For Metrolinx Electrification Project
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GO Rail Network Electrification Transit Project Assessment Process REVIEW OF PARSONS PROPOSAL TO UPGRADE TRACK CIRCUITS Final Public Meetings Round #3 Integrated Summary Report For Prepared by: Swerhun Logo Reviewed by: Gannett Fleming Project No. 060277 Metrolinx Electrification Project Contract No. QBS-2014-IEP-002 August 2017 Prepared By: Gannett Fleming Canada ULC 8/24/17 i | P a g e METROLINX GO RAIL ELECTRIFICATION Quality Assurance Document Release Form Name of Firm: Swerhun Facilitation Document Name: Integrated Summary Report Rev. 1 Submittal Date: August 14, 2017 Discipline: Public Consultation Prepared By: Casey Craig Date: August 9, 2017 Reviewed By: Nicole Swerhun Date: August 14, 2017 Approved By: Amber Saltarelli Date: August 14, 2017 Project Manager The above electronic signatures indicate that the named document is controlled by GF Canada ULC, and has been: 1. Prepared by qualified staff in accordance with generally accepted professional practice. 2. Checked for completeness and accuracy by the appointed discipline reviewers and that the discipline reviewers did not perform the original work. 3. Reviewed and resolved compatibility interfaces and potential conflicts among the involved disciplines. 4. Updated to address previously agreed-to reviewer comments, including any remaining comments from previous internal or external reviews. 5. Reviewed for conformance to scope and other statutory and regulatory requirements. 6. Determined suitable for submittal by the Project Manager. Prepared By: Swerhun Facilitation 08-14-2017 i | P a g e REVISION HISTORY Revision Date Comments 0 July 24, 2017 Initial Release to Metrolinx 1 August 14, 2017 Final Report reflecting edits per MX comments Prepared By: Swerhun Facilitation 08-14-2017 ii | P a g e Final Public Meetings Round #3 Integrated Summary Report TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 GO RAIL NETWORK ELECTRIFICATION TPAP PUBLIC MEETINGS OVERVIEW .....................................1 2 COMMON THEMES .......................................................................................................................2 3 INTEGRATED FEEDBACK SUMMARY ..............................................................................................3 3.1 FIND MORE EQUITABLE AND ACCURATE WAYS TO MEASURE AND MITIGATE NOISE AND VIBRATION. ....................4 3.2 DO MORE TO REDUCE THE NOISE FROM HORNS AND WHISTLES AT LEVEL CROSSINGS. ......................................4 3.3 BUILD NOISE BARRIERS TO A HIGHER STANDARD. ...................................................................................4 3.4 CHOOSE THE TECHNOLOGY WITH THE LEAST ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL, AND FINANCIAL IMPACTS. ......................5 3.5 ENSURE THERE IS ENOUGH PARKING TO ACCOMMODATE DEMAND FROM EXISTING AND INCREASED SERVICE USERS. .................................................................................................................................................6 3.6 DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT STRATEGIES TO MITIGATE TRAFFIC CONGESTION, PARTICULARLY AT AT-GRADE CROSSINGS. ..........................................................................................................................................6 3.7 STRENGTHEN COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE PUBLIC, STARTING BY PROVIDING TIMELY PUBLIC MEETING NOTICES. ..6 3.8 EXPLORE A RE-ALIGNMENT OF THE RAIL CORRIDOR. ................................................................................7 3.9 DESIGN AND BUILD ELECTRIFICATION INFRASTRUCTURE IN WAYS THAT REDUCE VISUAL IMPACTS. .......................7 3.10 OTHER FEEDBACK .........................................................................................................................7 4 NEXT STEPS ..................................................................................................................................8 5 ATTACHMENT 1: QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION – MISSISSAUGA: JUNE 26, 2017 ...........................9 5.1 OVERVIEW ...................................................................................................................................9 5.2 QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION ..........................................................................................................9 5.2.1 NOISE LEVELS ........................................................................................................................................ 9 5.2.2 TRAIN HORNS AND WHISTLES ................................................................................................................. 10 5.2.3 NOISE BARRIERS .................................................................................................................................. 10 5.2.4 ELECTRIFICATION INFRASTRUCTURE ........................................................................................................ 11 5.2.5 ROLLING STOCK (TRAINS) ...................................................................................................................... 11 5.2.6 TRAFFIC IMPACTS AND AT-GRADE CROSSINGS ........................................................................................... 11 5.2.7 PARKING AND STATION ACCESS .............................................................................................................. 12 5.2.8 HYDROGEN AND ALTERNATIVE TECHNOLOGIES .......................................................................................... 12 5.2.9 TREES AND VEGETATION REMOVAL ......................................................................................................... 13 5.2.10 ELECTRO MAGNETIC INTERFERENCE (EMI) / ELECTRO MAGNETIC FIELD (EMF) .......................................... 13 5.2.11 PROJECT COST AND TIMING ................................................................................................................. 13 Prepared By: Swerhun Facilitation 08-14-2017 iii | P a g e Final Public Meetings Round #3 Integrated Summary Report 6 ATTACHMENT 2: QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION – AJAX: JUNE 28, 2017 ...................................... 14 6.1 OVERVIEW ................................................................................................................................. 14 6.2 QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION ........................................................................................................ 14 6.2.1 ELECTRIFICATION INFRASTRUCTURE ........................................................................................................ 14 6.2.2 ROLLING STOCK (TRAINS) ...................................................................................................................... 15 6.2.3 PROJECT TIMING AND COMMUNICATION ................................................................................................. 15 6.2.4 HYDROGEN AND ALTERNATIVE TECHNOLOGIES .......................................................................................... 15 6.2.5 CONTRACTS AND PROCUREMENT............................................................................................................ 16 6.2.6 ACCESSIBILITY ..................................................................................................................................... 16 7 ATTACHMENT 3: QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION – TORONTO: JUNE 29, 2017............................... 17 7.1 OVERVIEW ................................................................................................................................. 17 7.2 QUESTIONS OF CLARIFICATION ........................................................................................................ 17 7.2.1 ELECTRIFICATION INFRASTRUCTURE ........................................................................................................ 17 7.2.2 ELECTRICITY USE .................................................................................................................................. 18 7.2.3 HYDROGEN AND ALTERNATIVE TECHNOLOGIES .......................................................................................... 18 7.2.4 BRIDGE REPLACEMENTS AND BRIDGE BARRIERS ......................................................................................... 19 7.2.5 PROJECT COST AND TIMING ................................................................................................................... 19 7.2.6 TRAFFIC IMPACTS AND AT-GRADE CROSSINGS ........................................................................................... 19 7.2.7 ELECTRO MAGNETIC INTERFERENCE (EMI) / ELECTRO MAGNETIC FIELD (EMF) ............................................ 20 7.2.8 NOISE AND VIBRATION MODELLING ........................................................................................................ 20 7.2.9 NOISE LEVELS AND NOISE WALLS ............................................................................................................ 20 7.2.10 TRAIN SPEEDS ................................................................................................................................... 20 7.2.11 RIDERSHIP ........................................................................................................................................ 21 7.2.12 NEW STATIONS ................................................................................................................................. 21 7.2.13 ROLLING STOCK (TRAINS) .................................................................................................................... 21 7.2.14 CONSTRUCTION ................................................................................................................................