Parliamentary Debates (Hansard)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Wednesday Volume 583 2 July 2014 No. 17 HOUSE OF COMMONS OFFICIAL REPORT PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Wednesday 2 July 2014 £5·00 © Parliamentary Copyright House of Commons 2014 This publication may be reproduced under the terms of the Open Parliament licence, which is published at www.parliament.uk/site-information/copyright/. 873 2 JULY 2014 874 Scotland’s economy, and jobs for the people of Scotland House of Commons that come from inward investment—instead of a referendum distraction. Wednesday 2 July 2014 John Thurso (Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross) (LD): My right hon. Friend will be well aware that marine renewable energy presents a considerable The House met at half-past Eleven o’clock opportunity for inward international investment as well as for export, based on the knowledge we have acquired. In that regard, it is vital that MeyGen’s project goes PRAYERS ahead. What discussions has he had with either the Department of Energy and Climate Change or the Crown Estate to enable that to happen? [MR SPEAKER in the Chair] Mr Carmichael: I have had a number of discussions, as I think my hon. Friend is aware, involving my colleagues in DECC and in the Crown Estate. I am very keen to Oral Answers to Questions ensure that no procedural difficulties will stand in the way of the development from MeyGen, which, as he and I both know, is a very exciting and potentially lucrative development for his area. SCOTLAND Angus Robertson (Moray) (SNP): Inward investment The Secretary of State was asked— into Scotland is at a 16-year high under a Scottish International Inward Investment National party Government and in the run-up to an independence referendum. That contrasts with all the claims of doom and gloom from the Chancellor of the 1. Mike Freer (Finchley and Golders Green) (Con): Exchequer. Given that the UK Government were What assessment he has made of the potential for spectacularly wrong in their claims on inward investment, international inward investment in Scotland after 2014. why should anybody trust the myriad Westminster scare [904528] stories? The Secretary of State for Scotland (Mr Alistair Mr Carmichael: I am delighted that the hon. Gentleman Carmichael): As part of the United Kingdom, Scotland gives me the opportunity to remind the House that of has an impressive track record of attracting international the 111 inward investment projects that were successful inward investment, which recent figures have put at its in 2012-13, 84 were supported by UK Trade & Investment. highest level for 16 years. Scotland has strong potential That is the sort of heft that is given to Scottish business to build on that record as part of the UK, the No. 1 by being part of the United Kingdom; that is what he location for Europe-bound foreign investment. wants us to walk away from. Mike Freer: Does my right hon. Friend agree that Angus Robertson: The UK Government have launched inward investment is boosted by Scotland being part of a confrontational approach to the European Union. a single market and having a single currency? The Prime Minister went to Brussels last week and was outvoted 26 to 2. If smaller countries have no say in the Mr Carmichael: Indeed; I do agree with my hon. European Union, why is it that a Luxembourger is the Friend. The people of Scotland very much understand new President of the European Commission—from a that access to the pound sterling as our currency and country smaller than the city of Glasgow? access to that larger UK market benefit them, and they value them, especially the business community. We know Mr Carmichael: I will take absolutely no lectures that, because that is why the nationalists are constantly from the Scottish nationalists on the subject of telling us that even in independence we would still be confrontational approaches. It really is a mark of the able to keep those things. They are wrong; it is cynical; desperation of the position in which they find themselves and as we saw from yesterday’s poll, nobody is really that that is the best they can come up with. being fooled by it. Mrs Anne McGuire (Stirling) (Lab): The Secretary of 11. [904538] Mr Brian H. Donohoe (Central Ayrshire) State commented on the Ernst and Young report, and it (Lab): However, it is the case that inward investment is also identified that although investment was increasing, faltering. I have had experience after experience of the number of jobs related to that inward investment talking to foreigners who are not investing in Scotland was decreasing. I wonder what action the Minister can as a result of the uncertainties and the possible likely take, hopefully in co-operation with the Scottish divorce. Are we not by far better off as a united Government, to ensure that there is greater correlation kingdom than we would be with a separate Scotland? between investment and jobs created in Scotland. Mr Carmichael: We are very much better off as a Mr Carmichael: The right hon. Lady points to a result of being part of the United Kingdom, and I long direction in which sensible politics ought to go, and I for the day when again Ministers here and in Edinburgh would love to be working in that way with the Scottish can all concentrate on doing their day job of working Government. Unfortunately, however, it takes two to together to get the maximum benefit to Scotland and tango. 875 Oral Answers2 JULY 2014 Oral Answers 876 Living Wage David Mundell: I absolutely agree. Tens of thousands of Scots have benefited from the fact that we have raised 2. Ann McKechin (Glasgow North) (Lab): What steps the personal allowance. Roughly two thirds of those on he is taking to incentivise employers in Scotland to pay the minimum wage are now paying significantly less tax the living wage. [904529] than they were when this Government came to power. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Scotland Mr Russell Brown (Dumfries and Galloway) (Lab): I (David Mundell): The Government support businesses know the Minister recognises that payment of the living that choose to pay the living wage, where it is affordable wage will ease the pressures of the cost of living that and does not cost jobs. many households experience, but in view of his recent admission to the Scottish Parliament’s Welfare Reform Committee that his Government’s benefits sanctions Ann McKechin: The Minister will be aware that many and welfare reforms have contributed to the increase in people in Scotland have started the holiday season and the number of food bank users, will he now apologise? packed their bags, and many will be visiting the beautiful islands of Scotland, but last week the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers reported that David Mundell: What I think politicians should apologise foreign-resident seafarers who are working on the ferries for is making the poor and most vulnerable into political are being paid as little as £2.35 an hour. That is a footballs. Poverty is a scourge in our country, not an disgrace to Scotland, and I urge the Minister to use his opportunity for a press release. offices to work with the Scottish Government to persuade the ferry companies to pay not only the minimum wage Mr Speaker: Order. In case the House is not aware, I but a living wage to every single one of their workers. can inform colleagues that the House of Commons has received its accreditation from the Living Wage Foundation. David Mundell: I most certainly take on board what the hon. Lady says and I will make representations in Independence Referendum that regard. I am sure she welcomes the fact that earlier this month the UK Government published a list of 3. Pete Wishart (Perth and North Perthshire) (SNP): employers who had not paid the minimum wage. What steps he is taking to inform the public about the Unfortunately, two of them were in Scotland. Scottish independence referendum. [904530] Mike Crockart (Edinburgh West) (LD): Mr Speaker, The Secretary of State for Scotland (Mr Alistair I know that you will be happy to hear that in May I Carmichael): To inform the debate, a variety of information, employed an apprentice in business administration in including a range of detailed analysis papers and a my office and committed to paying her the living wage. booklet for each household in Scotland, has been published. Does the Minister agree with me that all MPs’ offices I have also participated in public debates and will and Government Departments should set an example continue to do so to set out the benefits of Scotland’s and move as quickly as possible to being accredited remaining in the United Kingdom. living wage employers? Pete Wishart: For which we are eternally grateful, but David Mundell: The hon. Gentleman sets a good is not the best way to inform people to debate? Instead, example, and certainly in apprenticeship schemes offered we have the leader of the no campaign, his right hon. by Members of Parliament, I support the action he has Friend the Prime Minister, running a mile, feart to do taken. just that? What about the substitute-designate? It will be a slaughter worse than the Bannockburn re-enactment 14. [904541] Mr William Bain (Glasgow North East) if they put up the angry, agitated Alistair to debate with (Lab): Seven out of 10 young people in Scotland who the First Minister. The Secretary of State himself could are unemployed are applying for benefit for the second do it; he is good at this stuff—he could even take Rhona time.