Orbital Evidence for Clay and Acidic Sulfate Assemblages on Mars Based on Mineralogical Analogs from Rio Tinto, Spain
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Orbital evidence for clay and acidic sulfate assemblages on Mars based on mineralogical analogs from Rio Tinto, Spain The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Kaplan, Hannah H., Ralph E. Milliken, David Fernández-Remolar, Ricardo Amils, Kevin Robertson, and Andrew H. Knoll. 2016. “Orbital Evidence for Clay and Acidic Sulfate Assemblages on Mars Based on Mineralogical Analogs from Rio Tinto, Spain.” Icarus 275 (September): 45–64. doi:10.1016/j.icarus.2016.03.019. Published Version doi:10.1016/j.icarus.2016.03.019 Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:34391777 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Open Access Policy Articles, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use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c(<#$..+ /-'?*0' /@! /0- $.+-*+*. /* TR - .0'/!-*(($3/0- *!#4-/ ($) -'.9'/#*0"#/# $ )/$/4*!/# ($) -'.#. TS - ($) ($"0*0.< - 2 (*)./-/ /#/.$($'-.+ /-'*0' /! /0- . TT - *. -1 $)$-*-) 9!$ '9)'*-/*-4- !' /) .+ /-*!-*&) TU . $( )/.(+' .!-*($*$)/*9+$)<*($) 1$.$' =) -$)!-- - !' /) TV .+ /-)=-4$!!-/$*)( .0- ( )/.*!/# . .(+' .- 1 './#//# TW *0' /! /0- -$. .!-*(($3/0- *!'=+#4''*.$'$/ E$''$/ *-(0.*1$/ F) TX %-*.$/ <)'4. .*!*-$/'/!-*(/# *(+/ *))$..) ("$)" TY + /-*( / -!*--.E F.#*2./#//# (-/$).+ /-' ,0$1' )/.- '.* TZ *).$./ )/2$/#($3/0- .*!'=+#4''*.$'$/ .)%-*.$/ 92# - /# '= UQ +#4''*.$'$/ (4'.*$)'0 &*'$)$/ )C*-#''*4.$/ <. ./04!*-- "$*) UR 2$/#$) 0.#.( (*)./-/ ./#//# - '/$1 +-*+*-/$*).*!/# '= US +#4''*.$'$/ E.F)%-*.$/ 1-42$/#$)*) ./-/$"-+#$0)$/.2 ''. /2 ) UT ./-/$"-+#$0)$/.<# !*-( -*. -1/$*).0"" ././#//# %-*.$/ (4 UU $" ) /$E0/#$" )$F+-*0/)/#0.$)$/$1 *!'*'+ )- *3*)$/$*).9 S UV 2# - ./# '// -*. -1/$*)(4 *).$./ )/2$/#1-$/$*).$). $( )/!'03 UW )C*-!'0$# ($./-40-$)". $( )/ +*.$/$*)< UX UY &"!( UZ • *0' /.*-+/$*)$.*. -1 $)- !' /) .+ /-*!-. /2 )S<S= VQ S<Tc(< VR • !' /) .+ /-/$*$)/*9+$)'.*.#*2*0' /0 /*'= VS +#4''*.$'$/ )%-*.$/ < VT •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`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