DOCSLIB.ORG

JIRI VALENTA (Monterey, Calif., U.S.A.)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
JIRI VALENTA (Monterey, Calif., U.S.A.) JIRI VALENTA (Monterey, Calif., U.S.A.) Eurocommunism and Czechoslovakia* Eurocommunism of the 1970s and the pluralistic Communism of Czecho- slovakia of the late 1960s share some important similarities, and an exploration of the origins and development of Czechoslovak Communism may help to reveal the roots and the evolution of Eurocommunist ideas and tenets. In addition to the historical aspects of Czechoslovak Communism, I will discuss the mutual influence exerted by Eurocommunism and Czechoslovak Commu- nism upon each other in the 1960s and "1970s, and the consequences of this interaction. A disquisition on Eurocommunism is not necessary at this point, as the subject has been discussed elsewhere by myself and by Vernon Aspaturian.1 Herein I shall use the term not to designate a concept or condition, but, in a somewhat more imprecise and ambiguous fashion, to describe a current trend in the international Communist movement. This trend can be loosely identified as movement toward an independent form of Communism that, unlike the Soviet, is pluralistic in nature. Despite the ambiguous confines of this tenden- cy, Eurocommunism emerges as something more than a myth or the "pseudo- phenomenon" some have labelled it.2 Indeed, such West European Commu- nist officials as Spanish Communist Party (PCE) leader Santiago Carrillo and Italian Communist Party (PCI) leader Enrico Berlinguer have embraced the term as a convenient, though somewhat sloppy, shorthand for their parties' searches for a pluralistic, independent form of Communism. Carrillo traced *In writing this article I utilized my previous research on the history of Czechoslovak Communism undertaken with the late Professor Josef Korbel in preparation for his book Twentieth-Century Czechoslovakia: The Meanings of Its History (New York: Columbia Univ. Press, 1977). I have also benefited from interviews that I conducted with many Czechoslovakofficials-former members of Alexander Dubcek's government-and many of Dub?ek'sadvisers, including scholars and dissidents now living 111Western countfies. 1. See Jiri Valenta, "Eurocommunism and Eastern Europe: Promise or Threat?" pre- sented at the National Convention of the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies, October, 1977; Jiri Valenta, "Eurocommunism and Eastern Europe," Problems of Communism, 17, No. 2 (March-April1978), 41-54; and Jiri Valenta, "Euro. communism and Eastern Europe," in Teresa Rakowska-Harmstoneand Andrew Gyorgy, eds., Communism in Eastern Europe (Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press, 1979), pp. 290- 307. See also Vernon V. Aspaturian, "Conceptualizing Eurocommunism: Some Prelimi- nary Observations," in V. V. Aspaturian, J. Valenta and D. Burke, eds., Eurocommunism between East and West(Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press, 1980). 2. See, for example, Angelo M. Codevilla,"Eurocommunism, a Pseudophenomenon," Strategic Review (Fall 1978), pp. 62-70. 18 the evolution of the Eurocommunist trend in his "Eurocomunismo "y estado, the publication of which brought him into collision with conservative ideolo- gists in the USSR and Eastern Europe. The concept of Eurocommunism also exists in the minds of many conser- vative leaders in Eastern Europe. While there are those who continue to doubt its existence, some (such as the Czechoslovak leaders Vasil Bil'ak and Jan Fojtik) see Eurocommunism as a viable threat. For these men, Eurocom- - munism is an "instrument of anticommunism" designed to undermine the foundations of "real socialism" in Czechoslovakia and to return to power such "right-wing opportunists" and "traitors" as Alexander Dub?ek.3 Unlike most East European countries, Czechoslovakia shares many cultural values and political traditions with Western Europe. The prevailing democratic tradition has been a main force in the development of a Communism that is unique in Eastern Europe.4 Czechoslovak Communism is characterized by two main tendencies: the first, authoritarian (Leninist and/or Stalinist); the second, more democratic and pluralistic. H. Gordon Skilling has persuasively argued that this dualism helps to explain some of the dramatic shifts and crises in Czechoslovak Communism since 1921.5 The prevailing traditions and po- litical culture in Czechoslovakia as they have affected the dualism in Czecho- slovak Communism must first be explored in order to assess the origins and development of pluralistic, reform Communism, leading to the Eurocommu- nist-type renaissance of 1968. , Democratic Traditions in Czechoslovakia The dominant tradition in Czechoslovakia has been pro-Western and demo- cratic. There is a deeply rooted heritage of Protestant religious reform-Hussi- tism-that came to life in the Czech lands one hundred years before it surfaced elsewhere in Europe. The Czech Protestant ethic stressed the ideas of equality, tolerance, reason, and individualism.6 Despite the forced conversions to Ca- tholicism in the seventeenth century, the persecution of the Protestants during the early stages of Austrian rule, and the numerical majority of Catholics, the Protestant ethic survived as an important factor in shaping the character of 3. See, for example, Jan Fojti'k, 7Hbuna (PTaha) 19 April 1978. 4. Aspaturian, "Conceptualizing Eurocommunism." 5. See H. Gordon Skilling, Czechoslovakia's Interrupted Revolution (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press, 1976), pp. 21-42. Skilling has also scrutined the Stalinist trend in an excellent essay, "Stalinism and CzechoslovakPolitical Culture," in Robert C. Tucker, ed., Stalinism: Essays in Historical Interpretation(New York: Norton, 1979), pp. 257-82. 6. For studies treating Communism and Czechoslovak tradition, see H. Gordon Skil- ling, "Communism and CzechoslovakTraditions," Journal of International Affairs, 20, No. 1 (1966), 118-36; Paul E. Zinner, Communist Strategy and Tactics in Czechoslovak- kia, 1918-48 (New York: Praeger, 1963), pp. 5-24; and Galia Golan, "The Democratic- liberal Traditions in the Czech Lands," an unpublished paper. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • PCE, Santiago Carrillo: Enero De 1977 O El Giro Sacrificial De La Transición1
    3­02 Sanchez­Biosca, Vicente_EMP 1 14/06/2016 1:11 Página 49 PCE, Santiago Carrillo: enero de 1977 o el giro sacrificial de la Transición1 Vicente SÁNCHEZ­BIOSCA Universidad de Valencia [email protected] Recibido: 10 de octubre de 2015 Aceptado: 30 de marzo de 2016 Resumen La Transición española a la democracia ha sido objeto de uno de los más sólidos relatos construidos por el periodismo y refrendado por la sociedad civil. En su corazón tiene lugar un momento de violencia que se concentra en la llamada semana negra de enero de 1977, cuyo clímax está representado por la matanza de Atocha. El presente artículo analiza las distintas etapas de cristalización de ese relato: un capítulo de La Transición (Elías Andrés, Victoria Prego, 1995), Siete días de enero (J.A. Bardem, 1978), un repor­ taje de Interviú (febrero de 1977) y las crónicas periodísticas de El País, Diario16 y Mundo Obrero. Es­ pecial atención se presta a la figura de Santiago Carrillo, identificado con la estrategia del PCE, cuya consideración cambió radicalmente durante esa semana. Palabras clave: Transición democrática en España, Carrillo y PCE, Carisma y Transición, violencia fas­ cista, comunismo. The Spanish Communist Party, Santiago Carrillo: January 1977, or the sacrificial turning point in the Spanish Transition to Democracy Abstract The Spanish Transition to democracy has originated one of the most solid narratives built by the press in recent History. Its turning point is represented by the acts of violence that spread in Madrid during the so­called ‘black week’ (end of January 1977). Its apex was the massacre of a group of communist law­ yers by fascist gunmen.
    [Show full text]
  • Legitimacy by Proxy: Searching for a Usable Past Through the International Brigades in Spain's Post-Franco Democracy, 1975-201
    This is a repository copy of Legitimacy by Proxy: searching for a usable past through the International Brigades in Spain’s post-Franco democracy, 1975-2015. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/93332/ Version: Accepted Version Article: Marco, J and Anderson, PP (2016) Legitimacy by Proxy: searching for a usable past through the International Brigades in Spain’s post-Franco democracy, 1975-2015. Journal of Modern European History, 14 (3). pp. 391-410. ISSN 1611-8944 10.17104/1611-8944-2016-3-391 (c) 2016, Verlag C.H. Beck. This is an author produced version of a paper published in the Journal of Modern European History. Uploaded in accordance with the publisher's self-archiving policy. Reuse Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record for the item. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Legitimacy by Proxy: searching for a usable past through the International Brigades in Spain’s post-Franco democracy, 1975-2015 INTRODUCTION The 23 October 2011 marked the 75th anniversary of the official creation of the International Brigades.
    [Show full text]
  • (PCE M-L) Elena Ódena, Exemplary Communist
    Encyclopedia of Anti-Revisionism On-Line * Spain Communist Party of Spain M-L (PCE M-L) Elena Ódena, exemplary communist First Published: November 2013 http://pceml.info/actual/index.php/60-hemeroteca/biblioteca- marxista/elena-odena/300-elena-odena-comunista-ejemplar Transcription, Editing and Markup: Paul Saba and Sam Richards Copyright: This work is in the Public Domain under the Creative Commons Common Deed. You can freely copy, distribute and display this work; as well as make derivative and commercial works. Please credit the Encyclopedia of Anti-Revisionism On-Line as your source, include the url to this work, and note any of the transcribers, editors & proofreaders above. By Efrén H. | It is common to hear that no person is indispensable or irreplaceable. As a general rule, this principle is correct, but there are cases in which the disappearance of certain men and women, due to their exceptional qualities, leaves an immense vacuum difficult to fill. This is the case of Elena Ódena, founder, along with Raúl Marco, of the Communist Party of Spain (Marxist-Leninist). Woman committed from a very young age to the struggle of the working class, dedicated her life to the cause of communism, always defending the principles of Marxism-Leninism. PCE militant, she fought firmly against revisionist deviations and Khrushchev's lies about Stalin. That is why the great historian Pierre Vilar stressed "the fidelity of Elena to the three thinkers, the three revolutionary creators, Marx who foresaw the revolution, Lenin who made the revolution, Stalin who built the revolution and saved it, winning the war against the fascisms.
    [Show full text]
  • Santiago Carrillo Solares
    fundación TRANSICIÓN española Santiago Carrillo Solares Nacido en Gijón en 1915, pasó su primera infancia en Asturias, Santiago Carrillo se traslada junto a su familia a Madrid e ingresa en el Grupo Escolar Cervantes, donde es seleccionado para cursar bachillerato pero al no poder pagar los derechos de examen comenzó a trabajar como aprendiz en una imprenta. Poco después se afilia a las Juventudes Socialistas de España (JJ.SS.) y a la Unión General de Trabajadores (UGT). En 1930 comienza a colaborar como periodista en El Socialista y el 14 de abril de 1931 la República, se le encarga cubrir la información parlamentaria. Desde la dirección de la revista de las JJ.SS. Renovación, a la que accede en 1933, defiende su posición revolucionaria extendiéndola en el seno deEspañola las Juventudes. En 1934, fue nombrado secretario de las Juventudes Socialistas, momento en el cual existían dos corrientes en el PSOE, el de los reformistas de Besteiro y Prieto y el de los revolucionarios de Largo Caballero con el que Carrillo colabora estrechamente. Toma parte en el movimiento revolucionario de Asturias, lo que le lleva a la cárcel hasta que, tras la victoria del Frente Popular en las elecciones del 16 de febrero de 1936, es puesto en libertad. Al salir de prisión, los representantes de la Internacional Comunista en España le proponen y organizan un viaje a Moscú con las direcciones de las TRANSICIÓNJuventudes Socialistas y Juventudes Comunistas. A su regreso a España, la unificación de ambas formaciones no tarda en producirse, y en este proceso la nueva organización experimenta un espectacular crecimiento de afiliados.
    [Show full text]
  • THE SPANISH LEFT: ILLUSION and REALITY Lorenzo Torres
    THE SPANISH LEFT: ILLUSION AND REALITY Lorenzo Torres THE present crisis of the Spanish Left-and it is a real crisis we shall be discassing-is the result of a whole series of complex prob- lems, international as well as national. By national we mean primarily the growing lack of agreement between the policies and political activity of the parties of the traditional Left, and the actual situation in Spain. By international we refer to the crisis in the international workers' movement-the crisis of Stalinism, the Russo-Chinese con- troversy, the degeneration of Social-Democracy-all of which find an echo among the membership of the Spanish Workers' organiza- tions. These two sets of problems naturally interact one with the other. Within Spain. despite the present confusion, we are beginning to see emerge new critical forces, from within which a new socialist policy may come. That is the hope: of a programme for the future that will be based on Spanish and international realities and no longer on the out of date anti-Franco-ist dreams and disreputable compromises. The terrible defeat of 1939 naturally has taken many years before its effects have been overcome, even though a considerable number of working class leaders succeeded in escaping abroad. They, and the nucleus in Spain itself which in one way or another managed to escape being shot or imprisoned, rested all their hopes upon the defeat of Nazism and international Fascism. In 1945, on the morrow of the liberation of Europe from Fascism, the whole world seemed con- vinced that the Franco ri5gime would soon suffer a similar fate.
    [Show full text]
  • Eurocommunism: a Discussion of Carrillo's "Eurocommunism and the State" Sam Aaronovitch 1
    222 MARXISM TODAY, JULY, 1978 Eurocommunism: a discussion of Carrillo's "Eurocommunism and the State" Sam Aaronovitch 1. Introduction contents" but basing myself on his book and on Santiago Carrillo took the chance to write this other documents by communist parties and individ­ book in 1976 after entering Spain "illegally" in order, ual communists let me propose this as reasonably as he says, to tackle "one of the most confused and summarising this view. difficult questions confronting a communist today." First: the Soviet model of 1917 is an inappropriate It is not a major and original contribution to Marxist one for advanced capitalist societies which have theory but it is, nevertheless, an important and powerful and extensive state structures, developed liberating book written in a simple and direct way. civil society (i.e. a dense network of social, cultural Part of its importance rests in the fact that the and political groupings based on voluntary commit­ general secretary of an important communist ment), and considerable democratic traditions and party has written a book which begins to break with practices. past traditions and reflexes in the international Second, in such societies, the road to socialism communist movement and which gives reasons for a involves the working class, through its organisations, strategy which has attracted to itself the name of actually developing its own unity and building a Eurocommunism. Of course, that title is not strictly series of alliances which put it in a leading (hege­ accurate. It is applied to communist parties such as monic) position in all spheres of economic, social and the Japanese which are not European and would be political life thus enabling it to speak for the people rejected by some communist parties in European as a whole.
    [Show full text]
  • The Times, the Spectator. April 1978
    Speedier handover to Catalans presse From Harry Debelius himself and Señor Tarradellas. Madrid, April 3 s " We both agree to work for Señor Josep Tarrädellas, the a more democratic Spain, . to president of the Generalität, the strengthen the. unity, of Spain Catalan regional government, through the establishment of conferred in Madrid today with home rule." Señor Adolfo Suárez, the Prime Although neither. of the two Minister, and other political mentioned it, one . of the and military leaders in an toughest points in the negotia-. effort to speed up the transfer tions about the degree of of responsibilities and authori• autonomy for Catalonia is the ties to the Generalität. ^ matter of taxes and government After a one-hour meeting expenditure. ',. with the Prime Minister, Señor Señor Manuel Fraga Iribarne, Tarradellas said that it had been the leader of the conservative as cordial as the previous ones, Popular Alliance and former but he refused to disclose what Minister of the Interior, said had been discussed. He denied in Granada at the weekend that that a proposal to establish full the death penalty should be legal parity between'Castilian mandatory for the killing of a Spanish and the Catalan lan• policeman. He also called for guage was the most important a law to increase police powers of the matters under discussion. to deal, with terrorism. i; Princess returns: Princess Irene Señor . Tarradellas • told of Holland, wife of Prince reporters that he would meet Carlos Hugo de Bourbon-Parma, Señor Suárez- again on Thurs• leader of the Spanish Car list day.' He then left for talks with Party, returned to Spain today Lieutenant-General Manuel after nine years in exile.
    [Show full text]
  • 103-3-Ayer103 OTAN.Pdf
    La última batalla de la transición, la primera... Emanuele Treglia Ayer 103/2016 (3): 71-96 ISSN: 1134-2277 La última batalla de la transición, la primera de la democracia. La oposición a la OTAN y las transformaciones del PCE (1981-1986) * Emanuele Treglia LUISS-CIHDE Resumen: El propósito del presente artículo consiste en analizar el desa- rrollo experimentado por el movimiento de oposición a la OTAN en- tre 1981 y 1986, centrando la atención en un sujeto que fue uno de sus protagonistas: el PCE. El estudio seguirá dos líneas: por un lado, ilus- trará cómo el «partido del antifranquismo» participó en las dinámicas que caracterizaron las protestas contra la pertenencia a la Alianza At- lántica; por el otro, evidenciará la influencia que dicha participación ejerció en las transformaciones que en este periodo afectaron a la polí- tica y a la estructura organizativa de los comunistas españoles. Palabras clave: referéndum OTAN, PCE, Izquierda Unida, euromisiles, movimiento pacifista. Abstract: This article aims to analyse the development experienced by the Spanish anti-NATO movement between 1981 and 1986, focusing on one of its protagonists: the Communist Party of Spain. The study will follow two lines: on the one hand, it will illustrate how the «party of an- tifrancoism» participated in the dynamics that characterised the protests against NATO membership; on the other hand, it will highlight how this participation influenced the transformations undergone during this pe- riod by the communists’ politics and by its organisational structure. Keywords: NATO Referendum, Partido Comunista Español (Spanish Communist Party), Izquierda Unida, euromissiles crisis, peace movement.
    [Show full text]
  • El PCE Y El Movimiento Comunista Internacional (1969-1977)*
    El PCE y el movimiento comunista internacional (1969-1977)* Emanuele TREGLIA LUISS-CIHDE [email protected] Recibido: 28/01/2015 Aceptado: 15/09/2015 RESUMEN El artículo se centra en la actividad internacional del Partido Comunista de España (PCE) desde las se- cuelas de la represión de la Primavera de Praga hasta 1977. Fue un período caracterizado por el principio del declive definitivo del movimiento comunista internacional. El análisis abarca múltiples cuestiones. Examina las crecientes críticas del PCE hacia el modelo soviético, y sus repercusiones en las relaciones entre el partido liderado por Santiago Carrillo y el movimiento comunista. Además, el artículo explora el intento del PCE de promover un nuevo tipo de internacionalismo en Europa occidental, auspiciando una renovada colaboración entre comunistas y socialistas y aprovechando las condiciones brindadas por la distensión. En este contexto tuvo lugar el surgimiento del eurocomunismo, que el ensayo analiza ilustrando los factores internos y externos que determinaron su crisis en la segunda mitad de los setenta. Palabras clave: movimiento comunista internacional, eurocomunismo, PCE, Santiago Carrillo, PCI, Unión Soviética, Guerra Fría, distensión, Transición. The Communist Party of Spain and the International Communist Movement (1969-1977) ABSTRACT This article focuses on the international activity of the Communist Party of Spain (PCE) since the after- math of the Prague Spring’s repression until 1977. It was a period characterized by the beginning of the definitive decline of the international communist movement. The analysis takes into account multiple dimensions. It examines the PCE’s growing criticism towards the soviet model, and its repercussions on the relations between the party leaded by Santiago Carrillo and the communist movement.
    [Show full text]
  • El «Eurocomunismo» De Santiago Carrillo Y La «Revolución
    El «eurocomunismo» de Santiago Carrillo y la «revolución democrática y nacional» de Álvaro Cunhal: la política de los partidos comunistas en el final de las dictaduras en la Península Ibérica, 1974-1978 Raquel Varela ISCTE, Universidad de Lisboa «El segmento humano con el que habrá mayor dificultad para explicar la transición no serán los resentidos, ni los envidiosos, ni los perdedores, ni los violentos, ni los extranjeros. Serán los niños. No es fácil hacer pedagogía con la transición. Primero habrá que explicarles los personajes, luego las situaciones y, por fin, el resultado. Corremos el riesgo de que el no lo entiendan el se ofendan. Se necesita edad para comprender la transición. Lo idóneo es la ancianidad porque permite ese bello tono distante que empieza siempre diciendo '... si yo te contara...'». Gregorio Morán, El Precio de la Transición «Portugal es España» «De hecho en Portugal la dictadura de Salazar ha caído bajo la acción de algo que se asemeja mucho al pacto para la libertad que nosotros preconizamos para liquidar la dictadura fascista en España: la convergencia, en un momento dado, entre el movimiento obrero y popular y los grupos neocapitalistas (...)1». La declaración es de Santiago Carrillo, principal dirigente comunista de España –un país que vivía bajo la más grande movilización de masas desde la guerra civil. El líder comunista defiende aún en esta entrevista a Radio España Independiente la inmensa repercusión de los acontecimientos portugueses en su país; habla de Portugal como el país que enseña al país vecino como resolver su «problema nacional» y aún del extraordinario ejemplo del secretario-general del PCP, Álvaro Cunhal.
    [Show full text]
  • La Madre De Todos Los Camaradas». Dolores Ibárruri
    «La madre de todos los camaradas». Dolores Ibárruri... David Ginard i Féron Ayer 90/2013 (2): 189-216 ISSN: 1134-2277 «La madre de todos los camaradas». Dolores Ibárruri como símbolo movilizador, de la Guerra Civil a la transición posfranquista David Ginard i Féron Universitat de les Illes Balears Resumen: El siguiente trabajo aborda el proceso de construcción del sím- bolo «Pasionaria» como elemento de movilización y legitimación social por parte del Partido Comunista de España. Su singular biografía, su longevidad y las dimensiones internacionales de la Guerra Civil espa- ñola propiciaron su aparición, desarrollo y extensión. El culto a Dolo- res Ibárruri se inició durante los años treinta del siglo XX y desde en- tonces ha ido adaptándose a las necesidades de este partido político y a las circunstancias de cada periodo histórico. Palabras clave: mito, símbolo, comunismo, identidades militantes, culto a la personalidad. Abstract: This paper describes the process of constructing the symbol «Pa- sionaria» as an element of social mobilization and legitimacy of the Communist Party of Spain. Her unique biography, and longevity as well as the international dimensions of the Spanish Civil War led to its emergence, development and extension. The cult of Dolores Ibarruri began during the thirties of the twentieth century and has since been adapted to the needs of this political party and the circumstances of each historical period. Keywords: myth, symbol, communism, militant identities, cult of per- sonality. Uno de los rasgos esenciales de la cultura política que singularizó al movimiento comunista del siglo XX fue la articulación de un va- riado conjunto de recursos simbólicos que ejercían un poderoso in- Recibido: 10-12-2011 Aceptado: 25-05-2012 David Ginard i Féron «La madre de todos los camaradas».
    [Show full text]
  • El Discurso Político De Santiago Carrillo Durante La Transición
    Antonio Pantoja Chaves. El discurso político de Santiago Carrillo durante la Transición. Aplicaciones metodológicas. The political discourse of Santiago Carrillo in the process of Democratic Transition. Methodological applications. Antonio Pantoja Chaves. Facultad de Formación del Profesorado. Universidad de Extremadura Recibido el 2 de enero de 2009. Aprobado el 12 de abril de 2009. Resumen: Continuando con el análisis de los discursos de los líderes más importantes del proceso de Transición democrática en España, en esta entrega nos centramos en la trayectoria política de Santiago Carrillo y su liderazgo del comunismo en España. A diferencia del resto de los oradores analizados, su perfil no muestra ningún punto de inflexión que refuerce su discurso, más bien asiste a un declive continuo y progresivo, desde un discurso que equilibra dos posiciones contrarias ante un auditorio comprometido y agraciado por las palabras del orador, hasta presentar un perfil que reproduce el eclipse de la autoridad del líder comunista. Palabras clave: Discurso político. Análisis metodológico. Santiago Carrillo. Comunismo español. Summary: Continuing with the analysis of the speeches of the most important leaders of the democratic transition process in Spain, in this installment we focus on the political trajectory of Santiago Carrillo and his leadership of communism in Spain. Unlike the rest of the speakers discussed, his profile shows no turning point to strengthen his speech, rather attends a continuous and progressive decline, from a speech that balances two opposing positions before an audience engaged and graced by the speaker's words, to present a profile that reproduces the eclipse of the communist leader's authority.
    [Show full text]