Research Paper
GEOSPHERE Detrital zircon record of Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern Central Andes GEOSPHERE, v. 17, no. 3 T.N. Capaldi1,*, N.R. McKenzie2, B.K. Horton1,3, C. Mackaman-Lofland1, C.L. Colleps2, and D.F. Stockli1 1Department of Geological Sciences, Jackson School of Geosciences, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712, USA https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02346.1 2Department of Earth Sciences, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong, China 3Institute for Geophysics, Jackson School of Geosciences, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712, USA 11 figures; 1 table; 1 set of supplemental files
CORRESPONDENCE: [email protected] ABSTRACT arc width reflects shallower slab dip. Comparisons geodynamic processes, upper-plate deformation, among slab dip calculations with time-averaged and subduction-related magmatism. CITATION: Capaldi, T.N., McKenzie, N.R., Horton, B.K., Mackaman-Lofland, C., Colleps, C.L., and Stockli, D.F., The spatial and temporal distribution of arc εHf and Th/U zircon results exhibit a clear trend of The South American plate at 28°S –33°S is com- 2021, Detrital zircon record of Phanerozoic magmatism magmatism and associated isotopic variations decreasing (enriched) magma compositions with posed of numerous north-south–trending terranes in the southern Central Andes: Geosphere, v. 17, no. 3, provide insights into the Phanerozoic history increasing arc width and decreasing slab dip. Col- of variable composition that may have induced a p. 876–897, https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02346.1 . of the western margin of South America during lectively, these data sets demonstrate the influence spatial control on the geochemical signatures of
Science Editor: Shanaka de Silva major shifts in Andean and pre-Andean plate inter of subduction angle on the position of upper-plate subsequent Andean tectono-magmatic regimes Associate Editor: Christopher J. Spencer actions. We integrated detrital zircon U-Th-Pb and magmatism (including inboard arc advance and (Chapman et al., 2017). A critical debate persists Hf isotopic results across continental magmatic arc outboard arc retreat), changes in isotopic signa- over the timing and geologic expression of sub- Received 4 September 2020 systems of Chile and western Argentina (28°S–33°S) tures, and overall composition of crustal and mantle duction initiation along the South American margin Revision received 3 January 2021 with igneous bedrock geochronologic and zircon Hf material along the western edge of South America. after Paleozoic terrane accretion. Traditional models Accepted 19 March 2021 isotope results to define isotopic signatures linked have attributed magmatic compositional changes
Published online 6 May 2021 to changes in continental margin processes. Key to Triassic subduction shutoff during intraplate tectonic phases included: Paleozoic terrane accre- ■■ INTRODUCTION anorogenic and/or extensional conditions followed tion and Carboniferous subduction initiation during by Early Jurassic subduction initiation (Kay et al., Gondwanide orogenesis, Permian–Triassic exten- Subduction zones are fundamental components 1989; Mpodozis and Kay, 1992; Llambías and Sato, sional collapse, Jurassic–Paleogene continental of Earth systems that link lithospheric dynamics, 1995; Kleiman and Japas, 2009). Andean mag- arc magmatism, and Neogene flat slab subduc- mountain building, surface processes, magmatism, matic records that span from the Early Jurassic tion during Andean shortening. The ~550 m.y. and climate–carbon cycles. Spatial, temporal, and (ca. 200 Ma) to present provide a foundation for record of magmatic activity records spatial trends compositional changes in continental arc mag- interpreting the history of Andean subduction and in magma composition associated with terrane matism in Cordilleran-type orogenic systems orogenesis (Haschke et al., 2002, 2006; Trumbull boundaries. East of 69°W, radiogenic isotopic sig- have been shown to be a function of variations et al., 2006; Folguera and Ramos, 2011; Balgord, natures indicate reworked continental lithosphere in subduction dynamics and overriding plate pro- 2017; Faccenna et al., 2017; Schellart, 2017; Butler with enriched (evolved) εHf values and low (<0.65) cesses (Dickinson, 1975; Haschke et al., 2002, 2006; et al., 2019; Sundell et al., 2019; Spencer et al., 2019; zircon Th/U ratios during phases of early Paleozoic Kay et al., 2005; Trumbull et al., 2006; Kirsch et Chen et al., 2019). Although best known for Ceno- and Miocene shortening and lithospheric thicken- al., 2016; Ancellin et al., 2017; de Silva and Kay, zoic contractional orogenesis, the western margin ing. In contrast, the magmatic record west of 69°W 2018; Chapman and Ducea, 2019). The southern of South America has experienced varied tectonic displays depleted (juvenile) εHf values and high Central Andes, spanning the modern retroarc regimes throughout the Phanerozoic, potentially (>0.7) zircon Th/U values consistent with increased region of central Argentina and forearc region of preserving an earlier phase of subduction-related asthenospheric contributions during lithospheric Chile (Fig. 1), represent one of the few places on magmatism that dates back to the Carboniferous thinning. Spatial constraints on Mesozoic to Ceno- Earth where a long-lived (>100 m.y.) convergent (Alasino et al., 2012; Dahlquist et al., 2013; del Rey zoic arc width provide a rough approximation of margin provides the magmatic record necessary et al., 2016). For long-lived (>100 m.y.) Cordille- relative subduction angle, such that an increase in to evaluate spatial-temporal relationships among ran orogenic systems, variations in the position of the magmatic arc have been variably linked to
This paper is published under the terms of the Tomas Capaldi https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4894-736X changes in the dip of the subducted slab, the rate CC‑BY-NC license. *Now at Department of Geoscience, University of Nevada–Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada 89154, USA. of plate convergence, and/or magnitude of forearc
© 2021 The Authors
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 3 Capaldi et al. | Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern Central Andes Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/3/876/5319346/876.pdf 876 by guest on 28 September 2021 Research Paper
Carboniferous-Triassic Ediacaran-Devonian
Pgi 70˚W 68˚W 66˚W pCO 64˚W Sedimentary Igneous Ngi Quaternary Oi Qa Ngi PN fluvial-alluvial Neogene i Quaternary TR Qe Pgi Paleogene JK P pCO Qe 29˚S eolian Ngi Coastal Oi Paleogene- lower-mid Cordillera CD Di PN Neogene Ki Cretaceous Ji PN Qe Jurassic CPs JK Cretaceous Ji Jurassic N Pgi Oi La Rioja Pampean TRs Triassic Perm-Triassic Ki Arc PTRi Choiyoi Igneous CPi Ngi Precordillera CPs Carboniferous- Carboniferous- La Serena IRB Ci Permian CPi Permian 30˚S CPs JK CPi PTRi CD Cambrian- Devonian- BFB TRs Devonian Di Carboniferous Pacific Ji Sierras Pampeanas Qa Metamorphic Oi Ordovician Ocean Pgi Frontal Famatinian Precambrian- Famatinian Arc Cordillera PN Qa Arc pCO CPs Ordovician Ci Cambrian PN metasedimentary Pampean Arc Pgi Qa and crystalline rocks Oi Symbols Ki CD PN fault suture zone Oi 31˚S pCO city stratigraphic CD pCO section (Fig.9) Ngi Qa Ji CPi Ngi Ngi Zircon Samples Pgi Di PTR pCO new DZ εHf/ new U-Pb ages Chile Trench i Cordoba Ki San Juan new DZ εHf/ published U-Pb ages Principal TRs Capaldi et al., 2017; 2020 Cordillera DZ εHf/ U-Pb ages 32˚S JK PN Willner et al., 2008; Cristofolini et al., 2012 JK Pepper et al., 2016 LRB PTR Rio de i pCO Qe La Plata bedrock εHf/ U-Pb ages JK Qa Craton Dahlquist et al., 2013; 2016; 2018 Herve et al., 2014; Jones et al., 2015 JK Chilenia TRs CD Cuyania Pampia Di Otamendi et al., 2017; Rapela et al., 2018 JFR Ngi Ngi Terrane Terrane Terrane Di Valparaiso Qe 72˚W JK 71˚W PN 69˚W 67˚W 65˚W 0 50 100 km Pgi Mendoza Ngi 33˚S Jurassic-Cretaceous Cenozoic
Figure 1. Geologic map of Argentina and Chile (28.5°S to 33°S) highlighting major Phanerozoic magmatic provinces, proposed terrane boundaries, and zircon sample locations. BFB—Bermejo foreland basin; IRB—Ischigualasto rift basin; LRB—La Ramada Basin; JFR—Juan Fernandez Ridge; DZ—detrital zircon (SEGEMAR, 1999, 2012; Sernageomin, 2003).
erosion (Ramos et al., 2002; Kay et al., 2005; Stern, patterns and changes in magmatic composition pattern of Andean arc magmatism, and the depth of 2011). Subduction angle has been interpreted to along the Andean margin. The detrital record pro- melt generation. Integrated spatial, temporal, and modulate mechanical coupling along subduction vides valuable temporal controls on the evolution compositional trends in magmatism enabled us to margins, control retroarc basin evolution, and drive of upper-crustal composition (Condie et al., 2011; evaluate the spatial control on crustal geochemi- phases of arc migration that are reflected in iso- Cawood et al., 2012; Augustsson et al., 2016; Pepper cal signatures, timing of subduction initiation, and topic records (Ramos and Folguera, 2009; Horton, et al., 2016; Balgord, 2017; Dhuime et al., 2017; McK- estimation of subduction angle variations along the 2018a, 2018b; Chapman and Ducea, 2019). Evalua- enzie et al., 2018; Barber et al., 2019). Additionally, transition between the central and southern Andes. tion of the operative spatial and temporal scales the spatial and temporal patterns in magmatism of trends in magmatic arc composition provides a derived from compiled bedrock geochronologi- means to assess proposals of high-flux events and cal data sets provide constraints on magmatic arc ■■ GEOLOGIC SETTING magmatic lulls that may have generated cyclical width, from which we estimated average slab dip or punctuated phases of arc magmatism (de Silva values for past subduction systems. Subduction Igneous and associated metamorphic rocks in et al., 2015; Paterson and Ducea, 2015; Kirsch et angle can be calculated for a continental magmatic Argentina and Chile (Fig. 1) can be divided into four al., 2016). arc when the width of the arc and depth of melting distinct groups: (1) Ediacaran to Devonian base- This study presents new detrital zircon U-Pb are known (Fig. 2), assuming dehydration melting ment rocks of the Sierras Pampeanas and eastern ages, U-Th ratios, and Lu-Hf isotopic data from at a specific depth and vertical melt ascent (Keith, craton; (2) Carboniferous–Triassic rocks of the Fron- modern river sands and sandstones through- 1978, 1982; Peacock et al., 1994). To assess the rela- tal and Principal Cordilleras; (3) Jurassic–Paleogene out the retroarc region of central Argentina and tionships among arc width, subduction angle, and rocks of the Coastal Cordillera; and (4) Cenozoic forearc region of Chile (Fig. 1) to evaluate long- melting depth, we first characterized the modern volcanic rocks that get younger eastward from the term (>100 m.y.), regional (>100 km scale) geologic geometry of the Nazca subduction zone, the spatial Principal Cordillera toward the Argentina foreland.
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 3 Capaldi et al. | Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern Central Andes Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/3/876/5319346/876.pdf 877 by guest on 28 September 2021 Research Paper
Latest Ediacaran to Devonian igneous and meta melting depth relationship between slab dip = tan-1 morphic belts are exposed across the Sierras slab dip and arc width ) arc width ) Pampeanas. Key phases include the Pampean (555– 515 Ma) and Famatinian (495–460 Ma) magmatic narrow wide arcs, generated during east-dipping subduction arc width arc width (Ramos et al., 1986; Bahlburg et al., 2009). The Pre- cambrian to Ordovician history included accretion of Laurentian terranes (including Cuyania) to the Gond- continental crust wana margin, followed by the poorly constrained accretion of the Chilenia terrane (Ramos et al., 1984; low melting Thomas et al., 2015; Rapela et al., 2016; Martin et high slab dip al., 2019). Isolated granitic plutons of Devonian age depth slab dip across the Sierras Pampeanas region are interpreted to have been emplaced during extensional condi- tions (Dahlquist et al., 2013; Moreno et al., 2020). Figure 2. Schematic diagram illustrating relationships among continental arc width and dehydra- Carboniferous–Triassic igneous complexes form tion melting in the asthenosphere as a function of subduction angle for narrow arcs (gray triangle) and wide arcs (black triangle). much of the High Andes, with the Choiyoi igneous complex spanning the Principal Cordillera along the Chile-Argentina border and flanking regions western flank of the Principal Cordillera, and finally subduction angle, we utilized the time-space dis- to the west and east (Frontal Cordillera and parts Miocene (17–10 Ma) volcanic rocks in the eastern tribution of arc magmatism following the simplified of the Andean foreland). Batholith emplacement Principal Cordillera, Frontal Cordillera, and Argen- approach of Keith (1978, 1982) in which dehydration in the northern Frontal Cordillera involved many tine foreland (Parada et al., 1988, 1999; Kay et al., melting occurs at specific depths during vertical phases of Carboniferous to Triassic orogenic and 1991; Haschke et al., 2006; Jones et al., 2016). Mio- ascent of magma through the overriding plate postorogenic magmatism (Hervé et al., 2014; Sato cene magmatism was concurrent with significant (Fig. 2). Dehydration melting occurs in the upper et al., 2015). Late Carboniferous to early Permian (~150 km) retroarc crustal shortening largely focused mantle over a narrow range of depths defined as a magmatism was synchronous with growth of the in the Precordillera fold-and-thrust belt (Jordan et melting window with finite upper and lower limits NW-NNW–trending Gondwanide orogenic belt al., 1993; Allmendinger and Judge, 2014; Fosdick (Fig. 2). From this relationship, subduction angle during east-dipping subduction (Giambiagi et al., et al., 2015; Mosolf et al., 2019; Mackaman-Lofland can be calculated for a continental arc with a known 2014; Hervé et al., 2014). After the cessation of et al., 2020). The modern Pampean segment of the arc width and melting depth. The arc width to slab Gondwanide shortening and crustal thickening, the Nazca–South American plate boundary is character- dip relationship does not require estimates of the emplacement of calc-alkaline to alkaline bimodal ized by shallow subduction, an ~500-km-long gap in arc-trench gap (distance between the magmatic intrusive suites and exceptionally thick (>5–10 km) active volcanism, and foreland basement uplifts of front and subduction trench-slope break), which is ignimbrites of the Choiyoi Group (ca. 280–248 Ma) the Sierras Pampeanas that persist >700 km toward a function of both subduction duration and subduc- is consistent with crustal melting and possible the craton, potentially driven by subduction of the tion angle (Dickinson, 1973; Coney and Reynolds, postorogenic collapse prior to and during the ear- Juan Fernandez Ridge (Barazangi and Isacks, 1976; 1977; Jacob et al., 1977; Jarrard, 1986; Isacks, 1988). liest stages of Gondwana breakup (Mpodozis and Jordan et al., 1983; Ramos et al., 2002; Ramos and Kay, 1992; Kleiman and Japas, 2009; Sato et al., Folguera, 2009; Alvarado et al., 2009). 2015; Nelson and Cottle, 2019). Estimating Melting Depth for Modern Arc East-dipping subduction generated the Juras- Volcanos sic to Cenozoic Andean magmatic arc, which is ■■ METHODS AND RESULTS defined by north-trending belts involving princi- To identify the relationship of arc width to sub- pally granite/granodiorite intrusions and andesite Reconstructing Subduction Angle through Time duction angle, we first constrained the limits of flows. These belts show a systematic eastward the melting depth window beneath the modern decrease in age, from Jurassic (200–165 Ma) and The angle of subduction influences the position Andean arc. Pleistocene to Holocene arc volcano Cretaceous (130–90 Ma) rocks along the Chil- of the magmatic arc, thermal structure of the man- locations were compared with the geometry of ean coast, to Paleocene–Eocene (67–38 Ma) and tle wedge, and stress conditions in the overriding the subducted Nazca slab to extract values of arc Eocene–Oligocene (27–18 Ma) units along the plate. To constrain long-term variations in past width, slab dip, and slab depth directly below all
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 3 Capaldi et al. | Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern Central Andes Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/3/876/5319346/876.pdf 878 by guest on 28 September 2021 Research Paper
volcanic locations (Fig. 3). Volcano locations ( = n Nazca Slab Depth Nazca Slab Subduction Angle 1344; see Table S21) were derived from the Smith- sonian Institution database (Global Volcanism Slab Depth (km) Slab Dip (°) Program, 2013) and a compilation of South Amer- 25-50 0-5 8° 50-75 8° 5-10 ican bedrock radiometric ages (Pilger, 2018). The Andean arc Andean arc segments 75-100 segments 10-15 geometry of the Nazca slab was constrained by 100-125 15-20 4° 4° geophysical data, which integrated active-source 125-150 20-25 seismic data interpretations, receiver functions, 150-175 25-30 local to regional seismicity catalogs, and seismic 0° 175-200 0° 30-35 200-300 35-40 tomography models to characterize active global 300-400 40-45 subduction zone geometries (Fig. 3; Slab2 model: 4° 400-675 4° 45-50 Hayes et al., 2018). Comparisons between the posi- 50-55 tion of Andean arc volcanic centers and Nazca slab 55-60 8° 8° depth provided the upper and lower limits on the 60-65 65-70 Supporting Information for depth of dehydration melting. From the compiled 70-75 The detrital zircon record of Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern central 12° 12° Andes Andean arc segments, we derived a mean melt-
Capaldi, T.N.1,2*, McKenzie, N.R.3, Horton, B.K.1,4, Mackaman-Lo and, C.1, Colleps, C.L.3, and Stockli, D.F.1 ing depth of 91–150 km (Fig. 3A; Table S3). This 1 Department of Geological Sciences, Jackson School of Geosciences, University of Texas at value is in agreement with the observed locations Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA 16° 16° 2 Now at Department of Geoscience, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Las Vegas, NV 89154, of modern dehydration melting and volcano loca- USA tions above the expected slab depth determined Pleistocene Pleistocene 3 Department of Earth Sciences, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China 20° 20° to Holocene to Holocene 4 Institute for Geophysics, Jackson School of Geosciences, University of Texas at Austin, from tomographic models of the subducting Nazca ( ° S) Latitude ( ° S) Latitude
Austin, TX 78712, USA Volcano Volcano plate (Gilbert et al., 2006; Porter et al., 2012; Bian- n=1343 n=1343 *Corresponding author: Tomas Capaldi ([email protected]) chi et al., 2013). Importantly, this data synthesis 24° 24°
Contents of this le demonstrates a clear relationship for the modern
Text S1 magmatic arc in which progressively lower values 28° 28° Additional Supporting Information (Files uploaded separately) Fig. 1 Fig. 1 Captions for Datasets S1 to S8 of slab dips correlate with progressively greater
Introduction width of the magmatic arc (Fig. 3B; Table S3). 32° 32° Supporting information provided here include detailed metadata for zircon U-Pb and Lu-Hf analyses.
36° 36° Text S1 Calculating Magmatic Arc Width 1
We utilized an extensive data set of igne- 40° 40°
1 ous ages and locations between 28°S and 33°S Supplemental Material. Text S1: Analytical metadata. 500 km 500 km Table S2: Pleistocene–Holocene Andean volcanos and and between 65°W and 72°W to reconstruct arc 44° 44° slab geometry. Table S3: Pleistocene–Holocene volca- width through time. The spatial distribution of nic arc width and melt depth calculations. Table S4: magmatism was constrained by an extensive com- Bedrock geochronology and location compilation. Figure 3. Map of Andean Pleistocene to Holocene volcanic centers compared to Nazca plate geometry (from Table S5: Mesozoic–Cenozoic slab angle calculations. pilation (n = 1409; Table S4) of Phanerozoic bedrock Slab 2.0 models of Hayes et al., 2018). (A) Nazca plate depth from 25 to 675 km. (B) Nazca plate subduction Table S6: Detrital zircon U-Th-Pb data. Table S7: De- radiometric ages (Fig. 4A; Pilger, 2018). Using lon- angle between 0 and 75°. trital zircon Hf data. Table S8: Detrital zircon U‑Th‑Pb gitudinal variations in igneous age, the width of data compilation. Table S9: Zircon Lu-Hf data com- pilation. Please visit https://doi.org/10.1130/GEOS the magmatic arc can be estimated for Cenozoic .S.14251604 to access the supplemental material, and Mesozoic igneous activity, but Paleozoic recon- Cenozoic Andean shortening, including ~100 km of shortening were integrated over the entire data and contact [email protected] with any ques- structions are hampered by limited constraints on of shortening in the Precordillera fold-and-thrust set, assuming shortening occurred during the major tions. Readers can access new zircon Lu-Hf and U‑Pb data by name, sample location, and analyses type Paleozoic deformation. The sample density allowed belt, 10 km of shortening along the Frontal Cordil- phase of Andean shortening (since 20 Ma). From at geochron.org (https://www.geochron.org/results for Cenozoic–Mesozoic arc width to be calculated lera, 15 km of shortening in the Principal Cordillera, this relationship, subduction angle was calculated .php?pkey=29370) and in the supporting information for 2 m.y. intervals, with the exception of the Early and 10 km of shortening along the Coastal Cor- for the Mesozoic–Cenozoic Andean continental arc (Tables S2–S9). Site licensed under Creative Com- mons Attribution Noncommercial‐Share Alike 3.0 and Jurassic (190–170 Ma) magmatic arc (Fig. 4B). These dillera (Cristallini and Ramos, 2000; Farías et al., using the restored arc widths and melt depths of part of the IEDA Data Facility. calculations included palinspastic restoration of 2008; Allmendinger and Judge, 2014). Restorations 91–150 km (Fig. 4C; Table S5).
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 3 Capaldi et al. | Phanerozoic magmatism in the southern Central Andes Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/3/876/5319346/876.pdf 879 by guest on 28 September 2021 Research Paper