Annex B: Impact Assessment

[ Distance Attainment in Ofsted School name from free School type Capacity Impact rating 2011/12 grade school Secondary Schools Forge Valley 3.8 11-19 age range Overall 1350 Well below Inadequate MODERATE: A surplus of places, combined Community School places average with the proximity to the new free school could School Foundation School Date of most mean a moderate level of impact. The Free Overall surplus of The average recent School is unlikely to affect the long term Not a faith school 48 school places points score at Ofsted financial viability of the school overall (3.6% of total level 3 in 2013 is inspection: Mixed school capacity) 559.3 27/03/2013

Brinsworth 4.2 11-19 age range Overall 1487 Above average Good MODERATE: This school is located outside of Comprehensive School places and the proposer group do not expect School Academy The average Date of most to recruit a large number of pupils from this Converter Overall surplus of points score at recent area. The free school is unlikely to affect the 101 school level 3 in 2013 is Ofsted long term financial viability of the school Not a faith school places (6.8% of 717.3 inspection: overall. total school 14/06/2012 Mixed capacity)

UTC Sheffield 4.4 14-19 age range Overall: No No attainment No Ofsted It is too early to assess the impact the capacity data data available grade will have on the UTC University Sheffield that opened earlier this year. Technical College However it is worth noting that the curriculum of the UTC is mainly vocational and Not a faith school engineering based and the Chapeltown Academy offer will be purely academic. Mixed

Distance Attainment in Ofsted School name from free School type Capacity Impact rating 2011/12 grade school All Saints' 4.5 11-19 age range Overall 1244 Well above Outstanding MINIMAL: The school is located over 4 miles Catholic High School places average from the proposed Chapeltown Academy within School Academy Date of most the city centre. Whilst the school may lose a Converter No surplus The average recent few students due the impact will be minimal places points score at Ofsted due to the location, it is rated as an outstanding Roman Catholic level 3 in 2013 is inspection: provider and the fact that the school does not 926.9 11/03/2011 have any surplus places. Mixed

King Edward VII 4.6 11-19 age range Overall 1371 Above average Requires MINIMAL: The school is located over 4.5 miles School School places Improvement and the opposite side of the city centre from Community School The average the proposed Chapeltown Academy. Whilst the Overall surplus of points score at Date of most school may lose a few students the impact will Not a faith school 32 school places level 3 in 2013 is recent be minimal mainly due to the location of the (2.3% of total 787.1 Ofsted school in relation to the Chapeltown Academy. Mixed school capacity) inspection: 19/04/2013 16-19 Colleges Longley Park 1.4 Sixth Form Overall 1323 Below average Requires MODERATE: Due to the current performance Sixth Form College (General) learners Improvement and Ofsted rating of the college the free school College The average could have a high impact. Longley Park’s latest 99.9% of learners points score per Date of most Ofsted report states that “students’ are aged 16-18 student at level recent achievement and their rate of progress vary too 3 in 2013 is Ofsted much and too many do not achieve as well as This is a medium- 651.5 inspection: they should particularly on AS level sized college 15/03/2013 courses”. However the college has a large number of students and provides vocational courses that the free school will not offer. The financial viability of the college could be affected if significant numbers are reduced. Distance Attainment in Ofsted School name from free School type Capacity Impact rating 2011/12 grade school The Sheffield 4.0 Tertiary College Overall 12534 Below average Good MINIMAL: It is worth noting that the College learners Department for Business, Innovation and The average Date of most Skills, has also invested in an extension to the 46.5% of learners points score per recent Hillsborough College (which is a campus for are aged 16-18 student at level Ofsted and located less than 2 3 in 2013 is inspection: miles from the proposed Chapeltown This is a large 608.7 03/05/2013 Academy). However, this college also offers college vocational diplomas, apprenticeships, foundation degrees and caters for adult learners as well as 16-19 students. Even though the college is rated ‘good’ overall, its latest Ofsted report (May 2013) does state that this is not an outstanding provider because “success rates are not yet high enough and students on advanced level courses make insufficient progress”. We therefore assess the impact on the college will be minimal.

Rotherham 4.5 General Further Overall 6093 Well below Good MINIMAL: The College is over 4 miles away College of Arts Education College learners average from the proposed Chapeltown Academy. It and Technology Date of most also has a large number of students (over 37.5% of learners The average recent 6000) of which under 40 % are 16-19 year are aged 16-18 points score per Ofsted olds. The college focuses on providing a range student at level inspection: of vocational courses that the free school will This is a large 3 in 2013 is 24/05/2013 not offer. We therefore assess the impact on college 428.2 the college will be minimal. (vocational average points score) Distance Attainment in Ofsted School name from free School type Capacity Impact rating 2011/12 grade school Thomas 4.7 Sixth Form Overall 1392 Well below Good MODERATE: This college is located outside of (Voluntary learners average Sheffield and the proposer group do not expect College Controlled) Date of most to recruit a large number of students from 99.9% of learners The average recent schools in the Rotherham area. However the are aged 16-18 points score per Ofsted financial viability of the college could be student at level inspection: affected if significant numbers are reduced. This is a medium- 3 in 2013 is 05/01/2014 Also only 5% of students at Thomas sized college 813.1 Rotherham College achieved A level grades AAB or above (in 3 facilitating subjects) in 2013. To put these result in perspective the national average for students achieving A level grades AAB or above (in 3 facilitating subjects) is 9.6%. Dearne Valley 7.2 General Further Overall 2166 Well below Good MINIMAL: The college is located over 7 miles College Education College learners average from the proposed Chapeltown Academy. Date of most Whilst the college may lose a few students the 57.9% of learners The average recent impact will be minimal mainly due to the are aged 16-18 points score per Ofsted location of the college in relation to the student at level inspection: Chapeltown Academy. This is a large 3 in 2013 is 01/01/2014 college 424.4 (vocational APS) 7.8 Tertiary College Overall 5524 Below average Outstanding MINIMAL: The college is located over 7 miles learners from the proposed Chapeltown Academy. The average Date of most Whilst the college may lose a few students the 77.7% of learners points score per recent impact will be minimal mainly due to the are aged 16-18 student at level Ofsted location of the college in relation to the 3 in 2013 is inspection: Chapeltown Academy. This is a large 608.1 05/11/2010 college