DOCSLIB.ORG

THE PARTICIPATORY COMPLEX Participation As Ideology in The

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
THE PARTICIPATORY COMPLEX Participation As Ideology in The THE PARTICIPATORY COMPLEX Participation as Ideology in the Neoliberal Era Cayley Sorochan Art History & Communication Studies McGill University, Montreal October 2017 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of PhD © Cayley Sorochan 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT…………………………………………………………………………………...iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS………………………………………………………………vii PREFACE……………………………………………………………………………………..xi INTRODUCTION: THE PARTICIPATORY COMPLEX………………………..1 Sites of Analysis…………………………………………………………………………………11 CHAPTER ONE: PARTICIPATION AS IDEOLOGY...........................................25 An Imaginary Lived Relation................................................................................................26 Consumer Capitalism: Participation as Desublimation………..…………………………28 Enjoyment: Participation as point-de-capiton……..……………………………………...30 Neoliberalism and subjectivity..……..……………..……………………………………………32 The Participatory Complex……………………………...……………………………………….43 Activity, Passivity, Interpassivity..........................................................................................44 Structure, Procedure, Process……………...……………………………………………...47 Immediacy, Anti-representation……………..…………………………………………….49 Physical Presence: Face-to-Face and Bodily Co-presence………………………...……..51 Inclusion, Pluralism…………………..…………………………………………………...54 Consensus……………………………………..…………………………………………..56 Personalization as Empowerment……………………………………..………………….58 CHAPTER TWO: PARTICIPATION IN ACTIVISM……………………………67 Postwar Participation and the Vanishing Mediator of Direct Democracy……………………….70 The Radical Implications of Participatory Democracy……………………………………..……82 Occupy Wall Street: Genuine Democracy or Class Division?......................................................86 Participation as Ideology……………………………..………………………………………….90 Structure/Process/Procedures over Ends……...…………………………………………..92 Inclusivity or Openness………………………………………………..…………………..95 Anti-representational Attitudes………………………………………………..…………..97 Occupy or Reject Power?.............................................................................................................100 Participation in the Quebec Student Strike……………….…………………………………….101 CLASSE: The Organization Behind the Strike………………….……………………………..103 Syndicalist Ideology in the Student Movement…………………………………………….…..107 Democracy Beyond Deliberation: Cohesion, Combativeness and Solidarity………..………...112 Limits on Inclusion: common interests and ideological coherence……..……………….112 Dialogue as a path to Decision: The Destabilizing Potential of a Non-Negotiable Demand…………………………………………………………………………………..116 Neighbourhood Assemblies and the Difficulty of Expanding the Movement………….....121 The Movement Today……………………………………………………………..……………124 Conclusion: The Role of Participation in Social Movements………………….……………….125 ii CHAPTER THREE: PARTICIPATION AT WORK……………………………139 The Emergence of Participation at Work: Participation, Motivation and a More Humane Capitalism…………………………………………………………….………………………...145 The 1980s: Participation Is Disciplined by the Market……………….………………………..150 A Brief History of Unconferences……………………………..……………………………….155 The Rules of Bar Camp……………………………...………………………………………….160 The Projective City: From Institutional Hierarchy to the Ideology of the Project………….….168 Bar Camps and the Projective City……………………………………………………………..174 The Influence of F/OSS Ideology on Bar Camps……………………………………………....178 Enjoyment: The Unwritten Rules of Bar Camp Ideology………………….…………………..183 Passion and Enthusiasm: Enjoy(!) Work Camp…………………...……………………..185 Activity Over Passivity: Pragmatic Activity, “Useful Information” and Scarcity of Time………………………………………………………………………………………191 Refusing the Law of Participation: A Repressive Consensus?...........................................196 Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………….………..201 CHAPTER FOUR: PARTICIPATION IN ART…………………………………..215 An Ethics of the Demand: Dialogue and Social Amelioration as Ethical Standards…………...219 Bishop’s Critique: Aesthetics Beyond Ethics, the Secondary Audience and Lacanian Desire…………………………………………………………………………………………...230 To Be of Use: Superflex’s Tools of Participation and Market Utopia……………..…………..238 An Ethics of Desire: Activist Art and Deterritorializing Machines……………..……………..254 Papas Fritas: Interventionist Alternatives, Counter-Stabilization, and Revolutionary Drive……………………………………………………………………………………………263 Conclusion……………………………………….……………………………………………..274 CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………………….....286 BIBLIOGRAPHY…………………………………………………………………………299 iii ABSTRACT Participation has a particular ideological function in the context of digital networks. Approaching participation as a complex of values rather that a particular form of decision making or organizational structure, this dissertation analyzes a range of contemporary practices that embrace participation as an ideal. Such practices include social movements, open conferencing events in the knowledge and IT industries, and social practice art. Through these sites I seek to clarify the way that participation operates in terms of what Slavoj Žižek refers to as a mode of “enjoyment.” While in all cases participation is presented as a path towards progress or emancipation, this widespread assumption has led to the restructuring of social relations in a fashion that is not incompatible with capitalist exploitation. The dissertation explores the paradox that exploitation presents to social actors who place their hopes in participation as a primary principle in their vision of social transformation. I argue that our attachment to participatory values is an impasse to radical political organization and our capacity to build democratic power. In contrast to the conflation of participation with democracy in the radical imagination, I argue that participation today operates as a complex of values that has become uncoupled from direct democratic practices. The “participatory complex,” as I define it, includes: a valuation of activity over passivity; the privileging of procedure or structure over ends; a desire for immediacy and anti-representational attitudes; the privileging of face-to-face encounters or bodily co-presence; an orientation towards inclusiveness and pluralism; a will to consensus; and discourses of empowerment through personalization. iv RÉSUMÉ La participation détient une fonction idéologique dans le contexte des réseaux sociaux numériques. Cette thèse étudie la participation comme un complexe de valeurs et non comme une façon de prendre des décisions ou comme une structure organisationnelle. Ainsi, je m’emploie à analyser une série de pratiques contemporaines qui prônent une vision idéalisée de la participation. Parmi les pratiques qui idéalisent la participation on peut compter : les mouvements sociaux, les conférences ouvertes au public dans les industries du savoir et des nouvelles technologies (TIC) ainsi que l’art engagé. L’étude des diverses conceptions que l’on se fait de la participation au sein de ces domaines permet d’observer comment la participation opère selon les modalités de ce que Slavoj Žižek appelle la « jouissance ». Si dans tous ces cas de figure la participation représente le progrès et l’émancipation, une telle conception de la participation contribue néanmoins à une restructuration des relations sociales qui n’est pas sans rappeler la logique d’exploitation du capitalisme. Cette thèse examine le paradoxe que pose l’exploitation pour les acteurs sociaux qui avaient misé sur la participation en tant que principe fondateur du changement social qu’ils envisageaient. Je soutiens que notre attachement aux valeurs participatives représente une impasse pour la constitution de mouvements politiques radicaux et entrave notre capacité de bâtir un pouvoir démocratique. A l’opposé de l’imaginaire radical qui présuppose un amalgame entre participation et démocratie, j’affirme qu’aujourd’hui la participation opère selon un complexe de valeurs qui sont détachées des pratiques démocratiques directes. Ce que j’ai nommé « complexe de participation » comprend : une valorisation de l’activité au détriment de la passivité ; un intérêt marqué pour les procédures ou les structures plutôt que pour les fins ; un désir d’immédiateté et l’adoption d’une posture non- représentationnelle ; une valorisation du face-à-face et de la co-présence physique ; un v mouvement vers l’inclusion et le pluralisme ; une volonté d’établir des consensus ; l’établissement de discours d’émancipation fondés sur le principe de la personalisation. vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation was made possible by the support of many colleagues, friends, and mentors who over the years have contributed in numerous ways to my thinking, to my confidence and to my general well-being. The following people have in some fashion enabled me conceive this project and to persist through to its end. I owe enormous gratitude to my supervisor Darin Barney for his unending faith in my work, his precise and thoughtful comments on drafts, for engaging in enthusiastic conversations about politics and theory, and for his generous nature, sharp intellect and readiness to lend an ear. Numerous individuals have enriched the arguments found within by sharing their insights during workshops and conference talks. My thanks to all of the participants in the Banff Research in Culture residency “On the Commons” for being supportive in the early stages of this project when my critique of participation as ideology was only a rough sketch. Their receptiveness
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Real Democracy in the Occupy Movement
    NO STABLE GROUND: REAL DEMOCRACY IN THE OCCUPY MOVEMENT ANNA SZOLUCHA PhD Thesis Department of Sociology, Maynooth University November 2014 Head of Department: Prof. Mary Corcoran Supervisor: Dr Laurence Cox Rodzicom To my Parents ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis is an outcome of many joyous and creative (sometimes also puzzling) encounters that I shared with the participants of Occupy in Ireland and the San Francisco Bay Area. I am truly indebted to you for your unending generosity, ingenuity and determination; for taking the risks (for many of us, yet again) and continuing to fight and create. It is your voices and experiences that are central to me in these pages and I hope that you will find here something that touches a part of you, not in a nostalgic way, but as an impulse to act. First and foremost, I would like to extend my heartfelt gratitude to my supervisor, Dr Laurence Cox, whose unfaltering encouragement, assistance, advice and expert knowledge were invaluable for the successful completion of this research. He was always an enormously responsive and generous mentor and his critique helped sharpen this thesis in many ways. Thank you for being supportive also in so many other areas and for ushering me in to the complex world of activist research. I am also grateful to Eddie Yuen who helped me find my way around Oakland and introduced me to many Occupy participants – your help was priceless and I really enjoyed meeting you. I wanted to thank Prof. Szymon Wróbel for debates about philosophy and conversations about life as well as for his continuing support.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nature of the Participatory Worldview Chapter 1 – the Nature of the Participatory Worldview
    The Nature of the Participatory Worldview Chapter 1 – The Nature of the Participatory Worldview Chapter 1 – The Nature of the Participatory Worldview 1) The Participatory Worldview and the Spiral of Western Civilization As we find ourselves at the beginning of the third Millennium, Western civilization faces an epochal change. This change is far more profound than the mere numerical advance of the calendar. Our secular, dualistic, reductionist view of the world -- our Mechanistic Worldview, also known as the Newtonian or Cartesian worldview -- is showing signs of old age. After 400 years of guiding our inquiry and actions, after many successes and a growing number of failures, the Mechanistic Worldview is increasingly under attack on many fronts: philosophically, ethically, spiritually, even from within itself, from the scientific and technological perspective. Our intellectual and social lives have become vastly more complicated than in past generations. Social and environmental problems are rapidly mounting, and depression and apathy seem increasingly prevalent. Unfortunately, the Mechanistic Worldview -- the source of our values, the justification for our actions, the framework upon which all our ideas are laid out -- seems less and less able to cope, and less able to provide satisfactory resolution. The time has come to deeply reexamine our present worldview, and, to the greatest degree possible, to creatively transcend it. Even though the Zeitgeist affects us all, the task of articulating a new worldview falls primarily to those philosophically-inclined thinkers of all disciplines1. Traditionally the greatest burden for this task has fallen upon the philosophers proper. Philosophers are, after all, in the business of examining things deeply, of understanding the root causes of our intellectual and emotional deficiencies, and of charting new paths for society.
    [Show full text]
  • Editor's Note Development of a Spiritual Emergency Scale
    VOLUME 45, NUMBER 2, 2013 THE JOURNAL OF TRANSPERSONAL PSYCHOLOGY Editor’s Note v Development of a Spiritual Emergency Scale 105 TABLE OF MONIKA GORETZKI CONTENTS MICHAEL THALBOURNE LANCE STORM Neo-Piagetian Transpersonal Psychology: A New Perspective 118 EDWARD J. DALE Yoga Psychotherapy: The Integration of Western Psycholog- ical Theory and Ancient Yogic Wisdom 139 MARIANA CAPLAN ADRIANA PORTILLO LYNSIE SEELY Beyond the Evolutionary Paradigm in Consciousness Studies 159 ROBIN S. BROWN Building Bridges Between Spirituality and Psychology: An Indigenous Healer’s Teachings About Befriending the Self 172 ROCKEY ROBBINS JI Y. HONG Book Reviews Wisdom of the senses: The untold story of their SAMUEL BENDECK 198 inner life. J. Herlihy SOTILLOS Awaken inside yoga meditation. J. Carrera CHANELL JARAMILLO 203 The rebirth of the hero: Mythology as a guide to JAY DUFRECHOU 204 spiritual transformation. K. Le Grice Books Our Editors are Reading 214 EDITOR Marcie Boucouvalas ASSOCIATE Douglas A. MacDonald (Research) EDITOR EDITORIAL Carla Pacalo ASSISTANT BOOK REVIEW Arthur Hastings EDITOR BOOK REVIEW Lauren Bracciodieta EDITORIAL ASSISTANT BOARD OF Paul Clemens, Nevada City, California EDITORS Jack Engler, Schiff Center, Cambridge, Massachusetts James Fadiman, Menlo Park, California Jorge Ferrer, California Institute of Integral Studies Daniel Goleman, Williamstown, Massachusetts Elmer Green, Ozawkie, Kansas Stanislav Grof, Mill Valley, California Tobin Hart, State University of West Georgia Michael Hutton, Victoria, British Columbia Stanley Krippner, San Francisco, California Irene Lazarus, Raleigh, North Carolina Lawrence LeShan, New York, New York John Levy, Mill Valley, California David Loy, Bunkyo University, Japan Francis G. Lu, San Francisco, California David Lukoff, Petaluma, California Michael Murphy, San Rafael, California Peter L.
    [Show full text]
  • Person-Centred Inquiry Into the Spiritual and the Subtle John Heron
    Sacred Science Person-centred Inquiry into the Spiritual and the Subtle John Heron Endymion Press Auckland First published as a paperback in 1998 by PCCS Books, Llangarron, Ross-on- Wye, Herefordshire, HR9 6PT, UK. Sacred Science: Person-centred Inquiry into the Spiritual and the Subtle ISBN 1 898059 21 7 British Library Cataloguing in Publication data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress catalog record available First published as an e-book at www.human-inquiry.com in 2008 by Endymion Press, South Pacific Centre for Human Inquiry, 11 Bald Hill Road, R.D.1 Kau- kapakapa, Auckland 0871, New Zealand. This e-book is a reprint of the text of the 1998 edition by arrangement with PCCS Books. Page size: 15.6 cm by 23.4 cm. Font: Times New Roman 10 pt. Other paperback books by John Heron: Participatory Spirituality, Lulu Press, 2006* Cosmic Psychology, eighth edition, Endymion Press, 2006* Living in Two Worlds, third edition, Endymion Press, 2006* Helping the Client, fifth edition, Sage Publications, 2001 The Complete Facilitator's Handbook, Kogan Page, 1999 Co-operative Inquiry, Sage Publications, 1996 Feeling and Personhood, Sage Publications, 1992 *Also available as an e-book Contents Preface x Part 1: Perspectives of lived inquiry 1 Introduction and background 1 A pioneer approach 1 A self-generating spiritual culture 2 Gender-laden perennialism 3 Religious feminism 4 The nature of the self 6 Sacred science 8 A basic quaternary of terms 8 The transpersonal, ego and person 9 Personhood,
    [Show full text]
  • Superflex Keynote Speech: If Value, Then Copy*
    Superflex Keynote Speech: If Value, Then Copy* INTRODUCTION TO SUPERFLEX Good afternoon, I hope that you are enjoying your meal and I thank the waiters and waitresses who are serving us, and the cooks in the back. Good afternoon, I am Anupam Chander. I am Director of the California International Law Center, and I am a law professor here at UC Davis. I am speaking to you on behalf of Mario Biagioli and Madhavi Sunder, my colleagues at the University of California, Davis, and also on behalf of the UC Davis Law Review. I welcome you to a keynote address for our conference titled “Brand New World: Discovering Oneself in the Global Flow.” We are delighted today to welcome Rasmus Nielsen of the internationally renowned artist-group called “Superflex.” Based in Copenhagen, Denmark, Superflex consists of Jakob Fenger, Bjørnsterne Christiansen, and Rasmus who have been collaborating together since 1993. It is hard to do justice to the work of Superflex as the range of their work is nothing less than astonishing, from creating a brand of power-drinks for an Amazonian tribe in Brazil to a television series in Vietnam on Dutch Pirates of the seventeenth century who stole a * Transcript of keynote speech by Rasmus Nielsen at the UC Davis Law Review’s Brand New World symposium, UC Davis School of Law, October 4, 2012. 735 736 University of California, Davis [Vol. 47:735 treasure trove of Southeast Asian porcelain. As you can see, even the geographic scope of their work is dazzling. Their work is in collections and exhibitions across the world from Beijing and Tokyo to Europe and California.
    [Show full text]
  • From Participatory Democracy to Digital Democracy
    Fast Capitalism ISSN 1930-014X Volume 1 • Issue 2 • 2005 doi:10.32855/fcapital.200502.003 From Participatory Democracy to Digital Democracy Mark Kann Tom Hayden posted on his website, http://www.tomhayden.com, an article he coauthored with Dick Flacks to commemorate the fortieth anniversary of the Port Huron Statement. The two SDS founders concluded, “Perhaps the most important legacy of the Port Huron Statement is the fact that it introduced the concept of participatory democracy to popular discourse and practice.” The concept of participatory democracy encompassed values such as equality, decentralization, and consensus decision-making. It provided direction for “all those trying to create a world where each person has a voice in the decisions affecting his or her life.” [1] In this article, I suggest that Port Huron’s concept of participatory democracy included some ideas that were potentially antithetical to democracy and that potential, unfortunately, is being fulfilled in contemporary theories of digital democracy. The Port Huron Statement Revisited The Port Huron Statement contained two underlying themes that potentially subverted democratic equality. One was the notion that the American people were fundamentally flawed, most apparently, by their apathy. The other was that the best means to eliminate this flaw was to follow the lead of rational, deliberative activists. Both themes could be (and would be) used to justify political inequalities. Port Huron’s student-authors expressed a dim view of American citizens. The American people had closed minds. They exhibited a foolish confidence that the nation could muddle through its problems. They harbored a false sense of contentment, “a glaze above deeply felt anxieties,” arising out of loneliness, isolation, and estrangement.
    [Show full text]
  • Workplace Democracy: from a Democratic Ideal to a Managerial Tool and Back
    The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal, Volume 19(1), 2013, article 3. La Revue de l’innovation : La Revue de l’innovation dans le secteur public, 19(1), 2013, article 3. ___________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________ Workplace Democracy From a Democratic Ideal to a Managerial Tool and Back Markus Pausch Head of the Centre for Futures Studies University of Applied Sciences, Salzburg, Austria Lecturer, Department of Political Science and Sociology, Paris Lodron University, Salzburg, Austria 1 The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal, Volume 19(1), 2013, article 3. La Revue de l’innovation : La Revue de l’innovation dans le secteur public, 19(1), 2013, article 3. ___________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________________________ Workplace Democracy: From a Democratic Ideal to a Managerial Tool and Back Markus Pausch ABSTRACT In different political theories, democracy is not reduced to state institutions, but includes the democratization of the whole society, its organizations and enterprises. This idea goes back to the beginnings of modern democratic theory and to Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s Social Contract. It was adopted by different socialist thinkers, later on by trade unions and, in the 1960s and 70s, by political scientists such as Carole Pateman and other promoters of participatory democracy. According to this tradition, workplace democracy is considered to be necessary for the realization of democratic ideals like individual autonomy, freedom, voice and participation in all relevant questions influencing citizens’ lives. Parts of this normative idea were realized by trade union movements and laws, especially in Western European countries. Nevertheless, workplace democracy in the sense of the above-mentioned theories remained far from becoming reality.
    [Show full text]
  • Art and the Crisis of the European Welfare State Addresses Contemporary Art in the Context of Changing European Welfare States
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO No Such Thing as Society: Art and the Crisis of the European Welfare State A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Art History, Theory and Criticism by Sarah Elsie Lookofsky Committee in charge: Professor Norman Bryson, Co-Chair Professor Lesley Stern, Co-Chair Professor Marcel Hénaff Professor Grant Kester Professor Barbara Kruger 2009 Copyright Sarah Elsie Lookofsky, 2009 All rights reserved. The Dissertation of Sarah Elsie Lookofsky is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm and electronically: Co-Chair Co-Chair University of California, San Diego 2009 iii Dedication For my favorite boys: Daniel, David and Shannon iv Table of Contents Signature Page…….....................................................................................................iii Dedication.....................................................................................................................iv Table of Contents..........................................................................................................v Vita...............................................................................................................................vii Abstract……………………………………………………………………………..viii Chapter 1: “And, You Know, There Is No Such Thing as Society.” ....................... 1 1.1 People vs. Population ............................................................................... 2 1.2 Institutional
    [Show full text]
  • Participatory Democracy in Chávez's Bolivarian Revolution
    Who Mobilizes? Participatory Democracy in Chávez’s Bolivarian Revolution Kirk A. Hawkins ABSTRACT This article assesses popular mobilization under the Chávez gov- ernment’s participatory initiatives in Venezuela using data from the AmericasBarometer survey of 2007. This is the first study of the so- called Bolivarian initiatives using nationally representative, individ- ual-level data. The results provide a mixed assessment. Most of the government’s programs invite participation from less active seg- ments of society, such as women, the poor, and the less educated, and participation in some programs is quite high. However, much of this participation clusters within a narrow group of activists, and a disproportionate number of participants are Chávez supporters. This partisan bias probably reflects self-screening by Venezuelans who accept Chávez’s radical populist discourse and leftist ideology, rather than vote buying or other forms of open conditionality. Thus, the Venezuelan case suggests some optimism for proponents of par- ticipatory democracy, but also the need to be more attuned to its practical political limits. uring the past decade, leftist governments with participatory dem- Docratic agendas have come to power in many Latin American coun- tries, implementing institutional reforms at the local and, increasingly, the national level. This trend has generated a scholarly literature assess- ing the nature of participation in these initiatives; that is, whether they embody effective attempts at participatory forms of democracy that mobilize and empower inactive segments of society (Goldfrank 2007; Wampler 2007a). This article advances this discussion by studying popular mobiliza- tion under the government of Hugo Chávez in Venezuela, referred to here as the Bolivarian Revolution or Chavismo.
    [Show full text]
  • Radical Politics Between Protest and Parliament
    tripleC 15(2): 459-476, 2017 http://www.triple-c.at The Alternative to Occupy? Radical politics between protest and parliament Emil Husted* and Allan Dreyer Hansen** *Department of Organization, Copenhagen Business School, Copenhagen, Denmark, www.cbs.dk/en/staff/ehioa **Department of Social Sciences and Business, Roskilde University, Roskilde, Den- mark, www.ruc.dk/~adh Abstract: In this paper, we compare the political anatomy of two distinct enactments of (left- ist) radical politics: Occupy Wall Street, a large social movement in the United States, and The Alternative, a recently elected political party in Denmark. Based on Ernesto Laclau’s conceptualization of ‘the universal’ and ‘the particular’, we show how the institutionalization of radical politics (as carried out by The Alternative) entails a move from universality towards particularity. This move, however, comes with the risk of cutting off supporters who no longer feel represented by the project. We refer to this problem as the problem of particularization. In conclusion, we use the analysis to propose a conceptual distinction between radical movements and radical parties: While the former is constituted by a potentially infinite chain of equivalent grievances, the latter is constituted by a prioritized set of differential demands. While both are important, we argue that they must remain distinct in order to preserve the universal spirit of contemporary radical politics. Keywords: Radical Politics, Radical Movements, Radical Parties, Discourse Theory, Ernesto Laclau, Universalism, Particularism, Occupy Wall Street, The Alternative Acknowledgement: First of all, we would like to thank the anonymous reviewers and the editorial team at tripleC for their constructive comments.
    [Show full text]
  • Playground of Violence: Mennonites and Makhnovites in the Time of War and Revolution
    International Relations and Diplomacy, July 2015, Vol. 3, No. 7, 439-447 D doi: 10.17265/2328-2134/2015.07.001 DAVID PUBLISHING Playground of Violence: Mennonites and Makhnovites in the Time of War and Revolution Mikhail Akulov The Kazakh-British Technical University, Almaty, Kazakhstan Focusing on the relationship between the German Mennonite colonists and the self-professed followers of Nestor Makhno, this paper attempts to present a view of the Revolution in which participants are seen primarily through the framework of competition, rather than through binary narrative structures of victims vs. perpetrators, bourgeoisie vs. proletariat, revolutionaries vs. counterrevolutionaries, etc.. Always with an eye at a real or an imagined opponent, the Mennonites and the avowed adherents of the fabled bat’ko ended up profoundly influencing one another, conditioning one’s moves and limiting one’s latitude as does the omnipresent other vis-a-vis the unfolding self. In that light, violence, which both sides had on their record, functioned to cement such ongoing dialects, carrying the protagonists of these turbulent times well beyond their original intentions. Keywords: Russian Civil War, violence, Makhno, Mennonites, revolution Introduction The Russian Revolution, a subject relegated from the top priorities of the scholarly scrutiny in the late 1990s and early 2000s, is now making a comeback. The multiple jubilees are certainly working in its favor. Thus, pouncing upon the opportunity proffered last year by the centennial anniversary of the Great
    [Show full text]
  • SUPERFLEX Formed in 1993 by Bjørnstjerne Reuter Christiansen
    SUPERFLEX Formed in 1993 by Bjørnstjerne Reuter Christiansen, Jakob Fenger, Rasmus Nielsen. The Danish artist group SUPERFLEX has been working since 1993 on a series of projects to do with economic forces, democratic production conditions and self-organisation. With a diverse and complex practice that engages art, design, commerce and economic structures of dependency, the Copenhagenbased artists collective Superflex challenges the role of artists in contemporary society and explore the nature of globalization through ongoing collaborative projects. Bjørnstjerne Reuter Christiansen born 1969 Jakob Fenger born 1968 Rasmus Nielsen born 1969 Work and live in Copenhagen, Denmark & Sweden Education The Royal Academy of Fine Art in Copenhagen Solo exhibitions (selected) 2014 The Corrupt Show and The Speculative Machine, The Jumex Foundation, Mexico City, MX Superflex, Kunsthal Charlottenborg, Copenhagen 2013 Mærsk – The Opera, Horsens Art Museum, Horsens, DK 2012 7th Liverpool Biennial, Liverpool, GB Kuh, Thyssen-Bornemisza Art Contemporary, Vienna, AT Reprototypes, Triangulations and Road Tests – w. Simon Starling, Thyssen-Bornemisza Art Contemporary, Vienna, AT Prouvé in Africa / Bent, Pressed, Compressed, Welded, and then Copied, Musée d’Art Moderne, St-Etienne, FR Bankrupt Banks, Peter Blum, New York, US Modern Times Forever, 1301PE Gallery, Los Angeles, US Flooded McDonald’s, The Cube, Taipei, Taiwan 2011 COPY LIGHT – MODERN TIMES FOREVER, Galerie Jeusse Entreprise, Paris, FR Flooded McDonalds, Museum der Westkünste, Alkersum/Föhr, D Foreigners,
    [Show full text]