Background Table 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PAPER TYPE The VMMC Experience Project The VMMC Experience Project is a 501(c)3 nonprofit organisation representing men, women, and children who are adversely affected by “voluntary medical male circumcision” (VMMC) programmes for HIV prevention in sub-Saharan Africa. Developed by native Ugandans and Kenyans, it is the only platform for VMMC-affected men and women to share their experiences without Western interference. Its aim is to empower affected communities to raise awareness of adverse health and human rights consequences of mass circumcision and the African resistance movement at large. The Project rejects coercive practices for VMMC, and supports male circumcision as an elective procedure for fully informed, consenting adults. Prince Hillary Maloba Mutebi Ramadhan David Okwalo Keneth Nuwamanya Executive Director Community Mobiliser Coordinator Assistant UN Report: African opposition to mass circumcision 1 Acknowledgements The VMMC Experience Project thanks the following individuals for their content, input, and suggestions: Lawrent Wayagara (Uganda) Idah Nabateregga (Germany) Khayelihle Nxumalo (SA) Edward Gitta Musisi (Uganda) Patrick Ocol (Uganda) Sithembile Mlotshwa (Zimbabwe) Freddie Jackson (Uganda) Ronald Atwijukire Katebire (Uganda) Ralilich Mutasa (Uganda) Steven M. (Kenya) Gagela Mthunzi (SA) Aaron Jonathan Mwesigwa (Uganda) Samson Okwi (Uganda) K. Sabone (Botswana) M.B. Floe (Zambia) “Ricky Reward” (Uganda) Peter Minini Salala (Kenya) Kalinda Zimba (Zambia) “Patrick” (Namibia) “Arthur” (Uganda) Cleophas Matete (Kenya) Kenny Sililo (Zambia) Steve Wamusoro (Kenya) Jonsky Oduko (Uganda) Samson Otieno (Kenya) Fuambai Ahmadu (Sierra Leone) Tina Wa Namenya (Kenya) Ronald Laku (Uganda) Apollo Otieno (Kenya) Swamy Gowd (India) Reagan Orodi (Kenya) Edward Tiba (Uganda) “Patrick” (Uganda) Diana Nyandigah (Kenya) Michael Ywaya (Kenya) Josephine Y. Sserwanga (Uganda) Bakali Maloba (Uganda) Izaq-Churchill Imbwaga (Kenya) Janet Adhiambo (Kenya) Fuaborogbe P. TitaSoni (Uganda) Faroak Awira (Uganda) Ochonge Ngoya (Kenya) Kenneth Otwoma (Kenya) Oromokoma Wod P’arangi (Uganda) John Bosco Diakin (Uganda) Maryanne Achieng Odira (Kenya) Flint Kennedy (Kenya) Benon Kisembo (Uganda) Patrick Omsugu (Uganda) Calvine Odero (Kenya) Pertross C.I. Lexington (Zambia) Samuel B. Senfuka (Uganda) Alfos Walega (Uganda) Victor Awara (Kenya) Tshepo Motlokwa (SA) Daniel Bakaki (Uganda) Agnes Namkendi (Uganda) Benard Ochieng (Kenya) D.B.N. Magubane (SA) Micheal Tagaywa (Uganda) Fred Ochitai (Kenya) Wuod Naph (Kenya) Fredricks Donald Swaartboi (Namibia) Juliet Tete Sande (Uganda) Simple Patrick Okode (Uganda) Awino Achieng (Kenya) Ps Sifiso Dlamini (Swaziland) Hillary Kaheebu (Uganda) Paolo Otieno (Uganda) Tinto Linto (Zimbabwe) Ndabezinhle Mntungwa (SA) Connie Harter Matovu (Uganda) Daniel Moita (Uganda) Elias Osiba (Kenya) Tawanda Damba (SA) Cyrus Njuguna (Kenya) Clea Odhiambo (Uganda) Basiliza Odima (Kenya) Sam Winchester Maleke (SA) Beda Odhiambo (Kenya) Girisimo Odwani (Uganda) Bless Orishaba (Uganda) Aphiwe Sphelele Mntungwa (SA) Easter Achieng (Kenya) David Arapi (Uganda) Mariam Agweng (Uganda) Mpho Emkay (SA) Bonface Omondi Nyangla (Kenya) John Bosco Beressa (Uganda) Benson Funi Mwaka (Uganda) Sibonelo Dlamini (SA) Shemeji McOlare (Kenya) Kwere Kejunas (Uganda) King Andrew Kusingura (Uganda) Javon Narshon (Kenya) Julius Okuto (Kenya) Kareem Amza (Uganda) Samuel Sanya (Uganda) Akanu Ujah Agwu (Nigeria) Elly Ellistrez (Kenya) Humble Patrick (Uganda) Osama O. Kagezimunnyo (Uganda) Mbali Mduduzi Skosana (SA) Mike Malatji (SA) Veronica Nakasa (Uganda) Pius Turyasingura (Uganda) Lelo Nxasana (SA) Peter Oduor (Kenya) Todd Mohammed (Uganda) Franco Nyeko P’Kamach (Uganda) Letsogile Osupile (Botswana) Phoebs P.J. Jamieson (SA) Cody Sodua (Uganda) Rap Ebuka Ikeorah (Nigeria) Orapeleng Figo Ikaneng (Botswana) Edina Nkangala (SA) Lichiri Kamados (Kenya) Okul Ramathan (Uganda) Tumi Mmagwe Lefa Tjala (Botswana) Netsayi Chimenya (SA) Ignatius Wasunga (Kenya) Themba Tak Khoza (Zambia) Boikhutso P.M. Monga (Botswana) Kaboni Whitney Gondwe (SA) John Orio Onyanga (Kenya) Mbako Nnyepi (Botswana) Azizi Loneman (Botswana) Mbali Maleta (SA) Richard Bradley Ovidico (Kenya) Themba Mdluli (SA) Aldrin W. Kgomonne (Botswana) Lapani Chisi Ngala (SA) Casmiel Otieno (Kenya) Simon Collery (Tanzania) Meso Tshalakwe (Botswana) Moque M. Ngwira (SA) Edwin Medu Casol (Uganda) David Mac’Olonde (Kenya) Gibson Magapa (Botswana) Elizabeth Sharon Chintolo (SA) Cadon Agar (Uganda) Humphrey Hala Nairobi (Kenya) Thabologo Ramahobo (Botswana) Nikky Katungu (Zambia) Alan Kiria (Uganda) Stella Oiro (Kenya) David Kele Monekwe (Botswana) Lucky Mafex (Uganda) Pian Gratib (Uganda) Ochieng Ochoro (Kenya) HaweMah I.B.R. (SA) Leenox Chiseko Jonas (SA) Ivan Masaka (Uganda) Fred Okello (Kenya) Lilly George Nyar (Kenya) Monica Nambelela (Namibia) Dan Nanamasiti (Uganda) Min Izo (Kenya) Dennis Otieno Oluoch (Kenya) Kilian Wombulu (Namibia) Morris Malala (Kenya) Dorcas Sarkozy (Kenya) Dorothy Ongoro (Kenya) Saviour Pondala (Zambia) Samson Dambroka (Uganda) Dan Ojoo Milaw (Kenya) Ochieng Ochoro (Kenya) Skhanyiso Koples (SA) Mattias Malongo Okoche (Kenya) Garang Okaka (Kenya) Martin G.T.C. (Lesotho) John Ochola (Kenya) Paul Bahaya (Uganda) Calvin Parma Sobatha (Botswana) Setlhomo R. Tshwanelang (Botswana) Michael Ndalama Mwale (Kenya) Loko Sateti (Uganda) Martin Nyakundi O’barimo (Kenya) Ras Manxo (Botswana) Mukena Misebezi (Zambia) “Samson” (Uganda) Ras Emmanuel (Namibia) Mundia Mulena (Zambia) Mandla M. Kabini (SA) Vincente Endegna (Uganda) Chilufya Supa Chilu (Zambia) Kawooya Godfrey Lwabaaga (Uganda) Fuduka Maria Kabini (SA) Barbara Asimi (Uganda) Susan Isaac Jere (Zambia) Richard Wasonga (Kenya) Lydia Mwape (Zambia) Jamira Namatovi (Uganda) C. Daaram Simakungwe (Zambia) Mandela Owuor (Kenya) Tim Hammond (USA) Kati Ishana (Uganda) Ingrid Nayame (Zambia) Onimo Onguru III (Kenya) Brian Earp (USA) Edith Nakawe (Uganda) Champo Simukoko (Zambia) David Oyola (Kenya) Sharon Mohammed (Uganda) G.T. Linyada Mbewe (Zambia) Omondi Kong’o (Kenya) Permissions Dr. Kisembre (Kenya) P. Zamubeef (Zambia) Antonio Anto Leonardo (Kenya) Jutta Reisinger (Austria) Eric Sifu Wamalwa (Kenya) Dan Disepo (SA) Christopher Chikwanda (Zambia) Victor Schiering (Germany) “James” (Uganda) Kingsmann Lesedi (Botswana) D.C.B. Mimiey (SA) James Loewen (USA) Christian Bahls (Germany) Mondli Botha (SA) Geoffrey Omondi (Kenya) Ulrich Fegeler (Germany) Bashir Shamsudin (Malaysia) Mbaakanyi Lenyatso (Botswana) Anatomical photos Kennedy Owino Odhiambo (Kenya) Klaus Rasmussen (Austria) Vuyo Mbiko Bhunqu (SA) Job Kajwang (Kenya) Kristian Rikardsen (Norway) Ivan Barigye Sabiiti (Uganda) L.T. (USA) Jutta Reisinger (Austria) Zex Kalipalire (Zambia) Axam Kasajja (Uganda) J.D.G. (USA) 2 UN Report: African opposition to mass circumcision Acronyms MoH = Ministry of Health FHI 360 = Family Health International – a US-based NGO VMMC = voluntary medical male circumcision (policy) which administers the Male Circumcision Consortium EIMC = early infant male circumcision (policy) (MMC) ABC = “abstain, be faithful, condomise” campaign PSI = Population Services International – a US-based NGO providing VMMC through PEPFAR funding SSA = sub-Saharan Africa = Johns Hopkins University – a US-based hub for SA = South Africa JHU VMMC and EIMC research and implementation through NGO = non-governmental organisation its Jhpiego subsidiary STI = sexually transmitted infection AAP = American Academy of Pediatrics ART = antiretroviral therapy United States government agencies: PrEP/PEP = pre-/post-exposure prophylaxis = President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief FGC/FGM = female genital cutting/mutilation PEPFAR = US Agency for International Development DHS = Demographic and Health Survey – a nationally USAID representative survey administered by USAID CDC = Centers for Disease Control TTS = Three Tier System – a priority ranking system DOD = Department of Defense for HIV/AIDS interventions proposed by the VMMC HHS = [Department of] Health and Human Services Experience Project NIH = National Institutes of Health – a subsidiary of HHS WHO = World Health Organisation Disclosure The VMMC Experience Project discloses the following as potential sources of bias: Executive Director Prince Hillary Maloba belongs to a male circumcising community that is heavily burdened by HIV/AIDS. He re- ports being forcibly circumcised in a traditional Bagisu setting, and has campaigned against forced circumcision and child genital cutting practices for more than 25 years. Project Coordinator David Okwalo has experienced forced circumcision attacks among family members in Kenya, and has expressed human rights objections to child circumcision. Assistant Keneth Nuwamanya reported having at least one colleague who remains adversely affected by the VMMC campaign for HIV prevention in Uganda. Community Mobiliser Mutebi Ramadhan was circumcised in a religious setting and discloses no biases. UN Report: African opposition to mass circumcision 3 Background Table 1. Reduction in HIV infections to men from circumcision Total Infected with HIV The campaigns Control group 5,497 137 2.49% “Voluntary medical male circumcision” (VMMC) is among Circumcised group 5,411 64 1.18% the core strategies of the global AIDS response in sub-Sa- Absolute risk reduction: 2.49% - 1.18% 1.31% haran Africa (SSA). VMMC programmes are administered Relative risk reduction: (2.49% - 1.18%) / 2.49% 52.61% by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and Joint United Combined data from the three female-to-male trials [5-7].