Human Rights Journal, BPP Pro Bono Centre and BPP University

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Human Rights Journal, BPP Pro Bono Centre and BPP University HUMAN RIGHTS LAW JOURNAL 2020 V O L U M E N I N E BPP Pro Bono Centre BPP Law School BPP University London WC1R 4NY United Kingdom Copyright © 2020 BPP Pro Bono Centre No part of this publication may be reproduced, transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording or otherwise, or stored in any retrieval system of any nature, without the prior, express written permission of the BPP Pro Bono Centre and the author, to whom all requests to reproduce copyright material should be directed in writing. The opinions advanced by the contributors should not necessarily be considered reflective of those held by the Editors of the BPP Human Rights Journal, BPP Pro Bono Centre and BPP University. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure that the information contained is correct in this journal, the Editors, BPP Pro Bono Centre and BPP University do not accept any responsibility for any errors or omissions, or for any resulting consequences. This volume should be cited (2020) B.P.P.H.R.J. EDITORIAL TEAM Editors Alethea Redfern, BPTC, London Lucasta Bath, LLM, London Ryan Cooper, GDL, London Editorial Board Lucy Wildig, Solicitor and Joint Head of Pro Bono, BPP PRO BONO CENTRE Jessica Duxbury, Pro Bono Streetlaw Manager, BPP PRO BONO CENTRE CONTENTS FOREWORD ................................................................. i Baroness Helena Kennedy QC EDITORS’ NOTE .......................................................... v Alethea Redfern, Lucasta Bath and Ryan Cooper Articles AN END TO QUALIFIED IMMUNITY? .......................... 8 Kahill Sarronwala (LPC, London) CLIMATE CHANGE LITIGATION AND THE ROLE OF THE JUDICIARY: A CHALLENGE TO THE SEPARATION OF POWERS? .................................... 21 Alexander Westin Hardy (LLM, London) “[T]O HOLD IT FULLY ACCOUNTABLE UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW”: THE DEFENCE OF HUMAN RIGHTS BY THIRD-STATES IN THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE. ................................................ 33 Adam Weston (GDL, London) THE JURISDICTION PROBLEM IN BUSINESS AND HUMAN RIGHTS ADVANCES .................................... 48 Maria Shepard (GDL, London) TOWARDS AN INTERNATIONAL CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: REGIONAL TRADE AGREEMENTS AS A VEHICLE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS ................................ 57 Omar Mohamed (LLM, London) A TALE OF TWO SYSTEMS: EXTRADITION AND SECURITY IN HONG KONG ...................................... 71 Georgia-Mae Chung (BTC, Birmingham) WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD FOR ARTICLE 3 ECHR IN CASES INVOLVING THE DEPORTATION OF ILL PERSONS? .......................................................... 86 Miranda Sadler (GDL, Bristol) IMMIGRATION DETENTION: IS NOW THE TIME TO LOOK TO ALTERNATIVES? ...................................... 96 Kerrina Gray (GDL, London) RAPE MYTHS IN THE UK CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM ................................................................... 111 Isabella De Re (GDL, London) Case Commentary TO CATCH A PREDATOR: PAEDOPHILE HUNTERS AND ARTICLE 8 ....................................................... 127 Gregory Turpin (LLM, Leeds) ELGIZOULI V SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT [2020] UKSC 10: CASE SUMMARY AND ANALYSIS ..................................... 133 Oskar Butcher (GDL, London) FOREWORD BARONESS HELENA KENNEDY QC A pandemic presents huge challenges to societies - the risk of a cataclysmic death toll means that governments have to take exceptional steps. Few people of sound mind disagree. It is why virtually every nation in the world has passed Emergency Legislation to limit our freedom of assembly, curtail freedom of association, create powers to enforce rules on social distancing and quarantine and even develop apps which involve locational surveillance. The key part of this deal is that any liberties taken should not be out of all proportion to social need and the powers should be time limited and circumscribed. The problem is that this contagion coincides with another contagion – the rise of populism and authoritarianism. Under the flag of the pandemic, or using it as a distraction, many of the world’s new style “illiberal democrats” have seized the moment. The escalation of human rights abuse is truly i alarming. Horrifying, in fact. This year has seen the implementation of the National Security Law in Hong Kong, the rise of extreme religious conservatism and fascism in Hungary and Poland, crisis in Belarus as Lukashenko holds on to power and the continued assault against the legal profession and journalists worldwide. Across the Middle East and North Africa, in Pakistan and India, through Europe and the United States there has been an explosion of reported abuse and escalating violence against women behind closed doors. Police and military forces are using the virus as a pretext to round up dissidents. In the Philippines, President Duterte has given the instruction to shoot dead anyone breaking the lockdown rules. Throughout India the opportunity to turn on Muslims has been seized. Thousands of Uiyghur Muslims in China are locked up in concentration camps, with almost no accountability for the Chinese authorities. Even in the United Kingdom, the UK Government intends to break international law with the Internal Market Bill. A disregard for the rule of law has become a global issue. It would be all too easy to lay to one side the stealthy erosion of the Rule of Law and to think these abuses of human rights are not our problem. But this is another kind of contagion and it seeps into people’s hearts and minds and eventually it feeds on the body politic. To be silent and turn a blind eye is to be complicit. ii This is why I am grateful to be able to provide the foreword to this year’s BPP Human Rights Journal and introduce a series of articles by young lawyers with a great concern for the world’s human rights issues. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, whose recent death is a great source of sadness to us all, once said when asked about “post-truth” politics, that “when the pendulum swings too far in one direction it will go back”. The reason we have faith that the pendulum will swing back, and once again there will be global respect for the rule of law and human rights, is because of the young lawyers like those featured in this journal who are shocked by what they see in the world and become determined to bring about change. The breadth of issues covered in this issue speaks to the many ills seen round the world, from the increase in China’s control over Hong Kong to the additional plight faced by those in immigration detention throughout the crisis, and the ways in which the law must step in to correct such ills, such as the defence of Human Rights by Third States in the International Court of Justice. iii iv EDITORS’ NOTE It gives us great pleasure to present BPP Law School’s 2020 Human Rights Law Journal. Now in its eighth edition, the Journal was founded in 2008 by the Human Rights Unit, a student-led society within BPP University which organises events raising awareness of human rights around the world, as well as helping students become involved with related projects and initiatives. The Journal went out of print after 2017. Although 2020 has brought unprecedented disruption and difficulties, it also gave our editorial team a unique and unexpected opportunity to bring it back. Previous editions emphasised that human rights issues do not stop at borders. They explored domestic troubles, from Brexit to the devastating effects of legal aid cuts, and brought readers closer to understanding international problems such as Australia’s immigration system, torture in the United States, and airstrikes in Afghanistan. Human rights issues do not stop for pandemics, either. Amid an onslaught of COVID-19 coverage, other major stories have at times been overlooked. The articles in this edition – divided into domestic v and international topics for the first time to highlight the Journal’s global scope – address this oversight. On the international plane, Georgia-Mae Chung and Kahill Sarronwala go behind the protest lines to explain how Chinese extradition legislation and the doctrine of qualified immunity triggered unrest in Hong Kong and the United States. Other commentators assess possible mechanisms for enforcing human rights obligations. Alexander Westin Hardy considers the rise of climate change litigation, Adam Weston takes a close look at third- state intervention on human rights issues at the International Court of Justice, and Omar Mohamed examines the possibilities of a new generation of Regional Trade Agreements. In a similar vein, Maria Shepherd suggests that direct extra-territorial obligations might be help hold international businesses to account. Turning towards the United Kingdom and the European Union, Miranda Sadler questions what the future holds for cases involving the deportation of seriously ill persons, while Kerrina Gray asks examines the flaws of immigration detention exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic”. In light of concerning prosecution figures released by the Crown Prosecution Service earlier this year, Isabella Da Re surveys the ongoing impact of a selection of rape myths on our criminal justice system. vi Two contributors offer summaries of recent cases. Oscar Butcher overviews the first Supreme Court judgment on the Data Protection Act, notable for its consideration of the legality of handing over information to countries which use the death penalty. Gregory Turpin outlines another case in which the Supreme Court considered whether evidence gathered by online “paedophile hunters” can be used at trial. The pandemic exemplifies
Recommended publications
  • 12 Page Template
    Miscarriages of JusticeUK (MOJUK) 22 Berners St, Birmingham B19 2DR arguments, potentially divergent decisions, and the attendant risk of inconsistency and incoherence, Tele: 0121- 507 0844 Email: [email protected] Web: www.mojuk.org.uk such decisions should be reviewed only where there is sufficient reason to do so: for example, where there has been a material change of circumstances. In the present case, the High Court took full account MOJUK: Newsletter ‘Inside Out’ No 826 (23/12/2020) - Cost £1 of the arguments made on behalf of the appellant and reached a decision which reflected established practice. The question of whether the respondent falls within the scope of the practice described in New Judgment: R (on the application of Gourlay) v Parole Board [2020] UKSC 50 Davies is itself a matter of practice: it is not determined abstractly or on the basis of definitions used for The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed this appeal concerning the role of the Court other purposes, such as the meaning given to the expression “court or tribunal” in the European in relation to the principles governing the award of costs in lower courts. The appellant is a pris- Convention on Human Rights. There is nothing in the Judge’s reasoning which was erroneous in law, or oner serving a life sentence, the minimum term of which has expired. In 2014, the respondent with which the Supreme Court would consider it appropriate to interfere as a matter of practice. decided not to direct his release on licence and not to recommend his transfer to open prison The Court of Appeal also did not commit any error of law.
    [Show full text]
  • Battle Against the Bug Asia’S Ght to Contain Covid-19
    Malaysia’s political turmoil Rohingyas’ grim future Parasite’s Oscar win MCI(P) 087/05/2019 Best New Print Product and Best News Brand in Asia-Pacic, International News Media Association (INMA) Global Media Awards 2019 Battle against the bug Asia’s ght to contain Covid-19 Countries race against time to contain the spread of coronavirus infections as fears mount of further escalation, with no sign of a vaccine or cure yet WE BRING YOU SINGAPORE AND THE WORLD UP TO DATE IN THE KNOW News | Live blog | Mobile pushes Web specials | Newsletters | Microsites WhatsApp | SMS Special Features IN THE LOOP ON THE WATCH Facebook | Twitter | Instagram Videos | FB live | Live streams To subscribe to the free newsletters, go to str.sg/newsletters All newsletters connect you to stories on our straitstimes.com website. Data Digest Bats: furry friends or calamitous carriers? SUPPOSEDLY ORIGINATING IN THE HUANAN WHOLESALE On Jan 23, a team led by coronavirus specialist Shi Zheng-Li at Seafood Market in Wuhan, the deadly Covid-19 outbreak has the Wuhan Institute of Virology, reported on life science archive opened a pandora’s box around the trade of illegal wildlife and bioRxiv that the Covid-19 sequence was 96.2 per cent similar to the sale of exotic animals. a bat virus and had 79.5 per cent similarity to the coronavirus Live wolf pups, civets, hedgehogs, salamanders and crocodiles that caused severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars). were among many listed on an inventory at one of the market’s Further findings in the Chinese Medical Journal also discovered shops, said The Guardian newspaper.
    [Show full text]
  • GHB, GBL & Related Compounds: Literature Review
    ACMD Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs An assessment of the harms of gamma-hydroxybutyric acid (GHB), gamma-butyrolactone (GBL), and closely related compounds November 2020 1 Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 4 2. Previous ACMD advice and legal status of GHBRS- UK ..................................................... 5 3. Chemistry and pharmacology ................................................................................................... 7 GHB ................................................................................................................................................... 7 GBL.................................................................................................................................................... 8 1,4-BD ............................................................................................................................................... 8 GHV/GVL .......................................................................................................................................... 9 4. Therapeutic and other legitimate uses of GHBRS ............................................................... 10 Therapeutic uses ........................................................................................................................... 10 Industrial/commercial uses .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Highlights: Developments
    Highlights: Accountability: • Facebook has objected to a request from the Gambia to release posts and communications by members of Myanmar’s military and police for use in the genocide case against Myanmar at the ICC, arguing this would violate US law. International Support: • Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has pledged to provide $329 million in aid to Bangladesh for combating the coronavirus pandemic and has promised to talk with Myanmar to end the Rohingya crisis. High-level Statements: • Malaysia Foreign Minister Hishammuddin Hussein said he has requested the US to assist Malaysia in discussions with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees over the Rohingya refugee issue. • Myanmar’s leader Aung San Suu Kyi has formally declared her intention to seek a second term in November’s election. Developments: FB rejects Gambian plea to release Myanmar officials’ data New Age Bangladesh (August 7) Facebook has objected to a request from Gambia, which has accused Myanmar at the World Court of genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority, to release posts and communications by members of Myanmar’s military and police. The social media giant urged the US District Court for the District of Columbia on August 4 to reject the demand, which it said would violate US law. Facebook has said it is working to block hate speech. On August 6, a spokesperson said Facebook ‘stands against hate and violence, including in Myanmar.’ Similar: Facebook rejects request to release Myanmar officials’ data for genocide case BDNews24 (August 6) Facebook
    [Show full text]
  • Erga Omnes Partes Before the International Court of Justice: from Standing to Judgment on the Merits
    ERGA OMNES PARTES BEFORE THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE: FROM STANDING TO JUDGMENT ON THE MERITS Nawi Ukabiala, Duncan Pickard & Alyssa Yamamoto* I. STRATEGIC CONSIDERATIONS BEFORE INSTITUTING PROCEEDINGS ..... ...........................................................................................................236 II. LEGAL STANDARDS ON THE MERITS ................................................238 III. MARSHALLING EVIDENCE ................................................................241 A. Documentary Evidence.................................................................243 B. Third-Party Reporting..................................................................244 1. UN Fact-Finding ......................................................................244 2. NGO Fact-Finding ...................................................................246 C. Witness Evidence ..........................................................................246 D. Proceedings of Other Adjudicatory Bodies..................................248 E. Judicial Intervention.....................................................................249 IV. CONCLUSION .....................................................................................250 In its landmark order on provisional measures in Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (The Gambia v. Myanmar) (The Gambia v. Myanmar), the International Court of Justice (ICJ, or the Court) held that The Gambia had prima facie standing before the Court
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Restrictions on Relations with Burma
    U.S. Restrictions on Relations with Burma Updated March 18, 2020 Congressional Research Service https://crsreports.congress.gov R44570 U.S. Restrictions on Relations with Burma Summary Major changes in Burma’s political situation since 2016 have raised questions among some Members of Congress concerning the appropriateness of U.S. policy toward Burma (Myanmar) in general, and the current restrictions on relations with Burma in particular. During the time Burma was under military rule (1962–2011), restrictions were placed on bilateral relations in an attempt to encourage the Burmese military, or Tatmadaw, to permit the restoration of democracy. In November 2015, Burma held nationwide parliamentary elections from which Aung San Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy (NLD) emerged as the party with an absolute majority in both chambers of Burma’s parliament. The new government subsequently appointed Aung San Suu Kyi to the newly created position of State Counselor, as well as Foreign Minister. While the NLD controls the parliament and the executive branch, the Tatmadaw continues to exercise significant power under provisions of Burma’s 2008 constitution, impeding potential progress towards the re-establishment of a democratically-elected civilian government in Burma. On October 7, 2016, after consultation with Aung San Suu Kyi, former President Obama revoked several executive orders pertaining to sanctions on Burma, and waived restrictions required by Section 5(b) of the Tom Lantos Block Burmese JADE (Junta Anti-Democratic Efforts) Act of 2008 (P.L. 110-286), removing most of the economic restrictions on relations with Burma. On December 2, 2016, he issued Presidential Determination 2017-04, ending some restrictions on U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Reconstruction of Life Imprisonment in Prison System in Indonesia
    Jurnal Daulat Hukum Reconstruction of Life Imprisonment in Prison... Volume 2 Issue 4, December 2019 (Boma Wira Gumilar) ISSN: 2614-560X Reconstruction of Life Imprisonment in Prison System in Indonesia Boma Wira Gumilar1, Gunarto2 and Akhmad Khisni3 Abstract. The most important part in a Book of Criminal Law (Penal Code) is a prison, because the prison contains rules about the size and implementation of the criminal. The position of life imprisonment in the national criminal justice system is still considered relevant as a means of crime prevention, it can be seen from the number of offenses punishable with life imprisonment. However, life imprisonment is considered contrary to the penal system. This study aims to investigate the implementation of life imprisonment, weaknesses, and the solution in the future. The approach used in the study is a non-doctrinal legal research with socio-legal research types (Juridical Sociological). The results of research studies show that life imprisonment is contrary to prison system, and life imprisonment become an obstacle to fostering convicts back into society. Bill Criminal Code of September 2019 can be used as a solution to life imprisonment change in the future. Presented advice, in order to be disseminated to the application of the criminal purpose of the Criminal Code of Prison adopted in the future, so that the public and experts no longer make the criminal as a form of retaliation. Keywords: Reconstruction; Crime; Prison; Life Imprisonment; System; Corrections. 1. Introduction The law is the overall norms of life, develop, and apply in social life which contains the commands and prohibitions that take care of the order of a society.
    [Show full text]
  • Developments
    Highlights: Accountability: • Rohingya and Latin American human rights groups filed a lawsuit against Aung San Suu Kyi and several top Myanmar officials for crimes against Rohingya Muslims in Argentina under the principle of "universal jurisdiction." • The Gambia filed a lawsuit at the International Court of Justice accusing Myanmar of genocide against the Rohingya. • The International Criminal Court approved the probe into Myanmar's alleged crimes against the Rohingya. • The United Nations General Assembly adopted the resolution on the “Situation of human rights of Rohingya Muslims and other minorities in Myanmar”, asking Myanmar to ensure safe, sustainable Rohingya return. High-level Statements: • Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has again said that Rohingya refugees are a “threat to the security” of the entire region, and has urged the global community to resolve the issue. • The British High Commissioner to Bangladesh Robert Chatterton Dickson has expressed hope about a sustainable solution to the Rohingya crisis as soon as possible. Country Visits: • The president of the World Food Programme Executive Board Bureau H E Hisham Mohamed Moustafa Badr visited the visited Cox's Bazar refugee camps. • Arab film and TV star and World Food Programme (WFP) Goodwill Ambassador Hend Sabry visited the camps in Cox's Bazar. Developments: Envoy: China involved from day one to find Rohingya solution Dhaka Tribune (November 17) Chinese Ambassador to Bangladesh Li Jiming has said his country remains involved to find out a solution of the Rohingya issue. The ambassador was addressing a function at the Chinese Embassy in Dhaka marking the formation of a Chinese medical team, with support from the Chinese Yunnan Province, to be sent to Cox’s Bazar to help the host community as well the Rohingyas.
    [Show full text]
  • Developments
    Highlights: Accountability: • The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ordered measures to prevent the genocide of Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar. The panel of 17 judges at the ICJ voted unanimously to order Myanmar to take "all measures within its power" to prevent genocide. • An independent panel created by the Myanmar government has concluded that government security forces committed war crimes against Rohingya Muslims but that they did not commit genocide against the ethnic minority. In Myanmar: • Two women were killed, and seven other people injured, after Myanmar troops shelled a Rohingya village on Saturday. High-level statements: • Newly-appointed Japanese Ambassador to Bangladesh Naoki Ito has said Japan is ready to extend any kind of assistance in resolving the Rohingya crisis, as the country wants a sustainable solution to the problem. Country visits: • A delegation from Australia visited Bangladesh this week. • UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Myanmar, Yanghee Lee, conducted her final visit to Bangladesh under her mandate this week, issuing a number of statements regarding the situation in Myanmar at the end of her trip. Developments: China, Russia require revising Rohingya strategy New Age Bangladesh (January 26) The claim of jurisdiction by the International Court of Justice in Rohingya genocide case would require concerned countries, especially Russia and China, to revise their strategies over Rohingya issue, said immediate-past foreign secretary M Shahidul Haque at a discussion at North South University in Dhaka this weekend. UN Security Council members China and Russia were now expected to act as responsible states, said Shahidul, currently senior fellow at North South University’s Center for Peace Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Semantic and Morphological Techniques of Psychopaths in Dark Matter Youtube Channel
    CALL – Vol. 2, No. 2, December 2020, pp. 152-166 SEMANTIC AND MORPHOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES OF PSYCHOPATHS IN DARK MATTER YOUTUBE CHANNEL Indah Maria Ulfa1 and Rohmani Nur Indah2 Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim1, Malang, [email protected] Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim1, Malang, [email protected] ABSTRACT The brain of psychopaths may differ from normal individuals in terms of their cerebral organization of language. Psychopaths have a different way of communicating their ideas within their minds. There is a distinct technique of psychopathic language which can be identified. Therefore, this study examines the kinds of speech technique of psychopaths. It aims at discovering the semantic and morphological techniques used by four psychopaths in the Dark Matter YouTube channel. Methodologically, this study is categorized as descriptive qualitative research. The data were in the form of utterances by four psychopaths in Dark Matter channel posted on October 10, 2019. There were sixteen data in the form of utterances which contained kinds of the speech technique used by psychopaths. The researchers calculated the data by observing, transcribing, describing and analyzing the speech of psychopaths in the Dark Matter channel. Further, the data were classified by using Timor and Weiss (2008) patterns of psychopathic knowledge. The results showed that four psychopathic individuals demonstrated the kinds of the speech technique, which has a distinct pattern using semantic and morphological techniques. Based on semantic technique, all categories found in the data are vocabulary, repetition, figurative language, positive and negative connotations, and anaphora. The result also shows three categories of morphological techniques: nominalization, passivization, and first- person plural.
    [Show full text]
  • US Top Official Denies Decision to Leave Iraq
    COMMUNITY | Pages 4-5 SPORT | Page 1 War epic Bublik 1917 wins causes best fi rst shock drama fi lm in Qatar, Golden Verdasco Globe advances published in QATAR since 1978 TUESDAY Vol. XXXX No. 11420 January 7, 2020 Jumada I 12, 1441 AH GULF TIMES www. gulf-times.com 2 Riyals Protest against Ugandan pop-star MP’s arrest In brief US top offi cial QATAR | Phone call Amir, Mahdi discuss denies decision Iraq developments His Highness the Amir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani held yesterday evening a telephone conversation to leave Iraq with Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi. During the phone call, they discussed the developments in Iraq and eff orts being made to reduce Earlier reports said US has notified tension to maintain security and Baghdad of its troop withdrawal stability in the country and the entire region. for onward movement,” read a letter ARAB WORLD | Confl ict AFP/Reuters Washington/Baghdad from United States Marine Corps Brig- UN Libya envoy blames adier General William H Seely III, the commanding general of Task Force Iraq strike on Haft ar ally S Defence Secretary Mark Es- to his Iraqi counterpart. The United Nations Libya envoy per denied yesterday that US The authenticity of the letter, which said yesterday that a country Uforces would pull out of Iraq, was addressed to the Iraqi defence supporting commander Khalifa Supporters of Ugandan singer-turned-politician Robert Kyagulanyi aka Bobi Wine react near a police station after after a US general’s letter told the Iraqi ministry’s Combined Joint Operations Haftar’s self-styled Libyan he was arrested on charges of unlawful assembly before starting his first public meeting in his constituency ahead government that troops were prepar- Baghdad, was confi rmed to Reuters National Army (LNA) was likely of presidential election next year in Kasangati town, suburb of Kampala yesterday.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ethics of Humanitarian Intervention: the Rohingya and Uighurs’ Leviathan, 11 (1), 49 - 54 the Ethics of Humanitarian Intervention: the Rohingya and Uighurs
    Kichmann, S. (2020) ‘The ethics of humanitarian intervention: the Rohingya and Uighurs’ Leviathan, 11 (1), 49 - 54 The ethics of humanitarian intervention: the Rohingya and Uighurs Samantha Kichmann explores the ethical and political factors at play in an analysis of international humanitarian intervention through a case study of the Uighurs and Rohingya. urrently, there are two particularly pressing human rights crises attracting international attention: the state-sponsored persecution of Uighurs in China and of the Rohingya in Myanmar. Both groups are CMuslim ethnic minorities who claim victimhood of various abuses at the hands of their governments. The Uighurs are an indigenous Turkic people hailing from the Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region, with a historically complicated relationship with China: the Uighurs have expressed a desire for independence since the 1980s, while Beijing claims that Uighur nationalists have resorted to terrorism against the government (Terhune & Jonathon 2016, 142-144). In Xinjiang, at least one million Uighurs are detained in ‘re-education camps’ that Western powers can observe only via satellite imaging (Perlez 2019). Meanwhile, in Myanmar, the Rohingya have long been an oppressed minority, frequently subject to detention in internally displaced persons camps and to direct and structural violence, including ethnic cleansing and cultural genocide (Kingston 2015, 1167). Both cases raise the question of whether intervention is necessary and, if so, who has the responsibility and ability to intervene. The liberal West has long considered humanitarian intervention to be an essential duty (Pattison 2002, 268), but how can interventions take place without taking the form of Western-centric neo- imperialism or an imposition of Western interests over local ones? In an attempt to answer this question, we will review relevant tenets of just war theory and Mutua’s ‘Savage-Victim-Saviour’ conception of universal human rights in an attempt to define ethical intervention and bound it within a theoretical framework.
    [Show full text]