December 2014 Vol 21, No. 2
Spotlight on farm health and safety MORE THAN Focus JUST A YEAST on dairy crossbreds Yield cow Health Increases DMI by over Improves milk yield by an 0.60kg/cow/day in early average of 1.18kg/cow/day lactation*1 and reduces SCC*2 Selecting maize varieties Rumen health Reduces acidosis and metabolic disorders*3 and improves fi bre digestion*4 Dairy Crest review Over 400 trials prove works Are you maximising your cow’s potential?
* 1 Poppy et al. (2012) J Dairy Sci 6027 - 6041 * 2 Zaworski et al (2014) J Dairy Sci 3081–3098 * 3 Li et al, 2012. Journal of Dairy Science, 95: Suppl. 1 December * 4 White et al., 2008. Prof Anim Sci., 24: 114 – 119 Freephone technical information 0800 833 675 E: [email protected] bull proofs www.rumenco.co.uk UK distributor for
BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 1 Hoofsure Endurance Footbath Solution
Safe Cost-effective Scientifically Proven
SPECIAL OFFER Purchase 3 x 20 litre Hoofsure Endurance and receive a 5 litre acid resistant sprayer and Hoofsure Konquest Gel 300g
FREEPHONE 0800 3284982 or visit www.provita.co.uk D -HEN-B 3 277
Hoofsure Endurance should be used as part of an overall hoof care programme. Hoofsure Combat spray and Konquest gel available. NEWS
December 2014, Vol 21, No. 2 Semex Dairy Conference A & B pricing Semex UK has announced that Contents +HU5R\DO+LJKQHVV7KH3ULQFHVV system now 5R\DOZLOOEHYLVLWLQJWKHWK$Q- 1XͿHOGFRQIHUHQFHUHSRUW niversary Semex Dairy conference on Tuesday January 13th, 2015, in News review—Dairy Crest 10-11 on the agenda Glasgow. “We are delighted that Animal health—scours 12 7KH3ULQFHVV5R\DOLVYLVLWLQJRXU Barry Wilson comments 15 Three months after Farmers For Action leader David Handley conference,” said Semex’s Gordon mooted the idea of introducing ‘A & B’ pricing into their milk Miller. “She has a keen interest in )RFXVRQFURVVEUHGV contracts—to almost universal apathy and derision at the time— agriculture through her patron- Grassland management 22-24 more and more dairy companies are believed to be poised to adopt age of several organisations, is the system, although few have gone public. At the beginning of extremely knowledgeable about 0DL]HYDULHW\VHOHFWLRQ 'HFHPEHULWZDVNQRZQDWOHDVWÀYHZHUHFRQVLGHULQJLWLQIDFW dairy farming, and is a superb Tackling solar ulcers 33-34 Graham’s, The Family Dairy, for example, has introduced a ambassador for our industry.” Spotlight on health and safety 36-37 scheme from February where producers will be allocated a liquid volume and an ingredients volume, based on their supply from Trade balance improves 3DVWXUHWR3URÀWFRQIHUHQFH September 2013 to August 2014. The liquid volume will be 90% 5HFHQW 8. LPSRUWV DQG H[SRUWV of the volume, and the rest the ingredients volume “which will be +HLIHU5HDUHURIWKH BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 3 NEWS DairyCo consultation Help needed for ailing industry A consultation is being held to seek the views of dairy levy payers Ruthless retail milk discounting rebalance the EU market. chain to cover farmers’ relation- and industry organisations on the is not sustainable, and ultimately “We’re also calling on them ships with processors. We believe DairyCo business plan. will damage the future of the to continue their work on seek- this would bring better transpar- The plan sets out DairyCo’s UK dairy industry, NFU dairy ing new export opportunities and ency to the impact of the ongo- strategy and key activities to board chairman Rob Harrison has promoting our high quality dairy ing liquid milk discounting that improve productivity and com- warned. products both within Europe and we’re all seeing in our retailers. petitiveness for dairy farming Giving evidence to the Envi- outside. “The NFU has already written businesses in Great Britain. It cov- URQPHQW )RRG DQG 5XUDO$ͿDLUV “To help push consumption to all the major supermarkets to ers the period April 2015 to March Committee Select Committee on we urge policymakers to improve ask the simple question: ‘What are 2016 in detail with an outline for the current dairy price situation, the labelling of dairy products—to you doing to support British dairy April 2016 to March 2017. Mr Harrison argued that while the ensure consumers are buying Brit- farmers?’ as there are a number of The DairyCo divisional busi- farmgate milk price downturn has ish—and to be more co-ordinated areas that can be improved. ness plan can be downloaded been caused as the twin result of in their health messages. And to “A number of dairy farm- from the DairyCo website at increased global production and help farmers better manage volatil- ers are within dedicated supply www.dairyco.org.uk reduced global demand, there are ity we have called on Government relationships, but using milk as a The deadline for comments on a number of clear things that can to help develop a farm manage- loss leader puts downward pres- the draft plan is Tuesday January be done to cushion the impact on ment deposit scheme and to ex- sure on the whole industry and 13, 2015. Responses should be sent UK dairy farms. WHQGSURÀWDYHUDJLQJWRÀYH\HDUV while farmers’ margins are being to [email protected] “We know that government such as was recently announced by squeezed by global and political can’t step in to the market, but the Irish Government. issues we need our domestic retail- Phoenix Feeds they can support our hard working “We would also like to see the ers to support our farmers more dairy farmers at national and Eu- remit of the Groceries Code Adju- than ever,” he added. (See com- Technical support and feeds sup- ropean level. In Brussels they can dicator extended down the supply ment on page 32.) plies for the Leicestershire-based back the NFU’s call for a review Sandyford herd (Farm story, No- of the intervention price for dairy • Dairy farming in the UK was in a desperate state, MPs were told by vember issue, pages 10-11) are pro- products as well as a targeted re- David Handley, chairman of Farmers For Action. Giving evidence to the vided by William Marsland from opening of Private Storage Aid for Efra committee in the Houses of Parliament, Mr Handley said 400 milk Lancashire-based Phoenix Feeds. cheese—something that can help producers have quit the business so far this year, compared with 200 over the whole of last year. “The situation is getting so serious that in the last nine weeks we’ve passed three individual dairy producers on to the Samaritans because they were in such a desperate state and the full impact isn’t yet being seen.” Slurry Mr Handley said that the money between the processor and retailer EXPERTS IN SLURRY MANAGEMENT needed to be tracked. “We need to have some honesty and transparency. Solutions He disputed claims that the price cuts were down to global markets, say- LQJ´:HÀQGLWYHU\VXVSLFLRXVZKHQZHDUHEHLQJWROGWKDWLWLVRYHUVXS- Slurry Storage Systems ply when 85% of our milk never leaves these shores.” Automatic Scraper Systems New Stoneleigh headquarters for AHDB & DairyCo Slurry Pumps Slurry Mixers Multiscrapers Automatic Cow Brushes 0% Finance available Screw Press Separators on Automatic Scraper Systems, Separation Systems and Eco Eco-Bedder Systems Bedder Systems. Slurrystore Accessories Service & Parts for most slurry machinery Manufactured in the UK S.England / Wales David Turner 07818 053 159 The Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB)—which N.England Gary Morland 07919 563 796 includes DairyCo—has completed its move into a newly constructed Scotland / Ireland Robert Wilson 07769 728 128 headquarters building, leased from LaSalle Investment Management, Head Office Chris Richardson 01524 781 900 on Stoneleigh Park in Warwickshire. 7KHQHZDFFRPPRGDWLRQPHDQVWKDWWKH$+'%VWDͿDW Email: [email protected] 6WRQHOHLJK3DUNDUHLQRQHEXLOGLQJIRUWKHYHU\ÀUVWWLPHVLQFHWKHOHY\ www.storthmachinery.co.uk board was created in 2008—previously they have been spread across three separate buildings on the science park. 4 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 NEWS Cheddar export boost Maize silage analysis encouraging First Milk has secured a deal with D7H[DQÀQHIRRGVUHWDLOHUIRUWKH ,QLWLDO DQDO\VLV RI PDL]H VLODJH Maize silage analysis for 2014 H[SRUWRI0XOORI.LQW\UH&KHGGDU LQGLFDWHVWKHFURSFRXOGEHDZHO- )UDVHU%URZQH[SRUWVDOHVGLUHFWRU FRPHDGGLWLRQWRGDLU\UDWLRQVWKLV 2013/14 average Early 2014 average IRU)LUVW0LONFRPPHQWHG´'HYHO- ZLQWHUKHOSLQJRͿVHWVRPHRIWKH Dry Matter (%) 32.3 31.2 RSLQJDGGHGYDOXHH[SRUWVDOHVLV FKDOOHQJHVSUHVHQWHGE\WKLV\HDU·V Crude protein (%) 7.9 8.0 DNH\SDUWRIRXUEXVLQHVVVWUDWHJ\ JUDVVVLODJH D-value (%) 72.5 71.5 ´+DYLQJ DQDO\VHG RYHU IRUDJHVZHKDYHDJRRGSLFWXUHRI ME (MJ/kgDM) 11.4 11.3 KRZPDL]HVLODJHVZLOOIHHGDQGLW Starch (%) 31.6 30.6 LVHQFRXUDJLQJµFRPPHQWV7URXZ Starch degradability (%) 67.7 69.2 1XWULWLRQ *% UXPLQDQW PDQDJHU $GDP&OD\ZKRDGGVWKDWDQHF- By-pass starch (g/kgDM) 102.2 94.1 GRWDOHYLGHQFHLQGLFDWHVWKDWPDQ\ NDF (%) 42.0 41.7 IDUPHUVKDYHVHHQDSRVLWLYH\LHOG pH 3.9 4.0 UHVSRQVHVLQFHLQWURGXFLQJPDL]H LQWRWKHGLHW 0DL]H VLODJH LV D YLWDO VRXUFH IULHQGO\ PDQQHU )DUPHUV ZLOO 0U&OD\VD\VWKDWKLJKHQHUJ\ RI VWDUFK LQ GLHWV DQG 0U &OD\ QHHGWRHQVXUHWKH\IHHGVXFLHQW FRQWHQW DQG GU\ PDWWHU FRXSOHG H[SODLQVWKDWWRWDOVWDUFKOHYHOVDUH E\SDVVVWDUFKLQWKHWRWDOGLHWWR ZLWKUHGXFHG1')OHYHOVVXJJHVW ORZHU WKDQ ODVW \HDU EXW DUH VWLOO DYRLGSXVKLQJFRZVWRZDUGVVXE WKDW PDL]H VLODJHV ZLOO VXSSRUW JRRGDWFRPSDUHGWR FOLQLFDODFLGRVLVµ DVZHUHPDLQIRFXVHGRQGULYLQJ LQFUHDVHGSHUIRUPDQFH+HSRLQWV +RZHYHUWKHVWDUFKLVPRUHGHJUD- 0U &OD\ VD\V UHGXFHG 1') PRUHVWDEOHUHWXUQVIRURXUIDUPHU RXW WKDW 0( OHYHOV DUH VOLJKWO\ GDEOHDQGWKLVLVVLJQLÀFDQW DQG LQFUHDVHG VWDUFK GHJUDGDELO- RZQHUV 'HVSLWH WKH GHSUHVVHG ORZHUWKLV\HDUDW0-FRPSDUHG ´+LJKHU VWDUFK GHJUDGDELOLW\ LW\FRXOGPHDQPDL]HVLODJHFRXOG PDUNHWVLWXDWLRQDURXQGWKHZRUOG WR $OWKRXJK RQO\ D VPDOO PHDQV WKDW PRUH RI WKH VWDUFK LV FDXVH DFLGRVLV SUREOHPV XQOHVV 86PDUNHWVDUHSHUIRUPLQJVWURQJ- GLͿHUHQFH LW PHDQV WKDW UDWLRQV XVHGLQWKHUXPHQ7KLVLQFUHDVHV GLHWV DUH FDUHIXOO\ EDODQFHG DQG HU ZLWK TXDOLW\ &KHGGDU VHOOLQJ ZLOOVWLOOQHHGFDUHIXOEDODQFLQJWR WKHDYDLODEOHUXPHQHQHUJ\ZKLFK FRZVFORVHO\PRQLWRUHG IRUSUHPLXPSULFHVDQGGHPDQG HQVXUHWKDWWKHFRZV·WRWDOHQHUJ\ VXSSRUWVPLFURELDOJURZWK ´,W LV DOVR LPSRUWDQW WR UH- LQFUHDVLQJ\HDURQ\HDUµ UHTXLUHPHQWVDUHPHW ´$ PRUH DFWLYH UXPHQ ZLWK PHPEHU WKDW VWDUFK GHJUDGDELO- KLJKHU PLFURELDO JURZWK LV LP- LW\ LQFUHDVHV ZLWK WLPH LQ WKH SRUWDQW DV WKLV GULYHV GU\ PDWWHU FODPS VR WKH ULVN RI GLVUXSWHG LQWDNHV DQG \LHOGV 3URPRWLQJ UXPHQ KHDOWK FRXOG ULVH GXULQJ KLJKLQWDNHVKDVEHHQDQLVVXHZLWK WKH ZLQWHU )RU WKLV UHDVRQ ZH PDQ\JUDVVVLODJHVWKLV\HDUVRWKLV ZRXOG UHFRPPHQG WKDW PDL]H TK dust ZLOOEHDQDGGHGEHQHÀWIURPJHW- LV VDPSOHG PRQWKO\ WKURXJKRXW WLQJPDL]HLQWRGLHWV WKH ZLQWHU DQG GLHWV ÀQH WXQHG ´&RQYHUVHO\ WKHUH LV DQ IRUUXPHQDYDLODEOHVWDUFKOHYHOV Cubicle Disinfectant Powder UHGXFWLRQ LQ E\SDVV VWDUFK ,Q- ´1XWULWLRQLVWV VKRXOG XVH D FOXGLQJE\SDVVVWDUFKLQWKHGLHW IRUPXODWLRQ SDFNDJH FDSDEOH RI Improves hygiene of cubicles and bedded pens LVDQHͿHFWLYHPHWKRGRILQFUHDVLQJ LGHQWLI\LQJ WKH VSHHG DW ZKLFK WKH WRWDO VWDUFK IHG DQG WKHUHIRUH FDUERK\GUDWHVDUHGHJUDGHGLQWKH &RQWDLQVVSHFL¿FPLQHUDOV DQG¿EUHVIRUWKHLUGU\LQJ JOXFRJHQLF HQHUJ\ LQ D UXPHQ UXPHQµ 6HHSDJHV actions Contains DEFRA approved Processors on target Cornwall to host BGS disinfectant that is activated by moisture 3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVIURPWKH &RUQZDOO ZLOO KRVW WKH QH[W YLVLW 'DLU\ 8. (QYLURQPHQWDO %HQFK- RI WKH %ULWLVK *UDVVODQG 6RFLHW\ Cow Cubicles - use at 70g per cubicle “udder region” PDUNLQJ5HSRUWVKRZVWKDWGDLU\ DQQXDOPHHWLQJLQ-XO\ daily or 140g every other day. SURFHVVRUV KDYH DFKLHYHG DQ ¶0HDWLQJ DQG 0LONLQJ WKH Calculate 500g/cow/week LQFUHDVHLQHQHUJ\HFLHQF\VLQFH &UHDPRI&RUQLVK*UDVVODQG·ZLOO Calving boxes, Calf pens, EHKHOGLQ&RUQZDOOIURPWR Lambing pens -100g/ sqm/ every day ,WPHDQVWKH\DUHRQWUDFNWR -XO\ PHHW WKH &OLPDWH &KDQJH$JUHH- &RUQZDOO *UDVVODQG 6RFLHW\ Packaged in 25kg bags on half tonne & tonne pallets PHQWV DQG 'DLU\ 5RDGPDS PDGH XS RI IRXU ORFDO VRFLHWLHV WDUJHWV RI DQG UHVSHF- KDV RUJDQLVHG D GLYHUVH DQG LQ- Please call for WLYHO\ WHUHVWLQJ LWLQHUDU\ WKDW ZLOO WDNH FREE SAMPLES, and 10% off 7KH UHSRUW DOVR GHWDLOV WKH LQ VHYHQ OLYHVWRFN IDUPV DQG WKH À DIRECT PRICES UVWRUGHU SURJUHVVPDGHLQZDVWHPDQDJH- ¶)XWXUH)DUP·UHVHDUFKIDFLOLWLHVDW PHQW 3URFHVVRUV DWWDLQHG D 'XFK\&ROOHJH7KHHYHQWZLOOEH UHGXFWLRQLQWKHDPRXQWRIZDVWH EDVHGDWWKH/DQK\GURFN+RWHODQG VHQW WR ODQGÀOO SHU WRQQH RI PLON *ROI&OXEQHDU%RGPLQ LQSXW 7KH\ DOVR GHPRQVWUDWHG )RU PRUH LQIRUPDWLRQ LQ- DLQFUHDVHLQWKHDPRXQWRI FOXGLQJ D SUHYLHZ RI WKH SUR- ZDVWH UHF\FOHG RU UHFRYHUHG SHU JUDPPH YLVLW WKH %*6 ZHEVLWH³ t: 01772 690131 w: www.gshepherd.co.uk WRQQHRIPLONLQSXW ZZZEULWLVKJUDVVODQGFRP 6 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 Fullwood Fast. Reliable. Efficient. Pioneering runs in Fullwood’s blood. From generation to generation we have developed innovative solutions to make milking faster, more reliable and more GHƂEKGPV 1WT PQPQPUGPUG CRRTQCEJ JCU CNYC[U DGGP VQ FGNKXGT TGCN DGPGƂVU VQ RTQHGUUKQPCNFCKT[HCTOGTUCPFVJGKTEQYU6JCVGVJQUJCUOCFG(WNNYQQFU[PQP[OQWU YKVJHWNN[KPVGITCVGFVGEJPKECNN[CFXCPEGFCPFRTQƂVCDNGOKNMRTQFWEVKQP 9KVJVJGQTKIKPCN(WNNYQQF/GTNKPTQDQVCPGYGTCKPOKNMRTQFWEVKQPYCUDQTP1WT RCUUKQPHQTPGYVGEJPQNQIKGUJCUUGGPVJCVOCEJKPGFGXGNQRKPVQCVTWGENCUUNGCFGT $WVYGTGHWUGVQUVCPFUVKNN6JG(WNNYQQF/2GTNKPKUVJGPGZVIGPGTCVKQPQHCWVQOCVKE OKNMKPIU[UVGOUCPFKUTGCF[VQVCMGOKNMRTQFWEVKQPVQVJGPGZVNGXGN Fullwood M2GTNKPUGVVKPIVJGPGYUVCPFCTFKPGHƂEKGPVGTIQPQOKECPFGEQNQIKECNOKNM RTQFWEVKQP Welcome to the new era. Welcome to the fascinating, pioneering world of Fullwood. www.m2erlin.uk NUFFIELD FARMING SCHOLARSHIP CONFERENCE Improving business management 'RUVHWGDLU\IDUPHU-DVRQ9LFNHU\UHSRUWHGEDFNRQKLVVWXG\WRXUDWWKH1XI¿HOG6FKRODUVKLS )DUPLQJ7UXVW¶VDQQXDOFRQIHUHQFHLQ.HQWODVWPRQWK0LNH*UHHQUHSRUWV ost control and governance professional approach. ing has become over-technical their attitude to adversity.” Cwere the most important fac- “It was simple and, as I had whereas with careful overall man- In New Zealand he visited 28 tors for UK milk producers to ad- the skill set already, the transfor- agement and an eye on ‘the bigger dairy farms in 20 days—to the top dress to improve their businesses, mation to a spring calving system picture’, a much more down to 1% farm businesses in the country. DFFRUGLQJWR1XHOG6FKRODUDQG and paddock grazing was simple. earth approach would lower costs ´7KHVHZHUHPDLQO\ÀUVWDQG dairy farmer Jason Vickery. By Cow tracks were installed, I cross- of production and be far more sus- second generation businesses doing this they can compete on a bred my cows and put in a new tainable,” he said. “Via my study which were are hungry for success. global market, he argued. water system. The system soon tour I wanted to prove that UK Older businesses tend to rest on In partnership with his wife, EHFDPH SURÀWDEOH 7KLV UHOHDVHG GDLU\IDUPLQJFDQEHSURÀWDEOHLQ their laurels. Nicki, he is a tenant on the Duchy cash, freed up time and gave me a global market.” “We need to reduce costs to Estate at North Lawn Farm, near the opportunity to set up two new His conclusions were: UHPDLQSURÀWDEOH,WLVQRWHDV\WR Gillingham in Dorset where he has partnerships with young farmers 1: Farmers must dis- do but something we built up a herd of 350 dairy cows in two additional farm units milk- cipline themselves to can control,” said Mr on a grass-based system. ing a further 700 cows.” control cost, spend Vickery. “Until I took a trip to Ireland But he wanted to take his wisely and not fall He said it was in 2001 I had a very traditional business to another level and was into the trap of over- evident that the top approach to running my farm DZDUGHG D 1XHOG 6FKRODUVKLS managing and over- producers only dealt using all year round calving,” he which included visits to China, spending on their with the best people explained. “Impressed by the Australia and New Zealand where farms. and it was important OHYHO RI SURÀWV VPDOO GDLU\ IDUPV he was inspired by their business 2: Over spending and for UK farmers to do in Ireland were achieving, I came principals and got an appreciation over managing do the same. “It is im- home and modelled my system RIWKHEHQHÀWV8.IDUPHUVKDYHRQ not necessarily lead portant to get the right on what I had seen in Ireland their doorstep. WRKLJKHUSURÀWVRUHI- people around you. Jason Vickery. which was an altogether more “I believe that UK dairy farm- ÀFLHQFLHV DOEHLW WKH\ You need to get a good FDQLPSURYHWKLQJVDWDVXSHUÀFLDO consultant—but it is better to have aesthetic level. good consultant twice a year than 3: Controlling costs, as opposed average one every month. These to increasing output, is proven farmers were very good at getting to have a much greater chance of the right people around them. LPSURYLQJSURÀW “Grassland farming does not 6HHLQJWKHEHQHÀWVRIDSSO\LQJ get the press it deserves because the principles of governance to the LWRQO\EHQHÀWVWKHIDUPHU,QWKH business has been an important UK we often take advice from the learning curve for me and one sales rep which is certainly bad which enables a tight control over business.” development and costs. Governance was another key 5: Above all, learning from suc- LVVXH´7KHEHQHÀWRIJRRGJRY- cess, that of others as well as your ernance is that it frees up time for own, and adapting the business management and allows you to to emulate successful models and lower your costs and manage the SUDFWLFHV LV D EHQHÀFLDO DSSURDFK business better.” and earns no shame. He concluded: “The UK has a “My study tour has highlight- good climate, we can grow crops ed some simple changes which and have 70 million consumers can be made to my own business on our doorstep. But this means IRUPRUHHͿHFWLYHFRVWFRQWURODQG nothing unless you have got the WKXVJUHDWHUSURÀWµKHVDLG right business model in place.” “In China I looked at their During questions he was also manufacturing industry—produc- given an opportunity to give his LQJ PLON LQ 8. LV QR GLͿHUHQW WR views on EU subsidies. “We have producing a plastic toy in China. a generation of farmers who have They have a skilled work force and IRUJRWWHQDERXWSURÀWEHFDXVHZH work hard—and are expanding have subsidies. EU subsidies have everything they do with resource- EUHGLQHFLHQFLHVµKHVDLG fulness, discipline and attitude. “If we could farm without “In Australia they struggle VXEVLGLHVWKHQWKLVZRXOGEHQHÀW with drought and volatility,” he everyone. I hope my children will said. “It is an eye opener for doing be farming without subsidies in business in this environment and future,” added Mr Vickery. 8 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 PROTECTECEC YOUR HERD AGAINSTAGAG SCOURC U BOOSTO STT colostrumcolo t OPTIMISEIM scourco protection VaccinatingVac dams with Rotavec Corona prevents scour from taking hold of your young stock by BOOSTING the levels of antibodies in colostrum. ‘Use Medicines Responsibly’. Please see: www.noah.co.uk/responsible for more information. Rotavec™ Corona contains inactivated Rotavirus and Coronavirus and E. coli K99 antigens. Legal category: POM-VPS Withdrawal period: Zero days. Rotavec Corona is available from your veterinary advisor from whom advice should be sought. For information regarding side effects, precautions, warnings and contra-indications please refer to the datasheet at www.noahcompendium.co.uk. Rotavec™ Corona is the property of Intervet International B.V. or affiliated companies or licensors and is protected by copyrights, trademark and other intellectual property laws. Copyright © 2014 Intervet International B.V. All rights reserved. Further information is available from MSD Animal Health, Walton Manor, Walton, Milton Keynes MK7 7AJ. Tel: 01908 685685 Fax: 01908 685555 E: [email protected] Internet: www.msd-animal-health.co.uk 77360 NEWS REVIEW Dairy Crest exit liquid market Dairy Crest announced last month that it is to sell its liquid milk business to Müller Wiseman. Chris Walkland looks at the implications for the UK dairy industry. t was inevitable at some stage that Dairy Crest liquid milk business, which has cost the indus- Iwould look to sell some—or all—of its ailing try millions of pounds in recent years. And the liquid business. It couldn’t continue propping- upshot, surely, will be more long-term single XSLWVSURÀWVIRUHYHUE\VHOOLQJWKHIDPLO\VLO- supplier deals like Asda has with Arla. Factory ver—its depots as it has done in the past. rationalisation will take place and both Arla It was also an ideal in Arla’s and Müller’s DQG0OOHUZLOORYHUWLPHJHWPRUHPLONWRÀOO minds for three large liquid players to become their factories. two. The only questions were when, who, and But those who think it will lead to a substan- whether Dairy Crest would go as a whole, or in tial lessening of competition, which will cure the part. In the end it was the latter, with the an- ‘four pints for 99p’ syndrome among retailers QRXQFHPHQWWKDWLWLVÁRJJLQJLWVORVVPDNLQJ and bolster prices, are likely to be disappointed. liquid and butter businesses to Müller for £80m. That’s because we can expect to see the same The sale is conditional on the approval of thing that happened in bread (when suppliers the relevant competition authorities, of course. reduced in numbers) to happen in dairy—the But both sides are optimistic and will have retailers will help some of the smaller proces- taken soundings from the authorities. Those sors to grow. And rapidly. (Google Warburtons, experienced in takeovers and mergers point to Wikipedia). the ‘failing business test’ element of competition And there are plenty of smaller, capable, law to state that the competition authorities processors for them to choose from. should allow the deal to go ahead. On butter, Müller continues its ascendancy Assuming it does get the green light then, (only branded packet butter to go now); while what will it mean for the industry? Dairy Crest is left with cheese, some spreads and Well there is one less contestant for the infant formula products—which it will actually retailers to play musical chairs with for their sell through Fonterra. )RU&RPIRUWDEOH+HDOWK\3URGXFWLYH&RZV 0DNHKDUGFRQFUHWHEXLOGLQJVIHHOOLNHQDWXUDOSDVWXUHLQVSULQJ 5XEEHU)ORRULQJ 0DWWUHVVHV %DUQ&XUWDLQV x /HDGLQJJOREDOEUDQG x &KRLFHRIPDWWUHVVVW\OHV x &XVWRPPDGH\HDUZDUUDQW\ x )RUSDUORXUVSDVVDJHV x 3URYHQGXUDELOLW\DQGORQJ x 2SWLPXPYHQWLODWLRQDQG FXELFOHDOOH\VDQGZDONZD\V ZDUUDQWLHV ZHDWKHUSURWHFWLRQ &DOOXVIRUH[SHUWDGYLFHRUYLVLWRXUZHEVLWHIRUGHWDLOVRIDOORXUSURGXFWVLQFOXGLQJ /('/LJKWV x &XELFOHVDQG &DOO9LVLWZZZLQWHUVKDSHFRP 10 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 NEWS REVIEW As for the farmers, well, 400 supplying Davidstow will stay with Dairy Crest, the rest will join Müller. And, of course, there is one less processor for farmers (outside of Cornwall) to sell their milk to. Sentimentalists may sigh over the further demise of a once great British company, but that argument only applies to scale, and the deal may yet be the best thing that happened to Dairy Crest. For wry or cynical observers of the industry the timing of the deal maybe no coincidence either. That’s because making money out of The Müller take over of Dairy Crest includes dairy plants at Foston (above) and Severnside (left). liquid milk had been a struggle for Dairy Crest for years, and it was putting the whole future of who might be interested. Others from further But even then it might not be enough. the whole company at risk. DÀHOGDQGRXWVLGHRIGDLU\ZLOODOPRVWFHUWDLQO\ There are some big ambitions and bank Its poor performance was dragging the be interested. balances out there, and it is inconceivable that share price down. It was 426p when Müller If Dairy Crest is going to stay as a leading these companies will lose the acquisition bug. made its bid on November 6th, but a month name in the industry, therefore, then it will be Especially when the UK’s best loved cheese before it had been as low as 369p. Also Dairy hoping the share price continues to stay high. brand is the prize. Crest’s poor half-year interim results for the di- vision would almost certainly have sent it down again. At the same time there was some (albeit limited) speculation that if the price dropped to 350p then someone might just swoop in with a take-over bid. Adding to this, of course, was the fact that the Morrison’s contract is currently up for tender. The word on the street was that Mül- ler Wiseman was very keen to secure its busi- ness, and that would mean one thing for Dairy Crest—more pressure on margins. Remember, when the Sainsbury’s contract came up for renewal last year it cost Dairy Crest £10m to keep it. In this tough retail environment it is hard to think Morrisons would be looking to pay Dairy Crest more. Thus the loss of some or all of the Morrison’s contract would have potentially crashed the share price. Maintaining it would have cost it money too and probably put paid to it ever reaching its 3% margin (and credibility) target. Again the share price would most likely have fallen. There would, most likely therefore, have been some interesting conversations in the boardroom at Dairy Crest, with a couple of key questions particularly furrowing brows: “How do we stop the share price falling and get the share price up to reduce the risk of a takeover, and how do we protect Cathedral City?” 7KHDQVZHU"7RKLYHRͿWKHIDLOLQJOLTXLG division, and thus remove all of the uncertainty of the Morrison’s tender. So that’s the dairy industry take on this, be LWVSHFXODWLYHRUSLHRUVRPHZKHUHLQEHWZHHQ Whatever, the deal certainly perked up the share price—it rose from 426p to 490p on the day of the announcement and it is currently tracking above 500p. But has it done enough to protect Cathedral City? Well every dairy company would just love to have the product in their portfolio. Conse- quently this makes Dairy Crest a very lucrative acquisition target for the likes of Arla, Müller and Lactalis—to name just three companies BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 11 ANIMAL HEALTH Prevent scours to optimise performance Scours is the most common disease in young calves and the greatest single cause of death. Managing the risk of disease is crucial to reduce both long-term performance and economic losses. bout half of all calf deaths her colostrum ready for the calf to Aare caused by scours. But, ingest. the consequential economic loss Nia warns that a common from these deaths represents only mistake by farmers using the vac- a small proportion of the total cost cine is to think that the job is then of the disease. done. “However, to get the most “Rotavirus and coronavirus out of the vaccine, the colostrum are two of the most common caus- management programme must be es of infectious scours in calves,” spot on. says Nia Williams, Nettex technical “Roto Corona Plus is therefore manager. a good support to the vaccine and “Treating a single calf for colostrum management plan, or scours, costs on average, £120. But where vaccination is not routinely this does not take into account the used, it is an excellent addition additional time and labour costs to the heifer rearing programme. needed to rear sick calves initially, Reducing risk of exposure to disease will enhance lifetime performance. One 30 gram syringe will help pro- DQGWKHHͿHFWRIDQH[WHQGHGUHDU- vide the complementary resource ing period on future production weaning is the time when calves ies she produces and passes onto for calves to thrive,” she says. and productivity.” DUH PRVW HFLHQW DW FRQYHUWLQJ the calf via colostrum. But she Nia also advises that good hy- Reducing the risk of disease to feed into weight. “Any challenges may not have the necessary anti- giene and calf rearing management young stock is therefore crucial to experienced during this stage can bodies to protect her calf against practices will help limit the risk optimise heifer performance and mean calves are playing catch up rotavirus and coronavirus.” of disease. “Ensuring calf feed- longevity. DQG FDQ GHOD\ WKHLU WLPH WR ÀUVW Therefore, providing the calf ing buckets are kept clean, used service,” says Nia. with an additional boost of energy only for one calf, and thoroughly Research has shown that calv- and active proteins at birth can washed and sanitised before be- Causes and implications ing heifers at 24 months can play a help enhance natural defence ing used for another calf, will help Calf scours can be caused by either VLJQLÀFDQWUROHLQORQJWHUPPLON against disease challenges, such as reduce disease challenges. infectious agents or nutritional productivity and reduce the likeli- calf scours. “In addition to this, washing sources. Infectious scours caused KRRGRIFDOYLQJGLFXOWLHV´7KH The Roto Corona Plus Syringe, down, disinfecting and resting calf by rotavirus and coronavirus cause HͿHFW RI VFRXUV RQ KHLIHU SHUIRU- from Nettex, is formu- rearing buildings, if damage to the lining of the small PDQFHFDQH[WHQGWKHWLPHWRÀUVW lated to provide calves possible, and ensuring intestine leading to diarrhoea and calving. Ultimately this means with a source of concen- adequate ventilation, dehydration. The virus is most rearing costs are not paid back as trated bovine colostrum, are methods that can common in calves from one week TXLFNO\HͿHFWLQJIDUPÀQDQFHVµ DQG VSHFLÀF DFWLYH HJJ help to minimise the RIDJHEXWFDQDͿHFWFDOYHVIURP proteins to help support impact of calf scours. as young as one to two days old. natural defences. “Roto “If a calf is show- Management of scours “Damage to the gut lining Corona Plus does not ing signs of scours means calves can’t absorb nutri- A calf is born with no circulating replace colostrum but they should be iso- HQWV HͿHFWLYHO\ UHVXOWLQJ LQ WKH antibodies and is therefore reliant is administered to help lated from the main clinical symptoms of the disease, on a quality source of colostrum to support the dam’s colos- group and treated to such as diarrhoea,” says Nia. protect against disease challenges. WUXPLQWKHÀUVWKRXUVRI Nia Williams. reduce the impact of “This can predispose calves to Good colostrum management life,” she says. disease.” secondary infection with E. coli or should be a key focus for dairy “The additional intake of ac- Whether or not a calf devel- Cryptosporidium due to the fact farmers, explains Nia. tive proteins helps ensure calves ops scours is dependent on the it’s easier for these pathogens to “Ensuring calves receive at receive the tools they need to help interaction between the calf, its adhere within the gut, and cause least three litres of a quality source ÀJKW LPPXQH FKDOOHQJHVµ VD\V environment and its management. infection. RIFRORVWUXPLQWKHÀUVWVL[KRXUV Nia. Reducing the risk of exposure to ´,I FDOYHV VXͿHU IURP D EDG of birth, followed by a further An alternative practice for disease will help enhance long- or repeated, case of scours during three litres by 12 hours of age, farmers is to vaccinate cows for term performance and optimise rearing, the damage caused has the will mean they absorb the largest rotavirus and coronavirus four to returns. “The value of dairy calves SRWHQWLDOWRVHWEDFNDͿHFWHGDQL- quantity of antibodies available in six weeks prior to calving. The is often overlooked, but putting mals, causing long-term implica- the colostrum. aim of this is to allow the cow to LQWKHHͿRUWLQWKHHDUO\VWDJHVRI tions for health and performance.” “However, the immune status generate an antibody response OLIHZLOOUHDSORQJWHUPEHQHÀWVµ The period between birth and of the cow determines the antibod- which she is able to concentrate in concludes Nia. 12 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 FEED MARKET ANALYSIS TECHNICALLY SPEAKING By ‘Hayseed’ :LWK SURGXFHUV· PLON SULFHV pected to prompt further industry consolidation facing yet another cut from over the next 12 months. Larger players with QH[W PRQWK UXPLQDQW IHHG VXFLHQWÀQDQFLDOUHVRXUFHVDUHNHHQWRJURZ companies are getting in- to exploit economies of scale—especially when creasingly nervous over the EX\LQJUDZPDWHULDOVRQJOREDOPDUNHWVIURPD potential for a more bitter competitive battle small number of multi-nationals. for winter sales. As the capital funds returned to agricultural 'DLU\ FDNH DQG EOHQG YROXPHV KDYH KHOG IXWXUHVPDUNHWWKH\TXLFNO\GHHSHQHGOLYHVWRFN XS VR IDU VLQFH SURGXFHUV RQ SUHPLXP OLTXLG SURGXFHUV·JORRPE\UHYHUVLQJWKHVSRWPDUNHWV· contracts are still able to chase marginal litres. feed protein price slide by covering their short :KLOH RQO\ DFFRXQWLQJ IRU DERXW RI 8. SRVLWLRQV RQ VR\DEHDQ PHDO IXWXUHV PDUNHWV SURGXFWLRQWKH\DUHOLNHO\WRSURGXFHDSURÀW This hoped for temporary boost was supported DWWKHHQGRIWKLVPLON\HDU by unexpectedly high 2.2mt of US exports to Others have responded to potential losses &KLQDODVWPRQWKIURPLWVGZLQGOLQJVWRFNV E\ VWHSSLQJ XS RXWSXW KHOSLQJ WR SURGXFH 'HOLYHUHG +LSUR EXON SULFHV VKRW XS E\ record high volumes—to the resentment of over £30/t during the month to between £348 Farmers for Action activists. and £358/t across the country for spot delivery. %XWZLWKRXWWKHLUFDNHGHPDQGIHHGÀUPV But levels slide by about £5/t next month and would be even gloomier. Overall ruminant sales another similar reduction for the February to ZHUHWRQQHVGRZQGXULQJWKHÀUVWQLQH April run. months of this year. But higher margin dairy Farmers and compounder buying interest in FRPSRXQGVVDOHVZHUHDKHDG IXUWKHUIRUZDUGSRVLWLRQVGLHGRͿLQWKHH[SHF- 1RPLQDOO\IHHGUDZPDWHULDOPDUNHWVKDG WDWLRQRIDQHTXDOO\SUHFLSLWDWHSULFHIDOODFURVV LQGLFDWHGD\HDURQ\HDU WIDOOLQFDNHFRVWV WKHERDUG0D\2FWREHUUXQLVTXRWHGDW But this drop has not appeared on all compa- to £318/t—also £30/t more than early October. nies’ price lists since they were encouraged Yet global production remains on course by their farmer customers’ orders to buy raw to rise by at least 27mt and demand by 14mt materials earlier. WKLV VHDVRQ $FFRUGLQJ WR WKH 86'$ RI This meant forward cover on most feed America’s soyabeans were harvested by the FRPSDQLHV·ERRNVZDVRXWE\RYHU WDJDLQVW end of October with traders forecasting an even WKHVSRWPDUNHW+RZHYHUODVWPRQWK·VUHFRY- bigger crop of nearly 110mt. ery in both domestic grain and protein values Brazil’s planting conditions have improved KDVJDLQHGÀUPVVRPHEUHDWKLQJVSDFHDQGPD\ ZLWK WKH UDLQ DQG VWD\V RQ FRXUVH IRU D PW further reduce the eventual price reduction. crop. But its logistical problems ensures its %XWDFRPELQDWLRQRIÀUPVVHHNLQJWRKROG Hipro meal is trading for at least £10/t more sales and the bitter struggle by two major play- than any origin supplies. HUV³0ROH9DOOH\DQG1:)³LVDOUHDG\EHQHÀW- While there is some trader optimism of a ing producers. GRZQZDUGSULFHDGMXVWPHQWIRUWKLVNH\YHJHWD- There are widespread reports of discounts EOHSURWHLQQRQHDUHZLOOLQJWRPDNHVLJQLÀFDQW of up to £30/t to win or hold tonnage by a wider bets. Any origin Hipro for November 2015 to range of suppliers. Rations have also been refor- April 2016 is just under £300/t delivered. PXODWHGZLWKFKHDSHUOHVVHͿHFWLYHLQJUHGLHQWV Imported rapemeal remains at a competitive WRRͿHUORZHQHUJ\FDNHDWXQGHU W RI+LSUR·VYDOXHDW WR WIRUVSRW Poorer beef and sheep farmgate prices are delivery over the country through to January. H[SHFWHG WR NHHS FRPSRXQG DQG EOHQG IHHG )HEUXDU\$SULO LV TXRWHG DW XS WR W PRUH volumes lower. Many have already switched where cover has been bought earlier by rumi- WRVWUDLJKWVZKLOHVLODJHFURSVDUHELJJHUDOEHLW QDQWIDUPHUVDQGIHHGÀUPVIRUXSWR WOHVV XQLPSUHVVLYH TXDOLW\ DQG QHZ IRUDJH PDL]H Rapemeal is also vulnerable to price com- varieties are recording higher yields. petition from Vivergo’s dried distillers’ grain This may chop cumulative ruminant sales as its ethanol plant runs near full capacity—so E\WGXULQJWKLVFDOHQGDU\HDU³HTXLYD- IDU:LWKDVLPLODUSURWHLQFRQWHQWLWLV WR lent to the annual output of about three mills. £180/t for spot delivery from south west Eng- While falling feed costs—and fuel is fol- land to Scotland. ORZLQJ³KDYHRͿVHWVRPHRIWKHPDUJLQSDLQRI 6XQÁRZHU VHHG DW FUXGH SURWHLQ DOVR GHFOLQLQJPLONSULFHVERWKGRPHVWLFDQGZRUOG rose—by about £8/t—to upwards of £180/t PLONYDOXHVUHPDLQXQGHUSUHVVXUH delivered this month. But producers’ negotiating position is 'RPHVWLFJUDLQSULFHVERXQFHGEDFNDVH[- IXUWKHUHQKDQFHGE\WKHQHZWFDSDFLW\ SRUWDQGKRPHGHPDQGWRRNRͿZLWKIHHGZKHDW ruminant compound feed mill at Ayr. A John trading at £128/t plus delivered in East Anglia )HUJXVVRQYHQWXUHSDUWQHUHGE\0ROH9DOOH\LW DQGWKHVRXWK WPRUHRQ+XPEHUVLGHDQG is due on stream next month. Provided it is on up to £140/t further north and into Scotland. VFKHGXOHLWVLPSDFWZLOOULSSOHDFURVV%ULWDLQ·V Feed barley was trading at a £10 to £15/t western ruminant feed industry as surplus price discount in much of England and up to manufacturing capacity grows. £30 in the north and Scotland. +RZHYHUWKHVTXHH]HRQIHHGFRPSDQLHV· 7KLVPDNHVSDOPNHUQHOVDW WR W ZRUNLQJFDSLWDODQGSURÀWPDUJLQVLVDOVRH[- delivered more attractive. BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 13 GOLD CUP COMMENT )HUWLOLW\NH\WRKHUGSUR¿W This month John Taylor, herd manager at 2014 NMR/RABDF Gold Cup winners Worthy Farm in Somerset, reports on heifer performance and explains fertility management in the herd. he cows have settled really these work really well, so well that Twell onto their winter ration I don’t do a late night check any now and although production is more, unless there are cows calv- slightly down on last year, milk ing that is. I thought I was pretty quality is a lot better at 4.0% fat good at spotting bulling cows but and 3.25% protein. We get a small it’s surprising how many it picks butterfat bonus over 3.5% so that up that I didn’t see and it’s also will add 1p per litre—a little way useful for picking up low activity towards the price cuts. cows as well. I think production is down a I carry out all the AI myself as I lot as we have about 33% heifers feel it gives you a good insight into which is high for us, and as we general cow health. Usually the are calving our heifers younger better the bulling string the easier , WKLQN WKHLU ÀUVW ODFWDWLRQ ZLOO to AI and the better the chance drop slightly although lifetime of getting pregnant. I see good dairy yield should increase. This fertility as a top priority to bottom LV FRQÀUPHG E\ RXU HQG RI \HDU Heat detection collars have worked well in the herd at Worthy Farm. OLQHSURÀWDQGVHHHDFKFRZDVD NMR records which show a big- challenge. I operate a simple AI ger gap between cows and heifers be spot on at the moment and long short of maize doesn’t help but system of cow bulling morning— yields. It has been running at may it continue, as it has such a this year has been much better as AI pm, cow bulling pm—AI next DERXW NJ GLͿHUHQFH EXW KDV long-term bearing on fertility. The we had plenty of maize and next morning. jumped to 1,600kg this year. The downside of this is that the cows year looks even better. In 2013 we I take each cow that repeat cows averaged just over 13,000kg are bulling really strongly and actually ran out of maize at the end breeds as a personal failure, even with heifers doing 11,400kg. this is causing a few problems. RI-XO\WKHJUDSKVKRZVWKHHͿHFW more so when we get negative Obviously three times a day We have had three trodden teats on fertility. PD’s because that means not only milking is the next step but I still in the past couple of weeks and We replaced maize with have I not got her in calf, but I’ve feel our cows would be stood up have had to turn a few old girls in crimped wheat and although the also missed a heat as well. for too long and moved about too to the loose yard to recover after a cows milked just as well and milk I did my DIYAI training course much causing more lameness and I rampant night. quality was okay, conception rates about 27 years ago whilst work- think we would only achieve a 7% We don’t usually serve any dropped to about 30% ing at Trewithen Dairy to 8% rise which doesn’t justify the cows until 70 days but I have for three months. This in Cornwall. It’s the extra costs. No doubt the heifers started serving some of the lower year has been much only training course I would probably gain most, but at yielders a bit earlier, it seems a better with conception KDYHHYHUGRQHEXWÀYH what cost to fertility? waste not to when some are on rates staying at well days well spent with I keep getting told I should their third heat at about 60 days. over 45% throughout Mr Tudor-Owen, a fun have a separate heifer group, and We seem to have a lot of cows bull- the year. lecturer. I think perhaps with calving them ing at 21 days after calving which Since switching to We are now only younger, it is an option—but our is unusual for us and the vet is not all Alta all the time our using genomic bulls heifers seem to stand up for them- seeing too many not bulling at 70 fertility has definitely positive in DPR and PL selves pretty well and are far more days. improved and using daughter preg rates and aggressive feeders than our cows. Fertility has always been only easy calving bulls John Taylor. productive life and hope I think the secret is plenty of feed pretty good at Worthy but we helps a lot as we rarely in the future this will space and only 85% stocking rate always seem to struggle when have to calve a cow. I’m a great make our cows even more fertile, in the cubicles. cows are at grass from August to believer in leaving the cow alone easier to manage and last longer. Our transition cows seem to October. Probably always getting and only interrupting when you Sounds too good to be true, but have to. Something you learn with here’s hoping! experience but still get wrong oc- Well 2014 turned out to be a casionally. fantastic year for all at Worthy. As soon as a cow calves we There will certainly never be an- always give them 4ml Oxytocin other like it. Personally I’ve ticked to help them cleanse and all third a few boxes on my bucket list, the calvers get a calcium bolus and a biggest obviously being the Gold bottle under the skin if suspicion Cup. Unfortunately the wife was of milk fever. We do not get very not impressed with a few of the many cows with whites and don’t others, perhaps a few Christmas carry out any post calving checks drinks will change her mind. unless we suspect a cow is dirty. Wishing you all a Merry We have De-Laval heat detec- Christmas and a happy New Year tion collars on all the cows and from all at Worthy. 14 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 BARRY WILSON COMMENTS EU dairy & milk prices none of the City analysts have pointed out that Müller have got a snip. In January 2012 Müller paid £280m for There is something of a contest going on among some Robert Wiseman Dairies, about 19ppl for their liquid analysts at the moment over who can be the most milk business. Today Müller are paying £80m for DC’s bearish in their prognostications, with some predict- milk business, which works out at less than 7ppl. OK so ing that dairy and milk prices will fall below the Wiseman’s assets are better and DC’s business is mak- last collapse in 2009. I don’t buy this. Average EU ing losses—but so were Wiseman last year! farmgate milk prices in December seem certain to ——In the recent past the UK milk industry was striped average under 33c/kg, the lowest since the last half of horizontally like a football jersey. At the top, in Scotland 2012, and more than 7c (18%) lower than they were Wiseman held sway. In the north and Midlands, Express Dairies at the start of the year—but still at least 30% higher than the low were in charge. In the south Unigate and DC slugged it out. But point in the summer of 2009 when prices fell to 24.5c/kg. Today the proposed deal between Müller and DC has turned the stripes average EU butter prices are 40% higher than they were in 2009, vertical. Draw a line from Dundee to Southampton and a near per- SMP prices are 20% higher, WMP prices are 32% higher, Cheddar fect division of the country is achieved: Müller’s operations in the prices are 50% higher and whey powder prices are more than dou- west and Arla’s in the east. The untidy exception to this symmetry ble where they were in 2009. So don’t let anyone talk the market is DC’s Chadwell Heath dairy in east London. At the last count, down more than it is. DC operated a network of 72 depots which will bolt nicely on to the Müller + Dairy Crest Wiseman chain of six transport-only depots and four dairy depots. Some quick wins can be achieved in rationalising these two estates. As the parties to the deal admit, the proposed sale of Dairy Crest’s big &XULRXVO\WKH:LVHPDQQHWZRUNZDVQHYHUTXLWHÀQLVKHGRͿZLWK but chronically loss-making liquid milk division to Müller Wise- no depot for London and the southeast. Perhaps a visionary in East man—which has long looked like a no-brainer—and the 15% in- Kilbride foresaw a time when a very desirable piece of real estate crease in the DC share price between the beginning of October and WRWKHHDVWRI/RQGRQPLJKWEHFRPHDYDLODEOH6WDͿDWWKHELJ6HY- ZKHQWKHGHDOZDVÁDJJHGVXJJHVWVWKDWVRPHRQHJXHVVHGZKDW ernside dairy in Gloucestershire are already anxiously looking over was on the cards—will clearly face some high hurdles at the com- their shoulders over future prospects, halfway between Wiseman’s petition authorities. The OFT has had a long obsession with the heavyweight plants at Bridgwater and Droitwich. UK liquid milk business, even when there were ten suppliers in the 1990s. In 2003, the OFT took six months to review the proposed ³³0D\EHWKHPRVWÁDWWHULQJWKLQJWRVD\DERXWWKHSHUIRUPDQFH takeover of Express Dairies by Arla Foods, which they ultimately of DC since their virtual creation in 1979 is that while DC remain did, “unreservedly”. So will the OFT allow the move from three standing their two main British competitors in the 1980s, Unigate to two? Probably, in view of a number of factors: There are now and Northern Foods, have entirely disappeared from the scene. half a dozen regional operators bigger than ever before: Medina, Back in the 1990s, as the MMB/DC prepared for deregulation, Freshways, Payne’s, Graham’s, Braeforge, Cotteswold and others DC launched a major retrenchment that saw large chunks of their who between them now handle up to 1.5bn litres. Apart from Mark EXVLQHVVVROGRUFORVHG'&ZHUHVXFFHVVIXOO\ÁRDWHGLQIRU Allen’s obstinate refusal to see the writing on the wall, DC’s liquid £250m. Over the next three years they reversed tack and launched milk business has looked doomed for some time. There are now ten a major buying spree, including Raines and Yoplait UK, and cul- substantial supermarket chains operating in the UK and they are minated in their buying most of the rest of Unigate for £220m. ensuring that customers get low-priced milk. Indeed it could be $SDUWIURPWKHLUEULHIÁLUWDWLRQZLWK6W+XEHUWLQ)UDQFHWKDWZDV VDLGWKDWWKHVHWHQDUHNQRFNLQJVXFKVSRWVRͿSURFHVVRUVWKDWPLON about it for the last ten years, a breathtaking lack of ambition. In SURFHVVLQJSURÀWPDUJLQVDUHSUREDEO\QRZDWDQDOOWLPHORZWKLV WKHSDVWÀYH\HDUV'&·VVKDUHSULFHLVXSDQGWKH&(2·VVDOD- proposed takeover could give Arla and Müller a bit more clout in ry has doubled to £1.28m. Last month, 200,000 shares were issued the market. Maybe farmers will argue that this proposed merger WRWKH'&H[HFXWLYHVDWSHDFKDSDSHUSURÀWRI threatens their milk price. But would they be any better protected ³³$QGDOOEHWVDUHQRZRͿRQKRZORQJWKHUXPSRI'&ZLOOVXU- by a lame duck DC? vive on its own. Lactalis are hovering. Why did they recruit former ——Maybe because they are so relieved to be shot of a loss-maker, senior Dairy Crest executive Mark Taylor? BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 15 MILK PRICE LEAGUE TABLE MILK PRICE LEAGUE TABLE— MILK PRICE CHANGES—2014-15 September 2014 Monthly Annual April May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan price average Price Average $0&RVWDQGOLTXLG 'DLU\&UHVW0 63UR¿OH $0&RVWDQGPDQXI 'DLU\&UHVW0 69DULDEOH $UOD'LUHFW/LTXLG 0OOHU:LVHPDQ7HVFR $UOD'LUHFW0DQXI 3DUNKDP)DUPV $UOD)RRGV7HVFR $UOD0//ODQG\'LU/LT 0OOHU:LVHPDQ6DLQVEXU\ $UOD0//ODQG\'LUHFW 'DLU\&UHVW6DLQVEXU\3UR¿OH $UOD0//LTXLG 'DLU\&UHVW6DLQVEXU\9DULDEOH 0OOHU:LVHPDQ&RRS $UOD0/0DQXI $UOD)RRGV6DLQVEXU\ $UOD0/10DQXI &UHGLWRQ $UOD6DLQVEXU\ )LUVW0LON7HVFR $UOD7HVFR 'DLU\&UHVW'DYLGVWRZ3UR¿OH 'DLU\&UHVW'DYLGVWRZ9DULDEOH %DUEHU$- 5* $UOD'LUHFW0DQXIDFWXULQJ %HOWRQ&KHHVH %DUEHU$- 5* &UHGLWRQ'DLU\ 3DWWHPRUHV 'DLU\&UHVW'DYLGVWRZ 0OOHU:LVHPDQ0LON3DUW $UOD'LUHFW/LTXLG 'DLU\&UHVW/LTXLG *UDKDP¶V'DLULHV 'DLU\&UHVW0 6 :HQVOH\GDOH 'DLU\&UHVW6DLQVEXU\ 'DOH)DUP*% 'DOH)DUP*% $UOD0//ODQG\UQRJ'LU6HDVRQDO $UOD0//ODQG\UQRJ'LU /LT 'DOH)DUP1, $UOD0//ODQG\UQRJ'LU$ % )LUVW0LON&RPS %HOWRQ&KHHVH )LUVW0LON/LTXLG$ 'DLU\&UHVW/LTXLG3UR¿OH )LUVW0LON/LTXLG%0DQXI 'DLU\&UHVW/LTXLG9DULDEOH *ODQELD/ODQJHIQL )LUVW0LON7HVFR 0HDGRZ)RRGV&RPS/HYHO *ODQELD/ODQJHIQL :\NH)DUPV *UDKDP¶V'DLULHV 0HDGRZ)RRGV&RPS6HDVRQDO 6RXWK&DHUQDUIRQ&UHDPHULHV /DFWDOLV&DOHGRQLDQ )LUVW0LON&RPSRVLWLRQDO 0HDGRZ)RRGV )LUVW0LON/LTXLG% 0DQXISRRO 0:'&RRS $UOD0/10DQXI6HDVRQDO 0:'EDVHOLTXLG $0&R6WDQGDUG0DQXIDFWXULQJ $UOD0/0DQXI6HDVRQDO 0:'6DLQVEXU\ $0&R6WDQGDUG/LTXLG 0:'7HVFR $UOD0/0DQXI$ % 3DUNKDP)DUPV $UOD0/10DQXI$ % 3DWWHPRUHV )LUVW0LON/LTXLG$ $UOD0//RQGRQ/LTXLG 3D\QH¶V 'DOH)DUP1, 6RXWK&DHUQDUIRQ&UHDPHULHV 0LONSULFHVOLVWHGDERYHZLOOYDU\DFFRUGLQJWRWKHDPRXQWRI milk that is required by each retailer; additional milk will be paid :HQVOH\GDOH for at Dairy Crest’s standard liquid milk contract price; the milk :\NH)DUPV price above assumes that all litres produced are sold into the GHGLFDWHGPLONSRROV NOTES TO THE TABLE ABOVE ,QFOXGHG LV D SSO ERQXV ZKLFK IDUPHUV JHW ZKHQ WKH\ 3ULFHVOLVWHGDERYHDUHH[FOXVLYHRIFDSLWDOUHWHQWLRQVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQFKDUJHVIDUPHUJURXSVXEVFULSWLRQVDQG9$7 VLJQHGXSZLWKWKH3URPDUFRVWLQJVVXUYH\ 3ULFHFKDQJHVDUHOLVWHGDVUHSRUWHGE\WKHSURFHVVRUVEXWPD\QRWEHIXOO\UHÀHFWHGLQWKH'DLU\&RVWDQGDUGOLWUHSULFH 3ULFHVOLVWHGDERYHDUHLQFOXVLYHRI'DLU\&ROHY\VHDVRQDOLW\ 7KHVHFRQWUDFWVZLOOUHFHLYHDWKSD\PHQWWKHIRUHFDVWLV 7KHVHFRQWUDFWVZLOOUHFHLYHDWKSD\PHQWWKHIRUHFDVWIRUWKLVLVFXUUHQWO\SSO FXUUHQWO\SSO )URP$SULO)LUVW0LONRSHUDWHVWZRPDLQPLONSRROVDOLTXLGSRRO WKHH[LVWLQJ/LTXLG$FRQWUDFW DQGDPDQXIDFWXULQJ 7KHUHZLOOEHDGHGXFWLRQIRUEDODQFLQJFRVWVRQDOOOLWUHVDERYH SRRO0LONVXSSOLHGXQGHUWKHH[LVWLQJ+LJKODQGV ,VODQGVFRQWUDFWSOXVDFRPSRVLWLRQDOFRQWUDFWDQGDQHZµ/LTXLG%¶FRQWUDFW \RXU%$'3LQOLQHZLWKWKHPLONEDODQFLQJVFKHPH IRUPVWKHPDQXIDFWXULQJSRRO Milk prices are ranked according to the annual average price that ,QFUHDVHVDQQRXQFHGE\$UOD0LON/LQNDSSO\IURP$SULO0D\6HSWHPEHU6HSWHPEHU DQG2FWREHU ZRXOGEHSDLGRQDFRQWUDFWIRUPRQWKVJRLQJIRUZDUGLIWKH $UOD0LON/LQNDQG$UOD0LON&RRSHUDWLYHPHPEHUVWRUHFHLYHGSSOLQFUHDVHIURPWKH)HEUXDU\ SUHVHQWSULFHVFKHGXOHUHPDLQHGWKHVDPH3ULFHVOLVWHGDERYHH[- 7KHUHZLOOEHDGHGXFWLRQIRUEDODQFLQJFRVWVRQDOOOLWUHVDERYHLQGLYLGXDO%$'3LQOLQHZLWKWKHPLONEDODQFLQJVFKHPH FOXGHFDSLWDOUHWHQWLRQVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQFKDUJHVJURXSVXEVDQG 3ULFHGHFUHDVHIURP$SULO-XO\G$XJXVWDQG6HSWHPEHU 9$7EXWLQFOXGHWKH'DLU\&ROHY\DQGVHDVRQDOLW\DGMXVWPHQWV)RU 3ULFHGHFUHDVHDSSOLHGIURP$XJXVW PRUHLQIRUPDWLRQJRWRZZZGDLU\FRRUJXNPDUNHWLQIRUPDWLRQ SSODGGHGWR0 6SUHPLXPERQLVRQ-XO\ 16 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 MILK PRICES European milk Lely cows prices heading manage their down to 30c own time urope’s biggest dairy co-op Arla amba in Denmark have cut their Efarmgate milk price for December by 2c to 32.3c/kg (33.3c/litre, equivalent to about 25.6ppl). They have now cut their price by 10c (23%) since April. FrieslandCampina, the second biggest European dairy co-op, have not yet announced their December price but they are also expected to cut by around 2c; their November price was 34.5c/kg (35.5c/litre or about SSO 7KHVPDOOHU'XWFKFKHHVHPDNLQJFRRS'2&.DDVDUHWKHÀUVW major European milk buyer to cut their price to under 30c/kg. Arla in the UK have now cut their main liquid and cheese contracts by 1.63ppl to 25.22ppl (for the British Dairying/DairyCo standard litre). They have now cut this price by 7.98ppl (24%) since the spring. Arla have now FXWWKHLUOLTXLGFRQWUDFWSULFHE\VLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHWKDQ0OOHU:LVHPDQ RU'DLU\&UHVW $UODKDYHDOVRFXWWKHLU$UOD0LON/LQNFKHHVH FRQWUDFWSULFH E\VLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHWKDQ'DLU\&UHVWKDYHFXWWKHLU 'DYLGVWRZSULFH $VZHZHQWWRSUHVVWKHUHZDVQRKLQWWKDW0: or DC were about to cut their December milk prices. Somerset cheesemaker Wyke Farms DUH WKH ÀUVW PLON EX\HU to announce a price cut for January, down by 1.4ppl, taking their price down to 24.95ppl (for the BD/DairyCo standard litre), down SSOVLQFH-XQH7KLVSULFHLVQRZRQO\DERYHWKH)LUVW0LONDQG 8QLWHG'DLU\)DUPHUVFRQWUDFWV:\NHVD\´2XURZQGDLU\IDUPV are investigating all possibilities and will be taking any necessary DFWLRQWRPDQDJHFDVKÁRZLQWKLVGLFXOWSHULRGDQGZHVKDUHWKH unwelcome news with all milk suppliers.” The Dairy Crest formula milk price is to be cut by 0.798ppl for De- FHPEHUWRSSOGRZQMXVWXQGHUSSOVLQFH0D\%\FRPSDULVRQWKH standard DC liquid contract has been cut by 5.6p since June and LTO EUROPEAN MILK LELY ASTRONAUT A4 the formula is now 2.4ppl higher PRICE LEAGUE TABLE than the base liquid contract. • LTO LEAGUE TABLE (c/kg) Sept 12mth Our cows know exactly when it’s time to The average EU September avge be milked. Give your cows this trust and farmgate milk price was 37.47c/ Hameen O. (Fin) 46.34 46.61 kg, down 7% since January, ac- confidence and they will repay you with Granarolo (It) 43.87 44.73 cording to the latest monthly higher quality milk. /72 PLON SULFH OHDJXH WDEOH Sodiaal (Fr) 42.04 37.79 which is compiled by the Dutch Dairy Crest (UK) 41.95 39.87 For more information on the Dairy Board for the European Bongrain (Fr) 40.24 39.61 Dairy Farmers Organisation Danone (Fr) 39.05 38.73 .GN[|#UVTQPCWV#ECNN /72 Lactalis (Fr) 38.48 38.40 There has been a huge vari- QTVGZVVJGYQTF.GN[VQCPF F/C (Neth) 36.96 43.68 ation in price cuts this year as YGYKNNECNN[QWDCEM dairy commodity prices have Müller (Ger) 36.47 38.52 FUDVKHG0LONSULFHFXWVWKLV\HDU First Milk (UK) 36.11 37.79 have been minimal in Finland, Arla Foods (Den) 35.74 41.59 Italy and France; UK prices are DMK (Ger) 35.09 39.18 helped by the strength of ster- Milcobel (Belg) 32.68 39.69 ling; cuts have averaged 10%- 12% in Germany, by Arla and DOC Kaas (Neth) 32.05 40.51 by F/C; but the cuts have aver- Kerry (Ire) 32.02 37.08 aged around 20% in Belgium, in Glanbia (Ire) 30.50 36.80 Ireland and by DOC (Neth). The Average 37.47 40.04 GLͿHUHQWLPSDFWRIZRUOGSULFHV Emmi (Switz) 53.33 51.81 is most tellingly illustrated by Fonterra 26.86 36.88 farmgate milk prices in the US innovators in agriculture and NZ. Prices so far this year in US avge 47.53 39.52 NZ are down 34% whereas they Ranked on September prices. up 25% in the US. BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 17 CROSSBREEDING Italian crossbred performance FRQ¿UPV8.SURGXFHUV¶FKRLFHV $UHFHQWYLVLWE\WZR8.PLONSURGXFHUVWR,WDO\KLJKOLJKWHGWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRI1RUZHJLDQ 5HGFURVVEUHGFRZVLQKLJKSURGXFWLRQ+ROVWHLQKHUGVLQWKH3R9DOOH\,WFRQ¿UPHGWR WKHPWKHDELOLW\RIWKHEUHHGWRFRPELQHJRRGSURGXFWLRQZLWKIHUWLOLW\DQGORQJHYLW\ Crossbreds in the mixed herd of Stefanio Corini in Italy. Crossbred cows on the farm of Bodmin milk producer James Willcocks. he figures speak for them- and Norwegian Red crosses that Typical of herds in the region, their this is likely to fall to around 50c/l Tselves, says David Pettit, farm were managed side by side— ration is based on a TMR with (40p). Stefanio estimates that his manager for Denhay Farms in housed all year round and fed the mainly maize silage and ryegrass cost of production is around 40 Dorset. “The Po Valley is a tra- same TMR. with bought-in lucerne hay and a euro cents/l (31p). ditional Holstein heartland with Stefanio Corini’s 200-cow blend that includes soya, cotton So far he has 71 crossbreds high production herds housed 365 herd 60 miles east of Milan is a seed and minerals. running alongside his 132 Holstein days. Crossbreeding was working good example. He introduced the cows on the 66 hectare unit. His KHUH³WKHÀJXUHVVSRNHIRUWKHP- Norwegian Red to see if he can milk records show production by Milk prices and costs selves. Milk yield and solids were breed a cow that is better suited breed and he is very encouraged similar but the crossbreds had far to his farm than the pure Holstein. A combination of a basic price with just a small drop in yield that better fertility, lower somatic cell While not wanting to lose yield of 28 euro cents/litre (22p) from LVPRUHWKDQRͿVHWZLWKEHWWHUPLON counts and they were stronger and milk quality, he was seeking his local co-op, that produces the protein, lower cell counts and far cows that were easier to manage better fertility, a stronger cow to famous Italian hard cheese Grana better fertility, as shown in Table 1. and had far fewer health issues.” cope better with a housed high Padano, is topped up based on Having considered the third 0U3HWWLWUHIHUVWRRFLDOPLON production system and a smaller the retrospective cheese price. cross options, he has opted for recorded figures in the Italian cow that would bring greater feed This year the price paid has been some Fleckvich to add to the hy- herds he saw with pure Holsteins HFLHQF\ around 60 euro cents/l (47p) but brid vigour and also crossed again The new name in hoof hygiene Contact18 your Progiene hygiene specialists Tel: 0808 178 1010 E-mail: [email protected] DAIRYING December 2014 CROSSBREEDING Stefanio Corini’s milk records for Holsteins XQLW:HQHHGHGWREUHHGVWURQJ and Norwegian Red crossbred cows. fertile cows with good production ZLWKKLJKPLONTXDOLW\DQGORZFHOO Holsteins Crossbreds counts. Cows in milk 132 71 ´7KLV LV ZKHUH RQ SDSHU ZH Milk yield (305 days) 10,913 10,547 thought that the Norwegian cross ZRXOG VXLW XV EHWWHUµ KH DGGV Fat % 4.03 4.07 ´7KH EUHHG KDV D SURYHQ WUDFN Protein % 3.29 3.40 UHFRUG RI LQFUHDVLQJ IHUWLOLW\ E\ SCC (cells/ml) 260,000 160,000 WKDQNVWRPRUHWKDQ\HDUV RIEUHHGLQJIRUKHDOWKDQGIHUWLOLW\ Calving interval (days) 394 375 as opposed to the Holstein where Days open 128 93 VHOHFWLRQIRUWKHVHWUDLWVLVIDLUO\UH- Calving to 1st service (days) 76 65 cent. And it didn’t look as though Insemination per pregnancy 2.6 1.9 ZHFRXOGFRPSURPLVHPLON\LHOGV SDUWLFXODUO\7KH1RUZHJLDQ5HG Head detection rate (%) 48 60 ticked all the boxes. Conception rate (%) 33 49 ´6R ZH FDUHIXOO\ VHOHFWHG Stefanio Corini. Pregnancy Rate (%) 15 31 bulls within the breed and used WKHPRQFRZVDFURVVDOORXU WKHLU IHUWLOLW\ DQG KHUG ORQJHYLW\ Survival to 2nd lactation (%) 82 100 herds in a three month period for WR PXFK KLJKHU OHYHOV DV D UHVXOW Survival to 3rd lactation (%) 52 92 WKHSDVWWZR\HDUV7KHUHVXOWLQJ of introducing cross breeding. Survival to 4th lactation (%) 15 69 crossbreds will form the basis of ´2XUWDUJHWLVWRLPSURYHRXU WKHDXWXPQFDOYLQJKHUGµ FDOYLQJLQWHUYDOIURPGD\VDQG to the Norwegian Red. Both these +ROVWHLQFRZRQDQ\RIWKH'RUVHW 7ZR \HDUV RQ DQG 'DYLG LV PDLQWDLQ RU LPSURYH PLON IURP options secure a better male calf EDVHG XQLWV WKDW VXSSRUW QRZVHUYLQJWKHFURVVEUHGKHLIHUV IRUDJH IURP OLWUHV ZLWKRXW price than the Holstein. He is then FRZV SOXV IROORZHUV WKH VZLWFK WRFDOYHLQ6HSWHPEHU FRPSURPLVLQJ DYHUDJH SURGXF- crossing back to the Holstein. WR DXWXPQ FDOYLQJ FDOOHG IRU LP- WLRQRIOLWUHV:H·GDOVRKRSH $QGORRNLQJDKHDGÀYH\HDUV SURYHG IHUWLOLW\ ´7KH TXLFNHVW WR LPSURYH ORQJHYLW\ IURP WR What cross next? 6WHIDQLRVD\VWKDWPRUHWKDQ ZD\WRHVWDEOLVKWKLVKHUGZDVWR nearer four lactations.” of his herd will be Norwegian pool all the heifers born in a three The imminent decision is where 2QWRSRIWKLV'DYLGFDQVHH Red crossbreds but he will keep a month period and stock the one QH[W" ´:H·YH RSWHG WR FURVV WKH FRVWVDYLQJVLQKHDOWKDQGZHOIDUH small group of Holsteins as a refer- F1 cross heifers again with Nor- DV WKH YHW FDQ WDNH RQ D PRUH HQFH7KH&RULQLVDGPLWWKDWWKH\ ZHJLDQ5HGWRFUHDWHDQ)FURVVµ SURDFWLYH UROH DQG PLQLPLVH ÀUH can’t ignore the contribution of H[SODLQV'DYLG´7KLVPHDQVWKDW ÀJKWLQJZRUN the Norwegian Red crosses to the DOWKRXJKZHORVHVRPHRIWKHK\- VXVWDLQDELOLW\RIWKHLUGDLU\KHUG EULGYLJRXUZHFDQFRQVROLGDWHWKH Crossbreds on Bodmin 'DYLG 3HWWLW LQWURGXFHG 1RU- VXUYLYDELOLW\DQGIHUWLOLW\EHQHÀWV wegian Red sires into one of from the Norwegian Reds. We will Although Bodmin producer James 'HQKD\·V IRXU XQLWV³D XQLW KH then cross back to the Holstein. :LOOFRFNVWRRNQRFRQYLQFLQJWKDW GHVFULEHV DV ¶GLFXOW· ´5RXJK :KHQZHKDYHPDWXUHDQLPDOVRQ crossbred cows can hold their VWRQ\ODQGPDGHFURSSLQJGLFXOW WKHJURXQGZHPD\ORRNDJDLQDW own with the Holstein in terms of VR ZH GHFLGHG WR PDNH WKH introducing a third cross.” SURGXFWLYLW\DQGRXWSHUIRUPWKHP FRZKDJUDVVEDVHGV\VWHPDQG The figures and cattle that when it comes to health and fertil- VZLWFKWKHKHUGWRDXWXPQFDOYLQJ 'DYLGVDZLQ,WDO\DUHPDNLQJKLP LW\ KH ZDV LPSUHVVHG ZLWK WKHLU WRRYHUFRPHWKHIHHGLQJSUREOHPV WKLQN VHULRXVO\ DERXW XVLQJ WKH YHUVDWLOLW\ DQG VXLWDELOLW\ WR KLJK RQODQGWKDWLVSURQHWRGU\XSLQ Norwegian Red in other herds at SURGXFWLRQV\VWHPV mid-summer.” 'HQKD\´:HVDZWUDGLWLRQDO+RO- James has established a cross- While not running an extreme David Pettit from Dorset. VWHLQKHUGVLQ,WDO\WKDWKDGWDNHQ Continued on page 20. A HOOFCOUNT DIGICUR FOOTBATH AUTOMATIC FOOTBATH • Dual action of glutaraldehyde & surfactants for WITH INSTALLATION rapid acting hoof cleaning with long lasting effect • Highly concentrated and low application cost WIN • Free from QAC, formalin, heavy metals and antibiotics ENTER ONLINE AT: www.progiene-dairy.com BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 19 CROSSBREEDING Continued from page 19. bred herd of 300 cows on the fam- ily’s 304 hectare unit and combines the strengths of the Brown Swiss, Norwegian Red and New Zealand Friesian in a spring and autumn calving system. Cows are grazed as long as possible—typically up to nine months of the year for some cows. He admits that he did make a mistake early on in using Brown Swiss sires that were too big. “We ended up with cows that were too big and not ideal for our extended grazing system,” says James. “The lesson here is to select carefully within a breed—just as you would when selecting a Holstein sire. We seek a lot of help from Geno and this is important.” Despite appearing to be a more extensive system than those seen in Italy, James has similar goals to the Po Valley producers. “We moved from a black and white herd but wanted to maintain yields—our target is 8,000 litres James Willcocks from Bodmin has used Norwegian Red, Brown Swiss and NZ Friesians on his 300-cow herd. plus with half the milk from forage SOXV VRPH EXͿHU IHHGLQJ ZKHQ spent years working within one that produces milk on a fresh and high protein milk from cows fed required. The latest heifers are on breed but overall, there’s no dried forage based diet near Reg- on a silage-free diet. target, producing 28 litres a day, a doubt that the crossbred is more gio Emilia. Despite being one of Now milking 10 Holstein PRQWKLQWRWKHLUODFWDWLRQ:HÀQG HFLHQW DQG KDV WKH SRWHQWLDO WR the leading Holstein herds in the cross Norwegian Reds alongside that this doesn’t drop much—they improve the sustainability of our area, the Donas wanted to breed a their Holsteins, the results are have a fairly level production dairy herds,” he adds. “It might VOLJKWO\VPDOOHUDQGPRUHHFLHQW very encouraging. Yields have re- curve.” be worth them trying a few cross- cow that was easy to manage and mained around 12,800 litres while breds and see how they perform in had good milk quality with low the crossbred group is yielding their own system.” cell counts. Their milk is taken 3.43% protein compared with the Breed strengths And that’s exactly what twice daily to the local co-op for Holstein’s 3.22% and the days While the Brown Swiss provides Iaverio and Renata Dona have Parmesan cheese production open average is 105 days with a excellent legs, feet and yield char- done with their 130-cow herd ZKLFKVSHFLÀHVORZFHOOFRXQWDQG FRQFHSWLRQ UDWH WR ÀUVW VHUYLFH LQ acteristics, James uses the New the crossbreds of 40% compared Zealand Friesian for its grazing with 119 days and 24.3% in the strength. And the Norwegian Holsteins. Red adds great health and fertility EHQHÀWV More Norwegian Reds “Their fertility and conception rates are excellent. They show 7KHVHÀJXUHVDUHJRRGHQRXJKWR strong signs of bulling—often for convince the Donas that crossbreds 24 hours. This makes life a lot are the way forward. They have easier!” 40 more Norwegian Red heifers Equally important is long last- joining the milking herd in the ing, hassle free cows. “Like the next two years and it is likely that Italian producers, we want more more will follow. For them, the ODFWDWLRQVSHUFRZ)RXURUÀYHLV crossbred as enhanced their exist- now fairly normal here.” ing top quality genetics and these James acknowledges that F1 cows will be crossed back to the many producers are sceptical of in- Holstein to maintain the strengths troducing ‘other’ breeds. “They’ve Iaverio and Renata Dona have experimented with crossbreds. of both breeds. 01270 616816 Used by farmers, tanker drivers and processors – the dairy industry’s favourite antibiotic milk test 20 BRITISH DAIRYING December 2014 Protects every cow every milking The Cluster Purge Plus system is proven to reduce the risk of mastitis transfer across your herd, improving udder health and saving you money. State of the Art s .O INTERFERENCE IN EXISTING MILKING SYSTEM s 0OST RINSE WITH FRESH WATER TO PROTECT MILK AND LINER s 0ROGRAMMABLE mUSH SEQUENCES s -ILK SWEEP OPTION TO RETRIEVE MILK s &ROST