Origin of Kashmir Conflict and Its Complexities Malik Zahra Khalid
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
P: ISSN NO.: 2394-0344 RNI No.UPBIL/2016/67980 VOL-3* ISSUE-5* (Part-1) August- 2018 E: ISSN NO.: 2455-0817 Remarking An Analisation Origin of Kashmir Conflict and its Complexities Abstract Kashmir has a long and chequered history which has been divided by the historians in different periods like Hindu, Buddhist and Muslim periods of rule. The paper attempts to trace out the roots of present trouble as the unrest of 2016 has once more shown that the entire phases of protest are embedded in the history of Kashmir. From Burhan Wani killing to annexation by Mughals there are many important historical milestones which fill the dots to understand the real picture of trouble. The present deep rooted resistance has its traces in the long period of subjugation in which people of Kashmir witnessed change of rulers but no change in the rules of subjugation. From the autocratic rules to the democratically elected governments, the sense of alienation has become a new norm of life in the present days and it is only getting expressed with more anger and violence on streets of Kashmir. Various authors have shown some important windows of history to understand Malik Zahra Khalid this conflict in its totality and this paper has tried to connect some Sr. Assistant Professor, important milestones of Kashmir history to make readers understand Deptt.of Media Education Research some of the hidden aspects of the conflict. Centre, Keywords: Mughals, Freedom Struggle, Dogra Rulers, Muslim Uprising, University of Kashmir, Two Nation Theory, Agenda of Alliance. Kashmir Introduction Kashmir‟s sovereignty remained intact despite many upheavals in the past. It was Akbar‟s plans to annex all the principality around Mughal Empire that Kashmir was also pouched by Mughals. First they tied with military expeditions to annex Kashmir. Three attempts by Mughal army to take Srinagar were firmly repulsed by then rulers of Kashmir- The Chaks. Chaks were having a strong army of their own tribe which comprised of old Dardistan arch of undivided Jammu and Kashmir and was one of the finest armies to fight any external aggression. Mughals then worked on plan B, to befriend Chaks and bring them under pressure by continuous army aggression and finally bring them under kneels of great Mughal Empire. The last independent king of Kashmir Yousuf Shah Chak who was taken to durbar of Akbar was jailed and finally Mughals entered Srinagar and conquered Kashmir. Thus sovereignty of Kashmir was over and despite yearning of its country men to get back their freedom has eluded them so far. More and more efforts to revive the past has inflicted more tragedies and miseries on the people of Kashmir. The present unrest can be linked Aaliya Ahmed to the lost sovereignty to Mughals and the quest for sovereignty and Sr. Assistant Professor, freedom continues to live in the hearts and minds of Kashmiris even in the year 2017. Deptt.of Media Education Research The unrest of 2016 and its spill over in the year 2017 in Kashmir Centre, valley is not a bubble created by Burhan Wani killing on July, 8. It is no University of Kashmir, isolated uprising but has beneath it veins and roots, nourished by its tragic Kashmir history. The Kashmir problem in present context can only be understood when we go deeper into its history and try to trace the roots of this problem. Aim of the Study The aim of the study is to search for the context, for the present growing unrest and joining of local youth to militancy. The study is an effort to find the roots of the present problem of Kashmir and to throw light on such grey areas of the problem which hitherto have remained in oblivion. The study has tried to show the urgency and importance for the resolution of Kashmir dispute by dialogue and reconciliation and highlighted the ill effects of this pestering wound on the progress of entire South Asian region. The Indo-Pak stalemate in Kashmir has eroded the space for the pro-India politics in Kashmir and is virtually pushing the youth to the radicalization. The study has tried to show the real historical baggage of the problem and has attempted to show the real contours of the problem so that it helps in conflict resolution. 158 P: ISSN NO.: 2394-0344 RNI No.UPBIL/2016/67980 VOL-3* ISSUE-5* (Part-1) August- 2018 E: ISSN NO.: 2455-0817 Remarking An Analisation Review of Literature of governance and institutions failing to deliver have A number of books and articles have been been dealt with in a lucid and comprehensive manner written on the Kashmir conflict. This review of by Louis Kriesberg and Bruce Dayton in their seminal literature presents a snapshot of some important work titled „Constructive Conflicts: From Escalation to related works.‟ India, Pakistan and the Kashmir Resolution‟. Drawing its analysis from the cyclical Dispute‟ by Robert G.Wirsing (1994) looks at almost nature of conflicts, the book seeks to interrogate every detail of the Kashmir conflict, starting from the conflict in a multi-dimensional way. It has looked at very context of the issue to boundary intricacies. A conflict from every angle, and has gained its significant analysis, it however focuses less on the relevance from the episodes of violence, collective issue of self-determination of Kashmir. Another resistance, and incidents of violent mass protests eminent author, a British historian Alastair Lamb in his such as those in Kashmir. book “Kashmir: A Disputed Legacy, 1984-90” (1991) Victoria Schofield.(2003) in „Kashmir in argues about the veracity of the Instrument of Conflict: India, Pakistan and the Unending War‟ Accession and concludes that it was not signed by presents a vivid account of the genesis of the dispute. Maharaja Hari Singh of Kashmir on 26th of October Starting from early Hindu rule to subsequent Muslim 1947, a day before the Indian troops arrived in the rule, the valley finally went under the tyrannical rule of Kashmir Valley to defend Kashmir against the raiders Dogras. Maharaja Hari Singh signed the instrument of from the Northwest Province of Pakistan. Lamb accession with the India following the tribal invasion, argues that not only India‟s legal claim to the state of which has itself been the subject of controversy. Jammu and Kashmir is fraudulent but that the Schofield elaborates that the will of the people of accession was the outcome of a conspiracy between Kashmir to decide their own fate as mentioned in the INC leaders, the Maharaja‟s government and senior instrument of accession was never ascertained. Indian army officers including some British. Kashmir under Mughal Suzerainty In „Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Paths to Although historically it was 1557 which is the Peace‟, Sumantra Bose (2003) analyses how owing basic milestone to understand the subjugation and the its chequered history and the resonance of the clash search for freedom among the people of Kashmir. In of multi faceted interests and a distinct lack of political this period Mughals were able to annex Kashmir consensus, the state of J&K is no longer a simple largely by deceit as the last independent king of issue, politically or ideologically. Whether it be the de Jammu and Kashmir Yousuf Shah Chak was taken to facto sovereignty of India and Pakistan over their court of Akbar with honor and respect by Raja respective parts of the state, or the jurisdictions Bhagwan Das for an honorable settlement, was therein, or simply the grievances and aspirations of a imprisoned subsequently released given the title of politically alienated populace, only an accommodative „Panch Hazari‟, to look after Bihar province, where he compromise of hitherto fore unimagined proportions died along with his poetess wife Habba Khatoon in will see any meaningful end to this conflict. In his wilderness (Aatish-e-Chinar, by Sheikh Mohammad writings, Sumantra Bose has highlighted the plight of Abdullah) .The government of Jammu and Kashmir in the state time and again. Pakistan‟s support, for mid-1970‟s was able to trace the grave of last instance has been documented in „National Ideologies independent king of Kashmir Yousuf Shah Chak along and the Kashmir Conflict‟ in 2009. Since the most with his wife Habba Khattoon at Biswak, Bihar. powerful voice was that of Sheikh Abdullah and his Former secretary of J&K Cultural Academy National Conference, which had secular credentials Mohammed Yousuf Taing went to Bihar at the as a party, it would literally be the icing on the Indian insistence of then Chief Minister late Sheikh cake; hence the Indian interest. This step taken at the Mohammad Abdullah to trace the grave of Yousuf nascent stages of nationhood by both countries has Shah Chak. Finally J&K government installed an resulted in a conflict obituary on the stone at his grave showing the roots of Balraj Puri in a provocative article on the dispute and the endurance of Kashmiris to look for ”Kashmir and Rest of India: First Emotional Rupture‟ their lost freedom and liberty. (Interview of (2003) brings to light the first emotional rupture Mohammad Yousuf Taing with Noor-ul-Qamrain for between the Kashmir and rest of India to the Sheikh DDK, Srinagar, 1994). Abdullah's arrest in August 1953. There was always a After the Mughals it has been only more and contradiction between Indian democracy and the more subjugation with more iron fist than any regimented Kashmir, between monolithic Kashmiri accommodation of wishes and aspirations of nationalism and the regional aspirations of Jammu Kashmiris. Courts changed from Delhi to Lahore to and Ladakh which exploded with the Sheikh's arrest.