Measurement, Validation and Dissemination of Hurricane Wind
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MEASUREMENT, VALIDATION, ANALYSIS AND DISSEMINATION OF HURRICANE WIND DATA By LUIS D. APONTE-BERMUDEZ A REPORT PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER ENGINEERING UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2004 Copyright 2004 by Luis D. Aponte-Bermúdez This document is dedicated to my family for their support and prayers. TABLE OF CONTENTS page LIST OF TABLES............................................................................................................. vi LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................... vii ABSTRACT....................................................................................................................... ix CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................1 Hurricane History .........................................................................................................1 Overview of a Full-Scale Hurricane Wind Measurement Project................................3 2 MEASUREMENT SYSTEMS .....................................................................................7 Overview.......................................................................................................................7 Deployments Techniques..............................................................................................7 Instrumentation improvements for 2003 season.........................................................10 Deployments participations and tasks ........................................................................11 3 DATA VALIDATION................................................................................................14 Introduction.................................................................................................................14 Methodology...............................................................................................................14 Self Validation............................................................................................................15 Tower CBI vs. Tower XP ...........................................................................................22 Validation - Outside Sources......................................................................................24 NOAA Hurricane Research Division (HRD) Wind Surface Analysis Comparison...26 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................29 4 DATA PROCESSING AND ANALYSIS..................................................................31 Introduction.................................................................................................................31 Methodology...............................................................................................................32 Storm deployments overview and data summaries ....................................................33 Lateral length scales analysis......................................................................................37 Conclusions.................................................................................................................45 5 DISSEMINATION .....................................................................................................47 Introduction.................................................................................................................47 Summary of previous WinDLab version....................................................................48 iv WinDLab modifications .............................................................................................49 WinDLab package and distribution............................................................................53 Conclusions.................................................................................................................54 LIST OF REFERENCES...................................................................................................55 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH .............................................................................................56 v LIST OF TABLES Table page 1-1. Saffir-Simpson Scale ....................................................................................................2 2-1. Tower setup time differences .......................................................................................9 2-2. Tower XP and Tower CBI data acquisition system comparison................................10 3-1. Instrument combinations used to compute MSE........................................................19 3-4. Stations near to FCMP mobile towers during hurricane Isabel (2003) ......................25 4-1. Miscellaneous information added to data records. .....................................................33 4-2. Maximums peak wind speed observed during hurricane Isabel.................................36 4-3. Lateral length scale summary for mobile tower T1 during hurricane Isabel..............45 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure page 1-1. Mobile tower FCMP deployment for hurricane Michelle during 2001 hurricane season (right). Satellite tower testing at Florida Department of Transportation in Gainesville, FL (right)................................................................................................5 2-1. Mobile Tower configuration two. (Wilmington, NC - September, 2003 Hurricane Isabel).........................................................................................................................8 2-2. Mobile Tower computer box after modification for 2003 hurricane season. Testing at the Castillo de San Marcos (St Augustine, FL) with the cooperation of the National Park Service, an FCMP team from the University of Florida tested the new real- time data acquisition system on July 16, 2003.........................................................11 2-3. FCMP Deployment map for hurricane Isabel 2003....................................................12 3-1. Wind Speed time history displaying clear malfunction. (Data collected during hurricane Gabrielle Sept./14/2001) ..........................................................................15 3-2 Wind Speed comparison plot of 15 minutes average speed for mobile tower T3. A total of 155 15-minute records were collected with Tower CBI for hurricane Isabel at Frisco, NC. ...........................................................................................................18 3-3 Wind Direction comparison plot of 15 minutes average direction for mobile tower T3. A total of 155 15-minute records were collected with Tower CBI for hurricane Isabel at Frisco, NC..................................................................................................18 3-4. MSE time history between wind monitor and 10 meter gill anemometers using 100 Hz data collected with mobile tower T1 during hurricane Isabel at Wilmington, NC19 3-5. MSE time history between 10 meter gill anemometers and satellite 2 using 100 Hz data collected with mobile tower T1 during hurricane Isabel at Wilmington, NC ..20 3-6. Calibration curve for 10 and 5 meter gill anemometers. Generated using T1 Isabel data. ..........................................................................................................................21 3-7. Wind speed plot for Tower CBI record #45.(Start at 9/18/2003 13:42:41 UTC Time)21 3-8. Comparison plot of 15 minutes mean winds speed readings collected using the wind monitor with Tower XP and Tower CBI during hurricane Isabel at Frisco, NC. ....24 vii 3-9. Wind speed plot for Tower XP record #49. (Start at 9/18/2003 13:40:35 UTC Time)24 3-10. Weather Stations near FCMP towers during hurricane Isabel deployment..............25 3-11. Comparison of FMCP data collected during hurricane Lili with mobile tower T0 at Lafayette, LA., with data from Lafayette Regional Airport during October 3, 2002.26 3-12. HRD Max 1-min sustained surface winds model for hurricane Isabel.....................27 3-13. Maximum 1 min. comparison between HRD model and mobile tower T3 data from Tower XP during hurricane Isabel at Elizabeth City, NC........................................28 3-14. Direction comparison plot between HRD model and wind monitor for T3 during hurricane Isabel. .......................................................................................................29 4-1. FCMP deployment map for hurricane Isabel during 2003 season (left) and aerial view of mobile tower T2 (right)...............................................................................35 4-2. Summary graph of wind speed and direction for Tower T0 during Isabel.................36 y 4-3 Illustration of idealized measurement of Lu ................................................................39 4-4. Cross-covariance between pairs of instruments to get peak values............................41 4-5. Satellite tower deployment configuration for hurricane Isabel (top), and pictures of the actual deployments (below)................................................................................42 4-6. Instruments perpendicular to mean wind direction projection for mobile tower T1 during hurricane Isabel. Each record number on the x-axis corresponds to 15 minutes of data. ........................................................................................................43 4-7. Normalized cross-correlation