Boeing 787–8 Design, Certification, and Manufacturing Systems Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BOEING 787–8 DESIGN, CERTIFICATION, AND MANUFACTURING SYSTEMS REVIEW BOEING 787–8 CRITICAL SYSTEMS REVIEW TEAM March 19, 2014 Prepared for Ms. Dorenda D. Baker Mr. Daniel P. Mooney Director, Aircraft Certification Service Vice President of Boeing South Carolina Federal Aviation Administration Design Center Washington, DC Boeing Commercial Airplanes Seattle, Washington BOEING 787–8 CRITICAL SYSTEMS REVIEW TEAM Michael Kaszycki, Co-chair Rich Ptacin, Co-chair Manager, Transport Standards Staff Director, 787 Deputy Chief Project Engineer FAA Aircraft Certification Service Boeing Commercial Airplanes Christopher B. Bergen Stephen P. Boyd Manager, Phoenix and Van Nuys Manager, Airplane and Flight Crew FAA Manufacturing Inspection District Offices Interface Branch FAA Transport Airplane Directorate TJ Ginthner Jerome R. Hulm Sr. Manager, Regulatory and Quality Associate Technical Fellow System Oversight Boeing Commercial Airplanes Boeing Commercial Airplanes James Mitchell Christopher R. Parker Technical Fellow, Flight Control System Design Aerospace Engineer, Transport and Rotorcraft Boeing Commercial Airplanes Program Manager FAA Seattle Aircraft Certification Office Bradford A. Moravec Brett E. Portwood Chief Engineer, Mission Assurance Technical Specialist for Safety and Integration Propulsion Systems Division FAA Los Angeles Aircraft Certification Office Boeing Commercial Airplanes Jeff Shario Michael H. Song Chief Engineer, Propulsion Safety Director, Quality Engineering and Airworthiness Boeing Commercial Airplanes Boeing Commercial Airplanes Ian Y. Won Aerospace Engineer Airframe/Cabin Safety Branch, FAA Transport Airplane Directorate CSRT Program Support: Kristin Grimlund, Airplane Programs Business Operations, Boeing; and Matthew Bentley, Airplane Level Integration, Boeing Boeing 787–8 Critical Systems Review Team Report Page ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary .......................................................................................................... vii 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Background .......................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Scope of This Review .......................................................................................... 2 1.3. CSRT Membership and Activity ......................................................................... 2 1.3.1. CSRT Meetings .............................................................................................. 3 1.3.2. CSRT Phased Approach ................................................................................ 3 1.3.3. Review of Airplane Design and Design Processes ........................................ 4 2. CSRT Review Analysis—Key Messages ..................................................................... 7 2.1. Introduction .......................................................................................................... 7 2.2. B787 Entry Into Service—Comparison to Other Boeing Airplane Models ........ 7 2.2.1. Data Analysis ................................................................................................. 8 2.2.2. Summary ...................................................................................................... 10 2.3. Component Removals ........................................................................................ 11 2.4. Novel Technologies ........................................................................................... 11 2.5. Business Model .................................................................................................. 12 2.5.1. B787 Systems and Equipment ..................................................................... 12 2.5.2. Manufacturing/Quality ................................................................................. 13 2.5.3. FAA Certificate Management of Large Production Approval Holders ....... 14 2.6. Design Requirements ......................................................................................... 15 2.6.1. Background .................................................................................................. 15 2.6.2. Requirements Issues..................................................................................... 15 2.7. Inspection Delegation ........................................................................................ 17 2.8. Regulatory Oversight—FAA Review and Acceptance Policy .......................... 18 2.9. FAA Engineering Conformity ........................................................................... 19 3. Conclusions ................................................................................................................. 21 3.1. B787 Met Expectations in Service ..................................................................... 21 3.2. Improvement Needed ......................................................................................... 22 3.2.1. Manufacturing/Quality Business Model ...................................................... 22 3.2.2. Design requirements .................................................................................... 22 3.2.3. Inspection Delegation .................................................................................. 23 Boeing 787–8 Critical Systems Review Team Report Page iii 3.2.4. FAA Regulatory Oversight .......................................................................... 23 4. FAA Recommendations .............................................................................................. 24 Appendix A—Deep-Dive Review Summaries .............................................................. A‒1 A.1. Introduction ..................................................................................................... A‒1 A.2. Systems ........................................................................................................... A‒2 A.2.1. Selection Process Summary ...................................................................... A‒5 A.2.2. Observations Summary ............................................................................. A‒5 A.2.3. Conclusions ............................................................................................. A‒11 A.3. Propulsion ..................................................................................................... A‒12 A.3.1. Scope of Subteam Review ...................................................................... A‒15 A.3.2. Selection Process Summary .................................................................... A‒15 A.3.3. Observations Summary ........................................................................... A‒15 A.3.4. Conclusions ............................................................................................. A‒17 A.4. Structures ...................................................................................................... A‒17 A.4.1. Selection Process Summary .................................................................... A‒18 A.4.2. Observations Summary ........................................................................... A‒19 A.4.3. Conclusion .............................................................................................. A‒19 A.5. Manufacturing/Quality .................................................................................. A‒20 A.5.1. Selection Process Summary .................................................................... A‒20 A.5.2. Observations Summary ........................................................................... A‒21 A.5.3. Conclusion .............................................................................................. A‒26 A.6. CSRT Deep-Dive Review Summaries—Observations and Recommendations .................................................................................. A‒27 Appendix B—Acronyms ................................................................................................ B‒1 Cover image ©2013 Boeing. All rights reserved. Boeing 787–8 Critical Systems Review Team Report Page iv LIST OF FIGURES AND TABLES Table 1. CSRT Supplier Visits........................................................................................... 5 Figure 1. Schedule Reliability............................................................................................ 8 Figure 2. B787 vs. B777 EE–1s Since Entry Into Revenue Service.................................. 9 Figure 3. 14 CFR § 21.3 EIS Reporting........................................................................... 10 Figure A–1. B787 Components/Systems Selected for Deep-Dive Review .................. A–1 Figure A–2. Electric Power Generation & Start System .............................................. A–3 Figure A–3. Spoiler Electromechanical Actuators ....................................................... A–4 Figure A–4. Elevator Actuator ...................................................................................... A–4 Figure A–5. Valve Actuator Micro-Switches and Position Indication ....................... A–13 Figure A–6 Main Wing Fuel Tank Access Door Types and Locations ...................... A–14 Figure A–7. Full Flexible Coupling ............................................................................ A–14 Figure A–8. Horizontal Stabilizer and Aft Fuselage Sections 46, 47, and 48 ............ A–18 Figure A–9. Boeing 787 Value Stream Review.........................................................