Irish Political Review, June 2007
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Preventing The Future? Palestine: Families Nurses: Trade Brendan Clifford replies to And Policy Union Equality? Professor Garvin Conor Lynch Labour Comment page 15 page 8 back page IRISH POLITICAL REVIEW JUNE 2007 Vol.22, No.6 ISSN 0790-7672 and Northern Star incorporating Workers' Weekly Vol.21 No.6 ISSN 954-5891 Election 2007 "The Greatest Nation On Earth" Remember 62 The British Prime Minister said some years ago, when launching one of his five wars, The result of the 2007 election was that Britain has never made war except in a just cause. This must mean that Britain is Fianna Fail 78, Fine Gael 51, Labour 20, the agent of divine Providence in this world. Green 6, Sinn Fein 4, Progressive Demo- When making his retirement speech a couple of weeks ago, this same Prime Minister crats 2, Independents 5. The share of first . confirmed that was his meaning. He said: preferences was 41.6%, 27.3%, 10.1%, "…This country is a blessed nation. 4.7%, 6.9%, 2.7% and 6.6% respectively. The British are special. The world knows it. In our innermost thoughts, we know it. This is the greatest nation on earth." Fianna Fail obtained the same percent- age as the 2002 election but lost three No Irish political party or newspaper uttered a note of dissent. To have done so would seats (it had already lost two since 2002: have been 'divisive'. Beverley Cooper Flynn and Charlie It was not divisive on the part of the British Prime Prime Minister to assert that Britain McCreevy). Nevertheless it can claim to was the greatest state in the world—that it was a blessed state. But it would have been be the big winner in this election. It has divisive for any representative figure in Ireland, speaking out of the Irish experience of been in power for all but two and a half of English blessedness, to comment that Blair's statement was an expression of either the last 20 years and, after all the changes extreme Jingoism or of megalomania. Such is the condition of the relationship between in that period both in Irish society and the Ireland and Britain today. world, it remains the dominant political party in the state. The Taoiseach was invited to address the British Parliament to celebrate the joint achievement of London and Dublin in putting Northern Ireland back in the box, where Reflecting on his success, Ahern it is to engage in a make-belief politics outside the political life of either of the states. claimed on RTE that Fianna Fail had been Taoiseach Bertie Ahern said to the assembled Westminster Houses in Westminster the most successful political party in Hall: Europe. His success was all the more "I had the honour last week to welcome the new First Minister of Northern Ireland, the remarkable because it was achieved in the Right Honourable Ian Paisley MP, to the site of the Battle of the Boyne. This was a battle context of a vicious media campaign for power in these islands and also part of a wider European conflict. Its outcome resounds against him. On the Saturday after the through the centuries of Irish and British history to this very day. That time marked the election the Labour Party leader Pat beginning of an unbroken period of parliamentary democracy in this country." Rabbitte compared Fianna Fail to a tribe Here we have unconditional surrender by the leader of Irish democracy to English in its loyalty to its chief and admitted that, history—o r to the English Story. if any other party leader had been subjected continued on page 2 continued on page 4 critically by the media. His problem is, even though it is obvious that, in order to A Post-Election Coup? that, after years have gone by and millions do this, he must either join forces with As we go to press Justice Mahon and the have been spent, he has come up with Provisional Sinn Fein—or, if his Stickie Irish Times, aided by the Daily Mail, are nothing on which charges can be based partners baulk at this, he must mend his trying to change the outcome of the General against anybody, and he is taking it person- fences with Lowry and pay a million and Election after the Election, by means of an ally and has resorted to dirty tricks. We a half pounds to Beverley Cooper-Flynn intensified libel campaign against the will not speculate on whether this arises so that she can clear her debts to RTE over Fianna Fail leader, who, by any reasonable from political bias or sheer inadequacy. the libel action. And this supposes that stan dard, won the election. In view of the happenings of the last she and other Independents would be Justice Mahon is a would-be tax cheat couple of months, the Mahon Tribunal willing to make nonsense of themselves who had to disgorge £20,000 in 1992 and and the Irish Times must be regarded as a by supporting him. blames the late Fianna Fail TD, Liam combination. The fact that Lowry and Beverley Lawlor, for revealing this fact to the media. The Fine Gael leader has responded to Cooper-Flynn were poll-toppers shows He launched an assault on the Taoiseach the encouragement given to him by the how much credence the electorate places the first day of Tribunal business after the spurious Tribunal and the Oath-bound in the “corruption” indictments concocted Election. He had nothing new—or nothing British newspaper by refusing to concede by a few powerful people in Dublin for of substance—to do it with, but he knew that he lost the Election. He says he can reasons which have nothing to do with that the assault would not be looked at form a rag-bag Coalition of bits and pieces, good government. and govern them. It was the influence of C O N T E N T S the principles of the French Revolution, which survived the defeat of France, that "The Greatest Nation On Earth". Editorial 1 led to the first, very small, extension of the Remember 62. Editorial (Election of 24th June 2007) 1 Parliamentary franchise in Britain in 1832: 142 years after the Battle of the Boyne. A Post-Election Coup? Editorial 1 Irish Times Suppresses Debate. Cathal Brugha on the Fourth Estate (letters) 3 What was at issue at the Battle of the Boyne was religious freedom. King James Editorial Digest (Albert Reynolds; Harold Whelehan; Martin McGuinness; BBC, NI introduced it in the 1680s. The victory of Brian Feeney; Messines; Political Policing; Le Monde 3 King William led to its abolition for almost a century and a half—until 1829, when it Tally Ho Ho Hoey. Joe Keenan 6 was partially conceded in the face of mass Fianna Fail And The Decline Of The Free State. Jack Lane 7 rebellion in Ireland threatened by Daniel O'Connell. Fair Employment: The Flynn & Debast Case. Mark Langhammer 7 Another immediate consequence of Family And Policy. Conor Lynch (Reflections On Palestine, Part 5) 8 the Battle of the Boyne was the throwing of the slave trade open to private enterprise, The Great Debate. John Martin (Ahern v. Kenny on television) 10 which led to England becoming the main Irish Men And England's Wars. Seán McGouran 12 slave-trading nation in the world within twenty years. The Irish Times Campaign Against Bertie Ahern. IPR Group, Press Release 13 A consequence which took a generation Preventing The Future. Brendan Clifford (Part 2 of reply to Prof. Garvin) 15 to work out was the reduction of the monarchy to a figurehead behind which Shorts from the Long Fellow (Irish Times: 1. Opinion Poll Strategy; 2. Corruption the aristocracy and gentry ruled. But the Strategy; French Election Special) 19 disembowelling of the monarchy—which began with the Whig coup d'etat of 1715, A Brief Summary Of "Bertiegate". Editorial 22 introducing a German King who couldn't speak English—was not a measure which Labour Comment, edited by Pat Maloney: established popular government. What it The Nursing Dispute And After, back page established was the complete freedom of The Mid Cork Election Ballad Of D.D. Sheehan, page 23 the aristocracy to do as it pleased with the people. Carroll Professor Roy Foster was said. But there has been nothing constant highly praised a couple of years ago for in English history except the fact of the Popular rights require a framework of his book The Irish Story. What he meant English State and its pursuit of power. law maintained by a national state to which by the title was that the Irish make up a But the Story at any given moment always all classes are subject. That is not what the Story of Ireland and present it as history, tells of constancy of another kind, and Glorious Revolution of 1688 (made secure with little or no regard for historical fact. massages historical fact into compliance at the Battle of the Boyne) established. But, alas, the truth is that there is no longer with it. That is what it abolished. an Irish Story, invented or researched, Or, if there has been a constant ideal The national state, which existed in false or true. There is only a variation of which accompanied the unrelenting connection with the monarchy, was broken the English Story for Ireland. pursuit of power, it was an ideal which at up and its place was taken by a system in The English Story, both of England a certain point it became unprofitable to which the local aristocrat was the State itself and of the English contretemps in speak of—anti-Catholicism.