Some Notes on Chapter-Houses 189 Mackenzie Walcott 1 Says That The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Some Notes on Chapter-Houses 189 Mackenzie Walcott 1 says that "the ribs, with arches like the bright curves of a fountain, branching from a central pillar, and converging upon its capital, represented the relations of the cathedral to the diocese, with a body of clergy connected with it through their prebends, and sitting as a circle of assessors about the bishop, the capitulum with their caput." The central pillar is absent at Southwell, York (wooden vault), Howden, Manchester. VIII. CHAPTER-HOUSES ON THE CONTINENT. Our subject would be incompletely handled were we to omit all mention of chapter-houses abroad. We have, however, space for only a short mention of them. Fergusson 2 says that " chapter-houses are as rare in Germany as in France, and those that are found are not generally circular in either country." 3 The English editor of Liibke's Ecclesiastical Art in Germany (p. 277) quotes from Fergusson's Hand book (p. 885): " On the Continent it is true there are chapter-houses to be found, generally square rooms with wooden roofs, and not remarkable for their architecture." In his History of Architecture (vol. ii. p. 172), Fergusson speaks again of the chapter-house as "almost exclusively national (i.e. English). There are, it is true, some ' Salles Capitulaires' attached to Continental cathe- 1 English Minsters, vol. i. p. 38. 1 Hist, of Arch., vol. ii. p. 81. Cf. Notes C and D, p. 247. 3 This is in the second edition, dated 1874. Mackenzie Walcott in his Church and Convent. Arrangement, p. 39, makes the statement in almost the same words. Fergusson's first edition was published 1865-76, and the work appeared first as a " Handbook :: in 1855. Mr. Walcott's book is undated. But on p. 64, note 3, he quotes from " G. G. Scott, Proc. R.I.B.A., 1860." He also refers on several occa sions to Fergusson. So that we shall probably be safer if we take the dictum about foreign chapter-houses to be Fergusson's, quoted without acknowledgment, but endorsed by Mr. Walcott. i go Some Notes on Chapter-Houses drals or conventual establishments, but they are little more than large vestry-rooms, with none of that dignity or special ordinance that belongs to the English examples." He goes on to try to find a reason for this. But we should fall into error were we to conclude that there are no fine chapter-houses abroad. Pos sibly the apse of the churches (cf. Torcello) was first used for the meetings of the bishop and clergy. " In the ninth century the alley (of the cloister) next the church was used as a chapter-house [e.g. St. Gall, c. 820]. In 966, Herleve, wife of Duke Robert of Normandy, built a separate chamber for the purpose at Fontenelle." l Mr. Walcott mentions a good number of foreign chapter-houses, and so does Mr. Fergusson. It is difficult to understand how the more highly organised conventual life could be carried on without them. But, instead of pursuing this further, we will glance at the plan 2 of the Cistercian monastery at Maul- brunn in Germany, and there we find on the north side of the church in the east alley of the cloister (c. 18 feet wide) a chapter-house measuring 50 feet x 25 feet (i.e. 1250 square feet as against 1300 square feet at Chester). In the west wall are four openings, and in the east wall two windows. A circular staircase is in the north-east angle, and in the south-east corner an altar apse, £.15 feet in diameter. In the width, from north to south, are three pillars, which support an elaborate vaulted roof and divide the room into two alleys. This is evidently a building of importance, and not a mere vestry-room. There is another notable chapter-house at Ve"zelay in France, which demands a fuller description. Of the famous Romanesque church of Ve'zelay we have no time to speak that " splendid church of the 1 M. Walcott, Ch. and Conv. Arr., p. 121. 4 Liibke, Eccles. Art in Germany, p. 106. Some Notes on Chapter-Houses 191 Benedictines at the height of their power," dedicated to St. Mary Magdalene, " typically monastic, typi cally Romanesque," and especially interesting to us Englishmen from the fact that on Whitsunday, 1 166, before a great concourse of people, our archbishop, Thomas k Becket, driven from his see and (lately) from the Cistercian House of Pontigny, " pronounced his sentence of excommunication against the chief offenders, read the Pope's condemnation of the Constitu tions of Clarendon, and warned in a voice choked by sobs his sovereign and his old friend of the sentence which awaited him." Jutting out from the south transept is the chapter house of Ve"zelay, which was probably standing, newly built, at the time of Becket's visit, and in which he probably joined in the devotions and deliberations of his Benedictine hosts. It is ap proached from the church by a cloister some 15 feet in width, and it measures 46 x 36 feet 1656 square feet against the 1300 square feet of the Chester chapter-house, and the 1024 square feet of that at Exeter. It is, however, less in size than those at Canterbury, Durham, and Gloucester, and than those formerly existing at Peterborough, Win chester, Norwich, Bury St. Edmunds, &c. It dates from the twelfth century, a little earlier than the reconstructed choir. Its plan is rectangular, and, like that at Maulbrunn, it is divided into two alleys by a couple of pillars, which, together with two smaller pillars in each angle and six strong corbels built into the walls in the intervening spaces, sup port the quadripartite vaults, the ribs being richly moulded. The pillars are incrusted with " mosaics, intended without doubt to hide the defects of the stone." The room is lighted by three large round- headed windows in its eastern wall. On the western side, adjoining the cloister, is a range of five hand some arches of equal width (about 7 feet).1 The 1 There were five similar but quite plain arches at Winchester. 192 Some Notes on Chapter-Houses middle arch, which is somewhat higher than the others, is the doorway to the chapter-house. The arches are richly and heavily moulded, with a carved hood-mould over each, and are of two orders. They are supported by strong piers with engaged columns ; the abaci are large and the carved capitals deep, and the bases rest upon the low wall (3 feet thick) which alone separates the chapter-house from the cloister. An opening, glazed or otherwise, on either side of the chapter-house door is common enough in England. We have a good instance at Chester (before both the vestibule and the chapter-house). But the wide openings at V^zelay make the chapter house there much less private than any of our English chapter-houses- At the present time the room is filled with benches which face the altar standing beneath the central east window, and it is apparently used only as a chapel. How long the altar has stood there we have no means of knowing. The alley of the cloister, which remains, was rebuilt in the thirteenth century, and has been restored by Viollet-le-Duc. The roof is vaulted, or, at least, thick and richly moulded quarter-circular ribs stretch from the wall (at intervals of about 9 feet) to some fluted piers, which stand free, but are supported by heavy and lofty outside buttresses, each with a corresponding pier in its face. Between each but tress are three small Romanesque arches supported by double columns, which rest upon a low, thick basement wall. The cloister is covered by a roof of heavy curved tiles, and above the chapter-house is an upper hall, lighted on its east side by several round-headed windows. We must mention one more foreign chapter-house, the most noted of them all, though of the thousands of annual visitors to the " Spanish Chapel" of Santa Maria Novella at Florence probably but few realise that it was a chapter-house. Yet for over 200 years Some Notes on Chapter-Houses 193 it served that purpose, for which it was built in 1355. In 1567 Cosimo I, who worked such irre parable havoc at Santa Maria Novella, gave it to the fellow-countrymen of his Spanish wife, Eleanor of Toledo, and it was thenceforward known as the " Spanish Chapel." The story of the most interest ing church of Santa Maria Novella has been well told by the Rev. J. Wood Brown in a handsome monograph published in 1902. The Dominicans came into the possession of the church in 1221. In 1244, probably, a new chapter-house was built, but, through site exigencies, it was detached from the rest of the monastery. Shortly before 1 308 Baldas- sare Ubriachi built the convent another new chapter house, which gave upon the Great Cloister, and was known as " Capitolo del Nocentino," from its dedi cation to the worship of the Infant Jesus by the three kings. This building is still marked by a sculptured scene on its lintel representing the visit of the three kings to Bethlehem. Within half a century this chapter-house proved to be too small, and soon after 1348 (the awful plague year at Florence) a wealthy childless Florentine merchant, Mico Guidalotti by name, found the money for a third chapter-house, which Fra Jacopo Talenti built upon a somewhat awkward site, given by the convent, on the south side of what is now known as the Green Cloister.