be justified.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - TOURISM

Question No. 1694 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, for the Minister for Tourism: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 129

Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Tourism is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff. I would be prepared to provide the honourable member with a list of relevant positions. However, the time and resources required to manually search relevant documentation back to 1982 is beyond the resources of the Victorian Tourism Commission and the Alpine Resorts Commission.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - MANUFACTURING AND INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

Question No. 1697 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer is: The information required is not readily accessible from departmental records. In any event, details from individual personnel files cannot be disclosed without the consent of the officer concerned. The member may wish to research previous and current editions of the Victorian Government Directory for the information being sought.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - PORTS

Question No. 1698 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister responsible for Ports: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or his predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. D. R. WHITE (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development) - The answer is: The information required is not readily accessible from departmental records. In any event, details from individual personnel files cannot be disclosed without the consent of the officer concerned. The member may wish to research previous and current editions of the Victorian Government Directory for the information being sought.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - ETHNIC, MUNICIPAL AND COMMUNITY AFFAIRS

Question No. 1699 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or her predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer is: As advised in my response to the honourable member's earlier question on notice No. 1387, there are presently three Ministerial advisers in my office. These officers have been on my staff since the formation of the Ministry of Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs (MEMCA). It is not government practice to provide names of staff. MEMCA was established in January 1991. It consists of the Office of Local Government (formerly the Department of Local Government); the Office of Ethnic Affairs (formerly merged within the Ethnic Affairs Commission); the Older Persons Planning Office (formerly part of the former Department of Local Government); the Office of Youth Affairs (constituted from units within the Department of Labour); the Office of Rural Affairs (formerly part of the former Department of Agriculture); and Information Victoria. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

130 COUNCIL VVednesday. 12 August 1992

I would be prepared to provide the honourable member with a list of positions that may be relevant prior to the establishment of the Ministry of Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs. However, the time and resources required to seek out and manually search relevant documentation back to 1982 is beyond the resources of my Ministry.

MINISTERIAL ADVISERS - CONSERVATION AND ENVIRONMENT

Question No. 1700 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment: Since 1982 to date, what are the names of each of the successive Ministerial advisers and/or similar personal appointments made by the Minister or her predecessor in the Ministry or department, including where applicable the portfolio which the present Ministry replaced. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer is: It is not government practice to provide the names of staff. I am, however, able to provide the honourable member with a list of relevant positions: Ministry for Conservation 1982 Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser

Department of Conservation, Forests and Lands 1983 Ministerial Adviser Private Secretary 1985 Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Private Secretary 1988 Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Private Secretary

Department of Conservation and Environment 1991 Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Private Secretary AM-8 (five-month appointment) 1992 Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Ministerial Adviser Press Secretary Private Secretary Private Secretary (until June 1992)

BRAMBUK ABORIGINAL CENTRE

Question No. 1709 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs: (a) How many days was the Brambuk Aboriginal Centre open to the public in 1991. (b) How many tourists visited the centre in 1991. (c) What is the annual cost of salaries and maintenance of the centre. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs is: QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 131

Brambuk Living Cultural Centre was officially opened in December 1990, and became fully operational in late August 1991. (a) Since 1 September 1991, the centre has been closed on only two occasions, viz, Christmas Day and another day when the centre had no power because the SEC was undertaking cable work. (b) Between September and December 1991, approximately 12 024 visits were made to the centre. Between January and May 1992 centre visitation was 23 082. In the nine months between September 1991 and May 1992 visitation to the centre was in excess of 35 000. (c) In 1991-92 the annual cost of salaries and maintenance of the centre was $324 000.

LAND CLASSIFICATION REVIEW COMMITIEE

Question No. 1718 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Finance: What are the names of the members of the Land Classification Review Committee and the organizations they represent. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Finance is: The Land Classification Review Committee was disbanded on 18 June 1990 following the adoption by Cabinet of a revised consultation and assessment process for surplus lands. It is not government practice to provide names of departmental officers. However, when operating, the committee was comprised of officers from the following departments: Premier and Cabinet, Conservation and Environment, Planning, Treasury, Transport and the former Department of Property & Services.

HACC FUNDING IN HIGINBOTHAM PROVINCE

Question No. 1723 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, for the Minister for Community Services: What is the Home and Community Care funding to each agency in the cities of Mordialloc, Sandringham, Moorabbin, Caulfield and Brighton, respectively, delineating each program and the amounts involved. Hon. C. J. HOGG (Minister for Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Community Services is: Home and Community Care Program

Municipality Auapice Funding Type Service Allocation Total Brighton Anglican Homes for Recurrent Hurlingham Adult Day $21,238 Elderly People Care Centre Total Funding $21238 City of Brighton Recurrent Community Service Officer $22 S09 City of Brighton Recurrent Community Service Officer $13820 City of Brighton Recurrent Food Service $44 000 City 01 Brighton Recurrent General Home Help $480011 City of Brighton Recurrent Home Maintenance $23174 City of Brighton Recurrent Brighton Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City 01 Brighton Recurrent Specific Home Help $103 767 City 01 Brighton Capital Computer Software/Hardware $8000 City 01 Brighton Capital Extensions $87000 Total Funding $788 281 Cirrawheen Community Recurrent Cirrawheen Adult Day Care Centre $11125 Total Funding $11125 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

132 COUNCIL Wednesday, 12 August 1992

Caulfield City of Caulfield Recurrent Caulfield Combined Day Care Centre 5118053 City of Caulfield Recurrent Community Service Officer 517059 City of Caulfield Recurrent Community Service Officer 519079 City of Caulfield Recurrent Community Service Officer 528867 City of Caulfield Recurrent Community Service Officer 524799 City of Caulfield Recurrent Food Service 5138 999 City of Caulfield Recurrent General Home Help 5704949 City of Caulfield Recurrent Home Maintenance 551 011 City of Caulfield Recurrent Carnegie Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Caulfield Recurrent Caulfield Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Caulfield Recurrent Ormond Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Caulfield Recurrent Specific Home Help 5284 294 City of Caulfield Recurrent Volunteer Aid Service 511969 City of Caulfield Capital Computer Software/Hardware 519200 Total Funding 51436 280 Caulfield Hospital Recurrent Allied Health $33907 Total Funding $33907

Moorabbin East Bentleigh Community Health Centre Recurrent East Bentleigh Adult Day Care Centre $48338 East Bentleigh Community Health Centre Capital Modifications $6627 Total Funding $54965 Interchange Family Program Recurrent Southern Region Interchange Project $62865 Interchange Family Program Capital Computer Software/Hardware 510575 Total Funding 573440 Kingston Centre Recurrent Kingston Centre Adult Day Care Centre 523 437 Kingston Centre Recurrent Training 522902 Kingston Centre Fixed Term Allied Health 5103 633 Total Funding 51499n Leighmoor Parish Uniting Church Recurrent Leighmoor Adult Day Care Centre 557255 Total Fundmg 557255 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Allied Health S430JS City of Moorabbin Recurrent Community Service Officer 525954 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Community Service Officer S22 989 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Food Service 5118439 City of Moorabbin Recurrent General Home Help 51002937 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Home Maintenance $98062 City of Moorabbin Recurrent BentJeigh Senior Citizens Centr $6000 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Cheltenham Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Highett Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Moorabbin Senior Citiizens Centre $6000 City of Moorabbin Recurrent East Bentleigh Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Moorabbin Recurrent Specific Home Help $288646 City of Moorabbin Capital Alarm Systems $773 City of Moorabbin Fixed Term Access and Advocacy $149007 Total Funding 51779843

Mordialloc City of Mordialloc Recurrent Community Service Officer 524278 City of Mordialloc Recurrent Community Service Officer $20301 City of Mordialloc Recurrent Food Service 545498 City of Mordialloc Recurrent General Home Help $304 074 City of Mordialloc Recurrent Home Maintenance S23 063 City of Mordialloc Recurrent East Beaumaris Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Mordialloc Recurrent Mentone Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of MordiaUoc Recurrent Mordialloc Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Mordialloc Recurrent Specific Home Help $73325 City of Mordialloc Capital Computer Software/Hardware 512000 Total Funding 5520539 Mordialloc/Cheltenham Community Health Centr.. Recurrent Allied Health $247(1.) QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 133

Mordialloc/Cheltenham Community Health Centre Recurrent Aged Services Adult Day Care Service $98971 Mordialloc/Cheltenham Community Health Centre Recurrent Psycho-Geriatric Adult Day Care Service 518330 Mordialloc/Cheltenham Community Health Centre Capital Vehicle 520262 Mordialloc/Cheltenham Community Health Centre Capital Security System $8176 MordiaUoc/Cheltenham Community Health Centre Capital Construction of Adult Day Centre $320000 Total Funding $490499

Sandringham Hampton Community Centre Recurrent Hampton Adult Day Care Centre $40052 Total Funding $40052 City of Sandringham Recurrent Black Rock Activity Centre $32203 City of Sandringham Recurrent Community Service Officer 510361 City of Sandringham Recurrent Community Service Officer 519609 City of Sandringham Recurrent Food Service $56653 City of Sandringham Recurrent General Home Help $422226 City of Sandringham Recurrent Home Maintenance 524292 City of Sandringham Recurrent Brighton Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Sandringham Recurrent Brighton Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Sandringham Recurrent Brighton Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Sandringham Recurrent Brighton Senior Citizens Centre $6000 City of Sandringham Recurrent Specific Home Help 5188256 City of Sandringham Capital Computer Software/Hardwan! 520300 City of Sandringham Capital Food Service Equipment 5950 Total Funding 5798850 Uniting Church in Australia Recurrent St Martins Centre for the Aged and Frail $4153 Total Funding $4153

STATE BICYCLE COMMITIEE

Question No. 1724 Hon. G. P. CONNARD asked the Minister for Consumer Affairs, for the Minister for Transport: (a) Who are the members of the State Bicycle Committee, delineating the criteria of their appointment. (b) How many meetings have been held in 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date, delineating the attendance at each meeting. (c) What was the budget of the committee in 1990-91 and 1991-92, delineating the surplus/deficit in each year. (d) What projects were funded in 1990-91, and in 1991-92 to date. Hon. T. C. THEOPHANOUS (Minister for Consumer Affairs) - The answer provided by the Minister for Transport is: (a) Mr Fred Purcell (Chairman) Mr Ron Shepherd, Bicycle Victoria Ms Felicia Birman, Royal Automobile Club of Victoria Mr Harry Parsons, Municipal Association of Victoria Sgt Ted Wilson, Victoria Police Ms Terrye Cox, Vic. Federation of State Schools Parents' Clubs and Vie. Council of School Organisations Mr Ron Howard, Vie Cycling Federation Mr Cliff Hoath, Vie Chambers of Manufacturing & Industry Ms Lyn Dayble, Bicycle User group representative Ms Jan Burgess, Department of School Education Mr Brandon Mack, Ministry of Transport Mr Bill Johnsen, Melbourne Water Or Max Lay, Vie Roads Members of the State Bicycle Committee are appointed by the Chief Executive, Roads Corporation and represent bodies that have an interest in cycling. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

134 COUNCIL Wednesday. 12 August 1992

(b) 1990-91 1991-92 MEETINGS ATTENDANCE MEETINGS A lTENDANCE July 9 Jwy 9 August 12 August 12 September 10 September 12 October 10 October 9 November 11 November 12 December 11 December 8 Jwuruy 8 Jwuary 10 February 11 February 11 March 12 March 10 April 12 April 11 May 13 May 12 June 12 June 10 (c) Budget funds expended in 199Q-91 and 1991-92 were: 1990-91-$O.475m 1991-92 - $O.339m (d) The State Bicycle Committee provides advice wd makes recommendations to the Chief Executive, VIC ROAOS, on expenditure on a large rwge of infrastructure projects. Projects funded in 1990-91 and 1991-92 were: 1990-91: Victoriw Bicycle Strategy Bicycle Safety Footpath Cycling Trials Bicycle Mapping Geographic Information System 1991-92: Principal Bicycle Network Development Bicycle Safety Footpath Cycling Trials Bicycle Mapping Geographic Information System

ACCOUNTING - T AFE COLLEGES

Question No. 1725 Hon. R. A. MACKENZIE asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training: How mwy accountwts are employed in T AFE colleges and how many of those are TAPE graduates from - (i) Batmw Automotive College of TAPE; (ii) Box Hill College; (iii) Broadmeadows College of TAPE; (iv) Chisholm Institute of Technology; (v) Dwdenong College of TAPE; (vi) Driver Education Centre of Australia; (vii) Flagstaff College ofTAFE; (viii) Footscray Institute of Technology; (ix) Footscray College of TAFE 1989 wd 1990; (x) Frankston College of TAFE; (xi) Holmesglen College of T AFE; (xii) Melbourne College of Decoration; (xiii) Melbourne College of Printing and Graphic Arts; (xiv) Melbourne College of Textiles; (xv) Moorabbin College of T AFE; (xvi) Newport College of T AFE; (xvii) Northern Metropolitw College of TAFE; (xviii) Outer Eastern College of T AFE; (xix) Prahrw College of TAPE; (xx) Richmond College of TAPE; (xxi) Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology; (xxii) Swinbume Umitedi (xxiii) Western Institute; wd (xxiv) William Angliss College. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training is: Time wd resources necessary to compile this information cannot be justified. However, if the honourable member has a particular college in mind, I would be happy to provide that information. QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Wednesday, 12 August 1992 COUNCIL 135

ACCOUNTING -TAFE COLLEGES

Question No. 1726 Hon. R. A. MACKENZIE asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training: How many accountants are employed in T AFE colleges and how many of those are TAPE graduates from - (i) Bendigo College of Advanced Education; (ii) East Gippsland Community College of T AFE; (iii) Gordon Technical College; (iv) Goulburn Valley Community College; (v) Loddon-Campaspe College of TAPE; (vi) School of Mines and Industries, Ballarat Limited; (vii) South West College of TAPE; (viii) Sunraysia College of TAPE; (ix) Victorian College of Agriculture and Horticulture; (x) Wangaratta College of TAPE; (xi) Winunera Community College of TAFE; (xii) Wodonga College ofTAFE; and (xiii) Yallourn College of TAPE. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training is: Time and resources necessary to compile this information cannot be justified. However, if the honourable member has a particular college in mind, I would be happy to provide that information.

ACCOUNTING - TAFE COLLEGES

Question No. 1727 Hon. R. A. MACKENZIE asked the Minister for Conservation and Environment, for the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training: In each of the past two years and in 1992 to date, how many students graduated with an accounting qualification from each TAPE college in Victoria. Hon. B. T. PULLEN (Minister for Conservation and Environment) - The answer supplied by the Minister for Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training is: Time and resources necessary to compile this information cannot be justified. However, if the honourable member has a particular college in mind, I would be happy to provide that information.

INDEX

Autumn 1992 - VOLS 406, 407

LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

(Bills are listed alphabetically under "Bills" and questions on notice are listed in numerical sequence at end of index)

A Altona - Chemical complex agreement, q 669. Mobil refinery upgrade, q 900.

Abattoirs -Camperdown dispute, 249, 256. Ambulance Services - In north-eastern Victoria, Accident Compensation Commission - WorkCare q 838. Review, 1153, 1155. reports, 12, 1170. Animals - Leadbeater's possum, q 114. Kangaroos in Administrative Arrangements - Orders: Nos 98 to Chiltern Regional Park, 193, 198. Doberman dogs, 102, 12; Nos 103 and 104,209; Nos 105 to 108,906. 478,479. Feral, 716, 720, q 783, q 946. Raid on dingo farm, q 837. Flora and fauna studies, q 1012. Advertising - Alcohol, 831, 834. Government Registration of cats, 1169. Jirrahlinga All Pets programs, q 1328. Boarding and Wildlife Sanctuary, 1226, 1228. (See also "Conservation and Environment'') Aged Services- Apprentices - Business training seminars, q 785. General- Seniors Card, q 115. Senior Citizens Week, q 151. Church and charity registration fees, q 837, Arts, The - Secret Treasures of Russia exhibition, 625, q 1164. 626. Nursing Homes - Queen Elizabeth Geriatric Centre, 27,36. CAM/SAM funding, q 205. Private, 271, q 904. Yarraman psychogeriatric, q 671, 767, 774. Ashman, Hon. G. B. (Boronia) Ovens and Murray Home for the Aged, 772, 775. Burnley Private, q 945, q 1100, q 1102, q 1104, Companion Animals Bill, 90S. q 1105, 1169. Industrial dispute, q 1100. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, 1273. Agriculture (See "Food and Agriculture, Department Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 987. of") Harrods Furniture Pty Ltd - Employment practices, 1094. AIDS (See "Health - Diseases'') Housing Guarantee Fund - Registration of builders, q 481. Air Services - Airlines merger, q 1162. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1483. Albury-Wodonga Development Corporation­ Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Ministerial Council meeting dates, 770, 773. BilI,1217. Appointments, q 1011. Labour, Department of - Harrods Furniture Pty Ltd, 1094. Alcohol- Prices, 831, 834. Advertising, 834. Abuse, q 1434. Petitions -Companion Animals Bill, 90S. Port of Melbourne Authority (Amendment) Bill, 796, Aluminium Smelters of Victoria Pty Ltd - Proposed 798. sale of Portland smelter, q 839. Questions on Notice - Answers, 116. (2) INDEX

Roads Corporation - Inner-city clearway provisions, Baxter, Hon. W. R. (North Eastern) 718. Intersection at Henderson and Ferntree Gully Albury-Wodonga Development Corporation - roads, 768. Ministerial Council meeting dates, no. Small Claims Tribunal - Administration, q 1329. Appointments, q 1011. State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B Auditor-Ceneral- Report on Bayside project, 1442. power station, 193. Crimes (Culpable Driving) Bill, 809. Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill, 1338. Asia - Exports to, q 666. Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, 813, 817, 819, 820. Asset Collateralized Equity Ltd, q 1430. Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 629, q 665, q 727, q 780, q 1428. Audit of Standards of Treatment and Care in Grain Elevators (Amendment) Bill, 710. Psychiatric Hospitals, 733, 787. Heritage Rivers Bill, 613, 620. Auditor-General- Perfonnance audit, 191. Reports: Hospitals - Private for Wangaratta, 28. Clinical fire protection, q 438, 441; Ministerial portfolios, 733; audit of psychiatric, q 567. integrated education for children with disabilities, Legislative Council - Housekeeper, 1504. 786; Bayside project, 1435,1436. Role, q 898, q 941, Major Projects - Bayside, q 2, q 40, 1442. q 1009, q 1099, q 1158. Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill, 965. Aurora Gold Mine, 1003, 1006. Ministry, The - Ministerial responsibility: Minister Assisting the Minister for Manufacturing and Australian and Overseas Telecommunications Industry Development on Corporatisation, q 145. Corporation, q 728. (See also ''Manufacturing and Mission Energy, q 204, q 261. Industry Development" and "Telecom Australia") MuniCipalities - Road funding, q 835. General Australian Associated Motor Insurers Ltd - Vehicle purpose grants, 889. Rating of Loy Yang B power impact standards, lOO, 106. station, q 1100. National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1316. Australian Cement Ltd, Geelong - Gas tarIffs, q 1432. Planning - Fawkner planning scheme amendment, 673. Australian Communications and Computing Institute, q 263. Port of Melbourne Authority - Bayside project, q 2, q 40, 1442. Russian contract, q 107. East Swanson Australian Defence Industries - Benalla project, q 5. Dock, q 436, q 483, q 1162. World Trade Centre, q 1233. Australian Football League -Great Southern Stand, Port of Melbourne Authority (Amendment) Bill, 794, 769. Admission prices, 1092, 1095. 798,799. Road Safety (Licence Cancellation) Bill, 967, 972. Australian Hospitals Association - Health Ministers conference, 253, 258. School Education - Teacher transfers, 97. State Electricity Commission - Private Australian Loan Council - Guidelines, q 836. hydro-electric scheme, Koetong, 192. Sale of Loy Yang B power station, q 204, q 261, q 1100. Australian Medical Association - Bulk billing, q 1234. Corporatisation, q 629, q 665, q 727, q 780, q 1428. Victoria Grants Commission - Allocations, 889. Australian Newsprint Mills - De-inking plant, 949. Water (Rural Water Corporation) Bill, 1420. Australian Paper Manufacturers - Pulp and paper mill, Maryvale, q 433. De-inking plant, 949. Bayside Project -q I, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, q 39, q 41, Australian Private Hospitals Association - Health q 668, 1435, 1436. Ministers conference, 253, 258. Beaumaris - Heathland, 101, 103.

A viation (See 11Air Services'')

B Best, Hon. R. A. (North Western) Aboriginal Land (Manatunga Land) Bill, 759. Banks - Banking Industry Working Group, q 487, Birds - Freckled duck, q 486. q 902. Credit card transaction fees, q 1104. Companion Animals Bill, 905. Banyule Homestead, 624, 626, 1227, 1228. Dangerous Goods - Storage of radioactive waste, q 1234, q 1328. Barwon South West Women's Health Service, 312, 315. Egg Industry (Amendment) Bill, 1411. Extractive Industries - Chew ton quarry licence, 939. Golden Aluminium, Bendigo, 253. Government Appointments, Committee - Minister for Transport, 67. Second interim report, 473. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (3)

Health - Testing of imported food products, q 669. reading, 39; second reading, 120,214; Committee, Victorian Health System Review, 856. Storage of 221; remaining stages, 223. radioactive waste, q 1234, q 1328. Classification of Films and Publications (Amendment) Hospitals - Bush nursing, 639. Bill- Introduction and first reading, 733; second Housing - Government home finance schemes, 739. reading, 733, 1046; remaining stages, 1050. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1475. Classification of Films and Publications (Amendment) Bill Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) (No. 2) - Introduction and first reading, 762; Bill, 1210. second reading, 764, 1080; Committee, 1085; third reading, 1086. Manufacturing and Industry Development - Textile, clothing and footwear, Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill - Received from q943. Assembly and first reading, 835; second reading, 906, 1058, 1066; declared private Bill, 1055; motion Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System to treat as public Bill agreed to, 1056; dissent Review, 856. recorded, 1056; Committee, 1079; third reading, Petitions - Companion Animals Bill, 905. 10SO. Public Transport - Subway at Castlemaine, 142. Companion Animals Bill - Received from Assembly Racing (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, and first reading, 876; second reading, 950. 1415. Constitution (Governor's Salary) Bill - Received from RSPCA - Raid on dingo farm, q 837. Assembly and first reading, 577; second reading, Victorian Health System Review, 856. 584; third reading, 585. Youth - Kids on the Brink program, Bendigo, 891. Constitution (Independence of Judges and Public Officers) Bill-Second reading, 24; second-reading motion negatived, 26. Bills - Adjournment 11, 786, 1505. Crimes and Juries (Amendment) BiII- Introduction and first reading, 440; second reading, 527, 799; Bills- Committee, 804; remaining stages, SOS. Aboriginal Land (Manatunga Land) Bill- Received Crimes (Blood Samples) (Clarification) Bill-Second from Assembly and first reading, 474; ~econd reading, 291; Committee, 293; third reading, 296. reading, 526, 757; second-reading motion agreed Crimes (Culpable Driving) BiII- Introduction and first to by absolute majority, 760; Committee, 760; third reading, 576; second reading, 656, SOS; third reading, 761; third-reading motion agreed to by reading, 809. absolute majority, 762. Crimes (Family Violence) (Further Amendment) Bill - Accident Compensation (Further Amendment) Bill - Introduction and first reading, 762; second Received from Assembly and first reading, 1157; reading, 765, 1362; Committee, 1367; remaining second reading, 1181, 1358; second-reading stages, 1368. motion agreed to by absolute majority, 1361; Crimes (Forensic Procedures) Bill- Introduction and Committee, 1361; third-reading motion agreed to first reading, 762; second reading, 789. by absolute majority, 1362. Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances (Further Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill - Second Amendment) Bill- Introduction and first reading, reading, 129; Committee, 595; suggested 1169; second reading, 1512. amendments dealt with, 1507; remaining stages, Education (Further Amendment) Bill- Committee, 1507. 1088; remaining stages, 1090. Agricultural Industry Development (Tomato Processing) Education (Out of School Education) Bill - Withdrawn, Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 127. 1489; second reading, 1514; remaining stages, 1520. Egg Industry (Amendment) BilI- Received from Alpine Resorts (Amendment) Bill - Introduction and Assembly and first reading, 1157; second reading, first reading, 762; second reading, 788,1119,1192; 11SO, 1410; remaining stages, 1412. Committee, 1198; third reading, 1198. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill - Appropriation (July to October) Bill - Received from Second reading, 1264. Withdrawn, 1275. Assembly and first reading, 777; second reading, 788, 1253, 1514; remaining stages, 1514. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill - Second reading, 922, 974,987; Committee, 1121; Audit (Amendment) Bill (No. 2) - Received from remaining stages, 1151. Assembly and first reading, 433; second reading, 661,820. Fair Trading (Environmental Labelling) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 1157; second Bank Integration BiIl- Received from Assembly and reading, 1179. first reading, 1489; second reading, 1508; remaining stages, 1509. Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 1099; second reading, Banking (Premium Accounts) Bill - Received from 1184, 1333; second-reading motion agreed to by Assembly and first reading, 1489; second reading, absolute majority, 1340; Committee, 1340; 1509; remaining stages, 1512. remaining stages, 1344. Building Control (Further Amendment) BilI- Received Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous from Assembly and first reading, 1157; second Amendments) Bill - Received from Assembly and reading, 1178, 1408; remaining stages, 1410. first reading, 567; second reading, 578, 810; Chiropractors and Osteopaths (Amendment) Bill Committee, 817; third reading,820. (No. 2) - Received from Assembly and first (4) INDEX

Fisheries (Furthu Amendment) Bill - Received from Monash University (PhDrmacy College) Bill - Received Assembly and first reading, 201; second reading, from Assembly and first reading, 520; second 213,587; remaining stages, 594. reading, 577, 703; passed remaining stages, 709. Grain Elevators (Amendment) Bill - Received from National Parks (Wilderness) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 529; second reading, Assembly and first reading, 1051; second reading, 581,710; remaining stages, 714. 1109, 1293; Committee, 1319; remaining stages, Health Acts (Revision) Bill- Introduction and first 1323. reading, 762; second reading, 762. National Tennis Centre (Amendment) Bill - Received Heritage RiVtrs Bill - Received from Assembly and from Assembly and first reading, 192; second first reading, 296; second reading, 296, 600; reading. 211, 658; third reading, 659. Committee 617; remaining stages, 624. Parlillmentary Committees (Amendment) Bill (No. 2) - Hospitals and ChDrities (Extension) Bill - Received Introduction and first reading, 841; second from Assembly and first reading, 296; second reading, 841, 1237; remaining stages, 1242. reading. 298, 529; third reading, 530. Partnership (Limited Partnerships) Bill - Received Industrial Reliltions (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill - from Assembly and first reading, 941; second Received from Assembly and first reading, 897; reading, 958, 1282; Committee, 1285; third second reading, 955,1462; remaining stages, 1489. reading, 1289. Industrilll Reliltions (Superannuation Enforcement) Police (Industrial Functions) Bill - Second reading, Bill- Received from Assembly and first reading, 127; Committee, 127; remaining stages, 129. 897; second reading, 954, 1210; Committee, 1275; Port of Melbourne Authority (Amendment) Bill - remaining stages, 1276. Introduction and first reading, 576; second Legal Aid Commission (Amendment) Bill (No. 2) - reading, 661, 794; Committee, 797; third reading, Received from Assembly and first reading, 1157; 799. second reading, 1188, 1389; Committee, 1391; Public Account (Further Amendment) Bill - Received remaining stages, 1393. from Assembly and first reading, 433; second Libraries (Amendment) Bill - Received from reading, 659. Reference to Economic and Budget Assembly and first reading, 192; second reading, Review Committee, 879. 212,531,585; remaining stages, 587. Resubmitted Racilll and Religious Vilification BiIl- Introduction second and third-reading motions agreed to by and first reading, 950; second reading, 1053. absolute majority, 595. Racing (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill­ Liquor Control (Further Amendment) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 1157; Introduction and first reading, 576; second second reading, 1182, 1412; third reading, 1415. reading, 686. Road Safety (Licence Cancellation) Bill- Introduction Local Government (Elections) Bill-Second reading, and first reading, 762; second reading, 791, 967; 223; Committee, 233; third reading, 247. Committee, 972; remaining stages, 974. Local Government (Financilll) Bill - Received from Royal Melbourne Hospital (Redevelopment) Bill - Assembly and first reading, 897; second reading, Received from Assembly and first reading, 1003; 952, 1201; third reading, 1210. second reading, 1112, 1393; second-reading Loy Yang B Bill- Received from Assembly and first motion agreed to by absolute majority, 1399; third reading. 1157; second reading, 1189, 1368; dissent reading, 1399; third-reading motion agreed to by recorded, 1388; Committee, 1399; suggested absolute majority, 1399. amendments dealt with, 1507; remaining stages, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Bill­ 1507. Received from Assembly and first reading, 1009; Magistrates' Court (Costs) BiIl-Second reading, 122; second reading, 1086, 1276; second-reading Committee, 125; remaining stages, 126. motion agreed to by absolute majority, 1281; Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill-Second reading, Committee, 1281; third-reading motion agreed to 299; Committee, 1113; remaining stages, 1119. by absolute majority, 1282. Melbourne LIlnds and Market Sites (Amendment) Bill - State Electricity (Amendment) BiIl-Second reading, Second reading, 958; second and third-reading 22; Committee, 23; remaining stages, 24. motions agreed to by absolute majority, 1323. State Electricity Commission (Minimum Energy Melbourne Market and Park LIlnds Bill - Second Efficiency Levels) Bill- Introduction and first reading, 957; second and third-reading motions reading. 686; second reading, 754. agreed to by absolute majority, 1323. Superannuation (Occupational Superannuation Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill- Received from Standards) Bill - Received from Assembly and Assembly and first reading. m; second reading, first reading, 1086; second reading, 1111, 1290; 792, 907, 959; second-reading motion agreed to by Committee, 1291; remaining stages, 1293. absolute majority, 967; Committee, 1198; Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill- Received from suggested amendments dealt with, 1507; Assembly and first reading, 723; second reading, third-reading motion agreed to by absolute 755,912,990, 1489, 1514; concurrent debate, 757; majority, 1507. third reading. 1514. Melbourne Water Corporation Bill - Received from Swinburne University of Technology Bill- Received Assembly and first reading, 1099; second reading, from Assembly and first reading, 1003; second 1171, 1451; dissent recorded, 1458; Committee, reading. 1051, 1344; second-reading motion agreed 1458; remaining stages, 1462. to by absolute majority, 1357; Committee, 1357; LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (5)

third-reading motion agreed to by absolute Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 627, majority, 1358. q 665, q nJ, q 727. Comments of chairman, q m. Treasury Corporation of Victoria Bill - Received from Government Appointments Committee - Second Assembly and first reading, 1157; second reading, interim report, 468. 1332. Government Departments and Instrumentalities - Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill - Enhanced resignation packages, q 151. Received from Assembly and first reading, 107; Corporatisation, q 627, q 665, q nJ, q n7. second reading, 121,442; Committee, 530, 583; Health Department Victoria - Enhanced resignation remaining stages, 584. packages, q 151. Victorian Supply Service Bill - Received from Hospitals -Clinical audit of psychiatric, q 568. Assembly and first reading, 474; second reading, Heritage Rivers Bill, 600, 618, 619, 620, 622, 623, 624. 663. Legislative Council - Housekeeper, 1504. Vocational E.ducation and Training (Amendment) Bill­ Second reading, 687; second-reading motion Liquor Licensing Commission - AppOintments, agreed to by absolute majority, 702. q 114. Water (Elections) Bill - Assembly amendment dealt Major Projects - Bayside, q 1, q 6, q 9, q 39, 1436, with,879. 1450. Water (Rural Water Corporation) Bill - Received from Melbourne Lands and Market Sites (Amendment) Assembly and first reading, 1079; second reading, BiIl,1323. 1173,1416; second-reading motion agreed to by Melbourne Market and Park Lands Bill, 1323. absolute majority, 1423; Committee, 1423; Mission Energy, q 201. third-reading motion agreed to by absolute Mount Buffalo Chalet, q 487. majority, 1426. National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1293, 1320, 1321, Works and Seroices (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, 1322. No. 1) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, n3; second reading, 756, 912, 990, 1489, Parliamentary Committees (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 1514; concurrent debate, 757; remaining stages, 841,1241. 1514. Parliament House -Smoking policy, 1506. Petitions - Victoria Park agreement, 576. Bio-Molecular Institute, q 263. Point Hicks Lighthouse, q 835. Points of Order - Selective quoting, 54. Questions: Birds - Freckled duck, q 486, q 488. Migratory wader, redirection, 111; scope, n4, 778. Offensive q 571. (See also "Conservation and Environment") remarks, n6, 1448. Amendments, 1122. Reflection on Auditor-General, 1159, 1160. Port of Melbourne Authority - Bayside project, q I, Birrell, Hon. M. A. (East Yarra) q 6, q 9, q 39. Russian contract, q 107. Aged Services - Burnley Private Nursing Home, Questions on Notice - Answers, 1167. q 1102, q 1104. State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B Air Services - Airlines merger, q 1162. power station, q 201. Corporatisation, q 627, q 665, Auditor-General- Reports: fire protection, q 438; qn3,qn7. Bayside, project, 1436, 1450. Unions - Grants, 512. Australian Paper Manufacturers - Pulp and paper Urban Land Authority - Land purchases, 1017. mill, Maryvale, q 433. Bills - Adjournment, 11, 786. Business of the House - Sittings, 442, m. BLF Custodian - Reports: Nos 17 and 18, 12; No. 19, Collingwood Football Club - Victoria Park 1170. agreement, 576. Boating - Mooring fees, q 435. Conservation and Environment- Department - Restructure, q 1015. Communications Budget - Report on Estimates, 13. system, q 1232, q 1235, q 1325. Advertising campaign, q 1427. Building Societies - Interest rates, 1094. General - Sale of Crown land, q 267. Mount Buffalo Business Advice to Rural Areas - q 48, q 206, q 486, Chalet, q 487. Freckled duck, q 488. Point Hicks q 575. lighthouse, q 835. Constitution Centenary Foundation, 442. Business of the House - Presentation of reports, 11, Corporatisation - Government trading enterprises, 22, 51. Notices of Motion, 271. Sittings, 442, m. q 627, q 665, q n3, q n7. Interjections, 489. Use of correct titles, 634. Credit Tribunal- Appointment of chairperson, Adjournment debate: scope, 893. Sessional Orders, q 113, q 114. 986, 1078, 1157. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 922, 1121, 1122, 1123, 1124, 1125, 1126, 1127, 1128, 1129,1130,1131,1134,1135, 1137, 1138, 1140, 1141, 1142,1143,1144,1145,1146, 1147, 1148, 1149, 1150,1151. (6) INDEX

c Health - Drug shortages, 252. Human embryos, 1016, 1435. Cemeteries - Land at Pakenham, 250, 258, 624, 626, Hospitals - Bush nursing, 648. 768,774. Proposed burials at Lake Corangamite, Library Services - For VCE students, 140. q 669. Livestock Market Reporting Service, 1005. Magistrates' Court (Costs) Bill, 124. Mission Energy, q 203, q 263. Chairman of Committees, The (Hon. K. J. M. Wright) Municipalities - Rulings and Statements - Camberwell - Administration, q 948. Debate - Amendments, 1122. Relevancy of remarks, Grenville - Ballarat-Skipton railway reserve, 1092. 1291. Petitions - Human embryos, 1016,1435. Reference Rulings and statements as Acting President - to Standing Orders Committee, 1451. Adjournment Debate - Scope, 828, 891, 893. Scope Points of Order - Question must not seek opinion, 7. of point of order, 832. Selective quoting, 54. Offensive remarks, 65, 455. Audit of Standards of Treatment and Care in Reflections on decision of House, 90. Telephone Psychiatric Hospitals, 787. infonnation service, 439. Incorporation of Auditor-General- Report on integrated education material, 462. Government Appointments for children with disabilities, 786. Committee, 832. Debate - Member must address chair, 938. Portland Smelter Unit Trust - Proposed sale, q 839. Identification of document, 938. Ports - Mooring fees, q 435. Distinguished Visitors, 782. Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Hospitals - Audit of standards of treatment and Destruction of records, 829. care in psychiatric, 787. School Education - VCE library resources, 140. Joint Sittings of Parliament - Deakin University, Standing Orders Committee - Petitions, 1451. Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and State Electricity Commission - Sale of LOY Yang B Swinburne University of Technology, 939. power station, q 203, q 263. Questions without Notice - Interjections, 780, 840. Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd - Union Debating, 573, 628, 898. Scope, 778, 903. bans, q 1010. Rulings and statements as Deputy President - Urban Land Authority - Land purchases, 1020. Adjournment Debate - Interjections, 256. Only one Vennin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 442, matter may be raised, 475. Scope, 1006, 1093, 1225. 530. Relevancy of remarks, 1092. Wildlife Regulations 1992, 1225. Bills - Absolute majorities, 585, 594, 1323, 1423, 1426. Business of the House - Use of correct titles, 634. Debate -Interjections, 500, 1070, 1309. Remarks: Children's Protection Society - Alys Key Family relevancy, 617, 1077, 1223, 1307; offensive, 1220, Care program, 97. 1448,1476; withdrawal, 1221; unparliamentary, 1222. Quoted material, 1074. Audible Collingwood Football Club - Membership, q 7, 575. conversation, 1076. Tedious repetition, 1224. Victoria Park agreement, 576. Joint Sittings of Parliament - Deakin University, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and Community Affairs (See "Ethnic, Municipal and Swinburne University of Technology, 1065. Community Affairs") Questions without Notice -Interjections, 573. Community Services - {See also "Wright, Hon. K. I. M. (North Western)"} Children - Children's Protection Society Alys Key Family Care program, 97. (See also "Youth',) Chamberlain, Hon. B. A. (Western) Intellectual Disability Seroices - Security accommodation for youth, 255. (See also Boating - Mooring fees, q 435. ''Handicapped Persons" and ''Health - Mental Building Control (Further Amendment) Bill, 1408. Health'') Conservation and Environment - Crown land: rentals, 27; Lang-Koop school site, 474. Companion Animals Bill, 905, 949. Communications system, q 1326. Crime - Bureau of crime statistics, 524. Crimes (Blood Samples) (Clarification) Bill, 293. Connard, Hon. G. P. (Higinbotham) Crimes (Family Violence) (Further Amendment) Bill, Aged Services - Private nursing homes, 282. 1365. Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 599. Government Appointments Committee - First Beaumaris Heathland, 101. Interim report, 13. Minister for Transport, 52, 94. Chiropractors and Osteopaths (Amendment) Bill Adjournment of debate, 90. Second interim report, (No. 2), 217. 209,464. Companion Animals Bill, 949. Government Departments and Instrumentalities - Destruction of records, 829. Consumer Affairs - Alcohol advertising, 831. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (7)

Croatian Community Welfare Association of 313,314; voluntary agreement, q 669. Zumstein Victoria, 1091. Park camping grounds, 310, 314. Four-wheel drive Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 593. vehicles: levy, 475, 479; Tread Lightly program, Health - Victorian Health System Review, 864. q 487. Resource Assessment Commission report, q 484. 488. Mount Buffalo Chalet, q 487. Acupuncture, 1152. Environment handbook for small industries, HMVS Cerberus, 477. q 489. Banyule Homestead, 624, 626, 1227, 1228. Hospital Benefits Association Ltd - Merger, 890. Salinity: Saltwatch program, q 630; Goulburn Hospitals - Annual reports, 28. Monash Medical Valley drylands, q 1233. Greenhouse gas Centre, 52. Bush nursing, 650. Heidelberg emissions, q 781. Cranbourne Botanic Gardens, Repatriation, 772. 828, 832. Point Hicks lighthouse, q 835. Raid on Manufacturing and Industry dingo farm, q 837. Wonnangatta station, q 839. Development - Appointment of deputy Mountain grazing licences, q 900, q 903. Toorour director-general, 255. Forest Lodge, 1004, 1007. Flora and fauna studies, q 1012. Blu~green algae, q 1014. World Melbourne Water - Accounts, 625. Environment Week, q 1103. Snowsa!e, q 1166. Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Contaminated sites, q 1327. (See also"Animals", Review, 864. "Birds" and "Earth Summit") Monash University (Pharmacy College) Bill, 705. Mutual Community Ltd - Merger, 890. Consumer Affairs - Parliament of Victoria Committee - Third progress General- Vehicle impact standards, 100, 106. report, 1169. Labelling of toys, 193, 199. Prepaid funerals, q 269. Petitions - Monash Medical Centre, 52. Companion Increases in business fees, q 633. Uniform credit Animals Bill, 949. legislation, q 730. Regional trade measuremept Points of order - Tabling of reports, 51. authorities, q 783. Alcohol advertising, 831, 834. Washing machine repair companies, q 841. Port Phillip Bay - Artificial reef, 143. Commercial tenants, 892. Weight loss centres, Questions on Notice - Answers, 116. q 1235. Bunk beds, q 1331. Roads Corporation - Intersection at Chesterville Ministry - Telephone information service, q 439, Road and Bernard Street, Cheltenham North, 1225. q 1233. Adjudication branch, q 840. Use of car by Royal Melbourne Hospital (Redevelopment) Bill, director, q 902. Consumer tribunals, q 1013. (See 1397. also "Prices" and "Residential Tenancies School Education - Brighton Bay Secondary College Tribunal") site, 311. Primary Schools: Valkstone, 718; Moorabbin West Primary School, 1003. Constitution Centenary Foundation, 442. Social Development Committee - Report on mental disturbance and community safety, 634. Coode Island - Landy report, q 262, 310, 313, 314. Universities - Places, 184. Medical student numbers, Voluntary agreement, q 669. 195. Corporatisation -Government trading enterprises, Victorian Health System Review, 864. q 43, q Ill, q 145, q 205, q 208, q 574, q 627, q 629, q 630, q 631, q 665, q 666, q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 732, q 780, q 1158, 1331, q 1428. Conservation and Environment - County Court Judges - Report, 786. Department - Commercial forests project, q 784, 893. Appointments, lOOS, 1007, 1152, 1154. Restructure, q 1015. State Conservation Strategy, 1170. Communications system, q 1232, q 1235, q 1325, Cox, Hon. G. H. (Nunawading) q 1326. Advertising campaign, q 1427, q 1429. Animals - Doberman dogs, 478. General - Oyster cultivation in Swan Bay Marine Consumer Affairs - Vehicle impact standards, 100. and Wildlife Reserves, q 8. Sale of spray carts, 27, Increases in business fees, q 633. Regional trade 34. Crown land: rentals, 27, 35, 887, 894; sale, measurement authorities, q 783. Ministry: q 267, 475, 479; Lang-Koop school site, 474, 479; adjudication branch, q 840; use of car by director, Ballarat-Skipton railway reserve, 1092,1095. q 902; consumer tribunals, q 1013. Dandenong Ranges: picnic areas, 34, 36; land Grampians (Gariwerd) - Zumstein Park camping purchase program, 143, 144; conservation, q 436. grounds, 310. Jobs: council on fibre processing and sustainable development, q 44; funding by Priority Victoria, House Contracts Guarantee Act - Scope, 769. q 266, q 839, lOOS, 1007, 1152, 1154. Alpine Liquor Licensing Commission - Appointments, AdviSOry Committee, q 47. Wood chipping by q Ill, q 147. Midway Pty Ltd, 99, 103. Beaumaris heathland, Residential Tenancies Tribunal- Delays, q 265. 101, 103. Classification of saw logs, q 115. Mount Appointments, q 440, q 1166. Prosecutions, q 482. Disappointment State Forest, 142, 144. Artificial School Education - Life education centres, 33. reef for Port Phillip Bay, 143, 144. Hotham Chalet site, 143. Recycling and waste management, q ISO, Small Claims Tribunal - Delays, q 265. q 1429. Private hydro-electric scheme, Koetong, Appointments, q 440, q 1166. 192,198. Coode Island: Landy report, q 262, 310, (8) INDEX

Coxsedge, Hon. Joan (Melbourne West) Social Development Committee - Report on motorcycle safety, 153. Aged Services - Nursing homes: State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B power station, q 485. CAM/SAM funding, q 205. Toorour Forest Lodge, 1004. Conservation and Environment - Migratory wader Unions -Grants, 517. birds, q 571. Victorian Health System Review, 868. Consumer Affairs - Telephone infonnation service, q 439. Washing machine repair companies, q 841. Weight loss centres, q 1235. Cranboume Botanic Gudens, 828, 832. Environment Protection Authority - Contaminated sites, q 1327. Health -Medicare, q 3. Crawford, Hon. G. R. Uika Jika) Hospitals - Productivity gains, q 947. Universities - Places, 181. Legal and Constitutional Committee - Report on Witness Protection Act,SO. Unions - Grants, 514. Manufacturing and Industry Development - Commercial building energy code, q 1101. Credit - Unifonn legislation, q 730. Card transaction Seniors Card, q 115. fees, q 1104. Small Business Development Corporation - Green Directory, q 152. Credit Tribunal - Appointment of chairperson, q 113, Women -Small business forum, q 671.. Industry q 114, 153. restructuring, q 732. Croatian Community Welfare Association of Victoria, Youth - National policy, q 905. 1091,1094.

Crime (See ''Victoria Police'') Craige, Hon. G. R. (Central Highlands) Alpine Resorts (Amendment) Bill, 1119, 1198. o Animals - Registration of cats, 1169. Australian Football League -Great Southern Stand, Dandenong Ranges - Picnic areas, 34, 36. Land 769. purchase program, 143, 144. Conservation, q 436. Conservation and Environment - Mount Disappointment State Forest, 142. Four-wheel Dangerous Goods - Landy report on Coode Island, drive vehicle levy, 475. Priority Victoria job q 262, 310, 313, 314. Altona: chemical complex funding, 1152. agreement, q 669; Mobil refinery upgrade, q 899. Storage of radioactive waste, q 1234, q 1328. 193. Consumer Affairs - Labelling of toys, Contaminated sites, q 1327. (See also "Conservation Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, and Environment") 1264. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 988. Daratech Pty Ltd - Report, 441. Government Appointments Committee - Minister for Transport, 83. Heritage Rivers Bill, 612. Davidson, Hon. B. E. (Chelsea) Health - Victorian Health System Review,868. Banks - Credit card transaction fees, q 1104. Hospitals - Bush nursing, 653. In northern suburbs, Conservation and Environment - Resource q903. Assessment Commission report, q 484. Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Gambling - Gaming machines, q 7. Bill, 1212, 1275, 1462. Government Appointments Committee - Minister Labour, Department of -Occupational health and for Transport, 62. Second interim report, 468. safety regulations, 311. Hospitals - Royal Children's, q 40. Monash Medical Libraries (Amendment) Bill, 586. Centre: Moorabbin campus, 98. Local Government Commission - Chainnan, q 634. Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Bill,1215. Review, 868. Manufacturing and Industry Development - Food Motor Car Traders Guarantee Fund - Fees, 1227. processing, q 146, q 629. Telecommunications, q 71.8. Textile, clothing and footwear, q 942, q 1428. Petitions - Registration of cats, 1169. Infonnation technology, q 1232. Police (Industrial Functions) Bill, 127. Points of Order - Interjections, 8. Offensive remarks, Public Transport - Student concession cards, 890. 270. Reference to debates in same session, 462. Roads Corporation - Mansfield-Woods Point Road, Port of Melbourne Authority - East Swanson Dock, 1090. q434. School Education - Bus services: State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B Craigieburn-Broadmeadows-Pascoe Vale, 251. power station, q 778. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (9)

Victorian Health System Review, q 1328. Dockl~nds Authority - Port of Melbourne Authority land, 771, 773. (See also ''Ports'') de Fegely, Hon. R. S. (Ballarat) Drugs - Steroids, 33, 38. Illicit, 194, 198. Geelong rehabilitation program, 254, 259. (See also "Health'') Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 129, 595, 596,597,598,599,600. Duck Hunting - Freckled duck, q 486, q 488. Agricultural Industry Development (Tomato Processing) Bill, 1516 . E Australian Cement Ltd, Geelong -Gas tariffs, q 1432. E~rth Summit - Rio de Janeiro, q 781, q 1103. Bills - Adjournment, 1505. Community Services Victoria - Security Economic and Budget Review Committee - Reports: accommodation for intellectually disabled youth, cost of community service obligations, 12; 255. performance audit of Auditor-General, 118; Consumer Affairs, Ministry of - Telephone Parliamentary accountability and debt management, information service, q 1233. 786. Membership, 118. Estimates Subcommittee Egg Industry (Amendment) Bill, 1410. reports: 1991-92 Budget Estimates, 13; World Congress Centre, 1!07, 1242. Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, 810, 817, 818, 820. Education (See "Employment, Post-Secondary Gas and Fuel Corporation - Tariffs, q 1432. Education and Training" and "School Education'') Government, The - Advertising programs, q 1328. Employment, Post-Second~ry Education and Housing - Government home finance schemes, 751. Training- Law Courts - Skipton, 893. Employment - Jobs councils, q 44. Priority Victoria: Points of Order - Ministerial statement, 725. statement, 192; job funding, q 266, q 437, q 839, Prices -Gas, q 1432. 1005,1007,1152,1154, q 1231, q 1325. In Public Record Office -Staff, 717. telecommunications industry, q 569. Harrods School Education - Ararat Secondary College, 773. Furniture Pty Ltd, 1094, 1096. Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 454. General-Outer Eastern Group Training Ltd, 476. Post-Secondary Education - Admission procedures, 29,35. Tertiary places, 154. Nurse education in Defence Service Homes - Merbein, 247, 258. country institutions, q 1164.

Dent~l Services - Stop-work meeting of employees, Energy (See "Conservation and Environment", "Gas q 781. School, q 942. and Fuel Corporation", "Manufacturing and Industry Development" and "State Electricity Distinguished Visitors, 732, 782, 1366. Commission'')

Divisions - Environment (See "Conservation and Environment'') AboriginlllLand (Manlltunga lAnd) Bill, 761. Bush Nursing Hospitals, 1043. Environment Protection Authority - Contaminated sites, q 1327. Classification of Films and Publications (Amendment) Bill,105O. Environment Protection (Fees) Regulations 1991, 490. Collingwood lAnd (Victoria Park) Bill, 1078. Constitution (Independence of Judges and Public Officers) Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 949. Bill,26. Estimates Subcommittee (See "Economic and Budget Crimes and Juries (Amendment) Bill, 804. Review Committee'') Crimes (Blood Samples) (Clarification) Bill, 296. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, 1274, Ethnic Affairs, Office of - Services: interpreting, 1275. q 440, q 948; translation, q 634. Local Government Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 1125, Ethnic Affairs Ministerial Advisory Council, q 731. 1141,1145. Health education assistance, q 904. Croatian Community Welfare Association of Victoria, 1091, Heritage Rivers Bill, 620. 1094. The Jews and Italians of Carlton exhibition, Magistrates' Court (Costs) Bill, 126. q 1167. Migrant Skills and Qualifications Board, Nationlll Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1321. 1170. Funding for community-based organisations, Partnership (Limited Partnerships) Bill, 1288. q 1330, q 1433.

Select Committee on Government Appointments, 96. Ethnic, Municipal and Community Aff~in­ Tertiary Places, 191. Genua/ - Report on cost of community service Trade Union Grants, 520. obligations, 12. Urban Land Authority, 1029. Water (Rural Water Corporation) Bill, 1424. (10) INDEX

Ministry - Priority Victoria statement: local Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, enterprise development initiative program, q 437. No. 1) Bill,912. Exports - To Asia, q 966. (See also ''Manufacturing and Industry Development'') Evans, Hon. D. M. (North Eastern) Extractive Industries - Chew ton quarry licence, 939, Aged Services - Ovens and Murray Home for the 940. Aged,m. Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 135,595, F 596. Alpine Resorts (Amendment) Bill, 1195, 1198. Finance - Debt: management, q 4, q 7, q 145, q 147; Conservation and Environment - Sale of spray equity swap, q 778, q 779. Report on Parliamentary carts, 27. Alpine Advisory Committee, q 47. accountability and debt management, 786. (See also Kangaroos in Chiltern Regional Park, 193. "Corporatisation'') Mountain grazing licences, q 903. Feral, 716, q 783. Flora and fauna studies, q 1012. Fire Protection - Auditor-General's report, q 438, 441. Crime - Bureau of crime statistics, 520, 526. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, Fishing Industry (See "Food and Agriculture, 930,1125, 1134,1145. Department of - Fishing'') Finance - Debt management, q 7. Food and Agriculture, Department of - Food and Agriculture, Department of - Federal land management kit, 1153. Fishing - Oyster cultivation in Swan Bay Marine and Wildlife Reserves, q 8. Mooring fees, q 435. Forest Interpretative Centre, Toolangi, 251. General - Testing of imported food, q 669. Livestock Government Departments and Instrumentalities - Market Reporting Service, 1005. Federal land Debt management, q 7. management kit, 1153, 1154. Health - Insurance, q 633. Timber - Woodchipping by Midway Pty Ltd, 99, Heritage Rivers Bill, 604, 623. 103. Classification of sawlogs, q 115. Resource Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1487. Assessment Commission report, q 484. Legal and Constitutional Committee - Reports: Commercial forests project, q 784, 893. Logging in outstanding references, 271; Interpretation of Shire of Otway, 1004, 1007. Flora and fauna Legislation Act, 441. studies, q 1012. Medical Services - Nurse education in country (See also "Conservation and Environment'') institutions, q 1164. Food Processing (See ''Manufacturing and Industry Melbourne Water Corporation Bill, 1451, 1458, 1459, Development'') 1460,1461. Mineral Resources (Health and Safety) Regulations Forest Interpretative Centre, Toolangi - 251,258. 1991,1017. Mount Hotham - Chalet site, 143. Freedom of Information - Department of Manufacturing and Industry Development, 30, 34. Municipalities - Public access to swimming holes, 309. Wodonga: proposed superannuation levy, Funerals - Prepaid, q 269. q 1429. National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1300, 1322. G Parliament House - Smoking policy, 1506. Points of Order - Absolute majorities, 595. Scope of Gambling - Gaming machines, q 7, 575, q 1010. adjournment debate, 722. Relevancy of remarks, Casino for Geelong, q 1166. 1307. Roads Corporation - Snow clearing on alpine roads, Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 43, 830. q 111, q 145, q 205, q 208, q 574, q 627, q 629, q 630, Rural Water Commission - Funding, 1005. q 631, q 665, q 666, q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 732, State Electricity (Amendment) Bill, 22, 23. q 780, q 1158, q 1428. Public authority dividend, q 667, q 731. Comments of chainnan, q m, q 779. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill,912. Securitisation of trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. Trading Hours - Sunday, q 150. Asset Collateralized Equity Ltd, q 1430. Tariffs, Universities - Places, 172. q 1432. Vennin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 450. Gem Pier, Williamstown, 892, 893, q 947. Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) Bill, 700. Geriatric Services (See "Aged Services'') Water (Rural Water Corporation) Bill, 1416, 1423, 1424,1425. Golden Aluminium, Bendigo, 253, 257. Wodonga, City of - Proposed superannuation levy, Government, The - Advertising programs, q 1328. q 1429. Wonnangatta Station -Grass slashing, q 839. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - First interim report, 13. Minister for Transport, 52. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (11)

Alleged breach of privilege, 209. Second interim Hospitals - Psychiatric: staff recruitment, q 572. report, 209,270,455. Latrobe Regional Commission - Report, q 109. Government Commercial and Trading Enterprises Local Government (Elections) Bill, 232. Committee, q 145. Loy Yang B Bill, 1379. Manufacturing and Industry Government Departments and Instrumentalities - Development - Undersea electricity cable link, Debt: management, q 4, q 7, q 145, q 147; equity q 1327. swap, q 778, q 779. Corporatisation, q 43, q 111, Melbourne University (YCAH) Bill, 959, 1200. q 145, q 205, q 208, q 574, q 627, q 629, q 630, q 631, q 665, q 666, q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 732, q 780, Monash University (Pharmacy College) Bill, 704. q 1158, 1331, q 1428. Enhanced reSignation packages, National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1313. q 151, 208. Appointments, 255, 258. Employment of Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Bill, 1276. union officials, q 629. Destruction of records, 829, State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B 832. Securitisation of trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. power station, q 437, q 729, q 900, 1102. Regional power conference, 828. Stockpiling, q 945. Government Employee Housing Authority - Eviction of Co lac family, q 207, 718, 722. Swinburne University of Technology Bill, 1347. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1492. Government Trading Enterprises (See "Government Universities - Plac~, 159. Departments and Instrumentalities") Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) Bill,692. Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, Guest, Hon. J. V. C. (Monash) No. 1) Bill, 1492. Classification of Films and Publications (Amendment) Bill, 733, 1049. Classification of Films and Publications Hallam, Hon. R. M. (Western) (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 1080. Accident Compensation (Further Amendment) Bill, Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1075. 1358,1361. Constitution (Governor's Salary) Bill, 584. Appropriation Guly to October) Bill, 1253. Constitution (Independence of Judges and Public Asset Collateralized Equity Ltd, q 1431. Officers) Bill, 24. Audit (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 821. Crimes and Juries (Amendment) Bill, 799, 804, 805. Auditor-General- Role, q 898, q 941, q 1009, q 1099, Crimes (Culpable Driving) Bill, 805. q 1158. Crimes (Family Violence)(Further Amendment) Bill, Bank Integration Bill, 1508. 1362. Banking (Premium Accounts) Bill, 1509. Economic and Budget Review Committee - Reports: Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1058. cost of community service obligations, 12; Conservation and Environment, Department of - performance audit of Auditor-General, 118; Crown land: sale, 475; rentals, 887. Appointments, Parliamentary accountability and debt 1005. management, 786. Corporatisation - Government trading enterprises, Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill, 1333. q 43, q 111, q 627, q 725. Health - HIV / AIDS testing, 1091. Economic and Budget Review Committee - Legal Aid Commission (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), Estimates Subcommittee report: World Congress 1389, 1391, 1392. Centre, 1249. Loy Yang B Bill, 1371. Finance - Debt: management, q 4, q 147; equity Magistrates' Court (Costs) Bill, 122, 125, 126. swap, q 778. Partnership (Limited Partnerships) Bill, 1282, 1286, Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 43, 1287, 1288, 1289. q 111, q 627, q 725. Public authority dividend, Superannuation (Occupational Superannuation q 667. Securitisation of trade receivables, q 1431. Standards) Bill, 1290, 1291, 1292, 1293. Glenelg, Shire of - Union demarcation dispute, 98. Government Departments and Instrumentalities - H Debt: management, q 4, q 147; equity swap, q 778. Corporatisation, q 43, q 111, q 627, q 725. Hall, Hon. P. R. (Gippsland) Hospitals - Clinical audit of psychiatric, q 569. Hamilton Base, 829. Aurora Gold Mine, 1003. Leigh, Shire of - General purpose grants, 1226. Bairnsdale, Shire of - Boundaries, q 265. Local Government (Elections) Bill, 223, 233, 234 235, Education (Further Amendment) Bill, 1089, 1090. 236,237,238,239,240,241,242,243,244,245,246, Education - TA FE admission procedures, 29. 247. Tertiary places, 159. Local Government (Financial) Bill, 1201. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 977. Loy Yang B Bill, 1375. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 591. Melbourne Water -Securitisation of trade Heritage Rivers Bill, 609. receivables, q 1431. (12) INDEX

Mission Energy, q 202, q 206, 252. Smoking by youth, q 1012. Acupuncture, 1152, Moe, City of - WorkCare claim, 28. 1154. Municipalities -General purpose grants, 1226. Mental Health - Resignation of Director, Office of Status of councillors, 28. Tree planting, 309. Road Psychiatric Services, q 206. Psychiatric hospitals: fundin~ q 481. Accounting standards, 771. Dax House, Geelong, q 264; clinical audit, q 268, 567, 568, 573; mainstreaming programs, Points of Order - Audibility, 1106. q q q 309, 315,888,895, q 897, q 942; roster systems, q 570; Prices - Electricity, q 43, q 111. staff recruitment, q 572; audit of standards of Priority Victoria - A statement on jobs, 1005, q 1231, treatment and care, 733, 787; report on mental q 1325. disturbance and community safety, 51, 634; Public Account (Further Amendment) Bill, 879. qualifications of doctors, q 1433. Patient transport, Roads Corporation - VIC ROADS tender, 98. q 571. Yarraman psychogeriatric nursing home, q 671, 767, 774. State Electricity Commission - Morwell overburden, q 43, q 111. Corporatisation, q 43, q 111, q 627, q 725. Sale of Loy Yang B power station, q 202, Health (Radiation Safety) Regulations 1984,715,720, q 206, 252. Securitisation of trade receivables, q725. q 1431. Health Services Commissioner - Report, 1016. Strategic Research Foundation - Chairman, q 263. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 990. Taxation - Financial institutions duty on roll-over Henshaw, D. E. (Geelong) term deposits, 141. Aged Services - Private nursing homes, 279. Unions- Demarcation dispute in the Shire of Barwon South West Women's Health Service, 312. Glenelg, 98. Conservation and Environment - Leadbeater's Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 444. possum q 114. Priority Victoria jobs Victoria Grants Commission - Allocations, 1226. funding, q 839. World Environment Week, q 1103. Vistel Ltd - Sale, q 434. Earth Summit - Rio de Janeiro, q 1103. WorkCare -Claim by City of Moe, 28. Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, Ministry Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions,"1992-93, of - Priority Victoria: local enterprise No. 1) Bill, 990. development initiative program, q 437. World Congress Centre, 1249. Health (Radiation Safety) Regulations 1984, q 725. Hospitals - Psychiatric: Dax House, Geelong, q 264. Housing - Government home finance schemes, Handicapped Persons - Auditor-General's report on 753. integrated education for children with disabilities, Medicare, q 568, q 1160. 786. Access to national parks, q 901. (See also "Community Services - Intellectual Disability Points of Order - Offensive remarks, 1477. Services'') Priority Victoria, q 437, q 839. Salinity - Goulburn Valley drylands, q 1233. Hurods Furniture Pty Lld - Employment practices, Small Business Development Corporation - 1094,1096. Forum, q 46. Huardous Materials (See "Dangerous Goods'') Swan Bay Marine and Wildlife Reserves - Oyster cultivation, q 8. Health- Youth - Enterprise program, q 1015. Department VictoriD - Enhanced reSignation Rulings and Statements as Acting ChDirman - packages, q 151,208. Cemetery land at Pakenham, Debate - Amendments, 619. 250,258, 624, 626, 768, 774. Head lice programs, Rulings and Statements as Acting President - 771,775. Prosecution, q 784. Storage of radioactive Debate - Interjections, 873. waste, q 1234, q 1328. DiseJl5eS - Breast cancer screening program, 31, 37, q 632. Pediculosis, 771, 775. Cystic fibrosis, q 782. HMVS "Cerberus", 477, 478. HIV / AIDS: assistance to non-English-speaking community providers, q 904; testing, 1091, 1095. Drugs - Shortages, 252, 258. (See also ''Drugs'') Hogg, Hon. C. J. (Melbourne North) (Minister for General-Medicare, q 3, q 45, q 568, q 1099, q 1160, Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) q 1234. Funding: capital, q 49; CAM/SAM, q 205. Ministers conference, 253, 258. Barwon South Aboriginal Land (Manatunga Land) Bill, 474, 526, West Women's Health Service, 315. Human 760,761 embryos, 440, 1016, 1435. Consultative Council on Business Advice to Rural Areas, q 486, q 575. Obstetric and Paediatric Mortality and Morbidity Business of the House -Sessional Orders, 986,1078. report, 576. Insurance, q 633, q 1231. Testing of Education (Further Amendment) Bill, 1089, 1090. imported food products, q 669. Community health Education (Out of School Education) Bill, 127. centres, 786, 906. Church and charity registration fees, q 837. Latrobe region services, 841. Victorian Ethnic Affairs, Office of - Services: interpreting Health System Review, 841, 843, 1043, q 1328. q 440, q 948; translation q 634. Local Government LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (13)

Ethnic Affairs Ministerial Advisory Council, q 731. q 149, q 1011. Western, q 149. Gippsland, q 149. Croatian Community Welfare Association of Geelong, q 149. Preston and Northcote Community, Victoria, 1094. The Jews and Italians of Carlton q 149. Austin, q 149. Box Hill, q 149. Peter exhibition, q 1167. Funding for community-based MacCallum Cancer Institute, q 149. Enhanced organisations, q 1330, q 1433. resignation packages, q 151. Psychiatric: Dax House, Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, Ministry Geelong q 264; clinical audit, q 268, q 567, q 568, of - Priority Victoria: local enterprise q 573; mainstreaming programs, 309, 315, 888, 895, development initiative program, q 437. q 897, q 942; roster systems, q 570; staff recruitment, q 572; audit of standards of treatment and care, 733, Hospitals and Charities (Extension) Bill, 298, 530. 787. Medicare agreement, q 568. Bush nursing, 635, Libraries (Amendment) Bill, 192,212. 1030. Heidelberg Repatriation, 772, 775. For cystic Local Enterprise Development Initiative Program, fibrosis patients, q 782. Hamilton Base, 829,833. q 437. Proposed Whittlesea, 830, 833. Loan council Local Government Commission - Chainnan, q 634. guidelines, q 836. In northern suburbs, q 903. Local Government (Elections) Bill, 233, 234, 235, 236, Productivity gains, q 947. Proposed Epping, q 1009, 238,239,240,242,243,244,245,246,247. q 1165. Financial perfonnance of public, q 1432. (See also "Health - Mental Health") Local Government (Financial) Bill, 897, 952, 1210. Municipalities - Hotham Chalet, 143. Bairnsda/e - Boundaries, q 265. House Committee - Report on completion of Camberwell - Administration, q 948. Parliament House, 1107. Finance - Road funding, q 481, q 836, q 1106. General purpose grants, 894, 1228. Rating of Loy House Contracts Guarantee Act -Scope, 769, 770. Yang B power station, q 1101. Genera/- Status of councillors, 34. Tree planting, Housing (See "Planning and Housing'') 314. Cost of community service obligations, 12. G/ene/g - Union demarcation dispute, 103. Housing Guarantee Fund - Claims by Department of Planning and Housing, q 437. Registration of Keilor - Annexation poll, q 10. builders, q 481. Leigh - General purpose grants, 1228. Moe - WorkCare claim, 34. Sherbroo/ce - Annexation proposals, 102. Hunt, Hon. A. J. (South Eastern) (See "President, The Wodonga - Proposed superannuation levy, q 1429. (Hon. A. J. Hunt)") Priority Victoria, q 437. Questions on Notice - Answers, 115. Rural Enterprise Victoria Scheme, q 48, q 206, q 486, q575. Industrial Affain (See "Labour, Department of" and Senior Citizens - Seniors Card, q 115. Senior "Unions'') Citizens Week, q 151. Industry (See ''Food and Agriculture, Department of", State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B "Fishing" and ''Timber'' and "Manufacturing and power station, q 1101. Industry Development'') Swinburne University of Technology Bill, 1051. Victoria Grants Commission - Allocations, 894. Infertility (Medical Procedures) Act - Register, 1092, 1095. Victoria Police - Uncollected parking fines, q 1331. Victorian Family and Children's Services Council- Insurance - Health, q 633, q 1231. Report, 12. Western Port Development Council - Activities, Interpretation of Legislation Act - Report, 441. q 784. Women - Industry restructuring, q 732. Ives, Hon. R. S (Eumemmerring) Youth - Homelessness, q 267. Accommodation, q 671. Youth Policy Development Council, q 837. Australian Defence Industries - BenalJa project, q 5. Kids on the Brink program, Bendigo, 894. National Crimes and Juries (Amendment) Bill, 801. policy, q 905. Enterprise program, q 1015. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, Ministers council, q 1237. 1274. Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, Ministry of - Funding for community-based organisations, Hospital Benefits Association Lld - Merger, 890, 893. q 1330. Hospitals - Proposed private for Wangaratta, 28, 37. Exports - To Asia, q 666. Annual reports, 28, 37. Southern Peninsula, 29, 37, Government Appointments Committee - Minister 101, 105. Royal Women's, 31, 37. Royal Children'S, for Transport, 72. Second interim report, 270, 455. q 40. Monash Medical Centre, 52, 98,103, q 149,717, Health - Medicare, q 1234. 720. St John of God, Ballarat, 99, 309, 314, 888, 895. Yarra Junction District, 100, 105. Proposed Werribee, Hospitals - Capital works, q 148. q 113, q 668. St Vincent's, q 113. Capital works, (14) INDEX

Manufacturing Council of Victoria - Activities, qualifications of doctors, q 1433. Bush nursing, q836. 635,1041. Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill, 963. Housing Guarantee Fund - Claims by Department River Murray - Blue-green algae, q 1014. of Planning and Housing, q 437. Rural Enterprise Victoria Scheme, q 486, q 575. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1480. Small Business - Development strategy, q 943. Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill, 307. Telecom awards, q 1165. Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Small Business Development Corporation - Early Review, 858. retired employees program, q 207. Planning and Housing, Department of - Housing Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) Guarantee Fund claims, q 437. Fawkner planning Bill, 695. scheme amendment, 684. Government home finance schemes, 735, 875. Points of Order - Debating question, 573, 723, 945. J Remarks: offensive, 1220; relevancy, 1467, 1469, 1471. Proof of allegations, 1471. Jews and Italians of Carlton Exhibition, The, q 1167. Public Transport- Bus services for Maroona Primary School, 192. Jirrahlinga All Pets Boarding and Wildlife Sanctuary, 1226,1228. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 921. Urban Land Authority - Land purchases, 876, 1017, Joint Sittings of Parliament - Deakin University, 1028. Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and Unions - Employment of officials in government Swinburne University of Technology, 939, 1065, departments and instrumentalities, q 629. Dental 1097. health services employees stop-work meeting, q 781. K Victorian Equity Trust - Debt management, q 145. Victorian Health System Review, 858. Kennedy, Hon. C. J. (Waverley) Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, Apprentices - Business training seminars, q 785. No. 1) Bill, 921. Conservation and Environment - Jobs council on fibre processing and sustainable development, q 44. Kokodnski, Hon. Lida (Melbourne West) Health - Community health centres, 786,906. Abattoirs - Camperdown dispute, 249. Hospitals - Monash Medical Centre, 717. Alcohol - Abuse, q 1434. Municipalities - Road funding, q 1106. Australian Newsprint Mills - De-inking plant, 949. Petitions - South Eastern Arterial, 209. Community Conservation and Environment - Environment health centres, 786, 906. handbook for small industries, q 489. SnowSQ/e, Rural Enterprise Victoria Scheme, q 206. q 1166. Small Business, Department of - Banking Industry Consumer Affairs - Bunk beds, q 1331. Working Group, q 487. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 933. Youth - Accommodation, q 671. Policy Ethnic Affairs - Interpreting services, q 948. development, q 837. Health - Report on mental disturbance and community :;afety, 51. Breast cancer screening program, q 632. Cystic fibrosis, q 782. Victorian Knowles, Hon. R.I. (Ballarat) Health System Review, 861. Aged Services - Nursing homes: Queen Elizabeth Hospitals - Proposed Werribee, q 112, q 668. Geriatric Centre, 27; private, 288, Yarraman Keilor, City of - Annexation poll, q 10. psychogeriatric, q 671, 767; Burnley Private, q 945, Liquor Licensing Commission - Alcohol abuse, q 1100, q 1105. Church and charity registration q 1434. fees, q 837, q 1164. Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Corporatisation - Government trading enterprises, Review,861. q 732. Mission Energy, q 202. Dental Services - Stop-work meeting of employees, Mobil Oil Australia - Altona refinery, q 899. q 781. Personal Explanations - Environment Protection Finance - Debt management, q 145. (Resource Recovery) Bill, 949. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 587. Points of order - Scope of adjournment debate, 249. Government Departments and Instrumentalities- Offensive remarks, 520. Debt management, q 145. Corporatisation, q 732. Priority Victoria - Department of Conservation and Health -Capital funding, q 49. Victorian Health Environment job funding, q 266. System Review, 858. Social Development Committee - Report on mental Hospitals - St John of God, Ballarat, 99, 308, 888. disturbance and community safety,S!. Psychiatric: patient transport, q 571; Yarraman psychogeriatric nursing home, q 671, 767; LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (15)

State Electricity Commission - Sale of Loy Yang B Legal and Constitutional Committee - Reports: power station, q 202. Witness Protection Act, 50; outstanding references, Universities - Places, 163. 271; Interpretation of Legislation Act, 441. Victorian Health System Review, 861. Legislative Council - Housekeeper, 1504. Women - Breast cancer screening program, q 632. Liberal Party - Alleged activities of president, 249, L 256. Library Services - For VCE students, 140,714. Yarra Labour, Department of - Occupational health and Plenty Regional Library Service, 714. safety regulations, 311. Harrods Furniture Pty Ltd, 1094, 1096. Life Education Victoria, 33.

Liquor Licensing Commission - Gaming machines, Landeryou, Hon. W. A. (Doutta Galla) q 7, 575. Restaurant licences, q 110. Appointments, q 111, q 114, q 147. Alcohol abuse, q 1434. Business of the House - Notices of Motion, 271. Corporatisation -133l. Livestock Market Reporting Service, 1005. House Committee - Report on completion of Parliament House, 1107. Local Enterprise Deve10pment Initiative Program, q 437. Parliament House - Smoking policy, 271, 1151, 1506. Parliament of Victoria Committee - Report on Local Government (See ''Municipalities'1 Budget process, 13,441. Appointment of subcommittee, 754. Local Government Commission - Chainnan, q 634. Points of Order - Selective quoting, 54. Offensive remarks, 270. Public Bodies Review Committee -Corporatisation Long, Hon. R. J. (Gippsland) of State Electricity Commission, 133l. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, Lands (See "Conservation and Environment") 1145, 1148. Latrobe Regional Commission - Report, q 109. Health - Latrobe region services, 841. Law Courts - Medical malpractice litigation, 30, 37. Heritage Rivers Bill, 62l. County Court judges report, 786. Skipton, 893, 895. Loy Yang B Bill, 1368, 1399, 1400, 1401, 1404, 1405. Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill, 306. Lawson, Hon. Robert (Higinbotham) Municipalities - Authority, 11. Petitions - Local government, 11. Latrobe region Classification of Films and Publications health services, 841. (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 1084. Points of Order - Questions: relevancy of answer, Law Courts - Medical malpractice litigation, 30. 42; debating, 482; scope, 944. Quoted material, Loy Yang B Bill, 1387. 1468. Medical Profession - Malpractice litigation, 30. Reports - Procedures for presentation, 22. Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill, 964. State Electricity (Amendment) Bill, 22, 23. Port of Melbourne Authority (Amendment) Bill, 797. Public Record Office - Staff, 719. Lyster, Hon. M. A. (Chelsea) (Minister for Health) Public Transport - Rail crossings at Church and Bay streets, Brighton, 197. W-class trams, 830. Aged Services - Road Safety (Licence Cancellation) Bill, 970. General - Church and charity registration fees, q 837, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Bill, 1280. q 1164. School Education -Correspondence School, 96. Nursing Homes - Queen Elizabeth Geriatric Centre, 36. CAM/SAM funding, q 205. Private,285. Southern Consumer and Financial Advocacy Service, Yarraman psychogeriatric, q 671, 774. Ovens and 1227. Murray Home for the Aged, 775. Private, q 904. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1494. Burnley Private, q 945, q 1100, q 1102, q 1104, Tenancies - Commercia\' 892. q 1105, 1169. Industrial dispute, q 1100. Universities - Places, 185. Ambulance Services - In north-eastern Victoria, Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) q 838. Review, 1155. BiIl,697. Australian Hospitals Associations - Health Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, Ministers conference, 258. No. 1) Bill, 1494. Barwon South West Women's Health Service, 315. Cemeteries - Land at Pakenham, 258, 774. Proposed burials at Lake Corangamite, q 670. Leadbeater's Possum, q 114. Chiropractors and Osteopaths (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 39, 120,221,222,223. (16) INDEX

Classification of Films and Publications God, Ballarat, 104,314,895. Yarra Junction (Amendment) Bill, 734, 1046, 1085, 1086. District, 105. Southern Peninsula, 105. Proposed Classification of Films and Publications Werribee, q 113, q 668. St Vincent's, q 113. Capital (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 762, 764. works, q 148, q 1011. Western, q 149. Gippsland, Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 835, 906, 1055, q 149. Geelong, q 149. Austin, q 149. Preston and 1079,1080. Northcote Community, q 149. Box Hill, q 149. Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute, q 149. Constitution (Governor's Salary) Bill, 577, 584, 585. Enhanced resignation packages, q 151. County Court Judges - Report, 786. Mainstreaming programs, 315, q 942. Bush Crime - Bureau of crime statistics, 734. nursing, 655, 1035. Heidelberg Repatriation, 775. Crimes and Juries (Amendment) Bill, 440, 527, 804. Hamilton Base, 833. Proposed Whittlesea, 833. Loan Council guidelines, q 836. In northern Crimes (Blood Samples) (Clarification) Bill, 291. suburbs, q 903. Productivity gains, q 947. Funding Crimes (Culpable Driving) Bill, 576, 656, 809. for proposed Epping, q 1009, q 1165. Financial Crimes (Family Violence) (Further Amendment) Bill, perfonnance of public, q 1432. (See also Health) 762, 765, 1367. Infertility (Medical Procedures) Act - Register, 1095. Crimes (Forensic Procedures) Bill, 762, 789. Law Courts - Medical malpractice litigation, 37. Dangerous Goods -Storage of radioactive waste, Legal Aid Commission (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), q 1234, q 1328. 1157,1188,1391,1392,1393. Dental Services - Stop-work meeting of employees, Magistrates' Court (Costs) Bill, 125. q 781. Medical Services- Nurse education in country Drugs - Steroids, 38. Illicit, 198. Geelong Victoria, q 1164. Qualifications of psychiatric rehabilitation program, 259. (See also "Health'1 service doctors, q 1433. Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances (Further Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill, 1113, 1114, 1115, Amendment) Bill, 1169, 1512. 1116,1117,1119. Ethnic Affairs - Health education assistance, q 904. Mental Health Act - Amendments, q 942. Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill, 1184, 1340, 1341, Mental Health Review Board - Appointment, q 150. 1342, 1343, 1344. Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous Review, 843. Amendments) Bill, 567, 578, 817, 818, 819, 820. National Food Authority - Testing of imported food Government Departments and Instrumentalities - products, q 669. Enhanced resignation packages, q 151, 208. Obstetric and Paediatric Mortality and Morbidity, Health- Consultative Council on - Report, 576. Dtpartment Victoria - Enhanced resignation Pakenham, Shire of - Cemetery land, 626. packages, q 151, 208. Cemetery land at Pakenham, Partnership (Limited Partnerships) Bill, 941, 958, 258, 626, 774. Head lice programs, 775. 1285, 1286, 1287, 1288, 1289. Prosecution, q 784. Storage of radioactive waste, q 1234, q 1328. Personal Explanations - Enhanced resignation packages, 208. Diseases - Breast cancer screening program, 37, q 632. Pediculosis, 775. Cystic fibrosis, q 782. Points of Order - Offensive remarks, 29. Scope of AIDS/HIV: assistance to non-English speaking adjournment debate, 29. community providers, q 904; testing, 1095. Questions on Notice - Answers, 116, 118, 1169. Drugs - Shortages, 258. Racial and Religious Vilification Bill, 950, 1053. General- Medicare, q 3, q 45, q 568, q 1099, q 1161, Melbourne Hospital (Redevelopment) Bill, 1003, q 1234. Funding: capital, q 49; CAM/SAM, q 205. 1112,1399. Ministers conference, 259. Barwon South West Smoking - By youth, q 1012. Women's Health Service, 315. Insurance, q 633, Supreme Court Judges - Report, 786. q 1231. Testing of imported food products, q 669. Victorian Health System Review, 841, 843, q 1328. Unions - Employment of officials in government 629. Smoking by youth, q 1012. Acupuncture, 1154. departments and instrumentalities, q Stop-work meeting in dental services, q 781. Mental Hetllth - Resignation of Director of Office of Universities - Medical student numbers, 198. Psychiatric Services, q 207. Psychiatric hospitals: Dax House, Geelong, q 264; clinical audit, q 268, Victoria Police - Traffic fines for pensioners and q 567, q 568, q 569, q 573; mainstreaming jobless, 198. programs, 315, 895, q 897, q 942; roster systems, Victorian Ambulance Services Review, 1155. q 570; staff recruitment, q 572; qualifications of Victorian Health System Review, 841, 843, q 1328. doctors, q 1433. Patient transport, q 571. Yarraman Women - Breast cancer screening program, 37, psychogeriatric nursing home, q 671, 774. q 632. Barwon South West Women's Health Health Acts (Revision) Bill, 762. Service, 315. Health (Radiation Safety) Regulations 1884,720, q725. M Health Services Commissioner - Report, 1016. Hospitals - Private for Wangaratta, 37. Annual Mackenzie, Hon. R. A. (Geelong) reports, 37. Royal Women's, 37. Children's, q 40. Monash Medical Centre, 103, q 149, 720. St John of Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 132. LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (17)

Arts, The - Secret Treasures of Russia exhibition, Russia - Secret Treasures exhibition, 625. 625. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1497. Australian Football League - Match admission Universities - Places, 175. prices, 1092. Venoin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 448. Bank Integration Bill, 1509. Victorian Health System Review, 870, 1043. Alpine Resorts (Amendment) Bill, 1192, 1198. Victree Timber Products Pty Lld, 1004. Chiropractors and Osteopaths (Amendment) Bill Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) (No. 2),219. BilI,698. Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1055, 1063, Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, 1066, 1079. Dissent recorded, 1056. No. 1) Bill,1497. Conservation and Environment - Woodchipping by Midway Pty Ltd, 99. Classification of saw logs, q 115. Four-wheel drive vehicles, q 487. McLean, Hon. Jean (Boronia Province) Commercial forests project, q 784, 892. Coode Island - Landy report, 310. Aged Services - Nursing home industrial dispute, q 1100. Corporatisation -Government trading enterprises, q 574, q 670. Altona Chemical Complex - Agreement, q 669. Crime - Bureau of crime statistics, 525. Conservation and Environment - Recycling and waste management, q ISO, q 1429. Drugs - Illicit, 194. Geelong rehabilitation program, 254. Coode Island - Landy report, q 262. Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 984. Dandenong Ranges - Conservation, q 436. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, Earth Summit - Rio de Janeiro, q 781. 1273. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill, 1339. 1271. Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 982. Amendments) Bill, 816. Gambling - Gaming machines, q 1010. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 589. National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1306. Gambling - Casino for Geelong, q 1166. Small Business, Department of - Banking Industry Gem Pier, Williamstown, q 947. Working Group, q 902. Government Appointments Committee - Minister Small Claims Tribunal - Scope, q 633. for Transport, 89,90. State Electricity Commission - National electricity Government Departments and Instrumentalities - grid, q 108. Corporatisation, q 574, q 670. Youth - Ministers council, q 1236. Government Employee Housing Authority - Eviction of Colac family, q 207, 718. McNiece Media Services - ConsultanCies, 1225, 1229. Health - Victorian Health System Review, 870,1043. Heritage Rivers Bill, 608, 618, 620, 623. Major Projects - Bayside, q 1, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, q 39, Housing - Government home finance schemes, 745. q 41, q 668,1435,1436. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1478. Major Projects Unit - Report, SO. Jirrahlinga All Pets Boarding and Wildlife Sanctuary, 1226. Manufacturing and Industry Development - Loy Yang B Bill- Debate, 1383. Dissent recorded, Department - Fol request on mining companies, 30, 1389. 34. Appointment of deputy director-general, 255, Manufacturing and Industry Development, 258. Department of - Fol request on mining General- Food processing, q 146, q 629, q 1325. companies, 30. Golden Aluminium, Bendigo, 253, 257. Coode Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill, 305. Island: Landy report, q 262, 310, 313, 314. Melbourne Water Corporation Bill- Debate, 1455. Maryvale pulp and paper mill, q 433. Dissent recorded, 1458. Telecommunications industry: deregulation, Midway Pty Lld - Woodchipping, 99. q 481; investment and employment, q 569; AOTC, Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System q 728. Exports to Asia, q 666. Altona: chemical Review, 870,1043. complex agreement, q 669; Mobil refinery upgrade, q 899. Textile, clothing and footwear, National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1310. q 942, q 943, q 1428. Energy: commercial building Otway, Shire of - Logging, 1004. code, q 1101; efficiency strategy, q 1163. Points of Order - Explanation, 670. Sub judice rule, Information technology, q 1232. Undersea 1056. Tedious repetition, 1224. electricity cable link, q 1327. Prices - Football match admission, 1092. Public Transport - Melbourne-Adelaide rail Manufacturing Council of Victoria - Activities, q 836. service, q 10. Medical Panels, Convenor of - WorkCare reports, 12, Road Safety (Licence Cancellation) Bill, 970. 1170. (18) INDEX

Medical Services - St John of God Hospital, Ballarat: 433, 723. Auditor-General's report on Ministerial magnetic resonance imaging unit, 99, 309, 314, 888, portfolios, 733. 895. Nurse education in country institutions, q 1164. Qualifications of psychiatric service doctors, q 1433. Mission Energy, q 201, q 203, q 206, 252, 256, q 261, q 263, q 729, q 778. (See also "State Electricity Medicare, q 3, q 45, q 568, q 1099, q 1160, q 1234. Commission'')

Melba, Dame Nellie - Lilydale Historic Museum, 254. Mobil Oil Australia Ltd - Altona: chemical complex agreement, q 669; refinery upgrade, q 899. Melbourne Cricket Ground - Great Southern Stand, 769. Motor Car Traders Guarantee Fund, 1227, 1228.

Melbourne Water - Accounts, 625. Securitisation of Motor Vehicles (See "Roads Corporation'') trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. (See also "Corporatisation'') Motorcycles - Report on safety, 153.

Mental Health (See "Health - Mental Health'') Mount Buffalo Chalet, q 487. Mental Health Act - Amendments, q 942. Mount Hotham -Chalet site, 143. Snow clearing on alpine roads, 830, 833. Mental Health Review Board - Appointment, q 150. Multiculturalism (See "Ethnic Affairs, Office of',) Midway Pty Lld - Woodchipping, 99, 103. Municipalities - Bairnsdale - Boundaries, q 265. Mier, Hon. B. W. (Waverley) Broadmeadows - Fawkner planning scheme Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1069. amendment, 673. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 588. Camberwell - Administration, q 948. Heritage Rivers Bill, 615, 621. Coburg - Fawkner planning scheme amendment, Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) 673. Bill, 1220. Diamond Valley - Planning scheme amendments Points of order -Offensive remarks, 1220. Nos U7 and RL141, 140, 144, 1006. Public transport, 768. Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 450. Eltham - Public transport, 768. Finance - Road funding, q 481, q 835, q 1106. Migrant Skills and Qualifications Board - Report, Accounting standards, 771,774. General purpose 1170. grants, 889, 894, 1226, 1228. Rating of Loy Yang B power station, q 1100, q 1102. Migrants (See "Ethnic Affairs, Office of) Geelong - Casino proposal, q 1166. General- Authority, 11. Status of councillors, 28, 34. Public access to swimming holes, 309, 315. Tree Miles, Hon. J. G. (Templestowe) planting, 309, 314. Yarra Plenty Regional Library Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1071. Service, 714. Local Government Ethnic Affairs Ministerial Advisory Council, q 731. Regional Education (Further Amendment) Bill, 1089, 1090. trade measurement authorities, q 783. Proposed National Tennis Centre (Amendment) Bill, 658. superannuation levy, q 1429. Planning and Housing - Fawkner planning scheme Glenelg - Union demarcation dispute, 98, 103. amendment, 678. Proposed Park Street, Carlton, Grenville - Ballarat-Skipton railway reserve, 1092, development, q 1235. 1095. Racing (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, Kei/or - Annexation poll, q 10. 1412. Leigh - General purpose grants, 1226, 1228. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1501. MOl - WorkCare claim, 28, 34. Universities - Places, 179. Otway - Logging, 1004, 1007. Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1501. Pakenham - Cemetery land, 250, 258, 624, 626, 768, 774. Preston - Fawkner planning scheme amendment, Mineral Resources

N Port Phillip Bay - Artificial reef, 143, 144. Portland Smelter Unit Trust - Proposed sale of National Food Authority - Testing of imported food Portland smelter, q 839. products, q 669. Ports - Nursing Homes (See" Aged Services") General - Mooring fees, q 435. o Melbourne - Bayside project, q 1, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, q 39, q 41, q 668. Russian contract, q 107, q 109. Artificial reef in bay, 143, 144. East Swanson Dock, Obstetric and Paediatric Mortality and Morbidity, q 434, q 436, q 483, 718, 719, q 1162. HMVS Consultative Council on - Report, 576. Cerberus, 477, 478. Station Pier, q 668. Docklands Authority land, 771, 773. Gem Pier, Williamstown, Optus Communications, q 481. 892,893, q 947. World Trade Centre, q 1233. Outer Eastern Group Training Ltd, 476. Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - p Destruction of records, 829, 832.

Parks- President, The (Hon. A. J. Hunt) General - Alpine Advisory Committee, q 47. Rulings and Statements - Kangaroos in Chiltern Regional Park, 193, 198. Adjournment Debate - Remarks: controversial, 29; Training for friends groups, 197, 198. Mountain offensive, 29. Scope, 196,249. Sub judice rule, 250. grazing licences, q 900, q 903. Access for disabled, q 901. Auditor-General- Reports: fire protection, 441; Ministerial portfolios, 733; Bayside project, 1435. National- Grampians (Gariwerd): Zumstein Park camping grounds, 310, 314. Bank Integration Bill, 1508. Bayside Project, 1435. Parliament - Public Gallery protocol, 49. Televising of Bills - Absolute majorities, 26, 702, 760, 967, 1281, proceedings, 52, 1436. Refonn, 96. Alleged breach of 1340, 1357, 1358, 1360, 1362, 1399. privilege, 209. Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill - Declared private, 1055. Dissent recorded, 1056. Parliament House -Smoking policy, 271,1151,1506. Debate - Selective quoting: Standing Order No. 207, Honorary chaplains, 490. Report on completion of, 55. Remarks: offensive, 65, 270, 455, 1468; 1107. relevancy, 1466, 1467, 1470, 1471, 1472. Must be Parliament of Victoria Committee - Reports: Budget directed through Chair, 75. Reflection on decision process, 13,441; third progress, 1169. Appointment of House, 90. Seconders of motions, 455. Reference of subcommittee, 754. to debates in same session, 462. Sub judice rule, 1057, 1467. On tabling of reports, 1108. Pensioners (See "Aged Services" and "Senior Citizens'') Allegations, 1468, 1469, 1471. Imputations, 1469. Distinguished Visitors, 732, 1366. Personal Explanations - By Mr Theophanous, 153, Government Appointments Committee - Second 575. By Mrs Lyster, 208,1169. By Ms Kokocinski, 949. interim report, 209. Alleged breach of privilege, 209. Petitions - State schools, 11. Local government, 11. Monash Medical Centre, 52. South Eastern Arterial, Joint Sittings of Parliament - Deakin University, 209. Human embryos, 440, 1016, 1435. Victoria Park Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and Swinburne University of Technology, 1065. agreement, 576. Community health centres, 786, 906. Latrobe region health services, 841. Companion Legislative Council- Housekeeper, 1505. Animals Bill, 905, 949. Registration of cats, 1169. Loy Yang B Bill - Dissent recorded, 1389. Reference to Standing Orders Committee, 1451. Melbourne Water Corporation Bill - Dissent recorded, 1458. Planning and Housing - Parliament - Public Gallery protocol, 49. Televising Housing - Housing Guarantee Fund claims, q 437. of proceedings, 52, 1436. Alleged breach of Government home finance schemes, 735, 870. privilege, 209. Honorary chaplains, 490. Proposed Park Street, Carlton, development, Questions on Notice - Answers, 118, 270. q 1235. Questions without Notice - Debating, 6, 43, 46, 482, Planning - Planning scheme amendments: Nos L27 666, 723, 945, 1236, 1326. Seeking opinion, 7. and RL141 in Diamond Valley, 140, 144, 1006; Interjections, 8,149,489, 1236. Scope, 42, 46, 724. Fawkner, 673. Proposed development at Mont Imputations and allegations, 42. Conduct of Park, q 152. members, 45. Ministerial statement, 47, 725, 944. Relevancy of answers, 110. Redirection, 111. Point Hicks Lighthouse, q 835. Offensive remarks, 726. Audibility, 728. Pejorative tenn, 1104. Reflection on Auditor-General, 1159, Police (See "Victoria Police'') 1160. Elaboration, 1329. Reports - Presentation, 11,22,51. (20) INDEX

Senate - Vacancies, 1427. Lang-Koop school site, 479; Ballarat-Skipton railway reserve, 1095. Dandenong Ranges: picnic areas, 36; land purchase program, 144; Prices - Electricity, q 43, q 111. Alcohol, 831, 834. AFL conservation, 436. Jobs: council on fibre processing match admission, 1092, 1095. Motor car trader and sustainable development, q 44; funding by licence fees, 1227, 1228. Gas, q 1432. Priority Victoria, q 266, q 839, 1007, 1154. Alpine Advisory Committee, q 47. Woodchipping by Priority Victoria - A statement on jobs, 192, q 1231, Midway Pty Ltd, 103. Mount Disappointment q 1325. Funding: Department of Conservation and State Forest, 144. Recycling and waste Environment, q 266, q 839, 1005, 1007, 1152, 1154; management, q 150, q 1430. Coode Island report, Ministry of Ethnic, Municipal and Community 314. Four-wheel drive vehicles: levy, 479; Tread Affairs, q 437. Lightly program, q 487. Resource Assessment Commission report, q 484. Environment Privatisation (See "Corporatisation") handbook for small industries, q 489. Greenhouse gas emissions, q 781. Cranbourne Botanic Public Bodies Review Committee - Membership, Gardens, 832. Raid on dingo fann, q 837. 118. Report on corporatisation of SEC, 1331. Mountain grazing licences, q 900, q 904. Toorour Forest Lodge, 1007. Flora and fauna studies, Public Record Office - Staff, 717,719. q 1012. Blue-green algae, q 1014. Earth Summit, q 1103. q 1166. Contaminated sites, Public Records Act, 829, 832. Snowso/e, q 1327.(See also "Animals" and ''Birds'') Public Transport - Daratech Pty Ltd - Report, 441. Bus Services -School: Maroona Primary, 192, 197; Defence Service Homes - Merbein, 258. Templestowe Technical, 248; Ed ucation, Post-Secondary - T AFE admission Craigieburn-Broadmeadows-Pascoe Vale, 251. procedures, 35. Tertiary places, 187. Lower Templestowe, 477, 479. Egg Industry (Amendment) Bill, 1157, 1180. Corporation - Surplus land, 1017. McNiece Media Employment - Jobs: council on fibre processing and Services, 1225, 1229. sustainable development, q 44; funding by General-Services in Diamond Valley and-Eltham, Priority Victoria, q 266, q 839, 1007, 1154. 768. W-class trams, 830,834. Student concession Environment Protection Authority - Contaminated cards, 890. sites, q 1327. Rail Services - Melbourne-Adelaide, q 10. Subway at Environment Protection (Fees) Regulations 1991,490. Castlemaine, 142. Crossings at Church and Bay Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, streets, Brighton, 197,199. 1123,1124,1125,1126,1128,1129,1130,1131,1133, 1134, 1136, 1137, 1138, 1139, 1140, 1141, 1142, 1143, Psychiatric Services, Office of - Resignation of 1144,1145,1146,1147,1148,1149,1150. director, q 206. (See also "Health" - Mental Health") Fair Trading (Environmental Labelling) Bill, 1157, 1179. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 201, 213. Pullen, Hon. B. T. (Melbourne) (Minister for Food and Agriculture, Department of - Federal land Conservation and Environment) management kit, 1154. Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 595, 596, Forest Interpretative Centre, Toolangi, 258. 597,599,600. Heritage Rivers Bill, 296,617,618,619,620,621,622, Agricultural Industry Development (Tomato 623,624. Processing) Bill, 1489, 1514. Joint Sittings of Parliament - Deakin University, Altona Chemical Complex - Agreement, q 669. Melbourne Institute of Technology and Swinburne Animals - Feral, 720, q 783, q 946. Raid on dingo University of Technology, 939. fann, q 837. Flora and fauna studies, q 1012. Law Courts - Skip ton, 895. Auditor-General- Report on fire protection, q 438. Melbourne Lands and Market Sites (Amendment) Banyule Homestead, 626. BiII,958. Beaumaris Heathland, 103. Melbourne Market and Park Lands Bill, 957. Birds - Freckled duck, q 486. Migratory wader, Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill, 777, 792, 1198, q 571. 1199, 1200, 1507. Building Control (Further Amendment) Bill, 1157, Melbourne Water Corporation Bill, 1099,1171. 1178. Midway Pty Ltd - Woodchipping, 103. Companion Animals Bill, 876, 950. Migrant Skills and Qualifications Board - Report, Conservation and Environment - 1170. Department - Commercial forests project, q 785, 894. Monash University (Phannacy College) Bill, 520, 577. Appointments, 1007. Restructure, q 1015. Mount Buffalo Chalet, q 487. Communications system, q 1232, q 1235, q 1325, Mount Hotham -Chalet site, 144. q 1326. Advertising campaign, q 1427, q 1429. National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1109, 1319, 1320, Oyster cultivation in Swan Bay Marine General - 1321,1322. and Wildlife Reserves, q 9. Sale of spray carts, 34. Crown land: rentals, 35, 894; sale, q 267,479; Otway, Shire of - Logging, 1007. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (21)

Parks - R General- Alpine Advisory Committee, q 47. Training for friends groups, 198. Access for Recycling (See "Conservation and Environment'') disabled, q 901. National - Grampians (Gariwerd): Zumstein Park Reports - Presentation, 11,22,51. camping grounds, 314. Mountain grazing licences, q 900, q 904. Residential Tenancies Tribunal - Delays, q 265. Appointments, 153, q 440, q 1166. Prosecutions, Planning and Housing - Planning scheme q 482. (See also "Tenancies'') amendments: Nos L27 and RL141 in Diamond Valley, 144; Fawkner, 681. Government home Resource Assessment Commission - Report on forest finance schemes, 870. Proposed Park Street, and timber inquiry, q 484. Carlton, development, q 1235. Point Hicks Lighthouse, q 835. Rio de Janeiro - Earth Summit, q 781, q 1103. Points of Order - Amendments, 1122. River Murray - Blue-green algae, q 1014. Port Phillip Bay - Artificial reef, 144. Priority Victoria - Job funding, q 266, q 839, 1007, Roads Corporation - 1154. General- VIC ROADS tender, 98, 103. Report on Questions on Notice - Answers, 117, q 1169. motorcycle safety~ 153. Four-wheel drive vehicles: Resource Assessment Commission - Report, q 484. levy, 475, 479; Tread Lightly program, q 487. Road Melbourne Institute of Technology Bill, 1009, 1086, funding, q 481, q 835, q 1106. 1281,1282. Roads and Highways - South Eastern Arterial, 209. RSPCA - Raid on dingo farm, q 837. Inner-city clearway provisions, 718, 722. Salinity - Saltwatch program, q 631. Goulburn Intersections: Henderson and Ferntree Gully Valley drylands, q 1233. roads, 768; Chesterville Road and Bernard Street, Cheltenham North, 1225. Snow clearing on alpine, Sewerage - In Mildura area, 36. 830,833. Mansfield-Woods Point Road, 1090, 1095. State Conservation Strategy - Report, 1170. St Kilda Baths - Redevelopment, q 946. RSPCA - Raid on dingo farm, q 837. Sunraysia Water Board - Sewerage facilities, 36. Swan Bay Marine and Wildlife Reserves - Oyster Rural Enterprise Victoria Scheme, q 48, q 206, q 486, cultivation, q 9. q575. Swinburne University of Technology Bill, 1003, 1357, Rural Water Commission - Funding, 1005. 1358. Timber Industry - Woodchipping by Midway Pty Russia - Secret Treasures exhibition, 625, 626. Port of Ltd, 103. Classification of saw logs, q 115. Logging Melbourne Authority contract, q 107, q 109. in Shire of Otway, 1007. Toolangi Forest Interpretative Centre, 258. s Toorour Forest Lodge, 1007. Universities - Places, 187. Deakin University, Salinity - Saltwatch program, q 630. Goulburn Valley Swinburne University of Technology and drylands, q 1233. Melbourne Institute of Technology councils, 939. Urban Land Authority - Proposed housing Sandridge City Development Company Pty Ltd - development at Mont Park, q 152. Land Bayside project, q 1, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, q 39, q 41. purchases, 1025. School Education - Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 107, 121,583. Department - Brighton Bay Secondary College site, Victree Timber Products Pty Ltd, 1007. 311. Vocational Education and Training (Amendment) General- Life education centres, 33. VCE: library Bill, 687. resources, 140, 714. Bus services: Maroona Primary School, 192, 197. Templestowe Technical Water (Elections) Bill, 879. School, 248; Craigieburn-Broadmeadows-Pascoe Water (Rural Water Corporation) Bill, 1079, 1173, Vale, 251. Auditor-General's report on integrated 1423, 1424, 1425, 1426. education for children with disabilities, 786. Wildlife Regulations 1992, 1228. School Dental Service, q 942. Wonnangatta Station -Grass slashing, q 839. Schools, Post-Primary - Budget, 11. Correspondence, World Environment Week, q 1103. 96. Yarra-Plenty region: VCE library resources grant, 714. Ararat Secondary College, 773. Q Schools, Primary - Valkstone, 718. Moorabbin West, 1003. Teachers - Transfers, 97. Questions on Notice - Answers, 10, SO, 115, 152,208, 270,575,785,949, 1167. (See also "Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training'') (22) INDEX

Secret Treasures of Russia, 625, 626. Urban Land Authority - Proposed housing development at Mont Park, q 152. Select Committee on Government Appointments (See Victoria Police - Traffic fines for pensioners and "Government Appointments, Select Committee on") jobless, 194. Senate - Vacancies, 1427. Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1489. Senior Citizens - Seniors Card, q 115. Senior Citizens Yarra Plenty Regional Library Service, 714. Week, q 151. (See also"Aged Services")

Sewerage - In Mildura area, 32, 36. Small Business, Department of - Banking Industry Working Group, q 487, q 902. Women's seminar, q 672. Development strategy, q 943. Goods and Sgro, Hon. G. A. (Melbourne North) services tax, q 1013. Telecom awards, q 1165.

Ambulance Services - In north-eastern Small Business Development Corporation - Forum, Victoria, q 838. q 46. Green Directory, q 152. Early retired employees Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1076. program, q 207. Tourism, q 572. Business training Consumer Affairs - Prepaid funerals, q 269. seminars for apprentices, q 785. Unifonn credit legislation, q 730. Ethnic Affairs, Office of - Services: interpreting. Small Claims Tribunal - Delays, q 265. q 440; translation, q 634. Health education Appointments, 153, q 440 q 1166. Scope, q 633. assistance, q 904. The Jews and Italians of Carlton Administration, q 1329. exhibition, q 1167. Funding for community-based organisations, q 1433. Manufacturing and Industry Development - Smith, Hon. K. M. (South Eastern) Telecommunications industry, q 569. Bayside Project, q 4, q 8, q 41, q 668. Planning - Fawkner planning scheme amendment, Cemeteries - Land at Pakenham, 250, 624. 679. Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1077. Senior Citizens Week, q 151. Companion Animals Bill, 906. Small Business - Goods and services tax, q 1013. Cranbourne Botanic Gardens, 828. Docklands Authority - Port of Melbourne Authority land,771. Skeggs, Hon. B. A. E (Templestowe) Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 937. Aged Services - Private nursing homes, 281, q 904. Health - Human embryos, 440. Cemetery land at Banyule Homestead, 624, 1227. Pakenham, 250, 624. Building Societies - Interest rates, 1094. Hospitals -Southern Peninsula, 29, 101. Children's Protection Society - Alys Key Family Housing - Government home finance schemes, 748. Care Program, 97. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1470. Classification of Films and Publications Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), 1085. Bill,l220. Coode Island - Landy report, 313. McNiece Media Services -Consultancies, 1225. Corporatisation - Government trading National Parks (Wilderness) Bill, 1308. enterprises, q 205, q 631. Pakenham, Shire of - Cemetery land, 250, 624. Diamond Valley, Shire of - Planning scheme amendments Nos L27 and RL141, 140, 1006. Petitions - State schools, 11. Human embryos, 440. Drugs - Steroids, 33. Points of Order - Definition of "small business", 46. Relevancy: of answer, 109; of remarks, 1470. Sub Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 205, judice rule, 249. Offensive remarks, 520, 1468. q 631. Debating question, 666,903. Tedious repetition, Heritage Rivers Bill, 607. 1224. Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Port of Melbourne Authority - Bayside project, q 4, Bill,1219. q 8, q 41, q 668. Russian contract, q 109. East Library Services - For VCE students, 714. Swanson Dock, 718. Gem Pier, Williamstown, 892. Planning - Proposed development at Mont Park, Public Transport - McNiece Media Services, 1225. q 152. Questions on Notice - Answers, 115. Public Transport - In Lower Templestowe, 477. In School Education - Budget, 11. shires of Diamond Valley and Eltham, 768. St Kilda, City of - Baths redevelopment, q 946. Racing (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, Tenancies - Dispute at Mount Martha, 195. 1413. Unions - Grants, 490, 518. School Education - Bus services: Templestowe Technical School, 248. Urban Land Authority - Land purchases, 1023. Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 1489. Victoria Police - Uncollected parking fines, q 1330. Smoking - By youth, q 1012. LEGISLA TIYE COUNCIL (23)

Smoking - Parliament House policy, 271, 1151. By Swinburne University of Technology Bill, 1344. youth, q 1012. Universities - Places, 154, 190. "Snowsafe", q 1166.

Social Development Committee - Reports: mental Strategic Research Foundation - Chainnan, q 263. disturbance and community safety, 51, 634; Sunraysia Water Board - Sewerage facilities, 32, 36. motorcycle safety, 153. Superannuation - Proposed levy on municipalities, Southern Consumer and Financial Advocacy Service, q 1429. 1227. Supreme Court Judges - Report, 786. Southern Electric, q 900. (See also "State Electricity Commission'') Swan Bay Marine and Wildlife Reserves - Oyster cultivation, q 8. Standing Orders Committee - Petitions, 1451.

State Conservation Strategy - Report, 1170. T

State Electricity Commission - Morwell overburden, Taxation - q 43, q 111, q 483. Corporatisation, q 43, q 111, q 145, q 205, q 208, q 574, q 627, q 629, q 630, q 631, q 665, FinanciJJl Institutions Duty - On roll-over tenn q 666, q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 732, q 780, q 1158, depOSits, 141, 144. 1331, q 1428. National electricity grid, q 108. Private General - Effects of goods and services tax on small hydro-electric scheme, Koetong, 192, 198. Sale of business, q 1013. Low Yang B power station, 193, 197, q 201, q 203, umd Tax -Increases, 892. q 206, 252, 256, q 261, q 263, q 437, q 485, q 729, Gas and Fuel q 778, q 900, q 1100, q 1102. Regional power Public Authority Dividend - Corporation, q 667, q 731. conference, 828, 831. Securitisation of trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. Stockpiling, q 945. Undersea electricity cable link, q 1327. (See also "Mission Energy" and "Southern Electric',) Tehan, Hon. M. T. (Central Highlands) Aged Services - Private nursing homes, 271, 291. Statutory Rules - Environment Protection (Fees) Ambulance Services - Review, 1153. Regulations 1991, 490. Health (Radiation Safety) Regulations 1984,715,720, q 725. Mineral Resources Australian Hospitals Association - Health Ministers (Health and Safety) Regulations 1991, 1017. Wildlife conference, 253. Regulations 1992, 1225, 1228. Cemeteries - Proposed burials at Lake Corangamite, q 669. St Kilda Baths - Redevelopment, q 946. Chiropractors and Osteopaths (Amendment) Bill (No. 2),214,222. Health - Storey, Hon. Haddon (East Yarra) Department - Head lice programs, 771. Prosecution, Conservation and Environment, Department of - q 784. Advertising program, q 1429. Diseases - Breast cancer screening program, 31. Corporatisation -Government trading enterprises, Pediculosis, 771. q 208, q 666, q 729, q 1158. General - Medicare, q 45, q 1099. Ministers Finance - Debt-equity swap, q 779. conference, 253. Victorian Health System Review, Gas and Fuel Corporation -Corporatisation, q 208, 848. Insurance, q 1231. q 666, q 729, q 1158. Mental Health - Resignation of Director of Office of Hospitals - Roster systems in psychiatric, q 570. Psychiatric Services, q 206. Psychiatric hospitals: clinical audit, q 268, q 567, q 568, q 569, q 573; Libraries (Amendment) Bill, 531, 585. mainstreaming programs, 309, 888, q 897, q 942; Melbourne University (VCAH) Bill, 908, 1198, 1199, audit of standards of treatment and care, 733. 1507. Fire and Emergency Services (Miscellaneous Mission Energy, q 261. Amendments) Bill, 816. Monash University (Phannacy College) Bill, 703. Health (Radiation Safety) Regulations, 715. Parliamentary Committees (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), Hospitals - Women's, 31. Yarra Junction District, 1240. 100. Psychiatric: standards of treatment and care, Points of Order - Selective quoting, 55. Reference to 733. Proposed Whittlesea, 830. Loan Council debates in same session, 462. Tabling of report, guidelines, q 836. Proposed Epping, q 1009, 1107. Relevancy of remarks, 1466, 1467. q 1165. Bush nursing, 1030. Allegations, 1468. Imputations, 1469. Hospitals and Charities (Extension) Bill, 530. Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Bill, 1277. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1485. State Electricity Commission - Corporatisation, Infertility (Medical Procedures) Act - Register, 1092. q 208, q 666. q 729, q 1158. Sale of Loy Yang B Medical Treatment (Agents) Bill, 299, 1114, 1115, power station, q 261. 1116,1117,1118,1119. (24) INDEX

Mental Health Act - Amendments, q 942. Financial Institutions (Victoria) Bill, 1099. Mental Health Review Board - Appointment, q 150. Gambling - Gaming machines, q 7, 575. Ministerial Statements - Victorian Health System Government Commercial and Trading Enterprises Review, 848. Committee, q 145. Melbourne Hospital (Redevelopment) Bill, 1393. Government Departments and Unions -Grants, 503. Instrumentalities --Corporatisation, q 43, q 145, Victorian Ambulance Services Review, 1153. q 574, q 627, q 631, q 665, q 666, q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 780, q 1158, q 1428. Victorian Health System Review, 848. Government Employee Housing Women - Breast cancer screening program, 31. Authority - Eviction of Colac family, q 207, 722. Grain Elevators (Amendment) Bill, 529, 581. Telecom Australia - Small business awards, q 1165. House Contracts Guarantee Act - Scope, 770. (See also" A OTC " and ''Manufacturing and Industry Housing Guarantee Fund - Claims by Department Development'') of Planning and Housing, q 437. Registration of builders, q 481. Tenancies - Dispute at Mount Martha, 195, 199. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 897, Eviction of Colac family, q 207. Commercial, 892. 955. (See also "Residential Tenancies Tribunal',) Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Textile, Clothing and Footwear Industry (See Bill, 897, 954. ''Manufacturing and Industry Development") Liquor Control (Further Amendment) Bill, 576, 686. Liquor Licensing Commission - Gaming machines, q 7, 575. Restaurant liquor licences, q 110. Theophanous, Hon. T. C. Oika ]ika) (Minister for Appointments, q 111, q 114, q 147. Alcohol abuse, Consumer Affairs) q 1434. McNiece Media Services - Consultancies, 1228. Accident Compensation Commission - WorkCare reports, 12, 1170. Medical Panels, Convenor of - WorkCare reports, Accident Compensation (Further Amendment) Bill, 12,1170. 1157,1181,1361,1362. Ministry, The - Ministerial responsibility: Minister Assisting the Minister for Manufacturing and Advertising - Alcohol, 834. Industry Development on Corporatisation, q 145. Alcohol- Prices, 834. Abuse, q 1434. National Tennis Centre (Amendment) Bill, 192,211, Animals - Dobennan dogs, 479. 659. Apprentices - Business training seminars, q 785. Personal Explanations - Credit Tribunal, 153. Audit (Amendment) Bill (No. 2),433,661. Gaming machines, 575. Auditor-General - Role, q 1099. Planning and Housing, Department of - Housing Australian Football League - Great Southern Stand, Guarantee Fund claims, q 437. 770. Match admission prices, 1095. Points of Order - Questions: must not seek opinion, Banks - Credit card transaction fees, q 1104. 7; debating, 723; scope, 724, 944. Scope of Banyule Homestead, 1228. adjournment debate, 196. Tabling of reports, 1107. Proof of allegations, 1471. Remarks: relevancy, BLF Custodian - Reports: Nos 17 and 18, 12; No. 19, 1471, 1472; offensive, 1476. 1170. Prices - Electricity, q 43. Alcohol, 834. AFL match Collingwood Football Club - Membership, q 7, 575. admission, 1095. Motor car trader licence fees, Consumer Affairs - 1228. General- Vehicle impact standards, 106. Labelling of Public Account (Further Amendment) Bill (No. 2), toys, 199. Prepaid funerals, q 269. Increases in 433,659. business fees, q 633. Regional trade measurement Public Transport - Railway crossings at Church and authorities, q 783. Alcohol advertising, 834. Bay streets, Brighton, 199. McNiece Media Washing machine repair companies, q 841. Weight Services, 1228. loss centres, q 1235. Bunk beds, q 1331. Questions on Notice - Answers, 116. Ministry - "relephone infonnation service, q 439, q 1233. Adjudication branch, q 840. Use of car by Racing (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill, director, q 902. Consumer tribunals, q 1013. 1157,1182, 1415. Corporatisation - Government trading enterprises, Residential Tenancies Tribunal - Delays, q 265. q 43, q 145, q 574, q 627, q 631, q 632, q 665, q 666, Appointments, q 440, q 1166. Prosecutions, q 482. q 670, q 723, q 727, q 729, q 780, q 1158, q 1428. Roads Corporation - Snow clearing on alpine roads, Credit - Unifonn legislation, q 730. 833. Credit Tribunal - Appointment of chairperson, Road Safety (Licence Cancellation) Bill, 762, 791, 972. q 113, q 114,153. Small Business, Department of - Women's seminar, Education (Out of School Education) Bill, 127, 128, 672. Banking Industry Working Group, q 487, 129. q 902. Development strategy, q 943. Goods and services tax, q 1013. Telecom awards, q 1165. Entertainment and Modelling Industry Agents Bill, 1270. Small Business Development Corporation - Forum, q 46. Green Directory, q 152. Early retired LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (25)

employees program, q 207. Tourism, q 572. Melbourne - Council, 1050. Business training seminars for apprentices, q 785. Royal Melbourne Institute o/Technology -Council, Small Claims Tribunal - Delays, q 265. 939, 1065, 1097. Appointments, q 440, q 1166. Scope, q 633. Swinburne University 0/ Technology - Council, 939, Administration, q 1329. 1065,1097. State Electricity Commission - Morwell overburden, q 43. (See also "Government Departments and Urban Land Authority - Proposed housing lnstrumentalities") development at Mont Park, q 152. Land purchases, Telecom Australia - Small business awards, q 1165. 876,1017. Tenancies - Dispute at Mount Martha, 199. Eviction of Colac family, q 207. (See also "Residential v Tenancies Tribunal',) Tourism - Small Business Development Van Buren, Hon. C. F. (Eumemmering) Corporation, q 572. Trading Hours - Sunday, q 150. Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 134. Unions - Grants, 497. Cemeteries - Land at Pakellham, 768. Victorian Accident Rehabilitation Environment Protection (Resource Recovery) Bill, 974. Council- WorkCare reports, 12. Ethnic Affairs - Local Government Ethnic Affairs Victorian Supply Service Bill, 474, 663. Ministerial Advisory Council, q 731. Vistel Ltd - Report, 12. Fisheries (Further Amendment) Bill, 590. Women -Small business forum, 672. Hospitals -Capital works, q 1011. Financial performance of public, q 1432. WorkCare - Reports, 12,441,1170. Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1473. WorkCare Appeals Board - Reports, 12, 1170. Liquor Licensing Commission"""; Restaurant licences, q 110. Timber Industry -(See "Food and Agriculture, Loy Yang B Bill, 1374. Department of - Timber'') Manufacturing and Industry Development - Telecommunications industry Toolangi Forest Interpretative Centre, 251, 258. deregulation, q 481. Energy efficiency strategy, q 1163. Food processing, q 1325. Toorour Forest Lodge, 1004, 1007. Monash University (Pharmacy College) Bill, 704. Tourism - Small Business Development Corporation, National Parks - Access for disabled, q 901. q 572. Aurora Gold Mine, 1003, 1006. Pakenham, Shire of - Cemetery land, 768. Parliament House - Smoking policy, 1506. Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd - Union Rural Enterprise Victoria Scheme, q 48. bans, q 1010. Tourism - Small Business Development Trading Hours - Sunday, q 150. Corporation, q 572. Unions - Grants, 510. u Western Port Development Council - Activities, q 784. Unions - Youth - Homelessness, q 267. General - Demarcation dispute in Shire of Glenelg, 98, 103. Grants, 490. Employment of officials in Varty, Hon. Rosemary (Nunawading) government departments and instrumentalities, q 629. Dental health services employees stop-work Aboriginal Land (Manatunga Land) Bill, 757, 760, 761. meeting, q 781. Dispute in nursing homes, q 1100. Aged Services - Private nursing homes, 277. Electrical Trades Union - Bans at Toyota plant, q 1010. Asset Collateralized Equity Lld, q 1430. Health and Community Services Union - Conservation and Environment - Alpine Advisory Mainstreaming programs, q 942. Committee, q 47. Mountain grazing licences, q 900. State Public Services Federation Victoria - Dandenong Ranges - Picnic areas, 34. Land Mainstreaming programs, q 942. purchase program, 143. Victorian Secondary Teachers Association - Economic and Budget Review Agreement, 11. Committee - Estimates Subcommittee reports: 1991-92 Budget Estimates, 13; World Congress United Nations Conference on Environment and Centre, 1107, 1242. Development, Rio de Janeiro, q 781, q 1103. Gas and Fuel Corporation - Public authority dividend, q 731. Securitisation of trade Universities - receivables, q 941, q 1430. Asset Collateralized Deakin - Council, 939, 1065, 1097. Equity Ltd, q 1430. General- Places, 154. Illicit drugs, 194, 198. Medical Hospitals - Clinical audit of psychiatric, q 573. Bush student numbers, 195, 198. nursing, 645. Hospitals and Charities (ExtenSion) Bill, 529. (26) INDEX

Local Government (Elections) Bill, 230, 237, 240, 241, Western Port Development Council - Activities, 243,246. q 784. Melba, Dame Nellie - Lilydale Historic Museum, 254. Melbourne Water - Securitisation of trade White, Hon. D. R. (Doutta Galla) (Minister for receivables, q 941, q 1430. Manufacturing and Industry Development, and Minister responsible for Ports) National Parks - Training for friends groups, 197. Mountain grazing licences, q 900. Abattoirs - Camperdown dispute, 256. Outer Eastern Group Training Ltd, 476. Administrative Arrangements - Orders: Nos 98 to Points of Order - Length of answer, 47. Scope of 102, 12; Nos 103 and 104,209; Nos 105 to 108,906. adjournment debate, 249. Inaudible question, n8. Air Services - Airlines merger, q 1162. Sherbrooke, Shire of - Annexation proposal, 98. Albury-Wodonga Development Corporation - State Electricity Commission - Securitisation of Ministerial Council meeting dates, 773. trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. Appointments, q 1011. Swinburne University of Technology Bill, 1349. Alpine Resorts (Amendment) Bill, 762, 788, 1198. Universities - Places, 168. Altona - Mobil refinery upgrade, q 900. World Congress Centre, 1107, 1242. Appropriation Ouly to October) Bill, 777, 788, 1514. Asset Collateralized Equity Ltd, q 1430, q 1431. Auditor-General - Role, q 898, q 941, q 1009, q 1158. VIC ROADS (See "Roads Corporation'') Report on Bayside project, 1446. Australian Cement Ltd, Geelong - Gas tariffs, Victoria Grants Commission - Allocations, 889, 894, q 1432. 1226,1228. Australian Defence Industries - Benalla project, q 5. Victoria Police - Australian Paper Manufacturers - Pulp and paper Crime - Bureau of crime statistics, 520, 734. mill, Maryvale, q 433. Bank Integration Bill, 1489, 1508. General - Traffic fines: for pensioners and jobless, 194,198; uncollected, q 1330. Banking (Premium Accounts) Bill, 1489, 1509. Victorian Ambulance Services Review, 1153, 1155. Bayside Project, q 1, q 2, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, q 39, q 41, q 668,1446. Victorian Equity Trust - Debt management, q 145, Boating - Mooring fees, q 435. q 147. Business of the House - Sittings, 777. Sessional Victorian Family and Children's Services Council­ Orders, 1157. Report, 12. Collingwood Land (Victoria Park) Bill, 1056. Coode Island - Landy report, q 262, 313. Victorian Government Major Projects Unit (See Corporatisation - Government trading enterprises, "Major Projects Unit'') q 111, q 205, q 208, q 630, q 631, q 632. Victorian Health System Review, 841, 843,1043, Dangerous Goods - Landy report on Coode Island, q 1328. q 262, 313. Docklands Authority - Port of Melbourne Authority Victorian Accident Rehabilitation Council - land, 773. WorkCare reports, 12. Economic and Budget Review Committee - Membership, 118. Victree Timber Products Pty Ltd, 1004, 1007. Employment (See Priority Victoria) Vistel Ltd - Report, 12. Sale, 118, q 434. Extractive Industries -Chewton quarry licence, 940. Finance - Debt: management, q 4, q 7, q 145, q 147; w equity swap, q 778, q 779. Gambling - Gaming machines, q 1010. Casino for Walker, Hon. E. H. (Melbourne) Geelong, q 1166. Gas and Fuel Corporation - Corporatisation, q 111, Animals - Feral, q 946. q 205, q 208, q 630. q 631. Public authority Parliament House - Smoking policy, 1506. dividend, q 667, q 731. Comments of chairman, Salinity - Saltwatch program, q 630. q 777. Securitisation of trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. Tariffs, q 1432. Golden Aluminium, Bendigo, 257. Waste Management (See "Conservation and Government, The - AdvertiSing programs, q 1328. Environment" and "Dangerous Goods") Government Appointments Committee - Minister Water (See ''Melbourne Water'') for Transport, 92. Alleged breach of privilege, 209. Second interim report, 209. Government Departments and Instrumentalities - Debt management, q 4, q 7, q 145, q 147. Corporatisation, q 111, q 205, q 208, q 630, q 631. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (27)

Debt-equity swap, q 778, q 779. Destruction of Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - records, 832. Destruction of records, 832. HMVS Cerberus, 478. Prices - Electricity, q 111. Gas, q 1432. Hospital Benefits Association Ltd - Merger, 893. Priority Victoria - A statement on jobs, 192, q 1231, Industrial Relations (Enterprise Bargaining) Bill, 1465. q 1325. Industrial Relations (Superannuation Enforcement) Public Bodies Review Committee - Membership, Bill,1275. 118. Latrobe Regional Commission - Report, q 109. Public Transport - Melbourne-Adelaide rail service, Legislative Council - Housekeeper, 1504. q 10. Liberal Party - Alleged activities of president, 256. Questions on Notice - Answers, 10, SO, 117, 152,208, 575,785,949,1168. Loy Yang B Bill, 1157, 1189, 1399, 1400, 1401, 1404, State Electricity (Amendment) Bill, 23,24. 1405, 1406, 1407. State Electricity Commission - National electricity Major Projects - Bayside, q 1, q 2, q 4, q 6, q 8, q 9, grid, q 108. Morwell overburden, q 111, q 483. q 39, q 41, q 668, 1446. Corporatisation, q 111, q 205, q 208, q 630, q 631. Major Projects Unit - Report, SO. Sale of Lay Yang B power station, 197, q 201, Manufacturing and Industry Development­ q 206, q 261, q 263, q 437, q 485, q 730, q 778, q 901, Department - Fol request of mining companies, 34. q 1102. Regional power conference, 831. Appointment of deputy director-general, 257. 5ecuritisation of trade receivables, q 941, q 1430. General- Food processing, q 146, q 629, q 1325. Stockpiling, q 946. Golden Aluminium, Bendigo, 257. Landy Report State Electricity Commission (Minimum Energy on Coode Island, q 262, 313. Maryvale pulp and Efficiency Levels) Bill, 686, 754. paper mill, q 433. Telecommunications industry: Strategic Research Foundation - Chairman, q 263. deregulation, q 481; investment and employment, Superannuation (Occupational Superannuation q 569; AOTC, q 728. Exports to Asia, q 666. Textile, Standards) Bill, 1086, 1111, 1292. clothing and footwear industry, q 942, q 943, q 1428. Energy: commercial building code, q 1101; Supply (1992-93, No. 1) Bill, 723, 755, 757, 1514. efficiency strategy, q 1163. Information Taxation - Financial institutions duty on roll-over technology, q 1232. Undersea electricity' cable link, term deposits, 144. q 1327. Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd - Union Manufacturing Council of Victoria - Activities, bans, q 1010. q 836. Treasury Corporation of Victoria Bill, 1157, 1332. Melbourne Water - 5ecuritisation of trade University of Melbourne - Council, 10SO. receivables, q 941, q 1431. (See also Vermin and Noxious Weeds (Poison Baits) Bill, 531. "Corpora tisa tion") Victorian Equity Trust - Debt management, q 145, Ministerial Statements - Parliamentary reform, 96. q 147. Ministry, The - Absence of Minister, 201, 433, 723. Vistel Ltd - Sale, 118, q 434. Mission Energy, q 201, q 206, q 261, q 263. Works and Services (Ancillary Provisions, 1992-93, Mobil Oil Australia Ltd - Altona refinery upgrade, No. 1) Bill, 723, 756, 757, 1514. q 900. Mutual Community Ltd - Merger, 893. Parliament - Reform, 96. Wildlife (See "Animals", ''Birds'' and "Conservation and Environment") Parliament House - Smoking policy, lS06. Parliamentary Committees (Amendment) Bill (No. 2), Wildlife Regulations 1992, 1225, 1228. 843,1237. Points of Order - Selective quoting, 55. Alleged Witness Protection Act -' Report, SO. breach of privilege, 209. Sub judice rule, 250. Remarks: offensive, 726, 1468; relevancy, 1223, Women - Breast cancer screening program, 31, 37, 1291, 1466, 1467, 1470. Scope of question, 778. q 632. Barwon South West Women's Health Service, Reflection on Auditor-General, 1159. Imputations, 312,315. Small business forum, q 672. Industry 1469. restructuring, q 732. Port of Melbourne Authority (Amendment) Bill, 576, Wonnangatta Station - Grass slashing, q 839. 661, 797, 798, 799. Portland Smelter Unit Trust - Proposed sale of Woodchipping - By Midway Pty Ltd, 99, 103. Portland smelter, q 839. Ports - WorkCare - Reports, 12,441,1170. Claim by City of Moe,28,34. General - Mooring fees, q 435. Melbourne - Bayside project, q 1, q 2, q 4, q 6, q 8, WorkCue Appeals Board - Reports, 12,1170. q 9, q 39, q 41. Russian contract, q 107, q 109. East Swanson Dock, q 434, q 436, q 483, 719, q 1162. World Congress Centre - Report, 1107, 1242. HMVS Cerberus, 478. Docklands Authority land, 773. Gem Pier, Williamstown, 893, q 947. World World Environment Week, q 781, q 1103. Trade Centre, q 1233. (28) INDEX

World Trade Centre, q 1233.

Wright, Hon. K. I. M. (North Western) Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals Bill, 131. Defence Service Homes - Merbein, 247. Hospitals - Bush nursing, 1034. Sewerage - In Mildura area, 32.

y

Yarra Plenty Regional Library Service, 714. Youth - Security accommodation for intellectually disabled, 255. Homelessness, q 267. Accommodation, q 671. Youth Policy Development Council, q 837. Kids on the Brink program, Bendigo, 891,894. National policy, q 905. Smoking by, q 1012. Enterprise program, q 1015. Ministers council, q 1236. LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (29) QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Listed in numerical order of questions on notice answered during period covered by this index.

Ministerial portfolios and abbreviations

Conservation and Environment C&E Consumer Affairs Cons Affs Education and Training E&T Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs EM&CA Gaming Gaming Health Health Major Projects Maj Proj Manufacturing and Industry Development M&ID Ports Ports Small Business SB

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

496 Staffing and Salaries - Labour MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1521 733 Overseas Trips - Attorney-General's MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 537 Department 770 Estate Agents Guarantee Fund MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 539 925 Consultancies - Labour MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1582 952 Staffing - Labour MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 317 977 Films and Videos -Attorney-General MrSlorey Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 540 985 Films andVideos - Labour Mr Storey Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 317 991 Accident Compensation Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 318 Regulations - Labour 1000 Grants - Municipal Mr Lawson Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 319 Officers Association 1001 Grants - Victorian Mr Lawson Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 319 Trades Hall Council 1037 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (C & E) 24.3.92 423 Water Resources 1046 Opinion Polls - Treasury Mr Birrell Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 322 1053 Opinion Polls - Attorney-General Mr BirreJl Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 540 1056 Opinion Polls - Labour Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 322 1071 Rented Properties - Attorney-General MrAshman Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 540 1078 Rented Properties - Labour Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 323 1105 Motor Vehicles - Transport MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 325 1112 Motor Vehicles - Labour MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 7.4.92 541 1116 Property, Vehicles and MrCraige Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 152 Equipment - Labour 1117 Publications - Labour MrCraige Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1530 1131 Road Safety Campaigns - Mr Best Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 326 Transport 1132 Unpaid Fines - Mr Best Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 542 Attorney-General's Department 1162 Consultant - Labour Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 327 1168 Speed Cameras - Mr Skeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 327 "Away" Shots 1170 Speed Cameras - MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 14.4.92 560 Infringement Notices 1176 Publication "Fairplay" MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 327 (30) INDEX

Qn Date Page No. Subject 1tUltter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1178 Publication "Price Action" MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 7.4.92 542 1182 Unsewered Properties MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 7.4.92 543 1184 Omnimax Theatre - Funding Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 7.4.92 544 1185 Traffic in Melbourne Study MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 328 1201 Grants - Labour MrSmith Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 18.3.92 405 1202 Grants - Police and MrSmith Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 328 Emergency Services 1203 Grants - Corrections MrSmith Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 332 1208 Grants - Transport MrSmith Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1536 1211 Grants - Treasury MrSmith Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 333 1214 Grants - Premier MrSmith Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 340 1216 Grants - Finance MrSmith Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 341 1227 Hospitals and Health Mrs Tehan Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 342 Facilities - Expenditure and Completion Dates 1232 Former Ethnic Affairs MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 5.5.92 1576 Chairman - Employment and Overseas Trips 1233 Lovell Report MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 545 1236 EFT Positions - Community MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 24.3.92 423 Services 1240 Bandicoot Breeding Program Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C &: E) 18.3.92 413 1241 Prosecutions - EPA Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (then E &: T) 17.3.92 343 1242 Licence Fees and Fines - EP A Mr Birren Mr Punen (C &: E) 17.3.92 343 1246 Vic Image - Planning MrStorey Mr Punen (C &: E) 8.4.92 559 and Housing 1247 Vic Image - Sport MrStorey Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 344 and Recreation 1248 Vic Image -Conservation MrStorey Mr Pullen (C &: E) 17.3.92 345 and Environment 1249 Vic Image - Ports MrStorey Mr White (Ports) 17.3.92 351 1250 Vic Image - Ethnic, Municipal MrStorey Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 351 and Community Affairs 1251 Vic Image - Health MrStorey Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 352 1252 Vic Image - Education Mr Storey Mr Pullen (E &: T) 7.4.92 545 and Training 1253 Vic Image -Arts Mr Storey Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 352 1254 Vic Image - Treasury MrStorey Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 352 1255 Vic Image - Small Business Mr Storey Mr Theophanous (SB) 18.3.92 414 1256 Vic Image - Food and Mr Storey Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1545 Agriculture 1257 Vic Image - Police and Mr Storey Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 353 Emergency Services 1258 Vic Image - Major Projects Mr Storey Mr White (Acting Maj Proj) 17.3.92 353 1260 Vic Image - Transport MrStorey Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 354 1261 Infrastructure Contributions - Mr Chamberlain Mr Pullen (then E &: T) 17.3.92 354 Urban Land Authority 1262 Grampians (Gariwerd) Campaign Mr Chamberlain Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 355 1263 Ministerial Review of School MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 17.3.92 355 Entry Age Committee 1265 Traralgon Manager - Department MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 24.3.92 424 of Labour 1266 Theatre Projectionists Licensing MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 356 1267 Special Day Off - Ports MrAshman Mr White (Ports) 17.3.92 363 1268 Special Day Off - Small Business MrAshman Mr Theophanous (SB) 18.3.92 414 1269 Special Day Off - Manufacturing MrAshman Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 363 and Industry Development LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (31)

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1270 Payments - State Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 21.5.92 1626 Superannuation Board 1271 Superannuation - Department of Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Aifs) 17.3.92 363 Labour Employees 12n Termination Package - MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 364 Labour Inspector 12n Termination Package- Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 7.4.92 547 Labour Inspectorate 1273 Government Programs for Mr Ashman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 18.3.92 415 Homeless Youth 1275 Enhanced Resignation Package - MrAshman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 364 Arts 1276 Enhanced Resignation Package- Mr Ashman Mrs Lyster (Health) 7.4.92 547 Health 1277 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 365 Manufacturing and Industry Development 1278 Enhanced ReSignation Package- Mr Ashman Mr White (then Gaming) 17.3.92 365 Gaming 1278 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 25.3.92 429 Gaming 1279 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (SB) 18.3.92 416 Small Business 1281 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 365 Sport and Recreation 1285 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Aifs) 28.4.92 1545 Labour 1288 Enhanced Resignation Package- Mr Ashman Mr White (Acting Maj Proj) 17.3.92 366 Major Projects 1289 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 366 Police and Emergency Services 1290 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr White (Ports) 17.3.92 367 Ports 1291 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 367 Finance 1293 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 367 Corrections 1294 Enhanced ReSignation Package- Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (then E & T) 17.3.92 368 Agriculture 1295 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (C & E) 17.3.92 368 Education and Training 1296 Enhanced Resignation Package - MrAshman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 368 Education and Training 1297 Enhanced Resignation Package - Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 369 Premier 1298 Staff Attrition Rate - Ports Mr Ashman Mr White (Ports) 17.3.92 369 1299 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 370 Consumer Affairs 1300 Staff Attrition Rate - Arts Mr Ashman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 7.4.92 547 1301 Staff Attrition Rate - Health Mr Ashman Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 370 1302 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 18.3.92 416 Manufacturing and Industry Development 1303 Staff Attrition Rate - Gaming Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 25.3.92 429 1304 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (SB) 18.3.92 416 Small Business 1305 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 371 Sport and Recreation (32) INDEX

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1306 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1591 Community Services 1307 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (C & E) 17.3.92 372 Conservation and Environment 1308 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (then E & T) 17.3.92 372 Planning and Housing 1309 Staff Attrition Rate - Labour MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 372 1311 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 373 Aboriginal Affairs 1312 Staff Attrition Rate - Finance Mr Ashman Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 373 1313 Staff Attrition Rate - Corrections MrAshman Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 373 1314 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 374 Police and Emergency Services 1315 Staff Attrition Rate - Agriculture Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (then E & T) 17.3.92 374 1317 Staff Attrition Rate - Transport Mr Ashman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1546 1318 Staff Attrition Rate - Mr Ashman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 24.3.92 425 Education and Training 1318 Staff Attrition Rate- Mr Ashman Mr Pullen (E & T) 7.4.92 548 Education and Training Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 7.4.92 548 1319 Staff Attrition Rate- MrAshman Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 375 Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs 1320 Staff Attrition Rate - Premier MrAshman Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 376 1321 Fonner Ethnic Affairs Commission MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 18.3.92 417 Chairman - Employment Tennination 1322 Appointments - Ethnic Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 18.3.92 417 Commission 1323 Workforce Management Unit - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 376 Department of Labour 1323 Workforce Management Unit - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 5.5.92 1576 Department of Labour 1324 Braeside Joint Venture Proposal MrConnard Mr Pullen (then E & T) 17.3.92 376 1325 Taxi Hire for Train Crews Mr Wright Mrs"Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 377 1326 Government Outlay on Schools MrWright Mr Pullen (then E & T) 17.3.92 377 1328 Inter-country Adoptions - Applicants Mrs Varty Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 378 1329 Inter-country Adoptions - Approvals Mrs Varty Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1592 1330 Child Abuse - Reports Mrs Varty Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 17.3.92 379 and Prosecutions 1331 Natural Gas Contract Mr Chamberlain Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 379 1333 Fonner Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr White (M & ID) 17.3.92 380 Manufacturing and Industry Development 1335 Fonner Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 18.3.92 418 Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs 1336 Fonner Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C & E) 24.3.92 425 Education and Training 1336 Fonner Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 7.4.92 549 Education and Training 1336 Fonner Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C & E) 25.3.92 429 Education and Training 1337 Fonner Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 380 Health 1338 Fonner Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 380 Consumer Affairs 1339 Fonner Ministerial Adviser -- Mr Birrell Mr White (M & ID) 7.4.92 549 Finance LEGIS LA TIVE COUNCIL (33)

Qn Dtlte Page No. Subject 1tUltler Asked by Answmdby Answertd No.

1340 Former Ministerial Adviser - MrBirrell Mr White (M &t ID) 28.4.92 1546 Major Projects 1341 Former Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mr White (M ck ID) 17.3.92 381 Premier 1342 Former Ministerial Adviser - MrBirrell Mr Theophanous (SB) 18.3.92 418 Small Business 1343 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr White (M ck ID) 17.3.92 381 Tourism 1345 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM ck CA) 17.3.92 381 Aboriginal Affairs 1346 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM ck CA) 24.3.92 426 Arts 1347 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM &t CA) 17.3.92 382 Community Services 1348 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Hogg (EM &t CA) 17.3.92 382 Transport 1349 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (then Eck T) 18.3.92 418 Agriculture 1350 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C ck E) 17.3.92 382 Conservation and Environment 1351 Former Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C ck E) 7.4.92 550 Planning and Housing 1352 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1592 Attorney-General 1353 Former Ministerial Adviser- MrBirrell Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1593 Corrections 1354 Former Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 383 Police and Emergency Services 1355 Former Ministerial Adviser- Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 7.4.92 550 Labour 1356 Former Ministerial Adviser - Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 383 Sport and Recreation 1357 Journalists - Manufacturing MrConnard Mr White (M " ID) 17.3.92 383 and Industry Development 1358 Journalists - Ethnic, Municipal MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM ck CA) 18.3.92 419 and Community Affairs 1359 Journalists - Education MrConnard Mr Pullen (C ck E) 17.3.92 385 and Training 1359 Journalists - Education MrConnard Mr Pullen (C ck E) 7.4.92 550 and Training Mrs Hogg (EM &t CA) 7.4.92 550 1360 Journalists - Health MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 385 1361 Journalists - Consumer Affairs MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 386 1362 Journalists - Finance MrConnard Mr White (M ck ID) 7.4.92 551 1363 Journalists - Major Projects MrConnard Mr White (M ck ID) 17.3.92 387 1364 Journalists - Small Business MrConnard Mr Theophanous (58) 7.4.92 551 1365 Journalists - Tourism MrConnard Mr White (M " ID) 17.3.92 387 1366 Journalists - Treasury MrConnard Mr White (M ck ID) 7.4.92 552 1367 Journalists - Aboriginal Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM" CA) 17.3.92 388 1368 Journalists - Arts MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM ck CA) 17.3.92 388 1369 Journalists - Community Services MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &t CA) 17.3.92 388 1371 Journalists - Food and Agriculture MrConnard Mr Pullen (C " E) 18.3.92 419 1373 Journalists - Housing MrConnard Mr Pullen (C ck E) 7.4.92 552 and Planning 1375 Journalists - Corrections MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 389 1376 Journalists - Police and MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 389 Emergency Services 1377 Journalists - Labour MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 18.3.92 420 (34) INDEX

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answn'ed No.

1378 Journalists - Sport and MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 390 Recreation 1379 Journalists - Child Care MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 391 1380 Journalists - Women's Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 25.3.92 430 1381 Journalists - Premier MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 25.3.92 430 1383 Road Funds MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons AfEs) 29.4.92 1557 1384 Public Hospitals - Effective MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1593 Full-time Staff 1385 Staff - Manufacturing and MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 391 Industry Development 1386 Staff - Gaming MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 7.4.92 552 1387 Staff - Ethnic, Municipal and MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 18.3.92 421 Community Affairs 1388 Staff - Education and Training MrConnard Mr Pullen (E &: T) 7.4.92 553 1388 Staff - Education and Training MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1635 1389 Staff - Health MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 392 1390 Staff - Consumer Affairs MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 7.4.92 553 1391 Staff - Finance MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 7.4.92 554 1392 Staff - Major Projects MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 24.3.92 426 1393 Staff - Premier MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 25.3.92 431 1394 Staff - Small Business MrConnard Mr Theophanous (S8) 7.4.92 555 1395 Staff - Tourism MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 18.3.92 421 1396 Staff - Treasury MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 393 1397 Staff - Aboriginal Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 393 1398 Staff -Arts MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 394 1399 Staff - Community Services MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 394 1401 Staff - Food and Agriculture MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 18.3.92 422 1402 Staff - Conservation and MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 17.3.92 395 Environment 1403 Staff - Planning and Housing MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 7.4.92 556 1405 Staff - Corrections MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 14.4.92 563 1405 Staff - Corrections MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1594 1406 Staff - Police and MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 14.4.92 563 Emergency Services 1407 Staff - Labour MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1547 1408 Staff - Sport and Recreation MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons AfEs) 17.3.92 396 1409 Staff - Child Care MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 396 1410 Staff - Women's Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 25.3.92 432 1411 Staff - Ports MrConnard Mr White (Ports) 17.3.92 397 1412 State Development Fund - Mr Birrell Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 397 Loans to Major Projects Unit 1413 Property and Lands - Mr Birrell Mr White (M &: ID) 7.4.92 556 Major Projects Unit 1414 Jolimont-Eastside Project Mr Birrell Mr White (M &: ID) 24.3.92 426 1415 Salmonella - Yarra River Mr 8irrell Mr Pullen (C &: E) 17.3.92 398 1416 Museum Air Monitoring Station Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (then E &: T) 17.3.92 398 1417 Treasury Buildings - Media MrKennedy Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 399 ~an~tionsCkcupancy 1418 Open Space 2000 Programs MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 24.3.92 427 1419 Victorian Environmental MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 17.3.92 399 Education Council 1420 Housing Projects MrConnard Mr Pullen (E &: T) 7.4.92 557 1421 Health Department Employee MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 400 1422 Liquor Licence Holders - MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 401 Charges and Convictions 1423 Liquor Licence Holders - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 17.3.92 401 Receivers and Bankruptcy Fees 1424 Public Hospitals - Budgets MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 401 LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (35)

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1425 Fluoridated Water Supply Testing MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 17.3.92 402 1426 Pensioners - Winter MrAshman Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 402 Electricity Discount 1427 Pensioners - Winter Gas MrAshman Mr White (M &: ID) 17.3.92 403 and Fuel Discount 1428 Pensioners - Motor Vehicle MrAshman Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 17.3.92 403 Registration Concessions 1429 Victorian College of the Arts MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1635 Secondary School 1430 Fluoridation - Infant Formulas MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 28.4.92 1547 1432 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 14.4.92 564 Health Department Victoria 1433 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 19.5.92 1594 Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs 1434 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 14.4.92 564 Department of Conservation and Environment 1435 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 28.4.92 1548 Manufacturing and Industry Development 1437 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 28.5.92 1647 Premier 1436 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1636 Consumer Affairs 1439 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1548 Food and Agriculture 1440 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 28.4.92 1548 Finance 1441 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1549 Planning and Housing 1442 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 14.4.92 564 Police and Emergency Services 1443 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 19.5.92 1594 Community Services 1444 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 21.5.92 1626 Treasury 1445 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1595 Transport 1446 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1636 Sport and Recreation 1447 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 7.4.92 558 Aboriginal Affairs 1448 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 7.4.92 558 Gaming 1448 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1595 Gaming 1449 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 5.5.92 1576 Employment, Post-Secondary Education and Training 1450 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 29.4.92 1558 Education 1452 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1595 Major Projects 1453 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mr Pullen (C &: E) 5.5.92 1577 Water Resources 1454 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 2.6.92 1649 Arts (36) INDEX

Qn Date Page No. Subject 7J'Ultter Asked lTy Answered lTy Answered No.

1456 Employment of Former Member - MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 28.4.92 1549 Corrections 1457 Opinion Polls - Labour MrBirrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1595 1459 Publications - Conservation MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 21.5.92 1627 and Environment 1460 Publications - Consumer Affairs MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 2.6.92 1649 1461 Publications - Health MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 29.4.92 1558 1462 Publications - Ethnic, Municipal MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1596 and Community Affairs 1463 Publications - Ports MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 29.4.92 1559 1464 Publications - Manufacturing MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 29.4.92 1560 and Industry Development 1465 Publications - Sport MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1636 and Recreation 1468 Publications - Child-care MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 26.5.92 1638 1469 Publications - Community Services MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 26.5.92 1638 1471 Publications - Police and MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1599 Emergency Services 1474 Publications - Aboriginal Affairs MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1601 1475 Publications - Employment, MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 19.5.92 1601 Post-Secondary Education and Training 1478 Publications - Planning MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 4.6.92 1655 and Housing 1479 Publications - Water Resources MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 19.5.92 1602 1480 Publications - Tourism MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 21.5.92 1629 1481 Publications - Food and Agriculture MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 28.4.92 1549 1485 Publications - Women's Affairs MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1602 1486 Publications - Premier MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 19.5.92 1603 1488 Salaries -Conservation MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 21.5.92 1629 and Environment 1490 Salaries - Health MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 28.4.92 1551 1491 Salaries - Ethnic, Municipal MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1606 and Community Affairs 1491 Salaries - Ethnic, Municipal MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 20.5.92 1622 and Community Affairs 1492 Salaries - Ports MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 20.5.92 1623 1493 Salaries - Manufacturing MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 5.5.92 1577 and Industry Development 1494 Salaries - Sport and Recreation MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1639 1497 Salaries - Child-care MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 26.5.92 1640 1498 Salaries - Community Services MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 26.5.92 1641 1502 Salaries - Gaming MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 19.5.92 1607 1503 Salaries - Aboriginal Affairs MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1607 1504 Salaries - Employment, MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 19.5.92 1607 Post-Secondary Education and Training 1506 Salaries - Labour MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 10.6.92 1660 1507 Salaries - Planning and Housing MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 4.6.92 1657 1508 Salaries - Water Resources MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 19.5.92 1608 1510 Salaries - Food and Agriculture MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 28.4.92 1552 1511 Salaries - Major Projects MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 19.5.92 1609 1517 Geelong Staff - Conservation MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 28.4.92 1552 and Environment 1518 Geelong Staff - Consumer Affairs MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1642 1519 Geelong Staff - Ports MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 28.4.92 1552 1520 Geelong Staff - Ethnic, MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1610 Municipal and Community Affairs LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (37)

Qn Date Page No. Subject ""'tter Asked by Answered by Answued No.

1521 Geelong Staff - Ports MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 29.4.92 1574 1522 Geelong Staff - Manufacturing MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 29.4.92 1574 and Industry Development 1523 Geelong Staff - Sport and Recreation MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1642 1526 Geelong Staff - Child-care MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1643 1527 Geelong Staff - Community Services MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1643 1529 Geelong Staff - Police MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1610 and Emergency Services 1530 Geelong Staff - Treasury MrSkeggs Mr White (M &:10) 21.5.92 1630 1531 Geelong Staff - Gaming MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1610 1532 Geelong Staff - Aboriginal Affairs MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 14.4.92 S65 1533 Geelong Staff - Employment, MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 6.5.92 1581 Post-Secondary Education and Training 1535 Geelong Staff - Labour MrSkeggs Mr Theophanoous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1610 1536 Geelong Staff - Planning MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 26.5.92 1643 and Housing 1537 Geelong Staff - Water Resources MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 19.5.92 1611 1538 Geelong Staff - Tourism MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1611 1538 Geelong Staff - Ethnic, MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 20.5.92 1624 Municipal and Community Affairs 1539 Geelong Staff - Food and Agriculture MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1553 1540 Geelong Staff - Major Projects MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 28.4.92 1553 1543 Geelong Staff - Women's Affairs MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 14.4.92 S65 1544 Geelong Staff - Premier MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 14.4.92 565 1546 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1553 Conservation and Environment 1547 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 2.6.92 1651 Consumer Affairs 1548 Trade Union Grants - Health MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 21.5.92 1630 1549 Trade Union Grants - Ethnic, MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 19.5.92 1611 Municipal and Community Affairs 1549 Trade Union Grants - Ethnic, MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 20.5.92 1624 Municipal and Community Affairs 1550 Trade Union Grants - Ports MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 29.4.92 1574 1551 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 29.4.92 1575 Manufacturing and Industry Development 1552 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1644 Sport and Recreation 1555 Trade Union Grants - Child-care MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1644 1556 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 26.5.92 1644 Community Services 1558 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1612 Police and Emergency Services 1559 Trade Union Grants - Treasury MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 21.5.92 1632 1560 Trade Union Grants - Gaming MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1612 1561 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 14.4.92 565 Aboriginal Affairs 1563 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 4.6.92 1658 School Education 1565 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 10.6.92 1661 Planning and Housing 1566 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 19.5.92 1612 Water Resources 1567 Trade Union Grants - MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 28.4.92 1553 Food and Agriculture (38) INDEX

Qn Date Page No. Subject 17Ultter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1568 Trade Union Grants - Tourism MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 14.4.92 566 1569 Trade Union Grants - Major Projects MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 28.4.92 1554 1572 Trade Union Grants - Women's Affairs Mr Skeggs Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 28.5.92 1647 1573 Trade Union Grants - Premier MrSkeggs Mr White (M & ID) 28.5.92 1647 1574 Overseas Trips - Community Services Mr Connard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 26.5.92 1645 1575 Overseas Trips - Conservation MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 5.5.92 1580 and Environment 1577 Overseas Trips - Tourism MrConnard Mr White (M & ID) 28.4.92 1554 1578 Overseas Trips - Treasurer MrConnard Mr White (M & ID) 2.6.92 1651 1580 Overseas Trips - Premier MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 14.4.92 566 1583 Overseas Trips - Ethnic, MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 19.5.92 1613 Municipal and Community Affairs 1584 Overseas Trips - School Education MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM & CA) 2.6.92 1651 1585 Overseas Trips - Sport MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 26.5.92 1645 and Recreation 1587 Overseas Trips - Police MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1613 and Emergency Services 1588 Overseas Trips - Food and MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 28.4.92 1554 Agriculture 1590 Overseas Trips - Planning MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 14.4.92 566 and Housing 1592 Australia Day Committee MrConnard Mr White (M &: ID) 19.5.92 1614 1593 China Advisory Committee - Staft MrConnard Mr White (M & ID) 28.4.92 1555 1594 China Advisory Committee - MrConnard Mr White (M & ID) 28.4.92 1555 Members 1595 Australia Day Committee MrConnard Mr White (M &ID) 19.5.92 1615 1596 Australia Day Committee MrConnard Mr White (M & ID) 19.5.92 1615 1598 Appointments - Ethnic MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 19.5.92 1617 Affairs Commission 1599 Appointments - Liquor MrSmith Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1619 Licensing Commission 1600 Collingwood Football Club - MrSmith Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 19.5.92 1619 Liquor Licensing Commission 1602 National, State and Marine Parks Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C & E) 19.5.92 1619 1603 Chemical Storage Facilities MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 28.5.92 1648 1605 Lake Connewarre - Siltation MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 26.5.92 1646 1605 Lake Connewarre - Siltation MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C & E) 2.6.92 1652 1606 Algae Contamination of MrSkeggs Mr Pullen (C &: E) 19.5.92 1621 Geelong Rivers 1607 Macquarie Bank Consultancy - MrHallam Mr White (M & ID) 10.6.92 1661 Treasury 1608 Victorian Medical Board Mr Best Mrs Lyster (Health) 19.5.92 1621 Working Party Review 1614 "Conserve" - Conservation MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 21.5.92 1632 and Environment 1615 "Conserve" - Conservation MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 21.5.92 1633 and Environment 1616 "Conserve" - Conservation MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 21.5.92 1633 and Environment 1617 Women's Conservation and MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 26.5.92 1646 Environment Network 1617 Women's Conservation and MrConnard Mr Pullen (C & E) 2.6.92 1652 Environment Ntework 1618 Four-Wheel Drive Motor Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C & E) 3.6.92 1653 Registration Levy 1619 ''Life Force" - Conservation Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C & E) 3.6.92 1653 and Environment LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (39)

Qn Date Page No. Subject mIltter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1621 Luscombe and/or Australian MrBirrell Mr White (M &t ID) 10.6.92 1662 Community Research Consultancy - Premier and Cabinet

INDEX

Spring (August) 1992 - Vol. 408

LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

(Bills are listed alphabetically under "Bills" and questions on notice are listed in numerical sequence at end of index)

A Bills- Borrowing and Investment Powers (MMBW) BiII­

11Achieving Better Health and Health Services: Received from Assembly and first reading, 25. Strategic Directions 1992-94" - Missing pages, Intellectually Disabled Persons' Services (Trust Money) q29. BiIl- Received from Assembly and first reading, 25. Administrative Arrangements - Orders Nos 109 to 111,39. Liquor Control (Clubs) Bill - Received from Assembly and first reading, 78; second reading, 78; Advertising - National parks Community Awareness Committee, 79; remaining stages, 80. publicity campaign, 3. Liquor Control (Further Amendment> Bill (No. 2) - Introduction and first reading, 39. B Magistrates' Court (Filing) BiIl- Introduction and first reading, 38. Baxter, Hon. W. R. (North Eastern) National Parks (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) BiII- Received from Assembly and first reading, Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 2. 78. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Parliamentary Salaries and Superannuation Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, (Amendment) Bill-Received from Assembly and 27. first reading, 25; second reading and remaining Government, The - National parks Community stages, 77. Awareness publicity campaign, 9. Health Department Victoria - Achieving Better Health and HeJllth Services: Strategic Directions 1992-84, Birrell, Hon. M. A. (East Yarra) q29. Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 1. Members - Retiring, 81. Electoral- National parks Community Awareness publicity campaign, 3. Environment Protection Authority - Report on Best, Hon. R. A. (North Western) Yarra River pollution, q 37. Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appOintment, 68. Government Appoinbnents, Select Committee on - Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, Third interim report on Department of School 28. Education, 68. Government, The - National Parks Community Awareness publicity campaign, 3. (2) INDEX Liquor Control (Clubs) Bill, 79. o Members - Retiring, SO. Points of Order - Quoted documents, 12. Reflecting Davidson, Hon. B. E. (Chelsea) on decision of House, 13. Remarks: relevancy, 14; Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 72. offensive, 74, 76. Scope of question, 34, 35. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Privileges Committee - Membership, 28. Third interim report on Department of School Education, 72. Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 39, 56.

Business of the House - Postponement, 55. Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 1. c E

Chamberlain, Hon. B. A. (Western) Economic and Budget Review Committee - Reports: Public accounts committees, 39; health service Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 56. agreements, 40. Business of the House - Sittings, 60. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Electoral- National parks Community Awareness Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, publicity campaign, 3. 25; Department of School Education, 41, 56. Environment Protection Authority - Report on Varra Privileges Committee - Membership, 28. River pollution, q 37.

Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affain, Ministry Connard, Hon. G. P. (Higinbotham) of - Contract interpreters, q 33. Local Enterprise Social Development Committee - Report on mental Development Initiative scheme, q 37. disturbance and community safety, 40. Evans, Hon. D. M. (North Eastern) Conservation and Environment - Ecologically Business of the House - Postponement, 55. sustainable development principles, q 32. Government, The - National parks Community Awareness publicity campaign, 19. Consumer Affain - Uniform credit legislation, q 36. Legal and Constitutional Committee -Subordinate Legislation Subcommittee, 55. Cox, Hon. G. H. (Nunawading) F Points of Order - Debating of question, 37. Finance - Sale of State Insurance Office, q 31. Coxsedge, Hon. Joan, (Melbourne West) Members - Retiring, 81. G

Government, The - National parks Community Craige, Hon. G. R. (Central Highlands) Awareness publicity campaign, 3. Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 75. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, 25; Third interim report on Department of School Department of School Education, 41, 56. Education, 75. Hospitals - Proposed Northern, q 35. Government Departments and Instrumentallties - Personal Explanations - Ms Ann Morrow, 86. Appointment of Mr Justin Brenan, 39, 56. Petitions - Pedestrian-operated signals, Epping, 38. Guest, Hon J. V. C. (Monash) Crawford, Hon. G. R. Gika Jika) Economic and Budget Review Committee - Report on Public Accounts Committees, 39. Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 2. Liquor Control (Clubs) Bill, 79.

Credit - Uniform legislation, q 36. H

Hall, Hon. P. R. (Gippsland) Municipalities - Recreation officers salary subsidy scheme, q 32. LEGISLA TIVE COUNCIL (3)

Points of Order - Reflection on decision of House, 13. Debating of question, 37. H~ll~m, Hon. R. M. (Western) State Insurance Office sale, q 31. Kokocinski, Hon. Lici~ (Melbourne West) Health - Budget, q 30. He~lth - Members - Retiring, 83. Department Victoria - Achieving Better Health and Points of order - Offensive remarks, 76. Health Services: Strategic Directions 1992-94, q 29. Budget, q 30. L General- Priority Asthma program, q 31. Human embryos, 38. Ltwson, Hon Robert (Higinbotham) Mental Health - Report on mental disturbance and community safety, 40. Members - Retiring, 84. Petitions - Human embryos, 38.

Hensh~w, Hon. D. E. (Geelong) Government, The - National parks Community Leg~l md Constitution~ Committee - Subordinate Awareness publicity campaign, 17. legislation subcommittee, 55. Members - Conflict of interest guidelines, q 33. Loc~l Enterprise Development Initi~tive Scheme, q 37.

Hogg, Hon. C. J. (Melbourne North) (Minister for Long, Hon. R. J. (Gippsland) Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs) Points of Order - Scope of question, 34. Business of the House - Sittings, 60. Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, Ministry of - Contract interpreters, q 33. Local ~nterprise Lyster, Hon. M. A. (Chelsea) (Minister for Health) Development Initiative scheme, q 37. Intellectually Disabled Persons' Services (Trust Health- Money) Bill, 25. Department Victoria - Achieving Better Health and Municipalities - Recreation officers salary subsidy Health Services: Strategic Directions 1992-94, q 29. scheme, q 32. Budget, q 30. General - Priority Asthma program, q 31. Hospitals - Proposed Northern, q 29, q 35. Caulfield Hospit~ls - Proposed Northern, q 28, q 35. Caulfield General Medical Centre: WorkCare claims, q 31. General Medical Centre: WorkCare claims, q 31. Barwon rehabilitation services, q 35. Barwon rehabilitation services, q 35. Report on Magistrates' Court (Filing) Bill, 38. health service agreements, 40. State Insurance Office - Sale, q 31.

Hunt, Hon. A. J. (South Eastern) (See ''President, The M (Hon. A. J. Hunt)'') M~cey, Hon. Reg (Monash) Members - Retiring, 85.

Ives, Hon. R. S. (Eumemmerring) M~ckenzie, Hon. R. A. (Geelong) Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 62. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Government, The - National parks Community Third interim report on Department of School Awareness publicity campaign, 21. Education, 62. Hospitals - Barwon rehabilitation services, q 35. Liquor Control (Clubs) Bill, 78. K Members - Retiring, 81.

Kennedy, Hon. C.J. (Waverley) McLem, Hon. Jean (Boronia) Credit - Unifonn legislation, q 36. Local Enterprise Development Initiative Scheme, Parliament House - Working conditions, 86. q37.

Kn,owles, Hon. R. I. (Ballarat) Medical Services - Barwon rehabilitation services, Hospitals - Caulfield General Medical Centre: q35. WorkCare claims, q 31. (4) INDEX

Members -Conflict of interest guidelines, q 33. Government, The - National parks Community Retiring, BO. Awareness publicity campaign, 11. National Parks (Further Miscellaneous Amendments) Morrow, Ann - Statement on, 86. Bill, 78. Motions for Adjournment of House to Enable Honourable Members to Discuss Public Q Questions - National parks Community Awareness publicity campaign, 3. Questions on Notice - Answers, 38. Municipalities - Recreation officers salary subsidy scheme, q 32. R

p Roads Corporation - Pedestrian-operated traffic signals, Epping, 38. Parks - National: Community Awareness publicity campaign, 3. s

Parliament, The - Alleged breach of privilege, 25. School Education - Report of Select Committee on Government Appointments, 41, 56. Parliament House - Working conditions, 86. Select Committee on Government Appointments (See Personal Explanations - By Mr Craige, 86. "Government Appointments, Select Committee on'') Petitions - Human embryos, 38. Pedestrian-operated signals, Epping, 38. Sgro, Hon G. A. (Melbourne North) Members - Retiring, 83. President, The (Hon. A. J. Hunt) Rulings and Statements - Social Development Committee - Report on mental Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 2. disturbance and community safety, 40. Debate - Interjections, 12, 77. Minister not to refer to members in other place, 13. Scope, 13, 16. State Insurance Office - Sale, q 31. Reflecting on decision of House. 13. Remarks: relevancy 14, 74; offensive, 74, 75, 76. Reflection on Stoneham, Late C. P., OBE, 1. deliberations of Privileges Committee, 27. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, Storey, Hon. Haddon (East Yarra) 25. Points of Order - Scope of question, 33, 34. Members - Retiring, 86. Parliament, The - Alleged breach of privilege, 25. Questions without Notice - Scope, 33. Debating, 37. Subordinate Legislation Subcommittee (See "Legal and Constitutional Committee'')

Priority Asthma Program, q 31. T Priority Victoria - Local Enterprise Development Initiative scheme, q 37. Tehan, Hon. M. T. (Central Highlands) Hospitals - Proposed Northern, q 28. Privileges Committee - Membership, 28. Reference on third interim report of Select Committee on Government Appointments, 28. Theophanous, Hon. T. C. (Minister for Consumer Affairs, Minister for Small Business, and Minister Public Accounts Committees - Report, 39. Assisting the Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development on Corporatisation)

Pullen, Hon. B. T. (Melbourne) (Minister for Credit - Unifonn legislation, q 36. Conservation and Environment) Liquor Control (Clubs) Bill, 78. Conservation and Environment - Ecologically Liquor Control (Further Amendment) Bill (No. 2),39. sustainable development principles, q 32. Points of order - Debating of question, 37. Environment Protection Authority - Report on Victorian Accident Rehabilitation Council - Yarra River pollution, q 37. WorkCare reports, 39. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, ';IS. LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (5) v

Varty, Hon. Rosemary (Nunawading) Economic and Budget Review Committee - Report on health service agreements, 40. Government, The - National parks Community Awareness publicity campaign, 16. Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs, Ministry of - Contract interpreters, q 33. Points of order - Relevancy of remarks, 16.

Victorian Accident Rehabilitation Council - WorkCare reports, 39. w

White, Hon. D. R. (Doutta Galla) (Minister for Manufacturing and Industry Development, and Minister responsible for Ports) Administrative Arrangements - Orders Nos 109 to 111,39. Borrowing and Investment Powers (MMBW) Bill, 25. Brenan, Mr Justin - Report on appointment, 39. Budget - Papers, 39. Deaths - Hon. C. P. Stoneham, OBE, 1. Government Appointments, Select Committee on - Third interim report: alleged breach of privilege, 27. Members - Conflict of interest guidelines, q 33. Retiring, SO. Parliamentary Salaries and Superannuation (Amendment) Bill, 25, 77. Points of Order - Reflection on deliberations of Privileges Committee, 26. Scope of question, 33, 34. Unparliamentary remarks, 86. Questions on Notice - Answers, 38.

WorkCare - Caulfield General Medical Centre claims, q 31. Reports, 39.

Wrighl, Hon. K. I. M. (North Western) Members - Retiring, 85.

y

Yarn River - Environment Protection Authority report, q 37. (6) INDEX QUESTIONS ON NOTICE

Listed in numerical order of questions on notice answered during period covered by this index.

Ministerial portfolios and abbreviations

Conservation and Environment C&:E

Consumer Affairs ConsAffs

Education and Training E&:T Ethnic, Municipal and Community Affairs EM &:CA

Gaming Gaming Health Health

Major Projects Maj Proj

Manufacturing and Industry Development M&:lD

Ports Ports

Small Business SB

Qn Date Page No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

949 Inactive List - Labour MrAshman Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 89 1244 VICIMAGE - Premier and Cabinet MrStorey Mr White (M &: ID) 12.8.92 89 1370 Journalists - Transport MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 92 1431 Library Funding MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 93 1451 Employment of Former Member MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 93 1455 Employment of Former Member MrConnard Mr Theophanous (SB) 12.8.92 93 1458 Publications - Small Business MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (58) 12.8.92 93 1470 Publications - Corrections MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 94 1473 Publications - Gaming MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 12.8.92 95 1476 Publications - School Education MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 96 1482 Publications - Major Projects MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 12.8.92 97 1487 Salaries - Small Business MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (58) 12.8.92 97 1489 Salaries - Consumer Affairs MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 98 1499 Salaries - Corrections MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 12.8.92 99 1500 Salaries - Police and MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 12.8.92 100 Emergency Services lSOI Salaries - Treasury MrSkeggs Mr White (M &: ID) 12.8.92 101 1S05 Salaries - School Education MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 102 1512 Salaries - Arts MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 103 1516 Geelong Staff - Small Business MrSkeggs MrTheophanous(SB) 12.8.92 103 152S Geelong Staff - Finance MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 103 1528 Geelong Staff - Corrections MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 104 1534 Geelong Staff -School Education MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 104 1541 Geelong Staff - Arts MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 105 1545 Trade Union Grants - Small 8usiness MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (SB) 12.8.92 105 1554 Trade Union Grants - Finance MrSkeggs Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 105 1557 Trade Union Grants - Corrections MrSkeggs Mrs Lyster (Health) 12.8.92 105 1570 Trade Union Grants - Arts MrSkeggs Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 106 1579 Overseas Trips - Arts MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &: CA) 12.8.92 106 1609 Sewerage Facilities Mr Birrell Mr Pullen (C &: E) 12.8.92 106 1611 Standard Gauge Rail Line MrLawson Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 107 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (7)

Qn Date Page No. Subject mIltter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1612 Standard Gauge Rail Line MrLawson Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 107 1613 "Conserve" - Conservation MrLawson Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 107 and Environment NOTE: Should be ""Standard Gauge Rail Line" 1622 Four-Wheel Motor Vehicle Mr Birrell Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 lOB Registration Levy 1629 Asset Register - Ethnic, MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 lOB Municipal and Community Affairs 1634 Asset Register - Gaming MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 109 1637 Asset Register - Tourism MrConnard Mr White (M« ID) 12.8.92 109 1639 Asset Register - Aboriginal Affairs MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 109 1641 Asset Register - Community Services MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 110 1642 Asset Register - School Education MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 110 1643 Asset Register - Employment, MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 III Post-Secondary Education and Training 1644 Asset Register - Food and Agriculture Mr Connard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 112 1646 Asset Register - Water Resources MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 112 1648 Asset Register - Corrections MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 12.8.92 113 1652 Asset Register - Sport and Recreation MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons A'ffs) 12.8.92 114 1654 Asset Register - Child-Care MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 116 1656 Motor Vehicle Accidents- MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 116 Higinbotham Province 1657 Boating Licence Fees MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 117 1658 Boating Facilities MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 117 1659 Traffic Black Spots MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 118 1667 Central Area Transport Strategy MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 118 1668 Sandringham Rail Service MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 119 1669 Frankston Rail Service MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 120 1670 Motor Vehicle Accident Fatalities MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 121 1671 Racecourse Licences Board MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 121 1672 Boating Facilities Fund MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 122 1673 State Water Laboratory MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 124 1677 Ministerial Advisers - Child-care MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 124 1680 Ministerial Advisers - Gaming MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 125 1683 Ministerial Advisers - Corrections MrConnard Mrs Lyster (Health) 12.8.92 125 1685 Ministerial Advisers - Water MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 125 Resources 1687 Ministerial Advisers - Food and MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 126 Agriculture 1688 Ministerial Advisers - Employment, MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 126 Post-Secondary Education and Training 1689 Ministerial Advisers - School MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 126 Education 1690 Ministerial Advisers - Community MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 127 Services 1693 Ministerial Advisers - Treasury MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 128 1694 Ministerial Advisers - Tourism MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 128 1697 Ministerial Advisers - Manufacturing MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 129 and Industry Development 1698 Ministerial Advisers - Ports MrConnard Mr White (M « ID) 12.8.92 129 1699 Ministerial Advisers - Ethnic, MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 129 Municipal and Community Affairs 1700 Ministerial Advisers - Conservation MrConnard Mr Pullen (C « E) 12.8.92 130 and Environment 1709 Brambuk Aboriginal Centre MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM « CA) 12.8.92 130 1718 Land Classification Review Committee MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 131 (8) INDEX

Qn. Date PQge No. Subject matter Asked by Answered by Answered No.

1723 HACC Funding in Higinbotham MrConnard Mrs Hogg (EM &t CA) 12.8.92 131 Province 1724 State Bicycle Committee MrConnard Mr Theophanous (Cons Affs) 12.8.92 133 1725 Accounting - T AFE Colleges Mr Mackenzie Mr Pullen (C &t E) 12.8.92 134 1726 Accounting - T AFE Colleges Mr Mackenzie Mr Pullen (C &t E) 12.8.92 135 1727 Accounting - T AFE Colleges Mr Mackenzie Mr Pullen (C at E) 12.8.92 135