Synergistic ·Antiandrogenic Effects of Topical Combinations of Sa-Reductase and Androgen Receptor Inhibitors in the Hamster Sebaceous Glands
Jonathan R. Matias, M.S., Virginia L. Malloy, M.S., and Norm.an Orentreich, M.D. Biomedical Research Station, Orcntreich Foundation for the Advancement of Science, Inc., Cold Spring-on-Hudson, New York ORM, VLM, NO), and Department of Dermatology, NYU School of Medicine, New York, New York U.S.A. (NO)
The androgenic action of dihydrotestosterone (DHT) is an produced any effect on SGS. When combinations of these tagonized by agents that compete with testosterone for the two steroids were applied at low concentrations, SGS de Sa-reductase enzyme and by agents that block the binding of creased unilaterally to approximately SO%. This synergy oc DHT to its receptor. The topical synergistic effect of Sa-re curred best at a P : SL ratio of 1 : 2. The lower effective con ductase (SaRI) and androgen receptor inhibitors (ARI) was centrations of P may be explained by its greater percutaneous determined by measurement of the sebaceous gland size absorption. Synergy was also demonstrated at low concen (SGS) of the ventral ear skin of the intact, sexuall y mature trations with other antiandrogens: cyproterOlle acetate, can male Syrian hamsters. Progesterone (P), a SaRI, and spiro renone, hydroxyflutamide, and N -N-diethyl-4-methyl- nolac tone (SL), an ARI, produced a dose responsive decrease 3-oxo-4-aza-5a-androstane-17,B-carboxamide. The use of in SGS at topical concentrations of 0.01 % to 5.0%. At con anti-androgen combinations at low concentrations is of value centrations of 1,3, and 5%, P and SL combinations produced because of the decreased risk of systemic side effects while neither an additive nor synergistic inhibition ofSGS. At very maintaining potent topical efficacy. ] Jil l/est Dermatol low concentrations of up to 0.10%, neither P nor SL alone 91:429-433,1988.
ntiandrogens are divided into two major classes. The each class. In this study the androgen-sensitive sebaceous glands of first is represented by Sa-reductase inhibitors (SaRI), the hamster ventral ear pinna were utilized as a target organ for which co mpete with testosterone for the binding site evaluating the effect of topically applied combinations of antian in the Sa-reducta se enzyme. The second group is drogens. W e report here that combinations of topically applied comprised of androgen receptor inhibitors (ARI), SaRI and ARI exert a potent synergistic effect at very low doses Aw hich interf ere with the binding of dihydrotestosterone (DHT) to without evidence of sys temic side effects. the androgen receptor protein . Details of the biochemical and phys iologic effects of antiandrogens can be found in numerous reviews MATERIALS AND METHODS [e.g. , Refs 1,2). Animals Male Syrian golden hamsters were purchased from Har Because both types of antiandrogens act through entirely differ lan-Sprag ue Dawley, Inc. (Farmersburg, IN), at 10-11 weeks of ent mechanisms, the overall effi cacy of antiandrogen therapy might age. The animals werc houscd at a density of 4 to 5 animals per cage be enhanced by using combinations of selected compounds from with a photoperiod of 14 h li ght and 10 h dark. Food and water were provided ad libitum. The hamsters were acclimated to the labora tory conditions for at leas t 1 week prior to the experiments. Manuscript received N ovember 3, 1987; accepted for publication April Chemicals The following were purchased commerciall y: spiron 2 1,1988. Reprint requ ests to: Jonathan R. Matias, Biomedical Research Station, olactone (SL) from Sigma C hemical Company (St. Louis, MO); Orentreich Foundation for the Advancement of Scicncc, Inc., RD 2, Box progesterone (P) from Upjohn Company (Kalamazoo, MI); 4-preg 375, Cold Spring-on-Hudso n, NY 10516. ncne-3-one (4P3) fro m SyntBiotech, Inc. (Ncw York, NY); desox Abbreviations: ycorticosterone acetate (DOCA) , medroxyproges terone acetate ARI: androgen receptor inhibitor (MPA) and 4-androsten-3-one-17p-ca rboxylic acid (1 7BCA) fro m CN: ca nrcnone Steral oids (Wilton, NH). The following compounds were received 17 PCA: 4-androstcn-3-onc-17P carboxylic acid as gifts: canrenone (C N) from G.D. Searle Company (Skokie, IL); CA: cy proterone acetate n,n dicthyl-4 methyl-3-oxo-4-aza-Sa-androstanc 17p-carboxa DHT: dihydrotcstostcronc lI1ide (4-MA) from Merck, Sharpe, and Dohme (Rahway, NJ); hy DOCA: desoxycorticosterone acetate HF: hydroxyfluta111id e droxyflutamide (HF) and cy proterone acctatc (CA) from Schering 4MA: 1l,Il-di ethyl-4 1l1cthyl- 3-oxo-4-aza-Sa-androstanc 17p-carboxa- AG (Berlin, West Germany). 111 ide Radiolabeled steroids were obtained from th e following sources: MPA: 111 edroxyprogcstcronc acetate [1,2-3H(N))-progesterone (S.A. 57.5 CI/l11mol) from New En P: Progesterone gland Nuclea r (B os ton, MA); [1 ,2-3H (N))-spironolac tone (S.A. 44 4P3: 4-prcgnene-3-one Ci/ mmol) fro m Amersham (Arlington Heights, IL). 5 RI : Sa-rcductase inhibitor SL: spiro nolactone Procedures for the Topical Study The antiandrogens were dis SGS: sebaceous gland size solved in acctone either separately or in combinations. Twenty-five
0022-202X/88/S03.50 Copyright © 1988 by The Society for Investiga tive Dcrmatology, Inc.
429 430 MATIAS, MALLOY, AND ORENTREICH THE JOURNAL OF INVESTIGATIVE DERMATOLOGy
microliters of each solution was applied with a micropipette on the ventral surface of the right ear pinna, once in the morning and once - \00 ~ in the afternoon of each day, Monday through Friday. The left ;§ 80 pinna of the same animal was not treated and served as an indicator '0 60 of any systemic effect of the antiandrogen treatment. Control ani ~ w 40 ~ N PROGES TERON E mals received topical applications of acetone alone to the right ;;;; 20 pinna. Unless otherwise specified, the treatments were terminated <=>z « after 4 weeks and the animals were killed by cervical dislocation. A -' '"" \00 -- ·-"O"------o--~ __o.., preliminary study indicated that chis was the minimum time for ' . :=>'" 0 80 b attaining an antiandrogenic response in intact mature males. ~
Table II. Effect of the Topical Application of Low Concentrations of P and SL Combinations on Sebaceous Glands in Adult Male Syrian Golden H amsters (Mean ± S.E) Experimental Sebaceous Gland Size Group Treatment (N) (mm2 X 10- 3) % Control Index A Control (7) 34.0 ± 1.9 100.0 0.05% P (7) 30.5 ± 1.9 89.7 0.10% SL (6) 30.4 ± 1.8 88.4 0.05 % P + 0.10% SL (5) 23.9 ± 0.9' 70.3 1.36 B Control (5) 31.9 ± 1.5 100.0 0.025 % P (5) 30.2 ± 1.7 94.7 0.05% SL (5) 28.1 ± 2.4 88.1 0.025% P + 0.05% SL (5) 18.6± 2. 1h 58.3 2.42 , P < 0.001 compared with the cO lltrol; P < 0.01 compared with eith er P or SL. b P < 0.001 compared with the control; P < 0.001 compared with either P or SL.
Table III. The Effect of Further Dilution of 0.025% P and 0.05% SL Topical Preparation Oil the Antiandrogenic Effect on the Sebaceous G lands of Adult Male Syrian H amsters (Mea n ± S.E) Sebaceous Gland Size Treatment (N) (mm2 X 10- 3) % Control p Control (7) 30.0 ± 1.4 100 0.025% P + 0.05% SL (5) 16.9 ± 0.6 56 .3 0.001 0.012% P + 0.025% SL (6) 18.5 ± 1.1 61.7 0.001 0.006% p + 0.01 2% SL (6) 25.5 ± 2.1 85.0 NS' , NS: Not Significant at th e 0.05 level of probability.
However, this inhibitory effect was similar to that produced by the Table IV. In Vivo Percutaneous Absorption Rate of P and SL combination of 0.025% P and 0.05% SL. Despite the increased through the Ventral Ear Skin of Male Syrian Golden Hamsters number of antiandrogens present at low concentrations, the effect (Mean S.E) ± remained local ized on the treated ear. Absorption As noted above, a preliminary study indicated that any topical Experiment (N) (% of Dose Applied) P application of P or SL for a duration of less than 4 weeks was insufficient to produce a reduction of sebaceous gland size in normal Progesterone 4 73.5 ± 5.7 < 0.01 male h amsters. For this reason, topical therapy was given for a Spironolactone 4 40. 3 ± 5.4
Table V. The Effect of Various Combinations of SaRI and two ARI (CA and SL) did not produce any synergistic inhibitory ARIon H amster Ear Sebaceous Glands (Mean ± S.E) effects on the hamster ear sebaceous glands (Table VI). Area of Increasing the number of 5a-RI and ARI in a single topical prepa- Experimental Sebaceous Glands ration was also ineffective in increasing the magnitude of the an- . Group Treatment (N) (mm2 X 10- 3) % Control Index tiandrogenic effect (Table VII). This "antiandrogen cocktail" pro- duced an approximately 55% decrease in sebaceous gland size. A Control (6) 37.3 ± 1.1 100.0 0.025% 4MA (6) 34.5 ± 2.2 92.5 0.050% SL (6) 38.4 ± 1.7 102.9 4 MA +SL (6) 23.1 ± 1.5' 61. 9 3.66 3 .0 B Control (5) 31.3 ± 2.0 100.0 0.05% 4P3 (5) 26 .7 ± 1.0 85.3 0.10% SL (5) 26 .1 ± 0.7 83.0 4P3 + SL (5) 18.5 ± 0.6b 59.1 1.29 x ~ 2 .0 C Control (7) 34.0 ± 1.9 100.0 '!: 0.05% P (7) 30.5 ± 1.8 89 .7 ::IE VJ 0.10% CA (6) 31.7 ± 1.9 93.2 C) c a: P+CA (6) 22.5 ± l.4 66 .2 1.98 w z D Control (7) 30.0 ± 1.4 100.0 ~ 1.0 0.05% P (6) 30.5 ± 1.0 101.7 0.10% HF (6) 24.4 ± 0.9 81.0 P+ HF (5) 20.3 ± 1.2d 67.7 1.87 E Control (6) 31.8 ± 1.6 100.0 0.025% P (5) 30.2 ± 1.5 95.0 001 .01 0 .1 10 100 0.05% CN (5) 29.7 ± 1.3 93.4 RATIO P/SL P +CN (5) 17.5±1.1e 55.0 3.88
Figure 2. Determination of the ratio of P and SL required to produce the • P, 0.001 compared with the contro l; P < 0.005 compared with 4MA alone or SL alone. optimum synergistic antiandrogenic effect on hamster sebaceous glands. h P < 0.001 compared with either control, 41'3, or SL. Each data point represe nts an experiment consisting of four groups of five , P < 0.001 compared with the control; P < 0.01 compared with P or CA alone. hamsters treated with various combinations of P and SL. The index of d p < 0.001 compared with the control and P alone; I' < 0.05 compared with HF synergism or antagonism was ca lculated for each experimental set. Note that alone. the concentration of each steroid in any combination was at 0.1 % or lower. , p < 0.001 compared with either control, P alone, or Cn alone. 432 MATIAS, MALLOY, AND ORENTRE ICH THE JOURNAL OF INVESTIGATIVE DERMATOLOGY
Table VI. Absence of Synergistic Antiandrogenic Activity with Table VII. Effect Qf the Simultaneous AdministratiQn of Five CQmbinatiQns of Two. ARI Qr Two. SaRI Qn the Hamster Ear Different Sa-Reductase Inhibitors and Five Androgen Receptor Sebaceous Glands (Mean ± S.E) Inhibitors Qll Sebaceous G land GrQwth Experimental Sebaceous Gland Size Sebaceous Gland Size 2 3 2 3 ph Group Treatment (N) (mm X 10- ) % Control Treatment' (N) (mm X 10- ) A Control (7) 34.0 ± 1.9 100.0 Control Vehicle (5) . 31. 2 ± 2.3 0. 1% SL (6) 30.4 ± 2. 0 89.4 Antiandrogcn Combination (6) 0.1% CA (6) 31.7 ± 1.9 93.2 a) trea ted side 14.1±0.7 .001 SL+ CA (7) 28.5 ± 1.5' 83.8 b) untreated side 28.6 ± 1.0 NSb B Contro l (6) 28.6 ± 1.5 100.0 'The SaRI consist of DOCA, MPA, P, 17BCA, and 4P3; ARI consists of CA, RlJ 0.05% P (6) 28.7 ± 2.1 100.4 2956, O HF, SL, and CN. 0.05% 4MA (6) 28.2 ± 2.0 98.6 • Values were compared with the control vehicle. N S: Not Significant atO.05 Ieve! of P+4MA (6) 26.8 ± 0.6h 93.7 probability. • Significant at < 0.05 compared with the control; not significant CO tnpared wi th 0. 1% SL or 0. 1% CA. P was selected as a representative SaRI because it has been shown b Not signifi ca nt compared with the control, 0.05% P, or 0.05% 4MA. to. be a potent naturall y Qccurring inhibitQr of the Sa reductase enzym e l13,14J. SL, an aldosterQne antagQnist currently used in the trea tment of essential hypertension, exerts its antiandrogenic effect duration Qf 1 month in the abQve studies. HQwever, the effect Qf through a) impairment in tes tQsterQne biosynthesis via reductiQn Qf tQpical applicatiQns fQr IQnger p.eriQd s was also. evaluated. Figure 3 17[3 -hydroxylase activity and reductiQn of cytochrQme P4S0 COll shQ:Ws that the effect did nQt Increase With longer dUrations Qf tent and b) competitive inhibition Qf DHT binding to the cytoplas tQPlcal therapy. HQwever, it is important to nQte Qnce again that the mic andrQgen receptQr protein [15]. These steroids were considered anti-androgenic effect Qf cQmbinatiQ n therapy remained lQcalized ideal candidates for the experiments because both had preVIOusly to. the treated ear even after 3 mQnths Qf tQpical applicatiQll (data nQt been demonstrated to. decrease sebaceous glands size in the male shQwn). hamster ear when applied topicall y [4]. Data presented in this paper demQnstrate cQ nclusively that such DISCUSSION combinatiQns can exert a synergistic inhibitQry effect on the seba Central to. the ~t i o l Qgy Qf various androgenic dermatoses affiicting ceous glands of adult sexually mature Syrian hamsters. The syner human bemgs IS the penpheral cQ nversion Qf circulating testoster gism, additivism, and antagQnism of antiandrQgen combinatiQns one to dlhydrQtestosterone (DHT) and the fQrmation of a DHT- re were also examined using the methQd described by Berenbaum [1 6] ceptor complex. Provided that there is an absence of otber endo and found to. be in agreem ent with Qur own calculations. MQre crinopathies, current mQdes Qf therapy involve ,the use Qf systemic important, the synergy of these two. classes of inhibitors occurred and/Qr topical antiandrogens. NumerQus rapers have already been only at very low topical dosages. For example, the magnitude of published that demQnstrate the efficacy 0. oral CA [e:g., 6,7], and sebaceQus gland reductiQn induced by a combinatiQn of 0.025% P more recently, oral SL [8,9 J. Because commQn acne, lurSlltism, and and O.OS % SL (Table II) was equivalent to the separate applicatiQns male pattern baldness are cQnsidered essentia!ly cosm~tic problems of 1 % P Qr 3% SL. Because the cQmbinations are effi caciQus at lQW not worthy Qf an unfavQrable n sk: benefit ratIO, there IS an obviQUS doses, the possibility of systemic side effects are, therefQre, greatly ~eed to. develQP PQtent, locally effective treatment that avoids the minimized. Side effects attendant.to systemic a.nti androge~ therapy [10,11). Why sy nergism was evident at lQW but not at high tQpical doses .~ecau se Sa-:eductlon and sterOId-receptor interactIOns are each remains puzzling. The present data ca nnot explain this phenome cflncal events III the expression of androgen action, it is theQreti nQn . However, an insight into this question may be found when the cally possible ~o use inhibitQrs Qf each pathway in cQ lllbinatiQn. percutaneous absorption rate (P AR) Qf sterQids is considered. In the TIllS hYPQthesls was tested by applying cQ mbinations of these CQ m case Qf glucocQrticoids, fQr example, Stoughton [17] has shown that PQunds Qn the hamster ventral ear skin and thrQugh the assess ment increasing the concentratiQn Qf steroid in the topical preparation Qf the antiandrogeni c effect by measurement Qf the sebaceQ us causes a decline in the PAR and a proportionate reduction in its glands. The suitability of this cutaneous model [1 2) and the useful cutaneous biQlogic effect. When tes tQsterone 17[3 -valerate was ap ness of the methQd used fQr measurement have been discussed in plied topically, 0.04% concentratiQn was fQund to. be as active as detail in previous reports [3,4]. 0.2% or 1.0% in prQd ucing cutaneous vasoconstriction. Although satisfactory expl anations for this phenomenQn are still lac king, these observations may be similar in mechanism to. the low dose effects seen in this repQrt. One must also consider the possibility that the SaRl and ARI in the sQ lutiQn may interact pharmacolQ gically in some still unknown manner to create an antagonism at high con centratiQns and synergism at lower cQncentratiQns. W N A P:SL ratio of 1:2 was found to be optimal fQr inducing the v; inhibitory effect. Analysis of the percutaneQus absorptiQn of these :z '"
CN [20], produced synergistic inhibition when combined with P. 9. Cummings DC, Yang]C, Rebar RW, Yen SSC: Treatment ofhirsut However, combinations 'of two ARI's or two SaRI did not act ism with spironolactone. ]AMA 247:1295 - 1298, 1982 synergistically on the hamster ear skin sebaceous glands. 10. Rose LI , Underwood RH, N ewmark SR, Kisch ES, Williams GH: The combined use of various drugs for the treatment of acne has Pathophysiology of spironolactone-induced gynecomastia. Ann Int been described previously. Marsden et al [21] administered isotre Med 87:398-403,1977 tinoin and CA systemically in patients with acne and found the 11. W endt A, Hasan SH, Heinz I, Tauber U: Systemic effects of local absence of synergy between the two compounds, although each one antiandrogen therapy. Arch Dermatol Res 273:171,1982 reduced sebum production via independent mechanisms. Estrogens 12. Plewig G, Luderschmidt C: Hamster ear model for sebaceous glands.] also reduce sebum production through local [22] inhibition of seba Invest Dermatol 68:171-176, 1977 ceous activity and through inhibition of testosterone production via 13. Voigt W., Fernandez EP, Hsia SL: Transformation of testosterone into the pituitary-gonadal axis [23,24]. Systemic administration of estro 17B-OH-5a-androstan-3-one by microsomal preparation of human gens with CA [25] or glucocorticoids [26] failed to demonstrate any skin.] BioI Chern 245:5594-5595, 1970 synergistic antiandrogenic effect. The lack of synergy may in part be 14. Orentreich N, Matias ]R, Malloy V: The local antiandrogenic effect of due to the dose chosen for the studies or that insufficient levels of the intracutaneous injection of progesterone in the fl ank organ of these compounds actually reach the target tissue. In a recent study, sex ually mature male Syrian Golden hamsters Arch Dermatol Res 276:401 - 405, 1984 we have shown that a combination of Sa-RI and ARI was ineffec tive in inhibiting the growth of experimental prostate adenocarci 15. Corvo I P, Michaud A, Menard], Friefeld M , Mahoudeau: Antiandro genic effect of spironolactones:mechanism of action. Endocrinol noma, normal prostate, and seminal vesicle in a synergistic manner 97:52- 58 [27]. One may also consider the possibility that sy nergism may be 16. Berenbaum MC: Synergy, additivism and antagonism in immunosup best achieved only through direct administration of inhibitory com pression. Clin Exp Immunol 28:1 - 18, 1977 pounds to the target site, preferably via topical administration. 17. Stoughton RB: Penetration of drugs through the skin. Dermatologica To our knowledge, the concept of topical use of SaRI and ARI 152{SuppI1):27-36, 1976 combinations have not yet been tested clinically. The present find 18. Caill ean], Verhoeven G: Inhibition by a 4-methyl-4-AZA-steroid of ings using this cutaneous model strongly suggest that this concept NADPH: ~4-3-oxos t ero id-5 -ox i do-re du c ta se activity in cultured may have a potential therapeutic benefit in the local treatment of intersti tial cells derived from immature rat testes.] Steroid Biochem androgenic dermatoses because of its potent direct action at very safe 18:365-367, 1983 drug concentrations. 19. Neri R, Florence K, Koziol P, VanCleave S: Biological profile of a nonsteroidal an'tiandrogen SCH 1325 1 (4 1-nitro-3 1-trifluoro methyl isobutylanilide). Endocrinology 91:427 -437, 1972 REFERENCES 20. Nielsen PG: Treatment of moderate idiopathic hirsutism with a cream 1. ]anne OA, Bardin CW: Androgen and antiandrogen receptor binding. containing canrcnone (an antiandrogen). Dermatologica 165:636- Ann Rev Physiol 46:107 - 118, 1984 639, 1982 2. Lerner L]: Androge n antagonists. Pharmac Therap B 1 :2 17 - 231, 21. Marsden]R, Laker MF, Ford GP, Shuster S: Effect oflow dose cypro 1975 terone acetate on th e response of acne to isotretinoin. Br] Dermatol 3. Matias JR, Orentrcich N: The hamster car sebaceous glands: examina 110:697 - 702 tion of the regional variation by stripped skin planimetry. J Invest 22. Ebling FJ, Skinner]: The local effects of topically applied estradiol, Dermatol 81:43-46, 1983 cyproterone acetate, and ethanol on sebaceous secretion in adult 4. Matias JR, Malloy V, Orentreich N: A comparative study of the effects male rats.] Invest Dermatol 81 :448-451 , 1983 of percutaneously administered Sa-reductase and androge n receptor 23. Strauss ]S, Pochi PE: The hormonal co ntrol of human sebaceous inhibitors on hamster sebaceous glands. Ann NY Acad Sci 435:454- glands. In: Montagna W, Ellis RA, Silver AF{eds.). Advances in 456, 1985 Biology of Skin, Vol 4, Sebaceous Glands. Oxford, Pergammon 5. Feldmann RJ, Maibac h HI: Percutaneous penetration of steroids in Press, 1963, pp 220 - 252 man.] Invest Dermatol 52:89 - 94, 1969 24.. Forchielli E, Ras GS, Sarda ]R, Gibree NB, Pochi PE, Strauss ]S, 6. Burton JL, Laschet V, Shuster S: Reduction of sebum excretion in man Dorfman RI : Effect of ethinyl-estradiol on plasma testosterone ex by the antiandrogen cyproterone acetate. Br ] Dermatol 89:487- cretion in man. Acta Endocrinol 72:361 - 365, 1965 490,1973 25. Mugglestone C], Rhodes EL: The treatment of acne with antiandro 7. Ebling F], Cooke ID, Randall VA, Somers RS , ThomasAK, Skinner]: genjestrogen combination. 7:593-598, 1982 The influence of cy proterone acetate on the activity of hair follicles 26. Saihan EM, Burton ]L: Sebaceous gland suppression in fema le acne and sebaceous glands in man. In: Hammerstein], Lachnit-Fixon U, patients by combined glucocorticoid-oestrogen therapy. Br] Der Neumann F, Plewig G (cds.). Androgenization in Women. Ex matoI103:139- 142, 1980 cerpta Medica, Amsterdam, 1980, pp. 239 - 244 27. Malloy V, Matias j , C hin A, Orentreich N : Antiandrogenic effects of 8. Boisell e A, Tremblay RR: Clinical usefuln ess of spironolactone in the progesterone and sp ironolactone on prostate adenocarcinoma in the treatment of acne and hirsutism (abstr). C lin Res 26:840, 1978 Copcn haga n rat. Ann NY Acad Sci 494:310 - 312,1988
NOTICE
The Tricontinental Meeting of Inves tigative Dermatology will be held April 26-30, 1989 at the ]. W. Marriott Hotel, W as hington, D. C. Abstracts for this meeting must be received by December 16 , 1988. Direct abstracts and correspondence to: Ervin H. Epstei.n, Jr., MD. Room 269, Building 100 San Fra ncisco General Hospital 1001 Potrero Street Sa n Francisco, CA 94110