Underreported Stories on Climate Change and Coral Reefs in These
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Underreported Stories on Climate Change and Coral Reefs in These Times of Diminishing International Reporting: Mining the Scholarly Literature Through Regular Annotated Bibliographies by Lucy A. Higgins B.A., Brown University 2011 A thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Colorado at Boulder in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Arts in Mass Communication and Research School of Journalism and Mass Communication 2013 This thesis entitled: UNDERREPORTED STORIES ON CLIMATE CHANGE AND CORAL REEFS IN THESE TIMES OF DIMINISHING INTERNATIONAL REPORTING: MINING THE SCHOLARLY LITERATURE THROUGH REGULAR ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES By Lucy A. Higgins Has been approved for Journalism and Mass Communication ____________________________ (Bella Mody) ____________________________ (Michael McDevitt) _____________________________ (Sandra Fish) Date ______________ The final copy of this thesis has been examined by the signatories, and we find that both the content and the form meet the acceptable presentation standards of scholarly work in the above mentioned discipline. ii Lucy A. Higgins (M.A., Mass Communication and Research with a certificate in the Environment, Policy, and Society, School of Journalism and Mass Communication) Underreported Stories on Climate Change and Coral Reefs in These Times of Diminishing International Reporting: Mining the Scholarly Literature Through Regular Annotated Bibliographies Thesis direction by Bella Mody ABSTRACT The goal of this project is to explore solutions to the increasingly difficult challenge of covering international environmental topics, such as coral reefs and climate change, during times of constrained budgets, shrinking environmental reporting, and disappearing foreign news bureaus. In this context of limited resources, this study explores whether the periodic bibliographic review of scholarly literature may offer a low-expense avenue for news organizations to sustain or even increase the breadth and depth of coverage of these important topics. This study compares coverage of coral reefs and climate change in scholarly journal articles (2007-2011) to those in the popular press (2007-2012) using the New York Times (NYTimes) as an exemplar of the latter. The extra year in the latter was to allow for a possible time lag in information moving from the scholarly literature to the popular press. Articles on coral reefs and climate change identified in the scholarly literature (239) revealed numerous possibilities for stories that were not covered in the 22 annotated articles on this topic that appeared in the NYTimes. Whereas the most frequently discussed topics in the scholarly literature were the iii relationship between herbivorous fish and coral health, sea surface temperatures (SST), coral bleaching, and the resilience, recovery, and acclimation processes of coral reef ecosystems, the NYTimes’s articles focused on conservation, tourism, SST, and broad discussion of climate change and how it might affect coral reef ecosystems. Additionally, of the 22 NYTimes articles on coral reefs and climate change, only three (14%) included hyperlinks to scholarly articles and 12 (55%) included at least one scientific reference. Overall, this study demonstrates that during these times of declining resources for on-the-spot reporting, scholarly literature represents an affordable but currently underutilized means for news organizations to continue providing wide ranging and detailed coverage of international environmental issues. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would first like to extend many thanks to my thesis advisor, Dr. Bella Mody, for her support, guidance, and revisions through out this project and for mentoring me during my time at the University of Colorado at Boulder. Thank you for the classes, office discussions, and delicious dinners at your home (and for letting me take home the leftovers). I would also like to thank Sandra Fish and Michael McDevitt for their time and consideration in serving on my committee, and for teaching such interesting, well- developed classes over the course of my program. I would like to extend thanks to my family, especially my father, Stephen Higgins, for providing a source of positivity, revisions, and humor. I would be remiss not to include a heartfelt thank you to my boyfriend, Jake O’Connor, who has supported me over the course of this project, and to Mary Cornell, who served as my partner-in-thesis over the past year. Without you all, I would still be glumly annotating sources. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract …………………………………………………………………………..……..iii Table of Contents ......……………….……………………………………………..........vi Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION ...………………………………………………………..1 Chapter 2: LITERATURE REVIEW ………………………………...……………….6 2.1 Context: A Reconfiguration of the Media and a Decline in Media Coverage of Climate Change ………...……………………………………………….………...6 2.2 The Decrease in Foreign Correspondents …………………………..……...…9 2.3 Overview on Coral Reefs and the Impact of Climate Change ………………12 Chapter 3: METHODS ………………………………………………………..……….15 3.1 Time Period…………………………………………………………………..15 3.2 Scholarly Database…………………………………………………………...16 3.3 The Popular Press: The New York Times as an Exemplar……………...........17 Chapter 4: RESULTS ………………………………………………………………… 20 4.1 Topics Covered in the Scholarly Literature …………………………………20 4.1.1 Herbivorous Fish and Coral Reefs …………………………….......22 4.1.2 Sea Surface Temperature, Thermal Sress. Sea-Level Rise ………..24 4.1.3 Coral Bleaching …………………………………………………...26 4.1.4 Coral Reef Resilience and Recovery ……………………………...28 vi 4.1.5 Other Topics in the Scholarly Literature: Ocean Acidification and Marine Reserves and Conservation …………………………………..…29 4.1.6 Research Methods Used in Scholarly Studies …………………….31 4.2 Topics Covered in the New York Times ……………………………….…….32 4.2.1 Conservation ………………………………………………………34 4.2.2 Tourism ……………………………………………………………36 4.2.3 Sea Surface Temperature ………………………………………….37 4.2.4 Climate Change in General ………………………………………..38 4.2.5 NYTimes Sources and Hyperlinks ……………………………...…39 4.3 Comparing the Scholarly and NYTimes Literatures …………………………41 4.3.1 Possible Explanations for Differences …………………………….45 Chapter 5: CONCLUSION ……………………………………………………………49 Chapter 6: FUTURE RESEARCH …………………………………………………...52 REFERENCES ………………………………………………………………….…….. 53 APPENDIX A: Table for Scholarly Literature ………………..………………….….58 APPENDIX B: Table for NYTimes Articles ………………………………………....60 APPENDIX C: NYTimes Annotated Bibliography ………………………………….61 APPENDIX D: Scholarly Journal Articles Annotated Bibliography ………………82 vii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION Coral reef ecosystems are increasingly threatened worldwide by rising sea temperatures and ocean acidification, coupled with other human factors such as sedimentation and pollution, overfishing and destructive fishing, coastal development, and marine pollution and damage (Burke, 2011). At the same time, many US news organizations that could increase awareness and understanding of these threats are downsizing their global operations. For example, Bill Keller (Keller, 2012), the former editor of the New York Times (NYTimes), wrote, News organizations began their retreat from the world a long time ago, driven by economics and a wrongheaded belief that Americans don’t care that much about foreign news…two years ago 18 American newspapers and two entire newspaper chains had closed every one of their overseas bureaus. Other news outlets, including most TV networks, have downsized or abandoned full-time bureaus in favor of reporters or anchors who parachute in when there’s a crisis. They give spurts of coverage…but much less of the ongoing attention that would equip us to see crises coming and understand them when they erupt…Tweets are no substitute for being there… it’s possible we miss a layer of an immensely complicated story when we are not (there)… the price we pay for not being where news happens can be reckoned not only in less good journalism, but in less good policy. Because, make no mistake, some portion of the information governments call ‘intelligence’ is nothing more than an attentive reading of the news. In January of 2013, the NYTimes, Keller’s organization, announced that it was dismantling its nine-person environment desk further reducing availability of resources for adequately reporting on these important environmental developments. Colleges and universities often offer online resources, such as JSTOR, that consolidate scholarly journals, primary sources, and books. Google Scholar also offers readily available scholarly journal articles, many of which can be accessed without a journal subscription. Open databases are becoming more prevalent with the growing 1 debate about whether online journal articles should be free; PLoS (Public Library of Science) is a nonprofit that publishes open-access articles to the public (PLoS, 2013). Rather than continue to bemoan global environmental threats and shrinking foreign and environmental correspondence, I investigate unreported stories journalists might gain from freely available scholarly literature. Consistent with Thomas E. Patterson’s advocacy of knowledge-based journalism, this thesis presents a comparative study of popular press coverage of coral reefs and climate change against coverage in scholarly journal articles over a six-year period, from 2007-201 to benefits that could potentially arise from greater utilization of the scholarly literature in times of declining foreign and environmental correspondence. The purpose