Research Paper
GEOSPHERE Tectonostratigraphic record of late Miocene–early Pliocene transtensional faulting in the Eastern California shear zone, GEOSPHERE, v. 17, no. 4 southwestern USA https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02337.1 Rebecca J. Dorsey1, Brennan O’Connell1,*, Kevin K. Gardner1, Mindy B. Homan1,†, Scott E.K. Bennett2, Jacob O. Thacker3, and Michael H. Darin1,4 15 figures; 1 table 1Department of Earth Sciences, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon 97403, USA 2Geology, Minerals, Energy, and Geophysics Science Center, U.S. Geological Survey, 2130 SW 5th Avenue, Portland, Oregon 97201, USA CORRESPONDENCE: [email protected] 3New Mexico Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Socorro, New Mexico 87801, USA 4Nevada Bureau of Mines and Geology, University of Nevada, Virginia Street, Reno, Nevada 89557, USA
CITATION: Dorsey, R.J., O’Connell, B., Gardner, K.K., Homan, M.B., Bennett, S.E.K., Thacker, J.O., and Darin, M.H., 2021, Tectonostratigraphic record of late ABSTRACT shows that the southern Blythe Basin was part 2015, 2016a, 2016b, 2017; Darin et al., 2016; Umhoefer Miocene–early Pliocene transtensional faulting in of a diffuse regional network of linked right-step- et al., 2018). The ECSZ can be divided into a western the Eastern California shear zone, southwestern USA: Geosphere, v. 17, no. 4, p. 1101–1125, https://doi.org The Eastern California shear zone (ECSZ; ping dextral, normal, and oblique-slip faults belt of active deformation (modern ECSZ) defined /10.1130/GES02337.1. southwestern USA) accommodates ~20%–25% of related to Pacific–North America plate boundary by GPS motions, modern seismicity, and Quater- Pacific–North America relative plate motion east dextral shear. Diffuse transtensional strain linked nary-active faults (e.g., Oskin et al., 2008; Spinler et Science Editor: Andrea Hampel of the San Andreas fault, yet little is known about northward to the Stateline fault system, eastern al., 2010; Parsons et al., 2013; Zeng and Shen, 2014, Associate Editor: Andrea Fildani its early tectonic evolution. This paper presents Garlock fault, and Walker Lane, and southward to 2016; U.S. Geological Survey and California Geolog- a detailed stratigraphic and structural analysis of the Gulf of California shear zone, which initiated ical Survey, 2020) and an eastern belt (paleo-ECSZ) Received 19 August 2020 Revision received 14 January 2021 the uppermost Miocene to lower Pliocene Bouse ca. 7–9 Ma, implying a similar age of inception for that displays slow to negligible modern strain and Accepted 19 March 2021 Formation in the southern Blythe Basin, lower the paleo-ECSZ. is defined by structures that were active in Miocene Colorado River valley, where gently dipping and time but are now mostly inactive (e.g., Guest et al., Published online 14 May 2021 faulted strata provide a record of deformation 2007; Mahan et al., 2009) (Fig. 1). The onset of fault- in the paleo-ECSZ. In the western Trigo Moun- ■■ INTRODUCTION ing in the ECSZ is poorly known, with proposed ages tains, splaying strands of the Lost Trigo fault zone of initiation ranging from ca. 10–12 Ma (Dokka and include a west-dipping normal fault that cuts the The eastern California shear zone (ECSZ; south- Travis, 1990; Schermer et al., 1996; Reheis and Saw- Bouse Formation and a steeply NE-dipping oblique western USA; Fig. 1) is a wide zone of diffuse yer, 1997; McQuarrie and Wernicke, 2005; Nuriel et dextral-normal fault where an anomalously thick strike-slip deformation that currently accommodates al., 2019) to ca. 5–7 Ma (Gan et al., 2003; Langenheim (~140 m) section of Bouse Formation siliciclastic ~20%–25% of relative Pacific–North America plate and Powell, 2009) to ca. 2–4 Ma (Du and Aydin, 1996; deposits filled a local fault-controlled depocenter. motion in the Mojave Desert east of the San Andreas Rubin and Sieh, 1997). While it is generally agreed Systematic basinward thickening and stratal wedge fault (Dokka and Travis, 1990; Miller et al., 2001; that the width of the deformation zone has narrowed geometries in the western Trigo and southeastern Meade and Hager, 2005; Oskin et al., 2007, 2008). and become more localized through time into the Palo Verde Mountains, on opposite sides of the Col- Since late Miocene time, the ECSZ has been kine- western (active) ECSZ belt (Dokka and Travis, 1990; orado River valley, record basinward tilting during matically linked to the Gulf of California shear zone Dixon and Xie, 2018), few constraints exist on the deposition of the Bouse Formation. We conclude (Fig. 1; Bennett and Oskin, 2014; Bennett et al., 2017), timing, distribution, and structural style of strain in that the southern Blythe Basin formed as a broad where major strike-slip and normal faults related the paleo-ECSZ. Documenting the geologic evolu- transtensional sag basin in a diffuse releasing ste- to oblique rifting across the Pacific–North America tion of the older, eastern belt of the ECSZ is needed pover between the dextral Laguna fault system in plate boundary developed ca. 7–9 Ma in the northern to understand how late Miocene dextral strain in the south and the Cibola and Big Maria fault zones Gulf of California and Salton Trough region (Seiler et the Gulf of California shear zone was kinematically in the north. A palinspastic reconstruction at 5 Ma al., 2010, 2011; Dorsey et al., 2011; Bennett et al., 2013, linked with paleo-ECSZ faults in the Mojave Desert east of the San Andreas fault and farther north in the Walker Lane. Rebecca Dorsey https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8390-052X This paper is published under the terms of the *Current address: School of Earth Sciences, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria 3010, Australia Southern exposures of the uppermost Mio- CC‑BY-NC license. †Current address: Devon Energy Corp, 333 West Sheridan Avenue, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73102, USA cene to lower Pliocene Bouse Formation provide an
© 2021 The Authors
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 4 Dorsey et al. | Paleo–Eastern California shear zone Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/4/1101/5362321/1101.pdf 1101 by guest on 29 September 2021 Research Paper
excellent opportunity to address these questions because of their location within a transtensional Walker zone of right-stepping, NW-striking dextral faults Lane and north-striking normal faults related to the Gulf DV LV Colorado Stateline River of California shear zone and ECSZ (Fig. 1). Previous fault system 36°N studies found that faults in this area were active GF during late Miocene time (Sherrod and Tosdal, SoAvFZ 1991; Richard, 1993) and that fault-related defor- NV Fig. 15 CA BC mation continued during deposition of the Bouse CMF 35°N Formation (Buising, 1990; Dorsey et al., 2017; Gard- CRF N ner and Dorsey, 2021; Thacker et al., 2020). The A paleo- modern ECSZ age of the Bouse Formation is bracketed between ECSZ ca. 6.0 and 4.6 Ma (House et al., 2008; Sarna-Wo- SAF P BWRFZ 34°N jcicki et al., 2011; McDougall, 2008; McDougall and ETR Miranda Martínez, 2014; Dorsey et al., 2018; Crow B Blythe CFZ Basin AZ et al., 2019a), which thus constrains the age of syn-depositional structures. Post–4.5 Ma broad sag- Fig. 2 ST 33°N ging is recognized along the lower Colorado River LFS . Y R (Howard et al., 2015; Crow et al., 2018; Cohen et Gila al., 2019), including possible isostatic responses to sedimentation and erosion (Karlstrom et al., 2017), but the influence of ECSZ faults on regional sub- Pacific Ocean U.S.A.32°N sidence patterns during deposition of the Bouse Pi Mexico Formation remains poorly understood. Detailed GCSZ studies are needed to test kinematic models for the N GoC ECSZ and its links to the northern Gulf of California, 118°W 31°N San Andreas fault system, and Walker Lane (e.g., 0 km 100 SON Dolan et al., 2007; Oskin et al., 2008; Liu et al., 2010; 116°W 114°W Dixon and Xie, 2018). Figure 1. Map of the southern San Andreas fault system, Eastern California shear zone Stratigraphic analysis offers a powerful method (ECSZ), and Gulf of California shear zone (GCSZ), showing faults (black lines), surface expo- for documenting fault-related tilting and defor- sures of the Bouse Formation (purple), modern dry lakes (yellow), and inferred distribution mation of the Earth’s surface in areas of crustal of Bouse sedimentary basins in the lower Colorado River region (light blue). Pink shading extension, subsidence, and sedimentation (Gaw- highlights the modern ECSZ as defined by geodesy, active seismicity, and Quaternary-active faults; green shading shows the older, late Miocene to early Pliocene paleo-ECSZ. Red lines thorpe and Leeder, 2000; Gawthorpe et al., 1997, are faults in the modern ECSZ with historical surface-rupturing earthquakes. Abbreviations: 2018; Sharp et al., 2000; Withjack et al., 2002; Serck A—Amboy; AZ—Arizona; B—Blythe; BC—Bullhead City; BWRFZ—Bill Williams River fault and Braathen, 2019). This approach is especially zone; CA—California; CFZ—Cibola fault zone; CMF—Cave Mountain fault; CRF—Camp Rock useful in areas of slow or diffuse deformation, fault; DV—Death Valley; ETR—eastern Transverse Ranges; GF—Garlock fault; GoC—Gulf of California; LFS—Laguna fault system; LSBM—Little San Bernardino Mountains; LV—Las where low strain rates produce gentle bedding dips Vegas; N—Needles; NV—Nevada; P—Parker; Pi—Pinacate volcano; SAF—San Andreas that may be difficult to quantify with standard struc- fault; SoAvFZ—Soda-Avawatz fault zone; ST—Salton Trough; SON—Sonora; Y—Yuma. tural analysis or where structures are concealed or poorly exposed. Tilting related to syn-depositional normal and oblique-slip faults produces systematic use this tectonostratigraphic approach to interpret 2020). In addition, these methods offer a powerful thickness variations and distinctive stratal architec- structural controls on stratigraphic architecture and approach that could be used to reconstruct the late tures that can be used to reconstruct the timing, fault-related syn-depositional tilting dynamics that Cenozoic kinematic evolution of other important geometries, and kinematics of the causal fault were not identified in previous published studies in strike-slip fault zones such as the North Anatolian systems (e.g., Gawthorpe et al., 1997; Young et al., the paleo-ECSZ (e.g., Miller and McKee, 1971; Sher- fault (northern Turkey; Şengör et al., 2005), Dead 2003; Lewis et al., 2017; Muravchik et al., 2018). We rod and Tosdal, 1991; Richard, 1993; Thacker et al., Sea transform (Garfunkel, 2014), and regional
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 4 Dorsey et al. | Paleo–Eastern California shear zone Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/4/1101/5362321/1101.pdf 1102 by guest on 29 September 2021 Research Paper
strike-slip systems in southeast Asia (Sumatra, 0 km 5 114.8°W Tb 114.6°W Sagaing, and Red River fault zones; Morley, 2002). C o Qal,
l This paper presents a detailed stratigraphic Palo o Qt Tv r analysis of the Bouse Formation on opposing Verde a d o Cibola sides of the southern Blythe Basin, south of Bly- Mountains Fig. 4 Fig. 10 R
i the, California, integrated with geologic mapping Tb 36bbb v JTr 33.3°N e normal fault and structural data, to document late Miocene to Fig. 12 r PVF LTF early Pliocene deformation in the paleo-ECSZ in Qal, Qt Milpitas strike-slip fault the lower Colorado River corridor (Figs. 1, 2). We Wash Qal, Tb Qt Tb Tv document diagnostic stratal wedge geometries Qal, Qt Qal, Quaternary alluvium and that record a history of syn-depositional tilting and terrace deposits Qal, Qt subsidence in response to growth of normal and Qt Late Miocene to early oblique-slip faults around the margins of a transten- Tc Tb 33.2°N Pliocene Bouse Formation sional basin. These results provide new constraints Tertiary conglomerate JTr Tc on the time-space evolution of the ECSZ and sup- (Miocene) port prior suggestions that regional subsidence in Trigo Mountains Tb Tv Tertiary volcanic rocks a fault-bounded tectonic lowland controlled latest Tc Tv Tc Tv JTr Tv LRF Triassic-Jurassic metavolcanic Miocene shallow-marine inundation and subse- BP JTr N and metasedimentary rocks quent integration of the Colorado River into the JTr northern Gulf of California at ca. 5 Ma (e.g., Buis- Figure 2. Simplified geologic map of the southern Blythe Basin and surrounding ranges (compiled from Sherrod and ing, 1990; Bennett et al., 2016a; Dorsey et al., 2018). Tosdal, 1991). “36bbb” is a water well in which Bouse Formation was recorded to a depth of 92 m and did not penetrate the base of the Bouse Formation (Metzger et al., 1973). Red circle indicates fault geometry data station for this study (more are shown in Fig. 4). Background image is from Google Earth. Abbreviations: BP—Buzzards Peak; PVF—Palo Verde ■■ REGIONAL STRATIGRAPHIC fault (introduced in this study); LRF—Lighthouse Rock fault; LTF—Lost Trigo fault. FRAMEWORK
The Bouse Formation is a thin sequence of In the southern Blythe Basin (Fig. 2), south of Dorsey et al., 2018). The UBM and unit Tfg2 gravel upper Miocene to lower Pliocene sedimentary Blythe, California, the Bouse Formation consists of together define a laterally extensive conformable deposits that are discontinuously exposed along three regionally correlative members: (1) a basal thin sequence known as “Trigo sediments” (Goo- the lower Colorado River valley in western Arizona carbonate member consisting of mixed carbonate- tee et al., 2019) that we treat as a single map unit and southeastern California (Figs. 1–3). It uncon- siliciclastic bioclastic grainstone, conglomerate, (Tbug) in the western Trigo Mountains (Fig. 4). The formably overlies variably deformed Miocene and marl; (2) a siliciclastic member comprising Bullhead Alluvium is a widespread unit of lower volcanic and sedimentary rocks that accumulated green claystone, red mudstone, siltstone, and Pliocene Colorado River gravel and sand that during and after northeast-southwest extension cross-bedded channel sandstone of the earliest locally interfingers with unit Tfg2 gravel. In most in a belt of low-angle detachment faults known Colorado River; and (3) an upper bioclastic member places, Bullhead Alluvium is erosionally inset into as the Colorado River extensional corridor (How- (UBM), which forms a coarsening-upward sequence older deposits and records incision followed by ard and John, 1987; Spencer and Reynolds, 1991; of fossiliferous sandy grainstone, pebbly grain- regional aggradation in the lower Colorado River Sherrod and Tosdal, 1991; Spencer et al., 2018). stone, and calcareous-matrix conglomerate that region that took place ca. 4.5–3.5 Ma (Pearthree and Previous studies have bracketed the age of the overlies older members of the Bouse Formation House, 2014; Howard et al., 2015). southern Bouse Formation between ca. 6.3 and along a regional unconformity that likely represents The Bouse Formation in the southern Blythe 4.6 Ma using tephrochronology, biostratigraphy, ~100–200 k.y. (Fig. 3; Homan, 2014; O’Connell, 2016; Basin has been variably interpreted to record depo- and 40Ar/39Ar methods (Sarna-Wojcicki et al., 2011; Dorsey et al., 2018, 2019). Older members of the sition in either a large saline lake (Spencer and Spencer et al., 2013; McDougall, 2008; McDougall Bouse Formation below the UBM thicken toward Patchett, 1997; Spencer et al., 2008, 2013; Pearthree and Miranda Martínez, 2014; Dorsey et al., 2018; depocenters beneath the modern Colorado River and House, 2014; Bright et al., 2016, 2018a, 2018b; Crow et al., 2019a), making these deposits an ideal axis and thin and pinch out toward basin margins Gootee et al., 2019) or a shallow-marine tidal strait target for studies of late Miocene to present defor- (Fig. 3). The UBM is gradationally overlain by locally or estuary (Buising, 1990; Turak, 2000; McDougall, mation in the paleo-ECSZ. derived alluvial-fan conglomerate, unit Tfg2 (Fig. 3; 2008; McDougall and Miranda Martínez, 2014;
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 4 Dorsey et al. | Paleo–Eastern California shear zone Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/4/1101/5362321/1101.pdf 1103 by guest on 29 September 2021 Research Paper
Crossey et al., 2015; O’Connell et al., 2017, 2021; Tcb Alluvial-fan Bullhead Dorsey et al., 2018; Gardner and Dorsey, 2021).
conglomerate Tfg2 Interpretations for specific stratigraphic units are summarized below. Studies that support the saline Calcareous-matrix congl lake model tend to emphasize evidence from car- Tbug
bonate major- and trace-element chemistry and Coarse pebbly grainstone Tbu isotopic data (Sr, O, and C isotopes), while papers Wave-rippled grainstone, supporting the marine and estuarine model base rare C.R. mudst and sst their conclusions primarily on evidence from pro- cess sedimentology, paleontology, and trace fossils. C. R. Karst breccia and fissures sst
M Regional u ■■ METHODS d unconformity s t
a n Field work was conducted in the western Trigo d
s BOUSE FORMATION Green claystone
i Mountains, Arizona, and southeastern Palo Verde lt b s Marl a t Miocene s Mountains, California (Fig. 2). Geologic maps were a
l Tbbc Bioclastic volcanic and c Basal
a carb mbr compiled from previous work (Homan, 2014; Gootee travertine facies rb Tbbg older crystalline o et al., 2016; O’Connell et al., 2021; Dorsey et al., 2018; na Siliciclastic Member (Tbs) te Miocene fan rocks (Tv, Tvx) m Mioc. Gardner and Dorsey, 2021) and new mapping con- br Tfg1 conglomerate ducted for this study. Stratigraphic relations were Volcanics characterized by detailed geologic mapping, mea- Miocene volcanics
suring sections using a Jacob’s staff, correlation of Figure 3. Schematic stratigraphy of the Bouse Formation in the southern Blythe Basin, not to scale. Orange key contacts and marker beds, and construction of band at the top of unit Tfg1 represents a ravinement surface produced by sediment reworking and sorting geologic cross sections and stratigraphic panels to during regional transgression. Bouse upper bioclastic member (unit Tbu) overlies older deposits of the Bouse illustrate important stratal architectures and fault Formation along a regional unconformity that represents an unknown amount of time, possibly ~100–200 k.y. Fossil symbol in Tbu represents branching calcareous red algae that are common in this unit, not found in geometries. Detailed measured sections were com- the basal carbonate member. Abbreviations: carb—carbonate, C.R.—Colorado River, Bullhead—Bullhead piled from Master’s theses (Homan, 2014; O’Connell, Alluvium, mbr—member, mudst—mudstone, sst—sandstone, siltst—siltstone. See Figures 4 and 10 for 2016; Gardner, 2019). Fault geometric analysis further definition of lithologic unit symbols. was conducted using Stereonet 10 software (All- mendinger et al., 2012; Cardozo and Allmendinger, 2013). Kamb contours were calculated from poles to ■■ RESULTS onto travertine-encrusted local relief. Basal carbon- planes to decipher statistically significant geometric ate in the western Trigo Mountains is subdivided trends. Fault kinematic data were obtained by mea- Stratigraphic Summary into gravel-dominated and carbonate-dominated suring faults and striae on fault planes; shear sense facies, map units Tbbg and Tbbc, respectively was interpreted in the field using criteria outlined The basal carbonate member of the Bouse For- (Figs. 3, 4, 5A). The gravel-dominated facies in Petit (1987) and geologic observations such as mation ranges from ~1 to 25 m thick and overlies (unit Tbbg) is primarily reworked from underly- correlation of offset beds. Paleostrain was analyzed Miocene volcanic rocks and conglomerate along ing conglomerate. It is clast supported and well from fault kinematic data using FaultKin 7 software an unconformity that exhibits variable geometry sorted and displays tabular to trough cross bed- (Marrett and Allmendinger, 1990; Allmendinger et and relief around the study area (Fig. 2). In the ding formed in beach ridges, gravelly barchan al., 2012) to determine the incremental shortening western Trigo Mountains, bioclastic facies overlie dunes, delta mouth bars, and small Gilbert deltas (P) and extension (T) axes of measured faults. Strati- Miocene alluvial fan conglomerate along a sharp, (Fig. 5B; Dorsey et al., 2018; O’Connell et al., 2021). graphic and structural data were integrated with quasi-planar, laterally continuous disconformity Carbonate-dominated facies (unit Tbbc) overlie previously published age estimates (summarized (O’Connell et al., 2021). In the southeastern Palo and are interbedded with unit Tbbg and contain above) to interpret regional paleogeography, fault- Verde Mountains, a thin basal travertine unit is a wide range of sedimentary structures, facies ing controls on basin evolution, and development encrusted on steep irregular paleotopography in associations, and carbonate-siliciclastic mixtures of the paleo-ECSZ. Miocene volcanic rocks, and bioclastic facies onlap that record deposition in low- to high-energy tidal
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 4 Dorsey et al. | Paleo–Eastern California shear zone Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/4/1101/5362321/1101.pdf 1104 by guest on 29 September 2021 Research Paper
0 km 1.0 114.60° W Qt,Qi 114.65° W Tcb Tbug Tbs Qt,Qi Tbs Qt,Qi Qt,Qi Tbug Tbbc Tbug A’ Tbug Tbs Qt,Qi Qal ? Qt,Qi 3 Tfg1 Tfg1 3 E Tbs B’ D Tbs Fig. 7A 33.30° N Tbbc Tcb 3 A10 Fig. 7B Qt,Qi Qal 24 28 Fig. 7E 15 12 Qt, Qi Qt,Qi A12 A Fig. 8 Tfg1 B67 A11 B57 Tvx B66 Monocline B33 B59 A13 at depth Fig. 9A Fig. 7D (Fig. 9A) Hart Mine Wash A24 5 A15 N Qal BTbs Qt,Qi Tcb Qt,Qi Tfg1 Tvx Qt,Qi Lost Figure 4. Geologic map of the western Tbug Tcb Tbug Qt,Qi Tbbc Trigo Mountains, compiled from Gootee EXPLANATION et al. (2016), Homan (2014), O’Connell (2016), and this study (see location in Tb- 3 Qt,Qi strike and dip of bedding Fig. 2). Dashed lines from measured Qt, 9 5 Tfg1 bc Qi 22 monocline axis section locations show projection into normal fault (faults dotted stratigraphic panels (Fig. 9). Background Tbug D’ Tbbc where concealed) image is from Google Earth.
3 Trigo oblique-slip fault Fault-kinematic data station (Fig. 13) 33.275° N Qt,Qi A4 Tbs Fault-geometric data station (Fig. 13) 3 Big Fault B31 Tbug A15 Measured section location Wash Fig. 9B A19 Fig. 7C B53 A25 Qal Quaternary alluvium C B43 3 2 A5 C’ B42 B39 2 B41 B38 B50 Quaternary terrace and Qt,Qi inset terrace gravels Tbbc Tcb Tbug unconformity B71 10 22 B40 Tcb Pliocene Bullhead Alluvium Qt,Qi B70 B13 Tfg1 Upper bioclastic member 3 Tbug
fault and younger fan gravels; 3 B24 2 thin mudstone at base. Tbbc Tvx B27 unconformity A3 Fig. 9C B26 Marl 11 Tbs Siliciclastic member Wash B3 Qt,Qi Tb Tbbc Basal member: carbonate bc 13 Tfg1 Tfg1 4
Tfg1 Bouse Formation Tbbg Basal member: gravel Tfg1 Tbbg 25 unconformity Qt, 32 Tbbg Tfg1 Miocene alluvial-fan conglomerate Qi Tbbg unconformity 33.25° N Qt,Qi Tvx Miocene volcanic and older Tfg1 Tbbc E’ Tfg1 crystalline rocks (undifferentiated)
GEOSPHERE | Volume 17 | Number 4 Dorsey et al. | Paleo–Eastern California shear zone Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/17/4/1101/5362321/1101.pdf 1105 by guest on 29 September 2021 Research Paper