UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION Washington, DC
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION Washington, DC In the Matter of Investigation No. 337-TA-___ CERTAIN FOOTWEAR PRODUCTS COMPLAINT UNDER SECTION 337 OF THE TARIFF ACT OF 1930, AS AMENDED COMPLAINANT PROPOSED RESPONDENTS Converse Inc. Skechers U.S.A., Inc. One High Street 228 Manhattan Beach Boulevard North Andover, Massachusetts 01845 Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 978-983-2774 800-746-3411 [email protected] COUNSEL FOR COMPLAINANT www.skechers.com V. James Adduci, II Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Deanna Tanner Okun 702 SW 8th Street Jonathan J. Engler Bentonville, AR 72716-8611 Thomas R. Burns, Jr. 479-273-4000 Asha Allam www.walmart.com Evan H. Langdon Lauren E. Peterson A-List, Inc., d/b/a Kitson ADDUCI, MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG, LLP 115 South Robertson Boulevard 1133 Connecticut Avenue, N.W., 12th Floor Los Angeles, CA 90048 Washington, DC 20036 310-859-2652 Telephone: (202) 467-6300 www.shopkitson.com Facsimile: (202) 466-2006 Aldo Group Christopher J. Renk 2300 Émile-Bélanger Erik S. Maurer Montreal, Quebec Michael J. Harris H4R 3J4 Katherine Laatsch Fink Canada Audra C. Eidem Heinze www.aldoshoes.com Aaron P. Bowling BANNER & WITCOFF, LTD. Brian Lichtenberg, LLC Ten South Wacker Drive, Suite 3000 825 1/2 Silver Lake Boulevard Chicago, IL 60606 Los Angeles, CA 90026 Telephone: (312) 463-5000 www.brianlichtenberg.com Facsimile: (312) 463-5001 Cmerit USA, Inc., d/b/a Gotta Flurt 13875 Ramona Avenue Chino, CA 91710 909-590-8898 www.cmeritusa.com www.gottaflurt.com Dioniso SRL via Pievaiola 166-f2 06132 Perugia Italy 39-075-528-7168 [email protected] www.blackdioniso.com Edamame Kids, Inc. 1911-34 Avenue SW Calgary, Alberta T2T 2C2 Canada Esquire Footwear, LLC 385 5th Avenue, Second Floor New York, NY 10016 212-695-4140 www.esquirefootwear.com FILA U.S.A., Inc. 930 Ridgebrook Road Suite 200 Sparks, MD 21152 410-773-3000 www.fila.com Fortune Dynamic, Inc. 21923 Ferrero Parkway City of Industry, CA 91789 909-979-8318 www.fortunedynamic.com Gina Group, LLC 10 West 33rd St # 312 New York, NY 10001 212-947-2445 [email protected] www.ginagroup.com ii H & M Hennes & Mauritz LP 215 Park Avenue South, 15th floor New York, NY 10003 212-564-9922 www.hm.com Highline United LLC d/b/a Ash Footwear USA 44 Mercer Street New York, NY 10013 617-333-3235 888-497-6005 [email protected] www.ashfootwearusa.com Hitch Enterprises Pty Ltd d/b/a Skeanie Unit 3 13 Lyell Street Mittagong, New South Wales 2575 Australia www.skeanie.com Iconix Brand Group, Inc., d/b/a Ed Hardy 1450 Broadway, 3rd and 4th Floor New York, NY 10018 212-730-0030 [email protected] www.iconixbrand.com Kmart Corporation 3333 Beverly Road Hoffman Estates, IL 60179 847-286-2500 www.kmart.com Mamiye Imports LLC d/b/a Lilly of New York 1841 East 8th St Brooklyn, NY 11223 718-627-3579 Nowhere Co., Ltd. d/b/a Bape 4-22-3, Sendagaya Shibuya-Ku, 151-0051 Tokyo Japan us.bape.com iii OPPO Original Corp 108 - 118 Brea Canyon Road City of Industry, CA 91789-3086 909-444-3000 Orange Clubwear, Inc., d/b/a Demonia Deviant 14726 Goldenwest Street, Suite B Westminster, CA 92683 954-986-4152 714-610-8200 www.orangeclubwear.com www.demonia.co.uk Ositos Shoes, Inc., d/b/a Collection’O 9605 Rush Street South El Monte, CA 91733 626-579-4500 PW Shoes Inc. 58-30 Grand Avenue #3A Maspeth, NY 11378 718-366-6688 www.nypwshoes.com Ralph Lauren Corporation 650 Madison Avenue New York, NY 10022-1070 212-318-7000 www.ralphlauren.com Shenzhen Foreversun Industrial Co., Ltd (a/k/a Shenzhen Foreversun Shoes Co., Ltd) Room 1109-1112 F11 Yousong Science &Technology Bldg. 1st Road of Donghuan, Longhua Bao’an, Shenzhen Guangdong Province China Zip code: 518109 86-755-83545482 [email protected] www.cn-foreversun.com iv Shoe Shox c/o Zulily, Inc. 2601 Elliott Avenue, Suite 200 Seattle, Washington 98121 877-779-5614 www.zulily.com Tory Burch LLC 11 West 19th Street, 7th Floor New York, NY 10011-4277 212-683-2323 www.toryburch.com Zulily, Inc. 2601 Elliott Avenue, Suite 200 Seattle, Washington 98121 877-779-5614 www.zulily.com Fujian Xinya I&E Trading Co. Ltd. Floor 4 Building A China Shoes Capital ChendaiTown, Jinjiang Fujian Province China Zip code: 362200 86-0595-82012227 86-0595-36205555 www.china0595.com Zhejiang Ouhai International Trade Co. Ltd. Building B Jinzhou Building Wenzhou Avenue, Wenzhou Zhejiang Province China Zip code: 325000 86-577-88000112 www.jinzhougroup.com v Wenzhou Cereals Oils & Foodstuffs Foreign Trade Co. Ltd. 24th Floor International Trade Centre 236 Liming West Road, Wenzhou Zhejiang Province China Zip Code: 325003 86-577-88895700 86-577-88890816 [email protected] cofwz.com vi TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................1 II. THE CONVERSE TRADEMARKS AT ISSUE ..................................................................3 A. Converse’s Iconic Midsole Design ................................................................................4 1. The Converse Midsole Trademark is Famous ................................................................5 2. The Converse Midsole Trademark is Federally Registered .......................................... 13 B. Converse’s Iconic Outsole Design ............................................................................... 14 C. No Licenses Under the Asserted Trademarks............................................................... 18 III. COMPLAINANT CONVERSE ......................................................................................... 18 A. History of Converse .................................................................................................... 19 B. Converse Brand Protection – Counterfeiters ................................................................ 20 C. Converse Brand Protection – Knockoffs ...................................................................... 22 IV. PROPOSED RESPONDENTS .......................................................................................... 24 A. Skechers U.S.A., Inc. .................................................................................................. 28 B. Walmart Stores, Inc. .................................................................................................... 38 C. A-List, Inc. d/b/a Kitson .............................................................................................. 43 D. Aldo Group ................................................................................................................. 48 E. Brian Lichtenberg, LLC .............................................................................................. 52 F. Cmerit USA Inc. d/b/a Gotta Flurt ............................................................................... 56 G. Dioniso, SRL .............................................................................................................. 60 H. Edamame Kids, Inc. .................................................................................................... 64 I. Esquire Footwear ........................................................................................................ 68 J. FILA U.S.A., Inc. ........................................................................................................ 72 K. Fortune Dynamic, Inc. ................................................................................................. 75 L. Gina Group, LLC ........................................................................................................ 80 M. H & M Hennes & Mauritz LP ..................................................................................... 83 N. Highline United LLC d/b/a ASH Footwear USA ......................................................... 87 O. Hitch Enterprises Pty Ltd. d/b/a Skeanie ...................................................................... 91 P. Iconix Brand Group, Inc. d/b/a Ed Hardy .................................................................... 95 Q. Kmart Corporation ...................................................................................................... 99 R. Mamiye Imports LLC d/b/a Lilly of New York ......................................................... 104 S. Nowhere Co. Ltd. d/b/a Bape .................................................................................... 108 T. OPPO Original Corp. ................................................................................................ 112 U. Orange Clubwear, Inc. d/b/a Demonia Deviant .......................................................... 116 vii V. Ositos Shoes, Inc. d/b/a Collection’O ........................................................................ 120 W. PW Shoes Inc. ........................................................................................................... 123 X. Ralph Lauren Corporation ......................................................................................... 128 Y. Shenzhen Foreversun Industrial Co., Ltd (aka Shenzhen Foreversun Shoes Co., Ltd) ......................................................................................................... 132 Z. Shoe Shox ................................................................................................................. 136 AA. Tory Burch LLC........................................................................................................ 140 BB. Zulily, Inc. ................................................................................................................ 143 CC. Fujian Xinya I&E Trading Co. Ltd. ..........................................................................