Year in Review

Home , Bristol Law School, City Law School, David Kennedy (jurist), Durham Law School, Friedrich Kratochwil, Janet Halley

INSTITUTE FOR GLOBAL LAW & POLICY HARVARD LAW SCHOOL

nurturing innovative approaches to global law and policy

year in review 2013-2014 Albania Algeria Argentina Australia Austria Bangladesh Belarus Belgium Bosnia and Herzegovina Botswana Brazil Bulgaria Cameroon Canada Chile Colombia Cote d’Ivoire Croatia Denmark Egypt Eritrea Ethiopia Finland France Georgia Germany Ghana Greece Guinea Hong Kong Hungary India Iran Ireland Israel Italy Jamaica Jordan Kazakhstan Lebanon Macedonia Malaysia Mauritius Mexico Morocco Netherlands New Zealand Niger Nigeria Norway Pakistan Palestine Panama P.R. China Peru Philippines Poland Portugal Qatar Romania Russia Senegal Serbia Sierra Leone Singapore Slovakia Slovenia South Africa South Korea Spain Sri Lanka Sudan Taiwan Tanzania Thailand The Bahamas Turkey Uganda United Kingdom United States Uzbekistan Venezuela Zimbabwe annual report 2013-2014 IGLP’s Year at a Glance ...... 1-2

The Institute

Mission 3

Research Agenda 3

The Network ...... 5

Scholarly Resources ...... 5-6

Institute Administration 7-8

Faculty Contributors ...... 9

table of contents Councils ...... 9-10

Program Partners & Sponsors ...... 11-12

IGLP Working Formats 13-14

IGLP Events

The Workshop ...... 15-16

June 2014 ...... 17-26

Other Events ...... 27-32

Lectures & Presentations ...... 33 ANNUAL REPORT ANNUAL IGLP Research

Current Research Projects ...... 35-38

Collaborative Research Grants 39-42

Doha - Santander Research Grants ...... 43-46

People at the IGLP

IGLP Fellows ...... 47-50

Visiting Researchers 51-52

Travel Grants ...... 52-54

Event Participants ...... 55-71

Alumni Opportunities 73-74 yearIGLP’s at a glance 2013-2014

“I had a great time, and learnt so much (both content and methodology- and I haven't even mentioned the networks) and my academic life is truly reborn.” -2014 Workshop Participant “…thank you for creating this space for us to come together” “This is the best 64 professional, countries cultural, and represented at personal the June 2014 experience that events I’ve had.” -2014 Workshop Participant 141

universities Albania Algeria Argentina represented Australia Austria Bangladesh 263 at June 2014 Belarus Belgium Bosnia scholars at the events and Herzegovina Botswana June 2014 events Brazil Bulgaria Cameroon Canada Chile Colombia Cote d’Ivoire Croatia Denmark 1000 164 facebook likes scholars at the 628 as of July 2014 2014 Workshop in Doha invited participants since 2010

“An amazing “IGLP is not experience. This “I have been workshop has only organizing disenchanted, broadened my a great horizons – and provoked, moving forward, community, but I see issues of bewildered - also building global policy and and loved every governance from a 702 bridges across totally new lens. ” minute of it!” academic sessions many lines.” -2014 Workshop Participant -2014 Workshop Participant since 2010 -2014 Workshop Participant mission

The Institute for Global Law and Policy (IGLP) at Harvard Law School is a collaborative faculty effort to nurture innovative approaches to global policy in the face of a legal and institutional architecture manifestly ill- equipped to address our most urgent global challenges. Global poverty, conflict, injustice and inequality are also legal and institutional regimes. The IGLP explores the ways in which they are reproduced and what might be done in response. Scholars associated with the Institute are working to understand and map the levers of political, economic and legal authority in the world today. The Institute focuses on young scholars and policy makers who bring new ideas and perspectives to comparative and international legal research and policy. The IGLP aims to facilitate the emergence of a creative dialogue among young experts from around the world,

the institute strengthening our global capacity for innovation and cooperative research. We aim to provide a platform at Harvard for new thinking about international legal and institutional arrangements, with particular emphasis on ideas and issues of importance to the global South.

research agenda

The Institute is an international collaborative project to foster research and policy dialogue about the structure and potential for global governance and international law affecting pressing issues of global regulation and policy. The Institute aims to foster innovative approaches to global policy and political economy, and new thinking about international legal and institutional arrangements.

At the IGLP, we are convinced that governance is not only rules, institutions and procedures. Ideas also matter. If for a generation everyone thinks an “economy” is an input output mechanism to be managed, and then suddenly everyone thinks an economy is a market for allocating resources to their most efficient use in the shadow of a price system, a great deal has changed. That is also governance. At the IGLP, we encourage ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL research into the genealogy of governance ideas as they have played out in the fields of international law, international economic law, regulatory policy, human rights and development policy.

All of our academic programming is designed to support our research agenda, starting with our signature IGLP Doha Workshop for young scholars, and continuing through opportunities for Workshop alumni and IGLP scholars to build collaborative teams, deepen their thinking and develop research for publication through multiyear participation in our various conferences and other program formats. We also aim to provide a framework at Harvard for students and faculty interested in pursuing innovative and heterodox research on foundational questions of theory and history as well as pressing issues of global policy.

We seek to engage the policy community and to sponsor important transnational dialogue. In recent years, we have convened policy-makers and scholars in Colombia, Chile, Brazil, Thailand, Russia and China, as well as in the United States to engage with our ongoing research activities. We regularly convene international research teams for on‐site investigations of policy directions and experience, through site visits and discussions with policy makers, often followed by an academic conference reflecting a first cut on the findings of the research inquiry.

3 new thinking

challenging expertise

4 the network

The IGLP encourages academic collaboration and progressive research to nurture alternative ideas about international law, society, and political economy. We have developed a global network of scholars and policy makers who share our belief that ideas matter, and we have a commitment to cultivating a space for new voices and viewpoints to emerge around ideas about global governance, social justice and economic policy. Our common goal is to better understand how power is exercised in the world today, and how original and critical thinking can transform the ways in which policy experts, intellectual leaders and citizens understand our common global situation.

the institute More than 500 young scholars from more than 50 countries are alumni of our intensive Workshop. Well over 1000 young scholars have joined our online network and participate in our research activities.

The IGLP network portal on our website is designed to strengthen that network and to assist all those who share our critical impulse and concern about the ideas which govern our world to share new ideas, events, research, and experiences with others in the field. This space is designed to be a haven of collaboration and sharing, all with the purpose of advancing global governance thinking and ideas.

Members of the IGLP community are encouraged to reach out to one another to share their work, syllabi and their ideas through the Network News, New Thinking/New Writing, Events of Interest, or Working Papers sections of our website. The community connects with each other by posting on IGLP’s Facebook, following us on Twitter and by signing up to receive our bimonthly e-newsletter.

scholarly resources Fellowship Program ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

The Fellowship Program offers full or partial student and post‐doctoral fellowship support to a small number of scholars pursuing research in areas related to the IGLP’s ongoing work. Applicants considered for Fellowships are those whose work is challenging, original and focused on progressive and alternative ideas about global law and policy. Often, work of this nature is not supported by mainstream institutional resources, and the IGLP strives to give opportunities for diverse ideas to flourish. IGLP Fellows are integral members of the Institute and provide valuable programming insight and assistance with the execution of our conferences and workshops. The number of Fellowships awarded each year depends upon the available funding.

Visiting Researchers Program

The IGLP accommodates a small number of Visiting Researchers and Visiting Scholars each academic year, funded by outside sources. Visiting Researchers and Scholars apply to do research at Harvard Law School for periods of three months to one year. In making selections, the Institute considers the applicant’s background, field of interest, scholarly achievements, availability of Harvard Law School faculty for consultation in the proposed research area, and English language proficiency. Applicants should have completed their basic legal studies with high academic standing.

5 Applicants at a relatively senior stage of their professional career may be designated Visiting Scholars. This designation is made on the basis of the nature of the applicant’s proposal, the expected duration of their research, and prior academic experience. Visiting Scholar applicants are required to be affiliated with a university, research institute or governmental program in their home country.

Collaborative Research Grants

Our Collaborative Research Grant Program provides modest funding to small groups of young scholars who are seeking to carry out substantive research on projects related to the core research mission of the Institute. The IGLP encourages the development of progressive and alternative ideas about international law, society and political economy by supporting provocative and challenging intellectual work that might not otherwise find support from mainstream institutional resources.

Travel Grants

The IGLP provides modest research and travel support to a small number of scholars conducting research in areas closely related to the IGLP’s ongoing work. Applications are open to current Harvard Law School students and alumni of The Workshop. We hope to encourage focus on the life of the mind, on interdisciplinary reading, and on developing the intellectual background to understand and contribute to critical analyses of global law and social justice. Preference is given to current doctoral students and awards are limited to students who have been invited to present their scholarly work at academic conferences.

Doha - Santander Research Grants

The Doha - Santander Grants Program is generously supported by our Leading Sponsor, Santander Universities, to aid research by the IGLP Doha Workshop alumni and faculty pursuing innovative scholarship. Preference is given to work aiming to revitalize the Arab and Islamic traditions of law and governance and engaging issues of comparative law, global law, and policy in Qatar, the Middle East, and North African Region. The grants are intended to further the dialogue which begun at the January IGLP Workshop through long-term research collaboration.

6 administration Faculty Director of the Institute: David Kennedy

David is the Manley O. Hudson Professor of Law at Harvard Law School. He has taught international law, international economic law and policy, legal theory, law and development, and European law. He joined the Harvard Law faculty in 1981 and holds a Ph.D. from the Fletcher School at Tufts University and a J.D. from Harvard. He is the author of numerous articles on international law and global governance. His research uses interdisciplinary materials from sociology and social theory, economics, and history to explore issues of global governance, development policy, and the nature of professional expertise. He has been particularly committed to developing new voices from the third world and among women in international affairs. the institute

Professor Kennedy also has extensive experience as a practicing lawyer, having worked on numerous international projects, both commercial and public, including work with the United Nations, the Commission of the European Union, and with the private firm of Clearly, Gottlieb, Steen and Hamilton in Brussels. A member of the Council on Foreign Relations, he is past Chair of the World Economic Forum’s Global Advisory Council on Global Governance.

At Harvard, he served as Chair of the Graduate Committee and Faculty Director of International Legal Studies. He founded the European Law Research Center at Harvard in 1991 and has served continuously as Faculty Director. He has advised a number of educational institutions on their academic programs, and lectured as a Visiting Professor at numerous universities across the world. In 2008-2009, he served as Vice President for International Affairs, University Professor of Law and David and Marianna Fisher University Professor of International Relations at Brown University. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

7 Administrative Director: Neal O’Connor

Neal joined the European Law Research Center in 2003. In 2010, with the launch of the new Institute for Global Law and Policy, Neal was appointed Program Manager and in 2012, he became Administrative Director. He oversees the organizational and administrative functions for the Institute. Neal received a B.A. in history from Harvard University.

Events Manager: Kristen Verdeaux

Kristen joined the IGLP in July of 2013 as Events Manager. She has a B.A. in English and Political Science from the University of Connecticut. Kristen specializes in non-profit event planning, program management, and service delivery.

Web & Communications Coordinator: Alexis Brooke Felder

Alexis joined the IGLP in May of 2014 as Web and Communications Coordinator. She has a B.A. in English and Spanish from Simmons College, and a Certificate in Graphic Design from the School of the Museum of Fine Arts (Boston). Alexis is a graphic designer, communications specialist, and photographer.

Program Coordinator: Melinda Peterson

Melinda joined the IGLP in September of 2012. Melinda received a B.A. in Legal Studies and Criminal Justice from the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Melinda administers the Institute’s grants and financials, and assists with general office administration.

Program Assistant: Delia Harrington

Delia joined the IGLP in April of 2014 as Program Assistant. She has a B.A. in International Affairs from Northeastern University. Delia assists in event planning and manages several of the Institute’s programs, including the Fellowship and Visiting Researcher Programs.

IGLP Fellows 2014-2015

Lina M. Céspedes-Baez (Colombia) is currently pursuing her S.J.D. degree at the James E. Beasley School of Law, Temple University as a Fulbright Scholar.

Julia Dehm (Australia) is a Ph.D. Candidate at Melbourne University Law School.

Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) is a Ph.D. Candidate at Sciences Po Law School and has been an Italian barrister since 2011.

Maja Savevska (Macedonia) is a Ph.D. Candidate at the GEM PhD School, Erasmus Mundus Joint Doctorate on Globalization, EU and Multilateralism, where she was awarded a full scholarship by the European Commission.

Arnulf Becker (Chile/United States) Arnulf is currently a Visiting Faculty member at the Watson Institute for International Relations at Brown University. Arnulf received his S.J.D. from Harvard Law School.

Zinaida Miller (United States) is a doctoral Candidate in International Relations at The Fletcher School, Tufts University.

8 faculty contributors

The Institute draws on the expertise and experience of a wide range of Harvard Law School faculty. Each year we work closely with faculty on projects concerning global law and policy. Numerous faculty members have mentored our Visiting Researchers and Fellows over the years.

Christine Desan contributes regularly to our program through her work on the history of capitalism and the global economy. Duncan Kennedy is a regular participant in our work on comparative law, globalization and social theory. We have supported clinical projects in Africa developed by Lucie White in the fields of global health policy and human rights. We have supported Janet Halley’s work in the fields of comparative family the institute law, social theory and the feminist legacies of global governance. Gerald Frug’s work on international local government law has sparked a number of events, and we have supported his comparative research on the city as a legal concept.

Janet Halley, Allen Ferrell, Elizabeth Bartholet, Martha Field, Terry Fisher, Mark Ramseyer, Jesse Fried, Steven Shavell, Cass Sunstein, and Scott Brewer have participated in our Spanish training programs co- organized with the Garrigues law firm.Lucian Bebchuck, Reinier Kraakman, Robert Clark, Einer Elhauge, Guhan Subramanian, Allen Ferrell, Howell Jackson and Alan Dershowitz have all been participants in our conferences on corporate law and regulation. We work closely with the graduate program at the law school, encouraging interactions among doctoral students and their faculty colleagues, and are grateful for William Alford’s ongoing engagement and support. councils

Honorary Council ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL FERNANDO HENRIQUE CARDOSO, ALEKSANDER KWAŚNIEWSKI, Former JACQUES SANTER, Former Prime Former President of Brazil President of Poland Minister of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg and Former President of JACQUES DELORS, Former President of RICARDO LAGOS ESCOBAR, Former the European Commission the European Commission President of Chile , Former CLAUS-DIETER EHLERMANN, Former SURAKIART SATHIRATHAI MARK MALLOCH-BROWN, Former Spokesperson and Special Adviser Foreign Minister and Deputy Prime United Nations Deputy Secretary to the President of the European Minister of Thailand General, and Former Minister of Commission State in the British Foreign and NUR HASSAN WIRAJUDA, Former Commonwealth Office Foreign Minister of Indonesia H.M. FELIPE VI, King of Spain, as Honorary President of the Real JOSÉ MANUEL RAMOS-HORTA, Former Colegio Complutense, Madrid, Spain President of the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste ALFRED GUSENBAUER, Former Chancellor of Austria

9 Advisory Council Academic Council

DANIELA CARUSO, Boston University School TALAL ABDULLA AL EMADI, Qatar University KISHORE MAHBUBANI, Lee Kuan Yew School of Law, Boston, MA College of Law, Doha, Qatar of Public Policy, National University of Singapore, Republic of Singapore MATTHEW CRAVEN, SOAS, University of GIANMARIA AJANI, University of Turin, London, London, United Kingdom Turin, Italy SUSAN MARKS, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, CHRISTINE DESAN, Harvard Law School, PHILIP ALLOTT, Trinity College, Cambridge United Kingdom Cambridge, MA University, Cambridge, England PRATAP BHANU MEHTA, Centre for Policy KAREN ENGLE, University of Texas School of HELENA ALVIAR, Universidad de Los Andes, Research, New Delhi, India Law, Austin, Texas Bogotá, Colombia HORATIA MUIR WATT, Sciences Po Law JORGE ESQUIROL, Florida International JOSE MARIA BENEYTO, Parliamentary School, Paris, France University College of Law, Miami, Florida Assembly, Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France VASUKI NESIAH, New York University, New GERALD FRUG, Harvard Law School, York, New York Cambridge, MA YISHAI BLANK, Faculty of Law, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel SUNDHYA PAHUJA, Melbourne Law School, ANTONIO GARRIGUES WALKER, J&A Melbourne, Australia Garrigues, S.L.P, Madrid, Spain HILARY CHARLESWORTH, The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia ILEANA PORRAS, University of Miami School JANET HALLEY, Harvard Law School, of Law, Miami, Florida Cambridge, MA B.S. CHIMNI, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India PHILIPPE SANDS, University College London DUNCAN KENNEDY, Harvard Law School, Faculty of Laws, London, United Kingdom Cambridge, MA DAN DANIELSEN, Northeastern University Law School, Boston, MA CALIXTO SALOMAO FILHO, University of Sao MARTTI KOSKENNIEMI, University of Paulo Faculty of Law, Sao Paulo, Brazil Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland DENNIS DAVIS, High Court of Cape Town, South Africa HANI SAYED, The American University in JOSÉ MANUEL MARTÍNEZ SIERRA, Real Cairo, Cairo, Egypt Colegio Complutense, Cambridge, MA JAMES DER DERIAN, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia AMR SHALAKANY, The American University SALVADOR MEDINA CHAO, Ciudad Grupo in Cairo, Cairo, Egypt Santander, Madrid, Spain ALFREDO SAAD FILHO, SOAS, University of London, London, United Kingdom GUNTHER TEUBNER, Johann-Wolfgang- KERRY RITTICH, University of Toronto Goethe-University, Frankfurt, Germany Faculty of Law, Toronto, Canada GÜNTER FRANKENBERG, Johann-Wolfgang- Goethe-University, Frankfurt, Germany CHANTAL THOMAS, Cornell Law School, LEOPOLD SPECHT, Specht Böhm, Vienna, Ithaca, NY Austria CHRISTOPHE JAMIN, Sciences Po Law School, Paris, France DAVID TRUBEK, University of Wisconsin Law JOSEPH STIGLITZ, Columbia University, New School, Madison, Wisconsin York, New York SHIELA JASANOFF, Harvard Kennedy School, Cambridge, MA ROBERT WAI, Osgoode Hall Law School, ROMANO SUBIOTTO, Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen York University, Toronto, Canada & Hamilton, Brussels, Belgium EMMANUELLE JOUANNET, Sciences Po Law School, Paris, France LUCIE WHITE, Harvard Law School, Cambridge, MA SORAJAK KASEMSUVAN, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand MIKHAIL XIFARAS, Sciences Po Law School, Paris, France ANDREW LANG, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, United Kingdom

10 partners & sponsors Qatar Foundation

The Qatar Foundation was established with a mission to lead human, social, and economic development of Qatar, through education and research; making Qatar a vanguard for productive change in the region and a role model for the broader international community. As part of its flagship project, Hamad bin Khalifa University, the Foundation is seeking to establish a global law school and research center in Doha, with a mission to become a leader in new thinking about law and governance and

the institute to revitalize Arab law and governance traditions. An integral part of its law school project is to contribute to higher education worldwide by convening a global network of young scholars of law and governance, and to place young scholars and aspiring leaders from the region in dialogue with global peers. The Foundation aims to extend its global outreach by supporting institutions that share its belief in the values of global dialogue and research, in a way that will help the Foundation fulfill its mission. The Foundation now seeks to support the capacity of the IGLP to develop projects and pursue research of interest to the global community and the region. To obtain more information on the Qatar Foundation, visit their website: www.qf.org.qa

The Qatar Foundation is the Lead Sponsor of our intensive Workshop held in January in Doha, which is hosted by Hamad bin Khalifa University.

Santander Universities

Santander Universities, was created by Banco Santander on the conviction that the best way of contributing to growth and economic and social process is by backing the higher education and research system. Banco Santander’s commitment to progress finds its expression in the Santander Universities Global Division, whose activities form the backbone of the bank’s social action and enable it to maintain a stable alliance with the academic world in Latin America, China, United States of America, Spain, Morocco, Portugal, United Kingdom, Germany, Poland, Singapore, and Russia. Santander

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Universities Global Division, a team of more than 2,100 professionals distributed across 17 countries, coordinates and manages Banco Santander’s commitment to higher education. Between 1997 and 2012, Banco Santander channeled $1 billion into sponsorship of academic, research and technological projects in support of higher education. There are now over 1,000 academic institutions receiving support from Banco Santander for the development of academics initiatives including Harvard University and the IGLP. To obtain more information on Santander Universities, visit their website: www.santanderbank.com/us/universities.

Santander Universities is the Lead Sponsor of our June Residential Programing at Harvard, including our Colloquium.

The Real Colegio Complutense

The Real Colegio Complutense, Cambridge, MA, is a non-profit organization established in 1990 by Complutense University of Madrid, Spain to foster scholarly and scientific exchange between Harvard University and Spanish universities and institutions. The Real Colegio Complutense is a founding partner of the IGLP. To obtain more information on the RCC, visit their website: www.rcc.harvard.edu

11 Visa International, Inc.

Visa is a global payments technology company that connects consumers, businesses, banks and governments in more than 200 countries and territories, enabling them to use digital currency instead of cash and checks. Visa has built one of the world’s most advanced processing networks. It’s capable of handling more than 20,000 transactions per second, with reliability, convenience and security, including fraud protection for consumers and guaranteed payment for merchants. Visa does not issue cards, extend credit or set rates and fees for consumers. Visa’s innovations, however, enable its bank customers to offer consumers more choices: Pay now with debit, ahead of time with prepaid or later with credit products. In fact, approximately 70 percent of Visa payment transactions in the United States are debit and prepaid, not credit. Governments here and abroad have switched to digital currency instead of checks for benefits payments and purchasing in order to increase efficiency and lower costs, saving taxpayers money. From the world’s major cities to remote areas without banks, people are increasingly relying on digital currency along with mobile technology to use their money any time, make purchases online, transfer funds across borders and access basic financial services — all of which makes their lives easier and grows economies. To obtain more information on Visa International, visit their website: www.visa.com

J&A Garrigues, S.L.P

Founded in 1941, J&A Garrigues, S.L.P. is one of the longest established law firms in Spain. During the second half of the twentieth century, J&A Garrigues was a central pillar of the Spanish legal profession and was routinely consulted on all key reforms to Spanish law, particularly during the country’s transition to democracy. Playing key roles in the development of the country and its laws ensured that Garrigues became one of the most knowledgeable and respected law firms in Spain. To obtain more information on &A Garrigues, S.L.P., visit their website: www.garrigues.com.

Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen, & Hamilton

A leading international law firm with 12 offices located in major financial centers around the world, Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP has helped shape the globalization of the legal profession for more than 60 years. Their worldwide practice has a proven track record for innovation and providing work of the highest quality to meet the needs of our domestic and international clients. In recognition of the firm’s strong global practice, its effectiveness in dealing with the different business cultures of the countries in which it operates, and its success in multiple jurisdictions, Cleary Gottlieb received Chambers & Partners’ inaugural International Law Firm of the Year award. To obtain more information on Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP, visit their website: www.cgsh.com.

12 IGLP working formats The Workshop

Held in Doha, Qatar each January, the Workshop is an intensive residential program designed for doctoral and post-doctoral scholars and junior faculty. Sponsored by the Qatar Foundation and hosted by Hamad bin Khalifa University, the Workshop brings together more than 100 young scholars and more than 50 senior and junior faculty from around the world for serious research collaboration and debate. While in residence in Doha, participants review current scholarly developments, reconsider canonical texts and network with colleagues from across the world. Our aim is to strengthen the next generation of scholars by placing them in

the institute collaboration with their global peers as they develop innovative ideas and alternative approaches to issues of global law, economic policy, social justice and governance. Intensive writing workshops offer participants the opportunity to receive valuable feedback on their own research from their peers and more senior colleagues in small group settings. More than 500 young scholars from over 50 countries count themselves as alumni of the Workshop.

The Pro-Seminars

Pro-seminars are designed for small groups of scholars engaged in collaboration aimed towards publication. They bring together between ten and fifteen scholars by invitation and application, to work on a common topic. They typically meet in June at Harvard to brainstorm their evolving scholarly writing and advance their work towards publication. Pro-seminars are typically convened by senior Harvard Law School or IGLP faculty. The June 2014 Pro-seminar was entitled “The Role of Law in Structures of Global Production,” and explored the role of law in the construction, operation and governance of global value chains and production networks.

The Colloquium

Each June, we convene a Colloquium at Harvard for invited IGLP Faculty, Docents and guests to strengthen

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL our work through intensive discussion and engagement with leading scholars from other disciplines. Each year’s Colloquium pursues a common theme across a range of research fields. In 2012, the Colloquium focused on the political economy of the modern global order. In 2013, we focused on questions of method raised by the effort to think vertically about the relationship between global and local, macro and micro; and to think horizontally about comparison and differentiation among local or national arrangements. The goal of the 2014 Colloquium was to engage in a cross-disciplinary conversation about the mechanics of stability and change within and across fields.

The Conference

In 2013, our first international conference at Harvard brought together over 350 scholars working on innovative approaches to global governance, social justice and economic policy for two days of scholarly exchange. The IGLP Conference will be held every other June at Harvard Law School and is open to all those who are interested in pursuing new thinking about law and global policy, including those who are new to our network as well as IGLP alumni and friends. Our aim is to provide an ongoing opportunity for scholars connected to the Institute to return to Cambridge to present their research, to reconnect with peers from across the globe, and to find new opportunities for collaborative research with other innovative scholars. We will host our second conference in June 2015 at Harvard.

13 Workshops and Conferences

The IGLP regularly sponsors conferences and workshops, ranging from informal events at the Harvard Faculty Club to large meetings convening over 100 scholars in Cambridge and Doha, Qatar for intensive discussion. Our most important annual events take place in January and June.

Policy Roundtables

The IGLP periodically sponsors policy roundtables, ranging in duration from one to three days, concerning specific issues important to one or more of the IGLP’s constituencies, in which participants from industry, the practicing profession, government, and academia discuss topics of common interest in a relaxed setting. In recent years, we have held Policy Roundtables in China, Spain and Russia as well as Harvard on topics ranging from new approaches to regulation in developing economies to financial inclusion and new conceptions of international law.

Student Initiatives

The IGLP supports activities organized and led by doctoral students and Visiting Researchers at Harvard Law School. Students often prepare presentations based on their current research or invite smaller groups of students to informal discussions. These formats facilitate ongoing debate about a selection of themes of interest to both IGLP and students and scholars associated with our ongoing work. We regularly provide support for student groups at the school pursuing projects related to our research mandate.

Lectures and Informal Seminars

During the academic year, the IGLP sponsors a variety of lectures and informal seminars in which faculty and professional scholars share ongoing research in the areas of global law and policy. These events, which are generally open to all members of the Harvard community, aim to bring the best new thinking about global law and policy to the community for discussion and debate.

14 the workshop

From January 3-11, 2014, the IGLP held its 5th annual Workshop in Doha, as part of our collaboration with the Qatar Foundation. The Workshop was generously hosted by Hamad bin Khalifa University (HBKU), a member of the Qatar Foundation. This year’s Workshop convened 164 People, including faculty, docents and participants, representing 50 countries and 101 Universities. Qatar offered a perfect location for convening scholars from countries outside the North Atlantic area, allowing us to focus on recent developments in the region and to benefit from synergies with intellectual and cultural activities already underway in Education City.

iglp events At the 2014 Workshop we continued our tradition of seeking new ways of deepening the network of collaboration among our Workshop Alumni, and we also invigorated our core program with new participants and themes. We hosted a new group of IGLP alumni Docents, each of whom assisted with the organization of a Workshop Stream or convened a Writing Workshop. We also continued our program for Young Policy Professionals (YPP), designed for young professionals from Qatar and the surrounding region who have an interest in sharing their ideas with global academic peers. The Workshop again focused on a series of substantive Streams. Exploration of each Stream was led by a team of junior and senior scholars, and was designed to promote discussion of recent scholarly trends and policy problems, as well as classical texts. In 2014 our new themes included: the role of corporate power in global society, the relationships among science, technology, and political power in contemporary societies, and theoretical approaches to plural economic governance. We continued our efforts to stimulate new thinking about the legal foundations of global monetary affairs, economic development policy, global political economy and the struggle for social, political and economic justice. As an extension of the core curriculum the Workshop also featured guest speakers and panel discussions. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

15 2014 Workshop Streams Human Rights and Social Justice Plenary Lectures and Panel Conveners: Karen Engle (United States) University Discussions The Corporation in Global Society of Texas Law School, Vasuki Nesiah (United “Global Legal Education” Conveners: Dan Danielsen (United States) States) New York University, and Ratna Kapur Northeastern University School of Law, Dennis (India) Jindal Global Law School. Docents: Panelists: Vivek Kanwar (United States) Jindal Davis (South Africa) Judge, High Court of Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Melbourne Law Global Law School, Mikhail Xifaras (France) Capetown, Gary Gereffi (United States) School, and Paul Clark (United Kingdom) Garden The Sciences Po Law School, Talal Abdulla Al- Duke University. Docent: Grietje Baars (The Court Chambers. Emadi (Qatar) Qatar University College of Law, Netherlands) The City Law School, City Dan Danielsen (United States) Northeastern University of London. International Economic Law and Regulation University School of Law), and Richard Lehun Conveners: Robert Wai (Canada) Osgoode Hall (Canada) McGill Universitt. Comparative Legal Studies Law School at York University, and Alvaro Santos Conveners: Dan Brinks (United States) University (Mexico) Georgetown Law. Docents: Sadeq “International Adoption and Commercial of Texas at Austin, Günter Frankenberg (Germany) Bigdeli (Iran) University of Waikato School of Law, Surrogacy” Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe University, and and Nicolas Perrone (Argentina & Italy) London Panelists: Elizabeth Bartholet (United States) Horatia Muir-Watt (France) Sciences Po Law School of Economics. Harvard Law School, Cyra Akila Choudhury School. Docents: Boris Mamlyuk (United States) (United States) Florida International University, University of Memphis School of Law, and Zoran International Law / International Relations David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law Oklopcic (Croatia & Italy) Carleton University. Conveners: Friedrich Kratochwil (Germany) School, Ratna Kapur (India) Jindal Global Central European University, and Nathaniel Law School, John Ohnesorge (United States) Globalization and Labor Berman (United States) Brown University. University of Wisconsin, Sundhya Pahuja Conveners: Kerry Rittich (Canada) University Docents: Tor Krever (Canada) London School (Australia) Melbourne University Law School), of Toronto Faculty of Law, and Adelle Blackett of Economics, and Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) and Jeremy Perelman (France) The Sciences Po (Canada) McGill University. Docent: Vidya Kumar University of Kent Law School. Law School. (Canada) University of Birmingham. Islamic Law and Policy “Heterodoxy in International Law & Policy” Global Science and Technology Studies Convener: Intisar Rabb (United States) New Speaker: David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Conveners: Sheila Jasanoff (United States) York University School of Law. Docents: Noha Law School). Harvard Kennedy School, and Andrew Lang Aboueldahab (Egypt) Durham University, (United Kingdom) The London School of Cyra Akila Choudhury (United States) Florida “Food Security in the Middle East” Economic and Political Science. Docents: Ben International University, Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia & Panelists: Dennis Davis (South Africa) High Court Hurlbut (United States) Arizona State University Herzegovina) SOAS, University of London. of Cape Town), Gary Gereffi (United States) Duke and Vesco Paskalev (Bulgaria) European University, Ghada Ahmed (United States) Duke University Institute. Law and Economic Development University, Robert Wai (Canada) Osgoode Hall Conveners: Jorge Esquirol (United States) Florida Law School, Jorge Esquirol (United States) Florida Human Rights, Global Poverty and Development International University, and Scott Newton International University College, Osama Siddique Conveners: Jeremy Perelman (France) The (United States) SOAS, University of London. (Pakistan) Lahore University of Management Sciences Po Law School, and Lucie White (United Docents: Yugank Goyal (India) University of Sciences, Fahad Al Attiya (Qatar) Qatar National States) Harvard Law School. Docents: Alejandra Hamburg, Germany, and Onur Ince (Turkey) KOC Food Security Program. Azeuro Quijano (Colombia) Harvard Law School. University. and Mohammad Osama Siddique (Pakistan) “Labor Rights” Lahore University of Management Sciences. Legacies of Colonialism for Global Policy Panelists: Adelle Blackett (Canada) McGill Conveners: Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) University, Kerry Rittich (Canada) University Melbourne Law School, and Matt Craven (United of Toronto, and Faouzi Belknani (Qatar) Qatar Kingdom) SOAS, University of London. Docents: University. Luis Eslava (Australia) Melbourne Law School, and Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Melbourne Law School.

16 june 2014 at IGLP

In June 2014, the IGLP convened its 5th annual residential program at Harvard Law School. From June 2 - 3 we convened three Research Conferences and hosted 16 IGLP Collaborative Research Teams. From June 4-6 we convened our annual Colloquium along with a new IGLP Pro-Seminar. The Conferences and Pro-Seminars were designed to showcase the new thinking about law and global policy among our network of IGLP alumni and friends. The Collaborative Research Groups provided an opportunity for scholars connected to the Institute to return to Cambridge to present their research, reconnect with peers from across the globe, and find new opportunities for collaborative research with other innovative scholars. IGLP’s June 2014 events demonstrated the breadth of scholarship developed by members of the IGLP network and showcased iglp events ongoing and new research projects by IGLP alumni and faculty. The events brought together more than 263 scholars from over 64 countries and 141 Universities. We convened over 154 Academic Sessions on topics ranging from current thinking in the field of Islamic Law and Policy, to exploring the notion of “corporate power.” Harvard Faculty members participated in many of the panels and served as moderators, including David Kennedy, Janet Halley, Sheila Jasanoff and Duncan Kennedy. The three June 2-3 Conferences included:

Corporate Power in Global Society: Explication, Critique, Engagement, and Resistance, which interrogated the nature, structure, and effects of corporate power, convened byGrietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University of London; Dan Danielsen, (United States) Northeastern University School of Law; Dennis Davis (South Africa) Judge, High Court of Cape Town; Andre Spicer (United Kingdom) Cass Business School, City University of London.

Heterodox Approaches to Islamic Law and Policy, which compared critical and comparative methodologies and approaches to Islamic law and jurisprudence, and explored topics including Islamic legal history, family law, and finance, convened by:Cyra Akila Choudhury, (United States) Florida International University and Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina) SOAS, University of London.

Global Legal Thought: The Legacies of Heterodoxy, which compared the development and reception

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL of heterodoxy in legal thought in various regions and legal traditions. This conference also offered the opportunity to reflect comparatively on Duncan Kennedy’s contributions to American and global legal thought in anticipation of his retirement in 2015, convened by: David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School and Mikhail Xifaras (France) The Sciences Po Law School.

17 The June 2014 Pro-Seminar

IGLP Pro-Seminars are designed for small groups of scholars engaged in collaboration aimed towards publication. From June 4-6, 2014 the IGLP convened a Pro-seminar on The Role of Law in Structures of Global Production. Over the course of three days the group met to discuss and explore the role of law in the construction, operation and governance of global value chains and production networks: structures that have been theorized by sociologists and political economists to map the disaggregated modes of production that comprise much of modern global capitalism. Participants examined how diverse local, national, regional, international and transnational legal regimes, together with cultural norms and business practices, shape the expectations, background entitlements, institutional forms and bargaining positions of various players in global production networks. The group considered how those legal entitlements and normative expectations interact with material factors of production to produce particular forms of commercial relations as well as particular attributions of power and value creation. Finally, the group explored how those legal rules and norms come to shape value chain governance, including the allocation of economic surplus and power, as well as the perceived limits of possible regulatory interventions to distribute rents more equitably or to reduce adverse externalities that result from a networked organization of production.

The Pro-Seminar was organized by: Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University London, Dan Danielsen (United States) Northeastern University School of Law, Dennis Davis (South Africa) Judge, High Court of Cape Town, Jason Jackson (The Bahamas) Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, and Brishen Rogers (United States) Temple University Beasley School of Law.

june 2014 at IGLP The June 2014 Colloquium

The 2014 Colloquium, Does Heterodoxy Have a Politics? A Method? explored the history and contemporary potential for heterodox and critical approaches to scholarly work in the social sciences and law. The 2014 IGLP Colloquium was convened by IGLP Faculty Director David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School.

Launched in 2012, the IGLP Colloquium, held each June at Harvard, is designed to offer IGLP Core Faculty, Docents and guests an opportunity to strengthen their work through intensive discussion and engagement

iglp events with leading scholars from other disciplines. Each year’s Colloquium pursues a common theme across a range of research fields.

The goal of the 2014 Colloquium was to engage in a cross-disciplinary conversation about the mechanics of stability and change within and across fields. What is a heterodox intervention in anthropology, international relations, history, law, or economics? How has the history of critique differed in each field? What are the politics of heterodoxy in each field? Is there a method or many methods associated with a heterodox approach? What have been the game-changing moments, politically and intellectually, for each field? Our guest speakers included experts in several fields as well as IGLP Core Faculty and alumni. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

19 Panels and Presentations at the 2014 Colloquium Included:

Academia in the Public Realm: The Problem Genealogy of Heterodoxy in Economics of Boycotts Alfredo Saad Filho (United Kingdom) SOAS, Moderator: Zinaida Miller (United States) Tufts University of London. University. Panelists: Dennis Davis (South Africa) Judge, High Court of Cape Town; Genealogy of Heterodoxy in History Janet Halley (United States) Harvard Law Judith Surkis (United States) Rutgers School; and Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Melbourne Law School. University.

Bringing Heterodoxy to Bear: New Heterodoxy in International Finance and Approaches to Syria Banking

Moderator: David Kennedy (United States) Panelists: Tamara Lothian (United States) Harvard Law School. Panelists: Hani Sayed Columbia Law School; and Leopold Specht (Syria) The American University in Cairo; (Austria) Specht Böhm Rechtsanwalt GmbH, Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia and Italy) Carleton Vienna. University; Anne Orford (Australia) Melbourne Law School; and Usha Natarajan (Australia) Genealogy of Heterodoxy in International The American University in Cairo. Law

Circulations of Modernity in East Asia: New Martti Koskenniemi (Finland) University of Approaches to Comparative Law Helsinki.

Moderator: Mikhail Xifaras (France) Sciences Genealogy of Heterodoxy in International Po Law School. Panelists: Dongsheng Zang (China) University of Washington School Relations of Law; Hajime Yamamoto (Japan) Keio Helen Kinsella (United States) University of University Law School; Yun Ru Chen (Taiwan) Wisconsin-Madison. Harvard Law School; and Mika Yokoyama (Japan) Kyoto University School of Law. The Postcolonial Turn as Heterodox Intervention Comparative Heterodoxies: Science & Technology Studies | Critical Legal Studies | Panelists: Samera Esmeir (Israel/Palestine) Third World Approaches to International Law University of California, Berkeley; and Saba Mahmood (Pakistan/United States), University Panelists: Arnulf Becker (Chile) Brown of California-Berkeley. University; Duncan Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School; and Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Harvard Kennedy School. World Making and Norm-Making: Heterodoxy in Science and Technology Critical Approaches to International Criminal Studies Law Ben Hurlbut (United States) Arizona State Panelists: Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard University, School of Life Sciences; and Sheila Law School; Tor Krever (Canada) London Jasanoff (United States) Harvard Kennedy School of Economics and Political Science; School. Paul Clark (United Kingdom) Garden Court Chambers; Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University London; and Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) University of Edinburgh.

20 June 2014 Colloquium

21 June 2014 Colloquium

june 2014 at IGLP IGLP Faculty Research Projects at June 2014

Research at the IGLP is organized in multi-year projects spearheaded by our affiliated faculty. Together, these projects provide a focal point at Harvard Law School for new thinking in the fields of comparative law, global governance and international law. In June 2014 we were pleased to convene the IGLP Faculty Research Project Team working on Bandung and the Global South: 60 Years of Transformative International Law.

iglp events Participants included:

Raj Balakrishnan (United States) Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Arnulf Becker (Chile) Brown University

Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) SOAS, University of London

Luis Eslava (Australia) Melbourne University Law School

Michael Fakhri (Canada) University of Oregon School of Law

Robert Knox (United Kingdom) London School of Economics and Political Science

Vidya Kumar (Canada) University of Birmingham

Boris Mamlyuk (United States) University of Memphis School of Law

Vasuki Nesiah (United States) The Gallatin School, New York University

Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Melbourne University Law School

Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) University of Technology Sydney

Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) University of Glasgow

Hani Sayed (Syria) The American University in Cairo ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Jahangrinagar University

Mai Taha (Egypt) University of Toronto

23 IGLP Collaborative Research Grant Teams at June 2014

In June 2014 the IGLP was pleased to convene six of our IGLP Collaborative Research Grant Teams. The IGLP Collaborative Research Grant Program is designed to provide modest funding to small groups of young scholars who are seeking to carry out ongoing substantive research on projects related to the core research mission of the IGLP. In June 2014 the following IGLP Collaborative Research Grant teams joined us in Cambridge:

Critical Approaches to International Criminal Law (CAICL)

Convener: Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard Law School. Contributors: Alejandra Azuero-Quijano (Colombia) Harvard Law School; Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University London; Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) University of Edinburgh; Paul Kingsley Clark (United Kingdom) Garden Court Chambers; Delphine Dogot (Belgium) Sciences Po Law School; Christopher Gevers (South Africa) Melbourne Law School; Ioannis Kalpouzos (Greece) The City Law School, City University London; Tor Krever (Canada) London School of Economics and Political Science; Itamar Mann (United States) Georgetown Law School; John Reynolds (Ireland) National University of Ireland, Galway; Jamie Rowen (United States) University of Toronto; Christine Schwöbel (Germany) University of Liverpool Law School; and Immi Tallgren (Finland) University of Helsinki.

Global Art Law and Cultural Property: Productions of Value

Convener: Vivek Kanwar (United States) Associate Professor of Law, Jindal Global Law School. Contributors: Deval Desai (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School; Yugank Goyal (India) University of Hamburg; Priya Gupta (United States) Southwestern Law School; Richard Lehun (Canada) McGill University; Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) University of New South Wales; James Parker (United Kingdom) Melbourne Law School; and Jonathan Walz (United States) The Rollins College.

Legal Education on International Public Law: Rethinking the Latin American Experience

Locating Nature: Making and Unmaking International Law

Convener: Usha Natarajan (Australia) The American University in Cairo Department of Law. Contributors: Nadia Ahmad (United States) Sustainable Development Strategies Group; Saptarishi Bandopadhyay (India) Harvard Law School; Aurélien Bouayad (France) Sciences Po Law School; Julia Dehm (Australia) Melbourne Law School; Hélène Mayrand (Canada) University of Sherbrooke; Roger Merino Acuña (Peru) University of Bath; Areli Valencia (Peru) University of Ottawa; Karolina Zurek (Poland) Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies.

Indicators as Political Spaces

Convener: Rene Urueña (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes. Contributors: Dawood Ahmed (United Kingdom) University of Chicago Law School; Siobhan Airey (Ireland) University of Ottawa; Lina Buchely (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes; Marie Guimezanes (France) Toulouse 1 Capitole University; Marta Infantino (Italy) University of Trieste; Jothie Rajah (Singapore), American Bar Foundation; and Michael Riegner (Germany) New York University School of Law.

International Legal Structuralism

See page 39 for more information about these, and all other ongoing IGLP Collaborative Research Grant initiatives.

24 June 2014 at IGLP

25 June 2014 at IGLP

26 other events

International Business Law Program at Centro de Strategic Management of IP Assets Estudios Garrigues Madrid, Spain, September 26, 2013 Madrid, Spain July 3-9, 2013 On September 26, 2013 the IGLP, along with our The IGLP and our Leading Sponsors at the law firm Leading Sponsors J&A Garrigues, S.L.P, hosted J&A Garrigues, S.L.P held a week-long professional a seminar in Madrid for Garrigues attorneys on development program at the Centro de Estudios “Strategic Management of IP Assets.” Harvard Law Garrigues in Madrid. The program, which focused on School Professor Terry Fisher and Harvard Business

iglp events international business law, was designed for young School Professor Felix Oberholzer-Gee presented mid-career attorneys in Spain. Harvard Law School a joint program on “Strategic Management of Professor Scott Brewer offered one-day courses on Intellectual Property - An Integrated Approach.” International Dispute Resolution and International negotiations and contracts. Harvard Law Professor 11th Annual Business Law Seminar, IGLP/ Real Colegio taught a course on Corporate Bankruptcy Jesse Fried Complutense and Financial Regulation as well as a course on Harvard Law School, October 7-9, 2013 Insider Trading. Centro de Estudios Garrigues is a From October 7-9, 2013 the IGLP and our Leading teaching institution affiliated with the Firm and Sponsor, the Real Colegio Complutense, hosted aims to pursue activities in the field of training and our 11th Annual Business Law Seminar at Harvard the study of and research on legal and economic Law School. This year’s event, which focused on subjects relating to the Firm’s professional activity: “Restructuring of the Financial System and New legal, tax, finance, and human resources. Negotiation Strategies” featured presentations and roundtable discussions focused on comparative Reforming the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance issues between US and European corporate law. Court Harvard Law School Professors Reinier Kraakman, Harvard Law School, August 8, 2013 Steve Shavell, Guhan Subramanian, and Cass Sunstein On August 8, 2013 the IGLP was pleased to co- presented talks at this event. sponsor a major policy address by U.S. Senator

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) on legislation he’s Our Harsh Logic: A Forum on Israeli Occupation of proposed to reform the Foreign Intelligence the Palestinian Territories Surveillance Court and the Foreign Intelligence Harvard Law School, October 17, 2013 Surveillance Court of Review – collectively, the FISA On October 17, 2013 the IGLP was pleased to courts. The senior senator from Connecticut called sponsor a discussion at Harvard Law School the court established by the Foreign Intelligence about the landmark work “Our Harsh Logic: Israeli Surveillance Act a “black box” that had remained Soldiers’ Testimonies from the Occupied Territories, secret both to the public at large and even to most 2000-2010.” The event, which was convened by members of Congress and vowed to continue Harvard Law School Professor Janet Halley, featured his fight for passing his proposed legislation, presentations by Avner Gvaryahu, former paratrooper co-sponsored by Senators Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) and Dotan Greenvald, former combat soldier with the and Tom Udall (D-N.M.) aimed at addressing the Israel Defense Forces. The event was co-sponsored court’s procedural issues. The talk was presented in by The Harvard Law School Human Rights Program cooperation with Harvard Law School’s Programs and the Harvard Graduate School of Education’s Civic on the Legal Profession, the Human Rights Program, Education Initiative. the Berkman Center for Internet and Society, International Legal Studies, and the Harvard University Institute of Politics.

27 Property From Below: SYMPOSIUM Doing a Distributional Analysis MIT, February 28, 2014 Harvard Law School, March 17, 2014 On February 28, 2014, the IGLP co-sponsored a public On March 17, 2014, the IGLP and the Program on Science, symposium at MIT on “The Global Commodification of Technology and Society at the Harvard Kennedy School Land.” The symposium resulted from a research project on co-sponsored a program on “Doing a Distributional property rights in land through the Displacement Research Analysis” which focused on new work by IGLP affiliated and Action Network at MIT, which is a collaborative project faculty. Presenters included Isabel Cristina Jaramillo between MIT and the University of Louvain, Belgium. The Sierra (Universidad de los Andes) who shared her paper Symposium addressed the key dilemmas of property theory “Uncertainty as Method: Distributional Analysis as Critique in the context of global commodification of land that has and Reconstruction,” Duncan Kennedy (Harvard Law School) led to widespread dispossession and contributing to the who shared his new work “Analyzing Distribution: Ricardo, current world food, housing, energy and environmental Marx, CLS,” and Janet Halley (Harvard Law School) who crises, and explored alternatives to dominant property shared her article “Steps in a Distributional Analysis.” rights paradigms such as the commons, social mobilization, and peasant rights. Presenters included: Balakrishnan Informal Enforcement of Competition Law: Perspectives (Department of Urban Studies and Planning, MIT); Rajagopal from the U.S. and Europe Eran Ben-Joseph (Head, Department of Urban Studies and Center for European Studies, March 24, 2014 Planning, MIT); (University of Louvain); Olivier DeSchutter On March 24, 2014 at the Center for European Studies, (Cornell University); Philip McMichael Saskia Sassen the IGLP co-sponsored the Harvard European Law (Columbia University); and (University of the Ruth Hall Association’s Spring Conference, “Informal Enforcement of Western Cape); (Harvard Law School). Duncan Kennedy Competition Law: Perspectives from the U.S. and Europe.” The conference was an opportunity for young antitrust Book Talk: Innovations in Refugee Protection students and practitioners to present and debate their work Harvard Law School, March 6, 2014 with prominent antitrust scholars as well as prominent On March 6, 2014, the Harvard Law School Library and competition enforcement officials. Speakers included: the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs, Harvard Einer Elhauge (Petrie Professor of Law, Harvard Law School), University and the IGLP co-sponsored a book talk and Damien Geradin (Professor of Law, George Mason University panel discussion in honor of International Women’s Day School of Law), and Jacques Steenbergen (Director General and in celebration of Luise Druke’s recently published in the Belgian Competition Authority). book, “Innovations in Refugee Protection: A Compendium of UNHCR’s 60 Years Including Case Studies on IT Communities, Vietnamese Boatpeople, Chilean Exile, and Namibian Repatriation.” Book talk panelists included Martha Minow, Harvard Law School Dean, Jonathan Moore, former U.S. Refugee Coordinator, U.S. State Department, and Christianne Lemke, Max Weber Chair in German and European Politics at New York University. Luise Druke is a former Visiting Researcher at the IGLP.

28 other events

How the Law Responds to Unique Catastrophes: Property After Neoliberalism.” Participants critiqued Personal Reflections When it Comes to Tragic Choices the property regime that enables the neoliberal Harvard Law School, April 1, 2014 order and collectively explored how property law On April 1, at the Harvard Law School, the IGLP can be re-oriented to promote social flourishing over along with the Program on Science, Technology and the needs of capital. Presenters included Harvard Society at the Harvard Kennedy School co-sponsored Law School Professor Duncan Kennedy and Professor a talk by Ken Feinberg who offered personal Rashmi Dyal-Chand from Northeastern University

iglp events reflections on how he became an expert in managing School of Law. compensation in unique catastrophes. He spoke of the issues he has faced in achieving a sense of justice Critical Perspectives on Human Rights in the aftermath of tragedy through his various roles Harvard Law School, April 8, 2014 and appointments, including serving as Special On April 8, 2014, at Harvard Law School, the Human Master of the U.S. government’s September 11th Rights Program and the IGLP co-sponsored an Victim Compensation Fund, Special Master for TARP event on “Critical Perspectives on Human Rights,” Executive Compensation, and as the government- as part of a series to foster discussion around appointed administrator of the BP Deepwater human rights practices and concepts. The event Horizon Disaster Victim Compensation Fund. featured Jeanne Charn, a Senior Lecturer on Law at Harvard Law School, in conversation with Meera Technological Visions and Revisions: An STS Shah, who is a Clinical Advocacy Fellow at the Workshop Human Rights Program at Harvard Law School. The Harvard Kennedy School, April 4, 2014 discussion focused on comparing and contrasting On April 4, 2014 the IGLP co-hosted this workshop at the methodologies of international human rights the Harvard Kennedy School, which drew together advocacy projects and projects involving direct client several strands of current research on socio-technical representation. In particular, it explored how these imaginaries in the Program on Science, Technology different approaches to legal work address the ethical and Society at the Harvard Kennedy School. Through and pedagogical questions involved in navigating

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL multiple engagements with new, emerging, and power dynamics, informed consent, and connection reemerging technologies, the workshop explored to affected communities. the material, discursive, and political resources with which societies create shared visions of what they The Modern American Right’s Thinking About want, or do not want, from advances in technology. Expertise: Taxonomy and Reflections Of primary interest throughout was the connection Harvard Law School, April 9, 2014 of remembered techno-scientific pasts to the threats On April 9, 2014, the IGLP along with the Program and promises of imagined futures. , Alfred Nordmann on Science, Technology and Society at the Harvard from the Technical University of Darmstadt, delivered Kennedy School co-sponsored a talk by Boston the keynote address entitled “Beyond Conservation - College Professor Ken Kersh on “The Modern Revisioning Critiques of Technological Reason.” American Right’s Thinking About Expertise: Taxonomy and Reflections.” In his recent work, Unbound: This Land is Your Land: Remaking Property Professor Kersch has sought to demonstrate the ways after Neoliberalism in which modern American conservatism’s cultivation Harvard Law School, April 5, 2014 of a core set of symbolic commitments (e.g., the U.S. On, April 5, 2014 at Harvard Law School, the IGLP Constitution) and historical narratives (e.g., about co-sponsored a day-long conference with the student the meanings of the Founding, the Civil War, and journal “Unbound: The Harvard Journal of the Legal the Progressive Era) bridge these divides, unifying Left,” entitled, “This Land is Your Land: Remaking and motivating the movement in ways missed by

29 political theory’s standard analytic frames. In his talk, he citizenship, and territorial disputes? Are biological sciences, considered the possibility that critiques of, and stories technologies, and society entangled to the point of being about, science and experts, and their role in the modern co-produced, and if so in what ways? The symposium regulatory/administrative/social welfare state – what others tackled these questions from a global perspective, with the have variously called the “statutory,” “legislative,” or “policy” hope of fostering dialogue across disciplinary divides and state – have been a critical component of this set of unifying geographical regions. Nadia Abu El-Haj, Associate Professor narratives and symbols. of Anthropology at Barnard College & Columbia University delivered the keynote address entitled “The Nature of Politics.” Harvard Law School Brazilian Studies Association event featuring Brazilian Secretary of Foreign Commerce Harvard Law School, April 11, 2014 Prosecutions, Politics and Transitions On April 11, 2014, the IGLP co-sponsored an event with Durham Law School (UK), May 6, 2014 Brazilian Studies Association which featured Daniel On May 6, 2014, the IGLP co-supported this event with Marteleto Godinho, Brazilian Secretary of Foreign Commerce. the Centre for Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, Law The talk was focused on economic and social development and Global Justice, and Islam, Law and Modernity. This in Brazil, focusing on infrastructure. conference addressed the question of the prosecution of political leaders in the Arab region, with a focus on four countries whose leaders were ousted during the Arab Science, Identity, and Ethnicity: States and Citizens in Global Spring uprisings: Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, and Yemen. As much Knowledge Regimes of the transitional justice literature is currently heavy on Center for Government and International Studies, April 24-25, analyses of the Latin American experience, panelists also 2014 considered that region’s varied experiences with transitional From April 24 -25, 2014, the IGLP along with the Program on justice since the 1970’s. Panelists included: (Senior Science, Technology and Society at the Harvard Kennedy Elin Skaar Researcher, Chr. Michelsen Institute), , School and the Harvard Center for Middle Eastern Studies Moataz El Fegiry (former Executive Director, Cairo Institute for Human Rights co-hosted a two-day interdisciplinary workshop focused Studies, SOAS Law School), (Director, Lawyers on Science, Identity, and Ethnicity. Participants sought to Elham Saudi for Justice in Libya), (Senior Associate, understand the extent genetic sciences have expanded or Greta Barbone International Justice Programme, No Peace Without Justice), circumscribed the ways of authorizing ethnic and national and , (Guest Lecturer, Centre for Middle East belonging. How has research in population genetics and Khaled Fattah Studies, Lund University and non-resident scholar on human biogeography affected legal and political rights to Yemen, Carnegie Middle East Center).

other events

Workshop: Global Poverty and Heterodox International Digital Business Seminar Development Pathways Harvard Law School, July 7-11, 2014 Sciences Po Law School (France), May 17-19, 2014 On July 7-11, 2014, the IGLP and Real Colegio From May 17-19, 2014 the IGLP and The Sciences Compultense co-sponsored the International Digital Po Law School co-sponsored a Workshop in Paris, Business Seminar organized in collaboration with France, as part of our ongoing research project Instituto Superior para el Desarrollo de Internet on Global Poverty and Heterodox Development (ISDI). The aim of the seminar was to begin a vibrant Pathways. This workshop explored emerging ideas dialogue on Technology, Internet, Business Models iglp events about organizing political economies that push back and Entrepreneurship, and Social Networks. It against global inequalities. Participants examined brought together students, professionals and emerging ideas in sectors of contemporary global researchers from different backgrounds, who political economies, such as finance, agriculture, attended lectures delivered by prestigious professors industrial organization, supranational governance, from Harvard University, MIT and Cornell University, political movement, and critique. Participants as well as acknowledged professionals in the field of included: David Kennedy (Professor of Law and IGLP Innovation and New Technologies. Director, Harvard Law School), Duncan Kennedy (Carter Professor of General Jurisprudence, Harvard Seminar on International Taxation Law School), Roy Kreitner (Faculty of Law, Tel Aviv Harvard Law School, July 7-9, 2014 University), (Lloyd M. Bentsen Chair Willy Forbath On July 7-9, 2014, the IGLP, The Universidad Rey Juan and Associate Dean of Research, UT Austin School Carlos de Madrid, and the Real Colegio Complutense of Law), (Global Professor of Law, New Dennis Davis co-sponsored the Summer Course on International York University School of Law), (Louis Lucie White Taxation. The seminar addressed main issues in A. Horvitz Professor of Law, Harvard Law School), International Taxation, such as state aids, tax havens, (Professor, Department of Economics, Mushtaq Kahn anti-abuse clauses in double taxation conventions, SOAS London), (Professor of Olivier de Schutter and aggressive tax planning techniques. The so- Law, University of Louvain), (Doctoral Lauren Coyle called “BEPS” (Base Erosion and Profits Shifting), Candidate, Dept. of Anthropology, University of that has been the subject of important research ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Chicago), (Doctoral Candidate, Dept. Meghan Morris and policy-making initiatives promoted by the of Anthropology, University of Chicago), and Nate Organisation for Economic Co-operation and , (Ph.D. candidate in Sociology, University of Ela Development (OECD) and the EU Commission, was Wisconsin-Madison). also dealt with.

International Workshop. The Death Penalty: Modern Research Perspectives (History, Law, Politics) Harvard Law School, June 2, 2014 On June 2, 2014, the IGLP co-sponsored a day of lectures on the death penalty by experts and scholars to RCC fellows and associates, professors, students of Harvard Law School and other relevant schools and centers of Harvard University. There was an academic discussion about the origins of the death penalty, its evolution and its modern day implications and other key questions related to capital punishment. Other sponsors included: Real Colegio Compultense, Universidad Compultense de Madrid, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, and Fundación Universitaria Española.

31 international network

young scholars

32 lectures & presentations

Lectures and Presentations by • Panel, “International Law and Global Political Economy,” Professor David Kennedy “Power, Privilege and the Pursuit of Justice: Legal Challenges in Precarious Times,” 2013 Annual Meeting of • Conference Convener, “Global Legal Thought: The the Law and Society Association, Boston, MA, June 1, 2013. Legacies of Heterdoxy,” Harvard Law School, Cambridge, • Remarks, “International Law and Religion Working Group MA, June 3, 2014. Meeting,” Helsinki, Finland, May 13, 2013. • “Critique and Speculation,” Heterodox Innovations and iglp events • “Formulating a Global Agenda, Next Left: Framing a New Development Pathways: Mapping, Method, and Critique” Narrative,” FEPS Conference, IDEC-Universitat Pompeu Workshop, Sciences Po, Paris, France, May 18, 2014. Fabra, Barcelona, Spain, May 9-11, 2013. • Plenary Remarks, “Globalization and Legal Education,” • Remarks, ARPC Council Meeting, Beijing, China, April 23- Law and Boundaries Annual International Conference, 25, 2013. Sciences Po, Paris, France, May 19 - 20, 2014.

• Speaker, “American Conference Institute’s 29th • “Law and Global Political Economy,” Baldy Center for Law National Forum on the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act,” and Social Policy, SUNY Buffalo Law School, Buffalo, NY, PricewaterhouseCoopers, New York, NY, April 16-17, 2013. March 28, 2014.

• Moderator, “Koskenniemi Workshop: Does International • “Global Governance and Political Economy,” Cornell Law Law Needs a ‘Progressive’ Idea of History?” Temple School, Ithaca, NY, March 26, 2014. University, Philadelphia PA, April 12-13, 2013 • Remarks, “Global Governance and Political Economy” • Keynote Panel, “Reducing Poverty and Inequality: Workshop, Tulane University School of Law, New Orleans, Persistent Challenges and New Solutions,” The Lauder LA, February 26, 2014. Institute and the Wharton School, Philadelphia, PA, April • Remarks, “The Global Context for Risk Management,” 7th 11-12, 2013. Annual PwC Global Economic Crime Survey Roundtable, • Interview, “Risk Management and Resilience in Today’s New York, NY, February 19, 2014. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Global Regulatory Environment,” PricewaterhouseCoopers, • Plenary Remarks,”Heterodoxy in International Law & Washington DC, March 28, 2013. Policy,” 2014 IGLP Workshop, Hamad bin Khalifa University, • “Critical Approaches to International Law and Warfare”, Doha, Qatar, January 3, 2014. The American University in Cairo, Egypt, March 10, 2013. • “Rule of Law and Economic Development after 2015: • “Global Governance for the Political Economy of Today”, The Importance of Choices,” at the conference: “Investing Rafael del Pino Foundation, Madrid, Spain, February 21, in the Rule of Law, Justice and Security for the Post 2015 2013. Development Agenda”, Thailand Institute of Justice,

Bangkok, Thailand, November 15-16, 2013. • “Risk Management and Corporate Anti-Corruption Compliance Strategies -- A Discussion with Prof. David • “Fostering Peace and Development,” at the conference: Kennedy”, American Bar Association, Washington, D.C., “Dialogue on Diversity, Peace and Diplomacy”, Institute February 14, 2013. of Strategic and International Studies (ISIS), Putrajaya,

Malaysia, November 11, 2013. • “Critical Legal Scholarship”, Birkbeck Law School, London, January 24, 2013. • Opening Remarks/Keynote speaker, “The New Law of

Economic Development,” at the LANDS Conference, FGV • “Law and Global Political Economy”, IGLP Workshop, Doha, Law School, São Paulo, Brazil, July 1-4, 2013. Qatar, January 11, 2013.

33 34 current research projects

Rethinking Law and Finance in the Global Economy

This project, organized by Christine Desan (United States) Harvard Law School, of our Advisory Council, focuses on the lessons of heterodox and institutionalist traditions in both economic and legal science for understanding global political economy in the aftermath of the crisis. We are particularly interested in the relationships among private law, private ordering, national regulation, and opportunities for multilateral governance or coordination. We are exploring the significance of disarticulation and intended inefficiencies in global systems in avoiding systemic risk – when introduced both within the transnational governance of private financial institutions and through regulation. The project focuses on the legal structure of money, credit, and financial liquidity. It considers capital dynamics as a matter engineered over time by different government, non‐governmental organizations and private actors, paying particular attention to the ways in

iglp research iglp research which capital dynamics cross borders, studying the domestic and global dimensions of capital dynamics in tandem. During the 2012-2013 academic year, we co-sponsored a graduate student-faculty research seminar on Financial Capitalism, which focused on the structures of finance and money, with an eye towards the financial crisis.

Expertise and Governance

This project aims to strengthen research linking efforts to understand the role of expertise in global governance among IGLP scholars with parallel work undertaken in the Science and Technology Studies field. The focal point for collaboration has been a series of lectures, research workshops, and an inter-faculty reading group organized by IGLP Director David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School, and Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Harvard Kennedy School of Government. Questions under discussion include: Who are experts, whom do they represent, what are the sources of their authority, and how can expertise be held accountable? What kinds of institutions employ expertise, and what are the organizational characteristics of such institutions? How does the growing global reliance on experts affect the quality, effectiveness, and accountability of public policy and governance? Through readings and/or presentations from several fields— including law, anthropology, history, sociology, and science and technology studies—the reading group considers the ways expertise is defined, constituted, challenged, defended, or defeated in contemporary societies. The research initiative is supported by a seminar jointly taught by Jasanoff and Kennedy at Harvard Law School and the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. each spring. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

Global Genealogy of Family Laws

The rise of colonialism, capitalism, liberalism, modernity, and nationalism across much of the world was strongly inflected by the idea that legal and social life divides naturally into two opposite orders – the market and the family. The idea was that the market was or should be governed by contract law that would ideally be uniform across the world and that would enable contracts giving effect to the will of the parties; while the family was or should be governed by family law that gave effect to the spirit of each national people and that enforced interpersonal duties. The idea is so pervasive that it seems inevitable that commercial law will be uniform and western everywhere and that family life, gender and sexuality will be local and “different.” It also is so structural that it helps to explain how political economy imagines itself to encompass everything crucial about global governance while chronically “forgetting” the family, gender and sexuality. This IGLP project, led by Harvard Law School professor Janet Halley (United States), seeks to compare the spread of this idea and its various implementations across the world, both in the formation of colonial relations and in the breakdown of the colonial system. We believe that by understanding it genealogically and comparatively, we can better pry away the glue fixing us to it even today.

35 Global Poverty and Heterodox Development Pathways: Mapping, Method and Critique

This Project, which is led by Harvard Law Professor Lucie White and Sciences Po Law Professor Jeremy Perelman, is a collaborative effort among critical law and development scholars to present, map, and critique alternative development pathways that are emerging in the confused phase of the post-Washington Consensus. The initiative was launched as a Pro-Seminar in 2012 where members of the group presented short papers that tease out the methodological features of their respective approaches, as well as the distributional effects of the developmental pathways that they identify. In May 2014 The IGLP and Sciences Po Law School co-sponsored a Workshop in Paris, France, May 17-19, 2014 as part of our ongoing research project on Global Poverty and Heterodox Development Pathways. This workshop explored emerging ideas about organizing political economies that push back against global inequalities. Participants examined such emerging ideas in sectors of contemporary global political economies, such as finance, agriculture, industrial organization, supranational governance, political movement, and critique.

Bandung and the Global South: 60 Years of Transformative International Law

The Bandung Conference of April 1955 brought together twenty-five countries to oppose colonialism and neocolonialism and develop forms of political, economic and cultural cooperation across the Third World. The legacies of the Bandung Conference have long reach within critical traditions in international law. This project brings together scholars who have been influenced by the Bandung Conference and seeks to provide an opportunity for them to reflect on the legacies of the conference that animate their work today and the ways they can think about alternative futures going forward. There are many intersecting and overlapping conversations that Bandung inspires amongst critical international law scholars. Some contributions will provide more historical analysis on the conference and its milieu; others will focus on more contemporary themes that resonate with Bandung’s legacies of South-South cooperation and anti-imperialism. Some ground their interventions in Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL); others may locate it within the many spaces after nationalism in their countries. The project has been defined quite broadly to enable a range of different kinds of contributions with the goal of producing a scholarly volume for publication. This project has been organized by Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Harvard Law School, of our Academic Council, with the support of IGLP Docents Luis Eslava (Australia) University of Melbourne Law School), and Michael Fakhri (Canada) University of Oregon School of Law. The members of this project convened a series of meeting at Harvard Law School in June 2014.

Heterodox Approaches to Islamic Law and Policy

This project, which is led by Cyra Akila Choudhury (United States) Florida International University College of Law, and Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina) University of London, and advised by Harvard Law Professor Intisar Rabb (United States), explores current thinking in the field of Islamic Law and Policy. Specifically, it brings together a diverse group of established and emerging scholars to share critical and comparative methodologies and approaches to Islamic law and jurisprudence. Scholars from law, history, political science, anthropology, economics, and other social sciences share research on topics including Islamic legal thought, legal history, family law, finance, and the arts. The organizers of this project convened a two-day conference at Harvard Law School in June 2014.

36 current research projects

Corporate Power in Global Society: Explication, Critique, Engagement, and Resistance

This project, convened by Dan Danielsen (United States) Northeastern University School of Law, Dennis Davis (South Africa) High Court of Cape Town, and Jason Jackson (United States) Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania), explores the role of law in the construction, operation and governance of global value chains and production networks: structures that have been theorized by sociologists and political economists to map the disaggregated modes of production that comprise much of modern global capitalism. Research is focused on examining how diverse local, national, regional, international and transnational legal regimes, together with cultural norms and business practices, shape the expectations, background entitlements, institutional forms and bargaining positions of various players in global production networks. Taken into consideration are

iglp research iglp research how legal entitlements and normative expectations interact with material factors of production to produce particular forms of commercial relations as well as particular attributions of power and value creation. The group also explores how those legal rules and norms come to shape value chain governance, including the allocation of economic surplus and power, as well as the perceived limits of possible regulatory interventions to distribute rents more equitably or to reduce adverse externalities that result from a networked organization of production. The organizers of this project convened a two-day conference as well as a Pro-Seminar at Harvard Law School in June 2014.

Project on Global Financial Regulation and Financial Inclusion

This project, supported by IGLP’s Leading Sponsor, VISA International, encompassed inquiries into three related areas: liquidity in the global economy, including foundational research on the nature of global liquidity and capital as legal institutions; financial inclusion and banking services for the “unbanked” as an aspect of development policy; financial service regulation in emerging markets and alternative paths to economic development. Through a series of sponsored student and faculty research projects and public policy discussions we sought to develop a transnational research network of young scholars and IGLP faculty working on research themes related to global financial regulation. The initiative’s inaugural event was a policy workshop on March 30, 2012, which brought scholars from the IGLP network into sustained conversation with high-level government officials and industry representatives. In August 2012, the IGLP convened a research mission and workshop in Bangkok focused on new financial services regulation and development strategies in ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL the emerging markets of the ASEAN region. In 2012 and 2013, the initiative sponsored a competitive research grant program for young scholars.

The Next Left – The Challenges and Opportunities for Social Democratic Politics in a Global Economy

This project, which we are co-sponsoring with Dr. Alfred Gusenbauer (Former Chancellor of Austria) of our Honorary Council, encourages dialogue among those rethinking the politics of the left after globalization in various regions of the world, with a particular emphasis on the dynamics within Europe and between Europe and Latin America. The IGLP convened a meeting of the group at Harvard Law School in April 2012. On May 10 -11, 2013, the IGLP co-sponsored the policy roundtable, “Next Left: Framing a New Narrative”, in Barcelona, Spain. The event explored topics such as restoring a sense of politics, distinguishing modern progressivism, and building a welfare society. IGLP will cosponsor a further exploration of these themes in 2014.

37 Law and the New Developmental State

Law and the New Developmental State was a collaborative faculty project led by IGLP Advisory Council Member David Trubek that sought to examine the modern revival of the developmental state. This project, co-sponsored with the network on Law and the New Developmental State (LANDS) explored relations between the legal order and new state policies in Brazil, Mexico, Colombia and Venezuela. As part of this initiative the IGLP co-sponsored a seminar and research mission to Brazil in July 2013 which explored the emerging forms of new state activism in Brazil and elsewhere. In July 2013, research done for the LANDS initiative resulted in the publication of “Law and the New Developmental State: The Brazilian Experience in Latin American Context“. The project was spear-headed by David Trubek (United States) University of Wisconsin, in conjunction with other IGLP alumni including Diogo Coutinho (Brazil) University of São Paulo Law School, Mario Schapiro (Brazil) Fundação Getulio Vargas/São Paulo Law School, Shunko Rojas (Argentina) Harvard Law School, Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Georgetown Law School), Michelle Ratton Sanchez Badin (Brazil) Fundação Getulio Vargas/ São Paulo Law School), and Helena Alviar Garcia (Colombia) Universidad de los Andes Law School. The book explores the emergence of a new developmental state in Latin America and its significance for law and development theory.

38 collaborative research grants

The IGLP Collaborative Research Grant Program is designed to provide modest funding to small groups of young scholars seeking to carry out substantive research on projects related to the core research mission of the IGLP. Through the Research Grants Program, we seek to facilitate innovative group research and writing projects in these fields, and to deepen collaboration among our network of Harvard Law School graduate students, IGLP Workshop alumni, and IGLP faculty. These Grants are designed for small teams of two or more scholars. Preference is given to groups whose ideas or projects emerged out of the IGLP’s Workshop.

Collaborative Research Grants awarded in 2014 inlcude:

iglp research iglp research Global Art Law and Cultural Property: Productions of Value

Convener: Vivek Kanwar (United States) Jindal Global Law School. Contributors: Deval Desai (United Kingdom), Harvard Law School; Yugank Goyal (India) University of Hamburg; Priya Gupta (United States) Southwestern Law School; Richard Lehun (Canada) McGill University; Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) University of New South Wales; James Parker (United Kingdom) Melbourne Law School; and Jonathan Walz (United States) Rollins College. Description: If the art market were a country, it would be the 67th largest country in the world by GDP, and yet there is little understanding of the production of value in art practice and its legal regulation. This project will explore the potential for new methodologies to contribute to art law: from critical legal studies, science and technology studies, law and economics, archaeology, legal aesthetics, and value-chain analyses.

Indicators as Political Spaces

Convener: Rene Urueña (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes. Contributors: Dawood Ahmed (United Kingdom) University of Chicago; Siobhan Airey (Ireland) University of Ottawa; Lina Buchely (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes; Marie Guimezanes (France) Toulouse 1 Capitole University; Marta Infantino (Italy) University of Trieste; Jothie Rajah (Singapore) American Bar Foundation; and Michael Riegner (Germany) New York University School of Law. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Description: Since the early 1990s, indicators have played an important role in reshaping governance, policy, and the parameters of law. In exploring the new political spaces that are opened up by qualitative technologies of governance, this group will examine how indicators are used to perpetuate, shift, or resist power relations, and to achieve or prevent social change. Is global power experienced differently if it is exercised through an indicator? Does the emphasis on numbers take attention away from context, history, and questions of power?

39 International Legal Structuralism

Convener: Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) University of Colorado Law School. Contributors: Paulo Barrozo (United States) Boston College Law School; Arnulf Becker (Chile) Brown University; and Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) University of Glasgow. Description: This research initiative will re-examine the works of international legal scholarship influenced by “structuralism” from the 1980s forward (David Kennedy’s “International Legal Structures” and Martti Koskenniemi’s “From Apology to Utopia”. The group will meet at New York University in the fall of 2014 to explore the current application of legal structuralism in international legal scholarship, now a generation later. The group aims to produce an edited volume for publication.

Legal Education on International Public Law: Rethinking the Latin American Experience

Convener: Paola Acosta (Colombia) Universidad Externado de Colombia. Contributors: Laura Betancur (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes; Enrique Prieto Rios (Colombia) Birkbeck, University of London; and Jimena Sierra (Colombia) Universidad del Rosario. Description: This project aims to build a working academic platform in Latin America for the promotion of interdisciplinary and critical teaching of Public International Law. Although Latin America has long been a source of intellectual and political innovation in international law, the contemporary scholarly tradition is often characterized by a dogmatic form of teaching, based on a reproduction of a Western approach. The group hopes to generate a regional movement organized around rethinking approaches to teaching and researching in the field.

Locating Nature: Making and Unmaking International Law

Convener: Usha Natarajan (Australia) The American University in Cairo. Contributors: Nadia Ahmad (United States) Sustainable Development Strategies Group; Saptarishi Bandopadhyay (India) Harvard Law School; Aurélien Bouayad (France) Sciences Po Law School; Julia Dehm (Australia) Melbourne Law School; Hélène Mayrand (Canada) University of Sherbrooke; Roger Merino Acuña (Peru) University of Bath; Areli Valencia (Peru) University of Ottawa; and Karolina Zurek (Poland) Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies. Description: This project aims to locate nature as a central disciplinary concept in the international legal field, alongside sovereignty, jurisdiction, trade, and development. The project steps beyond the category of “international environmental law,” urging the unmaking and reformulation of central disciplinary tenets to encapsulate healthier understandings of nature. The group will explore ideas of the ‘human’ that underpin global law and policy, including the relationship between human rights law and the environment, environmental justice, and ‘environmentality,’ and the evolution of new areas of expertise.

40 collaborative research grants

Ongoing IGLP Alumni Collaborative Research Initiatives include:

Critical Approaches to International Criminal Law (CAICL) Organized by: Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard Law School; Alejandra Azuero-Quijano (Colombia) Harvard Law School; Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University London; Michelle Burgis- Kasthala (Australia) University of Edinburgh; Paul Kingsley Clark (United Kingdom) Garden Court Chambers; Delphine Dogot (Belgium) Sciences Po Law School; Christopher Gevers (South Africa) Melbourne Law School; Ioannis Kalpouzos (Greece) The City Law School, City University London; Tor Krever (Canada) London School of Economics and Political Science; Itamar Mann (United States) Georgetown Law School; John Reynolds (Ireland) National University of Ireland, Galway; Jamie Rowen, University of Toronto; Christine Schwöbel (Germany),

iglp research iglp research University of Liverpool Law School; and Immi Tallgren (Finland) University of Helsinki. Description: Mainstream debates in the international criminal law (ICL) field by and large do not examine the complicities of ICL in injustice and conflict. In contrast, CAICL aims to uncover and understand the exclusions and biases in the contemporary understanding of ICL and to question the assumptions that inform the field. In so doing, the Group hopes to identify and assemble an expanded range of sites of critique of (and within) ICL. With IGLP collaborative research support, in 2014 CAICL produced an edited collection, “Critical Approaches to International Criminal Law: An Introduction” (Christine Schwöbel, ed., Routledge).

Turf and Texture: Narrating the Legal International Organized by: Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) University of New South Wales; Nikolas M. Rajkovic (Canada) University of Kent Law School; and Surabhi Ranganathan (India) King’s College Cambridge. Description: Current debates in international law are informed by narratives about what the international legal order “is” or “should be.” Dominant labels include: “global administrative law,” “constitutionalization of international law,” “international legal pluralism,” and “fragmentation of international law.” While these narratives attempt to explain alleged convergences and divergences of international legal rules and institutions, little work has scrutinized the contribution of these narratives to an idea of the “legal international.” This project aims to compare and analyze these narratives across specific specialized regimes in order to understand how they function, and to evaluate their impact on positive international law.

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Global Law in Context Organized by: Luis Eslava (Colombia) Melbourne Law School; Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia & Herzegovina) SOAS, University of London; Vidya Kumar (Canada) University of Birmingham; Yoriko Otomo (Australia) SOAS, University of London; and Henrique Carvalho (Brazil) King’s College London. Description: This project responds to the inadequacy of current global law texts in addressing the rich variety of ways in which law is being produced, globalized and used across jurisdictions, scales of governance and social contexts. The group will generate an introductory undergraduate textbook, “Global Law in Context,” that will offer fresh and under-explored perspectives on global law as it relates to core legal subjects. The book will explore the plurality of mechanisms, rationalities, epistemologies, approaches, legal concepts and institutional arrangements that give a global shape to particular legal fields. It will provide an understanding of how global law is being constituted both as a new subject of knowledge and as a mode of practice and reasoning. At the same time, it will examine how existing (and emerging) understandings of global law build on, reinforce, and conflict with competing conceptions of law and globalization that are used to characterize the relationship between the Global North, Global South and elsewhere. Our textbook will be followed by a companion collection of essays entitled, “Global Law: Problems and Promises of a Concept.”

41 Rethinking Political Economy Organized by: Jason Jackson (United States & The Bahamas) Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania; and Anush Kapadia (United States) City University London. Description: This project seeks to address the narrow nature of academic and policy discourse around the socioeconomic and governance challenges we face, epitomized by the financial crisis, but also in long-standing debates on economic development and global governance. It seeks to promote new thinking on economic governance by analyzing the distributional implications of the crisis and how the responses to it were constructed through political contestation, rather than the dominant (depoliticized) view of these being technocratic outputs from “experts.”

Pursuing Your Enemies in the South: International Law and the War Against Crime and Terror Organized by: Arnulf Becker (Chile) Brown University; Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) University of Colorado Law School; John Haskell (United States) Mississippi College School of Law; Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) University of Glasgow; and Vivek Kanwar (United States) Jindal Global Law School. Description: Legal experts have explored the tensions between new forms and goals of warfare and the traditional law of war. Western states with strategic interests and military capabilities to pursue their enemies by using armed force beyond their own frontiers take an expansive reading of the law of war. On the contrary, international lawyers situated in the West, but who see the law from the perspective of the interest of the international community, generally advance a more restrictive interpretation of the law of war. Remarkably, however, there is no view interpreting rules and balancing policy objectives in light of the interests and position of those most commonly affected by the new modes of military intervention and conflict: weaker states of the semi-periphery. The collection that the group will produce will attempt to fill this gap.

Before and After Method: Histories and Sociologies of International Law Organized by: John Haskell (United States) Mississippi College School of Law; Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) University of Glasgow; Alejandro Lorite Escorihuela (Colombia) The American University in Cairo; and Umut Özsu (Canada) University of Manitoba. Description: This two-year project on the methodologies of international legal scholarship will attempt to “sociologize” the enterprise of international legal historiography. Broaching international legal history as a field of competing projects driven by rival visions of world order and state sovereignty, this enterprise will contribute to the increasingly self-reflexive literature on the sociology of international legal thought and practice.

Critical Approaches to Human Rights Organized by: Aziza Ahmed (United States) Northeastern University School of Law; Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) University of Edinburgh; and Zinaida Miller (United States) The Fletcher School, Tufts University. Description: This project will examine critical approaches to human rights with an eye towards understanding where and how the critiques have become absorbed into mainstream human rights work without significant transformation of the field.

42 Doha-Santander research grants

The Doha - Santander Grants program is generously supported by Santander Universities. The initiative supports research by IGLP alumni and faculty pursuing innovative scholarship aiming to revitalize the Arab and Islamic traditions of law and governance and to explore issues of comparative law, global law, and policy in Qatar, the Middle East, and North African Region. The grants are intended to further the dialogue begun at The Workshop through long-term research collaboration.

Collaborative Grants

Critical Approaches to Islamic Law and Economy II

Principal Investigators: Karen Rhone (USA), Doctoral Fellow, University of Chicago, and Laura Elder (USA), Assistant Professor, iglp research iglp research Saint Mary’s College

This project emerged out of Karen’s earlier Santander Grant Project on Islamic Law and Economy, which she launched in 2013. This project is focused on questions of Islamic law and policy that address genealogies of knowledge production and expertise, particularly those that coalesce around notions of moral economy, moral finance, and the resultant connections, and disconnections, to modes of global law and policy.

Chinese and Indian Land Grabs in Africa: Economic Imperialism?

Principal Investigators: George Forji Amin (Finland), PhD Candidate, University of Helsinki, and Razak Jaha (Ghana), Assistant Lecturer, University Cape Coast

This project investigates recent land acquisition patterns in Sub-Saharan Africa by Chinese and Indian investors in order to assess their effects on the proprietary rights of the African populace and their socio- economic impact on the livelihood of the latter. The researchers expect that analysis of these relatively new instruments of south-south economic hegemony may challenge the view that the “Third World” is inherently anti-imperialistic, enriching the literature on Third World Approaches to International Law while questioning ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL the wisdom among African political elites of considering China and India as “Third World friends.”

Individual Grants

Plural Customs and Formalization: Land Registration in Ethiopia

Mekonnen Ayano (Ethiopia), S.J.D. Candidate, Harvard Law School

This study analyzes the relationship between the plurality of customs and socio- economic relations respecting land in Ethiopia and the ongoing land registration program. The research will map customary practices and the history of land title and registration systems, examine theories justifying formalization, and analyze the consequences of the current formalization model. The work aims to develop alternative formalization procedures that could minimize damage to customary titles, practices and traditions. The grant will support field research in the Dugda district (Ethiopia) to identify the process of rural land registration and to examine whether and how it interferes with customary property titles.

43 Women in the new legal profession in India

Swethaa Ballakrishnen (United States), Ph.D. Candidate, Stanford University

Using in-depth interviews and new survey data, this project explores the institutional emergence of new legal professional spaces in India with egalitarian advantages for women legal professionals. As elsewhere, legal practice in India has been a male-dominated profession. Yet data suggests that women are less disadvantaged in new “global” legal workspaces in India emerging in the wake of market liberalization. These findings challenge conventional explanations of the persistence of professional gender hierarchy and of the organizational homogenizing impact of globalization. The grant will support comparative study of women lawyers working on global work in global firms, in traditional law practice, and those doing non-global work in global firms.

Authority and Islam: An Ethnography of Fatwa in Myanmar

Melissa Crouch (United States), Research Fellow, National University of Singapore

This ethnographic exploration of religious authority in Myanmar will use the practice of fatwa (Islamic legal opinions) to explore the contours of authority among the Islamic communities in Myanmar and to enrich our understanding of authority in Southeast Asia. The research will focus on the Islamic Religious Affairs Council, one of the peak Islamic bodies in Myanmar to issue fatwa, primarily in relation to questions of marriage, inheritance and divorce. The grant will support field research in Yangon and Mandalay, Myanmar, including interviews and the collection of primary materials.

Towards an Interruptive History of Islamic Law

Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina), Lecturer, SOAS, University of London

This project aims to identify factors shaping the Islamic legal tradition that have been overlooked in much Islamic law historiography, including cyclical globalization, vernacular knowledge systems, cultural revolutions, crude periodizations, and modernist re-configurations. The project began by assessing the major sources of Islamic legal historiography, and then focusing on issues befalling ‘scripturalist’ and ‘new historian’ works and their authors, including those of early Muslim imperialism and European colonialism. Earlier phases of the project, also supported by Doha - Santander grants, focused on archival and ethnographic work in Pakistan (2011), Egypt (2012), and Palestine (2013). This grant will support a third phase of research: a case study of newly emerging literature on the Mamluk historians of Islamic law and society undertaken through archival work in the UK, including translation and acquisition of research materials.

Constitutional Reform and Women’s Rights in Today’s Tunisia

John Hursh (United States), LL.M. Candidate, McGill University, Centre for Human Rights and Legal Pluralism

This project will deepen our understanding of the potential for local and international participation in legal reform and constitutionalization in Islamic majority nations, using the example of the Tunisian constitution’s provisions on women’s rights and gender equality. The grant will support travel to meet with influential academics, women’s rights supporters, and civil society organization leaders in Tunisia to discuss their role in securing a gender equality provision within the new constitution.

44 Doha-Santander research grants

Individual Grants (Continued)

Islamic Practices of International Heritage Protection & the Politics of Regionalism in International Law

Lucas Lixinski (Brazil), Lecturer, University of New South Wales

This project examines the (relatively sparse) participation of Islamic countries in the international heritage work of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) in light of the international heritage protection practices of the Islamic Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization

iglp research iglp research (ISESCO). The project will interrogate the politics of regionalism in international law, examining Islamic traditions of international law-making, and standard-setting, and the relationships between the Islamic tradition and universal-aspiring bodies.

Islamic Law and the Struggle for Governance in Somalia

Mark Massoud (United States), Assistant Professor, University of California, Santa Cruz

This project will contribute to scholarship on the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region by using the case of Somalia to illuminate how law (including Islamic law) plays a role in state formation and governance. Building on research in Sudan and Somalia, this interdisciplinary study of law and development focuses on how lawyers, activists, and community leaders use legal mechanisms to build peace and security. The study combines ethnographic fieldwork in Somaliland and archival research at the British Library. The grant will also support additional qualitative interviews in summer 2014.

Managing Foreign Investment in Natural Resources: Can Colombia Learn from Qatar?

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Nicolás Perrone (Argentina), Assistant Professor, Universidad Externado de Colombia

This project explores the lessons Colombia may learn from Qatar’s laws on foreign investment in natural resources. The natural resource boom in South America makes the management of natural resources a policy priority for countries like Colombia. Harnessing foreign investment without a loss of control or benefit has been a recurring challenge. Gulf countries, including Qatar, have moved from concession to joint venture agreements for the production of oil and gas in the last thirty years, allowing a higher degree of control and giving the government voice and authority over operations, risks and benefits. Although these alternative structures for foreign investment were discredited by the World Bank and the OECD during the nineties, this project examines the potential relevance of the Qatari experience for resource management in Colombia.

45 G20 “outreach” to Islamic and MENA Region Nations Susan Harris Rimmer (Australia), Director of Studies at the Asia-Pacific College of Diplomacy, Australian National University

This project investigates whether Muslim nations represented on the G20 (Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Indonesia) feel a responsibility to provide leadership in the G20 in ways influenced by Islamic conceptions of finance and banking, and whether and how these nations provide outreach about their G20 discussions to other Islamic states or Middle East and North Africa (MENA) countries. The study will explore the success of the “outreach” strategy—diplomatic meetings and communications strategies used by the host state to let the rest of the international community know the priorities of the G20 Summits— with particular focus on the Islamic world and the MENA region. The grant will support research in Jakarta, Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

The Reconfiguration of Migration through Islamic Finance

Shanthi Senthe (Canada), Ph.D Candidate, Osgoode Hall Law School

This research project explores the contours of Islamic finance within non-Islamic jurisdictions, its ‘legal’ integration into the financial system, and its links to remittance and migration patterns using Sri Lanka as a case study. The study supported by this grant—drawing upon earlier qualitative research in Sri Lanka on the regulation of financial inclusion—will examine the specific conditions propelling the rise and extension of Islamic finance in specific non-Islamic jurisdictions and the ways in which Islamic finance has transformed the financial regulatory landscape and influenced national dialogue on migration issues.

The Role of Ethnicity in the Political Organization of Nation-States: The Case of Uyghur Muslims in China

Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh), Assistant Professor, Chairman, Department of Law & Justice, Jahangrinagar University

Although ethnic conflicts typically result from a number of inter-related issues, this research focuses on the tension between two political ideologies: the secular political ideology of the Communist Party of China and the ever-increasing salience of Islam as a political ideology among Uyghur Muslims. The study aims to examine the concept of statehood in Islamic jurisprudence, and address its compatibility with nationalist movements by Muslim minorities along the religious line. The grant will support research using secondary literature and a short field visit to Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang.

The Rise of the Term ‘Shari’a-Compliant’ in 21st Century Finance

Nurfadzilah Yahaya (Singapore), Mark Steinberg Weil Early Career Fellow in Islamic Studies, Washington University School of Law

This study places the recent rise of the term and practice of “shari’a-compliant” banking products and investments in Islamic finance in historical perspective. The project will examine the determination of shari’a compliance, if by other names, in financial arrangements during the colonial period in Southeast Asia, and explore the process by which this yielded to today’s more explicit certification of compliance with shari’a. The grant will support archival work in Indonesia and Malaysia to examine colonial documents pertaining to Islamic law and commercial affairs in both Netherlands Indies and Malaya during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

46 IGLP fellows

Inaugurated in 2006, the IGLP Fellowship Program offers doctoral and post-doctoral fellowship support to a small number of scholars pursuing research in areas related to the IGLP’s ongoing work. Through the Fellowship Program the IGLP seeks to encourage the development of progressive and alternative ideas about international law, society and political economy by supporting original, provocative and challenging intellectual work that might not otherwise find support from mainstream institutional resources and which contributes to the emergence of new approaches to international law and global social justice.

The IGLP is very pleased to announce the appointment of six new Fellows. Joining the IGLP in 2014-15 as Residential Fellows are Lina Maria Céspedes-Baez, Julia Dehm, Tomaso Ferrando, and Maja Savevska. Our 2014- 15 Non-Residential Fellows are Arnulf Becker, and Zinaida Miller.

people iglp at 2014-15 Residential Fellows

Lina Maria Céspedes-Baez (Colombia) Temple University

Idealized Women, Idealized Harms: Governance Feminism and the Narrowing of Women’s Experiences in Colombia’s Armed Conflict

Lina M. Céspedes-Baez is a Colombian lawyer, currently pursuing her S.J.D. degree at the James E. Beasley School of Law, Temple University as a Fulbright Scholar. Her research has focused on the interactions between private law, international law, human rights and gender. Lina received her law degree from Universidad del Rosario (Colombia). She has a specialized degree in tax law from Universidad del Rosario, a Masters in Gender Studies from Universidad Nacional de Colombia, and an LL.M. with a concentration in international law from Cardozo School of Law, Yeshiva University. She has been a law professor at Universidad del Rosario since 2005, where she teaches Obligations (Obligaciones), Sources of Obligations (Fuentes de las Obligaciones), and Legal Theory, and where she has been a member of the University’s Democracy and Justice Research Group since 2011. She is currently part of the Colombian Observatory of Rural Real Property Restitution and Regulation (Observatorio de Restitución y Regulación de Derechos de Propiedad Agraria), an academic initiative among Colombian universities and scholars to monitor and conduct research about the implementation of land restitution measures approved by the Colombian

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL government in 2011 to redress harms to victims of Colombia’s internal armed conflict.

Lina’s research explores the impact the theoretical body of radical feminist scholarship has had on the identification, understanding and management of harms women face in the Colombian armed conflict and in transitional justice initiatives in Colombia and other post-conflict settings. She is interested in how radical feminism has narrowed the scope for understanding what constitutes gender-based violence in conflict. Her work explores how radical feminism has limited this understanding to sexual violence and related offenses, and how the overarching employment of the sexual domination matrix is used to explain the full range of harm women experience in this setting. In particular, Lina’s project focuses on how the radical feminist narrative has been deployed in the context of women’s land deprivation and massive displacement in the Colombian conflict, and advances alternative explanations to comprehend this phenomenon through the exploration of the intersection between feminism, theories of property and transitional justice.

47 Julia Dehm (Australia) Melbourne Law School

Climate Justice or Carbon Governmentality: Law, Life, Limits and Growth in Crisis

Julia Dehm is a Ph.D. Candidate at Melbourne Law School, and was a 2014 IGLP Workshop Participant. Among others, she works in the areas of environmental law, law and development, and legal theory. She has worked for the Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute and was a member of the Steering Committee of the Activist Legal Rights Website project at the Fitzroy Legal Service. Julia’s most recent publication is “‘REDD faces all around’: Implementing reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation in Indonesia” (Local-Global Journal, 2012). Julia’s research engages with dominant international legal and policy responses to the climate crisis and presents the climate crisis as a critical challenge for the global community. Where collective failure to respond to climate change with effective and equitable policy will accentuate already existing structural inequalities the ecological crisis simultaneously presents an opportunity for rethinking and reimagining global planetary co-habitation. The climate crisis is not simply a scientific or a technical challenge but ultimately a political and ethical social problem in which law and legal responses have the capacity to play a critical role. Julia’s research examines legal responses to the climate crisis through the United Nations Framework on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and other transnational forums in order to ask pertinent questions about the adequacy and equity of these approaches. A fundamental concern of her research is the increased marketization of transnational environmental governance and the centrality of carbon emission trading schemes to international mitigation and adaptation measures and how such responses may foreclose possibilities for ‘environmental justice.’ Her doctoral thesis examines the social implications of a specific carbon offset scheme under the UNFCCC umbrella called Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation (REDD+) in order to investigate contemporary reconfigurations of imperial control by the global North over forested land and biological resources in the global South.

Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) Sciences Po Law School

The Financialization of Global Agricultural Production: How Private Equity Funds, Private Development Funds and Pension Funds are changing the Global Food Chain

Tomaso Ferrando is a Ph.D. Candidate at Sciences Po Law School and has been an Italian barrister since 2011. He was also a 2012 IGLP Workshop Participant. During the last two years he has been a visiting researcher at Universidade de São Paulo (Commerce Law Department) and the University of Cape Town (Public Law Department). Tomaso holds a Master of Science in Comparative Law, Economics and Finance from the International University College of Turin, and has been a visiting researcher at both the law and anthropology departments of UC Berkeley. In 2010 he worked as a pro bono lawyer for Racimos de Ungurahui, a Peruvian NGO specialized in providing legal support to local communities affected by development projects and resources extraction. Since that time he has cooperated with local and international NGOs dealing with resource-related large-scale investments, including Greenpeace and Action Aid. When he wears the academic hat, Tomaso takes advantage of his multidisciplinary background to refuse the rigid separation between legal areas, in particular the public-private distinction that occupies Western legal thought and teaching. Tomaso’s doctoral research project starts from the assumption that any critical analysis of global value chains must reckon with the “increasing role of financial motives, financial markets, financial actors and financial institutions in the operation of the domestic and international economies.” As such, legal scholars should analyze the interplay of neo-liberalism, legal globalization and financialization both in terms of their interconnection and in terms of the use of law as a privileged proxy through which the expansion of finance, the internationalization of capital, and the globalization of markets are achieved. During his time as an IGLP Fellow, Tomaso plans to study the increasing financialization of the food regime as an ongoing process with multiple socio-economic implications. In particular, his research aims to determine the role of law in both favoring and constraining the consolidation and worldwide reach of finance within the food Global Production Network. He will focus on three different manifestations of the financialization of the food regime, each characterized by peculiar legal aspects, and relatively underestimated by the general debate: the financialization of agricultural development; the direct involvement of private funds in the food production system; and the role of institutional investors in the global food regime.

48 IGLP fellows

2014-15 Residential Fellows (Continued)

Maja Savevska (Macedonia) University of Warwick and Université Libre de Bruxelles

A Polanyian Critique of the Political Economy of the European Union

Maja Savevska is a Ph.D. Candidate at the GEM PhD School, Erasmus Mundus Joint Doctorate on Globalization, EU and Multilateralism, where she was awarded a full scholarship by the European Commission. She was also a 2014 IGLP Workshop Participant. Her mobility program includes holding simultaneous registrations at the University of Warwick and the Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB). She received

people iglp at her undergraduate training in political science from Ss. Cyril and Methodius University, Skopje. Maja received a full scholarship from the Open Society Institute to participate in an exchange program at the University of Washington Seattle, where she completed a minor in International Relations. She completed an M.Sc. in Global Governance and Diplomacy at the University of Oxford, where she was awarded the Open Society Institute/Foreign and Commonwealth Office Chevening scholarship. Her experience includes TA work at the Univerité Libre de Bruxelles and Humboldt University and extensive NGO work in Macedonia. Maja’s research interests fall within the remit of critical and heterodox political economy. Her project offers an interdisciplinary intervention that draws on the canonical texts of Karl Polanyi and the burgeoning Polanyian literature. Maja’s main object of inquiry is the morphology of the contradictions that underpin the socio-economic transformation of the European Union. She seeks to juxtapose the disembedding and embedding tendencies of this transformation. First, she is concerned with excavating the self-regulating market logic inscribed in the EU edifice by looking at historical development across three policy fields: competition, financial integration and education, and also by appraising the post-crisis macroeconomic reforms instigated by the Six-Pack, the Two-Pack, the Fiscal Treaty and the Euro-Plus Pact. She argues that the latter represent a missed opportunity for a U-turn in the course of competitive austerity, i.e. a lost kairos. This part of her research aims to problematize the policy solutions implemented in the aftermath of the Great Recession, which are predicated on a crisis narrative that entrenches the monetary orthodoxy. Second, Maja endeavors to examine emerging socio-environmental legislation that, despite its protective invocation, falls short of embedding the economy because it is predicated on deepened commodification. In doing so, she recuperates a critical Polanyian reading that highlights the unresolved ambiguities within these supposedly protective dynamics. ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL 2014-15 Non-Residential Fellows

Zinaida Miller (United States) Tufts University

Zinaida is a doctoral Candidate in International Relations at The Fletcher School, Tufts University. She joins the IGLP again this year, after serving as a Residential Doctoral Fellow from 2012-14. Her work examines the law and policy of post-conflict reconstruction, focusing on the interplay between ideas and institutions in the fields of transitional justice, state- and peacebuilding, human rights, and humanitarian aid. Using Palestine and Rwanda as case studies, her dissertation maps the allocation of power and authority among national and international actors in the aftermath of conflict, the ways in which ideas about how to reconstruct states both influence and are altered by institutionalization on the ground, and the effects of post-conflict discourses on resistance and political struggle. This work builds upon her previous studies of transitional justice, which examined the field’s systematic occlusion of economic inequality

49 and structural violence. Her publications include: “Perils of Parity: Palestine’s Permanent Transition” (Cornell International Law Journal, forthcoming 2014), and “Effects of Invisibility: In Search of the ‘Economic’ in Transitional Justice” (International Journal of Transitional Justice, 2008). She holds a B.A. from Brown University, a Masters in Law and Diplomacy from The Fletcher School, and a J.D. from Harvard Law School.

Arnulf Becker (Chile/United States) Brown University

Arnulf is currently a Visiting Faculty member at the Watson Institute for International Relations at Brown University. Arnulf received his S.J.D. from Harvard Law School. His areas of expertise include public international law, laws of war, the history of international law, comparative law and international legal theory. He has been a lecturer in public international law at King’s College London and a Pembroke Center Post-doctoral Fellow at Brown University. His research traces the global intellectual history of international law focusing on the role non-Western international lawyers have played in the construction of the international legal order between the second half of the nineteenth century and the first half of the twentieth century. His forthcoming book, “Mestizo International Law: A Global Intellectual History, 1842–1933,” will be published by Cambridge University Press.

Outgoing Fellows

The IGLP is also saying farewell to its outgoing Fellows. The IGLP is grateful for their hard work, creativity and dedication in assisting with the planning of the Institute’s academic programs and initiatives, and wishes them the best of luck in their next endeavors! Outgoing Fellows include Heidi Matthews (Canada) and Yun-Ru Chen (Taiwan).

Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard Law School

Heidi served as a 2013-14 Residential Doctoral Fellow, and recently received her S.J.D. from Harvard Law School. During her time at Harvard, Heidi was a Byse Fellow at Harvard Law School, a Fellow at the Film Study Center, the Edmund J. Safra Center for Ethics and the Project on Justice, Welfare and Economics at the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs at Harvard University. She was also a Doctoral Fellow of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada and a John Peters Humphrey Fellow of the Canadian Council on International Law. Heidi holds a B.A. from Mount Allison University and an LL.B.-B.C.L. from McGill University, Faculty of Law. She has worked at the Appeals Chamber of the Special Court for Sierra Leone, and the Office of the Prosecutor at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon. Her doctoral dissertation, “From Aggression to Atrocity: Interrogating the Jus in Bello Turn in International Criminal Law,” critically evaluates the role of the jus ad bellum/jus in bello distinction in the development of international criminal law, and offers a political theory of ICL’s contemporary manifestations. Her post- doctoral research project studies the relationship of the Cold War to international criminal law.

Yun-Ru Chen (Taiwan) State University of New York

After serving as a 2013-14 Residential Post-Doctoral Fellow, Yun-Ru will take up a post-doctoral fellowship at the Baldy Center for Law & Social Policy at the State University of New York in Buffalo. Yun-Ru earned her S.J.D. from Harvard Law School in 2013. Taking colonial Taiwan (1895- 1945), a former territory of imperial China and the first colony of Japan, as the vantage point, her dissertation suggests that ideas about nations and families were far from homogenous in the colonial encounter. She argues that it is not necessary that family law should play a reactionary role in developing nationalism in non-western societies. During her stay at the Baldy Center, Yun-Ru will turn her dissertation into a book manuscript tentatively titled, “Paradoxes of the National Family Law in (Post-) Colonial East Asia: Taiwan as the Nexus.” In addition, she will examine the modernization of Chinese family law and its relation to Chinese nationalism in the long twentieth century.

50 visiting researchers

The IGLP accommodates a small number of Visiting Researchers and Visiting Scholars each academic year, who apply to do research at Harvard Law School for a minimum of three months. In making selections, the Committee at the Institute considers the applicant’s background, field of interest, scholarly achievements, completion of basic legal studies with high academic standing, availability of Harvard Law School faculty for consultation in the proposed research area, and English language proficiency.

Mustapha El Karouni (Belgium) University of Ghent Mustapha El Karouni’s research focuses on Legal Theory and Comparative Law. During his time at the IGLP he focused on the development of a new theory of law which includes a global epistemological approach and the setting of a new postmodern cognitive paradigm. Mr. El Karouni is a member of the Brussels Bar, where he has been a legal advisor to governments in public law. Previously, he was an elected member of the Brussels Parliament. In 2013-2014 he was also a Visiting people iglp at Fellow at Harvard Law School and a Research Fellow at Ghent University in Belgium. His most recent publication is “Legal Science Challenged by Cultural Paradigms: ‘Subjective Objectivity’ in Legal Scholarship.”

Julio V. González García (Spain) Universidad Complutense de Madrid Julio V. González García research focuses on public goods, public procurement, economic globalization, administrative intervention in public services, education, university Law and European Law. He is a Full Professor of Administrative Law at the Department of Administrative Law of the Universidad Complutense de Madrid (UCM), where he also served as General Secretary from 2003-2011. He is the author of numerous law articles and books.

Helen Hartnell (United States) Golden Gate University School of Law Helen Hartnell is Professor of Law (Emerita) at Golden Gate University School of Law, where she teaches European Union Law, International Business Transactions, International Commercial Arbitration, International Trade Regulation, and Transnational Litigation. During her time at the IGLP she continued wok on her ongoing research project on “Legal Elites in Transnational Settings: Building the EU’s Civil Justice Field.” Professor Hartnell is the author of several publications, and writes and lectures extensively on international and comparative law. She has been ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL a visiting professor at several universities including the Free University of Berlin, the University of Cologne in Germany and at ELTE University in Hungary. In 2012 she was a Fulbright Scholar at the University Of Helsinki.

Zachary D. Kaufman (United States) Yale Law School Zachary D. Kaufman is a Visiting Fellow at Yale Law School, the Yale School of Management’s Program on Social Enterprise, and Yale’s Genocide Studies Program as well as a Lecturer in Yale’s Department of Political Science. Previously, Dr. Kaufman practiced law at O’Melveny & Myers LLP. His primary research interests lie at the intersection of criminal law, international law, international relations, international criminal law, international organizations (including international courts and tribunals), human rights law, and transitional justice. As a Visitor at the IGLP he continued work on his most recent book project “From Nuremberg to The Hague: United States Policy on Transitional Justice.” Mr. Kaufman, who received his JD from Yale Law School, has held appointment at the U.S. Departments of State and Justice, the UN International Criminal Tribunals for Rwanda and for the Former Yugoslavia, and the International Criminal Court.

51 Marcelo D. Torelly (Brazil) Brasilia University Law School Marcelo D. Torelly is currently a Ph.D. candidate at Brasilia University Law School. During his time at the IGLP his research centered on how institutional interactions between the Inter-American System of Human Rights and domestic legal regimes are reshaping constitutional law throughout Latin America and creating new global governance standards. Mr. Torelly holds a J.D. from Catholic University-Porto Alegre (PUCRS) and a M.Sc. from Brasilia University Law School. He has served as advisor for the Brazilian Ministry of Justice on Transitional Justice issues, as the head of Brazil’s Historical Memory Department from Amnesty, and as manager of the Transitional Justice Exchange and Development Program which is jointly sponsored by Brazil’s Federal Government and the United Nations.

travel grants

The Institute for Global Law and Policy provides modest travel support to scholars conducting research in areas closely related to the IGLP’s ongoing work who have been invited to present their scholarly work at academic conferences. In 2013- 2014 we awarded the following seven Travel Grants:

Mara Caden (United States) Yale University: Ms. Caden received a grant to travel to Harvard Law School to present her work at Professor Christine Desan’s Economist Workshop on October 28, 2013.

Rajshree Chandra (India) University of Delhi: Ms. Chandra received a grant to travel to present her paper on the “Laws of Nature” at the Melbourne Doctoral Forum on Legal Theory, December 9-10, 2013.

Yun-Ru Chen (Taiwan) Harvard Law School: Ms Chen was awarded a grant to travel to present her paper, “The Making of Market - Family Legal Distinction in Oriental Empire: The Case of Japan-Colonized Taiwan (1895-1945)” at the Center for History and Economics, Magdalene, College, Cambridge, UK on June, 10, 2014.

Deval Desai (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School: Mr. Desai received a grant to support his travel to University of Warwick where he presented a paper in September 2013 at the Workshop on International Law, Natural Resources, and Sustainable Development.

Ching-Fu Lin (Taiwan) Harvard Law School: Mr. Lin was awarded a grant to present his paper, “Toward a Rule-Based Framework for Public-Private Regulatory Cooperation: The Case of Food Safety” at the 8th Annual International Graduate Legal Research Conference which was held in London on April 14 & 15, 2014.

Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard Law School: Ms. Matthews received a grant to travel to London to present her work at the IGLP Critical Approaches to International Criminal Law (CAICL) Workshop at City University, London, on October 18-19, 2013.

Malcolm Rogge (United States) Harvard University: Mr. Rogge was awarded a grant to support his travel to the 2nd Annual UN Forum on Business and Human Rights which was held in Geneva, Switzerland from November 30- December, 5, 2013.

52 travel grants

June 2014 Doha-Santander Collaborative Travel Grant Teams

In June 2014 we were pleased to welcome recipients of Doha-Santander Collaborative Travel Grants. These grants were made available to groups of our IGLP Workshop alumni who applied to come to the IGLP in June to deepen the discussions they began together at the IGLP Workshop in the hope that it may lead to a Collaborative Research Project. The 2014 Doha-Santander Collaborative Travel Grants were made by possible with the generous support of Santander Universities. We welcomed the following Doha-Santander Collaborative Travel Grant Teams to join us at Harvard in June 2014:

Revolution, Constitutionalism and International Law Team leader: Vidya Kumar (Canada) University of Birmingham Law School. Team members: Philip Kaisary

people iglp at (United Kingdom) University of Warwick School of Law; and Sanale Sibanda (South Africa) University of Witwatersrand Law School. Commentator: Nathaniel Berman (United States) Brown University.

This project aims to explore the relationships among revolution, constitutionalism and international law, in both historical and contemporary contexts. By focusing on revolutions outside the global North, the team hopes to contribute to an alternative, critical and heterodox genealogy of constitutionalism.

Law’s Hegemony Team Leader: Honor Brabazon (Canada), University of Oxford. Team Members: Gleider Hernandez (Canada) University of Durham Law School; Tor Krever (Canada) London School of Economics and Political Science; and Mai Taha (Egypt) University of Toronto.

This group aims to explore the authority law commands over alternative systems through which to view, judge, and order our world. The group considered the extent to which law can be understood as hegemonic; that is, how its supremacy over other systems of authority, morality, and social organization is considered to be common sense, beneficial, and universal and to what ends law has obtained such significance.

(Dis)solving Informal Labor Vulnerability through Labor Laws: Examining the Failures, Frames & Assumptions Team Leader: Yugank Goyal (India) University of Hamburg. Team Members: Jorge Esquirol (United States) ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Florida International University College of Law; Vivek Kanwar (United States) Jindal Global Law School; Kerry Rittich (Canada) University of Toronto; and Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Georgetown Law.

This group is brainstorming together about the difficulty labor law traditions have had responding to increasing informality and labor vulnerability in developing nations, asking whether these difficulties are symptomatic of problems in labor law architecture or are simply a problem of their implementation.

Multinational Behavior in Africa: Human Rights Perspectives Team Leader: Qingxiu Bu (People’s Republic of China) University of Sussex. Team Members: Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Cornell Law School; and Kibrom Teweldebirhan (Eritrea) Harvard Law School.

This team is exploring the tensions in the human rights practices of Africa promoted and followed by multinational companies, the international human rights community, and China’s approach to ensuring human rights in Africa. The group will explore whether a comprehensive framework of hard law and soft law initiatives, along with other incentives, may be more promising than any of these in isolation.

53 Varieties of State Capitalism and International Economic Order: China, Russia, Brazil and Beyond

Team Leader: Ming Du (People’s Republic of China) Lancaster University School of Law. Team Members: Swethaa Ballakrishnen (India) Stanford University; Y-Vonne Hutchison (United States) La Isla Foundation; Yaraslau Kryvoi (Belarus) London School of Economics and Political Science; and Nicolás Perrone (Italy) London School of Economics and Political Science.

This research team hopes to shed fresh light on how to better integrate state capitalist countries, such as China, Russia and Brazil into the rule-based global economic system.

Reviving Comparative Law as a Heterodox Discipline Team Leader: Amaya Alvez Marin (Chile) Universidad de Concepción Department of History and Philosophy of Law. Team Members: Tatsuhiko Inatani (Japan) Kyoto University; and Marta Infantino (Italy) University of Trieste.

The group is exploring the critical potential of the comparative law field in the 21st century. Praised at the beginning of the 20th century for its potential to explore the globe’s legal diversity, the sense now is that comparative law struggles to maintain that role in a much more interconnected and globalized world. Group members are exploring the ways globalization has made comparative work and an understanding of legal pluralism more important.

Critical Global Economic Governance Team Leaders: Camila Villard Duran (Brazil) University of São Paulo; Gaye Gungor (Turkey) Gediz University. Team members: Miguel Adame Martinez (Spain) Universidad de Sevilla; Siobhan Airey (Ireland) University of Ottawa; Rifat Azam (Israel) Radzyner School of Law; Rui Guo (People’s Republic of China) Harvard Law School; Y-Vonne Hutchison (United States) La Isla Foundation; Enrique Prieto Rios (Colombia) Birkbeck School of Law, University of London; Seyed Mohamad Hassan Razavi (Iran) McGill University; and Maja Savevska (Macedonia), Université Libre de Bruxelles and University of Warwick.

This group aims to develop new thinking about global macroeconomic coordination and to explore governance models that might produce macroeconomic reforms that benefit citizens in a time of global economic transition. Group members aim to explore the emerging economic order in ways that may promote the human face of capital and improve understanding of the root causes of the on-going crisis and its spillover effects throughout the developing world.

Operation CIA: Critical Interdisciplinary Approaches Team Members: Swethaa Ballakrishnen (India) Stanford University; and Y-Vonne Hutchison (United States) La Isla Foundation.

This group aims to explore interdisciplinary methods and encourage innovative forms of scholarly expression and how they might practically equip themselves so that their research will speak to their disciplines as well as beyond them.

History, Anthropology, and the Archive in International Law Team Leader: Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Melbourne University Law School. Team Members: Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Melbourne Law School; Luis Eslava (Australia) Melbourne University Law School; Genevieve Painter (Ireland) University of California, Berkeley Law; and Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) University of Technology Sydney.

This group is developing a conversation about historical and anthropological methods, the archive, and the temporality of international law. While this relationship is already being analyzed in the domestic or national context, this groups aims to transpose this conversation to the international plane.

54 event participants

IGLP: The Workshop (Doha, Qatar) January 3-11, 2014

Workshop Faculty Ratna Kapur (India) Workshop Docents Jindal Global Law School Ghada Ahmed (United States) Noha Aboueldahab (Egypt) Duke University Gudrun Krämer (Germany) Durham University Free University of Berlin Talal Abdulla Al Emadi (Qatar) Alejandra Azuero-Quijano (Colombia) Qatar University College of Law David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School Harvard Law School Kamran Ali (United States) Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) University of Texas-Austin Fritz Kratochwil (Germany) The City Law School, City University, Central European University London Elizabeth Bartholet (United States)

people iglp at Harvard Law School Andrew Lang (United Kingdom) Sadeq Bigdeli (Iran) London School of Economics and University of Waikato School of Law Nathaniel Berman (United States) Political Science Brown University Qingxiu Bu (People’s Republic of Horatia Muir Watt (France) China) Adelle Blackett (Canada) Sciences Po Law School University of Sussex Law School McGill University Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Cyra Choudhury (United States) Dan Brinks (United States) The Gallatin School, New York Florida International University University of Texas School of Law University College of Law

Stuart Brotman (United States) Scott Newton (United States) Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Harvard Law School SOAS, University of London Melbourne Law School

Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) John Ohnesorge (United States) Paul Clark (United Kingdom) SOAS, University of London University of Wisconsin Law School Garden Court Chambers

Dan Danielsen (United States) Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Luis Eslava (Australia) Northeastern University School of Law Melbourne Law School Melbourne Law School

Dennis Davis (South Africa) Jeremy Perelman (France) Yugank Goyal (India) High Court of Cape Town, South Africa Sciences Po Law School University of Hamburg

Karen Engle (United States) Intisar Rabb (United States) John Haskell (United States) University of Texas School of Law Harvard Law School Mississippi College School of Law ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Jorge Esquirol (United States) Kerry Rittich (Canada) Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Florida International University University of Toronto Herzegovina) College of Law SOAS, University of London Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Günter Frankenberg (Germany) Georgetown Law Ben Hurlbut (United States) The Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Arizona State University, School of Life Main Robert Wai (Canada) Sciences Osgoode Hall Law School Gary Gereffi (United States) Onur Ince (Turkey) Duke University Lucie White (United States) Koç University Harvard Law School Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Vivek Kanwar (United States) Harvard Kennedy School Mikhail Xifaras (France) Jindal Global Law School Sciences Po Law School Baber Johansen (United States) Tor Krever (Canada) Harvard Divinity School London School of Economics and Political Science

55 Vidya Kumar (Canada) Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) Olabisi Akinkugbe (Nigeria) University of Birmingham University of Kent Law School University of Ottawa

Richard Lehun (Canada) Karen Rhone (United States) Jerusa Ali (Canada) McGill University University of Chicago Carleton University

Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Tawfique Al-Mubarak (Malaysia) University of Memphis, School of Law Jahangrinagar University International Institute of Advanced Islamic Studies Heidi Matthews (Canada) Rene Urueña (Colombia) Harvard Law School Universidad de Los Andes Amaya Alvez Marin (Chile) Osgoode Hall Law School Usha Natarajan (Australia) The American University in Cairo Workshop Participants Mekonnen Ayano (Ethiopia) Harvard Law School Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia and Italy) Mohamed Abdelaal (Egypt) Carleton University Indiana University Robert H. McKinney Rifat Azam (Israel) School of Law Radzyner School of Law Muhammad Osama Siddique (Pakistan) Lahore University of Management Sciences Paola Acosta (Colombia) Swethaa Ballakrishnen (United States) Universidad Externado de Colombia Stanford University Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Melbourne Law School Miguel Ángel Adame Martínez (Spain) Diane Bernard (Belgium) Universidad de Sevilla Université Saint-Louis (Brussels) Vesco Paskalev (Bulgaria) European University Institute Dawood Ahmed (United Kingdom) Laura Betancur (Colombia) University of Chicago Universidad de Los Andes Nicolás Perrone (Argentina and Italy) Universidad Externado de Colombia Siobhan Airey (Ireland) Honor Brabazon (Canada) University of Ottawa, Faculty of Law University of Oxford Jothie Rajah (Singapore) American Bar Foundation Ramzan Alnoaimi (Bahrain) Pascale Cornut St-Pierre (Canada) University of Bahrain Sciences Po Law School

56 event participants

(Continued) IGLP: The Workshop (Doha, Qatar) January 3-11, 2014

Participants (Continued) Gaye Gungor (Turkey) Richa Kumar (India) Gediz University University of Kent Law School Melissa Crouch (Australia) National University of Singapore Susan Harris Rimmer (Australia) Maryam Khan (United States) Australian National University Lahore University of Management Julia Dehm (Australia) Sciences Melbourne Law School Adil Hasan Khan (India) Graduate Institute of International and Jennifer Langlais (Canada) Debolina Dutta (India) Development Studies Université de Montréal Melbourne Law School Seyed Mohamad Hassan Razavi (Iran) Darryl Li (United States) Ahmed Eldakak (Egypt) McGill University Faculty of Law Columbia University

people iglp at Alexandria University Gleider Hernandez (Canada) Roopanand Mahadew (Mauritius) Yassin El Shazly (Egypt) University of Durham Law School University of Mauritius Qatar University College of Law Tomás Hoffman (Hungary) Bashar Malkawi (Jordan) Cynthia Farid (Bangladesh) Corvinus University of Budapest University of Sharjah, College of Law University of Wisconsin Law School Heather Hughes (United States) Itamar Mann (United States) George Forji Amin (Finland) American University, Washington Georgetown Law University of Helsinki College of Law Mark Massoud (United States) Bianca Gardella Tedeschi (Italy) John Hursh (United States) University of California, Santa Cruz Università del Primeonte Orientale McGill University, Centre for Human Rights and Legal Pluralism Hélène Mayrand (Canada) Afroditi Giovanopoulou (Greece) University of Sherbrooke Harvard Law School Y-Vonne Hutchinson (United States) La Isla Foundation Lena-Maria Möller (Germany) Ahmad Ghouri (Pakistan) Max Planck Institute for Comparative University of Sussex Law School Tatsuhiko Inatani (Japan) and International Private Law Kyoto University Karim Ginena (Canada and Egypt) Jacqueline Mowbray (Australia) Hamad Bin Khalifa University Marta Infantino (Italy) University of Sydney University of Trieste Toby Goldbach (United States) Roseline Njogu (Kenya) Cornell Law School Chiha Islam (Egypt) Riara University Law School Qatar University College of Law ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Sinja Graf (Germany) Ticiana Nogueira da Cruz Lima (Brazil) Cornell University Bogdan Ivanel (Romania) University of São Paulo Sciences Po Law School Jean Grosdidier (France) Yahaya Nurfadzilah (United States) Sciences Po Law School Aleksandra Ivlieva (Russia) Washington University in St. Louis Moscow State University Lukasz Gruszczynski (Poland) Gearóid Ó Cuinn (Ireland) Institute of Law Studies, Polish Razak Jaha (Ghana) Lancaster University School of Law Academy of Sciences University of Cape Coast Genevieve Painter (Ireland) Xavier Guignard (France) Philip Kaisary (United Kingdom) University of California-Berkeley, Paris Pantheon Sorbonne University University of Warwick School of Law School of Law

Marie Guimezanes (France) Ioannis Kalpouzos (Greece) James Parker (United Kingdom) Toulouse 1 Capitole University The City Law School, City University Melbourne Law School London Rui Guo (People’s Republic of China) Enrique Prieto Rios (Colombia) Renmin University of China Birkbeck, University of London

57 Mikko Rajavuori (Finland) Azadehsadat Taheri (Iran) University of Turku University of Semnan

Michael Riegner (Germany) Salma Taman (Egypt) New York University School of Law Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law Jamie Rowen (United States) University of Toronto Rustamjon Urinboyev (Uzbekistan) Lund University, Sayres Rudy (United States) Bryn Mawr College Areli Valencia Vargas (Peru) University of Ottawa Hengameh Saberi (Iran) Osgoode Hall Law School Daniel Vargas (Brazil) Harvard Law School Rafael Sakr (Brazil) Independent Researcher Latika Vashist (India) Jindal Global Law School Jaakko Salminen (Finland) University of Turku Tara Van Ho (United States) University of Essex, School of Law Maja Savevska (Macedonia) Universite Libre de Bruxelles Nneamaka Vanni (Nigeria) University of Warwick School of Law Oishik Sircar (India) Melbourne Law School Grigory Vaypan (Russia) Moscow State University Kalana Senaratne (Sri Lanka) University of Hong Kong Mika Viljanen (Finland) University of Turku Shanthi Senthe (Canada) Osgoode Hall Law School Camila Villard Duran (Brazil) University of São Paulo Sanele Sibanda (South Africa) University of Witwatersrand Natalia Volosin (Argentina) Yale Law School Ximena Sierra (Colombia) Rosario University Yan Xu (Hong Kong) The Chinese University of Hong Kong Ermin Sinanovic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) United States Naval Academy Mimi Zou (Australia) Oxford University Sahib Singh (United Kingdom) University of Cambridge

event participants

June 2014 IGLP Conference: Corporate Power in Global Society: Explication, Critique, Engagement, and Resistance (Harvard Law School), June 2-3, 2014

Conference Conveners Moral Technologies of Market Corporate Power and Corporate Construction: The Politics of Subjectivity Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) Multinational Firm Entry into Indian The City Law School, City University Retail Food Supply Chains Panelists: London Heather Hughes (United States) Jason Jackson (The Bahamas) American University, Washington Dan Danielsen (United States) Wharton School, University of College of Law Northeastern University School of Law Pennsylvania Corporate Subjectivity, Corporate Moral Technologies of Market Social Responsibility and the Equator Dennis Davis (South Africa) Construction: The Politics of Principles in Project Finance High Court of Cape Town Multinational Firm Entry into Indian people iglp at Retail Food Supply Chains Outi Korhonen (Finland) Andre Spicer (New Zealand) University of Turku Cass Business School, City University Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Standardising Industries, of London Melbourne University Law School Normalising Subjectivities: Jurisdictional Rivalries between Corporations in European Order Imagining Corporate Power Company and State in the Early Modern Period Jongchul Kim (South Korea) Panelists: Columbia Law School Joshua Barkan (United States) Richa Kumar (India) Playing with Two Legal Categories, University of Georgia Brussels School of International Property and Contract: An Law, Genealogy, and Literature in Studies, University of Kent Explanation of the Rise of Financial the Political Analysis of Corporate The Security Bazaar: Mapping Corporate Power from a Legal Power Actors, Markets and Technologies in Perspective Migration and Border Control Jennifer Bair (United States) Subverting or Harnessing University of Colorado Corporate Power, State and Corporate Power Mapping Corporate Power: GVCs, Capital Governance and the New Corporate Panelists: Imaginary Panelists: Chris Jochnick (United States) Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) Oxfam America Gwen Gordon (United States) Sciences Po Law School Addressing and Harnessing Wharton School, University of When Westphalia Encounters Corporate Power for Pro-Poor Ends Pennsylvania Transnationality: Sovereignty, Narrative, Image, and the Making of Territory and the Creation of the Meetali Jain (United States) the Corporate Self Foreigner in Kiobel and Co. University of Witwatersrand Law School ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Elana Shever (United States) Sandy Hager (Canada) Exploring Home Grown Regional Colgate University London School of Economics and and Local Strategies to Resists The Feminized Face of Oil: Shifting Political Science Corporate Power in Africa Corporate Image and Corporate Public Debt as Corporate Power: Power Mapping the New Aristocracy of Michelle Le Roux (South Africa) Finance University of Witwatersrand Law Corporate Power & the Other School Dean Snyder (United States) Polanyi’s Double Move: Lessons Panelists: Syracuse University from Marikana Swethaa Ballakrishnen (India) Global Value Chains and the Stanford University Corporate Power of Commercial Power & Privilege: The (Possible) Capital: A Marxian Analysis Advantage of New Organizations in the Global World Megan Bowman (Australia) University of New South Wales Amy Cohen (United States) Corporate Regulatory Power and Ohio State University Moritz College Green Governance: An Illustrative of Law Case

59 Corporate Power vs. State Power Jennifer Bair (United States) Amy Cohen (United States) University of Colorado Ohio State University Moritz College of Law Panelists: Neil Robinson (United Kingdom) Swethaa Ballakrishnen (United States) Alessia Contu (Italy) University of Limerick Stanford University University of Massachusetts-Boston State Capture and Business Capture: Political and Corporate Power under Neo- Philip Balsiger (Switzerland) Dan Danielsen (United States) Patrimonialism European University Institute Northeastern University School of Law

Nathanael Ali (Ethiopia) Joshua Barkan (United States) Dennis Davis (South Africa) Erasmus University Law School University of Georgia High Court of Cape Town, South Africa United in Vigilance: Corporation & State in Counterterrorism Jason Beckett (United Kingdom) Katherine Fallah (Australia and Lebanon) The American University in Cairo University of Technology, Sydney Liam Campling (United Kingdom) Queen Mary University of London, School Kate Benak (United States) Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) of Business and Management The Evergreen State College Sciences Po Law School Beyond Fisheries ‘Management’? Competition, Market Power and Laura Betancur (Colombia) Mike Godbe (United States) Sustainable Resource Extraction Universidad de Los Andes Northeastern University School of Law

Elizabeth Havice (United States) Megan Bowman (Australia) Gwen Gordon (United States) University of North Carolina University of New South Wales Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania Beyond Fisheries ‘Management’? Competition, Market Power and Camille Brou (Côte d’Ivoire) Paul Gutierrez (United States) Sustainable Resource Extraction Urban Agriculture International Program Brown University

Katherine Fallah (Australia and Lebanon) Priscilla Browne (Ghana) Sandy Hager (Canada) University of Technology, Sydney University of Birmingham London School of Economics and Political Making War and Making Law: The Science Corporation in the Global Regulation of Qingxiu Bu (United Kingdom) Military Violence University of Sussex Elizabeth Havice (United States) University of North Carolina Participants Rafael Burgos-Mirabal (United States) University of Massachusetts-Amherst Hedayat Heikal (Egypt) Pieter Van Malleghem (Belgium) Harvard Law School Harvard Law School Liam Campling (United Kingdom) Queen Mary University of London Hozami Helwani (Saudi Arabia) Lukman Jayeola Agunbiade (Nigeria) University of Massachusetts-Boston Royal-Equity Chambers Marc Camprubi Artal (Spain) University of Barcelona Heather Hughes (United States) Nathanael Ali (Ethiopia) American University, Washington College Erasmus University Law School Rebecca Chan (United States) of Law The Tobin Project Rifat Azam (Israel) Philip Ireland (United Kingdom) Interdisciplinary Center Anna Chung (South Korea) University of Bristol Law School Université Libre de Bruxelles Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University David Ciepley (United States) London University of Denver

60 event participants

(Continued) June 2014 IGLP Conference: Corporate Power in Global Society: Explication, Critique, Engagement, and Resistance (Harvard Law School), June 2-3, 2014

Participants (Continued) Alexandra Manea (Romania) Titu Maiorescu University of Bucharest Maja Savevska (Macedonia) University of Warwick/Université Libre Jason Jackson (United States) Wharton School, University of PA Ayako Matsuura (Japan) de Bruxelles Yale (United States) Meetali Jain (United States) Elana Shever University of Witwatersrand Law Dirk Matten (Germany) Colgate University School York University, Schulich School of Business Ximena Sierra-Camargo (Colombia) Universidad del Rosario Chris Jochnick (United States) (Egypt) people iglp at Oxfam America Farida Mortada Harvard Law School Dean Snyder (United States) Syracuse University Fleur Johns (Australia) University of New South Wales, Claire Mumme (Canada) University of Windsor Andre Spicer (New Zealand) Cass Business School, City University Jinyoung Kang (South Korea) University of Massachusetts-Boston Gearóid Ó Cuinn (Ireland) of London Lancaster University Law School (India) Jongchul Kim (South Korea) Santosh Stephen Columbia Law School Guillermo Otalora Lozano (Colombia) Massachusetts Institute of Technology Harvard Law School (Colombia) Brenda Kombo (United States) Federico Suárez Northeastern University School of Law Miguel Padro (United States) Universidad Externado de Colombia The Aspen Institute (Netherlands) Outi Korhonen (Finland) Jeroen Veldman University of Turku Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Cardiff Business School Melbourne Law School (Brazil) Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Camila Villard Duran Harvard Law School Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) University of São Paulo University of Kent Law School (People’s Republic of China) Richa Kumar (India), University of Kent Ying Xia Michael Riegner (Germany) Harvard Law School Michelle Le Roux (South Africa) NYU Law School University of Witwatersrand Law School Neil Robinson (United Kingdom) University of Limerick ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL David Levy (United States) University of Massachusetts Malcolm Rogge (Canada) Harvard Law School

61 event participants

Bandung and the Global South (Harvard Law School), June 2, 2014

Participants Vivek Kanwar (United States) Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Jindal Global Law School Melbourne Law School Antony Anghie (United States) S.J. Quinney College of Law, University of Vidya Kumar (Canada) Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) Utah University of Birmingham University of Technology Sydney

Rajagopal Balakrishnan (India) Tayyab Mahmud (Pakistan) Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) Massachusetts Institute of Technology Seattle University School of Law University of Glasgow

Arnulf Becker (Chile) Boris Mamlyuk (United States) John Reynolds (Ireland) Brown University University of Memphis, School of Law National University of Ireland, Galway

Cyra Choudhury (United States) Usha Natarajan (Australia) Hani Sayed (Syria) Florida International University College of The American University in Cairo The American University in Cairo Law Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) The Gallatin School, New York University Jahangrinagar University SOAS, University of London Liliana Obregón Tarazona (Colombia) Mai Taha (Egypt) Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Universidad de los Andes University of Toronto Cornell Law School Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia and Italy) Fabia Veçoso (Brazil) Luis Eslava (Australia) Carleton University Faculdade de Direito do Sul de Minas Melbourne Law School Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Melbourne Law School

62 event participants

June 2014 IGLP Conference: Heterodox Approaches to Islamic Law and Policy (Harvard Law School), June 2-3, 2014

Conference Conveners Critical Inquiries: Muslim Feminist Karim Ginena (Canada and Egypt) Scholarship and the Practice of Hamad Bin Khalifa University Cyra Akila Choudhury (United States) Muslim Family Law in the United Contemporary Approaches to Florida International University Kingdom Governing the Islamic Banking College of Law Industry Dipika Jain (India) Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Jindal Global Law School Islamic Family Law II Herzegovina) Inheritance Rights of the Hijras in SOAS, University of London the Indian Colonial Courts: The Panelists: Pluralistic Dual Hindu-Islamic Anicée Van England (United Kingdom) Heterodoxy and Critique in Religious Identity of Hijras and the SOAS, University of London

people iglp at Islamic Legal Thought Colonial, Post-Colonial and Modern Meeting the Challenge of Developing Understandings a Gender-Inclusive Methodology in Panelists Islamic Law Robert Gleave (United Kingdom) Lena-Marie Möller (Germany) University of Exeter Max Planck Institute for Comparative Tawfique Al-Mubarak(Malaysia) Legal Norms and Normal Laws: Why and International Private Law International Institute of Advanced Studying ‘Heterodox’ Islamic Law The Use and Misuse of a Islamic Studies Matters Comparative Approach to Family Surrogacy in Islamic Law: A Law Reform Maqasidic Analysis Kecia Ali (United States) Boston University Politics of Law and Justice John Hursh (United States) Read it Slant: Feminist Critical McGill University Perspectives on Islamic Law and Panelists: Casting a Long Shadow: How the Legal Theory Mohamed Badar (Egypt and United Politics of Independence Shape Kingdom) Women’s Rights in Contemporary Haider Ala Hamoudi (United States) Northumbria Law School Tunisia and Morocco University of Pittsburgh Law School The International Criminal Court and Islamic Legal Realism the Nigerian Crisis: An Inquiry into Islamic Law, Arts and the Boko Haram Revolution Islamic Legal History and Jurisprudence George Forji Amin (Finland) Moderators: University of Helsinki Chantal Thomas (United States) Panelists: The Gulf States, Kafala System and Cornell University Law School Nahed Samour (Germany) the Crisis of International Law Humboldt University Amr Shalakany (Egypt) A Critique of Adjudication: Formative Islamic Finance and Political American University in Cairo ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Moments in Islamic Legal History Economy Panelists: Gianluca Parolin (Italy) Panelists Huda Lutfi (Egypt) The American University in Cairo Karen Rhone (United States) Contemporary Artist, Cairo) Department of Law University of Chicago, A Tale of Personhoods: “Ulamā and Law and the Reconstitution of Sherief Gaber (Egypt) Fuqahā” Economic Justice Mosireen Media Collective, Cairo

Samy Ayoub (Egypt) Jonathan Ercanbrack (United States) Marc Michael (United Arab Emirates) University of Arizona SOAS, University of London New York University Legal Authority and State Power: The Transformation of Islamic Law in Critical Notes on Early Modern Ḥanaf Global Financial Markets Ania Zremski (Egypt) Jurisprudence Townhouse Gallery, Cairo Bashar Malkawi (Jordan) Islamic Family Law I University of Sharjah, College of Law Natalie Bell (United States) Critical Issues of Governance in New Museum, New York City Panelists: Islamic Financial Institutions: A Samia Bano (United Kingdom) Reformed Framework SOAS, University of London

63 Participants Hedayat Heikal (Egypt) Anicée Van Engeland (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School SOAS, University of London Haider Ala Hamoudi (United States) University of Pittsburgh Hozami Helwani (Saudi Arabia) Miyase Yavuz (Turkey) University of Massachusetts-Boston SOAS, University of London Kecia Ali (United States) Boston University Clinton Hermes (United States) Maliheh Zare (Iran) Qatar Foundation NYU Law School Tawfique Al-Mubarak (Malaysia) International Institute of Advanced Islamic John Hursh (United States) Studies McGill University

Majed Alsulais (Saudi Arabia) Huda Lutfi (Egypt) Taif University, KSA The American University in Cairo

Samy Ayoub (Egypt) Tayyab Mahmud (Pakistan) University of Arizona Seattle University

Mohamed Badar (Egypt / United Kingdom) Bashar Malkawi (Jordan) Northumbria Law School University of Sharjah, College of Law

Samia Bano (United Kingdom) Marc Michael (Abu Dhabi) SOAS, University of London NYU Law School

Natalie Ann Bell (United States) Lena-Maria Möller (Germany) New Museum Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law Laura Betancur (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes Farida Mortada (Egypt) Harvard Law School Marc Camprubi Artal (Spain) University of Barcelona Gianluca Paolo Parolin (Japan) The American University in Cairo Cyra Choudhury (United States) Florida International University College of Andrea Quinn (United States) Law Berkeley School of Law

Mustapha El Karouni (Belgium) Rayees Ra mon (India) Ghent Univeristy; Ecole des Hautes Etudes Post Graduate Fellow en Sciences Sociales Rachel Rebouché (United States) Halim El-Deeb (Egypt) Temple University Police Academy in Egypt Karen Rhone (United States) Jonathan Ercanbrack (United States) University of Chicago SOAS, University of London Michael Riegner (Germany) George Forji Amin (Finland) NYU Law School University of Helsinki Nahed Samour (Germany) Sherief Gaber (Egypt) Humboldt University Mosireen Media Collective, Cairo Amr Shalakany (Egypt) Karim Ginena (Canada / Egypt) The American University in Cairo HBKU / Darden School of Business Leopold Specht (Austria) Robert Gleave (United Kingdom) Specht Böhm University of Exeter Ania Szremski (Egypt) Fatumetul Zehra Guldas (United States) Townhouse Gallery for Contemporary Art Boston University Chantal Thomas (United States) Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Cornell Law School SOAS, University of London

64 event participants

June 2014 IGLP Conference: Global Legal Thought: The Legacies of Heterodoxy (Harvard Law School), June 3, 2014 Conference Conveners Theme B: Gender and Legal Thought Helena Alviar (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes David Kennedy (United States) Discussants: Harvard Law School Janet Halley (United States) Antony Anghie (United States) Harvard Law School S.J. Quinney College of Law Mikhail Xifaras (France) Sciences Po Law School Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Rajagopal Balakrishnan (India) The Gallatin School, New York Massachusetts Institute of Technology Roundtable I: Global Patterns University of Heterodoxy: One Narrative or Paulo Barrozo (United States, Brazil) Many? Roundtable III: Methods Boston College Law School

people iglp at of Critique as Engines of Conveners: Heterodoxy Arnulf Becker (Chile) David Kennedy (United States) Brown University Harvard Law School Convener: Mikhail Xifaras (France) Jason Beckett (United Kingdom) Mikhail Xifaras (France) Sciences Po Law School The American University in Cairo Sciences Po Law School Theme A: Critical “Tools” and the Kate Benak (United States) Theme A: The Globalization of Legal Practice of Critique The Evergreen State College Thought Discussants: Nathaniel Berman (United States) Discussants: Pierre Schlag (United States) Brown University Arnulf Becker (Chile) University of Colorado Law School Brown University Laura Betancur (Colombia) Martti Koskenneimi (Finland) Universidad de Los Andes Daniela Caruso (United States) University of Helsinki Boston University School of Law Fabiana Bettini (Italy) Theme B: Heterdoxy in Legal Thought: Università di Macerata Theme B: History and Periodization The Use of Economics, Cost Benefit Analysis and Various “Pragmatisms” Sadeq Bigdeli (Iran) Discussants: University of Waikato School of Law Hani Sayed (Syria) Discussants: The American University in Cairo Dina Waked (Egypt) Yishai Blank (Israel) Sciences Po Law School Tel Aviv University Antony Anghie (United States) University of Utah Dan Danielsen (United States) Karima Bouaifel (Algeria) ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Northeastern University School of Law Sonatrach Roundtable II: The Politics of Legal Thought Participants Rafael Burgos-Mirabal (United States) University of Massachusetts-Amherst Convener: María Luisa Gómez Moreno (Spain) Duncan Kennedy (United States) Universidad de Málaga Marc Camprubi Artal (Spain) Harvard Law School University of Barcelona Paola Acosta (Colombia) Theme A: Heterodoxy, the Critical and Universidad Externado de Colombia Daniela Caruso (United States) the Left Boston University School of Law Libby Adler (United States) Discussants: Northeastern University School of Law Yun-Ru Chen (Taiwan) Horatia Muir Watt (France) Harvard Law School Sciences Po Law School Aziza Ahmed (United States) Northeastern University School of Law Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Akbar Rusalov (Uzbekistan) Melbourne Law School University of Glasgow Amaya Alvez Marin (Chile) Universidad de Concepcion

65 Amy Cohen (United States) David Kennedy (United States) Gearóid Ó Cuinn (Ireland) Ohio State University Moritz College of Law Harvard Law School Lancaster University Law School

Matt Craven (United Kingdom) Duncan Kennedy (United States) Liliana Obregón Tarazona (Colombia) SOAS, University of London Harvard Law School Universidad de los Andes

Dan Danielsen (United States) Martti Koskenniemi (Finland) Anne Orford (Australia) Northeastern University School of Law University of Helsinki Melbourne Law School

Christine Desan (United States) Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Guillermo Otalora Lozano (Colombia) Harvard Law School Harvard Law School Harvard Law School

Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) Regina Larrea (Mexico) Lisa Lucile Owens (United States) University of Colorado Law School Harvard Law School Columbia University

Anna di Robilant (Italy) Mitch Lasser (United States) Genevieve Painter (United States / Ireland) Boston University School of Law Cornell Law School University of California-Berkeley

Jorge Esquirol (United States) Richard Lehun (Canada) Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Florida International University College of McGill University Melbourne Law School Law Carl Lisberger (United States) James Parker (United Kingdom /Australia) Jorge Fabra (Colombia) Harvard Law School Melbourne Law School McMaster University (Canada) Tayyab Mahmud (Pakistan) Nicolás Perrone (Argentina) George Forji Amin (Cameroon / Finland) Seattle University Universidad Externado de Colombia University of Helsinki Itamar Mann (United States) Ileana Porras (United States) Motoaki Funakoshi (Japan) Georgetown Law University of Miami School of Law Kyoto University Maria Rosaria Marella (Italy) Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) Jorge Gonzalez-Jacome (Colombia) University of Perugia University of Glasgow Universidad Javeriana – Colombia Giovanni Marini (Italy) Rachel Rebouché (United States) Gaye Gungor (Turkey) University of Perugia Temple University Beasley School of Law Gediz University Ayako Matsuura (Japan) Gonçalo Almeida Ribeiro (Portugal) Janet Halley (United States) Yale Católica Global School of Law Harvard Law School Heidi Matthews (Canada) Michael Riegner (Germany) Mohammad Hamdy (Egypt) Harvard Law School New York University School of Law Harvard Law School Zinaida Miller (United States) Kerry Rittich (Canada) Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina) The Fletcher School, Tufts University University of Toronto SOAS, University of London Farida Mortada (Egypt) Brishen Rogers (United States) Hedayat Heikal (Egypt) Harvard Law School Temple University Beasley School of Law Harvard Law School Horatia Muir Watt (France) Malcolm Rogge (Canada) Gleider Hernandez (Canada) Sciences Po Law School Harvard Law School Durham University Claire Mumme (Canada) Maria Rosaria Marella (Italy) Tatsuhiko Inatani (Japan) University of Windsor University of Perugia Kyoto University El Karouni Mustapha (Belgium) Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Marta Infantino (Italy) Ghent Univeristy; Ecole des Hautes Etudes Georgetown Law University of Trieste en Sciences Sociales Hani Sayed (Syria) Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Vasuki Nesiah (United States) The American University in Cairo Harvard Kennedy School The Gallatin School, New York University Pierre Schlag (United States) Fleur Johns (Australia) Fernanda Nicola (Italy) University of Colorado Law School University of New South Wales American University Washington

66 event participants

(Continued) June 2014 IGLP Conference: Global Legal Thought: The Legacies of Heterodoxy (Harvard Law School), June 3, 2014

Participants (Continued) Nimer Sultany (Palestinian) Robert Wai (Canada) SOAS, University of London Osgoode Hall Law School Amr Shalakany (Egypt) The American University in Cairo Mai Taha (Egypt) Dina Waked (Egypt) University of Toronto Sciences Po Law School Hila Shamir (Israel) Faculty of Law, Tel Aviv University Chantal Thomas (United States) Lucie White (United States) Cornell Law School Harvard Law School Carolina Silva-Portero (Ecuador) Harvard Law School Chris Tomlins (United States) Mikhail Xifaras (France) University of California Irvine Sciences Po Law School people iglp at Leopold Specht (Austria) Specht Böhm Philomila Tsoukala (Greece) Georgetown Law Matthew Spurlock (United States) Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Pieter Van Malleghem (Belgium) Harvard Law School Jeannie Suk (United States) Harvard Law School Camila Villard Duran (Brazil) University of São Paulo ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL

67 event participants

IGLP Pro-Seminar: The Role of Law in Structures of Global Production (Harvard Law School), June 4-6, 2014

Organizers Liam Campling (United Kingdom) Jason Jackson (United States) Queen Mary University of London Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University Amy Cohen (United States) Nisha Mistry (United States) London Ohio State University Moritz College of Law Brookings Institution

Dan Danielsen (United States) Dan Danielsen (United States) Claire Mumme (Canada) Northeastern University School of Law Northeastern University School of Law University of Windsor

Dennis Davis (South Africa) Dennis Davis (South Africa) Vesco Paskalev (Bulgaria) High Court of Cape Town High Court of Cape Town, South Africa European University Institute

Jason Jackson (The Bahamas) Klaas Eller (Germany) David Quentin (United Kingdom) Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania University of Cologne Stone King LLP, Cambridge University

Brishen Rogers (United States) Dezso Farkas (Canada) Brishen Rogers (United States) Temple University Beasley School of Law Osgoode Hall Law School Temple University Beasley School of Law

Participants Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) Jaakko Salminen (Finland) Sciences Po Law School University of Turku Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University David Hansen-Miller (United States) Alvaro Santos (Mexico) London International Transport Workers’ Federation Georgetown Law

Jennifer Bair (United States) Elizabeth Havice (United States) Lucie White (United States) University of Colorado University of North Carolina Harvard Law School

68 event participants

June 2014 IGLP Colloquium: Does Heterodoxy Have a Politics? A Method? (Harvard Law School), June 3, 2014

Genealogy of Heterodoxy in Heterodoxy in International Genealogy of Heterodoxy in International Law Finance and Banking Economics

Panelist: Panelists: Alfredo Saad Filho (United Kingdom) Martti Koskenniemi (Finland) Tamara Lothian (United States) SOAS, University of London University of Helsinki Columbia Law School Genealogy of Heterodoxy in The Postcolonial Turn as Leopold Specht (Austria) International Relations Heterodox Intervention Specht Böhm Rechtsanwalt GmbH, Vienna Helen Kinsella (United States) Panelists: University of Wisconsin-Madison people iglp at Samera Esmeir (Israel/Palestine) Critical Approaches to Department of Political Science University of California-Berkeley International Criminal Law Circulations of Modernity in Saba Mahmood (Pakistan/United Panelists: East Asia: New Approaches to States) Heidi Matthews (Canada) Comparative Law University of California-Berkeley Harvard Law School Comparative Heterodoxies: Moderator: Science and Technology Tor Krever (Canada) Mikhail Xifaras (France) Studies/ Critical Legal Studies London School of Economics and Sciences Po Law School / Third World Approaches to Political Science International Law Panelists: Paul Clark (United Kingdom) Dongsheng Zang (China) Panelists: Garden Court Chambers University of Washington School of Arnulf Becker (Chile) Law Brown University Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) The City Law School, City University Hajime Yamamoto (Japan) Duncan Kennedy (United States) London Keio University Law School Harvard Law School Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) Yun Ru Chen (Taiwan) Sheila Jasanoff (United States) University of Edinburgh Harvard Law School Harvard Kennedy School Bringing Heterodoxy to Bear: Mika Yokoyama (Japan) Kyoto Academia in the Public Realm: New Approaches to Syria University Graduate School of Law The Problem of Boycotts Moderator: World Making and Norm-

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Moderator: David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Making: Heterodoxy in Science Zinaida Miller (United States) Law School and Technology Studies Tufts University Panelists: Panelists: Panelists: Hani Sayed (Syria) The American Ben Hurlbut (United States) Dennis Davis (South Africa) University in Cairo Arizona State University, School of Life High Court of Cape Town Sciences Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia and Italy) Janet Halley (United States) Carleton University Shelia Jasanoff (United States) Harvard Law School Harvard Kennedy School Anne Orford (Australia) Melbourne Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) University Law School Genealogy of Heterodoxy in Melbourne University Law School History Usha Natarajan (Australia) The American University in Cairo Panelist: Judith Surkis (United States) Rutgers University

69 Participants Dan Danielsen (United States) Tor Krever (Canada) Northeastern University School of Law London School of Economics and Political Libby Adler (United States) Science Northeastern University School of Law Dennis Davis (South Africa) High Court of Cape Town Vidya Kumar (Canada) Aziza Ahmed (United States) University of Birmingham Northeastern University School of Law Christine Desan (United States) Harvard Law School Richard Lehun (Canada) Talal Abdulla Al-Emadi (Qatar) McGill University Qatar University College of Law Luis Eslava (Australia) Melbourne Law School Tamara Lothian (United States) Helena Alviar (Colombia) Columbia Law School Universidad de Los Andes Samera Esmeir (Palestinian) University of California-Berkeley Saba Mahmood (Pakistan and United Antony Anghie (United States) States) S.J. Quinney College of Law, University of Jorge Esquirol (United States) University of California-Berkeley Utah Florida International University College of Law Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Alejandra Azuero-Quijano (Colombia) University of Memphis, School of Law Harvard Law School Günter Frankenberg (Germany) The Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main Heidi Matthews (Canada) Grietje Baars (The Netherlands) Harvard Law School The City Law School, City University Gerald Frug (United States) London Harvard Law School Zinaida Miller (United States) The Fletcher School, Tufts University Elizabeth Bartholet (United States) Motoaki Funakoshi (Japan) Harvard Law School Kyoto University Pier Giuseppe Monateri (Italy) University of Turin Arnulf Becker (Chile) Yugank Goyal (India) Watson Institute for International Studies, University of Hamburg Horatia Muir Watt (France) Brown University Sciences Po Law School Janet Halley (United States) Nathaniel Berman (United States) Harvard Law School Usha Natarajan (Australia) Brown University The American University in Cairo Vanja Hamzić (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Sadeq Bigdeli (Iran) SOAS, University of London Vasuki Nesiah (United States) University of Waikato School of Law The Gallatin School, New York University John Haskell (United States) Stuart Brotman (United States) Mississippi College School of Law Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia / Italy) Harvard Law School Carleton University Ben Hurlbut (United States) Qingxiu Bu (People’s Republic of China) Arizona State University, School of Life Anne Orford (Australia) University of Sussex Sciences Melbourne Law School

Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) University of Edinburgh Harvard Kennedy School Melbourne Law School

Yun-Ru Chen (Taiwan) Vivek Kanwar (United States) Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School Jindal Global Law School Melbourne Law School

Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Ratna Kapur (India) Vesco Paskalev (Bulgaria) Melbourne Law School Jindal Global Law School European University Institute

Cyra Choudhury (United States) David Kennedy (United States) Nicolás Perrone (Argentina / Italy) Florida International University College of Harvard Law School Universidad Externado de Colombia Law Duncan Kennedy (United States) Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) Paul Clark (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School University of Kent Law School Garden Court Chambers Helen Kinsella (United States) Rachel Rebouché (United States) Matt Craven (United Kingdom) University of Wisconsin-Madison Temple University Beasley School of Law SOAS, University of London Martti Koskenniemi (Finland) University of Helsinki,

70 event participants

(Continued) June 2014 IGLP Colloquium: Does Heterodoxy Have a Politics? A Method? (Harvard Law School), June 3, 2014

Participants (Continued)

Karen Rhone (United States) University of Chicago

Kerry Rittich (Canada) University of Toronto

Alfredo Saad Filho (United Kingdom) SOAS, University of London

people iglp at Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Georgetown Law

Hani Sayed (Syria) The American University in Cairo

Mohammad Shahabuddin(Bangladesh) Jahangrinagar University

Amr Shalakany (Egypt) The American University in Cairo

Leo Specht (Austria) Specht Böhm

Judith Surkis (United States) Rutgers University

Chantal Thomas (United States) Cornell Law School

René Urena (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes

Robert Wai (Canada)

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL Osgoode Hall Law School

Lucie White (United States) Harvard Law School

Mikhail Xifaras (France) Sciences Po Law School

Hajime Yamamoto (Japan) Keio University Law School

Mika Yokoyama (Japan) Kyoto University

Dongsheng Zang (Japan) University of Washington School of Law

71 72 IGLP 2013 doha in january cambridge in june core curriculum

plenary lectures the workshop the conference an intensive residential program discussion sections for scholars developing innovative the colloquium ideas and alternative approaches to issues of global law, economic writing workshops the pro-seminars policy, and social justice. social program alumni opportunities

alumni opportunities enrichment curriculum

workshop for faculty and docents santander/iglp doha grants

iglp alumni collaborative research grants iglp: the workshop JANUARY 2-11, 2015 | DOHA, QATAR the workshop is an intensive residential program designed to strengthen the next generation of doctoral & post-doctoral scholars by placing them in collaboration with their global peers as they develop innovative ideas and approaches to issues iglp travel grants of global law, economic policy, social justice and governance.

iglp: the conference JUNE 1-3, 2015 | CAMBRIDGE, MA a biannual international conference on new directions in global thought for new iglp ongoing research projects and returning members of the iglp network to present and discuss innovative research in the institute’s core areas.

ANNUAL REPORT REPORT ANNUAL iglp: the colloquium JUNE 4-5, 2015 | CAMBRIDGE, MA an annual colloquium for core faculty, invited guests and iglp docents.

iglp: the pro-seminars JUNE 4-5, 2015 | CAMBRIDGE, MA pro-seminars bring together 10-15 scholars who are working on a common topic to brainstorm their scholarly writing and advance their work toward publication.

73 IGLPIGLP 20132015 doha in january cambridge in june core curriculum plenary lectures the workshop the conference an intensive residential program discussion sections for scholars developing innovative the colloquium ideas and alternative approaches to issues of global law, economic writing workshops the pro-seminars policy, and social justice. social program alumni opportunities enrichment curriculum workshop for faculty and docents santander/iglp doha grants

iglp alumni collaborative research grants

iglp travel grants

iglp ongoing research projects

74 The Workshop 2014

75 76 economic development

rethinking global finance

77 Albania Algeria Argentina Australia Austria Bangladesh Belarus Belgium Bosnia and Herzegovina Botswana Brazil Bulgaria Cameroon Canada Chile Colombia Cote d’Ivoire Croatia Denmark Egypt Eritrea Ethiopia Finland France Georgia Germany Ghana Greece Guinea Hong Kong Hungary India Iran Ireland Israel Italy Jamaica Jordan Kazakhstan Lebanon Macedonia Malaysia Mauritius Mexico Morocco Netherlands New Zealand Niger Nigeria Norway Pakistan Palestine Panama P.R. China Peru Philippines Poland Portugal Qatar Romania Russia Senegal Serbia Sierra Leone Singapore Slovakia Slovenia South Africa South Korea Spain Sri Lanka Sudan Taiwan Tanzania Thailand The Bahamas Turkey

Uganda United Kingdom United78 States Uzbekistan Venezuela Zimbabwe INSTITUTE FOR GLOBAL LAW & POLICY Harvard Law School, Cambridge, MA 02138 +1-617-495-3145 www.iglp.law.harvard.edu