A3393-B11-01-Jpeg.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
'j h° y ^ - T yJ/c/i-f J/rtesf J c s J t XJ /y? £^c/<?t-i//£-nc/jr & > v / r s a . ■ p / " <?7* v w n> ■-■•-.•— ........... .... .... —....... ..... • ..... ' y / s / r j L f , J r 7 $ sy/yy^2 j_j ^ y < n j o / * \ S ' ^ ■ ^ 7 r v 7 y / & ‘*7 S * 1 'zCezi/t Ses- si %?e*77\*oc"(L (0sv*t+T4j*zs4fr--^f *V7 kT < ^ t r - t * - S 2^ -> /e 3'tf t? S&L-ciS^ SL y^a^se Sn/^ /%-£■ TX* £, c SXsStzz s&'jh^tS'' ‘SXCt^X' S U ~ Z Z a f ’ ^Kc S t"tS *r St? Sa*yz&*S . T c S ^ v ^ ^ C m vV«-.v»\» U.Wt'MW vivs^r' * ’••*• % % £ f r i e s' infers s/Hf' ^£** 4 . s w y S z <r& ^-i^r>*dds y - r u ^ _ £ ~ /'e cjt^t/cj^' r / ^ V <7^7 S'£/&*j£ /~lstf7^ '-7^-~tt.-i/£ ^7d& *i- pCP^iA/r'd?/^ 7^ 7.^ A / ^ih-sU^nsx<-> i> ^ f~s'*7/£/7:*Y S7?des4, (7/e^TT' £7^=-) *-r-^ - ^ T ^ c TC A T T^’U^-T' yY 'e A /* ’ ^ , J T '^ y y / y C ^ r ^ / ' 7 $ l i | I _j£-~ AyT'//4'jO^- 7%s'f 7/<£&!e? y \ s ^ y / ' »<S t^Z^r-^y -£~ <r’^w _ T^Cd^ , y yf 'i^eA.'Tr.'y - t M*. —e -^yC d A i '- T p r t ^ W *Ydtj6y y^p7 Syy,* <*^j/ y \ ^ ^ ^ 7 ly ~ ry ~ <n7/? t l TT* ~7*C^y'<7 ^Z- '/& 7'7^'Z’ 7j*y2£.4!r 7& <^£^7 j2£Cf~y'c . r*'' y*' r- <S|IV>^j,.<j s ? e 4 / e * r t4> ' it ■ ‘3 ryz^r^d^' -*ptS'd &ZZY /^f yc? ypy-Y i 5 - * * > ' 2 . < i£ * -c S : JI ’ i S -y 'd 7 6 I >/£<«- — —«*. ££■&?. jC y#y y > y p a ^ y < 7 y j f £ y y& y y ^ <p<?* p a & c s ? y c ^ y *y> y^^yy*'- *- <* - ^ / / |^v < - Aps-)s-7/t? erz^y y ^ y /^/yy y^e*/ JZU/ -Ztaf z$4r7&*7«0r~ S /.y > cZ*<dt -7-1-7 d-T^-dyyy-ySt 7 /-ssTd&rztf -*r* r 7 * - . s ?s*f /£> <s i ' <**<£?* 'I?-<'-<V, ■ ■7<? ' , •' ytiPt*' O^tS r/j’s-^ ■■* JZ-*^ £tP' Ss>^s ry ^£>1.^<s-<z^ ,-J^-ryd^'^£</\ —^ y y s * * . 'i - ^ - ‘^ " t- ? 6 C t z ^ S / k:^ £ d iv a s '? * ? ' v<5 ^ i^ £ y O <?eZ^k/y0 ^■ -£c.tt«f <PZi^7 £?CLSch&^e £cZ^4f/<zis-i - £/6 / £\ '^ttrl?ct:&^r • J / & < f * / t 7 c/ < = z ^ K ^ e'* * y p S -j £ 'f * r ~ s ^ /~ c Z * d <^t £y^z~rcd£- Z— <f~l/d' ^-7 ✓ J PROFESSOR B. A. HEPPLE, Q.C., ix.d. THE MASTER’S LODGE T he Master CLARE COLLEGE CAMBRIDGE CB21TL Telephone: +44 (0)1223 333241 Facsimile: +44 (0)1223 333249 E-mail: [email protected] 20 May 2000. Rusty Bernstein 57 Lock Crescent Kidlington Kidlington Oxford 0X5 1HF Dear Rusty Memory against Forgetting is a compelling account of your memories. Mine coincide in many respects with yours , but I believe that there are gaps and inaccuracies in your story, particularly as it relates to me. So I am sending you a copy of the memoir which I wrote in May/June 1964 while the events of Rivonia were still vivid in my mind. 1 have not published this, but I have lodged it in the Mayibuye Centre and the Bram Fischer Library. I cannot comment on what you write about my parents (p.44), because they never confided in me about these matters. They were able to play the role in later years which you rightly acknowledge by maintaining strict secrecy. I do not understand what purpose is now served by making these disclosures . ( Incidentally. Alex did not “inherit”- he worked as factory manager for the company founded by my mother’s father and resigned in 1948 when he became an MP- and there is an unfair innuendo that he worked in the Labour Party rather than the CP because of some personal ambition to play a leadership role.) With best wishes to you and Hilda, Yours ever. 57 Lock Crescent, Kidlington. 0X5 1HF 25. 05. 00 Professor B.A. Hepple, The Master's Lodge,, Clare College, Cambridge. CB2 1TL Dear Bob, Thank you for your letter, and for your own memoir of the events at and around Rivonfa. As you say, they agree In most respects with my own much later memories. I cannot see that any purpose would now be served - forty years after - in arguing over what differences there are, unless those differences can substantially alter the reading of the historical record. I doubt if any do. But I must say that it appears to me to be a distortion of history that your account makes no reference to the Communist Party, which was so central to the happenings at Rivonia and to your own part in them. I assume that your account - written in 1964 - was circumscribed by codes of "secrecy" and "security" which we imposed on ourselves at that time, but which are now surely inappropriate in serious historical writings. I am not sure what "disclosures" about your parents puzzle you. I can only think that you refer to my "disclosure" that, at one time, they were both members of the Party. That fact is not in question, though it was almost never voiced at the time - again for reasons of politics and "security". You may be distressed that it has now been voiced. But I think it is one of the many secrets of the^ast which are germane to a South African understanding of its own history. So/any years beyond the time when it can possibly affect you, your parents or the movement adversely, I would ask Primo Levi's question: "If not now, when?" You are wrong to suggest an innuendo that Alex' decision to continue in the Labour Party rather than the CP was for reason of a personal ambition for a "leadership role". He took a considered and principled reckoning of the best contribution he could make to our cause. I approved and supported his decision, although I took a different view of the right direction in my own case. I had a high regard for both your parents, which has remained with me since those times. Sincerely, and with good wishes, { 1 0 MORNING 8TAR Prlday F»bru>ry 11 2000 Who are Rivonia’s PAUL JOSEPH examines an account of the contribution of white South Africans to the children? struggle against apartheid. T has now become fashion Washington Post in South Africa in able among white South 198.1. He is also holder of the Pulitzer Africans to say tlint they Prize for international reporting. were against apartheiD — a Frankel tells the story through four fa milies and their children. They arc Rusty trenD which the increasing and Hilda Bernstein. Ruth First and Joe numbersI of white South Africans Slovo. Hamid and Anne Marie Wolpc taking up resiDence in Finchley, and Brain and Molly Fischer. The first three are of Jewish and the Inst of Afrika LonDon have brought with them. ner background. there is an anecdote about a black O f those several hundreds of white South African woman who was in exile people who supported the liberation for 25 years and. after the unbanning of movement, the majority came from the the A N C . P A C and the SACP, went on a Jewish community. But Frankel quashes visit to South Africa. the notion that all Jews were against apar Seated next to her on the flight was a theid. tile Smith African woman who did not At the outset, he tells of his interview »ther to enquire whether her co-passen with Dr Percy Yular, who prided himself ger and daughter were South Africans, on his Jewish background yet was the (lushing about the new South Afiica and ruthless chief prosecutor in the Rivonia full of piaise for Nelson Mandela, she trial in which Nelson Mandela and his co- went on to say how they, the whites, had accused faced possible death sentences. been against apartheid. Now. Yular claims that he “wanted to At this point, the quiet black woman save their lives." He wanted them to he exploded in anger. charged not with treason, which carried "Excuse m e!" she said. "I don't re the death penalty, hut snbotap** But, at member seeing you mound when we the time, sabotage also carried the death fought against apartheid, lhere were penalty. some whites and \Ve knew most of them The South African Jewish Board of — and. if we did not know them, we Deptuties comes in for n drubbing for its would have heard of them. duplicity and acquiescence with the apar theid regime, By and large, all white South Africans ‘Rivonia’s Children benefited from the system of racial op pression. irrespective of their origin — is a unique work of English. Afrikaner. Jewish. Portugese. Greek or Italian. scholarship and Whites were “Europeans" against the should be a source “Non-Europeans" and they voted lor suc cessive white governments to entrench of valuable the privilege that they enjoyed. However, the four families who fea reference to the ture in Frankel's account bring into focus those whites who made the courageous history of South moral decision to go against apartheid. Africa and for those It was never an easy choice.